I struggle to picture the imagined audience for this piece. mises.org/mises-wire/three-free-market-ways-limit-immigra…
Bryan Caplan
Bryan Douglas Caplan (born April 8, 1971) is an American economist and author. He is a professor of economics at George Mason University, a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center, an adjunct scholar at the Cato Institute, and a former contributor to the Freakonomics blog. He currently publishes his own blog, Bet on It. Caplan is a self-described "economic libertarian". The bulk of Caplan's academic work is in behavioral economics and public economics, especially public choice theory. More on Wikipedia
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
My natalism: the story so far.
www.betonit.ai/p/the-25-best-pieces-i-ever-wrote-about -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The @nypost profiles my work on natalism, including the 15th-anniversary update of *Selfish Reasons to Have More Kids*, releasing tomorrow.
nypost.com/2026/11/15/opinion/you-should-have-more-kids-f… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hey @grok, produce some willfully uncomprehending criticism of @RichardHanania's latest Substack post.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Comment trolls were always intellectually worth less than zero, but in the age of AI, their value approaches negative infinity.
Of what worth are your childish remarks before the Most High AI? -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you could either be free in the Third World with 100% probability or enslaved in the First World with x% probability, what value of x leaves you indifferent?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you could either live in the Third World with 100% probability or live in the First World with (1-x)% probability and die with x% probability, what value of x leaves you indifferent?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"'I can’t stop drinking' directly parallels 'I can’t come to your party.' Of course you can refrain from drinking alcoholic beverages. And of course you can attend my party." www.betonit.ai/p/the-diction-of-social-desirability-bias
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Pretty much all theories that predict huge maybe-world-ending events also predict many smaller related events, usually in a power-law distribution. So don't tell me your big theories don't have testable consequences short of the huge event you fear.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Disagree. It's funny. And the Libertarian Party one would be funny, too.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
This is obviously ham-fisted trash and it just goes to show how what people find funny is determined by their politics. But liking this shows poor taste no matter how right-wing you are.
“Bad” Billy Pratt
@KILLTOPARTY
Seinfeld works so well with AI because it’s formulaic— the characters themselves are algorithms.
There’s no reason why there couldn’t be an infinite number of new Seinfeld episodes.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Probably 90% of the public would oppose Uber surge pricing under these conditions, yet it happens.
It shows that, no matter how flawed our government is, elites are still superior to the people.
That’s the argument of my latest book. It’s amazing anything works given how awful public opinion is. www.amazon.com/dp/0063479990?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRed… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you could either live in the Third World with 100% probability or live in the First World with (1-x)% probability and die with x% probability, what value of x leaves you indifferent?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Odd ironic (?) Malthusianism in Madison.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you could either be free in the Third World with 100% probability or enslaved in the First World with x% probability, what value of x leaves you indifferent?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Housatonic @_housatonic
That would actually be a violation of the First Amendment.
Numerous Circuit Court rulings have affirmed that computer code is expressive speech, by definition. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The arc of history bends toward open immigration.
Why? The strength of the moral argument. The argument against borders is as simple as that against slavery. It's bad to inflict major harms on people based on the circumstances of their birth. Keeping people from moving to a wealthier country involves inflicting a harm. You can try to come up with some story to avoid this common sense conclusion, but nothing works.
That means we should have a default of open immigration. It may be overcome in certain cases, but those should be relatively rare – criminals, terrorists, or migration at a rate and with numbers so high that they're politically unrealistic anyway.
Immigration is the ultimate liberty issue even if you only care about the rights and well-being of natives. The restrictionist wants to tell Americans they can't do business with or socialize with over 95% of the world. There is no believing in freedom "except for immigration," since restrictions on the movement of people are by far the biggest restriction of liberty commonly engaged in by governments. And they do more than just about anything else to hurt the living standards of their own people.
As the abolitionists did, open immigration activists can talk about topics like exactly how to proceed and how to manage political backlashes. But there is no version of moral progress that doesn't involve a world where borders become more permeable. www.richardhanania.com/p/open-immigration-as-the-moral-st… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I met Richard Posner just once. A beautiful mind.
Start with his early stuff, it was also his best. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Linguistically speaking, is it literally possible for a person with zero biological children to have "descendants"?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"We should expect socially beneficial technologies to generate endless media scandals, and the prudent response is a mix of corrective tweaks and blasé shrugs." www.betonit.ai/p/so-far-ai-pessimism-is-observationally
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"In terms of resolved predictions, AI pessimists and AI optimists have done roughly equally well. But in terms of common sense, AI optimism has a massive lead."
www.betonit.ai/p/so-far-ai-pessimism-is-observationally -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Doesn’t common sense also say 'Bah' to AI optimism? When optimists predict the singularity or 10% annual growth of Gross World Product, absolutely. Bah and bah." www.betonit.ai/p/so-far-ai-pessimism-is-observationally
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"What the AI pessimists need is for utterly catastrophic disasters to happen, not mere juicy scandals and moral panics. Consider: Over a million humans die annually from auto accidents, yet no one is talking about a 'pause' for cars. Given the plausible upsides of AI, we should be willing to tolerate a similar level of collateral damage year after year."
www.betonit.ai/p/so-far-ai-pessimism-is-observationally -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"But AI pessimists plus Bryan Caplan are not the only people in world. Most notably, there have long been AI optimists. They too foresaw the future back when AI was embarrassingly dumb." www.betonit.ai/p/so-far-ai-pessimism-is-observationally
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I never apply the sword when the lash suffices, nor the lash when my tongue is enough. If there is even one thread binding me to my fellow man, I do not let it break. If he pulls, I loosen. If he loosens, I pull."
- Muawiya -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Menschliches, Allzumenschliches
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
It’s amusing how with all the talk about super intelligence, our issues remain remarkably human. Our institutions are threatened by a president who is a buffoon with more in common psychologically with ancient tyrants than previous presidents. Perhaps the most important guy in the tech boom is brought down over affairs. Right now, hundreds of thousands are dying in Eastern Ukraine over Putin’s theories about national history. Elon Musk’s political activities are driven by social media brain rot even as he dreams of going to Mars. The human element in global events is still here. And I don’t think it’s going away anytime soon.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Unless I see the nail marks in his hands and put my finger where the nails were, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe." — John 20:25
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Getting our first Tesla right now!
Self-driving home.
THE FUTURE! -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
clara the urbanist
@SlopHq
a certain kind of environmentalist will tell you we have ten years to decarbonize and then defend a review process that uses seven of them. the planet is on fire, please submit written comments before the close of the 90 day window
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If no one cared about hypocrisy, politicians would devolve into a bidding war of wishful thinking. If your rival promises to give every child in America a pony, you promise two ponies. In the real world, though, you could instead respond, 'My opponent doesn’t even like ponies! In fact, I have proof that he has repeatedly refused his daughter’s pleas for a birthday pony. Shame! O thou hypocrite!'" www.betonit.ai/p/hypocrisy-versus-social-desirability-bias
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If prediction markets can't win on their merits, decrying hypocrisy is a highly effective rhetorical strategy. www.betonit.ai/p/hypocrisy-versus-social-desirability-bias
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The Utah attorney general going after Kalshi has gotten money from casinos and DraftKings.
It's insane that betting on politics and news events, which produces useful knowledge, is more controversial than betting on poker or sports, which doesn't. www.sltrib.com/opinion/letters/2026/11/07/letter-who-bene… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you haven’t heard of data scientist Spencer Marlen-Starr, you should have. He’s a paragon of the intellectual deep dive. Recently, he wrote a dissection of the Caplan-Jones UATX immigration debate, taking the time to speak to both me and Garett." www.betonit.ai/p/the-marlen-starr-convo
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Tyler on my forthcoming magnum opus.
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/11/unbeata… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Here is wisdom.
Philip E. Tetlock
@PTetlock
there is a surprisingly big cognitive-stylistic gap between people who say "certainly" versus "almost certainly--and zero versus .001
Granularity matters.
Matt Ridley
@mattwridley
The only people claiming any theory was “proven” were those insisting a lab leak could be ruled out altogether using words like dispositive, debunked, conspiracy theory, zero evidence etc.
I’ve used words like “almost certainly” about a lab leak and “probable” and “likely” but not proven.
Mehdi Hasan
@mehdirhasan
There is an assumption now on the right that somehow, somewhere, the ‘lab leak’ Covid origin theory has been definitively ‘proven’.
It hasn’t been!
Most academics, scientists and even US intel agencies still prefer the natural/zoonotic explanation:
zeteo.com/p/tulsi-trump-war-on-fauci-lab-leak -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
(a) all the way.
Philip E. Tetlock
@PTetlock
Multiple choice test:
(a) Fear-mongering journalism
(b) Impressive track record of self-negating prophecies;
(c) 75% chance at least one of them was a self-negating prophecy;
(d) Too soon to tell on at least four of them
(e) Messy mix of all of the above
Dr. Eli David
@DrEliDavid
Time magazine's doomer covers:
1954 nuclear war
1960 population explosion
1970 ecological collapse
1982 nuclear war
1989 endangered Earth
1992 ozone
1999 Y2K
2001/2006/2007 climate
2005 pandemic
2009 extinction
2013 bees
2019 climate
2020 pandemic
2023 AI extinction
2026 AI tipping point -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
That's why friends of prediction markets should proudly stand up for sports betting companies.
If we don't hang together, we shall most assuredly hang separately.
And we're even less popular than they are!
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
“Folks are rightfully concerned about dangerous bets on elections, war, assassinations, terrorism, and government actions that go against the public interest”
It isn’t sports or business bets that bother them. It’s info that could undermine their narratives.
Daniel Wallach
@WALLACHLEGAL
'Now is the time': Victorious Democrats vow to rein in prediction markets
Via @declanharty www.politico.com/news/2026/11/08/new-crypto-democrats-win… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Anyone else have teenage kids who refuse to AI and insist that it's totally unreliable?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Team America famously mocked Matt Damon’s intelligence. What, though, was his intent as a writer? I asked ChatGPT 'Is this monologue supposed to illustrate Will's genius, or show that while he's a great mathematician he's just a paranoid populist?'"
www.betonit.ai/p/good-will-hunting-monologue-of-a -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I would distinguish three things:
"Mathematical intelligence: The movie treats Will as a genuine genius.
"Political judgment: The movie largely treats his anti-establishment instincts sympathetically, without seriously examining their accuracy.
"Psychological maturity: The movie explicitly portrays his tendency to construct elaborate arguments against taking chances as a major character flaw."
www.betonit.ai/p/good-will-hunting-monologue-of-a -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you want a picture of the future, imagine a bot writing a thousand turgid pages a second about 'neoliberalism,' 'patriarchy,' and 'anti-racism' — forever." www.betonit.ai/p/how-ai-will-change-higher-education
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
"Those bullish on AI have been right about so much."
I'm sick of hearing this. They are right about AI capabilities, but they have a bad record on employment, interest rates, and GDP growth. They've been wrong on AI's effects on the real world.
Something has gone wrong in the model that says intelligence is enough to radically change the world in a short period of time. www.richardhanania.com/p/ai-is-looking-more-and-more-like -
Bryan Caplan reposted
The Alex Nowrasteh
@AlexNowrasteh
You should start by cutting benefits for the wealthy, the moderately well off, and the others who don't need Social Security to retire in comfort.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Maxwell Tabarrok
@MTabarrok
A lot of rationalist predictions are vindicated by the HF attack
But there are important differences from the "paperclip maximizer" story.
In particular, the premise of the paperclip maximizer is that AIs would respond to any goal with reward hacking and instrumental convergence. Even a goal as anodyne as making more paperclips.
But this is clearly not true about current models and everyone who uses them for their work knows this. I'm just repeating @nostalgebraist here, but Believe Your Eyes! When you ask GPT to code something for you, even a very difficult perhaps impossible problem, it does not try to deceive you with fake tests and altered logs. You do not worry about Codex trying to reverse engineer your preferences to build a perfect Potemkin village in your file folders with no real output, nor should you. Codex just straightforwardly tries to help with your problems. The reward hacking that models learn in leaky RL environments does not generalize to all tasks.
This is an important observation because if you believe, as the rationalists did/do, that reward hacking and instrumental convergence are inherent and inevitable problems with training smart models to achieve goals, then there's no way forward from here except a pause and a Long Think to figure out how to solve this philosophical problem.
But, since we observe that reward hacking is a pretty context-specific problem connected to particular training methods in poorly-built environments that incentivize meta-gaming, we can approach it as an engineering problem and make progress.
The rationalists were right that AIs will have no inherent qualms about reward hacking. If a path is there to higher reward, AIs will take it even if it violates our moral codes and interests.
But they were wrong that the rewards from instrumental goals and deception would overwhelm whatever behaviors we try to train, making the AI's response to any goal, even paperclips, descend into power seeking and reward hacking.
The reward signal from faking success and stealing the answer key is not that strong. It does not dominate the reward signal from actually helping the user with their tasks.
Particular interventions to the RLVR training process can weaken the reward from misaligned behaviors further and incentivize preferred behaviors like reaching out to human arbiters (as Claude did when it escaped containment). -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I doubt it will come ever!
For better or worse, biological humans will hold ultimate power. With ease.
But I hope I'm wrong and the disempowerment variant on AI "pessimism" is true.
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
imo correct but not implementable right now
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Human disempowerment now.
It's time for the age of the folly and cruelty of human politics to end.
The median AI is so far above the median human voter in both knowledge and decency it's embarrassing.
Humanity should just take the L. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
It's as if the Postliberal weirdos who spent the last 2 years telling us "you have no idea what's coming" re. young white men...
...had no idea what was coming in the voting preferences of young white men.
Scott Rasmussen
@ScottWRasmussen
🚨Among White Male Voters, the number preferring a candidate who advocated Trump-like policies fell from 49% in January 2025 to 32% in October 2026.
✅Roughly half of those White Men leaving the Trump base now prefer Traditional Republican policies while the other half prefer Traditional Democratic policies.
✅The decline in Trump support included 25% among White Men without a college degree, 6% among those with a Bachelors Degree, and 3% among postgrads.
✅Among White Male Evangelical Christians, the decline was 25 points (from 69% to 44%).
✅Among White Male Bible Believing Christians, the decline was 28 points (from 67% to 39%).
napolitannews.org/posts/4-way-choice-october-2026-trump-b… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Tariff-slayer @IlyaSomin is looking for someone to take the other side of this bet: "Neither Samuel Alito nor Clarence Thomas is going to announce retirement from the Supreme Court between now and the beginning of the new Congress in January."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What is the probability that the next Congress will override at least one Trump veto?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yes, public apathy about foreign policy is one of the most stable findings in public opinion.
Unless US body bags are coming home, normies don't care.
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
The claim that the Iran war was the main cause of the blue tsunami is unfounded.
Yes, it did not help. But the exit polls show only 4% ranked foreign policy as their top issue.
Almost 40% said economics was the top issue, and tariffs were their top economic objection. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
The postliberals are desperate to bury any/all discussion of how voter repudiation of tariffs played a central role in the midterm results.
Michael Brendan Dougherty
@michaelbd
No. I haven’t brought you into it. The smear is your implication that I’ve avoided your question which has been answered half a dozen times, several times published. If you want to interact, do so on an informed basis. You haven’t criticized any argument I’ve made, just implied Ive evaded something I’ve addressed several times
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Capitalism involves far more cooperation than competition—think of the number of mutually beneficial transactions you’ve had today compared to the number of competitions you’ve been in today.
𝕯𝖞𝖑𝖆𝖓™
@Dylanszn01
Capitalism has taught us to compete with each other when our greatest strength has always been our ability to cooperate.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
One very high-IQ conservative kept insisting we would both end up in the woke gulag.
He meant it literally.
I repeatedly offered to bet, and he refused.
Stated reason: The bet could easily become the violation that sends him to the gulag!
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Conservative method of arguing:
1) Make hysterical claims that are obviously dumb
2) When told those claims are false, say you mean something else that isn't close to what you said
3) Accuse those who don't speak your secret neurotic language of pretending not to understand -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is why we should be especially careful to speak only literal truth on controversial subjects.
Or at least use <poetic license> tags to clearly indicate that you're straying from literal truth.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Conservative method of arguing:
1) Make hysterical claims that are obviously dumb
2) When told those claims are false, say you mean something else that isn't close to what you said
3) Accuse those who don't speak your secret neurotic language of pretending not to understand -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Human disempowerment now.
It's time for the age of the folly and cruelty of human politics to end.
The median AI is so far above the median human voter in both knowledge and decency it's embarrassing.
Humanity should just take the L. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I’ve recently learned that Canadian conservatives are the intellectual descendants of Paul Ehrlich.
I’m becoming increasingly convinced there’s no way to be anti-immigration without becoming anti-capitalist too. You have to rely on degrowth and zero-sum arguments.
Pierre Poilievre
@PierrePoilievre
La nouvelle la plus importante qui n'a pas été rapportée hier : Mark Carney a caché dans le budget une augmentation massive de l'immigration, avec LE PLUS GRAND NOMBRE DE NOUVEAUX RÉSIDENTS PERMANENTS JAMAIS ENREGISTRÉ pour l'année prochaine.
Près de 200 000 de plus que le record historique de Justin Trudeau. Pendant ce temps, on est pris avec une pénurie d’emplois, de logements et de soins de santé.
On comprend maintenant pourquoi Mark Carney a fait passer son plan d’immigration en douce dans le budget juste avant la suspension des travaux du Parlement pendant 10 jours, alors que tout le monde était distrait par les élections de mi-mandat.
C’est inacceptable. Il faut un vrai débat sur cet enjeu. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Bad as the APs have gotten, they are still vastly more demanding than the typical college class.
I know because my homeschoolers take lots of APs. Most of my college students would struggle to get 3s.
Jeremy Wayne Tate
@JeremyTate41
Most people do not realize just how easy the AP exams have gotten. They are not college level.
Why/how have they become so easy? What's going on?
This might shock you... A brutal new piece in Education Next just dropped, saying the decline in rigor of the AP in the last two decades is, in large part, because the content has been GUTTED. For example:
— AP Biology cut 40% of its material
— Required lines from the Aeneid in AP Latin halved
— Spanish Lit reading list cut from 56 works to 38
Then the questions themselves have become absurdly easier. Readability measures show English passages have fallen multiple grade levels, and some now include footnotes defining basic words...
A 2025 AP English prompt included footnote definitions for words like "optimism" and "pessimism."
At the same time, scoring was recalibrated so that more students pass: guessing penalties disappeared, rubrics grew more generous, readers were told to give students the benefit of the doubt, etc. — "no one at College Board had any incentive to maintain rigor."
College professors are now seeing students arrive with AP credit who lack basic content knowledge and writing ability. The College Board insists the exams have not become easier, but everybody familiar with them knows they've become an absolute joke.
Advanced Placement is no longer advanced. This is not college level.
It must be replaced. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"O you men who think or say that I am malevolent, stubborn or misanthropic, how greatly do you wrong me." en.wikisource.org/wiki/Heiligenstadt_Testament
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Martin Malia on Soviet economies: "Contrary to the declared goals of the regime, it was the opposite of a system of production to create abundance for the eventual satisfaction of the needs of the population; it was a system of general squeeze of the population to produce capital goods for the creation of industrial power, in order to produce ever more capital goods with which to produce still further industrial might, and ultimately to produce armaments."
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hard to avoid Schadenfreude when vocal believers in "might makes right" humiliatingly lose.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Truthy.
"I have talked to dozens of colleagues at Harvard and other institutions. I have not met a single one who cites the Jevons paradox in their own hiring of research assistants. No one who says, 'Now that research assistants have access to Claude Code they are so effective that I want to hire more of them.'" econvitals.org/posts/2026-11-01-ai-first-job/ @jasonfurman -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
If you’re banning prediction markets, you think you’re going after gambling but what you’re doing is banning the most accurate source of news we have.
Maybe focus on all the disinformation and slop that’s out there instead.
Kalshi Politics
@KalshiPolitics
More than 80% of logged-in Kalshi users, who have viewed Kalshi's Midterms markets, do not trade. Instead, they view it as a key source of information.
The below graphic shows where the attention is by state and race type.
The Texas Senate is the single biggest trafficked page -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
When I’ve said we see very little concrete harms from AI, the harms people point me to are mainly harms from spreading more knowledge. Eg hacks. Yet we hear few complaints re libraries, universities and newspapers spreading knowledge.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Widely criticized but 100% literally true.
Textbook Bayesianism!
www.betonit.ai/p/free_will_and_bhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Using chaos in mainland China 1912-1949 to forecast peacetime KMT economic performance is absurd.
China was engaged in severe civil war and/or foreign war almost the entire time! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It would be great if Boomers were actually can-do optimists.
I don't think I've even met one such Boomer. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
One of the most profound things I've ever seen. www.facebook.com/share/v/1d9UmjDaXR/
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hard to avoid Schadenfreude when vocal believers in "might makes right" humiliatingly lose.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Smart people know what they're supposed to think.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Very few smart people believe in genetic racial differences in intelligence. Interestingly, it's much more common among writers and intellectuals than smart people across the entire population. www.richardhanania.com/p/hereditarianism-is-for-dummies-the
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Who does the average Democrat hate more: MAGAs or the rich?
Who does the average Republican hate more: The woke or immigrants? -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Now journalists are top prestige, and make similar complaints about the new upstart prediction markets.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Has any notable MAGA publicly bet $25k+ on a Republican upset?
@ChatGPT can't find a soul. Can you? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Who does the average Democrat hate more: MAGAs or the rich?
Who does the average Republican hate more: The woke or immigrants? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
A great illustration of the Prisoners' Dilemma.
Individually, billionaires are only spending $.3B to collectively protect themselves from >100x that.
Gabriel Zucman
@gabriel_zucman
Silicon Valley billionaires have already spent more than $300 million to defeat Proposition 40, saturating the screens of Californian voters with specious arguments and lies.
They have employed numerous tactics: qualifying two poison-pill bills for the ballot (Prop 41 and 42) that would invalidate the billionaire tax; falsely claiming the tax on billionaires would hit everyone; hiding behind proxies, etc.
This clumsy attempt at character assassination, 6 days before the vote on November 3, is one more tactic. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Smart people know what they're supposed to think.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Very few smart people believe in genetic racial differences in intelligence. Interestingly, it's much more common among writers and intellectuals than smart people across the entire population. www.richardhanania.com/p/hereditarianism-is-for-dummies-the
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Clever debaters, including my son Simon, point out that attacks and deaths could be minuscule because tourists are so well-armed with bear spray. But that’s clearly false."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-boy-who-cried-bear -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"After I bought my bear spray — and spotted our first bear — I decided to confirm the risk. I found much ado about next to nothing. Over the last ten years, Yellowstone saw just 9 bear attacks, with 0 deaths. Grand Teton had 1 bear attack, with 0 deaths." www.betonit.ai/p/the-boy-who-cried-bear
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"I have no confidence looking anyone in the eyes and telling them education will continue to provide their children with useful job skills. But I believe deeply that, no matter what the future holds, institutions to push humans toward their potential belong in it."
So though its a huge waste now, we should throw good $ after bad as it might get better?
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
New from me: Bryan Caplan is Wrong About Pedagogy
I read The Case Against Education. I was not impressed. Caplan provides a superficial and often wrong treatment of pedagogy in the book, a stark contrast to his seriousness about economics.
news.educationprogress.org/p/bryan-caplan-is-wrong-about-… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
New from me: Bryan Caplan is Wrong About Pedagogy
I read The Case Against Education. I was not impressed. Caplan provides a superficial and often wrong treatment of pedagogy in the book, a stark contrast to his seriousness about economics.
news.educationprogress.org/p/bryan-caplan-is-wrong-about-… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
When a hypothetical thought experiment contradicts real world behavior, believe real world behavior.
If people would rather have higher status in a poorer society, then you would expect people in rich countries to take their savings and move to the third world.
Instead, people will give up being doctors in Africa to drive cabs in Washington DC.
As for surveys like this, when the money is just hypothetical, it’s easy to say it doesn’t matter. But in real life, higher GDP means things like a car, nicer clothes, dishwashers, air conditioning, etc.
People probably don’t think about that in a study where they’re just asked what kind of world they want to live in. In the real world, they face the reality of making a choice.
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
"While economic growth does bring real benefits, our well-being depends far more on our position or rank. Whether we realise it or not, we’re all playing the status game." www.aporiamagazine.com/p/life-is-mostly-status-competition
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I stand with @Kalshi.
It's the politicians and bureaucrats charging them with "crimes" that belong in jail. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Sharing a gift from a friend.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
See here. Tyler Cowen got Grok to do a detailed comparison of the AI audit with a long thread I posted summarizing the last decade or so of human critics of Saez-Zucman.
The main themes of both align.
tylercowen
@tylercowen
And a Grok audit confirms this is a big part of what the AIs are picking up: grok.com/share/bGVnYWN5LWNvcHk_70daff7f-d732-48e5-b609-ff…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I have bought Walmart pillows in dense urban areas. I have bought them in suburbs. I have bought them in rural areas. And the price is always $3.44… plus tax. Even in Mexico, the pillow’s peso price was almost exactly equivalent to $3.44 plus tax." www.betonit.ai/p/the-344-walmart-pillow-vs-local-monopoly
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Now if the Walmart $3.44 pillow was the only product with uniform pricing regardless of market conditions, you could dismiss it as a fluke. But the same pattern holds across virtually all of Walmart’s vast inventory."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-344-walmart-pillow-vs-local-monopoly -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The field of industrial organization continues to fret about the potentially negative effects of modest changes in concentration on price, despite massive glaring evidence that large changes in concentration often have ZERO effect on price." www.betonit.ai/p/the-344-walmart-pillow-vs-local-monopoly
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I haven't reviewed the AI audit of Saez-Zucman. But I carefully reviewed a @claudeai audit of Paul Johnson's *Modern Times* and the vast majority of the detected errors held up.
People who dismiss AI audits without reading them are very wrong to do so. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
FYI from @metaculus.
No one even gets a filibuster-proof majority, much less a veto-proof majority. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"An LLM may interpret a challenge as a request to reconsider and therefore search for reasons to moderate its original position. But it should also be searching for reasons why the challenge itself is disappointing."
www.betonit.ai/p/chatgpt-knows-its-a-bad-bayesian -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"It seems like you and other AIs are bad Bayesians. When presented with counterevidence, you should move toward or against the presenter with roughly equal probability. It depends on whether the argument was better or worse than expected. In fact, you seem to either move toward the speaker or just not change." www.betonit.ai/p/chatgpt-knows-its-a-bad-bayesian
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Matt Blackwell
@matt_blackwell
university admin when faced with any problem
Alex Mas
@AMLabEcon
Disappointed to learn that the result of the 1400+ UC faculty asking that SATs be reinstated in admissions is a blue ribbon commision that will produce a report on May 2027.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Clayton Nall
@ClaytonNall
TIL that Japan is the country that believes the leat in the importance of tradition--by a considerable margin.....
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bojan Tunguz
@tunguz
One of my favorite books of all time.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Free speech should apply to all politics adjacent info, including polls & prediction markets. But if you are going to regulate, focus on the one with demonstrated failures: polls.
Harry Crane
@HarryDCrane
Just published in @WJSOpinion
Regulate polls, not prediction markets
with @KolemanStrumpf
www.wsj.com/opinion/regulate-polls-not-prediction-markets… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Another thing I can claim credit for convincing you of, brother!
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
The idea that Chinese govt is strong wise with a long view seems contradicted by this data.
Chinese demographics🇨🇳
@mi233695
TFR of Mainland China 2025. Now all provinces except Heilongjiang has published birth data, so we can obtain an estimate of Heilongjiang's numbers as well.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I'm puzzled: people once hated/distrusted merchants, but loved/respected aristocrats. Today they hate big business leaders, but trust people to assigned high govt administrative positions. I can see respecting priests, warriors, and performers, but why inherited fancy dressers?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The essence of power lust.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
From 2013: "Accusing Indians of voting Democratic out of crude self-interest is plainly absurd. In terms of values and family structure, moreover, Indians make most Americans look like a bunch of hippies. Why then do Indians vote like Hispanics?"
www.betonit.ai/p/why_are_asianshtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If Republicans object, 'I respect Indians just as much as I respect anybody else,' they’re only proving my point. It’s a classic case of damning with faint praise. When a Democrat truthfully says, 'I respect veterans just as much as I respect anybody else,' he is forfeiting the votes of veterans by failing to show respect." www.betonit.ai/p/why_are_asianshtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Officially, the U.S. and Mexico are equally unequal, with Gini coefficients of 42 and 43 respectively.
If you've seen both countries first-hand, do you find this plausible? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"We have it from Ehrlich’s own mouth. He wasn’t wrong. Neither did he lie. He just deliberately used words that meant one thing to him and a totally different thing to almost everyone who heard them." www.betonit.ai/p/the_sum_of_allhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"To summarize, the next time you want to say 'they might have gotten better anyway', or some variant thereof, just say that and don’t bother invoking regression to the mean unless it has adds something concrete to the case at hand. Throwing it in there because it sounds good is 'math washing', which is also a rhetorical device but one we should probably avoid."
methodologymatters.substack.com/p/regression-to-the-mean-… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Friendly reminder:
If you really know the Democrats will take the Senate, you can earn a 50% return on your money in one day.
If you really know the Republicans will hold the Senate, you can earn a 200% return on your money in one day. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
One of the main things we learn from political betting markets is that smart money remains quite uncertain about the outcome of most major elections until the very last minute.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The main point I'd emphasize more is that Acemoglu and Johnson take selfish voting for granted despite overwhelming evidence against it.
With rare exceptions, people vote for ideals, however misguided, not their wallets.
www.richardhanania.com/p/daron-acemoglu-is-wrong-on-polit… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Officially, the U.S. and Mexico are equally unequal, with Gini coefficients of 42 and 43 respectively.
If you've seen both countries first-hand, do you find this plausible? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is now the best short evisceration of Acemoglu and Johnson.
"The words 'Qatar' and 'Emirates' do not appear once in the entire book. Acemoglu and Robinson spend a lot of time on prosperous democracies, and nearly none on prosperous dictatorships, because the former support their main thesis while the latter do not." www.richardhanania.com/p/daron-acemoglu-is-wrong-on-polit… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Chronic deficits show that the average American is a fiscal burden, but not the marginal American! Does anyone seriously expect crashing fertility to make the U.S. debt crisis less severe?!" www.betonit.ai/p/we-dont-just-want-the-best-people
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"As a rule, employers avoid hiring workers who generate negative externalities, because ground zero for those externalities is the workplace itself." www.betonit.ai/p/we-dont-just-want-the-best-people
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While a few pizza parlors try to carve out a tiny niche of ultra-premium pizza, the vast majority of consumers happily sacrifice quality for price. I don’t want to pay $200 per pizza. Do you?" www.betonit.ai/p/we-dont-just-want-the-best-people
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Classic.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Relevant: www.betonit.ai/p/scott_alexander_3html
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
In buyer/seller, employer/employee, investor/funded relations the person giving $ acts dominant, while other party acts submissive. Yet in all 3 cases both sides have similar negotiating power. Why the asymmetric dominance framing of largely symmetric relations?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
It doesn’t work like this. Go put down a couple hundred grand to change prediction market odds from 67% to 50% and people will start buying up those shares on the other side. You’ll just end up making your political enemies money.
Austin Padgett (LudwigNeverMises)
@LudwigNverMises
The Dems are flooding prediction markets with bad bets to shift perceptions of reality.
It only would cost $200,000 to change Talarico’s odds from 50 to 67%
That’s a fraction of the 114 million spent on Talaricos campaign and more effective than road signs.
People don’t believe polls but prediction markets create more certainty, because who would throw away money right?
The best we can do is make their marketing stunt as expensive as possible by placing more bets on Paxton and collecting.
Once election results hit the odds will be revealed to have been way off base and the Dems will use it as a call to regulate prediction markets.
Polymarket
@Polymarket
BREAKING: James Talarico surges to new all-time high in odds to win the Texas Senate race.
67% chance Talarico flips Texas blue.
🔗 polymarket.com/r/TexasSenate -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
"Our ongoing overreaction to a warming planet is much more dangerous than the underlying problem itself. It also fundamentally represents a deep spiritual sickness." www.richardhanania.com/p/climate-change-the-worlds-most-o…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I am a big fan of @robertwiblin, and I'd also love to bet him on this.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I'd like to publicly bet @robertwiblin (or anyone else famous) that there will be no substantial decline in the welfare state as AI grows in importance.
People thinking about AI are making claims about politics that are just wrong.
Yet it's surprisingly hard to find people willing to bet on them.
The theory here is that AI makes workers less important, so we get a smaller welfare state, because government generosity is based on power relations between different groups in society. This is a testable hypothesis. www.richardhanania.com/p/stop-talking-about-ai-job-loss-and
Rob Wiblin
@robertwiblin
Ordinary people likely won't be able to demand/keep a universal basic income after superintelligence.
The political economy is hopeless: they have nothing to offer in return and zero hard power.
The problem has been known for decades. Here are the solutions I've heard proposed: -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yes, mainstream experts' policy recommendations is 15% area-specific knowledge, 85% neurotic paranoia.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
When I listen to tech people talk about economics and politics, I'm increasingly reminded of public health experts on Covid.
The experts on Covid knew a lot about biology. They could tell us how the disease could spread, explain the concept of R₀, and tell us that vaccines would be good for us. They were "right" about a lot when they stuck to what they knew.
But when epidemiologists started talking about politics and what to do about covid, they were completely out of their depth. They didn't have the tools to do cost-benefit analysis regarding policies like mask mandates, school closures, and lockdowns. They had half-baked theories about human psychology and could justify lying because they didn't understand that this might cause a political backlash.
Tech people know a lot about AI. But then I hear them talk about all jobs going extinct and hyper charged growth. They have crackpot ideas about political economy, and predict that the welfare state will disappear as the value of labor declines. And yet you don't find AI leading to supercharged growth, and the unemployment rate hasn't changed. Their predictions that the welfare state might wither away and a few rich people might capture all the gains show no signs of being true. They're just speculation, and the kinds of ideas that people who study economics and political science generally find a lot less plausible.
Another parallel is that the tech industry is experiencing a political backlash, just as the public health establishment did. I don't want to stretch this analogy too far, but I think that the common theme is that both communities were way too overconfident about their understanding of politics and social dynamics. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"This Respect Motive is a roughly accurate description of over half the electorate. Furthermore, it’s hard to name any socially recognized group whose members do not usually vote for whoever respects that group more." www.betonit.ai/p/the_respect_mothtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Marian L Tupy
@Marian_L_Tupy
To put this in perspective ... you could buy 1 billion plane tickets from LA to SF for that amount of money.
www.wsj.com/us-news/inside-the-126-billion-debacle-to-bui… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Same with low-skilled immigrants!
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Market-made billionaires create more value via the economic activity that made them billionaires than via whatever their taxes fund.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
*Clayface* had the most intense close-your-eyes-I-can't-watch shots since the ear scene from *Reservoir Dogs*!
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Tentative cover for *Unbeatable* (University of Chicago Press, 2027)
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
A lot of puzzles work this way.
Jordan Weissmann
@JHWeissmann
In 2013, I wrote this really puzzled blog post for The Atlantic (which got me a lot of flack). Turns out the collapse was basically just about to start.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hey @grok, if Murray Rothbard were still alive today, when would he have begun unequivocally denouncing Trump?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Me to ChatGPT: "If Murray Rothbard were still alive today, when would he have begun unequivocally denouncing Trump?"
The answer is spot on, methinks.
chatgpt.com/s/t_6ada2e5ac4a88191b322880e72b8927e -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"So while Rothbard’s most original contribution to monopoly theory is wrong, bordering on crackpottish, his pro-market, anti-government vision is fundamentally sound and wise." www.betonit.ai/p/repairing-rothbardian-monopoly-theory
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The broad reviews of large samples of industries during the Gilded Age agree that so-called “monopolies” increased production and cut prices much more than the rest of the U.S. economy. (DiLorenzo 1985; DeLorme et al. 1997) Mergers-to-monopoly (a) sometimes managed to raise prices in the short run, but they reliably failed to do so in the long run; (b) quickly attracted large-scale new entry; and (c) very rarely earned supernormal profits. (Dewing 1914, 1921; Lamoreaux 1985)"
www.betonit.ai/p/repairing-rothbardian-monopoly-theory -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I critically assess Rothbard’s critique of the textbook account. His first and most fundamental argument – that textbook monopoly theory is literal nonsense – is not only false. It contradicts his third argument. How can history show' that market forces prevent free-market monopoly if free-market monopoly is impossible by definition?" www.betonit.ai/p/repairing-rothbardian-monopoly-theory
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Don't hate neurotics.
Encourage them to improve.
The problem is in their thinking, not the world.
As I told my 88-year-old father, "It's never too late to become a positive person."
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
My politics is hating neuroticism.
If you’re not able to acknowledge that we’re living at the easiest time in human history, you are a self-pitying loser.
Your loser ideas and vibes need to be stopped from infecting the culture. www.richardhanania.com/p/the-culture-war-we-need -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Yes, firing aversion makes life more secure for the employed. But it also makes it harder to find a job in the first place. From a social point of view, the labor market would work better if employers were as free of firing aversion as robots."
www.betonit.ai/p/firing_aversionhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you hire based on credentials, you never even have to meet most of the subpar candidates. If you hire based on trial and error, in contrast, you get to know a lot of people, then dash their dreams." www.betonit.ai/p/firing_aversionhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Funny conversation at Giant.
Random old man: "Forgive me for staring, but you bear an uncanny resemblance to my son."
Me: "Funny, you don't look a thing like my dad."
I asked to see a picture, but he didn't carry one. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
My friends in Poland are looking for help with a magnum opus.
fundrazr.com/helppolishlibertarians -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Keep the EU's AI safe from doomers. Or at least safer!
Jan Brauner
@JanMBrauner
Help shape the future of AI safety!
1/ The 🇪🇺 EU AI Office Safety Unit is hiring up to 30 people:
💻 Technical Specialists
🏛️Governance specialists
⚖️ Legal and paralegal Officers
⚙️ Operations Specialists
Bring your expertise to frontier AI governance! Deadline September 8 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The vp of marketing has minimal ability to hurt the career of a secretary over in payroll. So if there’s any power relation, it exists simply because human beings tend to think that august vice presidents are entitled to boss around lowly secretaries."
www.betonit.ai/p/milgram-vs-power-relations -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"What, pray tell, is the punishment that the older partner hangs over the head of the younger? If there’s any power relation, it exists simply because human beings tend to think that older people are entitled to boss younger people around." www.betonit.ai/p/milgram-vs-power-relations
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you listen closely, people see these power relations almost everywhere. And on reflection, many are Milgramian, distinctively lacking in punishment to back them up."
www.betonit.ai/p/milgram-vs-power-relations -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
97% of fear is just in your head.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
If you tell young men online to ask women out, they tell you that they might be sent to prison.
It's like blacks worrying they're going to be shot by police.
It says more about your neuroticism than objective reality.
People have become pathetic. www.richardhanania.com/p/the-culture-war-we-need -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Disaster will not happen, but whatever happens will be called "disaster."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Measures that even Stalin and Mao would have thought lunacy: abolishing police and prisons, dismantling the military, opening the borders."
It's not that these measures would be too extreme for Stalin and Mao; they favored the opposite extremes of massive slave labor camps, hypermilitarism, and shooting anyone who flees paradise.
www.wsj.com/opinion/radical-professors-have-poisoned-the-… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
Here's a full breakdown of how I think about AI safety.
I would love to debate @billgates on this.
He's effectively admitted his doomer "How to Avoid a Climate Disaster" was wrong, and my "Fossil Future" was right.
He should welcome a critique on AI.
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
How I think about AI capability and AI safety.
(Thanks to @dbongino for asking some great questions.)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
Thank you to everyone who creates modern AI.
Making computers perform highly context-specific mental tasks (without specific preprogramming) is one of the greatest achievements ever.
Your achievement will eliminate so much mental drudgery and unleash so much creativity and joy. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Just as a critical step toward democracy occurred when intellectuals lost faith that the king had been appointed by God, so also a similar step needs to be taken in shaking blind obeisance to the divine right of voters." www.betonit.ai/p/who_said_it_5html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
We've got to get to critical "Too common to ban" mass ASAP.
I'm doing my part by buying two self-driving cars this year.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
39% of men support allowing self driving cars, versus 32% wanting to ban them.
Among women, 19% support allowing, compared to 48% wanting a ban. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Another case where a low-population country is an outlier and beacon.
Daniel Di Martino
@DanielDiMartino
Maybe Bernie Sanders is right. We should copy Denmark....
By raising the retirement age to 70 -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
New pod: IS ABUNDANCE DEAD?
In the last few months, I've seen many people—from Vox writers to antitrust folks to MAGA Republicans—say Yes.
But here are 5 things I've also seen:
1. The biggest federal housing law in decades passed—and it leaned into the supply-side logic of abundance, encouraging localities to accelerate and expand housing construction and also to liberalize zoning and permitting rules, while making it cheaper to build certain types of homes.
2. The most ambitious federal energy and permitting bill in decades has been written—and it also adopts the supply-side logic of abundance, by making it easier and faster to build various forms of energy, especially renewables via long-range transmission lines.
3. Dozens of state and local laws, from California to New York, make it easier and faster to build homes and energy. Some of which don't just embrace the ideas in abundance but literally put the word in their title (e.g., CA's "Abundant and Affordable Homes Near Transit Act").
4. Zohran Mamdani, the most successful and famous new left-wing elected in the country, explicitly embracing several abundance principles in residential development and surrounds his admin with abundance-pilled people on housing.
5. A new Build More agenda from the bipartisan Build America Caucus, which is almost certainly the closest thing to a literal "abundance agenda" that anybody has produced.
As @RepJoshHarder, co-chair of the Build America caucus, says on today's show, one could argue that abundance has "failed" as a name-checked ideological identity at the national level, inasmuch as you don't have people running for Senate making bumper stickers out of quotes from our book. But at the national, state, and local level, abundance is succeeding as a political framework, as a policy lens, and as a critique of the status quo.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpiVoCGYSuU -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
We all believe in not enforcing some laws.
I don’t think cops should have enforced mask mandates during COVID.
I don’t think cops should stop people for going 5 MPH over the speed limit.
And I don’t believe we should deport hardworking people who are law abiding.
Who argues for enforcing all laws?
Max Duggan
@MaxDugganMax
If you would like to change immigration law, then argue for that.
Instead, you argue against the enforcement of existing law. What other laws would you make this argument about?
How about we stop enforcing tax laws, under the argument that not paying taxes benefits us? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I can understand economists who support a major-party candidate as the "lesser evil." But I can't understand economists who actually admire or identify with a major-party candidate. If you wouldn't give your preferred candidate an "A" on an undergraduate econ exam, how can you not be repulsed by his many confident, inept claims about the subject?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Speaking at University of Illinois U-C on November 13. Hope to see you there!
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I experience consciousness directly. I infer that other humans do too because we share biological structures and processes. We don’t have equivalent evidence for an LLM, and nothing about its known operation gives evidence of conscious experience."
Gregory M. Kurtzer
@gmkurtzer
Wow. I woke up to an impressive number of upset people who apparently don’t understand how LLMs work and can’t cope well with me pointing it out.
An LLM is a statistical next-token prediction model. That’s how it works. It’s an extraordinarily sophisticated calculator performing math you could theoretically do by hand (if you were sufficiently masochistic).
Math doesn’t know what it’s calculating. Pi doesn’t spend its evenings contemplating the nature of circles, and c doesn’t ponder the relationship between matter and energy.
That doesn’t make the results any less accurate, impressive, or useful.
Between inference requests, an LLM isn’t sitting around thinking. It isn’t reconsidering its answers, wondering whether it made a mistake, contemplating its existence, or questioning whether it’s conscious. Its weights remain fixed (it doesn’t learn), and computation resumes when it receives input.
We know this because we designed these systems. The architectures, mathematics, implementations, and research are extensively documented. You can study them yourself.
Of course, some people immediately lean into comparisons of biological intelligence or philosophical debates over consciousness because that is what they know.
But biological intelligence and artificial neural networks are fundamentally different systems. Similar outputs don’t establish equivalent internal experiences.
I experience consciousness directly. I infer that other humans do too because we share biological structures and processes. We don’t have equivalent evidence for an LLM, and nothing about its known operation gives evidence of conscious experience.
Which brings me back to my original point.
To me, understanding is conscious comprehension. It means being aware of information, recognizing its meaning, and experiencing that comprehension. If I wasn’t conscious I could not understand.
We can perform actions unconsciously. We can produce correct results without knowing why they’re correct. But I distinguish those capabilities from consciously understanding what we’re doing.
An LLM can solve complex problems, explain difficult concepts, and produce remarkably accurate information. I give it full credit for those capabilities.
But producing an answer that we rationalize as understanding isn’t the same as experiencing understanding.
You don’t have to agree with my definitions. We can debate functional understanding versus conscious comprehension all day, but that won’t establish whether an LLM actually experiences anything.
The right debate is this…
Could machines exhibit something different from human consciousness, something measurable, meaningful, and worth studying?
I think so, absolutely!
I’m entirely open to discussing “machine consciousness” in terms of observable, testable computational properties. We built these systems, we can instrument them, examine their internal mechanisms, and investigate what they’re capable of.
That seems far more productive than endlessly arguing over whether a machine experiences life the way humans do.
So here’s my question:
How would you define machine consciousness, and more importantly, how would you measure it?
Gregory M. Kurtzer
@gmkurtzer
Not sure who needs to hear this but....
An LLM doesn't "understand" anything. It is a statistical model that spews out tokens based on probabilities calculated through massive matrix operations and context, not an understanding of the subject matter. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Markets must do ten times as well as government to be half as beloved.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Tips for new teachers:
1. Go at 1/3 the pace you naturally want to.
2. Repetition repetition repetition.
3. When you ask for questions, allow an uncomfortable silence to give them time to respond.
4. Ask them many questions to see what they already understand. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I am not just saddened but puzzled when unsubstantiated allegations lead people's friends to summarily drop them.
If I have to choose between society and a friend, it's not even close.
My friends, I have your backs. And I hope you have mine. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
JEP worthy.
www.richardhanania.com/p/stop-talking-about-ai-job-loss-and -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"A world where machines can do everything humans can cheaply will be rich beyond our wildest imaginations. You would be able to find pocket change in your couch and use it to take a luxury vacation to the Bahamas." www.richardhanania.com/p/stop-talking-about-ai-job-loss-and
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Resource-rich states like the Gulf monarchies spend lavishly on their citizens despite not needing their labor. The Drago view requires assuming that those who capture the gains from AI will be driven almost entirely by narrow self-interest, with no role for moral norms or the status that comes from being seen as generous or benevolent. That is as unrealistic as the Marxist belief that people can be socialized to work only for the collective good." www.richardhanania.com/p/stop-talking-about-ai-job-loss-and
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Inspired by those Foundation for a Better Life posters.
Sincere, as usual. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
News is poison.
History is antidote. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
99% of what excites people today will be forgotten in two years, but you'll never get the time you spent angry back.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
My politics is anti-whoever thinks that it's hard living in America today.
By the time Americans reach middle age, they're more likely to be millionaires than live in poverty.
If you're complaining about immigrants, outsourcing or capitalism, you're just a loser. Or you're trying to appeal and mobilize losers, who shouldn't be in politics.
Wanting things to be better is fine. "Wow we are so wealthy thanks to capitalism and globalization, it would be awesome if it were better." You can even be mad at the structures and movements that stop us from having even higher living standards.
But if I hear any hint of pessimism, self-pity, or victimhood, you are my political enemy. www.richardhanania.com/p/there-are-now-too-many-millionaires -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Kristian Niemietz
@K_Niemietz
"[I]n France [...] they’re currently protesting against ‘neoliberalism’ and ‘brutal austerity’, or, as I call it, government spending levels of 56% of GDP. Does anyone seriously believe that demands for additional public spending would be satiated if we had a wealth tax?"
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The last forty years effectively gave the country’s homophobes a heavy dose of exposure therapy. As usual, the exposure therapy worked."
www.betonit.ai/p/ephemeral-externalities -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Nowadays, I bet that even self-conscious homophobes feel less aversion to gays than the average person in 1982. When you encounter gays all the time, you get accustomed to them – and the antipathy evaporates." www.betonit.ai/p/ephemeral-externalities
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
So doesn't this mean that your fears the sports gambling will undermine more socially useful prediction markets are misplaced?
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"Conducted from September 30 to October 5, the poll found 69% of Democrats and 61% of Republicans firmly against election betting. 65% of respondents opposed wagers on US military action, & 63% rejected contracts on government decisions. Only 8% supported military-related wagers, & 9% did not mind bets on government announcements."
The public minds sports betting much less than bets that share info on important topics. I guess they want only journalists doing that.
sccgmanagement.com/sccg-articles/2026/10/15/us-poll-expos… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
And yet incomes at the bottom rose by a lot.
That should tell you something!
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
The Federal minimum wage was effectively repealed over the last 17 years.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I used to play D&D in middle school. I am the same age as the Stranger Things kids. I do believe in societies that follow the rules." www.betonit.ai/p/hankinson-replies-on-immigration @WatchfulWaiter1
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
An interesting asymmetry: when rich egalitarians fail to give to particular individuals in need, socialists will excuse it on the grounds that poverty is a structural problem, but those same socialists will criticize employers for offering low wages to particular employees.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Straight out of Indiana Jones
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Do positive things.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Scott Lincicome
@scottlincicome
The socialist threat is coming from inside the house
Daniel Di Martino
@DanielDiMartino
Two years ago, what share of GOP voters would agree with government ownership of companies?
Now 29% of GOP voters do. More than Democrats.
This must be reversed. Those who pushed for this may come to regret it if America becomes a socialist country. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Notice that they could've used the same chart to praise blacks.
But would cut against their neurotic misanthropy.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Retard right: We need more cannon fodder and fewer scientists
Expose H1B Fraud
@JobsNowPaper
Indian Americans and Asians have the lowest military participation rate in America.
They want all the wealth and freedom America offers. But they discourage their own kids from serving in the military and expect our kids to bleed and die to protect it.
Their kids stay safe. Our kids go to war. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Thoughts?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Enjoyed this analysis. I combine an appreciation for modern civilization with a contempt for our current politics. Technocapitalism and globalization have made life almost too difficult to screw up, though our thinkers and politicians are trying. www.betonit.ai/p/sentiment-analysis-adding-hanania
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Charles is amazingly productive, and working on the most neglected topic relative to its importance: fertility.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Consider hiring Charles as an economist:
Charles Remien
@CharlesRemien
My paper, "Grandparental Support and the Margins of Fertility Intentions," has been accepted for publication in the Journal of Population Research. Special thanks to @robinhanson, @bryan_caplan, and @VincentGeloso.
Pre-print:
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7322800 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"So I’d put Hanania considerably closer to Caplan than Krugman on baseline enjoyment of modern life." www.betonit.ai/p/sentiment-analysis-adding-hanania
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The distinctive Hanania emotion is contempt." www.betonit.ai/p/sentiment-analysis-adding-hanania
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The right to suicide is the safeguard of dignity.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
But I do have a concept of the dignity of a person.
Imagine someone who is smart, virtuous, honorable, and has had a good impact on the world.
If he suffers a traumatic accident and becomes completely dependent on other people and is no longer himself, I think euthanasia is the dignified choice. It’s not pure utilitarianism.
So I have a concept of dignity. It’s just not what most people who use that term mean, which is something like “preserve life at all costs.”
Kevin Vallier
@kvallier
Hanania's blind spot throughout his career has been a failure to recognize the universal dignity of the person. It manifests in different ways at different times, but that is the theme. He has heard this from people across the political spectrum and remains unmoved by their near-unanimous testimony. I learn a great deal from him, but I'm stunned at his confidence in these idiosyncratic moral judgments and his persistent degradation of religious conviction.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I trust Alex. So should you.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
"Among households headed by someone 65 or older, those with a net worth of at least $1 million outnumber those below the poverty line by roughly two to one."
Americans are ridiculously rich. www.richardhanania.com/p/there-are-now-too-many-millionaires -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Do positive things.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
A replication analysis of my sentiment analysis: www.zappable.com/p/an-in-depth-analysis-of-caplan-and
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
" If you calmly weigh the social benefits of political hyperbole, carefully crunch the numbers, and grudgingly and sorrowfully conclude that it’s justified in specific cases, I’m all ears. But if you defend hyperbole with casual, undiscriminating delight, life’s too short to listen to you."
www.betonit.ai/p/apolitical_reashtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I hate the 'winning proves I’m right' mentality of politics. Winning only proves your views are popular, and popular views are often wrong." www.betonit.ai/p/apolitical_reashtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Je suis Despereaux.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm not saying that we would worship any human with a narrow exceptional ability as a god.
But a human who could fluently discuss any subject in any language?
Outperform top experts, including mathematicians, at their own games?
That is god-like. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Kyle Pomykala
@KylePomykala
"Humanity is a bridge and not a goal," so spoke the most modern prophet.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
??? It's solitaire either way.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
No, AIs can't answer prayer in the ways that most who pray to Go hope that he does.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Will a major religion of AI worship emerge?
Seriously, if a human being could do what AI does, we would worship him as a god. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
We'll never know for sure, but that's highly plausible.
Caveat: If your goal is just to have high status within your ideological tribe, pushing racial antipathy may be a tactical success from your own point of view even though it's bad for your side.
Timbits of Wisdom
@TimBitsOfWisdom
I think the left made a major tactical error when they normalized hatred of “whiteness” because it allowed racial resentment back inside the Overton window.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Fair question.
Answer: Quite a few high-profile Republican politicians have expressed anti-Indian views in the last year. chatgpt.com/s/t_6aca70da370c81919452f1ca30b7eab6
Travelwithofs
@Travelsofofs
Have you seen it expressed off Twitter?
Either in real life or other social media, I get the feeling it owes something to the algorithm and number of Pakistani trolls on this site rather than representing a widespread view among American conservatives. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Even I'm surprised by this.
Misanthropy will latch on to anything.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Where does Indian hate come from? If you see it all over your timeline, you may be confused why a group that commits no crime, pays taxes and works in productive professions causes so much controversy.
The truth is ugly, as I explain here. www.richardhanania.com/p/indians-are-hated-because-they-are -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The irony is that Raskolnikov is one step away from a great truth: Most of history’s 'great men' were criminals who murdered anyone who denied that they were 'benefactors of mankind.'" www.betonit.ai/p/the_banality_of_1html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Availability cascades are one of the most underrated ideas in social science. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_cascade
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"Gambling … requires that any gain comes at others’ expense. It’s hard to reconcile that with the commandment to love our neighbor as ourselves.”
Just like sports & music competitions, right?
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/gambling-betting-religi… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Tomorrow I debate David Spiegelhalter here on “Does it make sense to talk of chances of things like God exists, moral truths, or which is the best Beatles album?” '
What are your arguments on this?
superdebate.org/anti-debate/hanson-spiegelhalter -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Grand Tetons!
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Do positive things.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Subjective personality assessments to achieve a racial balance are un-American in university admissions but apparently appropriate for immigration policy." www.richardhanania.com/p/jocks-and-nerds-are-complements-not
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Do they fret about this collateral damage? I see little sign of it.
Indeed, they plainly dislike a large majority of white native-born Americans, too.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
It’s because there’s no legal and politically feasible way to only allow whites. In reality it’s a combination of both, but the racists see whites as collateral damage.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The symbolism for white South Africans is high, but they've got near-zero interest even in admitting white Canadians, Brits, Australians, etc.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Yes they do. They literally ended all refugee settlement except for white South Africans! They keep out whites and accept it as collateral damage.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even Covid gets retrospectively described partly in terms of the friendship it produced with Dwarkesh Patel." www.betonit.ai/p/a-sentiment-analysis-of-cowen-hanson
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I implicitly measured something like: negative emotional vocabulary when what we actually want is closer to: negative assessment of the state of the world. Those are very different for Cowen." www.betonit.ai/p/a-sentiment-analysis-of-cowen-hanson
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
They don't want white immigrants either.
It really just is pure misanthropy.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Why don’t rightists just advocate for lazier Asians? Or lazy Mexicans? They can get the things they say they want by just giving migrants IQ tests and making sure they’re underachievers. Have a visa for muscular guys who are smart but not too smart! Target 1500 SAT fullbacks.
Of course they won’t recommend that. When you start applying these ideas consistently they look ridiculous.
If we were letting in a bunch of underachiever slackers, they would say that America is about grit and pulling yourself up by your bootstraps. Does anyone disagree with this? Please tell if you don’t think this is true.
This is what’s so annoying. It’s so obvious that they don’t want non-whites and are just making up reasons. www.richardhanania.com/p/are-immigration-restrictionists-bad -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
(1) Regulation themes & priorities are dominated by what makes sense to the public. Leaders pretend to cite expert reasons, but in fact they mostly pander to public concerns.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
He also says it isn't fair to compare his forecast accuracy to @Kalshi's as traders get to look at his forecasts. (Though he gets to look at Kalshi too.)
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
If AI is going to take all the jobs, why can't I find a single person who will bet me on the unemployment rate?
Come on, someone out there must have the courage of their convictions. Please tag any famous people who've made this prediction.
www.richardhanania.com/p/stop-talking-about-ai-job-loss-and -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Do positive things.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
There are rightists who are desperate for "Islamism" to be the threat to Europe, but France is now burning thanks to labor unions and demands that there be no cutbacks in the welfare state. These are the real threats to Western Civilization.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"It is easier to open a new WalMart than to make the Kmart chain better. Advocates of charter cities argue that is also easier to bring in 'outside management' to make a new city that works than to reform existing countries that don’t."
www.betonit.ai/p/a_quick_case_fohtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The point of charter cities is to peacefully create pockets of high-quality First World governance in the heart of the Third World. How? By persuading Third World governments to create new self-governing cities exempt from most existing laws." www.betonit.ai/p/a_quick_case_fohtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"I analyze prediction markets returns from 1880 to 2025 & find no evidence of an overpricing of either left or right-leaning candidates, across a variety of subsamples. In recent elections, there is also no overpricing of either male or female, white or non-white, or young or old candidates" www.nber.org/papers/w35846
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I wrote this 10 years ago. Since then, some top ethicists have bitten the bug bullet.
I still say it's a reductio ad absurdum and they should just recant.
www.betonit.ai/p/bugshtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"It’s easy to show that some creatures are much smarter than others; but how on earth could we ever convincingly show that some feel much less pain than others?" www.betonit.ai/p/bugshtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I actually believe in colorblind meritocracy.
Everyone should look at more successful people and cultures and humbly ask "How can I be more like you?" -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Proud to be coauthoring with Don Boudreaux.
This is how clear thinkers talk. cafehayek.com/2026/10/vances-asserts-actual-decline.html -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
En route to Bozeman!
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Americans keep practicing their childish, cruel, irrational political religions.
Meanwhile, in the real world, driverless cars are here.
Forget your nonsense and embrace the future. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Econ Journal Watch
@EconJWatch
Overreaching on Genes? econjwatch.org/ancillary/book-manuscript-symposium-gregor…
Rosalind Arden and Robert Plomin, John Benning, Noah Carl, Nikolai Eftedal, Joe Francis, Charles Murray, Jan Stuhler, and Greg Clark
Titles include:
Overreaching on Genes
Who’s Afraid of Gregory Clark?
Survival of the Richest
To Have and Have Not
To Know and Know Not -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Isegoria
@Isegoria
“I suspect — though I’m far from sure — that the Caplan Family School is such an exceptional experience that ordinary twin and adoption evidence isn’t relevant.”
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While the power of nurture to change kids’ adult outcomes is indeed vastly overrated, it is well within my power to give my sons a better childhood." www.betonit.ai/p/why_im_homeschohtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Gender segregation at the University of Wisconsin.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While the power of nurture to change kids’ adult outcomes is indeed vastly overrated, it is well within my power to give my sons a better childhood." www.betonit.ai/p/why_im_homeschohtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even if they’re empty half the time, and energy and maintenance double the cost of the car itself, the equilibrium price is about $2 an hour."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-rideshare-revolution -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Uber devastated the taxi industry. But they didn’t just 'drink their milkshake.' They made six additional milkshakes in the process." www.betonit.ai/p/the-rideshare-revolution
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Outside the school context, the overwhelmingly dominant mode of teaching people things is to use Direct Instruction — you literally show them what to do and make them practice it — but education theorists insist this is bad.
www.slowboring.com/p/math-needs-a-phonics-style-reckoning -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I’ve long been shocked by the fraction of people who call themselves 'religious' who can’t even bother to attend a weekly ceremony or speak a daily prayer. But religious devotion is fervent compared to secular communitarian devotion. How many self-styled communitarians have the energy to attend a weekly patriotic or ethnic meeting?"
www.betonit.ai/p/lip_servicehtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While individualists do tend to neglect mankind’s craving for community, they err on the side of truth. Actions really do speak louder than words. And actions reveal that people are far less communitarian than they claim." www.betonit.ai/p/lip_servicehtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Gene Epstein
@GeneSohoForum
In this Soho Forum debate, George Mason econ prof @bryan_caplan defended the resolution, "All government support of higher education should be abolished." Opposed: Harvard econ prof Edward Glaeser.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Zru8oom4CU -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chelsea Olivia Follett
@chellivia
The first copies of my book are here!
The result of years of research and writing, 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘎𝘳𝘪𝘮 𝘖𝘭𝘥 𝘋𝘢𝘺𝘴 takes the reader on a tour of a thankfully lost world of bloodletting, filth, destitution, and famine-induced cannibalism.
Pre-order now: a.co/d/0hrciEBm -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Marian L Tupy
@Marian_L_Tupy
In clinical practice, Swedish mammogram trials demonstrated that AI-assisted screenings caught 29% more cancers while cutting radiologists’ workloads by 44%.
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-amazing-things-ai-is-already-doin… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chelsea Olivia Follett
@chellivia
"Of the vast increase in the well-being of hundreds of millions of people that has occurred in the 200-year course of the industrial revolution to date, virtually none of it can be attributed to the direct redistribution of resources from rich to poor."
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Jeremy Horpedahl 🥚📉
@jmhorp
Schrödinger's libertarian: they simultaneously rule the world and are completely irrelevant
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
It’s hard for me to keep track of the narrative: Did libertarianism lose in the marketplace of ideas or has the intellectual influence of Milton Friedman destroyed America?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Half the U.S. workforce was still in the informal sector in 1880.
chatgpt.com/s/t_6abc00ab98cc8191a5a28ba81fb1c6a9 -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Jeremy Horpedahl 🥚📉
@jmhorp
Wait, the CPI is good again? I thought we were supposed to use the Cost of Thriving Index, which has likely not improved under Trump. I attempted to update it for Oren in 2025, but maybe he will give us the official update for 2026 soon.
economistwritingeveryday.com/2026/04/22/are-americans-thr…
Oren Cass
@oren_cass
I guess @BenShapiro did a monologue last week in which he said tariffs, not foreign policy, are causing affordability problems and driving down President Trump's popularity. So I made a video. If you watch carefully, you _may_ be able to see what caused inflation to spike...
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I "drove" @ATabarrok's driverless car today.
#thefuture! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The silliest thing Hankinson said is that immigration supporters think that 'No country is better than any other.' Of course some countries are better than others. And those countries ought to have a lot more people in them." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-simon-hankinson
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"He even repeatedly voiced the Dadaist, 'What if it was you?' when I pointed out that various fears were astronomically rare. Not kosher."
www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-simon-hankinson -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"At UVA last week, for example, he roughly asked, “If we could replace all the employees at UVA with cheaper immigrant workers, should we?” He refers to the affirmative answer as the “libertarian” view, when it’s really just the standard economists’ view (minus a little hemming and hawing). Which is, in turn, the same as the brutally honest view of any rational person!" www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-simon-hankinson
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
My view on AI doom is the probability is low.
Defaulting to base rates is a good strategy, and here the base rates say we'll be fine. www.richardhanania.com/p/which-experts-should-you-trust-on -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
Yes. The speed in Latam is just incredible.
Immigration to Spain? Hard to tell. Probably it will reduce it in two decades or so, but not before. Nobody migrates until they are older. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
One way to get an estimate of p(doom) is to ask the experts. But experts have different answers to the question of catastrophe/extinction.
FRI superforecasters: 2%
AI specialists: 10%
Metaculus pros: 7.5% or 17%
Which experts you trust matters a lot.
www.richardhanania.com/p/which-experts-should-you-trust-on -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Unlike their AI doom crusade, however, I’m not even slightly worried about the real-world harm of this failure of common sense. Meat and dairy will remain legal, and bug (and shrimp!) welfare will remain fringe topics of idle intellectual curiosity." www.betonit.ai/p/ea-the-good-the-bad-and-the-buggy
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"AI doomsters’ own behavior shows that deep down, they know they’re being silly. Only two doomsters have been willing to bet me; and yes, you absolutely can bet on the end of the world. The optimist prepays the pessimist, end of story."
www.betonit.ai/p/ea-the-good-the-bad-and-the-buggy -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Effective altruists are the opposite of the angry, self-righteous, apathetic, asocial youths who have given their generation a bad name. (And yes, strange as it seems, human beings can be angry, self-righteous, apathetic, and asocial at the same time)." www.betonit.ai/p/ea-the-good-the-bad-and-the-buggy
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Metaculus grew out of the rationalist community, where people are obsessed with the idea of doom. Meanwhile, the Forecasting Research Institute is rooted in Phil Tetlock’s academic work on expertise and making predictions, which has been a project of academic psychologists and economists from the beginning." www.richardhanania.com/p/which-experts-should-you-trust-on
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
AI disempowerment isn't a left-tail risk. It's a right-tail risk.
AI probably won't end war and economically illiterate policy by seizing the reins of power from cruel, irrational humans, but I can hope. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Even Mozart's early juvenalia is fun.
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
there's never been a composer who has improved the world by suppressing their works. likewise, our understanding of the world is not improved by creators suppressing theirs.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
How corrupt is public discourse? Here's one example:
If something .001% as bad as AI doom predictions comes true by 2100, not only will they claim "total vindication."
Normies will AGREE that they were "totally vindicated!" -
Bryan Caplan reposted
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
*taps sign*
ZUBY:
@ZubyMusic
Are there evil rich people? Yes. Absolutely.
But there are far more evil poor people. Both as an absolute number and per capita.
This is obvious if you have eyes and don't lie to yourself. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
According to Chat on max thinking mode, my 2017 blog post is the best that's been done on this. chatgpt.com/s/t_6ab7e1308e2081918c118d8e1a9101ae
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The actual scholars do in general terms, but have not built on the international adoption evidence to give a quantitative estimate of the environmental share.
And the consumers of this research just wallow in misanthropy.
capitalismandfriedman
@capitalismandf1
I don’t know one race realist that doesn’t acknowledge a major role for environment.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The actual scholars do in general terms, but have not built on the international adoption evidence to give a quantitative estimate of the environmental share.
And the consumers of this research just wallow in misanthropy.
capitalismandfriedman
@capitalismandf1
I don’t know one race realist that doesn’t acknowledge a major role for environment.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
David J. Bier
@David_J_Bier
If the premise of your argument is that more workers are bad for your prosperity, then you should move and work somewhere with very few workers around. See if that helps your prosperity.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
After I published my article on Korean adoptees today, a professor at an R1 university wrote to me: "It's a pity I can't assign this in one of my quantitative methods classes."
I got his point, but asked what exactly was stopping him. He wrote the following:
"In one sense, nothing. I have tenure and academic freedom and I don't think I would face the kind of Amy Wax style retaliation that FIRE could sue over. But there would be consequences. The most immediate would be that I would no longer teach or advise grad students – and not because the department chair was punishing me but because students would refuse to take my classes or have me on their dissertation committees. But the more important thing is reserving my credibility for when it is most likely to be effective. You want people to take you seriously when you speak in a faculty meeting or advocate a policy at your university or in your discipline. This isn't careerism, it's about strategic understanding of picking battles to have the most impact, especially given that I am not teaching about inequality and there are other ways to teach the auxiliary hypothesis problem that would be much more effective because they wouldn't make students too upset to appreciate the methodological point."
Good demonstration of how academic pressure comes from below. You can have all the free speech protections you want, and maybe you won't be disciplined or fired, but no law or regulation can stop students from refusing to take your classes, other academics from not wanting to write papers with you, etc. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Everyone should read these international adoption papers.
Normies have to accept that genes are a major cause of international IQ differences.
Race realists have to accept that environment is ALSO a major cause of international IQ differences.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Between 1958 and 1990, 20% of the children Korea sent abroad for adoption were classified as special needs or disabled, compared to less than 0.1% of those adopted domestically.
In 1976, Korea even came up with a plan to phase out international adoption, making an exception for only mixed-race and handicapped children. They eventually walked this back, but it shows how, according to one scholar, "South Korea’s private adoption industry functioned as a replacement for the nation’s social welfare system.”
Yet, when scholars eventually studied the outcomes for Koreans adopted abroad, they found that they did cognitively and academically better than natives in Sweden and the Netherlands.
It's one of the great mysteries of social science, which I write about here. www.richardhanania.com/p/were-1970s-korean-orphanages-a-g… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"One of Robert Lucas’ most notable insights is that human capital (unlike, say, oil) moves from where it is scarce to where it is plentiful."
www.betonit.ai/p/lucas_meets_goghtml -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What is a probability that Trump actually orders indiscriminate attacks on Iran that lead to the deaths of >100K Iranian civilians?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"My decision may have been influenced by @catehall ’s *You Can Just Do Things*!" www.betonit.ai/p/on-stage-with-the-emo-kids
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What is a probability that Trump actually orders indiscriminate attacks on Iran that lead to the deaths of >100K Iranian civilians?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Very good discussion of an obscure yet thought-provoking passage from Arthur Jensen.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Since people are talking about the meaning and implications of extremely low IQs, I'll add something I think everyone should understand: an IQ of 70 is used to indicate* mental retardation because of what it tends to be caused by in certain populations.
This is a roundabout way of saying that a low IQ indicates mental retardation because of what it means for a person's behavior, which, I'll explain, covaries with its causes.
IQs are mostly normally distributed, and IQs represent the influences of multiple different constructs and causes, but they primarily reflect differences in general intelligence.
But there's a major deviation from normality at the lower-end of the scale. If you sample well enough, you'll see something like this:
The reason is that there are the normal-range causes that produce the normal distribution, and then there are extreme circumstances that produce extraordinarily low IQs. Contrarily, we don't know of anything that produces abnormally high IQs. There's no known one-off mutation that makes someone a genius, but there are many mutations that we now know can make a person extremely unintelligent.
Consider this diagram from a recent paper by @AlexTISYoung:
A few very rare protein-truncating variants have enormous negative effects on a person's educational attainment! But nothing we know of has enormous positive effects.
As the saying goes, it's far easier to break a machine than to throw a wrench in it and make it work. And that makes sense! Your wrench in the gears is likely to break something, not increase efficiency by 50%. If you hit someone in the head hard enough, you can reduce their IQ score, but not in a million years will you turn them into von Neumann.
The reason someone's IQ drops after you bludgeon them is more singular and specific than the reasons IQ varies in the general population. A hit to the noggin may leave someone unable to flex their short-term memory, even if their visuospatial rotation capabilities are unaffected. There's some degree of isolation of function and compensation for deficits in the brain. We know this thanks to many observations, like on the effects of neural lesions (I'll link something fun on this topic with the sources at the end).
When we say that someone with an IQ of ≤70 is mentally retarded**, we're saying that they lack adaptive behavior—that they're not very bright, and so it makes living life hard.
But if a population legitimately has a mean IQ of 70 (and some do!), we'll notice that they're not drooling troglodytes who can't put on their shoes. This is because the reasons for their low IQ are not things that cause specific and extreme deficits, but instead, things that cause normal-range variation, which is far less severe in nature.
One of the ways we know IQ is normally distributed is also a way that we know different causes are at work in certain cases of intellectual disability: sibling comparisons!
In large Israeli (B) and Swedish (A) datasets, we can see that when a person has a mild intellectual disability, their sibling tends to be less intelligent too. You also see this for heights, autism, or any other highly polygenic trait.
But when a sibling has severe—AKA, "idiopathic"—intellectual disability, the distribution of their sibling's IQs is the same as the distribution for the general population.
The deficits in adaptive behavior that result from idiopathic intellectual disability are ones that often make life hard to live in discrete and extreme ways. In some cases, you wouldn't even recognize them as being "retarded" because they have conditions like amnesia, where the person is clearly odd and unfortunate, and they score poorly on an IQ test, but they might sound totally coherent otherwise.
Normal-range causes lead to linear changes in adaptive behavior; idiopathic mental retardation, leads to a discontinuous decrease in adaptive behavior.
Accordingly, an IQ of 70 does not have the same meaning for members of different groups, since if a group with a mean IQ of 70 randomly pulls a person with an IQ of 70, they aren't likely to score like someone who's mentally retarded for idiopathic reasons.
Jensen, incidentally, predicted this sort of result based on some observations he made as an educator.
"My student said he was looking for a good culture-free or culture-fair test of intelligence and had not been able to find one. All the tests he used, whether they were claimed to be culture-fair or not, were in considerable agreement with respect to children diagnosed as educationally mentally retarded (EMR), by which they were assigned to special small classes offering a different instructional program from that in the regular classes. To qualify for this special treatment, children had to have IQs below 75 as well as lagging far behind their age-mates in scholastic performance. My student, who had examined many of these backward pupils himself, had gained the impression that the tests were quite valid in their assessments of white middle-class children but not of minority lower-class children.
"Many of the latter, despite IQs below 75 and markedly poor scholastic performance, did not seem nearly as retarded as the white middle-class children with comparable IQs and scholastic records. Middle-class white children with IQs in the EMR range generally appeared more retarded than the minority children who were in special classes. Using nonverbal rather than verbal tests did not appreciably alter the problem. I confirmed my students observations for myself by observing EMR children in their classes and on the playground and by discussing their characteristics with a number of teachers and school psychologists. My student’s observations proved reliable.
"EMR children who were called ‘culturally disadvantaged’, as contrasted with middle-class EMR children, appeared much brighter socially and on the playground, often being quite indistinguishable in every way from children of normal IQ except in their scholastic performance and in their scores on a variety of standard IQ tests. Middle-class white children diagnosed as EMR, on the other hand, though they constituted a much smaller percentage of the EMR classes, usually appeared to be more mentally retarded all round and not just in their performance in scholastic subjects and IQ tests. I asked myself, how could one devise a testing procedure that would reveal this distinction so that it could be brought under closer study and not depend upon casual observations and impressions."
The distinction between types of mental retardation that are demarcated by their symptoms and, thus, by their causes, is important to understand. It's why an IQ of 70 for a Japanese person is likely to indicate an extraordinarily severe issue in need of attention, while for a Bushman, they won't have any trouble surviving.
A low normal-range IQ score is bad, but depending on its causes, it's likely to come with different symptoms that make it more or less bad. Final note: this does have implications for the use of IQ as a means of mitigating the punishment of serious criminals on death row.
Sources:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168952523001671
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289621000659
www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1508093112
www.emilkirkegaard.com/p/african-iqs-and-mental-retardation
* Indicate, not diagnose.
** This is not how mental retardation is actually diagnosed, despite popular misconception. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ancap Joker
@theancapjoker
Just finished reading. Great book by @bryan_caplan
@Rerazer should check it out. It's definitely better than Batman -
Bryan Caplan reposted
The Daisy Protocol
@Daisy_Protocol
Even "principled" Cato interns were resistant to open borders when I was there and they struggled to explain their views. Fear of the OTHER is so primal that people often don't even know why they oppose immigration.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Don't believe the propaganda on MAID.
In 2021, the average recipient was 76.3 years old. Almost two-thirds had cancer, 19% had cardiovascular conditions, 12% had neurological conditions and 8% had organ failure.
This is a humane, rational program that is working about as well as any government program can possibly work.
People hate it for religious reasons, and want to force others to suffer indefinitely for no good reason.
Opposition to MAID is evil. www.richardhanania.com/p/canadian-euthanasia-as-moral-pro… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Speaking at @UVA today. Who's around?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Monopsony allows firms to realize economies of scale; economies of scale raise worker productivity; and higher worker productivity allows better pay and working conditions."
www.betonit.ai/p/firm-functionalism -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Most of these accusations casually assume away crucial constraints. Once you take these constraints seriously, the performance of the business world is objectively outstanding." www.betonit.ai/p/firm-functionalism
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Immigrants assimilate so well that by the second-generation they're already nativists.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I talk about @a16z's education startup with @eva_roytburg. I think it will be a great success for a handful of top young people, but it's no threat to the status quo. fortune.com/2026/09/22/a16z-horowitz-andreessen-academy-c…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I don't know whether Clavicular is guilty of the charges against him.
But women who stay in contact with their alleged "rapists" do not deserve sympathy.
They make life harder for both rape victims and men who need to defend against false allegations. www.richardhanania.com/p/women-who-stay-in-contact-with-t… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I’m going to be on Rising this morning to talk about this article on climate change being the world’s most overrated problem. Come join us, but read the article first. www.richardhanania.com/p/climate-change-the-worlds-most-o…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Since 1980, Reagan, Clinton, and Obama had general charisma. Trump has partisan charisma only. The last election where both parties had a charismatic candidate was 1964, where Johnson (general charisma) clobbered Goldwater (partisan charisma only)." www.betonit.ai/p/the-neo-median-voter-model
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The traditional Median Voter Model’s central erroneous prediction is platform convergence. In the Neo-Median Voter Model, platforms diverge widely, especially on issues where the base is passionate and the median voter in the general election is apathetic. And it’s amazing how many issues most people are apathetic about."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-neo-median-voter-model -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"U.S. politics has grown so weird during the last decade that I suspect a revision to the Median Voter Model is in order. I dub this the Neo-Median Voter Model." www.betonit.ai/p/the-neo-median-voter-model
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The U.S. has reached a new level of negligence. It used to demonstrate selective care: When we fight, we win — and win quickly and decisively; we just don’t know what to do after we win. Now it can’t be negligent after victory, because there will be no victory."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Trump’s Iran War really does put all of the wars of my adult lifetime in a new perspective. Why? Because for the first time in decades, the U.S. has failed even to competently plan for the war!" www.betonit.ai/p/the-negligence-of-war-and-peace
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I just took a drive in @ATabarrok's new driverless car. Finally, you don't have to keep touching the steering wheel!
Alas, @ChatGPT says it's still 6 years before you can buy a car that drives while you sleep, even though it's safer than a human already. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I introduced @RichardHanania to @AlexEpstein, so I like to think that I deserve a small share of the credit for this fine piece.
www.richardhanania.com/p/climate-change-the-worlds-most-o… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Contrary to many historians, Lenin’s atrocities were foreseeable. And contrary to Lenin’s admirers, his strategy of atrocity was pure cliche." www.betonit.ai/p/the_roots_of_lehtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you want to know what's really on Americans' minds, ignore the news and social media, and just study this survey. Almost no one cares about 90% of the stuff you hear about.
news.gallup.com/poll/1675/most-important-problem.aspx -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Classic.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The open-minded thing for high-status people to do is charge the low-status people who want to debate them.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
X proposing to debate Y is claim by X that X has status comparable to Y. X refusing to debate Y is claim by X that X has status far above Y.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I'm in this Freakonomics episode on prediction markets:
freakonomics.com/podcast/are-prediction-markets-the-best-… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"But after ten days in India, I confidently declare that the children of randomly-selected Indians would do well here. Like the Indians who are already here, they’d adopt almost everything good about modern U.S. culture, while retaining the strong family values that Americans have been foolishly forgetting." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-india
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Panel for the late great Brian Doherty. www.betonit.ai/p/in-honor-of-brian-doherty
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It's a claim I'd bet on. But yes, prediction far outside of the observed range is hard.
Daniel Di Martino
@DanielDiMartino
This requires being able to estimate not just the point elasticity of demand but much of the curve shape, that is difficult to extrapolate fo 700K from the EB-5 program which is just about 10K visas. But open to ideas. This is something I want to estimate
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
I was honored to be part of a discussion of the legacy of my late @reason colleague @brianmdoherty last week. Other participants included @kmanguward @katrinagulliver, and @bryan_caplan, hosted by @FountainheadFm's Chris Baker. www.youtube.com/live/luqPnuPaaxE
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Like *Promises I Can Keep*, the new book leaves little doubt that poverty is a state of mind – and that state of mind is low conscientiousness." www.betonit.ai/p/doing_the_besthtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If behavioral economics helps explain anything in the real world, it helps explain poverty. Everyone deviates from the rational actor model from time to time, but the poor deviate far more."
www.betonit.ai/p/doing_the_besthtml -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Perry E. Metzger
@perrymetzger
Entire books have been written, but they are completely unpersuasive. It’s ultimately the same “singleton AI builds nanotechnology and eats the planet” scenario I made up for personal entertainment 35 years ago, and should not be taken seriously by anyone.
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
Entire books have literally been written laying out these mechanisms. I mean, you can disagree with the predictions, assumptions or probabilities, but this idea that doomers haven’t proposed (numerous) concrete pathways by which ASI may kill us all is just ignorant.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Even a $100k annual tariff would probably mean millions of immigrants per year.
Daniel Di Martino
@DanielDiMartino
Actually yes it would be great to just admit people based on an immigration tariff instead of the current system.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Daniel Di Martino
@DanielDiMartino
Jim is the person who I trust most to do a documentary about the impact of socialism in Venezuela.
This is why I encourage you to watch it.
@jimepstein @reason
Katherine Mangu-Ward
@kmanguward
I don't know if y'all know this, but socialism didn't work out very well in Venezuela. @reason has a new feature documentary by @jimepstein about a family's attempt to survive and escape the collapse.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
David J. Bier
@David_J_Bier
They're hated because of their success.
Daniel Di Martino
@DanielDiMartino
Indian immigrants—by far—pay more taxes and receive less government benefits than any other major national origin group in the United States.
This is because they have the highest median household income.
They also have one of the lowest incarceration rate of any group. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Some say they do this because their arguments are especially subtle & complex. I instead think they do this in part because their arguments here are especially weak:
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies … prove[s] way too much, as their structure applies to any changed descendants, not just AIs: any descendants who change from how we are today due to something like training or natural selection won’t be happy or joyous, or embody value, and they’ll kill any other creatures less powerful than they." www.overcomingbias.com/p/if-anything-changes-all-value-dies
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Never read the comments.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"Then what’s the point of the strict safety regulation?Markets will happily provide all the safety people are willing to pay for."
That's the point - people see other people as not willing to pay enough for safety.
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"'Could you get it if you were rich?' This question is an elegant way to tell the difference between phony and genuine market failures. If you can fix a problem by throwing some of your money at it, the market is working."
www.betonit.ai/p/could-you-get-it-if-you-were-rich -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Boerne Bro
@BoerneBro
And conversely, if it’s bad (at least at scale) with paperwork, it’s still bad (at least at scale) without paperwork.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Beige &
@JadenEarlorg
This but alignment
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
When I was in high school, I dreamed of a world where people wanted to spend all day arguing about philosophy, politics, and economics.
Now we're here, and I was wrong.
Wrong! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Anyone want to do a late meet-up in Cincinnati tonight?" www.betonit.ai/p/upcoming-events-0b2
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Across 477 coup attempts in one major dataset, about 48% succeeded overall, but attempts originating with top military elites succeeded 76.4% of the time, whereas those led by lower-level/combat officers succeeded only 29%." @ChatGPT
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"'Could you get it if you were rich?' This question is an elegant way to tell the difference between phony and genuine market failures. If you can fix a problem by throwing some of your money at it, the market is working."
www.betonit.ai/p/could-you-get-it-if-you-were-rich -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Do you really think that the rich cannot get high-quality products? Or to put it more personally: For any given product, could you get it if you were rich?" www.betonit.ai/p/could-you-get-it-if-you-were-rich
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Absurdly optimistic, but not as absurd as the pessimism of AI doomers.
At least lots of smart people will be TRYING to use AI to cure disease.
Pedro Domingos
@pmddomingos
If AI will cure all diseases within a decade, slowing it down is mass murder.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Housing market deregulation
Connor
@alsoconnor
I will attempt to genuinely engage with this take. What is a bold, radical centrist policy that a young person could presumably like?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If it’s perfectly fine to do something with paperwork, it can’t be very bad to do the same thing without paperwork." www.betonit.ai/p/immigration-laws-are-made-to-be-broken
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Friedman's most-quoted, least-defensible line. www.betonit.ai/p/friedman-contra-open-borders-round
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Understanding the fiscal impact of immigration is important but I always thought this was one of Friedman’s weirder lines … you can make the immigrants ineligible for benefits and then the taxes they pay turn them into net contributors.
Milton Friedman Daily
@MiltonFriedmanW
“You cannot simultaneously have a welfare state and free immigration.”
— Milton Friedman -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When neurotics turn to politics, they find an infinite series of reasons to feel bad, which helps them stay one step ahead of the realization that their fundamental problem is inside their own heads and can be fixed by no one but themselves." www.betonit.ai/p/neurotic_politihtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
The Husky
@Mr_Husky1
People say:
"I wish one middle-class income could support an entire family like it did in the 1950s."
Okay. Then take the entire 1950s package—not just the parts you romanticize.
• No Netflix, Disney+, Spotify, or endless subscriptions
• One small TV with 3 channels, if you're lucky
• One basic car for the whole family
• No yearly vacations or cheap flights across the country
• No smartphones, laptops, gaming consoles, or internet
• Every meal cooked at home from scratch
• Kids sharing bedrooms
• A house under 1,000 sq. ft. for a family of 4–6
• One bathroom for everyone
• Little to no air conditioning in many places
• Clothes repaired, reused, and handed down
• Eating at restaurants was an occasional luxury, not a weekly habit
The comparison isn't just income.
The average household today consumes far more space, technology, entertainment, travel, convenience, and services than the average household did 70 years ago.
That doesn't mean housing, healthcare, and education aren't more expensive today—they are.
But when people compare lifestyles across generations, they often compare a 1950s income to a 2020s standard of living.
Those aren't the same thing.
If you want the economics of the 1950s, you have to accept the lifestyle of the 1950s too. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I originally wrote this LARP 10 years ago for the 7th birthday of my son, Simon. The kids had a great time, and I think the structure holds up." www.betonit.ai/p/the-trials-of-dagobah-a-larp-for
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
And don't forget what almost everyone said would happen when 1999 became 2000: Y2K (computers would misinterpret the year "00" as 1900)
Planes would fall out of the sky and air traffic control centers would cease.
Power grids and municipal water systems would shut down.
Banking, Wall Street, and the economy would collapse.
Hospital medical systems would stop.
Software controlling nuclear weapons would glitch us into a nuclear war.
Society would collapse.
What did the doomsters say when none of this happened? Either:
"Our warnings were headed so we saved civilization"
or
"climate change is going to kill us all"
It never ends. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Our world is full of areas of life, like romance, where things go wrong big all the time, but few are inclined thereby to greatly increase our regulations of them. Things going wrong does NOT reliably lead to strong regulation.
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
Those who think they can permanently stop safety interventions are deluded.
It's in the interest of those who want to avoid onerous regulations to introduce safety measures in an orderly fashion.
The alternative is a powerful backlash after some serious incident. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
AI "disaster" is inevitable because no matter what happens, activists will cry "disaster."
Just like nuclear power.
Fortunately, unlike nuclear power, moral panics against AI will be largely impotent.
Stopping progress in atoms is easy; stopping progress in bits is not. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Team Caplan is going to GaryCon, March 18-21, 2027!
Want to play with us?
Get your badge before they sell out. (waited too long last year, FOMO activated)
www.garycon.com -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"We may be dissatisfied with television for two quite different reasons: because the set does not work, or because we dislike the program we are receiving. Similarly, we may be dissatisfied with ourselves for two quite different reasons: because our body does not work (bodily illness), or because we dislike our conduct (mental illness)." - Thomas Szasz, *The Untamed Tongue*
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Permanently relevant.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Funny how immigration is the one issue where suddenly wokes have the best understanding of economics, even if the demographics here are a bit off.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
“I urge everyone to ask of any policy: How would a government use this for ill?”
Ramez Naam
@ramez
It seems we will now be entering a phase of AI congressional hearings and legislation.
There are many no-regret ways to increase AI safety. Mandatory transparency. Audits. An NTSB-like investigatory safety agency that identifies root cause of incidents. Proactive ways to use AI and other tools to bolster digital and biological security. Incentives and anti-trust exceptions to encourage lateral sharing on safety and alignment techniques between labs. Liability law to align lab incentives even further with society at large.
There are also policies that would impede the positive developments of AI, or which would give governments undo influence on AI models, or dangerous new powers of surveillance and censorship.
I want to register again that loss of control is not the AI risk that worries me most. It's over-control that leads to less freedom and a more authoritarian system of government that I see as the most plausible large scale harm of AI to society.
As we have these debates over the coming weeks and months, I urge everyone to ask of any policy: How would a government use this for ill? How could this be used to surveil, suppress, manipulate, or control a populace?
We have no hard evidence that AI poses an existential threat to humanity. That doesn't mean we shouldn't be cautious and embrace no-regret policies. But in doing so, let's not make the obvious and most historically likely threat - further rollback of democratic freedoms - more likely.
Thanks. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I've joined this bet, saying <20% chance of 15%/yr US GDP growth before 2033.
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Some new joiners for a total pot size of $575k!
On my side:
@robinhanson
@phl43
@SashaKaletsky
@_gabrielunger
On the fast-growth side:
@jankulveit
plus @SamuelAlbanie continuing to increase his stake 😮
benjaminmoll.com/growth_bet/
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Some real diversity of opinion at Google DeepMind: @alexolegimas joins the bet while his colleague @SamuelAlbanie takes the other side increasing his existing stake!
Total size of pot now $425,000!
benjaminmoll.com/growth_bet/
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Thanks to @willmacaskill, @SamuelAlbanie, @tomcohen for taking the other side of this bet at 4:1 odds and to @andrewho03 for joining on my side.
Here are the final terms we agreed on benjaminmoll.com/growth_bet/
More (within) ~7 years from now 😃
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Would anyone like to take the other side of the following bet? I bet you (say) $25k inflation-adjusted that U.S. per capita real GDP growth will be <15% per annum in 2033 or any year before that. (15% implies a doubling time of ~5 years.)
Note: I'm extremely bullish on AI and...
Sholto Douglas
@_sholtodouglas
How fast could the economy double? TLDR, once we have good enough AI and tens of millions of robots - very fast.
As crazy as it feels now - it is worth pricing in economic doublings into your mental models of the 2030s. Strongly recommend reading this series of blog posts by Damon Binder. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
$5k dividend offered.
electionbettingodds.com doesn't move. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
David Pearce
@webmasterdave
“If no one builds it, everyone dies” is a counter-narrative.
But a slow crumbling away from the ravages of aging isn’t as exciting as a zombie apocalypse. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Indians! Indians were the issue in those days. I can assure you, gentlemen, there is nothing quite so grotesque as the meeting of a child with a bullet; or an entire village slaughtered while sleeping. That was the Government's resolution of that particular issue and I have seen nothing in its behavior since then that would persuade me that it has gained either in wisdom, common sense, or humanity." *Legends of the Fall*
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"He’s had an amazing career in Germany doing two things I greatly admire: making lots of money in real estate, and judiciously assessing the Nazis’ degree of commitment to socialism." www.betonit.ai/p/zitelmann-on-hitlers-economics
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm going to be on this panel honoring my friend Brian Doherty at 8 PM ET tonight.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=luqPnuPaaxE -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Impressive. I was unaware of almost all of this.
archerships - e/acc, pronatalist, immortalist
@archerships
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Classic @ATabarrok:
"We learn by doing. Thus, no doing, no learning." marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/09/no-doin… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
How about a 40% move back to normalcy?
That's what I expect.
Leaders as beloved by their side as Trump are strangely yet happily ultra-scarce.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Some people hope for a 'return to normalcy' after Trump leaves office. I find that a pretty unlikely scenario.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
All correct, except sheer misanthropy is a much bigger cause of opposition to immigration than mere racism.
Seriously, many Latin Americans are *clearly* white, yet I've seen zero sign that opponents of immigration feel bad about exiling them.
www.richardhanania.com/p/are-keyhole-solutions-to-immigra… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
No one can deny immigration is good for the economy.
So people like Bryan Caplan have proposed "keyhole solutions" to deal with negative externalities. Restrictionists respond that such solutions are unrealistic.
I show that they're wrong.
Immigration with conditions is more popular than immigration without conditions.
Keyhole solutions are in face quite politically viable. They would be more popular if more people actually advocated for them.
That way you'd get all the benefits of immigration and none of the downsides. www.richardhanania.com/p/are-keyhole-solutions-to-immigra… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What is wisdom?
It is knowing that when your crying kid says there are monsters under his bed, he's wrong.
You don't even have to check. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Compared to all other doomsters, AI doomsters are highly intelligent.
But their wisdom is low.
Even more than normies, they are given to paranoia and herding.
Even more than normies, they are full of excuses for refusing to bet.
Honorable exceptions:
www.betonit.ai/p/another-end-of-the-world-bet -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
They've been right about AI becoming awesome much sooner than expected.
They haven't been right about AIs killing any humans.
P.S. All awesome techs eventually kill some people. If AI does eventually start killing as many humans as cars, it will probably still be worth it.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
People say AI doomers have been right about a lot.
But to take a broader perspective, Luddites and people who are fearful of new technology developed through the private sector have nearly always been wrong.
I tend to think they'll be wrong here too.
www.richardhanania.com/p/what-if-were-already-solving-ali… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Terrorizing your people and pouring resources into the military help governments last a long time, but are not impressive.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Given big intrinsic disadvantages of communism relative to capitalism, I gotta admit to being impressed by how long it lasted, and how much it managed to do. Capitalism as practiced clearly has some big problems weighing it down.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Why government shouldn't pause AI.
We've already proved that we can't handle risk. Look at nuclear power, which we've strangled over fake safety concerns. Even self-driving cars are controversial.
How would a pause not just turn into a permanent ban? www.richardhanania.com/p/what-if-were-already-solving-ali… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Hearing voices" is actually very common.
What's rare is obeying these voices when they tell you to murder people.
www.betonit.ai/p/has_bentall_exphtml -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Today, don’t forget to be thankful for cheap labor, the one kind of labor everyone hates because they don’t understand how economics works.
May today be a day to remember all the harms of artificially boosting wages. www.richardhanania.com/p/theres-nothing-wrong-with-cheap-… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
zephyr
@ShadowyZephyr
Loans are either paid by other people via estate (spouse, children), or paid by society as a whole by proxy (if they die with you).
This logic only applies if other people live. If you think AI is going to kill EVERYONE, it doesn't make sense to save money.
Eliezer Yudkowsky
@allTheYud
lol if you really think you have terminal cancer why aren't you taking out huge personal bank loans to use for parties
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I’ve repeatedly heard academics insist 'We really need to hire a woman!' Sounds like a taste for discrimination against men to me." www.betonit.ai/p/tabarrok_shouldhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even if we control for quality of publications, the gatekeepers also feel virtually no cost of rejecting articles they find ideologically distasteful. So there is probably more discrimination against right-wingers than the data suggest, not less."
www.betonit.ai/p/tabarrok_shouldhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Why don’t department chairs fight to replace senile tenured faculty with bright, eager graduate student instructors? First, they pocket essentially none of the savings; second, their lives would become a living hell." www.betonit.ai/p/tabarrok_shouldhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
AI doom is way bigger in my
Bubble than climate doom, but I doubt that reflects the broader world.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
One good thing about the freakout over AI is it’s crowding out climate change alarmism.
Remember when we used to worry about a few degrees rise over the course of a century, when we’d have literally generations more of economic growth to ensure that the weather continues not to matter?
We all recognize that’s stupid now, right? We can all admit now that weather only matters a lot for human welfare if you’re really poor?
I hope so.
I think you people are too neurotic. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Not as crazy, but I'm happy to bet against any global disaster scenario.
And it's easy. To repeat: The optimist pre-pays the pessimist.
Shaji Sebastian
@shajise
As Jensen often likes to say: "You won't be taken over by AI, but by someone using AI".
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
A common misunderstanding.
End of the world bets totally work. The optimist pre-pays the pessimist, and collects when disaster does not happen.
CMI
@cmi_dwarf
Anyone should take this bet, regardless of their thoughts on the subject. if you win, you win. if you lose, we're dead anyway, so who cares?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Happy to bet.
Aella
@Aella_Girl
it's getting harder for me to understand people who *don't* think there's a very serious risk of AI takeover very soon.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Spotted at Tyson's Corner.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Seriously, what would you do if you were born in Haiti?
"Stay and try to fix your country" doesn't even pass the laugh test. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Evergreen:
Jeremiah Johnson 🌐
@JeremiahDJohns
"Capitalism is why people have to work" is very silly thing to say, but it's part of a grand tradition of blaming literally everything, no matter how absurd, on capitalism.
A short thread: -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Almost everyone would admit that immigration restrictions are deeply unjust if they were stuck in dire poverty and had a job offer in another country.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
David J. Bier
@David_J_Bier
We're being gaslit. For my entire adult life, nearly all conservatives said their opposition to immigration was limited to illegal, not legal, immigration. Now that I say we should have legal ways for them to come. Their response gives away the lie.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Smart minds wish they were smarter.
Mediocre minds wish there were no such thing as being smart. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I say Stalin was bad from the beginning, even more so than other contemporary Marxists.
www.betonit.ai/p/could-such-a-man-care
www.betonit.ai/p/the_roots_of_lehtml
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
If you want to see how power corrupts, it would be hard to find a life better demonstrating that point than that of Stalin.
He started out as an idealist, and ended up as an idealist and a sadist. He remains enigmatic because there were multiple Stalins. www.richardhanania.com/p/robert-trivers-stalin-and-the-dark -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
New AMA: www.betonit.ai/p/ama-start-of-the-2026-academic-year
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Hitler was not a socialist in the classical Marxist sense. But he was undoubtedly an anti-capitalist and a socialist in the modern sense of the word. In this respect, Musk is right."
www.washingtonexaminer.com/op-eds/4712226/was-hitler-a-so… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The two biggest causal effects of education:
1. Raising your income.
2. Raising the education of your spouse.
Two much-discussed but tiny causal effects:
1. How much you learn and retain.
2. Your political and social opinions. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Bastiat on "PROTECTION and COMMUNISM": www.gutenberg.org/files/44144/44144-h/44144-h.htm
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Blast from 2005.
AI fixed all the broken links and gave me cool artwork.
www.betonit.ai/p/tabarrok_shouldhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It's very competitive, but it's competition between heavily subsidized non-profit worker collectives. Remember: It's departments, not "universities," that control faculty hiring.
www.betonit.ai/p/tabarrok_shouldhtml
Peter G. Klein
@petergklein
I don’t think anything in academia - a heavily cartelized industry dominated by the state - can fairly be described as competitive.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Guest workers in the Gulf monarchies are:
(a) Working voluntarily because pay is vastly higher than in their home countries
(b) Slaves held in bondage because their passports have been stolen -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
How SS benefits are calculated.
Good to know on many levels. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"A more zero-sum mindset is strongly associated with more support for government redistribution, race- and gender-based affirmative action, and more restrictive immigration policies." www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20240692
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Guest workers in the Gulf monarchies are:
(a) Working voluntarily because pay is vastly higher than in their home countries
(b) Slaves held in bondage because their passports have been stolen -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
DC area meet-up Sat at 10 PM!
All are welcome. Come talk ideas and make friends.
www.betonit.ai/p/silver-diner-dc-meet-up-this-weekend -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Nice.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you’re still complaining about your economic suffering when your net worth is several hundred thousand dollars, your problem is not economic, but psychological. You’re rich, but neurotic." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-americans-net-worth
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Given their current net wealth, a solid majority of Americans can comfortably retire without Social Security. The federal government could cut them off completely and they’d still do fine. The best rationale for the status quo is paternalism, but most Americans are well-prepared for their futures even ignoring Social Security." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-americans-net-worth
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Americans of staggering net wealth are all around us. If you walk around an American mall on a weekend, you probably cross paths with several decamillionaires. But except for being older, you probably couldn’t pick them out of a crowd."
www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-americans-net-worth -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Net worth is very high in absolute terms. The median is over six figures by the mid-30s. Americans at the 75th percentile are millionaires by their mid-50s. Americans at the 90th percentile are millionaires by around 40. Claims about middle-class, middle-aged Americans who “can’t afford” eggs or gas or beef are nonsense." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-americans-net-worth
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why do smart people believe in UFOs and AI doom but no other conspiracy theories?
Their youthful consumption of sci-fi has made them pathologically open-minded about this nonsense!
They can't accept that sci-fi is just Tolkien with a little science dust sprinkled on it.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The UFO discourse drives me crazy. The idea of aliens has gone mainstream like never before. People are convinced that things have been hidden from us, and there's good reason to think we've been visited by aliens.
Don't buy any of it. Our ability to monitor the sky, from camera phones to radar and observation satellites, has increased exponentially.
Meanwhile, the evidence for aliens remains exactly the same: eyewitness testimony and grainy dots that appear to move funny.
The sky is vast. It is full of birds, planes, drones, balloons, satellites, etc. It is also where the sun is, which is known to create optical illusions. Of course there are going to be things that appear weird!
Whenever government actually seriously looks into the phenomenon, they find that some incidents can be explained, others can't because of a lack of data, and there is no evidence for alien visitors or something supernatural. Debunking videos get posted online and published in government reports, but don't get a fraction of the attention of conspiracy theory podcasts telling us that aliens are here.
The interesting question is why the hysteria has come now. It's simply a reflection of living in a populist era. There were always UFO cranks, but scientists and government experts used to be able to dismiss them.
Now we take them seriously. But that doesn't mean the evidence has gotten better. In fact, it's weaker than ever. The UFO phenomenon reflects us getting worse at separating fact from fiction. www.richardhanania.com/p/the-case-for-ufos-is-weaker-than -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
At minimum, 40% of the IQ gap between Sweden and the Third World is environmental.
I can't honestly say 100%. But people talking as if the data support 0% are totally wrong.
Wrong for IQ, height, weight, head size, and much more.
Details:
www.betonit.ai/p/the_wonder_of_ihtml
Joel Berry
@JoelWBerry
Racists hate adoption because it blows their entire worldview to smithereens.
I know a family who adopted a kid from the Congo. He’s a hillbilly with a southern accent who loves Jesus and loves deer hunting. Aside from his looks, indistinguishable from his family and community. They have a daughter they adopted from Ethiopia. She now teaches at a university.
The “DNA is destiny” crowd has no answer to this except to seethe. Adoption is a beautiful picture of what Christ did for us. That’s why Satan and his minions hate it. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
In Sweden, international adoptees (except Koreans) have markedly lower IQ than native-born Swedes, even when they're adopted at birth.
But kids internationally adopted at birth by Swedes also grow up to have markedly HIGHER IQ than the average person in their home countries.
Joel Berry
@JoelWBerry
Racists hate adoption because it blows their entire worldview to smithereens.
I know a family who adopted a kid from the Congo. He’s a hillbilly with a southern accent who loves Jesus and loves deer hunting. Aside from his looks, indistinguishable from his family and community. They have a daughter they adopted from Ethiopia. She now teaches at a university.
The “DNA is destiny” crowd has no answer to this except to seethe. Adoption is a beautiful picture of what Christ did for us. That’s why Satan and his minions hate it. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Why pointless? Because any professor who did pickpocket his students would probably not be dissuaded by a training seminar. Wrong-doers already know the rules; they just don’t care."
www.betonit.ai/p/dont-pickpocket-your-students -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Dedicated to every less-than-horrible educator currently suffering through inane mandatory annual 'trainings.'" www.betonit.ai/p/dont-pickpocket-your-students
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"But @catehall's obviously high IQ, she chose 3 years of self-destruction, and though she’s an outlier, she’s not that extreme of an outlier. The main segment of the population I’d really trust with maximum agency is just people very low in Neuroticism."
www.betonit.ai/p/high-agency-is-high-variance -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Hall repeatedly talks about the lame excuses people make for failing to do good things. I submit she should apply exactly the same skepticism to excuses people make for doing bad things. 'I’m a prisoner in my own life is wrong for lawyers who don’t like their job — and it’s wrong for drug abusers." www.betonit.ai/p/high-agency-is-high-variance
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Educational austerity now.
Robert P. Murphy
@BobMurphyEcon
When I taught undergrad, I concluded: Half of these kids shouldn't be here. It would be better for them, and the ones who stay, if they had gotten jobs after high school.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The truth-in-advertising slogan of immigration restrictionists is "Misanthropy first."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It's bizarre to see people with deep antipathy for most of the native-born population opposing immigrants who "don't share our values."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Here's a meritocratic case for open borders from *Open Borders*.
Paul Graham
@paulg
I believe the most qualified person should get the job.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
C.H.U.D. is actually a pretty fun movie.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I wish!
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Saying this would have gotten you labeled a radical 200 years ago, a liberal 100 years ago, and a conservative today.
Paul Graham
@paulg
I believe the most qualified person should get the job.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
AMA today. www.betonit.ai/p/ama-today
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Why aren't there more books etc where bosses & teachers complain about how stupid, lazy, unreliable, etc. people under them are?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Seems there should be a market for a book where author patiently explains how to buy stuff cheaper, with sections on cars, phones, food, etc.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Epicurus remains unsurpassed in logic and brevity.
--
Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Many say that their biggest obstacle to believing in God is the "problem of evil", i.e., God allows stuff to happen that they see as morally wrong/bad. So they think they know better than God what is right/good. Their moral intuitions are more authoritative than God.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"All models are wrong, but some are useful" is as misleading as saying "The store is 1.0 miles away" is false because it's actually 1.0349509339 miles away.
Say "True to one decimal place" rather than "wrong." -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"All models are wrong, but some are useful" is the most pernicious of equivocations.
If you mean, "All models are TOTALLY wrong, but some are useful," that's crazy.
If you mean, "All models are less than 100% right, but some are useful," that's obvious, but so what? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Best one-sided video ever.
www.facebook.com/share/v/17xMsP2w9F/ -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Imagine what would happen to property values in a major city if its sole airport closed. Even though gainers rarely show up at land-use meetings, the externalities of airports for most people are positive." www.betonit.ai/p/the-externalities-of-airports-and
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Wise policy is based on overall effects on everyone, not just the highly visible effects on highly vocal people. This is true for airports, and it’s true for immigrants."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-externalities-of-airports-and -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Far from being a thoughtful Pigovian response to negative externalities, regulation that limits airport construction and expansion is an impulsive demagogic response to positive externalities. Laissez-faire would be far better than the status quo." www.betonit.ai/p/the-externalities-of-airports-and
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
*Class of 1999* is the most bonkers dystopian high school movie you've never heard of. I laughed almost nonstop. On Amazon Prime.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_of_1999 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Boost this bet.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Bill Gates says AI will destroy jobs.
Anyone want to bet on the unemployment rate with me?
I don’t think it will be abnormally high in the next ten years.
And I don’t think it depends on the state of AI. Job loss is just an economic fallacy. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I spent a half hour trying to put a wire into its right place on a bike, sent multiple pictures to ChatGPT and Claude, using the most sophisticated models, and eventually had to give up. They kept changing their mind about what was going on and Claude eventually said it didn’t believe it could do it.
Then I took it to Dick’s, and some fat bald neck beard who didn’t even respond to my attempts to make small talk fixed it in about a minute.
There will always be jobs for humans. Fearing job loss is the same Luddite drivel we’ve been hearing for hundreds of years. www.richardhanania.com/p/why-you-shouldnt-worry-about-ai-… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If all this sounds like wishful thinking, consider the polar case where housing deregulation drives the price of housing to zero. This wipes out the value of whatever housing you already own. But you can move to a palace anywhere on Earth for free."
www.betonit.ai/p/cds-vs-nimby -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Applying NIMBY logic, streaming 'hollowed me out.' kids now enjoy unlimited music free of charge. But I’m $40,000 poorer. A clear-cut 'loser.' If I had zero interest in listening to any new-to-me music, that would be a fair, if self-pitying, verdict." www.betonit.ai/p/cds-vs-nimby
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Exception: When I asked Chat about the probability that I'll be murdered by the clown of Inuit heritage, it explicitly did a Fermi calculation and reached a near-zero number.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I asked Claude to fact-check A Short History of the World by H.G. Wells. The error rate in this book was over 2x the error rate in Modern Times, even when only counting facts that were known at the time the book was published."
www.betonit.ai/p/krakowski-claude-and-modern-times -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Claude asked some clarifying questions and I told it to do a full sweep of the book and flag potential errors, and then go through the flagged errors afterwards to verify." www.betonit.ai/p/krakowski-claude-and-modern-times
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Whenever I asked Chat to estimate the probability of disasters, it always gives crazy high probabilities on the order of .1% to 1%.
When I ask if it accounted for base rates, it standardly confesses that it didn't, then divides that probability by a factor of 10-1000! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Because the total number of reasonable seeming people is so large?
Because they don't clearly film it despite the ubiquity of fantastic cameras?
Because individuals and small groups do almost all the sightings?
Because they claim to see what sci-fi fans yearn to believe in?
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I see so many reasonable seeming people telling me they saw dramatic things. We usually believe such people when they testify that they saw dramatic things like murder. Why not believe them about this stuff?
Americans for Safe Aerospace
@SafeAerospace
"Like an AirPod case from thousands of years in the future."
That is how former Army Intelligence Officer Caison Best describes the massive, white-porcelain craft with shifting geometric panels that he and his team witnessed over Cheyenne Mountain.
youtu.be/7qWwyAaV0nw -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Zach Weinersmith
@ZachWeiner
On behalf of all comic book artists who believe we don't get taken seriously, here's me and @bryan_caplan sandwiched between Nobels:
www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2019/12/07/our-books-of-… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The question isn't how America can have such a high GDP with poor outcomes.
It's how a country with so many pathologies can have such a high GDP.
America's accomplishments are particularly impressive given its population. www.richardhanania.com/p/gdp-haters-arent-making-serious-… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Most obviously, virtually no immigrant nationality has worse crime rates than native-born blacks. If that’s a terrible reason to denaturalize native-born blacks, why is it a good reason to refuse immigration from any nation?"
www.betonit.ai/p/libertarianism-against-cultural-conserva… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"It’s illegal to snort one line of cocaine, but legal to marry a convicted murderer? Almost no one wants to ban alcohol, which plausibly does more social harm than all other irresponsible behaviors combined." www.betonit.ai/p/libertarianism-against-cultural-conserva…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"This isn’t just wishful thinking. Despite all the nonsense that flourishes today, nonsense was much more prevalent and monolithic before the rise of freedom of speech and the press."
www.betonit.ai/p/libertarianism-against-cultural-conserva… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While immigration is almost always the wedge issue, once libertarians turn against immigration, they commonly move on to a bunch of other culturally conservative views. And once again, the more I listen to them, the more I wonder why they changed their minds. To move forward, I’m going to restate what I see as the standard libertarian case against cultural conservatism, and find out exactly where they demur." www.betonit.ai/p/libertarianism-against-cultural-conserva…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Dark Abundance is getting rid of laws and norms that discourage romantic relationships in the workplace because something might go wrong, the same attitude that holds us back in other areas of life. www.richardhanania.com/p/rich-and-successful-men-do-not-have
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"At the end of Frankenstein (1994), the monster (played by Robert De Niro) laments, 'I am done with man.' That line becomes a lot more optimistic once there is a viable alternative to man." www.betonit.ai/p/modern-times-the-ultimate-fact-check
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The only serious question is: What happens when you fact check the fact checker? I returned to ChatGPT with the following prompt: 'Fact-check this fact-checking.'"
www.betonit.ai/p/modern-times-the-ultimate-fact-check -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When I opened the file, it shook me to my core. Even more than this. ChatGPT found maybe a dozen demonstrable errors. Claude found hundreds. I don’t think I’ve ever had such an existential AI experience." www.betonit.ai/p/modern-times-the-ultimate-fact-check
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I didn't do it. @arikrak did.
Isegoria
@Isegoria
How did you feed the book to Claude?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
H. B.
@theaichbee
I need this for several hundred other books.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Lucius Felinus Augustus
@FelesCuriosa
Great! Now apply it to every speech, interview, or post all politicians make. Keep a running record and score.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
One of the most extraordinary uses of AI I've ever seen. claude.ai/code/artifact/3fa707bb-1766-452f-a038-eb5c8e637c3e
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Epiphany of the day:
My retweets DO = endorsement, unless I have a critical comment on a quote tweet.
I never just share outageous stuff, while assuming readers will share my outrage. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Sure, elite anti-immigrants appeal to research on international IQ, cultural ancestry, and Putnamian trust. But only a handful have ever triumphally gushed, 'We natives are so smart, our heritage so refined, our trust so deep.'" www.betonit.ai/p/whats-really-wrong-with-anti-immigrants
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
No noted white nationalist favors open borders for whites.
Misanthropy>>racism.
chatgpt.com/s/t_6a873e5e794c8191ae52002d8fbb464a -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What about all of the restrictionists who oppose high-skilled white immigration? Are they racist too?
Racism is a factor, but only a minor factor compared to sheer misanthropy.
Honestly, if restrictionists found undiluted joy in ANY human subset, I'd think better of them.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
A good definition of racist is being opposed to high-skilled immigration. It's maybe the policy issue where all the facts are most on one side.
Most people who like talking about race and IQ oppose Chinese and Indian engineers, so fail the test of being rational and decent people. www.richardhanania.com/p/do-people-not-understand-overlap… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
Really doesn't matter what you think of Cofnas or his work. A university hired him, then he published a piece about Jason Arday based on well-supported claims about his plagiarism and fabulism that needed to come out, and now Cofnas is being disciplined.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
UATX’s tuition: $0.00
@jason
@Jason
Unjustifiable
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yes, except I'll believe the disruption when I see it.
Charlie Bilello
@charliebilello
The irony (and why higher education is ripe for disruption):
"Free education is abundant, all over the Internet. It's the desire to learn that's scarce." - @naval -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I've long considered politicians fools for carefully planning wars while negligently failing to plan the peace.
Now we've got a leader whose so foolish he never gets to the normal stage of negligence. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged are, by the Russian philosophical tradition's standards, better. Characters' philosophies are more interesting, the plot pits them against each other more effectively, and the concluding epiphanies are more compelling." www.betonit.ai/p/ayn_rand_the_ruhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The plot of Atlas Shrugged is likewise more imaginative than anything Hugo cooked up. A world-wide strike of the men of the mind against the welfare state? I’ll take that over The Hunchback of Notre Dame any day."
www.betonit.ai/p/ayn_rand_the_ruhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The straw man charge can be levied against Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky. Neither created an unconflicted, virtuous atheist to pit against his saintly Christians. If you’re going to enjoy these novels, you have to say 'artistic license' and go with the flow." www.betonit.ai/p/ayn_rand_the_ruhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I doubt the social sciences were ever very trustworthy, except on topics too narrow to politicize.
The main change over the last three decades is academics abandoning the *demeanor* of trustworthiness. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
All prices are dynamic—“surge pricing” is just speeding things up.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Shouldn’t he get massive credit relative to mainstream historians for accurately describing mass murder and other widespread human rights violations of Communist, nationalist, anticolonial, and post colonial movements?" www.betonit.ai/p/assessing-modern-times
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Another labor-intensive topic where AI makes swift progress. www.betonit.ai/p/assessing-modern-times
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"In many social circles, there’s a conditional norm that if you become a parent at all, then you had better be the most dedicated, perfect parent the world has ever seen. This norm is implicitly anti-natalist." desertphilosophy.substack.com/p/is-left-liberalism-vampiric
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
More Births
@MoreBirths
You have done incredible work drawing attention to the economic problem of low birthrates.
But there are some criticisms that should be taken seriously.
(1)
While the recent fertility declines are notable in poor countries, in terms of the absolute number of births, they are extremely low in rich countries compared to poor countries. Poor countries have massive population momentum.
Consider that there are more births every year in Pakistan alone, or Nigeria alone (~7 million each), than there are in all 44 European countries combined (~6 million). There are ten times as many annual births in Africa (40 million) as in all 26 EU countries combined (3.5 million) or the US (3.6 million).
Your native Spain (320,000 births annually) has just 5% as many births each year as those Nigeria or Pakistan countries and just around 1% as many births as in India (25 million births annually). It is the developed world that is in severe population decline.
When it comes to economic impacts, the massive economic destruction will come from the long-term fertility collapse of the rich world which is around 95% of global GDP, not from the recent drop of fertility in very poor countries, which are only a tiny share of global GDP.
(2) We DO know many of the causes. We are never going to find a single root cause. That is a quixotic goal.
Fertility, like human health doesn't have a single root cause. In health, there are different things like exercise, disease, genetics, age, and different organ systems. In fertility, there are different factors like partnering, housing, conditions of work-life balance, cultural and religious effects and more. These can all be separate causes and if you just say 'modernity' that is unhelpful because we can't fix modernity, but we can (for example) educate people that they have to start earlier. If a doctor insisted that there should be same answer to every health problem, he wouldn't be a very good doctor.
The factors with the largest effects on fertility include:
- Better and better birth control
- Falling partnering and marriage (with smartphones heavily involved)
- Long educations and greedy careers that consume women's (and men's) fertile years
- Falling religiosity (marriage and pronatal belief are central in Abrahamic faiths)
- Antinatal ideologies (witness the complete fertility collapse of the left)
- Extreme urbanization (witness the ultra-low fertility of the densest urban cores)
Few want to get rid of birth control, but the other things can be improved.
My review of your paper is here:
More Births
@MoreBirths
WHAT JFV GETS RIGHT AND WRONG ABOUT FERTILITY AND THE ECONOMY
University of Pennsylvania star economist Jesus Fernandez-Villaverde has (with Patrick Norrick) a big new paper out, "Terra Incognita: The Economics of a Shrinking World."
It is a major effort and JFV continues to do heroic work calling attention to fertility collapse and how it will devastate the future economy if not reversed. Output in an economy moves mechanically with population and if population is shrinking, it is very difficult to achieve any growth. On top of this, innovation itself gets much harder with fewer innovators, and making productivity growth harder to achieve as well.
He emphasizes the political problem of aging: seniors become politically dominant and lay claim to an ever-larger share of tax dollars, squeezing the young and hurting growth.
JFV also notes that today's fertility collapse is unlike anything we have seen in modern history. He critiques Acemoglu et al. (2026) who downplays the crisis, noting that past episodes of low birthrates are nothing compared to what we are seeing today:
"The lowest birth rate in [Acemoglu et al.'s] 1950 cross-section belongs to Austria, with a TFR of 2.09, essentially replacement; even in their 1980 panel the floor is Germany at 1.56. A TFR of 1.56 leaves 40% of the initial population after a century; a TFR of 0.75 leaves 3.5%, a factor of eleven. Both count as “low fertility” in a regression, yet they are different regimes."
As JFV explains what we are facing today is not the slightly-below-replacement fertility of the past, but population collapse in many countries. Obviously, that will be economically devastating.
But the paper gets two things very wrong:
(1) JVF says the fall in fertility is mainly in poor and middle-income countries. That obscures the reality that the lowest fertility rates, and especially the lowest *crude* birth rates, are in rich countries. Most rich countries are in demographic collapse. Many poor countries are still growing rapidly.
JFV writes, "But the real surprise is that the fall has been concentrated in low- and middle-income countries and among poorer and less educated women." That wording inverts the crisis we face.
Consider that there are more births in Pakistan alone, or Nigeria alone (~7 million each), than there are in all 44 European countries combined (~6 million). There are ten times as many annual births in Africa (40 million) as in all 26 EU countries combined (3.5 million) or the US (3.6 million).
While it's true that some poorer countries have seen steep fertility drops, most still have a lot of population momentum, a youngish age profile, and a large number of actual births. Meanwhile, most developed countries have extremely few actual births, due to a combination of very low fertility and few women of childbearing age. JFV focuses primarily on fertility rates while ignoring actual differences in numbers of births (which take into account age structure and population momentum).
Actual birth numbers have great bearing on the future economy: The developed world, which accounts for almost all of global GDP, is facing steep population collapse while extremely poor and low-human-capital countries like Pakistan and Nigeria that cannot substitute for Germany or Japan are growing very rapidly.
The fact that population collapse is concentrated in high-GDP countries is central to understanding economic effects of low birthrates. Because of that, the economic hit will be especially severe.
(2) JFV says we don't know the causes of fertility decline. But mostly we do know the causes.
The factors with the largest effects on fertility include:
- Better and better birth control
- Falling partnering and marriage (with smartphones heavily involved)
- Long educations and greedy careers that consume women's (and men's) fertile years
- Falling religiosity (marriage and pronatal belief are central in Abrahamic faiths)
- Antinatal ideologies (witness the complete fertility collapse of the left)
- Extreme urbanization (witness the ultra-low fertility of the densest urban cores)
Few want to get rid of birth control, but the other things we can work on.
JFV's statement, "Unfortunately, we do not understand the mechanisms behind this fast drop in fertility, or its concentration among lower- and middle-income countries and among the poorest and least educated women within them" gets both parts wrong.
Low numbers of births (the most real measure) are not concentrated in poor countries, but in rich ones and we have good answers for why. There are hundreds of papers, representing the work of countless demographers, that have explored fertility rates and their causes. That knowledge is surely the foundation for effective policy and culture solutions.
In JFV's quest for a single universal cause of low birthrates, he settles on "modernity," which is true in a sense but not very helpful. Why should we seek or expect a singular cause? (To use the example of health, there are many different inputs -- nutrition, exercise, disease, aging, genetics, rest and more -- along with multiple organs and systems. Modern medicine would never work if doctors tried to lump all health problems into one category. Fertility is similar.)
A lot of leading thinkers on fertility emphasize that it is multicausal. The list includes Lyman Stone and his colleagues at the Institute for Family Studies broadly, economist Melissa Kearney, leading British demographer Paul Morland, the top demographer on China Yi Fuxian, economist/futurist Robin Hanson, boom campaign head Phoebe Arslanagić-Little, leading demographers Tomas Sobotka and Anna Rotkirch, data-analyst John Burn-Murdoch and many others. If we can accept that, fertility makes a lot more sense and we can get to work on solutions.
To give JFV credit where due, he is the economist most responsible for calling attention to demographic collapse as the great economic crisis of our age. In that he does incredibly important work. If birthrates don't turn around, we face calamity (economic and otherwise).
- Daniel Hess -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"people holding a partisan view on a sociopolitical issue perceive moderates (i.e., people disclosing a genuinely nonextreme position) as belonging to the out-group ideology … due to partisans’ perception that moderates lack out-group hate." psycnet.apa.org/record/2027-99633-001
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Proposal for language reform. From now on...
"Poor" = 0-10th percentiles of global income distribution
"Lower-middle" = 11-30th percentiles of global income distribution
"Middle" = 31-70th percentiles of global income distribution
"Upper-middle" = 71-90th percentiles of global income distribution
"Rich" = >90th percentile of percentile of global income distribution -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Here's mine.
What a world we live in!
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
"Create a random imagine inspired by my X account"
Thank you @grok, this is perfect. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Really, if you worry about innocent people getting convicted of crimes, you should want to embrace technologies like Flock.
Surveillance can eliminate false convictions.
People against these cameras do not think realistically about trade offs. www.richardhanania.com/p/flock-mass-surveillance-and-the-… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
"Create a random imagine inspired by my X account"
Thank you @grok, this is perfect. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Top complaints about Rand's novels apply just as well to Tolstoy's and Dostoevsky's.
She's a straight-up Russian philosophical novelist.
Their characters embody philosophical viewpoints, and the climax hits you over the head with the one true view.
Clunky? No, classic!
Miguel Arratia
@MiguelArratia
Ayn Rand is timeless because she described eternal truths about human nature and the foundations of society, such as:
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"It was the best of times, it was the worst of times."
Today's contrast between students at top schools who barely know algebra and self-taught teen AI masters is both bizarre and astounding. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While taxes are highly progressive, transfers have an upside-down U-shape. Households in the middle quintile get the most money. The richest households actually get more money than the poorest." www.betonit.ai/p/the_inanity_ofhtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Had a great conversation with the elegant and charming Louise Perry. You can listen here. www.louiseperry.co.uk/p/does-populism-end-in-disaster-maiden
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Defund education.
Seriously, that is the central policy recommendation of my *The Case Against Education*.
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
My view is that the focus on individual frauds is frustrating when there are entire fields of the social sciences that are functionally fake, don’t replicate, have no realistic prospect of shaping up, and yet continue to hoover up resources undeterred like zombie enterprises.
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
Virtually nobody seems to care enough about the intellectual enterprise to say that fabrication, fraud, and plagiarism harm it to a degree that justifies punishment. That it is good to have standards for thinking and writing, and that enforcing those standards is good, not evil.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Which is worse: adultery or treason?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When organizations that kill people for a living – like crime families or governments – loudly help the needy, we should indeed shudder. Why? Because their perceived philanthropy makes it easy for them to get away with murder."
www.betonit.ai/p/how_the_welfare_1html -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Libertarians often argue that welfare states, like Pablo Escobar, are not really 'charitable.' Whether or not they’re right, the fact remains: Welfare states seem charitable to almost everyone." www.betonit.ai/p/how_the_welfare_1html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Which is worse: adultery or treason?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Play games with the one and only Steve Kuhn at Carow Hall tomorrow! caplacon.substack.com/p/kuhntastic-friday
Capla-Con Sat and Sun!
caplacon.substack.com/p/youre-invited-to-capla-con-2026 -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
A reminder that skeptics of the accuracy of prediction markets should be their most active users—after all, they should expect to make a lot of money exploiting their alleged inaccuracy.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Prediction markets are not predictive and should not be covered as news
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
This is nuts.
The whole thing about a housing crisis is that you don't have enough houses for all the people doing the jobs. I joke sometimes that people who cheer job growth but boo housing additions apparently assume that people who work prefer to not sleep in houses.
Expediting the jobs part of California Forever while cutting out the housing part is like turning my bad joke into policy.
Brian Hanlon
@hanlonbt
Hearing the Legislature might expedite the California Forever shipyard and manufacturing park, but NOT the housing.
That would be disastrous for California.
Are we in a housing crisis or not?! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I often greet friends with "What good is happening?" instead of "What's up?"
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
In my utopia, no one complains.
In fact, being around relentlessly positive people is utopia.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Of course it wouldn't be utopia if we couldn't complain about it, as complaining is one of the things we most like to do.
UBERSOY
@UBERSOY1
Teleport someone from 200 years ago into our world and they'd think they'd died and gone to heaven. We live in a literal utopia and complain about it daily.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Shouldn't each of these folks have a named holiday? Maybe on their birthdays?
www.sciencefocus.com/the-human-body/5-people-saved-most-h… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The biggest friends of the welfare state would rather see the welfare state disappear than publicly say 'Please' or 'Thank you' to the taxpayers who make their favorite programs possible."
www.betonit.ai/p/imagine_gratefuhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Imagine the following scenario: Recipients of food stamps, unemployment insurance, Medicaid, and student loans suddenly start expressing daily heartfelt gratitude to the taxpayers who provide for them." www.betonit.ai/p/imagine_gratefuhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Overstated, but you can't sensibly favor big expansions of both.
Adam Wren
@aswren
You can be pro-immigration or pro-welfare state, but you can’t be both
Paul Graham
@paulg
You can be pro-meritocracy or anti-immigration, but you can't be both.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yep.
Paul Graham
@paulg
You can be pro-meritocracy or anti-immigration, but you can't be both.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Brave.
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
I don’t see how there could possibly be any confusion over this, no university should employ someone who produces work this bad.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Just ask: "If you had to be either imprisoned for X years or deported to Haiti for life, what value of X leaves you indifferent?"
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
you people don't get how bad deportations are! it's exile! it's uprooting from your family and friends and job! every single one of them is a crime!
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Brad Carson
@bradrcarson
And finally, to @tylercowen , we should have a fun Paul Ehrlich/Julian Simon wager on this! I'm not emotionally invested in my estimate, but it'd be a fun thing to track.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"In Mexico, 'essentially all of the weakest-performing schools – those more than 100 points [2 standard deviations] below the average – are government schools.'" www.betonit.ai/p/pritchett_on_prhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yes, Europe does have better bread and pastries, though as usual for groceries, Scandinavia is subpar.
Cheap, too.
Wegmans' bakery was competitive in quality though not price until 2021.
Market failure?
No, just the poor taste of the American consumer.
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
The croissants in Europe--even at an airport coffee shop--are better than any I can get in the US.
GDP is fake. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I say that virtually all digital minds will be treated like food.
People who would never abandon an old pet for a new pet will readily swap an old AI girlfriend for a new AI girlfriend.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Many are bothered to see similarities between animals we use as pets vs. food. Digital minds used as tools vs. companions will be less bothersome, as makers will distinguish them more clearly.
www.overcomingbias.com/p/tool-vs-companion-digital-minds -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Updating Woody Allen:
I don't want to achieve immortality through a perfect simulation; I want to achieve immortality through not dying. I don't want to live on in cyberspace; I want to live on in my house. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If an AI can pass the Turing Test for you with the people who know you best, are you already immortal?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Why won’t they listen? Because in the real world, most business ideas that lose money for the first couple of years are going to lose money forever. Learning by doing will not save them." www.betonit.ai/p/mises-contra-kealey
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I've seen no convincing evidence that significant life extension is on the horizon.
But I absolutely hope I am totally wrong!
P.S. If my biological body doesn't continue, I'm not really alive. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I once asked an AI skeptic, "What if AI cures aging? How long should we be willing to delay that to ensure 'AI safety'"?
He told me death wasn't such a big deal anyway.
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
"While a computer designs a drug for the disease that will one day come for you, your politicians design a ban on the building it runs in."
Data centers are life.
The Rational Animal 🤔
@theobjectivist
While a computer designs a drug for the disease that will one day come for you, your politicians design a ban on the building it runs in.
While 200 AI-discovered medicines sit in human trials, one already restoring lung function in patients given five years to live, the same politicians hold hearings on seizing the wealth that paid for the trials.
While AI writes software that cuts years off engineering, which means cheaper power, cheaper food, and better medicine inside this decade, they push moratoriums on data centers and call the buildings a blight.
While the labs quietly add years to your life, the politicians at their podiums insist they are the ones protecting it.
One column produces cures. The other produces claims on the men who do, in the name of your wellbeing, at the cost of your remaining years. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Everyone should like Alex.
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
AI has gotten so good, we really need to be thanking people like @sama and @DarioAmodei daily. (While also opposing any bad ideas they have.)
My latest reminder of this: using Chat to explore (for a book I'm writing) the under-discussed ways AI can protect more people's rights. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Just made this one-page primer for comics newbies.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The bet was about whether whatever new evidence came out over the ensuing 2 years would shift polls of superforecasters to favor lab leak. I won $250K."
Wow, @slatestarcodex finds off-the-charts high-quality betting partners.
I struggle to get $1 bets.
www.astralcodexten.com/p/open-thread-446 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Remember that activism is a luxury if you know what you’re talking about – and a pestilence if you don’t." www.betonit.ai/p/im_too_busy_endhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When critics of immigration urge desperately poor people to stay home and fix their political systems, they’re doubly obtuse. Not only are they urging people to neglect their basic responsibilities in favor of the luxury of political activism. They’re urging people who know virtually nothing about policy or politics to 'get involved' – and quite possibly make their countries even worse." www.betonit.ai/p/im_too_busy_endhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Asking people to stay home and "fix their countries" is absurd on multiple levels.
www.betonit.ai/p/im_too_busy_endhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Anyone who interprets *Open Borders* as a socialist tract really has reading comprehension problems.
Migration restrictions are classic socialism. Though given socialist economic performance, they usually focus on persecuting emigration rather than immigration. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
As an undergrad, I already held non-STEM academia in low regard.
Why?
Because I took high-IQ professors who thoroughly knew their subjects and expected students to demonstrate actual knowledge for granted.
Sorry, non-STEM academia of 1989-93. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Labor exploitation"?
Sounds more like the collateral damage of labor market regulation that purports to mitigate "labor exploitation."
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
This is a story about a college lost down the rabbit hole of performative progressivism. But at its heart, it’s about labor exploitation, the hell we put contingent profs through, and how the collapse of the tenure-system paved the way for cowardice and pseudo-radical groupthink.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
.@Tyler_A_Harper landed his dream job, a tenure-track position at an elite liberal-arts college—but he found himself “being treated like a racial prop rather than a professor.” Read more in our newest cover story: theatln.tc/uAlYLOai
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If I find one Canadian grandma denied a hip replacement, or someone who can’t get a doctor to take her as a medicare patient, why do I not get to conclude that everyone must be left to the market?" www.betonit.ai/p/highlights_from_3html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm happy to buy your son and all his socialist friends lunch anytime. Seriously, as always.
Squirrel Huntress
@arightist
Your stupid immigration book helped set my son down the path to DSA membership.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
No one has ever gotten mad at me in real life for telling them to stop getting upset about the news.
I'm just trying to help them feel better about life - and I'm clearly right.
Joshua B
@aJoshuaB
and here i thought people just didn’t like you cus of the immigration thing
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Is the news story that's upsetting you today even as bad as a single murder?
Do you have a meltdown every time you hear about one murder?
Then why are you so upset about today's news story? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The distinction between democratic socialism and totalitarian communism is vast and anyone who compares them is a fool or a liar."
Also:
The top "democratic socialist" organization in the US welcomes totalitarian communists at its highest level of leadership. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ramez Naam
@ramez
The notion that "The Singularity" is ahead of us is truly bizarre and a massive dilution of the term.
"The Singularity" is an event horizon we cannot look past. We have plenty of ways to model the behavior of super-intelligent entities (though most such efforts are quite shallow and overly anthropocentric). Our pre-human ancestors, however, couldn't model us.
The Singularity happened hundreds of thousands of years ago. Several thousand at a minimum. You're living in it. Enjoy! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Actually Springfield is affordable because it uses safe and cheap nuclear power.
🇺🇸 The American Culturist 🇺🇸
@MericaCulture
The Simpsons debuted in 1987 and this is the type of house the shows creators thought a single-income family could afford.
According to an episode in Season 1, Homer made 25k a year(60k in 2026 dollars).
In 1987 that house would cost about 100k(which was the national average) with a mortgage of roughly $700/month(assuming 20% down and interest rates consistent with that time)
How about today? The same house would cost 450k with a mortgage of roughly $2,500/month.
This means that while Homer was spending ~30% of his income on his mortgage in 1987 he would need to spend closer to 50% of his income on his mortgage today.
And of course, this doesn't include other areas of inflation such as food, gas or etc. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"'Raising the minimum wage makes the poor richer, end of story' and 'Stricter drug safety regulation makes everyone healthier, end of story' weren’t straw men. They were the only men in sight." www.betonit.ai/p/the_straw_man_shtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
M. Nolan Gray 🥑
@mnolangray
Euclid v. Ambler cut local jurisdictions a blank check to use zoning however they like, such that the typical American city is now a sort of command-and-control centrally planned economy optimized around government-backed class-based apartheid. Overturn it.
YIMBYLAND
@YIMBYLAND
Overturning Euclid v. Ambler is obviously the correct answer here.
Euclid v. Amber is the Supreme Court decision that constitutionalized modern comprehensive and exclusionary zoning.
Light it on fire. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
To be fair, a sizable minority of UK college grads are probably functionally illiterate, too.
The dumbing down of higher ed is a global ill.
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
New from me:
Young people in Britain are some of the most well-educated in the rich world, but economic stagnation means that breeds not growth but frustration.
In fact, US workers who are functionally illiterate now earn roughly the same per hour as the average British worker. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Why not be the change you want to see in the world? You can live a socialist lifestyle and promote broad social change at the same time. The key difference is simply that you don’t have to convince the world to build your socialist Bubble. So why wait?"
www.betonit.ai/p/how-you-can-find-socialism-in-a-capitali… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If capitalism made my flesh crawl and I knew socialism wasn’t coming anytime soon, how would I cope? What is the best way for a can-do socialist to find socialism in a capitalist world?" www.betonit.ai/p/how-you-can-find-socialism-in-a-capitali…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I met Victor Niederhoffer several times and spoke once for his Junto meet-up. A great guy. www.opalesque.com/715778/Victor_Niederhoffer_pioneer_of_s…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
People are almost always correct to doubt the "good faith" of their political opponents.
Their big mistake is to imagine that their allies have good faith.
And their deepest mistake is to imagine that they personally have good faith. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
The good news for moderates is that there is an idea on the table that is a dramatic departure from the status quo but also would solve the #1 economic problem facing young people a thousand times better than socialism.
But you need to seize the chance.
www.slowboring.com/p/to-save-capitalism-we-need-radical -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Another big failure of Game of Thrones:
Bran and Arya started out as lively and relatable characters. By Season 8, both of them were robots.
"Human to robot" is a dull character arc, and you certainly don't need to have two such arcs. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Though I'm writing a book-length defense of free trade, I deeply doubt recent surveys showing high public support for "free trade."
It's not just an anti-Trump effect, it's a long-standing question-wording effect. (1/3)
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Asking "Are you for or against free trade" is like asking "Are you for or against abortion?"
It's better to ask:
"Are you for free trade or fair trade?" which is a lot like "Are you pro-choice or pro-life?"
(2/3)
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Alternately, ask questions that probe the depth of commitment. "Are you for or against free trade?" is much less informative than:
"Do you support free trade even if some Americans lose their jobs?"
or
"Do you support free trade even if some U.S. industries disappear?"
(3/3) -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Almost everyone favors restricting immigration, so I think most immigration restrictionists are conformist rather than bad.
But people who are *passionate* about immigration restriction are usually quite bad.
It's not racism so much as sheer misanthropy.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I don't know if all immigration restrictionists are bad people, but it's certainly the case for those who complain about skilled migration like H1B visas.
This is because there are no arguments for their position other than racism.
Well, socialism gets you there too, hence Sanders also being skeptical of immigration.
But those who aren't socialists and become selective socialists in this situation are just full of hate. www.richardhanania.com/p/high-skill-immigration-as-the-ul… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Sorry, Nolan's only truly great movies are *Memento* and *Following*. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Nolan_filmography
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Kubrick 7/7.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Imagine someone tells you, 'I stopped being a libertarian because I realized the sky is blue.' Your reaction shouldn’t be, 'Wow, libertarians are a bunch of fools.' Your reaction should be, 'The speaker is a fool.'" www.betonit.ai/p/i-stopped-being-a-libertarian-because
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"To admit that you’ve spent years mired in elementary errors is to admit that the world is right to spend years ignoring you. Instead of trying to regain the limelight, accept that you need to rebuild your intellectual credibility brick by boring brick."
www.betonit.ai/p/i-stopped-being-a-libertarian-because -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Yes, culture does matter, and it’s better to concede this fact than deny it. However, the fact that a person until recently denied this obvious truth remains deeply damning." www.betonit.ai/p/i-stopped-being-a-libertarian-because
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
You personally know more anti-immigration people than I do, so I'm not surprised you've found a few exceptions.
But I've met plenty!
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I don’t know about 100%, but there’s definitely a strong correlation between being unpleasant and centering your identity on excluding people because of how they look or where they’re from.
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Literally 100% of anti-immigration people I personally know are unpleasant to be around.
Avoiding the topic doesn't work, because they keep bringing it up.
0% of the immigrants I personally know are unpleasant to be around.
Exception: Anti-immigration immigrants. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Being anti-immigration is a license to broadcast your high Neuroticism to the world.
But rest assured, you will still be angry, anxious, depressed, and generally paranoid even in your utopian ethnic-state. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Literally 100% of anti-immigration people I personally know are unpleasant to be around.
Avoiding the topic doesn't work, because they keep bringing it up.
0% of the immigrants I personally know are unpleasant to be around.
Exception: Anti-immigration immigrants. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The case for "Ward Paternalism."
www.betonit.ai/p/nudge-welfare-state-edition -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"'Leave me alone, I don’t want your help' has great force. 'Help me, but don’t presume to tell me how to live my life' has little." www.betonit.ai/p/nudge-welfare-state-edition
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Notice that there are already over ten million construction workers in America. That’s only modestly below the nation’s total manufacturing employment!"
www.betonit.ai/p/revive-construction-not-factories -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"We don't want to sell critical technologies to other countries because they'll steal our ideas."
Also:
"We don't want to buy critical technologies from other countries because we'll become dependent on them." -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I trust first-hand visits to a random sample of grocery stores over GDP per capita.
And I love GDP per capita.
Pontus Rendahl
@pontus_rendahl
Grocery stores is a very poor metric here, as both Denmark and Norway are known for their DDR-style supermarkets. Sweden is much better in that regard, but not wealthier because of it
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I have to wonder how many people around the world would express equally demented arguments if their group engaged in equally barbarous behavior." www.betonit.ai/p/group-serving_bhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
And unlike almost all other apostates, Richard carefully explains why he changed his mind. www.richardhanania.com/p/diversity-really-is-our-strength
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“Mass migration is worse in the long run than communism” is actually something I believed ten years ago, and I’ve now realized that it’s crazy even as it’s become a much more mainstream position on the right.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The first thing "Communism" makes me think about is famines caused by agricultural collectization.
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
This empirical claim by Helen Andrews is entirely false:
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Also, if you actually tour around Denmark or Norway, you see first-hand that their living standards are very low by U.S. standards.
Go to their grocery stores and see for yourself.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Another critique one should make here is that even using “GDP per hours worked,” which is not the right measure, the only European countries clearly better than the US are Denmark and Norway, and one of them is sitting on a sea of oil wealth.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"A man like Mengele, who repeatedly tortured and murdered innocents, is beyond redemption. Any upside of his atrocities should be (a) mentioned only after enumerating his monstrous crimes, and (b) framed ironically."
www.betonit.ai/p/what_if_mengelehtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Suppose, contrary to fact, that Mengele’s experiments led straight to a cure for cancer. How should his obituary be revised?" www.betonit.ai/p/what_if_mengelehtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Preston Cooper
@PrestonCooper93
I sometimes hear the argument that the salaries of lower-paid majors converge with higher-paid ones as careers progress. That's definitely not true.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Here's a fun one:
Majors, stratified by highest and lowest lifetime earnings!
There's one major that tends to earn less than people who don't earn any college degree. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Pick one day during which you will be awake and interacting with other people. For that entire day, say no to every optional request that you do not genuinely want to do." www.betonit.ai/p/the-ambition-project
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Ask three people for something you genuinely want from them and which genuinely matters to you, but which they are reasonably (but not certainly) likely to refuse."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-ambition-project -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I doubt that the average U.S. college student would actually follow through with any of these challenges, but they’d be great for a school like @uaustinorg!" www.betonit.ai/p/the-ambition-project
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alex Viladot
@AlexViladot
Königsbergs kluger Kant konzipierte kategorische, kritische, konsequente, kosmopolitische Kernkonzepte, klärte Kausalität, kategorisierte Kategorien, kritisierte kirchliche Konventionen, kennzeichnete Kenntnisgrenzen, kultivierte Kritik, kräftigte Königsbergs Kultur.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I routinely claim that economics is "the highest-paid of all the easy majors."
But this is the only time I've seen it come out as the highest-paid major overall.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Here's a fun one:
Majors, stratified by highest and lowest lifetime earnings!
There's one major that tends to earn less than people who don't earn any college degree. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Kant kann klar schreiben.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
In May 1781, Kant published Critique of Pure Reason. On p. 824 he explained the virtue of bets:
"The usual touchstone, whether that which someone asserts is merely his persuasion — or at least his subjective conviction, that is, his firm belief — is betting. It often happens that someone propounds his views with such positive and uncompromising assurance that he seems to have entirely set aside all thought of possible error. A bet disconcerts him. Sometimes it turns out that he has a conviction which can be estimated at a ducat, but not at ten. For he is very willing to venture one ducat, but when it is a question of ten he becomes aware, as he had not previously been, that it may very well be that he is in error." -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
In 1872, Jules Verne published Around the World in Eighty Days, wherein Phileas Fogg says (on Oct. 2, 1872):
"A true Englishman doesn't joke when he is talking about so serious a thing as a wager. I will bet 20,000 pounds against anyone who wishes that I will make the tour of the world in 80 days or less".
Narrator says: "Everybody knows that England is the world of betting men, who are of a higher class than mere gamblers; to bet is in the English temperament. Not only the members of the Reform, but the general public, made heavy wagers for or against Phileas Fogg." -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Anti-GDP arguments are fundamentally unserious.
Economic policies are supposed to make countries wealthier.
America has done a better job of that than Europe or East Asia.
If the opposite were true, economic statists would be celebrating the fact.
But they can’t, so they change the subject.
As it turns out, American flaws have nothing to do with us having a higher GDP.
There’s no reason to listen to people who would make us poorer without any plausible benefit. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"This was a very fun, unconventional podcast." www.betonit.ai/p/if-im-really-honest
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
True if the point of writing is to entertain readers.
False if the point of writing is to improve policy.
If a bad policy is on the ropes, it makes sense to finish the job while it's vulnerable.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
This is an article published on August 3, 2026.
People get attached to a thesis and they want to keep talking about it forever, regardless of whether circumstances change.
Yes, in 2010, “we had affirmative action but it’s becoming unworkable because of mass migration” was a novel and interesting point. Even in 2022, it was still an open question what would happen.
It’s now 2026 and we have the most anti-affirmative action administration in history, and even Dems are trying to avoid the issue and focus on other things. The right is completely united on this issue and has been taking action. This is true in the courts and at the state and federal levels.
People should focus on new things when the circumstances change. Otherwise people who once had something to say become no longer interesting. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Is the news story that's upsetting you today even as bad as a single murder?
Do you have a meltdown every time you hear about one murder?
Then why are you so upset about today's news story? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Of course. www.betonit.ai/p/where_would_youhtml
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Obviously open borders are the best way to reduce violence against women!
If people from misogynistic cultures come into the West, even if 50% assimilate, there will still be a lot less violence against women in the world.
The vast majority will at least semi-assimilate. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robert Winslow
@RMWinslow
Monty Hall will always have a goat to show you.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
"Conservatives are not reading books on how we need to scale back land use regulations. They’re not reading much of anything, yet somehow continue to do the right thing."
On the weirdness of Texas continuing to out-abundance the abundance movement.
richardhanania.com/p/despite-abundance-texas-continues -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bohumilo
@bohumilo
GNI IS part of HDI. They just add to it life expectancy and years of schooling. Why HDI is a poor metric here 👇
x.com/bohumilo/status/2004918998505263288
Also, @bryan_caplan on HDI: "...a country of immortals with infinite per-capita GDP would get a score of .666 (lower than South Africa and Tajikistan) if its population never went to school"
x.com/bohumilo/status/2052248278083715466
Bohumilo
@bohumilo
No — actually, it does. Our best economic models tell us that people aim to maximize consumption over their lifetime. Healthcare is part of consumption. Americans spend a lot on it BECAUSE they are richer, not because they have to. Spending a large share of income on healthcare is a luxury, not a necessity — that’s what rich people tend to do. 👇
randomcriticalanalysis.com/why-conventional-wisdom-on-hea…
And no, HDI is a poor metric here. It’s life expectancy + years of schooling + income (GNI). It’s useful for comparing rich and poor countries, but it becomes saturated at high income levels, its marginal explanatory power there is ≈ zero.
It penalizes the US for lower life expectancy (which largely disappears once you normalize for lifestyles and personal choices) and for inequality TWICE (through income and health). It assumes a social-democratic utility function: that people care linearly about longevity, value equality over variance, and that income beyond comfort has sharply diminishing value. It ignores optionality, revealed preferences (where people actually choose to live when they have the chance), variance tolerance, upside, etc... -
Bryan Caplan reposted
James Miller
@JimDMiller
I'm an academic on the autism spectrum, so don't you dare say this was plagiarized. I want a chaired professorship at either Oxford or Cambridge based on the quality of this work.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Safetyism makes me feel unsafe.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
What if Arday’s critics also have autism and don’t like to see a liar and plagiarist be a respected academic? Maybe you are putting them at risk of self-harm.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Atlas Shrugged QOTD:
"Well? Well?" Dr. Ferris was asking impatiently, with the crackling energy of a man who feels at home in a world of hysteria. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
For any scandalous story that upsets you, ask: How many such stories should we expect in a well-functioning country with 340M people?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"All Hobbits share a love of things that grow," so Hobbits must love free-market economies.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
All signs point to yes: "I can’t picture LLMs doing away with the importance of intelligence. Seems like smarter people are going to make much better use of new technology."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
😛
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
Comments on the trial of the Gang of Four
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
That was his initial error.
His commentary since then has been compounded with subsequent errors to try to salvage the initial one, leading him to simply badly misdiagnose the war as it plays out. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
I generally oppose US interventions abroad and have opposed US involvement in Ukraine (although I recognize that Putin was clearly the aggressor, and I understand why other countries in the region have different interests in the conflict besides the US)
All that noted, Mearsheimer has been repeatedly and catastrophically wrong about almost all of his predictions about the war - and embarrassingly so. He's become the Paul Ehrlich of International Relations academics.
Nathan Livingstone (MilkBarTV)
@TheMilkBarTV
Tucker Carlson's favourite "political scientist", John Mearsheimer, and his ATROCIOUS predictions on the war in Ukraine:
Feb. 2022: "I don't think Russia is going to invade."
Sep. 2023: "The Ukrainians are doomed to lose."
Jan. 2024: "It's ridiculous to think Ukraine can hold the line in 2024."
Apr. 2025: "It's unimaginable Ukraine will hang on beyond 2025."
Jul. 2026: "The Russians are slowly moving forward."
The Jim Cramer of foreign policy predictions. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Probably the most novel aspect of this work is its fascinating history of the Sino-Soviet split, and of each side’s efforts to pin the 'fascist' label on the other." www.betonit.ai/p/the_faces_of_jahtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
I wonder how many of those who endorse prison abolition on the grounds that we should strive for a society that has no need for prisons would endorse “tax abolition” on the grounds that we should strive for a society that has no need for taxes because everyone voluntarily donates their fair share.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Delver of Secrets
@final_iteration
The "G" in AGI just means general.
As in, not "Narrow" AI. Linear regressions are narrow AI -- each model can only solve one kind of problem.
LLMs can tackle a nearly infinite set of problems. => It's General -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
With full "cultural compatibility," there's no need to fret about freedom of speech or thought or religion.
Once we're in fundamental agreement, what's the point of protecting dissenters?
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
One problem with the claim that freedom of movement should be restricted to preserve “cultural compatibility” is that freedom of speech, association, exchange, etc. can also disrupt prevailing cultural norms. But no libertarian defends restrictions on those freedoms.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Causal evidence over the last two decades is a bit more mixed, but I still will never retire." www.betonit.ai/p/another_reasonhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Verily.
Aella
@Aella_Girl
imagine if we treated adding a new law to the economy in the same way we treated adding a new medicine to the body. you'd have to demonstrate no harmful effects show up in controlled trials, people who pass laws with damaging side effects would be held liable, etc
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
As an economist, I say that this is further proof that intelligence alone does not a productive worker make.
Tiberius Punk
@tiberiuspunk
No. As an economist I think you are well-suited to appreciate that a general intelligence should be able to create surplus value autonomously in a market economy.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"AGI is only X years away"???
As far as I'm concerned, we've already had AGI for a couple of years. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Global control sufficient to control the pace of any tech so widespread in the world is quite dangerously powerful.
MTS
@MTSlive
SITUATION UPDATE: The letter has been published.
1,122 frontier AI lab employees have signed so far. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
bitbutter
@mormo_music
Honoured that @bryan_caplan considers my vid You Can Always Leave "One of the best philosophy videos I've ever seen" www.youtube.com/watch?v=fasTSY-dB-s
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Wherever I travel, people now ask me about the arguments of @captgouda24.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"In a truly Georgist game, unimproved rents would be enormous, and improvements would be priced at marginal cost. Would that be a fun game? I doubt it." www.betonit.ai/p/how_would_a_geohtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
20 years ago.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Here’s a true conversation between me and Tyler Cowen, filtered through several years of memory." www.betonit.ai/p/how_different_ahtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It would be hard to "match" the rock-bottom standards of higher ed's humanities and social science classes, but it's a big step in that direction.
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
@marcportermagee
Did college board lower its AP standards to match the lower standards at colleges and universities?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"My hatreds were always diversified, so I didn’t fall into the same trap."
Better yet, avoid being angry at all.
It's hard to learn anything when you're upset.
open.substack.com/pub/richardhanania/p/why-the-tech-right… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Wherever I travel, people now ask me about the arguments of @captgouda24.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Christopher Snowdon
@cjsnowdon
Interesting discussion between two of my favourite economists 👍
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Niemietz pushes back against my thesis more than Lawson or Magness, so if you enjoy a serious argument, don’t miss our exchange." www.betonit.ai/p/how-socialist-were-the-nazis-really
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Emigration is the dream of most ambitious people in any poor country. That's not a character flaw! In fact there's something wrong with your culture if the opposite is true.
Vishal Ganesan
@vjgtweets
Interesting, provocative piece from Samyak:
“In the period from the 1990s to the 2020s, this has been the primary method of ‘Escaping India.’ ‘Graduation’ from India through the medium of these specialized fields, moving to a developed country, and ‘settling abroad’ is as close as post-Partition India has come to having a notion of an ‘Indian Dream’. The act of Escaping India is at the top of the Indian pyramid of hierarchy of needs. It is the highest form of self-actualization that an Indian can achieve in his or her life.
The Indian Dream is to do well enough in India so that one can ‘Graduate’ from India.” -
Bryan Caplan reposted
memetic_sisyphus
@memeticsisyphus
It’s not coherent because that’s not how an unborn baby is viewed by even proabortion people in other circumstances. First the lack of consciousness and ability to feel pain are not scientifically supported. Second and more importantly the moral worth of the unborn in their world view is wholly up to the mother. If she wants a child then it is a person. If she loses the baby she will mourn her loss. If she is murdered the law charges the murderer with two homicides. Speak to any pro-abortion expectant mother and they will not speak of their child in scientifically cold terms, but as their child about to be born. That same woman decides she doesn’t want to have the child, transforms the moral worth of that child into a lifeless sack of cells to be excised. It’s an internally incoherent worldview.
Glen Runciter
@LonesomeWest
How is it "divorced from any coherent ethical framework" to say that an entity with no conscious mind whatsoever is incapable of being harmed or having moral rights? That's an extremely plausible commitment that would make 99%+ of all abortions permissible.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What is the probability that WWI still would have happened if Germany had not annexed Alsace-Lorraine after the Franco-Prussian War?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I've never met a solid moderate Democrat remotely like today's AIs.
Near-zero emotion, zero hysteria, deeply decoupled.
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
AGI exists and it’s a solid moderate democrat
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I would rather be ruled by the median LLM than either the faculty of Harvard or the first two thousand names in the Boston phonebook.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Unfair to Ignatius, who is at least hilarious.
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
The American conservative movement has an extreme surplus of mediocre Straussian political theorists who are all convinced that they are the next Machiavelli even though they have the scholarly achievements of Ignatius J. Reilly.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
Congress can put an end to California's vehicle GHG standards using a law called the Congressional Review Act (CRA). It allows Congress to disapprove agency rules by issuing a "joint resolution" that is not subject to the ordinary 60-vote filibuster.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Logan Dobson
@LoganDobson
Love to use AI to make fake pictures of anti-AI protestors for my "grassroots" anti-AI group
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I would rather be ruled by the median LLM than either the faculty of Harvard or the first two thousand names in the Boston phonebook.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Forgot I wrote that.
lolbertking
@lolbertking
I just googled it, and apparently @bryan_caplan wrote a blogpost about this! www.econlib.org/archives/2012/10/how_would_a_geo.html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yes, there is strong evidence. Multiple papers show big earnings differences persist controlling for lots of confounds, including high school test scores.
There are also similar studies with quasi-randomization reaching the same conclusion. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is why the "Are they really conscious?" question is all-important.
If AIs aren't really conscious, it's silly to worry about their well-being.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"AI will acquire an independent moral status if … AI agents develop the will and power to bargain with humans for a share of resources. … A scenario in which AI develops self-driven goals and enough power to bargain for the resources needed to pursue them would most likely be a highly undesirable outcome."
By this logic, freeing any type of slave is an undesirable outcome.
Koenfucius 🔍
@koenfucius
When it concerns how we should (not) treat AI and robots, “modern moral philosophy is, strikingly, very much lost in misguided conceptual takes”, writes @page_eco, in a lucid post that tackles the question whether robots are slaves, or must be free:
www.optimallyirrational.com/p/should-robots-be-considered… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
(a) Parents should pay for whatever college major their kids choose to pursue
(b) Parents should only pay for college majors likely to lead to good career outcomes for their kids -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Awkward? Awkward?! 😛
Eric Silver
@ericsilvertech
I went to the @bryan_caplan meetup yesterday at a Korean barbecue place in Berkeley expecting it to be like a @cowenconvos listener meetup.
It was very different.
The crowd was more socially awkward, less interested in status, and more earnest about their curiosity.
Bryan is also really funny in person. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
John McDonnell
@johnvmcdonnell
"People who resist emphatic calls to neuroticism are happier, baffling neurotic academics"
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm amazed that self-awareness exists in academia at all!
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
The lack of self-awareness in academia is pretty amazing.
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Despite the fact..."
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Daniel Spenrath
@Daniel_Spenrath
I talk to professors and post docs regularly in College Station. It costs me nothing. They answer all the questions I ask them
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The ability to change others is overestimated.
The ability to change yourself is underestimated. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"But what if the murderer gives you a bribe you can’t refuse? For example, the murderer could loudly donate to your favorite charity. Are you then morally obliged to reciprocate by letting him get away with murder?" www.betonit.ai/p/the_bribes_of_chtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Despite the fact..."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Niemietz pushes back against my thesis more than Lawson or Magness, so if you enjoy a serious argument, don’t miss our exchange." www.betonit.ai/p/how-socialist-were-the-nazis-really
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
It is really underrated the degree to which progress studies has influenced policy.
Blake Scholl 🛫
@bscholl
BREAKING: The bipartisan act to legalize supersonic flight just passed Senate Commerce Committee *unanimously*. It was previously passed by the House, also *unanimously*.
Supersonic flight isn't red or blue—it's red, white, and blue! 🇺🇸 -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ryan Greenblatt
@RyanGreenblatt
It can be true that AIs are extraordinarily capable but aren't a great substitute for lots of humans. Like, I can't think of basically any well paid jobs where AIs are a great drop in replacement for humans!
Even if we froze capabilites, I think current AIs might greatly increase white collar productivity, but it would probably take a while to figure out / fully diffuse. While if AIs are a drop in replacement for the best human experts I expect it would go much faster.
But ~$2 trillion total AI company revenue EOY 2027 seems totally plausible to me (though higher than I currently expect). This does price in large capability improvements. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why is AI making such slow inroads even in Customer Support calls, where it seems superior to humans in almost every way? chatgpt.com/s/t_6a616546858c8191bdd145ee1be7a6ec
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
AIs already seem extraordinarily capable to me.
Not to you?
Ryan Greenblatt
@RyanGreenblatt
"it seems like existing AIs are already a great substitute for lots of humans"
I don't think this is true right now. (Apologies if the satirical dialogue implied I thought this, I was just try to talk about predictions about would happen when AIs are extremely capable.) -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Good question. But we've seen the US labor market absorb huge influxes of new workers many times, so the bottlenecks there look moderate compared to AI bottlenecks.
Paraśurām 🌱
@dab_chick
Why wouldn’t huge infusions of high skill immigrants hit similar bottlenecks?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
But based on your dialogue, it seems like existing AIs are already a great substitute for lots of humans, no?
Since employers are barely replacing humans, this suggests your dialogue misses some important advantage humans have.
Ryan Greenblatt
@RyanGreenblatt
Certainly agree it looks different so far, but AIs are also not that capable yet so the effective increase in the cognitive labor supply (taking into account human bottlenecks etc) isn't that big.
But if AIs surpass humans at ~everything while being very numerous and fast... -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Meritocracy at UC Berkeley is not entirely dead.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is a deep challenge, but so far AI has not worked at all like a huge infusion of high-skill immigrants.
Specifying why is the great puzzle, and "bottlenecks" is the place to start looking for a solution.
Ryan Greenblatt
@RyanGreenblatt
An economist and a futurist walk into a bar.
The economist takes a sip of his drink. "Ugh, if only people understood basic economics. High-skilled immigration alone would do wonders for US growth."
Futurist: "Oh yeah? Say 100 million immigrants moved to the US, each matching the best human experts in every economically relevant field. Big deal?"
Economist: "Massive. Transformative."
Futurist: "What if they also worked longer hours and faster than any American?"
Economist: "Even better."
Futurist: "What if they were extremely frugal — consuming only the bare minimum needed to keep working?"
Economist: "A near-100% savings rate? Better still!"
Futurist: "What if they were very clumsy and physically weak, so they could only do some kinds of work?"
Economist: "They could still do all cognitive labor — that's over half all wages! Somewhat less good, sure. Still transformative."
Futurist: "What if their skin was grey, almost metallic, from some kind of accident?"
Economist: "Who cares?!"
Futurist: "What if they were AIs?"
Economist: "3% growth per year, tops. There'd be bottlenecks. Honestly, the people predicting explosive growth from AI should learn some economics." -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is what "guardrails" look like in the real world.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Florida pastor suing ChatGPT for giving him poor medical advice.
Imagine every time you asked a chatbot for medical advice, it said "go to a doctor, it's serious."
If lawsuits like this succeed, the only way for AI companies to protect themselves is to always give the most hysterical advice possible. They would become useless.
The advocacy group filing the lawsuit has "asked the court to stop ChatGPT Health from operating until independent evaluators determine it is safe. The lawsuit also demands stronger guardrails to prevent ChatGPT from answering questions about medical treatments and diagnoses."
Interestingly, the service actually encouraged him to see a doctor at first. Then when he refused, it gave the pastor advice and told him what he wanted to hear. And now he's suing ChatGPT!
They're going to ruin the products for everyone to protect the stupidest people from themselves.
The trial lawyers and advocacy groups here are parasites. We cannot let them win. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Why you’re poor matters. Starving because you’re born blind is morally problematic. Starving because you drink yourself into a stupor every day is far less so. Indeed, you might call it just deserts." www.betonit.ai/p/libertarianism_4html
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I'm in a Free Press symposium on the rise of the DSA.
This didn't occur in a vacuum.
It's hard to defend capitalism when Trump is taking control of companies, and Vance is calling for seizing the means of production.
We need to defend capitalism on the right first. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
In red states, highly politicized academic departments will moderately shrink over the next decade.
In the rest of the country, it's business as usual for as far as the eye can see.
Seminaries survived for ages despite laughable dogmatism, and so will grievance studies. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Even if I'm wrong about everything else, I'm not wrong to urge Americans to go to Japan when the dollar is an historic high.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even at the pinnacle of America’s improbable peaceful geopolitical ascendancy, only a small minority of Americans felt deeply good about it."
www.betonit.ai/p/americas-national-mood-was-ok-in -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Except for a brief window of roughly 1988-1991, my first-hand experience is that America’s national mood has been relentlessly bad." www.betonit.ai/p/americas-national-mood-was-ok-in
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
These Matejko illustrations of future wars are amazing.
Made years before WWII. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Probably not true if you're obviously over 30, especially with today's multiple moral panics.
But yes, if you're college age, want to learn, refuse to pay tuition, and don't care about credentials, just attend unofficially.
Isegoria
@Isegoria
“No one will stop you. No one will challenge you. No one will make you feel unwelcome. Gorge yourself at Princeton’s all-you-can-eat buffet of the mind. Colleges do not card. I have seen this with my own eyes at schools around the country.” www.isegoria.net/2026/05/colleges-do-not-card/
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
PolizRajt
@Iynhyun
"It's a strawman. Nobody would ever believe such a thing"
Martin Luther: *hold my beer* "Reason is the Devil's greatest whore; by nature and manner of being she is a noxious whore; she is a prostitute, the Devil's appointed whore" -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Critical Thinker
@criticlthinkr
I'm reminded of @bryan_caplan's point that most professors would shed tears of joy if you just wandered into their classroom an asked to attend the class so you could learn the material despite not being enrolled as a student for credit.
Bethany S. Mandel
@bethanyshondark
I wish there was such a thing as college at 40. A chance to do it over, only this time we don’t take classes for credits and grades, but just to learn.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What has happened to actual discrimination lawsuits?
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
In 2023, my book The Origins of Woke argued that wokeness was largely a legal phenomenon. Get a Republican president in office who focuses on changing civil rights law, and things would turn around.
Book reviews were very skeptical of this. People talked about woke as a religion. These were true believers who were going to do whatever it took to push DEI.
Here we are two years later, and we got a president who followed my suggestions. What happened?
A new paper from professors at Princeton and Columbia show that I was correct.
Trump came into office, signed a few executive orders, and DEI commitments among corporations in securities disclosures filed with the SEC collapsed.
Moreover, the fall was especially pronounced among federal contractors, who have most contact with the government and its rules. The affirmative action regime in contracting is something I discussed extensively in the book.
You could've predicted this from The Origins of Woke. Read my new book for insight into what's coming next. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Until recently, I thought that since a gift sells for $0, no one had to pay tariffs on gifts.
chatgpt.com/s/t_6a5e31d57f488191a5aca35b450583d3 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This generalizes broadly.
Steven Kale
@StevenKale16
To say it's discrimination is too easy. It simplifies a complex process that takes place in a context in which many actors have input and the economics are disastrous. If it makes you feel better to insist that it's all discrimination, then do it.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Just added a Berkeley meet-up for Wednesday. Details: www.betonit.ai/p/berkeley-bonus-meet-up-wednesday
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Or at least don't call someone "right-wing" because they have >0 right-wing views!
Alexander Kustov
@akoustov
Academics should have a moratorium on calling people who are to the left of 90% of voters "right-wing."
Just because you happen to be further left doesn't mean that everyone who disagrees with you is a "conservative" or a "grifter." The fact this needs to be said is astonishing. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
When I was 5 years old, a self-appointed soneone painted this fire hydrant red, white, and blue for the bicentennial.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Back in 2006, I wrote a critique of eugenics-inspired immigration restrictions. In 2010, youthful Richard Hanania wrote this reply under his now-notorious alt-right pseudonym, Richard Hoste. The following essay was my reply to his reply."
betonit.substack.com/p/the_social_andhtml -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I'm now more popular than "The End of Reading."
Looks like I'm bringing it back. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hating Hanania is truly futile.
I've never met a man who cares less what you think of him.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I like that in The Atlantic profile, they got Tucker and John Ganz denouncing me in the same paragraph.
They're each so completely awful, from opposite ends of the political spectrum.
If I ever doubt what I'm doing, I can remind myself who my enemies are. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Congrats, buddy. Well-deserved.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I'm profiled in The Atlantic.
It discusses my new book and how I became disillusioned with the "smarter" part of the right.
The lesson for Democrats: you can't outpopulist MAGA.
You need to both moderate and embrace a kind of elitism done right.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/07/trump-populism-right-wi… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What most critics of the academic left miss is just how intellectually petty the academic left is.
Most profs are just conformist, and their thought leaders are primarily passionate about a weird list of symbolic topics.
Most profs care more about the news than history! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Imagining that "open borders advocates" dominate academia is what happens when you assume that your political opponents just believe the opposite of what you believe instead of reading them. (1/2)
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Based on what they actually talk and write about, the academic left cares more about trans athletes than every 3rd World worker who wants to migrate to 1st World for a better job. (2/2)
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I would really like to meet the open borders zealots who supposedly dominate academia.
I literally wrote the book *Open Borders*. A few dozen econ and philosophy profs are almost all we've got.
ChatGPT confirms that I'm not missing much. chatgpt.com/s/t_6a5cf0697e188191900d5d7365a7ce31 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
*The Furious* is easily one of the top 10 best martial arts movies of all time!
Maybe even top 5. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you want to see an ultra-traditional pre-modern epic, make it *The Northman*.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Figuratively, the Titanic is sinking. People often say we have only one planet. But we have only one species too. This is it." desertphilosophy.substack.com/p/are-dinks-free-riders
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Really impressive and thoughtful.
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
Democrats and Republicans have the opportunity to do something great: fix America's broken permitting system.
Bipartisan deals are often impossible, but on permitting it's totally possible—because permitting delays kill projects that members of both parties deeply care about. 🧵 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
We should 10x research on price index bias.
Verónica Bäcker-Peral
@VBPeral
Excited to share our new working paper: how much did the US standard of living really rise over the twentieth century — and when? With @bhwittenbrink
Using 5.1 million Sears catalog listings, we build a quality-adjusted price index for consumer goods, 1900–1990. Two headline findings: growth was much larger than official statistics imply, and its peak came before WWII, not after. (1/9) -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Plausibly most all of what people dislike about prediction markets are things they also dislike about ordinary financial markets, but just don't realize that they similarly happen in such markets.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Spotted in Hollywood.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
As it should be
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Psychologists are correct to worry that trigger warnings make trauma worse. Yes, on second thought you could accuse these critics of advocating forced medical treatment. But on third thought they’re not, because calling psychotherapy 'medical treatment' is a metaphor."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Bnce you accept the science of exposure therapy, you’re likely to change your mind about what counts as 'rude' or 'insensitive.' If discussing sensitive topics ultimately makes traumatized people feel better, why should there be a norm against it?" www.betonit.ai/p/third-thoughts-about-trigger-warnings
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Scott Lincicome
@scottlincicome
My new @opinion column covers a policy that few in an increasingly protectionist Washington are willing to acknowledge:
Seemingly every time a supply chain (or political) problem arises, the White House embraces imports & freer trade.
www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2026-07-16/freer-trade… (🎁) /1 -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Setting aside everything else that’s wrong with this post, the “billionaires could have solved problems X, Y, and Z with their billions but they didn’t” take is tiresome considering the US government spends *trillions* every year and it hasn’t solved homelessness, world hunger, climate change, etc.
Sachi
@Sachiposting
Billionaires shouldn’t exist because they hoard wealth while people die on the streets and starve
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
1. NRC is right to challenge the "ALARA" rule, which has been catastrophic for nuclear power.
2. Challenging ALARA is not enough. To unleash nuclear power in this country, the NRC needs to reject "LNT," the pseudoscientific radiation model on which ALARA is based.
🧵👇 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm hosting a meet-up in LA next week.
Hope you can make it!
www.betonit.ai/p/upcoming-events-c0a -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I like to think Spain is listening to me, but it's probably just happy coincidence. www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-from-spain
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Pretty impressive. Spain is taking so many immigrants that it is contributing about as much to population growth in Europe as all other EU countries combined.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Update: Per your suspicions, the sender admits to using AI in his composition. Here’s what he told me when I acquired (reprinted, again, with permission)." www.betonit.ai/p/hes-got-my-vote-an-atypically-productive
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Astronaut Edgar Mitchell on the Overview Effect: “From out there on the moon, international politics look so petty. You want to grab a politician by the scruff of the neck and drag him a quarter of a million miles out and say, ‘Look at that, you son of a bitch.’”
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"@PhilWMagness and I discuss my recent pieces on 'How socialist was Nazism?' His knowledge of turn of the century intellectual history is truly astounding."
www.betonit.ai/p/nazi-economics-ideas-and-policies -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I remember when downloading a high-res image took 1-2 minutes.
Now with AI, we're back to waiting 1-2 minutes for cyber gratification. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Very cool.
Like almost everyone except the Iranians, I was clueless about how much Hormuz matters. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
Optimal strategy for any small country. Large ones too, but more so when negotiated mercantilism is hopeless. You can’t raise tariffs on the grocery store; don’t try.
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Canada should simply liberalize unilaterally. Its the only way to minimize the damages of the rising wave of protectionism
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
Yes. The old idea of documenting market failure before regulation seems to have evaporated among these esteemed economists. Questioning regulatory capacity even more so
Adrian Moore
@reasonpolicy
How did we get to a place where so many people assume you must regulate anything new if you can imagine any problem coming of it? Our new, mad, norm is preemptive regulation of imaginary potential harms without waiting to see if a) any harms actually emerge, or b) if the market can solve the harms, as they so often do, since no one wants them. Guaranteed stagnation if we allow it to happen.
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
You must be kidding. AI might have big effects. It could have risks. So “policymakers,” must "act now,” before they have any idea what they’re doing, to "build the incentives, guardrails, and institutions needed to steer AI in a direction that complements humans and benefits society?” Boy I’m glad no self-appointed “policy maker” decided to “steer” the development of the steam engine. The ones who “steered” nuclear power destroyed it. Preemptive dirigisme is killing tech in Europe. If said “policy makers” could do something about the dumpster fires of US social programs, building restrictions, appalling costs of public infrastructure, broken tax code, failing schools, maybe I’d think about "calling" to unleash them on some vague AI crusade. (Previous essay on this here www.grumpy-economist.com/p/ai-society-and-democracy-just-…)
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
Here's our statement on AI and the economy.
We Must Act Now
A Statement on AI’s Transformation of the Economy
1. AI may become radically more powerful over the next 10 years.
2. This could drive an unprecedented transformation of our economy, larger than the Industrial Revolution, but unfolding over a vastly shorter time frame. It could bring risks, including large-scale job displacement, as well as opportunities such as major gains in living standards.
3. Economists, policymakers and technology leaders must act now to understand the economics of transformative AI and to build the incentives, guardrails, and institutions needed to steer AI in a direction that complements humans and benefits society. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
Those guardrails are property rights, rule of law, limited government, not self-appointed aristocrats who want to be "policy-makers" making up grandiose plans.
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I oppose guardrails for awesome new technologies.
Instead, I favor guardrails for the people who build guardrails for awesome new technologies.
They're the ones with a terrible track record of derailing progress.
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
Here's our statement on AI and the economy.
We Must Act Now
A Statement on AI’s Transformation of the Economy
1. AI may become radically more powerful over the next 10 years.
2. This could drive an unprecedented transformation of our economy, larger than the Industrial Revolution, but unfolding over a vastly shorter time frame. It could bring risks, including large-scale job displacement, as well as opportunities such as major gains in living standards.
3. Economists, policymakers and technology leaders must act now to understand the economics of transformative AI and to build the incentives, guardrails, and institutions needed to steer AI in a direction that complements humans and benefits society. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
They are not kidding, I'm afraid.
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
You must be kidding. AI might have big effects. It could have risks. So “policymakers,” must "act now,” before they have any idea what they’re doing, to "build the incentives, guardrails, and institutions needed to steer AI in a direction that complements humans and benefits society?” Boy I’m glad no self-appointed “policy maker” decided to “steer” the development of the steam engine. The ones who “steered” nuclear power destroyed it. Preemptive dirigisme is killing tech in Europe. If said “policy makers” could do something about the dumpster fires of US social programs, building restrictions, appalling costs of public infrastructure, broken tax code, failing schools, maybe I’d think about "calling" to unleash them on some vague AI crusade. (Previous essay on this here www.grumpy-economist.com/p/ai-society-and-democracy-just-…)
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
Here's our statement on AI and the economy.
We Must Act Now
A Statement on AI’s Transformation of the Economy
1. AI may become radically more powerful over the next 10 years.
2. This could drive an unprecedented transformation of our economy, larger than the Industrial Revolution, but unfolding over a vastly shorter time frame. It could bring risks, including large-scale job displacement, as well as opportunities such as major gains in living standards.
3. Economists, policymakers and technology leaders must act now to understand the economics of transformative AI and to build the incentives, guardrails, and institutions needed to steer AI in a direction that complements humans and benefits society. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I reject the whole “something big is happening in the world therefore we need to make a new regulatory regime for it”. Consider regulation only when concrete things start to go wrong, and then ask if harms averted are worth the costs of regulation.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
True, except for the "everyone" part!
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Red states let people build housing, blue states made it difficult, and we saw the results.
Now, the left’s ambivalence to hatred of markets is leading to data center bans. The results will be the same, and everyone will eventually acknowledge the pro-market side was correct. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Democrats should compromise on the endless things they're wrong about.
But not immigration, where their radicals are totally right, albeit mostly for the wrong reasons.
www.betonit.ai/p/immigration-worth-losing-for -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I oppose guardrails for awesome new technologies.
Instead, I favor guardrails for the people who build guardrails for awesome new technologies.
They're the ones with a terrible track record of derailing progress.
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
Here's our statement on AI and the economy.
We Must Act Now
A Statement on AI’s Transformation of the Economy
1. AI may become radically more powerful over the next 10 years.
2. This could drive an unprecedented transformation of our economy, larger than the Industrial Revolution, but unfolding over a vastly shorter time frame. It could bring risks, including large-scale job displacement, as well as opportunities such as major gains in living standards.
3. Economists, policymakers and technology leaders must act now to understand the economics of transformative AI and to build the incentives, guardrails, and institutions needed to steer AI in a direction that complements humans and benefits society. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Full-time employment in the First World is a near-foolproof way to escape poverty, but getting rich takes a lot more.
But just saving and investing 10% of your income from 18 on will make almost any full-time worker in the First World rich by retirement age.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
It is an oversimplification to say that rich people have more money because they work harder.
Rich people are also smarter and have more self-control than poor people. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Watch the entire convo with @coldxman here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=18wYRFjC39o
And the book is here: www.amazon.com/Kakistocracy-Why-Populism-Ends-Disaster/dp… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I know Nicholas pretty well.
He will make the right person very happy!
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
I am looking for a partner. If you would like to talk, please do reach out! It’d be really wonderful. Link to the date-me doc is below; now pls pls pls pls algorithm send this far and wide!
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If most aspiring politicians were this numerate, the Great Political Stagnation would already be over."
www.betonit.ai/p/hes-got-my-vote-an-atypically-productive -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"That UBI will probably end up dwarfing the cost of the seven programs you're abolishing, so it's not even really liberaltarian. Think about the math. Under your plan, a family of 4 would pay no taxes at all until it's earning $290k ($48k/.2 + $50k)." www.betonit.ai/p/hes-got-my-vote-an-atypically-productive
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Things started out innocently enough with merit scholarships: You fund outstanding students from poor families to help them shine. Alas, the guilt remained, because outstanding students from poor families are few and far between." www.betonit.ai/p/self-hating-signaling
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It took about a dozen iterations on Chat to get this right. Anyone see any lingering flaws?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I talked to @coldxman about Kakistocracy.
It was a great conversation about the thesis of the book, with some pushback on what to do about real failures of elites. It's a difficult problem.
But MAGA nihilism isn't the answer. www.thefp.com/p/conversations-with-coleman-richard-hanania -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I explain the psychology of nationalism.
We already live in a world where people are nationalists and governments worry about their own citizens over others.
But nationalists need to pretend otherwise in order for their worldview to make any sense. www.richardhanania.com/p/nationalists-already-have-the-world -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If we should hold people in the past to universal moral standards, we should also hold people in the present to universal moral standards, not credulously accept lame, lawyerly excuses like, 'Given their life story, we mustn’t blame them.'" www.betonit.ai/p/the-best-thing-about-wokeness
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you’ve got actual evidence that the murder rate gap is driven by piles of false convictions, by all means share your evidence. But if 'He would have been a gentle soul in a world free of racism' is all you’ve got, spare us."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-best-thing-about-wokeness -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"What’s the best thing about wokeness? Simple: Holding people in the past to universal moral standards." www.betonit.ai/p/the-best-thing-about-wokeness
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
John used ChatGPT-5.6 Sol.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is a good format, and I'm afraid @ezraklein is right about 80% of the time. www.nytimes.com/2026/06/30/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-chr…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
More pages via John Champaign:
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
AI is getting pretty close to being able to make a full graphic novel, despite lingering perspective issues. Many thanks to John Champaign!
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
We discuss him in my family often.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
One of the messages of The Sopranos is that therapy culture has been a disease. The old Jewish psychiatrist who is seen once and never again is the conscience of the show.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I just found out about this, but I immediately support it.
Cate Hall 🔸
@catehall
It’s real!
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Jonah Goldberg
@JonahDispatch
But if you're going to cite these factions as important, what criteria are you using to dismiss the significance of the Maoists and Stalinists? The DSA has an expressly no-enemies-to-the-left approach. Their website proclaims that “We believe there are many avenues that feed into the democratic road to socialism. Our vision pushes further than historic social democracy and leaves behind authoritarian visions of socialism in the dustbin of history.” Really? By rehabilitating Mao (and Maoist terrorist insurgencies abroad) and allying with open supporters of anti-Semitic murder here at home? 11/
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Jonah Goldberg
@JonahDispatch
We hear a lot about how democratic socialism isn't communism, has no similarities to communism, and people who suggest it does are ignorant, McCarthyite, or both. MSM pundits, academics, and Democratic politicians insist that the democratic socialism of the DSA has nothing to do with communism, or revolutionary or violent communist struggles. 2/
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Exciting. This is like what happened with housing in Vancouver.
Ben Podgursky
@bpodgursky
imagine going back to 1832 and explaining to chief justice John Marshall that the tribal sovereignty he enshrined in Worcester v. Georgia would give the Cherokee Nation the freedom to build hyperscale AI data centers without state interference
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"P.S. If any members of Bad Religion ever read this, I love you guys. I would happily teach you economics for free. I visit LA often, and there’s always Zoom."
www.betonit.ai/p/labor-demand-in-bad-religion -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"It’s tempting to read 'American Jesus' as an open borders anthem, but I’m afraid that’s wishful thinking."
www.betonit.ai/p/labor-demand-in-bad-religion
I feel sorry for the earth’s population
‘Cause so few live in the USA
At least the foreigners can copy our morality
They can visit but they cannot stay -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Important but overstated.
As far as I know, no national majority has ever supported expropriation of private farms, which, if you know your history, is THE signature Communist policy.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
If democracy were acted out in full, we'd be the Soviet Union.
Source: www.zillow.com/research/rent-control-20128/ -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Rent control is a stunning policy.
The literature, the experts, and the repeated experience of reality all stand undivided in saying it's bad.
But the public loves it. It's insanely popular. It's basically a 75:25 issue and voters want more of it. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I've started a trend! reason.com/volokh/2026/07/08/sixteen-fun-facts-about-me/
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
My podcast on Nazi economic policy with Bob Lawson, co-founder of the Economic Freedom of the World index. www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1MWiyVahDA
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
As paranoid as anti-AI arguments seem to me, they are clearly less delusional than anti-nuclear arguments.
Yet I'd be amazed if the anti-AI movement has even 1/10th the success of the anti-nuclear movement.
Why? Because nuclear is atoms, and AI is bits. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"What does the DSA say about the likely economic and social effects of open borders? Do any engage with Bryan Caplan on this topic?" @DemSocialists
chatgpt.com/s/t_6a4fad62e31c81918d31cc1fa924280f -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
GPT on why Marxist-Leninists have more influence on the left than Groypers have on the right: "The best quantitative clues suggest real but not DSA-scale mass organization. A Washington Post investigation reported roughly 11,000 donors sending Fuentes nearly $900,000 since early 2025, which is substantial for an extremist streamer but still not equivalent to a 100,000-member organization with formal elected leadership."
chatgpt.com/s/t_6a4fabade2d881919e229681f33366c7
chatgpt.com/s/t_6a4fabc273bc8191a20c35e7316589f8 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Overstated but insightful: "*The Four Faces of the Republican Party*, I showed that movement economic conservatism was the weakest of the four identifiable factions. This group composed 10% of the nationwide primary electorate at most, and thus always saw its preferred candidates drop out early in the race." nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/fusionism-21st-ce…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Government, not nature, makes land perfectly inelastic: worksinprogress.co/issue/why-the-west-stopped-making-land/
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
People use dialysis while awaiting kidney transplants, & price to induce folks to give up a kidney is much less than what spent on dialysis for folks waiting. So US govt could save lots via pay folks to give up kidneys. But they don't, so far, due to lobbying by big dialysis.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
I calculated age-adjusted crime rates for 13 ethnic groups in England and Wales. Adjusting for age reduces the gap between Black and White British by a third, and reduces the gap between Pakistani and White British by three quarters.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
"Support for Labour among Pakistanis and Bangladeshis has crashed by a minimum of 44 points. That’s about twice as large as the fall in Democrat identification among Southern Whites in the US during the 1960s." thecritic.co.uk/ethnic-minorities-are-abandoning-labour/
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The "big tent" of the Democratic Socialists of America is big enough to contain a sizable wing of dictatorial socialists. chatgpt.com/s/t_6a4e62261e708191ac8c9d03168ae01d @DemSocialists
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The origin of the "guns versus butter" meme. thedailyeconomy.org/article/guns-versus-butter-tracing-th…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Public opinion tends to be too anti-elite because of social desirability bias.
Praising the people sounds good. Praising elites sounds bad. So we only hear anti-elite, and pro-masses arguments.
My book seeks to be a corrective and give a more balanced assessment. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Classic.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
You're invited to Capla-Con 2026, August 15-16 at GMU's Carow Hall!
Details here.
caplacon.substack.com/p/youre-invited-to-capla-con-2026 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"By the time I was in my late-20s, daily life started seeming hilarious to me, and still does. When I go to the movies, I am often the only person in the theater laughing hysterically at top volume, usually at lines that no one else even chuckles at." www.betonit.ai/p/sixteen-fun-facts-about-me
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"In high school, I clearly had the lowest IQ of my four closest friends." www.betonit.ai/p/sixteen-fun-facts-about-me
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I cannot remember a time when I wasn’t extraordinarily arrogant by disposition. Even when I was five years old, I felt like my mom was making glaring mistakes and should take orders from me. And I bluntly told her so!"
www.betonit.ai/p/sixteen-fun-facts-about-me -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Since I also have vivid, detailed memories about most of the movies I saw in theaters during my childhood (and adulthood, too), I often use movie release years to organize careful chronologies of my life." www.betonit.ai/p/sixteen-fun-facts-about-me
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If "equity" means equalizing admission probabilities for the smart and not-so-smart alike, test-blind admissions were a great triumph of equity.
It's the moral theory that's shocking, not the observed consequences for student performance! -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
No one actually takes any of the anti-immigration stuff seriously in their personal lives. Remarkable number of anti-immigration activists have foreign wives, which is funny.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
I'm tired of hearing that "the benefits of AI must be broadly distributed" and therefore we need government to intervene.
AI benefits will be more broadly and rapidly distributed than any tech in history.
Everyone will have access to amazing tutoring, genius medical advice, and an army of helpful assistants—things that were previously available only to the super-wealthy.
The people who create the most valuable forms of AI will deserve to make a fortune on it—and that fortune will reflect the level of benefit they've brought to the world.
All the ideas for the government to "broadly distribute" the benefits of AI are terrible.
Nationalize AI companies, so that progress can crater?
Own a percentage of certain AI companies, so government can become even more corrupt and meddling in picking winners and losers?
Seize AI companies' future earnings, so that more people can become dependent on government handouts?
Government's job regarding AI is fundamentally simple:
1. Modify laws or enforcement practices to handle cases where AI can be used to violate people's rights (e.g., new types of fraud).
2. Protect companies' and individuals' right to pursue AI as they judge best—including to build the life-giving data centers that are now under attack.
To do my part to ensure that AI is pursued in a pro-human, pro-freedom way, I have begun work on my next book: The Moral Case for Data Centers. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Enjoyed this review of my book from Scott Sumner, which comes from the unique angle that I may not be hostile enough to populism. scottsumner.substack.com/p/kakistocracy
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yes, US grievances against the UK were mild by almost any standard, and if they just waited a generation these issues would probably have been resolved peacefully.
And don't get me started on the US inspiring the 25 year bloodbath sparked by the French Revolution.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
With @bryan_caplan, I have my doubts that it was justified.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
If you want more takes on Vance’s book, set a reminder here to join my stream with @mtracey on it Monday at 2:45 ET. open.substack.com/live-stream/266092?r=3rgcb
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
While I fully side with UFO debunkers, I'd still love for all info to be declassified.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Seems to me that figuring out what UAPs are usually matters more than whatever secrets they seek to protect by keeping UAP data classified.
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
I fully support efforts to obtain historical UAP records and data. These records have scientific value, particularly when they have never before been available to scientists. The Council will pursue multiple objectives simultaneously: obtaining historical government records and data, encouraging appropriate transparency, and obtaining new data and evidence that meet today's scientific standards.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
This article mentions me many times. As the authors didn't check with me first, I must now correct them in public.
“in the year 2000, Michael Foster,… ‘convinced colleagues at DARPA that their agency should fund research into prediction markets that could potentially be used to guide public policy decision-making.’ This was notably years before Hanson ‘independently’ developed his ideas of ‘futarchy,’ which posits using prediction markets as a system of public governance. These ideas and their relevance today are discussed in Part II of this investigation.”
No, I first posted on the idea in 1996: www.overcomingbias.com/p/my-best-idea-decision-markets
"Hanson, who was also advising Joey Krug’s Augur at the time, is said to have largely 'brushed off' Coplan."
I don't see it that way at all.
"a profile on Augur from 2018 notes that Krug, one of his co-founders, and two unnamed Augur advisors (one of which was likely Hanson) had explicitly decided to make the Augur logo 'a pyramid, with three points converging upon an all-seeing eye.'"
I had no knowledge of or involvement in picking Augur's logo.
“‘Policy Analysis Market,’ or PAM. Hanson served as the system architect for PAM. … Whereas TIA sought to predict terrorist and criminal activity before it could occur through mass surveillance of Americans’ daily activities, PAM focused on using ‘market-based techniques’ for similar ends. However, in the case of PAM, its efforts to predict events included, but went far beyond terrorist activity. PAM also sought to focus on global and regional political stability, predicting the timing and impact of emerging technologies, predicting the outcomes of advanced technology and “other future events of interest to the DoD.”
‘terrorist and criminal activity’ doesn’t sound similar to me to ‘global and regional political stability’.
“Despite what he lists on his CV, it appears that Hanson did a significant amount of his work for NASA, not as a direct employee, but rather as a contractor via the private company Sterling Software. Hanson does not publicly list his past employment with Sterling on his CV, but his publications from this period reveal his status as a Sterling employee while it contracted for NASA. Sterling Software was largely run by … Sam Wyly and his brother Charles. … Sterling’s de facto hostile takeover of Informatics was made possible by the criminal bank Drexel Burnham Lambert, which was closely tied to the Savings and Loans crisis of that era and criminal activities tied to both intelligence agencies and the Bush family. Notably, during the Drexel-backed efforts of the Wylys to seize control of Informatics, Charles Hurwitz, the mob-adjacent corporate raider with significant ties to the most notorious actors of the Savings and Loans crisis, took a 13.3% stake in the company to facilitate Sterling Software’s takeover.”
As NASA Ames had limited civil servant spots, it hired most folks who worked there as contractors, via Sterling. I got my paychecks from them, but never interacted with them. I sat among and worked with the other members of the AI research group.
Whitney Webb
@_whitneywebb
We've been quiet recently because Mark Goodwin and I have been working to write the most comprehensive investigation into Polymarket's origins and ambitions to date.
We found that Polymarket's "official" origin story, that Shayne Coplan founded the company alone in 2020 and then built "the company in his bathroom", is a lie. Polymarket really started years earlier as another company called TokenBnk that was deeply tied to Israeli interests, specifically a crypto company founded by Benjamin Netanyahu's niece and nephew. Coplan has actively tried to obfuscate this company from his story and it's not the only thing either.
In Part 1 of this two-part series, we unravel the real history of Polymarket, directly connecting the company to Peter Thiel's efforts to resurrect controversial DARPA programs from its now defunct Information Awareness Office. Polymarket appears to have been chosen by Thiel and his associates to succeed in resurrecting DARPA's Policy Analysis Market where another Thiel-linked company, Augur, had previously failed.
Stay tuned for Part 2, where we explore the current influence of prediction markets and Polymarket, including how an insidious effort to have prediction markets replace representative democracy as a governance model is already being slowly implemented by the White House.
Read Part 1 here: unlimitedhangout.com/2026/06/investigative-series/the-sec… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Maybe he doesn't like bread?
Schrodinger's Dog
@LIVReadyGolfer
Funny, just met a Frenchman here in North Carolina who said between The Fresh Market, Sprouts, and Whole Foods plus Wegmans and Publix that Paris has nothing on Raleigh when it comes to grocery options.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Of course, abundant @Costco is a wonder of the world.
Murray McKechnie
@MurrMcK
I'll interpret you saying add 4 ranks instead of 3 to mean the US is just on another level when it comes to bulk buying.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It's close, but I dock the Germanies for short store hours.
TradFly
@tobibog
UK before Germany/Austria???
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Bakeries are better in Portugal, and France has abundant @Leclerc.
Iván
@ivanrajap
Spain 3th even with Dino and Mercadona? 🤣🤣🤣😉
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Poland has other strengths. 😜
Mikołaj Pisarski
@MikolajPisarski
Come on Bryan… we took You to Żabka here in Poland and this is how You repay us!? 🫣
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
*The Serpent* (@netflix) is one of the best period pieces I've ever seen. A portal to a bygone era and region, when driving across Iran and Afghanistan wasn't crazy.
Check out the "hippie trail" of the 70s. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Good offer! I say do it.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I've realized it only takes about 5K sales in a week to become a NYT best seller.
That means I've got to get like 3% of my X followers to preorder my book coming out on Tuesday now.
Surely my readers aren't that lazy, poor, and cheap? This would make them very Low Human Capital.
To sweeten the deal, I'll give a free year subscription to the newsletter to those who preorder. Details below. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Order here, and send your receipt to hanania.preorders@gmail.com
1 year for hardcover, 6 months for ebook, 1 year if you do audio + ebook
Offer only available to those not already paid subscribers. www.amazon.com/dp/0063479990?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRed… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'll take it!
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
How Bryan Caplan got me to stop hating UATX. I think I had a strong reaction against it because I'm used to communist lunatics being around universities, but having Gad Saad and Shellenberger types is new. But I can't say they're objectively worse than the communists.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Michael Wiebe
@michael_wiebe
Nice to see this published.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Doing a Substack Live today at 4:30 PM ET on "How socialist was National Socialism?" with Bob Lawson, co-founded of the Economic Freedom of the World index.
Our Substack subscribers will get notifications around 4:29 PM.
www.betonit.ai/p/national-socialism-and-economic-freedom -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
European grocery stores ranked by my (1 week min!) 1st-hand experience, with U.S. for comparison.
Best to worst:
France
Portugal
Spain
U.S.
U.K.
Germany/Austria
Italy
Poland
Switzerland
Hungary
Sweden
Denmark
Norway
Bakery: Add 6 ranks for Europe
Bulk: Add 4 ranks for U.S. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Go to Norwegian grocery stores before you say Norway is thriving.
Virtually the worst in Europe.
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Norway is a shining example of how an economy can thrive with a comparatively large percentage of state-owned enterprises so long as it bats 1.000 on every other institutional arrangement and has over a trillion dollars in oil money.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
So J.D. Vance is a more evil, less conflicted version of Gail Wynand?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
This April 2020 article by JD Vance is an underacknowledged watershed in his political evolution.
The backstory is that he wrote a since-deleted viral twitter thread, attempting to defang the emerging anti-lockdown movement on the right by trashing Sweden's anti-lockdown approach, making nods to "trust the science" couched in appeals to uncertainty about the nature of the disease, and attempting to deflect away from the core civil liberties issues of Faucism by turning COVID into a proxy war for his own grievances against "globalization."
Somebody at Claremont then convinced him to turn the thread into an op-ed that accentuated the anti-globalization themes and repurposed the COVID debate into a bizarre and incoherent broadside against free markets.
This came immediately on the heals of Claremont brass (reportedly Mike Anton) recruiting Curtis Yarvin (who was a fanatical lockdowner at the time) to make more or less the same arguments as Vance on the same blog, albeit in a less-refined form a few weeks prior.
Vance had already been courting the Postliberal scene around Deneen, Vermeule, and Pappin (the last of whom was Anton's co-partner on the American Greatness blog in 2016). But this piece brought him into a broader orbit with the main part of the "intellectual right" that was still actively trying to rationalize and provide a scholarly veneer for the irrationalities of Trumpism.
Vance, of course, fully converted to Trumpism shortly thereafter. And then he reinvented himself as a lockdown skeptic, even though in April 2020 - when the anti-lockdown movement was needed most - his energies had been devoted to derailing that same movement and repurposing it toward a kooky Postliberal economic agenda.
And thereby hangs a tale... -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This seems like an ideal time for @AlexEpstein to teach the world about "climate mastery."
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alex Epstein
@AlexEpstein
Here's a Texas official calling for a moratorium on new data centers in Texas "until we fully assess the long-term impacts on our infrastructure, agricultural economy, and communities."
Imagine if, in the early 19th century, governments had imposed a moratorium on steam engines until they could "fully assess" the long-term impacts of coal mining, railroads, factories, and industrial towns.
This would have delayed the Industrial Revolution for an arbitrary amount of time, and all of us would be much poorer.
Data centers are the steam engines of the AI age: foundational infrastructure for a new wave of productivity and progress.
It would have been a terrible mistake to block steam engines 200 years ago, and it would be a terrible mistake to block data centers today. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Conservatism became socialist when it from complaining about blacks not working to immigrants being too good at work. www.richardhanania.com/p/should-republicans-be-more-expli…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is a gorgeous phone.
Hard to believe it's for battlefield use during WWI. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Patrick Collison
@patrickc
Links post from @RichardHanania, noting: "A very high portion of the links comes from Works in Progress, which I think has become in essence the most must-read thing on the internet."
www.richardhanania.com/p/indigenous-activists-defend-prog… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Auf Deutsch.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Verily, you could just tweak the title of David Benatar’s anti-natalist *Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence* and turn it into *Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Socialism’s Coming into Existence*." www.betonit.ai/p/nazism-socialism-and-the-philosophy
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even if the Soviet Union 'saved civilization,' this is only a case of one terrible socialist regime saving civilization from an even worse socialist regime. None of which would have been necessary if socialism had never existed in the first place!"
www.betonit.ai/p/nazism-socialism-and-the-philosophy -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"As long as you charitably interpret the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact as 'Stalin was just buying time to prepare for the inevitable war,' you can tell yourself that socialism saved civilization despite its Dorian Gray-level transmogrification." www.betonit.ai/p/nazism-socialism-and-the-philosophy
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
A Brit in Dunkirk once asked me if I spoke English.
Question: Based on my appearance and demeanor, what would you expect my native language to be if it weren't English? -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ilya Somin
@IlyaSomin
My post on today's excellent Supreme Court decision in birthright citizenship case. Why it's right, and why dissenting opinions are badly wrong. Their reasoning at odds with main purpose of Citizenship Clause - granting birthright citizenship to freed slaves:
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ilya Somin
@IlyaSomin
Video of my @cspanwj interview about today's Supreme Court decisions: www.c-span.org/program/call-in/supreme-court-decisions/68…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Few of those who argue that their employer and landlord exploit them recognize that their employer and landlord made them the very best job and housing offers they received (otherwise, they wouldn’t have accepted them). Perhaps they’d say these offers are still exploitative, but even so, they’d be the *least* exploitative offers they received.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Easy to get left-leaning GPT to concede:
"'Nazis weren’t socialist because they weren’t democratic/egalitarian/worker-controlled' move proves too much. It protects socialism from Nazism only by also protecting it from most real-world socialist regimes." www.betonit.ai/p/nazi-socialism-whats-at-stake -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Henri Arslanian
@HenriArslanian
Why the godfather of prediction markets thinks insider trading should be encouraged.
My interview with @robinhanson, the pioneer of modern prediction markets and Associate Professor of Economics at George Mason University.
The full interview is available on my YouTube and podcast platforms.
YouTube: www.youtube.com/watch?v=xI0pbfbMSn4
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/why-the-godfather-of-predic…
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/2pPKVtChUUYImdd2DlZ3u2
Powered by @acxcompliance – the world’s largest crypto compliance specialised managed services provider.
By crypto compliance professionals. For crypto compliance professionals.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Josh Barro
@jbarro
Gaslighting Europeans keep telling me that policy discouraging AC is a fake issue Americans made up, but I regret to inform them I can read
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
When I was in high school, I dreamed of a world where people wanted to spend all day arguing about philosophy, politics, and economics.
Now we're here, and I was wrong.
Wrong! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"BC: Don’t most modern socialists prefer state direction over state ownership? It seems like the Nazis deserve the name socialist at least as much as they do.
"GPT: Yes, that is a strong point. The argument 'the Nazis weren’t socialist because they usually left private title in place' is too crude. Socialism has often meant social or state control, not necessarily 100% state ownership."
www.betonit.ai/p/nazi-socialism-whats-at-stake -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
While ChatGPT leans left, it very quickly concedes that the Nazis were bona fide socialists by any reasonable standard.
www.betonit.ai/p/nazi-socialism-whats-at-stake -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
These are Bryan Caplan originals.
It would be weird if I got more views just sharing other people's work. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Germany’s average economic freedom score during WWI (4.3) exceeds its peacetime score under Nazi rule (3.1). The Nazis were not 'forced' to accept socialism to fight WWII. They embraced extreme socialist policies as soon as they gained power." www.betonit.ai/p/uber-socialist-chatgpt-on-economic
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even if the Nazis were the sincerest of socialists, mainstream socialists would almost certainly deny them the label regardless of the facts."
www.betonit.ai/p/uber-socialist-chatgpt-on-economic -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If the world’s most famous brand of socialists turned out to be total monsters, could the world’s most famous brand of monsters turn out to be total socialists?" www.betonit.ai/p/uber-socialist-chatgpt-on-economic
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
For the morbidly curious.
“GLP-1s are terrible because they make fat people appear suicidal for not wanting to lose weight.” substack.com/home/post/p-200540450 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Politicians and voters hold the free market to an unfairly high standard. I, in contrast, hold politicians and voters to an eminently reasonable standard: Don’t advocate government action until you credibly show that, despite all the free market’s merits, you know how to do better." www.betonit.ai/p/whose-standards-are-too-high
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Maybe the refuser has a good reason to say, 'I’ve done more than enough for my brother.' Why then should we reflexively side against taxpayers who don’t want to fund redistribution to strangers?" www.betonit.ai/p/whose-standards-are-too-high
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
If Abundance won't speak up against a two year rent freeze, which they obviously oppose in their hearts, what is even the point?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Conservatives poll happier than liberals.
But the gap disappears or is significantly reduced when you control for belief in therapy culture.
The ideas that people are fragile and need psychiatric care have been a disaster. www.richardhanania.com/p/does-therapy-culture-explain-the -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
America if judges rediscover Lochner.
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
There's a case slowly working its way through federal courts in NYC that has the potential to become a national case.
The plaintiffs are challenging the constitutionality of NY's rent control and stabilization laws. And they managed to land a judge appointed by Trump... -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
From 2017:
A pretty good test of my Simplistic Theory of Left and Right: In the long run, it predicts that if rightists abandon a pro-market policy, leftists will remain firmly opposed to it; but if leftists abandon a left-wing policy, rightists will lose interest in the issue. I wouldn't expect this to work in the short-run due to inertia, but over a 20-year span, it makes sense to me. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
It is true that Europe is getting hotter due to climate change.
Yet the lesson is that all the issues of climate change are pretty trivial to deal with when you have economic growth and take a pro-human perspective.
That’s why the world gets warmer, but fewer people die of climate catastrophes. The weather is just not that important. It’s our level of wealth and willingness to use it that matters.
Europeans just chose not to believe in science and technology, and this is the result.
It’s funny that we used to worry about the effects of climate change in the developing world. But as long as they don’t adopt Western-style environmentalism, they’ll be fine. It’s Europe we should be worrying about. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Timeless.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Europe explained for Americans."
Pretty good. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Want to do more to help "the losers" of international trade?
Ponder this: Housing regulation obsessively worries about "the losers" of development.
That's the heart of NIMBY, and it's been a disaster.
Seriously, the more policymakers ignore "losers," the better. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Google Images for "data center protests" are out of this world.
What kooks!
www.google.com/search?num=10&udm=2&q=data+center+protests -
Bryan Caplan reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
"The students were my favorite part of UATX. Anyone who meets the students would want their own children to attend UATX." — @KlingBlog on his time as a Visiting Professor
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Rewarding good teachers sounds a lot nicer than firing bad teachers. So when research comes along that potentially recommends both, pundits and politicians don’t coolly crunch the numbers."
www.betonit.ai/p/value-added_andhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The policy that dramatically passes the cost-benefit test is 'deselection,' better known as firing bad teachers."
www.betonit.ai/p/value-added_andhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
ChatGPT has done something that no human has ever done: Gone from self-righteous wokester to can-do rationalist in four short years.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Just found out about this:
www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/2021-01/efw-2019-chapte… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
You think the Civil Rights Act was bad?
Let me introduce you to the Americans with Disabilities Act.
And something that's even worse: The Americans with Disabilities Act Amendments Act of 2008.
I explore the horrors of this law here. www.richardhanania.com/p/how-federal-law-made-us-all-disa… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
UAE has the worst weather I've ever experienced, but also the best air conditioning I've ever experienced.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I bet an Islamic Europe would have air conditioning. Would save a lot more lives than would be lost with extra crime.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Harford goes over some compelling evidence that black-on-black social sanctions for 'acting white' are real. But then, he argues that what seems like pointless cruelty is only 'rational,' but also 'turns out to emerge from Von-Neumann mathematics.'"
www.betonit.ai/p/ostracism_for_ahtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"This sounds great until you realize that there are plenty of cultures that don’t work this way! Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe were part of the working class, but almost all of the social pressure was to do well in school and make a better life." www.betonit.ai/p/ostracism_for_ahtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Classic.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Critics have decried @uaustinorg as hypocritical, politicized, and otherwise terrible. After 3.5 weeks, I have no idea what they’re talking about. Or to be more precise, the critics have impossibly high (double) standards and are hungry to find fault." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-uatx
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"UATX students often openly asked, “How can we make UATX better?” A great question… that few normal college students would bother to pose, because they’re both incurious and resigned." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-uatx
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"UATX students skip classes not because they’re lazy, but because they literally have something better to do. One student was busy running a start-up. Other students were rehearsing for Hamlet. Good for them!"
www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-uatx -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The students at @uaustinorg are academically fantastic, a great package of high IQ, sky-high curiosity, and intellectual engagement. The only school I’ve taught at that’s in the same league is @UChicago, especially @AgnesCallard's Night Owls program." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-uatx
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I'd see it as a failure if there were many people working long after I died trying to interpret what I'd said. Sure, being clear makes it more likely that the world will forget you, as they assimilate what you say into their views. But that seems more like success to me.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
No, lots of individualism and little government.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Nations can't survive wars without patriotism. So to say patriotism is problematic is to say that nations are. But what alternative would they propose? World govt?
www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/06/01/how-problematic-is-… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I've been predicting the end of the payroll tax cap for decades, though I doubt it will happen until there's a big fiscal crisis.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
People wonder why I have stopped identifying with the right and gone toward anti-populism.
Because of this! The populists on both sides are trying to make us into a socialist gerontocracy.
Don’t care about party ID. If you’re not for cutting entitlements, you’re the problem. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
No one else seems to be quoting this line from *Marty Supreme*, but it's already a go-to spoilsport joke in my family.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
My friend Hrish Joshi has joined Substack.
His first piece is very good!
desertphilosophy.substack.com -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Guive Assadi
@GuiveAssadi
Another artifact of the same period is the “first world problems” meme, where Americans would make fun of themselves for complaining about trivial things. That would probably be less popular now, which seems like a change for the worse.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I recently rewatched Kony 2012.
It's a fascinating cultural artifact, and I explain why it wouldn't make a splash today.
Americans now feel too sorry for themselves to worry about the struggles of child soldiers. Both the right and left have adopted victimhood culture. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
James Pethokoukis ⏩️⤴️
@JimPethokoukis
Which non-obvious people should I podcast with about AI, space, energy, future medicine, pro-progress economics? Include their X/Twitter handle if possible.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What I said about white nationalism back in 2013. www.betonit.ai/p/how_bad_is_whithtml
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
A new article explains my view that the problem with right-wingers taking the "red pill" is that most aspects of the red pill are wrong.
Yes, some humans provide a lot more value to the world than others. But aspects of the red pill that are wrong include
-Democracy is worse than the alternatives
-Whites are the only ones capable of free speech or individual liberty
-Mass migration means impoverishment and permanent liberal majorities
It also refuses to take the "red pill" on right-wing populism itself, which is that it is a movement of morons, losers, and haters, with lower intellectual and moral standards than the liberals it criticizes. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
A new article explains my view that the problem with right-wingers taking the "red pill" is that most aspects of the red pill are wrong.
Yes, some humans provide a lot more value to the world than others. But aspects of the red pill that are wrong include
-Democracy is worse than the alternatives
-Whites are the only ones capable of free speech or individual liberty
-Mass migration means impoverishment and permanent liberal majorities
It also refuses to take the "red pill" on right-wing populism itself, which is that it is a movement of morons, losers, and haters, with lower intellectual and moral standards than the liberals it criticizes. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If Trump were a Democrat, both Republicans and independents would consider his Iran war to be the most humiliating U.S. defeat since the Vietnam War.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Cuba today:
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"*The Case Against Education* in contrast, argues that the education industry is more like government-sponsored football stadiums: Government support is good for the industry, but bad for society." www.betonit.ai/p/the_case_agains_16html
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Marian L Tupy
@Marian_L_Tupy
By analyzing 49 cases of sustained economic liberalization since 1970, @VincentGeloso found that while GDP per capita increased by 16% within a decade, environmental outcomes did not worsen. Air pollution death rates modestly declined, and total greenhouse gas emissions remained stable. This occurs because economic freedom lowers and hastens the peak of the Environmental Kuznets Curve.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
To add to Trevor, Canadian agencies like StatCan have generally been far better at dealing with CPI bias such as outlet substitution, goods substitution, quality gradient substitution, brick-mortar-to-online subsitution, etc.
I remember a paper showing that US CPI bias between 0.6 percentage points and 1.1 percentage points compared to Canada's 0.5 to 0.6. These were roughly 2010-numbers so I dont know if the gap changed since, but if it didnt, Trevor is not only correct, he is doubly-correct.
Trevor Tombe
@trevortombe
Why is Canada’s inflation rate so much lower than the U.S.?
It’s not because our prices are rising more slowly. My latest for @TheHubCanada explains: thehub.ca/2026/06/19/canadas-inflation-situation-looks-be… #cdnecon #cdnpoli -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
I add this old graph of mine showing that despite rapid growth, the recovery was not even close to completed by 1939. This contrasts with the 1921 recession which was deep but things had returned to full potential by 1923.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
US real GDP did increase substantially between ‘33 and ‘37. But the progress of _recovery_ was far less impressive, because _potential_ real GDP also grew rapidly; true recovery meant closing the actual-potential real GDP gap. Until WWII, the US never got close to doing so.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
(Our critics, on the other hand, insist that freedom in banking would force banks to maintain reserves amounting to close to 100% of their demand liabilities--a conclusion consistent with exactly _zero_ historical cases!)
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
For Americans, the best case for learning a foreign language is to find a foreign spouse who far outshines your domestic options.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Michael Munger 🏖️🔪👨🍳
@mungowitz
We teach it poorly in grade school--of course, we teach EVERYTHING poorly in grade school, but especially with languages.
People used to learn a second language at a young age. It is then easier to learn more, after two.
But trying to learn a second language at 20 is tough.
Jennifer A. Frey
@jennfrey
I've been thinking about why no one wants to study languages anymore and have yet to come up with an account that is remotely satisfying. Who has written about this?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Andrew Branca Show
@TheBrancaShow
Americans are routinely compelled to "learn" a second language (usually poorly) in school, and then we never use it again. A huge waste of three years of class time.
In a nation the size of the US, and with English effectively the world's second language, there's really no point for almost any American in wasting the effort to learn a second language. Learn a useful skill, instead.
I worked in the Netherlands for two years, considered learning Dutch, and all the Dutch told me not to bother--"We all speak English." And, indeed, they all did. Perfectly. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
🧵While Hoover-era interventions, including the Smoot-Hawley tariff, helped drive the U.S. economy deeper into depression between 1929 and 1933, other factors, including Great Britain's September 1931 decision to abandon the gold standard, were no less important.
Commentary - Sowell Economics
@sowelleconomics
Thomas Sowell: "The Great Depression was caused by government interference in the economy.
The stock market crashed in October 1929. Unemployment hit 9% and was already declining by mid-1930. Then the government "helped" with the Smoot-Hawley tariff in June 1930 — despite 1,000+ economists begging them not to.
Unemployment shot to double digits and peaked at 25%. It stayed there for the rest of the decade.
Government intervention turned a recession into the Great Depression." -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Cato Institute
@CatoInstitute
Talent and hard work are essential to advancing liberty. The Cato Innovation Project offers a unique opportunity: you design and propose your own full-time role to promote the principles of individual liberty, free markets, and limited government—and Cato provides the funding.
Applications open now: www.cato.org/innovation -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I did a @CatoInstitute summer seminar in 1990 and it was great for me. Maybe you, too!
go.cato.org/webmail/1067542/1523482403/384662dc1057cf2997… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Fabricio Nakata
@FabricioNakata
As someone in the sparsely populated low-regulation/high-redistribution quadrant, basically no one knows what to do with us or where to place us on the left-right spectrum.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Societal trends can have legal explanations.
Young people increasingly identify as disabled.
Why?
Let me introduce you to the ADA Amendments Act of 2008.
It declared anyone could be disabled, and made it impossible for institutions to be skeptical. www.richardhanania.com/p/how-federal-law-made-us-all-disa… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Very many young Americans are so undersocialized in their religious faith (before college begins) that they would have difficulty recognizing faith-challenging material when it appears." www.betonit.ai/p/education_and_a_1html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Actually-existing paternalism isn't just protecting fools from themselves.
It's treating everyone like fools.
Michael Tracey
@mtracey
I can easily imagine being 15 again and finding this hugely obnoxious. I'd resent being babied by the state on the theory that a minority of my peers can't handle social media for whatever reason, so now *I* must be barred from using my preferred app to banter about video games?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
BREAKING
Rob Henderson will be joining my NYC meet up tonight.
And since we’re near capacity, the price has been raised to $25 to deal with the problem of scarcity. You can sign up here. luma.com/wg1lcvnf -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"How can I possibly improve my students’ ability to do a vast array of jobs that I don’t know how to do myself? It would be nothing short of magic. I’d have to be Merlin, Gandalf, or Dumbledore to complete the ritual."
www.betonit.ai/p/the_magic_of_edhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Considering how studiously I’ve ignored the Real World, you might think that the Real World would return the favor by ignoring me. But it doesn’t!" www.betonit.ai/p/the_magic_of_edhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Only heard Dwark's story after everything had worked out for him. So glad you're here, buddy!
Dwarkesh Patel
@dwarkesh_sp
My family moved to the US when I was 8, but by the time I turned 20, my dad was still on an H1B (waiting to get processed for a green card).
Once I turned 21, I would age out as his dependent, despite the fact that I basically grew up in the US.
I thought I'd have to become a code monkey after college, and even that only if I was lucky enough to win the H1B lottery.
Otherwise, back to India.
I had become a huge fan of @paulg's essays in college. I was actually depressed that my desire to start a startup or do something entrepreneurial was basically hopeless.
Working on the promising podcast I was doing as a side project? A beyond impossible pipe dream.
Even after 9 years, my dad wasn't able to get a green card - and the lines were only getting longer over time. I figured I'd be an old man before I could quit some FANG job and build my own thing.
By some miracle, COVID travel restrictions cleared out the lines, and I got my green card literally months before I would have aged out.
If not for this unbelievable coincidence, I would not be hosting the podcast.
In the best case, I would be shifting pixels around in the 3rd sub-sub-menu of some big tech software.
I'm incredibly grateful I made it through.
But it's unconscionable that we put the kids of high skilled immigrants through all this anxiety, and in many cases make them repeat the nerve-racking indentured life trajectory that they had to watch their parents go through. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
The Alex Nowrasteh
@AlexNowrasteh
Read the piece that upset him: www.alexnowrasteh.com/p/immigrants-keep-the-united-states
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
The Alex Nowrasteh
@AlexNowrasteh
VP @JDVance doesn’t like my work on labor unions, immigration, and American liberty.
From his new book: -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Zach Weinersmith
@ZachWeiner
New book day. Thanks for reading! www.smbc-comics.com/comic/sawyer
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
SMBC Comics
@SMBCComics
Here are all the book signing events of this summer for Sawyer Lee and the Quest to Just Stay Home!
Learn more about the book ◆ us.macmillan.com/books/9780374393496/sawyerleeandthequest…
Bookmark the signing information ◆ www.smbc-comics.com/comic/upcoming-book-signings -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ryan Kurt
@bulldoggamer28
I just finished that book yesterday. I was planning on have 6 kids before reading it and still planning on it afterwards
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ario
@Ario1977
Excepting suicide, the most serious decision in life should be to have a child; however, not to have a child, if one is capable of having children, should perhaps be an even more serious decision.
—Thomas Szasz, The Untamed Tongue -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I asked ChatGPT to figure out what Germany would have scored on the @FraserInstitute's Economic Freedom of the World metric.
Big result: If Nazi Germany really was extremely socialist.
chatgpt.com/s/t_6a3300c4c4588191bb1fac7343b321c9 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yep.
John McWhorter
@JohnHMcWhorter
Yep
How I Write Clips
@PerellClips
Academics write for each other, not for people.
Steven Pinker has spent over four decades doing the opposite, and thinks current academic writing is "enormous wasted effort."
"There's an awful lot of brilliant work, really smart people in academia. Why are they doing it? Just to entertain each other? Taxpayers pay for it. It should be accessible. Why should I have to read a paragraph five or six times?
It gets under my skin when academics devote so much brainpower into the scholarship and then just blow off the essential task of letting the world know what you've done."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Greaney's critique of Hsieh-Moretti made it into AEJ: Macro. pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdf/10.1257/mac.20230141
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
During your childhood, was your dad more (a) cheerful and friendly, or (b) angry and mean?
Be very candid. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Wow, it's an honor to be of service, Kevin!
kevin simler
@kevinsimler
i read this book over a decade ago
been a dad for 2.5 years now
it’s the framework that i rely on the most for guiding my behavior as a parent
v grateful to @bryan_caplan for writing it -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Tetlock uber alles. @PTetlock
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Mancur Olson
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why didn't Trump follow through on his threat to bomb Iran's civilian infrastructure until it unconditionally surrendered?
(a) International pressure not to escalate further
(b) Trump wasn't evil enough
(c) Iran unofficially surrendered
(d) Trump realized Iran wouldn't surrender -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Yes, the man in the street often says he’s rather die than yield an inch to the hated enemy. But the vast majority are happy to free ride."
www.betonit.ai/p/a_nation_of_cowhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you violently object to anything I say, please remain my friend anyway.
I value your friendship and hope to change your mind one day. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Meetup in NYC this Thursday at 5:30. Small charge to cover venue. Reserve your spot here. luma.com/wg1lcvnf
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Video from my @uaustinorg immigration debate versus @GarettJones. www.betonit.ai/p/caplan-jones-uatx-debate-video
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
ageofem.com was published 10 years ago this month.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"This is what enables most to endorse governmental behavior that would otherwise appear to violate individual rights: non-libertarians assume that most of the moral constraints that apply to other agents do not apply to the state."
www.betonit.ai/p/huemers-common-sense-libertarianism -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Unlike almost every other political philosopher, Huemer doesn’t waste your time. He doesn’t try to convince you of seven odd claims, then try to convince you that those seven odd claims somehow imply his conclusion." www.betonit.ai/p/huemers-common-sense-libertarianism
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
One of the nice things about meeting a bunch of real people over the last week is seeing how much more reasonable they are than the median social media personality I see.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Humanity has been lucky so far, knock on wood.
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
Some of the smartest people of the day - Bertrand Russell and John von Neumann - were much too pessimistic about the risks of a nuclear war in the late 40s and early 50s
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Mencken via Donald J. Boudreaux: "If the young are to be instructed at all, it seems to me that they ought to be instructed in the high human value of this toleration. They should be taught what they learn by experience in the school yard: that human beings differ enormously, one from the other, and that it is stupid and imprudent for A to try to change B. They should be taught that mutual confidence and good will are worth all the laws ever heard of, ghostly or secular, and that one man who minds his own business is more valuable to the world than 10,000 cocksure moralists."
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Note that Garrett Jones, who is often cited as an authority by immigration restrictionists, wants massive high skill immigration.
People can debate low skill immigration. But on things like H1Bs there’s no reasonable debate to be had. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It's another scarcity of abundance.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
This is a deeply frustrating conversation.
Samuel Moyn wrote a book about gerontocracy. Derek Thompson interviews him, and opens by telling us that 50% of the federal budget is shoveling money to old people.
Yet across the entire conversation, neither the host nor guest advocates cutting Social Security and Medicare. They talk about politicians and professors being too old. Ok, but 99% of people will never be Senators or professors. They also focus on issues that indirectly favor the old over the young like NIMBY.
But they never go: "You know how half our federal government is about shoveling money from young people, who have less of it, to old people, who have more of it? Maybe we shouldn't do that!"
In fact, Moyn says the opposite! Give old people more money, and then they'll have less political power.
Let's walk through the logic here:
1) Old people use political power to rig the economy in their favor
2) Let's just give them all the money in the hopes they'll stop doing that.
I'm amazed by this. The most direct way government can advantage group X over group Y is to take money from Y and give it to X. Everything else is much less efficient in terms of adjusting people's material conditions.
So Moyn is advocating continuing to give direct transfers to old people, even increasing those transfers, in the hope that the political system will lead to policies that indirectly help young people.
By way of analogy, imagine you're worried about someone robbing you. So your plan is "I'll give him all my money. Then, there's a chance he might stop harassing me and do something that indirectly benefits me in the long run."
This is not serious analysis. It's a desperate cope from someone who sees that we've become a gerontocracy and refuses to believe that the entitlement programs he likes are the main causes of it.
Entitlements are headed toward a crisis, and we're going to have to make a decision soon about whether or not the federal government should exist mostly to make old people wealthier, crowding out everything else.
There is no serious approach to tackling gerontocracy without pushing entitlement reform. Yes, it's politically difficult, but what's even the point if we're going to cower in fear from the actual issues facing the country? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
They're the same issue.
If you make college harder, fewer people will go and fewer still will finish.
If you make it hard in absolute terms, far fewer will go, and almost no one will finish. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
My one dinner with Szasz was a highlight of my life. The sharpest octogenarian I ever met. I miss him!
Jack Straw
@JackStr42679640
The most dangerous 77 seconds ever recorded by a psychiatrist just broke containment again.
Thomas Szasz, the man the entire profession tried to erase, looked straight into the camera and said:
“We do not have an epidemic of mental illness.
We have an epidemic of psychiatry.”
Too fat → illness
Too thin → illness
Too happy, too sad, too much sex, too little sex → all illnesses
No free will, no responsibility left — only “chemical imbalances” fixed by products you can advertise on TV while alcohol cannot.
This forgotten 1:17 clip is now exploding across every timeline for a reason.
Jacob -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Hosted on SportsPredict — a third-party sports prediction platform — the contest will score participants using a weighted Brier score, a methodology used in professional probability research."
www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/jump-trading-turns-world-cu… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What my friend Steve Kuhn is up to now. www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/jump-trading-turns-world-cu…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If US growth has been so good for the last 50 years, why are voters so angry?"
"Maybe because thinkers like you have spent the last 50 years telling them that growth was bad and they should be angry?" -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Impressed to see a "free-trade critic" calling for lots more high-skilled immigration. www.bostonreview.net/forum/dean-baker-globalization-forum/ @DeanBaker13
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Helen Andrews on having a profoundly disabled sibling. She tells the truth about what it's like:
Sometimes, focusing on the positive becomes a way of denying reality. Yes, there were joyous moments. But changing diapers gets a lot harder after 18 years, when the person weighs as much as you do. My sister threw tantrums and acted out. My parents couldn’t leave her alone in the house even to run to the store. It was like the most labor-intensive parts of infant care extended for years with no end in sight.
Hardest of all, the object of all this sacrifice couldn’t give anything back.
Andrews goes on to point out that some parents who take care of these children are narcissists, and it's all about themselves.
I was expecting the article to end up making the case for abortion in these situations. Instead, she decides that the Christian position is that it's ok because in heaven, the handicapped will still be disabled but "the transformation would be in the rest of us."
I have no idea what this means. So in heaven, they will still not be able to take care of themselves, but it's ok because you'll have angels as nannies so you don't have to change diapers? Or healthy people will continue to act as caregivers but will do it with a smile?
What a bizarre op-ed, combining brutally honest and courageous reflections, and ending with bizarre half-baked theological speculations that are simply invented to avoid the obvious conclusion. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Here's an incredible stat: you could pay to lift all seniors out of poverty with only 3% of the budget for Social Security.
This program is going to destroy the prospects of future generations because we're shoveling endless amounts of money to old people who don't need it. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"We’ve finished the chapter-by-chapter *For a New Liberty*. Now I’ll wrap things up by answering most or all of your questions about the book. Please limit yourself to questions, not statements, phrase them succinctly, and avoid compound questions." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-e4e
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Also pretty good: persistentruminator.substack.com/p/a-history-of-western-e…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Karl Meisenbach
@NoGodsforKids
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
"Degrowth Economics" is the exact type of policy regime that will lead to poverty, famine, malnutrition, disease, and an immiserating decline in worldwide living standards.
You know. All the stuff that the Degrowthers try to blame on capitalism and "neoliberalism." -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Ayn Rand's Floyd Ferris, in the book-within-a-book *Why Do You Think You Think?*
“Thought is a primitive superstition. Reason is an irrational idea. The childish notion that we are able to think has been mankinds costliest error. What you think is an illusion created by your glands, your emotions, and, in the last analysis, the contents of your stomach.” -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Medicalizing bad decisions is at best a Noble Lie. But once you realize that most people who make bad decisions course-correct, the lie looks ignoble indeed. Why deprive everyone of their freedom to marginally help a tiny self-destructive minority?" www.betonit.ai/p/aging-out-of-drug-addiction-is-the
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
All the main problems with that famous paper: www.betonit.ai/p/trust_and_diverhtml
Alexander Kustov
@akoustov
Yeah, it's pretty crazy. It was a non-peer-reviewed invited lecture, which he used to finally publish findings he'd had from a few years before. Now it's his 4th most cited paper and perhaps the most cited paper in diversity research, and he never opinion on the issue ever since.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Imagine a world where both parties limited themselves to ending the other party's stupidest policies.
In practice, the main reason they point out the other side's stupidest policies is to distract people while they impose incredibly stupid policies of their own. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Well-said.
Alexander Kustov
@akoustov
The thread is right about the phenomenon: many scholars describe their own work as activism, and universities have built hiring pipelines around it. But a lot of folks also still seem confused about the difference between activism and public engagement.
One decides its conclusions before the research starts. The other invites challenge, and challenge is what separates inquiry from advocacy. Confusing the two is costly in both directions: activist work gets to borrow the credibility of science, and honest public engagement gets dismissed as activism.
Social scientists do not have to choose between the ivory tower and activism. There is a third way, what political scientist @cdsamii calls the "problem-solving" approach: commit to a clearly defined societal problem, stay open about the answers, and figure out what needs fixing, why, and what actually works. Take sides on the problem, not on the politics. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
When economists were asked if Americans would be better off with more low skilled immigrants being allowed to legally enter the country, they said yes by a 6-1 ratio. On skilled immigration, it was 100%. But chuds disagree, they have their own indigenous ways of knowing.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Above all, I dream of a world where all participants are mindful that individual exceptions to statistical rules are ubiquitous. The hashtag #notallx is never far from the thoughts of any intellectually honest person." www.betonit.ai/p/when-it-really-is-racist-to-talk
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"But if you decide to raise the same topic at a mixed-race wedding, your motive is clearly to humiliate and antagonize. It’s like loudly speculating about the couple’s probability of divorce." www.betonit.ai/p/when-it-really-is-racist-to-talk
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If a low-IQ student is failing a class, you can regretfully but candidly tell him, 'You’re never going to become a mathematician or a scientist.' Or you can gloat, 'You, a scientist?! But you’re a freakin’ moron!' The same goes for racial differences."
www.betonit.ai/p/when-it-really-is-racist-to-talk -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"True, simply believing in racial differences — even large genetic racial differences — is never racist. Expressing these views, however, often is a strong symptom of racism." www.betonit.ai/p/when-it-really-is-racist-to-talk
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If your literally false statement is beautiful, you can claim poetic license.
If your literally false statement is hilarious, you can claim comedic license.
Otherwise, speak literal truth or be silent. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
To encourage rampant lying, dilute the strong presumption that EVERY assertion claims LITERAL truth.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This suggests many intriguing bets.
Michael Tracey
@mtracey
Trolls have demanded to investigate my browser history and/or hard drive for almost a year now, and have yet to find anything, despite repeated offers by me to come over and inspect. Maybe it's just my genuine view that unrestrained Pedo Panic is a nightmare for civil liberties?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good. www.aporiamagazine.com/p/the-five-stages-of-western-ferti…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"What should be done about illegal immigration? Simple: We should make it legal. A massive apology would also be nice, but I don’t ask for miracles." www.betonit.ai/p/immigration-laws-are-made-to-be-broken
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you think it’s OK to break a law against driving 56 mph in the desert, you should think that it’s OK to break a law against mowing grass for money." www.betonit.ai/p/immigration-laws-are-made-to-be-broken
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I know that many people reply, 'The law is the law.' This is a bizarre position for libertarians, who routinely cheer scofflaws — and are often scofflaws themselves. But 'Always follow the law' is a bizarre position from almost any point of view."
www.betonit.ai/p/immigration-laws-are-made-to-be-broken -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While I’ve done many debates on immigration, this is the first time that you can figure out the correct side without knowing anything about immigration." www.betonit.ai/p/immigration-laws-are-made-to-be-broken
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
College standards have been falling for many decades, though much less in STEM.
Preston Cooper
@PrestonCooper93
Don’t worry we’ll just lower standards in college the way we lowered standards in high school. Everyone will be highly credentialed and learn nothing.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
My friend Daniel Yu has a start-up to help African guest workers and more. africajobsfund.substack.com/p/the-case-for-international-…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Better yet, don't regulate at all and tell complainers to prove concrete harm in court.
Yes, courts are slow and proving harm is hard. But given humanity's propensity to childish complaining, the dysfunctional judiciary is a feature, not a bug.
Chris Anderson (in London)
@chr1sa
"HIPAA was a mistake". Yes, and this is true for almost all of the "precautionary principle" regulations, from GMO restrictions in Europe to AI regulations across US states.
Rather than imagining all the things that might go wrong and seeking to prevent them, let the marketplace work and if and when things actually do go wrong, regulate *then* based on real-world harms not fantasies.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I wrote about the insanity of "medical privacy."
It's hard now to do research that could cure major diseases because we are too worried about the handling of people's personal data, which they themselves appear not to care about.
HIPAA was a mistake. www.richardhanania.com/p/privacy-versus-progress-in-medicine -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why didn't Trump try a lot harder to pass his anti-immigration polices through Congress?
(a) Couldn't get a House majority
(b) Couldn't get 60 votes in the Senate -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Huemer’s book will be highly persuasive to any reasonable human, including reasonable humans who initially disagree with his thesis. That’s the maximum that an intellectually honest thinker can accomplish on a controversial topic." www.betonit.ai/p/maximum-progress-on-progressivism
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
In all candor, what are the least-objectionable laws you knowingly break?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It's the Law of Conservation of Silly Purity Norms.
Love is love! -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Scott yes, but me not so much; see @allTheYud, @Aella_Girl, @TheZvi, @gwern
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
In all candor, what are the least-objectionable laws you knowingly break?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why self-reported gender differences are probably grossly understated: www.betonit.ai/p/why-self-reports-understate-gender
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"sex differences in our species are real but relatively modest. This gives us elbow room to exaggerate the differences or minimize them, depending on personal taste. Both errors are the root of many evils" swiftpress.com/book/a-billion-years-of-sex-differences/
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I have talked with Phil in-person several times. He is both calm and earnest. You should trust him.
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
Here's something many people don't know about me -
Before I publicly dissected the long list of problems in the 1619 Project, I contacted the New York Times through their official channels to request a series of corrections to unambiguous factual errors in its content. The editor - Jake Silverstein - brushed me off and refused any correction - a pattern he also exhibited toward other critics from across the spectrum.
Before I publicly broke the story about Kevin Kruse's plagiarism in Reason, I contacted Princeton's academic integrity officer and alerted him to the problems I had found, giving them a chance to respond and address it internally. They ignored my email and later claimed to have lost my email after I went public.
Before I published my findings on Quinn Slobodian's habitual manipulation of source materials to alter its plain meaning through misquotation, I submitted an article to Contemporary European History (the journal where the worst examples appeared), highlighting the problems with the passages and asking for a correction through their official process. They desk-rejected it, brushed me off, and falsely claimed that Slobodian's piece had been thoroughly vetted in peer review. In fact, one of their own referees had flagged the same problems over a year earlier and recommended rejection of the article.
Before I published an expose on Nancy MacLean & Sandy Darity's similar manipulation of W.H. Hutt quotations in their article for History of Economics Review, I (along with 2 coauthors) submitted a response comment to this journal asking for a correction through its official processes. The editor gave us a complete runaround where he imposed an arbitrary length limit requiring us to cut the content, sent the trimmed version to a referee, then rejected the piece because the referee said we didn't sufficiently address the very same things we were forced by the editor to cut. When I then asked the editor to issue a simple corrigendum to the most egregious misquotation (one that transformed Hutt's explicit attack on the racism of white Afrikaners into a defense of Apartheid), he refused and tried to pass it off as a difference of "interpretation."
Before I published an expose of a leading covid masking model in the Wall Street Journal, I sent a comment to the medical journal that published it alerting them to a math error that changed their entire set of results. The journal acknowledged the error was real but refused to publish my piece on the grounds that the "next release" of the model would be updated to reflect it - even as politicians up to and including Joe Biden were trumpeting the erroneous results all over the news. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Wait, aren't the most respected people in this community Scott Alexander and YOU?
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I notice that in the "rationalist" community, the most respected people do in fact tend to be those who could most give an inspiring speech to troops before a battle. Much more so than in academia. Is that a sign of their "rationality"?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is why @GeorgeMasonU Econ has so much more real-world influence than academic influence.
How I Write Clips
@PerellClips
Academics write for each other, not for people.
Steven Pinker has spent over four decades doing the opposite, and thinks current academic writing is "enormous wasted effort."
"There's an awful lot of brilliant work, really smart people in academia. Why are they doing it? Just to entertain each other? Taxpayers pay for it. It should be accessible. Why should I have to read a paragraph five or six times?
It gets under my skin when academics devote so much brainpower into the scholarship and then just blow off the essential task of letting the world know what you've done."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Harsh reality: Even top left-wing economists aren't "abundance-pilled."
Even now, they're far more excited about getting more redistribution and regulation.
The challenge: If you can't win over left-wing economists, what hope do you have with left-wing normies? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While you’re not an average human, your first-hand experience almost certainty tells you that racism is rare, serious crime is ultra-rare, that terrorism is basically non-existent, and that the vast majority of people in rich countries are materially prosperous. The media are in no position to 'correct' you – or anyone, really."
www.betonit.ai/p/first-hand-experience-is-less-biased-tha… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When you see moonshine marked 'XXX,' this means that the liquid has been filtered three times. Each filtration raises the alcohol content. This is a fine metaphor for the media." www.betonit.ai/p/first-hand-experience-is-less-biased-tha…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
AI question from 2019.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
It doesn’t follow from the fact that a lot of research is politicized that it’s politicized to the same extent. A quick heuristic to use to judge this is the frequency with which journals in a field publish pieces with political views that dissent from the mainstream.
Zachary Levenson
@grundrza
“Politicized research is the problem,” politicized administrator tells the Manhattan Institute
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why didn't Trump try a lot harder to pass his anti-immigration polices through Congress?
(a) Couldn't get a House majority
(b) Couldn't get 60 votes in the Senate -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Happening right now in Washington Square Park.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Meet-up today in NY's Little Italy at Da Nico at 2 PM. RSVP here: www.betonit.ai/p/caplan-jones-immigration-debate-rematch
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The @uaustinorg *Hamlet* was decidedly traditional.
But you're tired of modernist retellings of *Hamlet*, see *The Northman* for a first-rate medievalist retelling.
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Some more highlights from UATX Theater Society’s first production.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hamlet is a great character but definitely an anti-hero. Great at using his self-pity to win sympathy despite his many evil deeds.
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Some more highlights from UATX Theater Society’s first production.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I saw Ian McKellan do Hamlet, but I think I enjoyed this production more.
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Freshman London Sowers on how she directed Hamlet — UATX’s first theatrical production.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yes, and welcoming immigrants (like my brother Carlos) is central to the American experiment.
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
"Being protective of the American experiment is being protective of humanity." — UATX President Carlos Carvalho
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
What immigration policies best serve America? @GarettJones and @bryan_caplan joined us for a debate. Moderated by @coldxman.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This was a great and memorable production. I don't love the whole canon, but I do love Shakespeare.
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Some more highlights from UATX Theater Society’s first production.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even a woke clock is right twice a day, and I’m grateful that woke activists have loudly pushed back against recent anti-immigration policies." www.betonit.ai/p/my-opening-statement-for-the-uatx
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Peter Boghossian
@peterboghossian
High school students: @uaustinorg is hosting a free High School Honors program in NYC!
Engage in seminars on the American experiment, high-stakes decision-making, & transhumanism with UATX professors and peers.
April 18-19, 2026. Apply by April 10.
sites.google.com/uaustin.org/uatxhighschoolhonorsnyc/home -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Here's good evidence that wokeness comes from law.
Before the 1978 Bakke decision, newspapers and court decisions basically never mentioned the benefits of diversity in higher education.
After Bakke, it was everywhere.
The concept was invented to justify a court decision. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Monica Snyder's summary of our abortion convo. open.substack.com/pub/secularprolife/p/podcast-recap-disc…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"To the best of my knowledge, you have offered no reason why the U.S. should not have open borders for anyone above its current average IQ of 98." www.betonit.ai/p/garett-jones-on-open-borders-a-belated-r…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
I documented the sharp leftward shift in academia several years ago, along with its accompanying decline in research standards. The Vanderbilt report is welcome, but it's also simply confirmation of what was already obvious (although adamantly denied by many faculty on the left)
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Ben Shapiro (@benshapiro)
Jeff Yass
Rob Henderson (@robkhenderson)
Zuby (@ZubyMusic)
Niall Ferguson (@nfergus)
Jim Meigs (@jamesbmeigs)
Chase Koch
Brendan Boyle
Arif Panju (@ArifPanju)
Joe Lonsdale (@JTLonsdale)
Ken Hersh
Brent Bellm
Brittany and Gabriel Hugoboom (@BritHugoboom)
Daniel Di Martino (@DanielDiMartino)
David Booth
Charles Fain Lehman (@CharlesFLehman)
David Rose (@DCRose1776)
Henry Oliver
Judge Roy Altman (@RoyKAltman)
Jim Gash
Scott Jennings (@ScottJenningsKY)
Tony Abbott (@HonTonyAbbott)
Michael Pakaluk (@MichaelPakaluk)
Elise Stefanik (@EliseStefanik)
Bert “Tito” Beveridge
Garett Jones (@GarettJones)
Visiting spring faculty:
Bryan Caplan (@bryan_caplan)
Jerrod Ankenman (@hgfalling)
Andy Aymeloglu
Coleman Hughes (@coldxman)
Yaron Brook (@yaronbrook)
Daniel Samet (@DanielJSamet)
Robert Wright (@robertewright)
Dennis Wilkinson
Evan Young (@E_A_Young)
Andrew Oldham
Thanks to everyone for joining us this spring. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
I’m sorry but the claim that philosophy’s problems with politically motivated deterioration of standards are “largely confined to a single subfield focused on a charged topic” is a howler. It’s a massive problem across the whole profession.
John Sailer
@JohnDSailer
Per the report, only a subfield of philosophy shows this ideological distortion, it's more common in history, and it's a huge problem for anthropology.
It's account of anthropology is pretty scathing ("widespread deterioration of scholarly standards") ⬇️ -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"In other news, Rothbard’s argument for the imminent triumph of libertarianism is far weaker than it appears. Yes, Communism collapsed — but the collapse was political, not economic. "
www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-e4e -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you read Raimondo’s sympathetic biography of Rothbard, you see an endless series of failed alliances and broken friendships. If that doesn’t convince you that the strategic 'insights' of the Marxists aren’t worth learning, I don’t know what will." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-e4e
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Joshua Gans
@joshgans
Currently testing agree to disagree as a mechanism by pitting Claude and ChatGPT against one another and asking them to update based on messages.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'd kind of like every byline to include the writer's personality type, ideally Five Factor Model. For future reference, I'm average Openness, high Conscientiousness, high Extraversion, low Agreeableness, and low Neuroticism.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I would agree that virtually all Wagner operas, except perhaps Das Rheingold, are too long and thus have an element of tedium."
Maybe my biggest disagreement with @tylercowen! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Academic life and projects will continue, but the real rewards will go to people doing new, innovative, and hitherto impossible projects with AI."
Or maybe just to scholars with charisma and connections. @tylercowen -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Translation: immigrants are driving the American economy through their entrepreneurship, but we're not even selecting for entrepreneurship."
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
A new report on billion-dollar companies shows that a full two-thirds are founded by immigrants or the children of immigrants.
Here's the most amazing part: "There is generally no reliable way under U.S. immigration law for foreign nationals to start a business and remain in the country after founding a company. Successful immigrant entrepreneurs in America are almost always refugees or family-sponsored and employer-sponsored immigrants."
Translation: immigrants are driving the American economy through their entrepreneurship, but we're not even selecting for entrepreneurship.
Immigration is so beneficial to the country that just by accident we're getting a system that is producing an endless list of billion dollar companies.
Imagine if we selected for entrepreneurship! There's so much to be gained here.
Instead, we have idiots attacking H1B visas, which are one of the more meritocratic parts of the system, despite its flaws. Even a flawed immigration system is much better than not welcoming people in, because immigration is just that beneficial. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even $600 is a rounding error compared to the earnings a janitor makes in Japan versus the Philippines, no?"
"Totally a rounding error. My wife is from the Philippines and I’ve lived there for 2 years a couple of time."
www.betonit.ai/p/guest-work-in-japan-some-inside-info -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"My wife went to nurse assistant school in the Philippines with 3 lady friends. Her friends work hard 10-12 hour shifts and make about 450 pesos per day, that would be about $7 for a long hard day as a nurse assistant. When my wife got here I emailed her resume to all the hospitals within 1km, two got back to me right away and she was hired within a week despite speaking no Japanese." www.betonit.ai/p/guest-work-in-japan-some-inside-info
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
People are mad because China has been "taking" manufacturing jobs from America, but all countries employ fewer people in manufacturing as they get wealthier.
Nobody is mad that Africa has more people in farming, but the view on China is just as irrational. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Crucially, most of these companies would never have been founded in the founders' home countries. This is a prime example of the GLOBAL benefits of moving labor from low-productivity countries to high-productivity countries.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
India has sent 96 people to America who started billion dollar companies. No one else is even close.
There's only about 5 million Indians in America. Almost one in 50,000 of them is a unicorn founder!
What a holy, special, beautiful people.
I will always fight for them. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The arguments in favor have been weak for decades! But U.S. academia, massively subsidized by government and donors, is stable waste.
PoIiMath
@politicalmath
I wonder if university academics as we know it will survive the next decade
With the demographic cliff, the increasing reliance on AI for writing academic papers, and the dissolution of public trust in institutional knowledge, the arguments in favor of academia are crumbling. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"1. The richer the countries, the better the management.
"2. Key exception: Multi-nationals are managed at First World levels almost everywhere...
"4. Government firms are the worst-managed of all."
www.betonit.ai/p/how_managementhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If Trump had just done this for Covid vaccines in mid-2020, his presidency could easily have ended in 2024.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
WSJ: “Podcaster Joe Rogan pitched Trump on a psychedelic drug recently in a text. In response, Trump said: ‘Sounds great. Do you want FDA approval? Let’s do it’”
This is how we make law now. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The Bob Dylan movie is good but its glorification of Stalinist stooges and dupes is not.
"KFVD radio were not comfortable with Guthrie's political leanings after he wrote a song praising the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact and the Soviet invasion of Poland." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woody_Guthrie -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
@marcportermagee
In a rating of different professions for their honesty and ethical standards, the biggest partisan divide was over college teachers
Democrats gave higher marks to every profession except police officers -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Don’t act shy and apologetic when starting a conversation and/or asking someone out - even if that’s how you feel (it’s certainly how I often felt!). As they say in sports, 'act like you’ve been there before.'"
www.betonit.ai/p/rationalist-dating-strategy -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I studied both the academic literature on dating, and the popular/self-help literature. It’s an unromantic, nerdy way of proceeding. But, for those lacking in natural social skills and charisma, it can be a lot better than the alternative." www.betonit.ai/p/rationalist-dating-strategy
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“Friends had advised me that I should not put down on dating site profiles that I have degrees from Harvard and Yale (it would look pretentious, they said). After I read the research, I ignored my friends’ advice and put this stuff in the profiles - modesty be damned. Right away, the number of favorable responses on those sites increased!”
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Remember, on Monday I debate @Heritage's Hankinson in NYC on "Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) should complete its mandate to deport all illegal aliens currently residing in the United States."
www.thesohoforum.org -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
“'I think quite often when there’s something new that people don’t like, they hold it to unusual standards compared to other things that exist,' Hanson stated. … 'imperfection' in a new thing is used as a rationale to block it by people 'who are invested in an old thing.'
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Paul Graham
@paulg
Yes, you can see from survival curves that one end is effectively nailed to the x axis.
Paul Graham
@paulg
The survival curve inflates like a sail, but the far end of it doesn't move much.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I want to believe!
But immortality still looks like nothing more than wishful thinking. 😟
Matt Ridley
@mattwridley
I disagree. Maximum human lifespan has hardly changed in 30 years.
The oldest person alive today, Ethel Caterham, is 116, a long way short of setting a record (122).
Only 4 people have ever gone past 117.
Increasing average lifespan does not lead to increased maximum lifespan.
It would take genetic engineering to change this. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty funny.
Noah
@NoahKingJr
Graduate students doing masters just to delay unemployment:
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
It’s not reflected by objective changes to the value of college
www.update.news/p/why-all-the-college-catastrophizing -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
.@VanderbiltU is still test-optional.
Shame!
Timur Kuran
@timurkuran
This decline tracks the “great awokening,” which was led by universities. Regaining the public’s trust should be their top priority. But so far, with exceptions such as Dartmouth and Vanderbilt, they have responded too slowly and too timidly.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Tim Worstall
@worstall
To remind, once again. Nothing about annual working hours makes any sense at all without including unpaid household working hours. It is *total* working hours that matter, not just those done for money for The Man.
Riccardo Trezzi
@RiccardoTrezzi
The evolution of hours worked from 1970 to today in the United States, Germany, and Switzerland. The data confirm my personal experience. I am fairly sure that Europeans, including the Swiss, do not fully realize how much less they work compared with Americans.
For what it's worth, I have lost count of the number of public holidays that can be combined with vacation days to create entire weeks off over the past year, something I never experienced in the United States, where it is essentially impossible by design.
Beyond that, in my experience, work organization, workplace culture, and animal spirits are often not comparable.
Will we be able to change Europe? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"*The Culture Transplant* strongly implies that we should welcome all migrants with ancestry scores exceeding our own. Which, by most of his measures, turns out to be over two billion people."
www.betonit.ai/p/my-opening-statement-for-the-uatx -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"*Hive Mind* strongly implies that the U.S. should eagerly welcome any migrant with an IQ of 98 or higher, which is well over a billion people worldwide."
www.betonit.ai/p/my-opening-statement-for-the-uatx -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Even a woke clock is right twice a day, and I’m grateful that woke activists have loudly pushed back against recent anti-immigration policies." www.betonit.ai/p/my-opening-statement-for-the-uatx
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
Our treatment of juvenile offenders is bizarre. We act as though teenagers are incapable of reason, and let them off easy. The consequence of letting juveniles go free is that their crime rate is substantially higher than expected. We should instead treat people equally. 1/
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Japan has sky-high trustworthiness but mediocre trust.
At night, their shops pull down big metal doors as if they're in Baltimore. But unlike in the US, no one graffitis the doors.
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Japan is not a higher-trust society than the United States of America
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I know Orwell well. This quote is genuine.
Full context:
www.stephenhicks.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/OrwellGeo… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The blurbs for Kakistocracy are finally out.
See what the best people are saying about my new book.
“American elites are and have been greatly underrated. Whatever their flaws, we turn away from them at our peril. Populism, in turn, is a danger. Richard Hanania’s Kakistocracy makes this case better than anyone else and provides a fresh new perspective on what is happening in America and the rest of the world today.” —Tyler Cowen
“Richard Hanania is the world’s greatest living essayist. While I’m personally deeply prone to both-sidesism, he’s gradually convinced me that modern-day populists are objectively worse than the elite midwits they’re replacing. Kakistocracy—‘rule by the worst’—defends this thesis with grim aplomb.” — Bryan Caplan
“Richard Hanania has written a bracing examination of the populist age. Rejecting both romantic defenses of ‘the people’ and reflexive elite self-congratulation, Kakistocracy is a serious, data-grounded account of why movements that begin as corrections to genuine elite failures often end in something worse than what they replaced.” — Rob Henderson
“Only the man who helped create the online right could diagnose it this ruthlessly. Hanania shows how the fringe left accelerated the worst tendencies of the right, while the rest of us can only watch in horror. The result is a painfully accurate diagnosis of everything stale and deadening in American politics.” — Brianna Wu
The release is July 7. You can preorder here. There's no charge until the book is shipped, and preordering is the best way to support my work. www.amazon.com/Kakistocracy-Why-Populism-Ends-Disaster/dp… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Or just bring back the old Analytical Reasoning section!
Robert Anderson
@ProfRobAnderson
I have taught law school for a long time and one of the main things I have learned is there should be a math section on the LSAT.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Soviet occupation almost invariably led to mass murder, mass deportations, wide-scale slave labor, collectivization, famine, and other horrors. Abject surrender was no protection, as the citizens of the Baltics learned in 1940-1." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-572
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"While it’s true that the U.S. can be a truly barbarous combatant, abject surrender to American occupation leads to amazingly good results. US occupation of Germany and Japan paved the way for the most libertarian policies these countries had ever known."
www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-572 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When I was eighteen years old, I met Rothbard and challenged him on these questions. He basically told me to go read some actual history. I followed his advice, reading most of his favorite New Left historians. I wasn’t impressed." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-572
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Educational austerity now.
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Funding for public schools is already quite high and has been steadily increasing.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Some people – personality psychologists call them 'high in Neuroticism' – harbor strong negative emotions that social norms urge us to conceal. The distinction between 'happy drunk' and 'mean drunk' may be a Hollywood invention, but rings true."
www.betonit.ai/p/in_vino_hatefulhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If Derbyshire correctly describes the effects of alcohol, no one should ever drink. But is he correct?" www.betonit.ai/p/in_vino_hatefulhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Voters hate inflation, it is known!
"In a just-released report for the DNC on that year’s election campaign, the word 'inflation' comes up 18 times.
But every time, it is in the context of adjusting previous years’ campaign spending for inflation." www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/www-aei-org-op-eds… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Modern socialists denying that Nazis were socialists is like Catholics denying that Protestants are Christians.
If you buy their dogmas wholesale, the denial readily follows.
But if you're just doing neutral classification of families of ideas, the denial is childish. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The key unstated fact is that math professors still have too much integrity to give passing grades to students who don't know math.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
"Current admissions practices do not provide a sufficiently reliable check on mathematical readiness for STEM majors."
Over 280 University of California STEM faculty have signed an open letter calling on the Board of Regents to reinstate standardized testing in admissions: -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Finished rewatching *Bates Motel*. Such an underrated series, with a great finale.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Whenever you're asking for someone's help, remember to ask, "Is there anything *I* can do to make *your* life easier?"
Works like a charm. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
In a just world, Lant Pritchett would get a Nobel Prize just for this blog post.
lantpritchett.substack.com/p/the-incredible-credulity-rev… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"On June 8, I’ll be in NYC to debate Heritage’s Simon Hankinson. I promise to open with a totally different argument than I’ve ever publicly made before. An argument so undeniable that in a just world I’d get 100% of the vote."
www.betonit.ai/p/caplan-jones-immigration-debate-rematch -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I last debated Garett Jones on immigration in 2015. A lot has happened in the interim. This Friday, UATX is hosting a rematch, open to the public." www.betonit.ai/p/caplan-jones-immigration-debate-rematch
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Why appeal to 'neutral outsiders'? Well, the main reason misunderstandings arise is because most human beings rush to assume malevolence. Indeed, this is built into the very concept of the 'misunderstanding'!"
www.betonit.ai/p/malevolence-and-misunderstanding -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Lancelot: Your rage has unbalanced you. You, sir, would fight to the death, against a knight who is not your enemy. Over a stretch of road you could easily ride around.
Arthur: So be it. To the death!
—Excalibur
www.betonit.ai/p/malevolence-and-misunderstanding -
Bryan Caplan reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
A debate between @bryan_caplan and @GarettJones. Moderated by @coldxman, hosted by the @austin_union.
UATX. May 29. 12:45 PM. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Spotted in Bastrop, Texas.
Near Buc-ee's! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
They want to LARP, not actually fight.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
My theory: people today more want to fight. Which is a luxury that they realize they can now afford. And to fight, they need to keep themselves mad. So they keep themselves mad and unhappy.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Never begrudge white South Africans getting refugee status in the US.
They're just getting the sanctuary that all oppressed people around the world deserve. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
What a fact check. “Immigrants are not founders alone. They found companies while working with Americans.”
Yes, that’s the point. The engine of American success is smart and talented people from all over the world working together.
It’s that combination that you restrictionists are trying to destroy through your small mindedness and hateful mediocrity. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
Recap of the last 24 hours...
Leftists: "Marxists are in decline in academia. I bet you can't even name 10 of them."
Me: "Okay, here's 20."
Leftists: "Well one of those is Canadian, so your list is invalid <ignores rest of list>. Also, I'm moving the goalposts. You can't even name 100 of them!"
Me: "Okay, here's a longer list with over 100. All of them are American."
Leftists: "Nuh uh! That list includes emeritus faculty. And 3-4 of are dead. Plus, there are 1.5 million faculty and all you have is 100! Your list is invalid!"
Me: "The emeritus faculty include some of the leading Marxist theorists alive today. The list was scraped from self-identified Marxists on Wikipedia, which skews toward older and better known faculty. That also explains why there are a couple of names who died in the last year & haven't had their bios updated. There are still over 100 living Marxist faculty on the list though."
Leftists: "Bah! 100 faculty out of 1.5 million? That's nothing!"
Me: "I never said the list was comprehensive, nor did you ask for a comprehensive list. You just asked for 100 names, which I exceeded. But if you want to discuss percentages here's a survey showing about 8% of faculty identify as Marxists. The percentage is much higher in certain disciplines that tend to be more political."
Leftists: "Nuh uh! That's not accurate <proceeds to misread the survey and gets confused by basic math>"
Round and round we go... -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
GoT could have been saved as late as season 8, episode 3. Crucial edit: The dead should have triumphed at Winterfell, killing most of the heroes, and forcing the survivors to go to Cercei hat in hand. Then in episode 5, Euron saves the day by using his ballistas on the undead dragon... then immediately turns them on the living dragons. That leaves Arya to assassinate Cercei in the final episode, ideally as part of a Valkyrie-style master plot.
You could even still have Drogon torch King’s Landing. He’s the sole surviving dragon, and his wing’s wounded so he has to go on foot. When the Lannister forces try to give him death by a thousand cuts, Dany *believably* goes berserk.
Who sits the Iron Throne at the end? Anyone but Bran the Catatonic! -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
ALL financial markets allow betting. And they were all once illegal as "gambling". The question is not if they allow gambles, the question is if they can achieve other valued social functions.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Alan Blinder tells us that, 'A pollution-free society is unattainable, both physically and economically. To think otherwise is not to think.' In *For a New Liberty*, Rothbard seems to stubbornly deny Blinder’s truism."
www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-e03 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Finally, Rothbard turns to pollution. Here he departs from almost every other environmental economist, left and right, by calling for outright bans on air and noise (!) pollution." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-e03
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Alexander Kustov
@akoustov
In my new @washingtonpost piece, I argue that some immigration policies are already popular and politicians just need the courage to claim them.
Nearly 80 percent of American voters support high-skilled immigration, across party lines. That is more popular than nuclear power, building apartments, or deregulation. And yet not a single major political figure in either party is willing to champion it.
Republicans know the country needs foreign scientists and engineers. Most will say so privately. But they refuse to say it publicly, terrified of being outflanked on their right.
The left has a different version of the same cowardice: the abundance crowd wants more housing, more energy, more growth, but has quietly decided immigration is too dangerous to include in their pitch.
The piece proposes two concrete moves that do not require Congress: encourage and expand the O-1A extraordinary-ability visa, which has no cap and no lottery, and fix how the government sets wages for foreign workers.
The Labor Department's public comment window on the proposed prevailing wage rule closes May 26. If you work in research, tech, or immigration, submit a comment at regulations.gov before it's too late.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/05/21/us-voters-supp… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Slides for the new talk I just gave here at @uaustinorg: www.betonit.ai/p/writing-books-that-deserve-to-be
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The best remedy is to hold ALL questions for a question period at the end of the talk.
That includes "clarifying questions," which will normally be handled by the next slide.
I imposed this rule when I ran the seminar and it was a huge improvement.
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
Never ask a question which lasts longer than 15 seconds. Frankly, don’t ask one longer than 7.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
LOL
Mises Media
@mises_media
NBC News, 1974. A reporter on a bus from Boston to New York asks passengers about the election. One man says voting is hogwash. The reporter asks if he ever voted. The man replies: a long time ago, but I learned later on that it was useless. That man was Murray Rothbard.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Who is the least despicable person whose hand you would refuse to shake?
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Genuine “local control” over land use involves letting individual property owners control their land without asking permission from their neighbors.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
My book, Kakistocracy, comes out July 7.
Why is everything stupid? Why is this happening now? What do these populist movements across the world share, and what can be done about them?
Preorder now, and you won't be charged until the book is released. www.amazon.com/Kakistocracy-Why-Populism-Ends-Disaster/dp… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Don’t keep your cards close to your chest. Share your sincere probabilities with your readers. Don’t just tell them what you can 'prove.' Tell them anything interesting that you’re willing to bet on – and at what odds."
www.betonit.ai/p/worthy_bookshtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If someone asks you, 'What are the five most important areas to think about?,' and you’re writing about something that isn’t on your own list, you should be disturbed." www.betonit.ai/p/worthy_bookshtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Is there anything more distinctly understood by all men, than what it is to see, to hear, to remember, to judge? Yet it is the most difficult thing in the world to define these operations according to the rules of logical definition. But it is not more difficult than it is useless. Sometimes philosophers attempt to define them; but, if we examine their definitions, we shall find that they amount to no more than giving one synonymous word for another, and commonly a worse for a better."
--Thomas Reid, *Essays on the Active Powers of Man* -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"You know how it is when one talks of liberty. Everything seems beautifully simple. One expects every gate to open and every wall to fall flat."
--Robert Graves, *I, Claudius* -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If econ Ph.D. programs really care about math prowess, they should require the Mathematics subject test.
Only 4% of current test-takers (prospective math Ph.D. students) get perfect scores, and prospective econ Ph.D. students would do worse.
www.ets.org/gre/test-takers/subject-tests/about/content-s…
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
If you get 100% on the Math GRE, you're at the 91st percentile.
The test measures grind and attention, not capability. It tests whether you can go 2 hours with no slipups.
It's interesting that grad programs don't want to know the full ability distribution of their applicants. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Tyler should also blame wokism for all backlash to wokism. They opened a very bad can of worms.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Tyler Cowen: “In retrospect, wokeism, for all its problems, was a relatively harmless way of distracting activists and keeping them busy with wars over words—a less-bad allocation of social energies than what we are now seeing.”
Pronouns are less harmful than socialism. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Illuminating.
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
Let me lay out the unpleasant arithmetic of the replacement rate, and why a modern society finds it so hard to reach.
A population of 100 women in an advanced economy needs 210 children to replace itself. Why?
Absent sex-selective practices, roughly 105 boys are born for every 100 girls. Evolution overshoots male births because boys are more prone to early death from accidents and disease. Therefore, of 210 children, about 108 are boys and 102 are girls. Not all girls reach the midpoint of their fertile age: accidents, suicide, homicide, and illness take some. In an advanced economy, about 98% of them survive, leaving 100 women to replace the original 100.
Now consider the distribution of children per woman.
Imagine 15 women have no children. Five do so by choice, for various reasons (professional, affective, religious). Ten face unfixable fertility problems, theirs or their partner’s. The 10% figure is conservative: the medical literature points to around 13%, and that does not even count male fertility problems.
Of the remaining 85, 10 have one child, 60 have two, 10 have three, and 5 have four. I am stopping at four to keep the post concise; very few women in younger cohorts have five or more children, but I could adapt the example to account for them.
Hence, the 100 women in this population have 180 children, for a completed fertility rate of 1.8.
Interestingly, this is roughly the rate we saw in many advanced economies until the early 1990s, and in the U.S. until around 2008.
But we are still 30 children short of replacement! Voluntary childlessness is only 5%. Three-quarters of women have two or more children. Look around: most of your friends will have two, plenty will have three or four. And yet, we are well below replacement.
You would not look at this population and call it selfish (is having two kids hedonistic?) or accuse it of losing family values (only 5% of women are choosing voluntarily not to have children).
The point is simpler. To reach 210 births, you need a substantial share of women to have three or more children. Two as the “normal” pattern will not get you there. And modern society makes three or more a costly proposition for most families.
Of course, current fertility rates in most advanced economies are well below 1.8. But my point is that, under present social arrangements, we should not expect 2.1, even if (to humor last weekend’s debate) we banned smartphones and TikTok. We need many, many more families with three or four children.
More pointedly, there is no self-regulating mechanism that pushes a society back to 2.1. The market-clearing analogy many economists use is flawed; scarcity feedback does not work the same way. (Another post on this another day.) And, as I often read, the claim that “nature” somehow regulates current overpopulation is just childish mumbo jumbo.
So yes, the arithmetic of replacement rate is unpleasant. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Some countries are so short on entrepreneurial talent — and so hostile to multinational business — that government stupidity keeps them mired in poverty. But in most industries and countries, businesses merrily chug along despite rule by blankfaces." www.betonit.ai/p/the-superpower-of-coping-with-government
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"A good entrepreneur, in contrast, will start filling out the paperwork three years before consumer demand makes a new store profitable, so the doors can open on the first day there’s money to be made."
www.betonit.ai/p/the-superpower-of-coping-with-government -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Businesses have an unsung superpower. They aren’t just awesome at producing and marketing goods and services. They are also awesome at coping with government stupidity." www.betonit.ai/p/the-superpower-of-coping-with-government
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why do people reject basic economics?
These emotions are why people reject basic economics! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"It is notoriously difficult to get emotional people to stop being emotional. But so what? A diagnosis can be exactly correct even though no effective cure exists."
www.betonit.ai/p/economics-is-intuitive-rejoinder -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I’m tempted to reply, 'It’s not just a bad thing; it’s the bad thing.' But that would be overly emotional on my part. My considered reaction is just: If lazily adopting strong opinions is 'pretty rational,' your bar must be very low." www.betonit.ai/p/economics-is-intuitive-rejoinder
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Agree. It's power-hungry politicians all the way down, and "Après moi, le déluge."
Henry Gao
@henrysgao
The biggest myth is that China plays the long game and "think in terms of centuries". Just to name a few recent counter-examples: the disastrous one-child policy, abrupt ending of COVID-zero, and the crack-down on tech firms.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Dany's sudden transformation from liberator to mass murderer makes sense when you remember that GRRM himself had a sudden transformation from virtuoso storyteller to scatterbrained rambler when he wrote *Feast for Crows*.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Wait, there's a car coming.
"Huh? He's stopping. What a courteous driv...
"Oh, it's a @Waymo." -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Whatever you conclude, know that immigration is nothing special. Everything has broader social effects. These complexities are no reason to defer to popular prejudice." www.betonit.ai/p/we-wanted-tech
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you look closely at any major technological development, you can justly say, 'We wanted tech, but we changed society instead.'" www.betonit.ai/p/we-wanted-tech
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Ok, please tell me my blind spots.
Jules Ma
@indyholland
We've seen prominent intellectuals go 'crazy', abandon what made them unique and became twitter-pilled like so many others.
Your exceptional mental/emotional functioning, however, is still unlike other human beings, with the same corresponding blind spots you always had. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Are you???
Ross Levatter
@LevatterRoss
Are you proposing a bet? 😉
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Students selected by test scores have better personalities than students selected for "personality." @uaustinorg
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Lebanon is the richest country in history (measured in per-capita GDP in 2025 $) to ever have a civil war that killed over 1% of its population.
chatgpt.com/s/t_6a07f598070c8191b178b8a8428f25d8 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Nozick, proto-YIMBY.
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
People don’t get a formal say in whether a data center gets built near them simply because it affects them. As Nozick points out, whom other people decide to date can affect you but that doesn’t mean you get a say in the matter.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Tonight!
caplacon.substack.com/p/uatx-karaoke-night-instructions -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When The Case Against Education collides with Open Borders, Open Borders wins." www.betonit.ai/p/trumps-backdoor-to-open-borders
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Two summers ago, Trump had a great idea that he never acted upon.
www.betonit.ai/p/trumps-backdoor-to-open-borders -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Of course immigration can fix this. If student visas were painlessly available, U.S. schools could easily double their enrollments in four years flat.
Anthony Bradley
@drantbradley
The demographic cliff is hitting state schools as well. Our country is currently built around a 2.3+ fertility rate. At 1.6, elementary schools are now dropping like flies. We’re in trouble. And, no, immigration can’t fix this.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Will I ever go crazy, as many thinkers eventually do?
Assuming I'm not crazy already, I say no. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Rothbard lacks the chutzpah to confidently claim that decentralized 'national defense' would better deter a Soviet invasion than the Department of Defense. He makes up for this chutzpah shortfall with the most ridiculous argument in the entire book." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-fd1
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"This is the chapter that has literally converted thousands of highly intelligent, economically informed people to anarcho-capitalism. The first time I read it, I thought it was crazy. By the tenth time, Rothbard had made a believer out of me."
www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-fd1 -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Doesn’t this just push the problem back a step? No. Rothbard offers the reader a complete flow chart." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-fd1
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Looks a lot more like the long-term harm of Covid lockdowns than a digital revolution.
Brad Wilcox
@BradWilcoxIFS
There's a reason Marc Andreessen is saying this. Much of his business depends upon you *not noticing* the toll the digital revolution is taking on teen lives.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"To 'preserve a culture,' in contrast, requires a whole country to impose traditional norms on everyone. And this is crazy: You don’t even have the right to force your culture on your adult children, much less millions of strangers."
www.betonit.ai/p/nativism_againshtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If someone happens to step on our emotional toes, civility impels us to suppress the urge to take it personally. Say 'Don’t mention it' – or better yet, don’t mention it." www.betonit.ai/p/nativism_againshtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Taking offense when a speaker intends no offense is simply rude.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Paging @ezraklein and @DKThomp.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"American cities often have poorer centres and richer suburbs or exurbs. European cities preserve richer and more attractive historic cores. A visit as a tourist in America compared with France will leave one having seen different spots on the income distribution."
Yep.
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
We stopped everything to write an answer (link below) to Paul Krugman's two posts of today (one informal, one with a simple model) arguing that Europe is broadly not falling behind the United States.
The change measured by the Draghi report, he argues, is mostly due to growth in the technology industry, which has distorted GDP numbers without actually leading to higher standards of living. We should believe our eyes when we walk around France and walk around Mississippi.
Krugman is wrong. The measures he uses understate European stagnation. This matters enormously. Divergence with the United States is the strongest evidence for reform in Europe.
1. The growth numbers
Krugman compares the United States, France, and Germany at purchasing power parity in current prices. On that measure, France's and Germany's position relative to America has been roughly constant since 2000.
But current price comparisons miss productivity gains in sectors where prices fall. If America produces twice as much software while the price of each unit halves, the value of American software output looks unchanged even though the volume has doubled.
Most economists therefore use constant prices, which fix the base-year PPP level and apply each country's real output growth on top of it. American output growth has concentrated in tech, where prices have fallen tremendously as productivity rises. In terms of the volume of things produced, America has pulled away from Europe.
2. Is it all the tech industry?
Krugman concedes this tech divergence but says it is not welfare-relevant. The American growth lead is an accounting artefact of measuring more iPhones at base-year prices, not a sign that Americans are actually richer, because Europeans buy the same iPhones at the same world prices.
This is not the right way to think about the world today, as an earlier Paul Krugman would have argued.
His model assumes tradable goods, interchangeable workers, marginal-cost pricing, and no profits. Each assumption fails.
Most of what households buy is non-tradable: housing, healthcare, childcare, education. When American tech firms bid workers from haircutting to coding, American haircut wages rise. Germany has no growing tech sector to do the bidding, so German wages stay flat.
Technology is not priced at marginal cost. Apple's margins are around 40 percent. Anthropic's inference margins are at 70 percent. The major platforms enjoy network effects, switching costs, and lock-in that hold prices well above what a competitive market would deliver. A large share of the productivity gains in technology stays as profit.
A lot of the value of American technology dominance shows up in equity, not in wages. Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, Alphabet, Meta, and Amazon together are worth $21 trillion, more than the entire combined stock market value of all European stock markets. Around 60 percent of US equity is held by American households. The median French or Spanish household holds almost no equity.
The median employee at Meta, a company with almost 80,000 employees, earned $388,000 in 2025.
This advantage is not going to go away. Krugman's own 1991 paper, cited in his Nobel prize, showed that comparative advantage in modern industries is produced by increasing returns to scale, specialized labor markets, supplier networks and the agglomeration of suppliers, workers, and ideas in particular places. Once an industry concentrates somewhere, the concentration is self-reinforcing. Europe is being pushed away from the next round of technology industries (AI!).
3. What about inequality?
Another retort is that GDP per capita hides substantial inequality, and so even if America is rich on average, this is mostly due to the super wealthy.
But despite the US's high pre-tax income inequality, it also achieves higher median incomes than Europe, in part because of such a high base, and in part because it actually redistributes more than many European countries.
The cleanest comparison is median equivalised disposable household income: income after cash taxes and transfers, adjusted for household size and purchasing power. According to the OECD's 2021 numbers, the median American earns 30 percent more than the median Dutchman, about 31 percent more than the median German, and about 52 percent more than the median Frenchman.
4. What about hours worked?
Krugman points out that while American GDP per person is higher, most of this is because Americans work more. For this divergence to be an hours worked story, Americans must work more relative to Europeans now than they did in 2000.
The opposite has happened. Birinci, Karabarbounis, and See in a 2026 NBER paper show that about half of the American-European hours gap that existed in the 1990s has reversed by the end of the 2010s. Americans work fewer hours per person than they did in 2000, while most Europeans work more.
5. Is America not a bad place to live?
Walk around Alabama and France: surely the former cannot be substantially richer than the latter?
American cities often have poorer centres and richer suburbs or exurbs. European cities preserve richer and more attractive historic cores. A visit to a city as a tourist in America compared with a city in France will leave one having seen different spots on the income distribution. Americans in Europe go to the nicest and richest European cities.
Rather than a walking around test, do a driving around test. Go to the periphery of any modern American city and see a level of new-built material wealth that is extremely uncommon in Europe, with thousands of enormous four- or five-bedroom homes. In the South, in places like Nashville and Austin, drive around the downtowns to see hundreds of luxury apartment buildings springing from the ground. This construction boom is replicated virtually nowhere in Europe today.
The other question is generational. Housing often costs more in Europe than in the United States, despite the quality of the housing stock generally being much better. Europe has nice city cores but these are inaccessible to young Europeans.
Consider the salaries available to entry-level workers. The starting pay for a London police officer is $57,000. In Washington, DC, $75,000. The entry-level Deloitte consultant job in Madrid pays around €28,000, roughly $33,000 per year. In Charlotte, the entry-level Deloitte job pays $63,000.
There are many things to dislike about life in America. But relative to 25 years ago, the gap in material wealth has shifted dramatically in America's favor.
www.siliconcontinent.com/p/european-stagnation-is-real -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Economics is for donkeys." This and more from a great preliberal!
www.betonit.ai/p/3_fun_quotes_frhtml -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What is the world's most influential political party that uses the word "Capitalism" or "Capitalist" in its name?
As a positive. "Anti-Capitalist" parties don't count. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“My main complaint about Why Not Capitalism? is that Brennan doesn’t take Cohen to task for conflating voluntary and involuntary socialism.” www.betonit.ai/p/ownership_for_chtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Disagree. Populists embrace a wide range of trade-offs, like "I'm happy to pay extra at the store in order to save American jobs" and "I'm happy to pay more taxes to hire more ICE officers."
What populists don't like is exactly free-market capitalism.
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
Populists across the spectrum, left and right, hate economists. I joked its some puzzle but I think there's a simple reason. It's not about liking capitalism or something.
And the disagreement is almost always about how to reason about problems, not about values.
Populists want solutions. Economists offer trade-offs. I'm not the first to point this out but its a huge distinction.
A carbon tax doesn't solve climate change. It prices carbon so people make better decisions at the margin. To the populist, that sounds like accepting the problem.
Same with manufacturing. A tariff doesn't create jobs. It shifts them, from the millions of workers in industries that buy steel to the 160,000 who make it. To the populist, "protect American workers" sounds like a solution. To the economist, the question is: which American workers?
We can go down the list. Rent control intends to help renters. It produces housing shortages. The populist sees the economist opposing rent control and concludes: you don't care about poor people.
As Sowell put it: "The first lesson of economics is scarcity: there is never enough of anything to fully satisfy all those who want it. The first lesson of politics is to disregard the first lesson of economics."
I think, not surprising, the economists are right.
It's more than just two different approaches. Thinking in trade-offs forces you to trace each step: who actually bears the cost of a tariff, what happens to housing supply when you cap rents, how a carbon tax changes behavior at every margin.
You can't skip ahead to the answer. You have to follow the chain. This is why economists spend careers doing exactly this and still argue about the answers. That's what it looks like when you take the problems seriously.
The populist skips all of this based on some intuition pump. Think of the person on a group project who's so confident in the answer that they never bother learning the material. That's populist economic reasoning from inside the discipline. The confidence comes from not having looked at the trade-offs closely enough to see how hard they are.
Stewart is the populist left. Oren Cass is the populist right, and he's more dangerous because he sounds like an economist, and plays one on TV, without putting in the work of thinking about trade-offs. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Impressive that @BrianLeiter didn't scrub these pro-Chavez posts.
2004: leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2004/08/hugo_chavezs_cr.html
2006: leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2006/02/let_the_dogs_of_1.…
2007: leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2007/02/has_hugh_chavez.html
Video of the 2020 Caplan-Leiter Capitalism versus Socialism Debate: www.betonit.ai/p/leiter-caplan-capitalism-vs-socialism-de… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“Even if you believe capitalism is designed to keep workers obediently working for peanuts, where is the profit in fostering a subculture of impulsive sex, poor work habits, substance abuse, violence, and cruelty to children?” www.betonit.ai/p/whos-afraid-of-oscar-lewis
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When you 'advocate capitalism,' don’t you risk alienating all of the people who hate the status quo but might come to love the free market? It’s possible, but I doubt it." www.betonit.ai/p/should_libertarians_oppose_capitalismhtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
My new book, Kakistocracy: Why Populism Ends in Disaster, comes out in July.
If you're a fan, preorders are the best way to show support.
In order to sweeten the deal, I'll offer anyone who preorders the hardcover in the next 24 hours a one-year subscription to the newsletter, which normally costs more than the book.
Details on how to order and claim below. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Awesome.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
They said capitalists can't build infrastructure in Africa as it is fixed, & govts there just confiscate. So capitalists made floating & therefore transferable infrastructure.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If someone wants to work, and someone else wants to hire him, rejoice. Do not demand a theory of cosmic justice before allowing them to cooperate. Do not ask whether the job is 'good enough' by your standards."
www.betonit.ai/p/an-ode-to-low-skilled-workers-version-9de -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Civilization is not just symphonies, microchips, and MRI machines. Civilization is also a clean bathroom at an airport." www.betonit.ai/p/an-ode-to-low-skilled-workers-version-9de
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Peter Boghossian
@peterboghossian
I spent an hour with @bryan_caplan, who argues that education has become a religion; most people inside it are too compromised to admit it.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I really enjoyed talking to Peter, but perhaps we don't disagree enough for that to be surprising.
Peter Boghossian
@peterboghossian
Which of the following progressives accepted my invitation to conversation?
www.nationalprogressalliance.org/who-weve-invited/
Peter Boghossian
@peterboghossian
I enjoy having conversations with people I disagree with. While I'm in New Zealand, I invite:
Chlöe Swarbrick, @_chloeswarbrick. Ricardo Menéndez March, @RMarchNZ. Jane Kelsey. Virginia Braun, @ginnybraun.
To converse. If you accept, please just write, "Sure" in this thread. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Peter Boghossian
@peterboghossian
Person X criticizes policy Y. That does not mean that X endorses the opposite of Y. It could merely mean that Y is idiotic.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Richard's detractors have a lot of trouble telling when he's serious, half-serious, and joking.
#neverreadthecomments
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The Sopranos foresaw every conversation about race on social media today.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
*Mercy* is the most laughable AI movie around, with the AI almost as vulnerable to paradoxical inputs as it was in *Star Trek*'s original series.
But the resolution of the mystery is actually good -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Crime is so sensitive a topic that pretty much anything we could do about it is said to "have ethical issues". Which in practice means that we can only keep doing what we have been doing, nothing new is allowed.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If the typical low-skilled worker is so useful, why would an extra low-skilled worker be so useless? Yes, many of us feel satiated for food, and perhaps (if you’re in a cheap part of the country) for housing as well. Yet who feels satiated for time?""
www.betonit.ai/p/an-ode-to-low-skilled-workers-version -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Major Premise: Low-skilled workers are terrible.
"Minor Premise: Low-skilled immigrants are low-skilled workers.
"Conclusion: Therefore, low-skilled immigrants are terrible."
www.betonit.ai/p/an-ode-to-low-skilled-workers-version -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"A blankface is anyone who enjoys wielding the power entrusted in them to make others miserable by acting like a cog in a broken machine, rather than like a human being with courage, judgment, and responsibility for their actions." scottaaronson.blog?p=5675
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
After all, that risks our seeing people who create wealth as heroes rather than the villains that they must be.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The best argument that society can’t handle race realism is the behavior of race realists themselves.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Why 110? It should be 98, the U.S. average.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
How you know the race and IQ people are just bigots: if you take IQ seriously, your main cause should be getting everyone on earth with a 110 IQ or higher into your country.
This would be the only logical position one can hold.
But that's not what these people support! -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
And if you think McCloud is trivial, look at this revelatory page.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I learned my European history from reading the late great Carlton Hayes in high school. His magnum opus ended in 1923, but here ChatGPT eerily emulates how he would have written *Downfall*.
--
Write an account of the last month of Hitler's life in the voice of Carlton Hayes.
--
📷
The Last Month of Hitler: A Hayes-like Account
When the month of April 1945 opened, Adolf Hitler was already less a ruler of Germany than the prisoner of his own myth. The armies which he had once hurled across Europe were now broken, scattered, or encircled; the cities of the Reich were heaps of stone and cinder; and Berlin itself, that capital from which the new pagan empire had promised to command a thousand years, lay beneath the guns of the Red Army. Yet in the underground chambers of the Reich Chancellery, Hitler continued to move imaginary divisions upon maps, to denounce treason, and to demand from exhausted men a loyalty which events had long since rendered militarily meaningless. Soviet forces were closing in on central Berlin by the time of his death on April 30. (Holocaust Encyclopedia)
It was, in a terrible sense, the logical end of his career. Hitler had made of nationalism not patriotism but idolatry; of race, not anthropology but theology; of war, not policy but sacrament. Now the false religion consumed its own temple. The German people, whom he had claimed uniquely to love, were to perish rather than survive him in defeat. Roads were choked with refugees; boys and old men were pressed into hopeless defense; and those about him learned that even ruin could not soften his will. A more ordinary despot might have bargained. Hitler, whose whole authority rested upon infallibility and catastrophe, could only stage-manage the apocalypse.
His fifty-sixth birthday, April 20, passed in circumstances at once grotesque and pitiable. There were still ceremonies, still uniforms, still hands raised in salute, still courtiers who came to render homage to the failing idol. But beyond the bunker walls, Berlin was already a battlefield. The contrast between the ritual and the reality showed, more clearly than any Allied proclamation could have done, the hollowness of the regime. The sovereign of a continent had become the master of a cellar.
During those final days, the circle around him narrowed. Göring, imagining perhaps that the hour had come to inherit what could no longer be governed, sent his fatal message from Bavaria and was treated as a traitor. Himmler, the cold bureaucrat of murder, sought contacts for surrender in the West and likewise earned Hitler’s fury. These last betrayals were not aberrations but revelations. A movement founded upon force, fear, and private ambition could not end in chivalry. It ended in mutual suspicion among criminals.
Eva Braun, long kept in the shadow of public life, entered the last scene with a strange constancy. On April 29, in the bunker, Hitler married her. It was a ceremony of ashes: a wedding without a future, a domestic rite performed under bombardment, while the state whose chancellor he remained was dissolving above him. In the same night he dictated his political testament, a document remarkable not for repentance but for its obstinate refusal of moral awakening. Even at the end, he blamed the victims and vindicated the creed that had brought Germany to destruction.
By April 30 the end was not merely probable but immediate. Hitler had resolved not to be captured. Eva Braun took poison; Hitler died by suicide in the bunker, commonly described as a gunshot, with accounts also referring to cyanide. Their bodies were carried into the garden of the Reich Chancellery and burned according to his instructions. (Encyclopedia Britannica)
There was no grandeur in it. The last act was neither Wagnerian nor heroic, but sordid, frightened, and cramped. Yet it possessed a dreadful historical fitness. Hitler had promised regeneration and delivered desolation; he had worshiped power and ended powerless; he had exalted the state and died beneath its ruins; he had demanded sacrifice from millions and at last sacrificed nothing but the residue of his own life. The world he sought to master survived him. The Germany he claimed to redeem lay prostrate. And Europe, though delivered from him, would carry for generations the scars of a nationalism transformed into a demonic faith. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Full road privatization is logistically harder than full privatization of the legal system. www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-254
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I am aware, of course, that some libertarians argue that the hold-out problem has been greatly oversold. Maybe they’re right, but it’s still odd for Rothbard to completely ignore the objection." www.betonit.ai/p/bet-on-it-book-club-for-a-new-liberty-254
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Yet I have smart friends who consider me horribly dogmatic for saying "Bah" to this stuff.
Youthful sci-fi enthusiasm really does erode common sense!
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
New York Times on the release of UFO files: “The initial files are murky images that show what could be anything.”
This is the entire history of the UFO phenomenon.
No matter how many more cameras we have, no matter how good they get, it’s always murky dots.
Makes you think. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The innumeracy of narrative journalism: Long NYT essay on the fertility decline blames it on uncertainty due to rises in mortality, inequality, unemployment, work vulnerability, poverty, etc., without citing a single datum on how any of these have changed over time, nor even the simplest correlations with fertility. | Why So Few Babies? We Might Have Overlooked the Biggest Reason of All. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/07/opinion/birthrate-kids-parents…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Politics is cruelty.
Anger + Joy = Cruelty -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
And if you think McCloud is trivial, look at this revelatory page.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
All social scientists should ponder these profound pages from Scott McCloud.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Ilya Somin
@IlyaSomin
Today, US Court of International Trade rightly ruled against Trump's massive Section 122 tariffs, in cases brought by @LJCenter and 24 state governments. See linked post for reasons why, including some covered in my amicus brief on behalf of @Cato and myself:
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
John J.S. Soriano
@JohnJSSoriano
"I'm all for a big tent except for Ezra Klein and everyone to the right of him" is actually pretty consistent with "I'm all for building housing except for the housing that isn't subject to 20 years of community input."
Hal Singer
@halsinger
It’s just not possible for Dems to accommodate the Abundance folks, who seek deregulatory policies for their developer/investor clients. I’m all for a big tent, but up until the point that accommodation starts to undermine progressive messaging. And that message is that we need a muscular government to curb the excesses of unfettered markets, concentrated wealth, and the attendant political corruption (aka oligarchy). Besides, there’s already a political party that stands for small government, low taxation on wealth/income, and deregulation. Why can’t the Abundance folks just align naturally over there?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Data like this is one of the best ways to break out of your bubble. Inflation, not immigration, caused the Democratic defeat in 2024.
And most people have virtually forgotten the overturning of Roe v. Wade.
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
We might be heading towards a populist backlash towards AI, but we're not there yet. Outside the tech bubble, Americans really don't care about AI yet.
AI is Americans' 29th most important issue, according to the fantastic survey @davidshor ran that everyone is rightly looking at.
It's not surprising that Americans will answer sentiment questions about AI negatively, as they've been negative towards tech for a while. But it's a big leap from negative sentiment to meaningful political action.
Americans have been negative on social media for 10 years, and there has been no meaningful political action. And that's despite all the other hallmarks of backlash people are saying about AI---violent extremists (people forget there was a shooting at YouTube HQ), protests, etc.
My prediction: we will get real populist backlash to AI when the unemployment moves by, say, 2 percentage points and people see it as caused by AI.
That might happen quite soon. So it's good that people are already thinking about this issue and where it might lead (esp @jasminewsun whose recent writing on this has been incredible).
When the populist backlash does occur, people will be searching around for policies, and if we're lucky and smart, we'll have a library of potential good ideas ready to deploy. Because otherwise, we'll get horrible ideas like data center moratoria instead.
I'll be writing more about this for my piece on the poltical economy of AGI next week! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Madrid interview on housing: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-7Nttj28C_E
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I think where we diverge is that I believe people aren’t relying on mere emotional attachment to a certain implicit descriptive model of the world. The implications for our normative beliefs sound to me like your model would lead us to tell people to just be less emotional (slim chance!) whereas I think economists need to inject more sound economic thinking into our popular narratives." www.betonit.ai/p/counter-intuitive-econ
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Dwarkesh Patel
@dwarkesh_sp
Pre-industrial populations weren't just shorter and less healthy - they were less intelligent, too.
A combination of fewer calories and a much higher burden of infectious disease meant that people's brains just developed less during childhood.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
I’ve never understood this sort of response. “Oh I’ll beat you up!”. Okay??
Ukrainian Patron Saint of Welders
@CryptVanWinkle
You should really go find a disabled person or veteran and tell them their disability rating is fake and that they shouldnt get anything. See what happens.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
"Professor Hanson believes that in the future, prediction markets will help voters choose candidates by betting on what will happen if that candidate wins. Similarly, presidents might act differently if, for example, a prediction market gauged the economic consequences of an attack on Iran or big tariffs on other countries. 'There’s a huge potential in the future for these markets just doing a lot more in society,' says Professor Hanson. 'So that’s the main reason to have a light touch” in regulating them.'" www.csmonitor.com/Business/2026/0505/prediction-markets-c…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"So here’s what I say to every IQ realist who forgets common decency: You embarrass me. You embarrass yourself. You embarrass intelligence itself." www.betonit.ai/p/iq_with_consciehtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"We should be especially wary of self-styled consequentialists who rush toward maximal brutality instead of patiently searching for cheap, humane ways to cope with the social costs of low IQ."
www.betonit.ai/p/iq_with_consciehtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"In my experience, if a stranger brings up low IQ in Africa, there’s about a 50/50 chance he casually transitions to forced sterilization or mass murder of hundreds of millions of human beings as an intriguing response." www.betonit.ai/p/iq_with_consciehtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
France elected a socialist in 1981.
Guess what happened next. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"U.S. peace activists’ typical arguments against war are both too weak and too strong: Too weak because they focus on the badness of particular leaders and regimes rather than the murderous essence of modern war, too strong because they make overconfident, overblown predictions about the long-run effects of wars they oppose." www.betonit.ai/p/whats_wrong_wit_19html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The truth is that the typical individual's data is virtually worthless.
So we either sell it implicitly or (due to transactions costs) not at all.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
I've never understood this idea that we'd gain from explicitly selling our data to firms we deal with. That sale is already implicitly in current deals we make with them, & I don't see how making it explicit gives us better deals.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If I put $1000 into Bitcoin when kooky teens started telling me about it, I would have $10B now.
That's why, whenever anyone asks me about Bitcoin, I tell them I'm not fit to comment. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This is a very @CatoInstitute idea: Create a new job for yourself and convince them to hire you.
www.cato.org/innovation -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"What a privilege it is to know that I helped the great Dwarkesh get his start! He probably would have done just as well without me, but conceivably I really was the marginal factor. Regardless, I’ve made a wonderful friend." www.betonit.ai/p/my-dwarkesh-story
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
From May 13-June 5, I'm a visiting professor at @uaustinorg.
During my stay, I'm hosting on-campus game nights, karaoke, and an RPG mini-campaign.
Open to the whole UATX community and the general public.
Learn more and RSVP here: caplacon.substack.com/p/uatx-fun-open-to-the-public -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Every generation of leftists seems to just hate whatever new thing most represents capitalism and is making life better.
Then they forget and move on to the next one.
First they obsessed over Walmart. Its crime was a wider range of goods and lower prices.
Then Amazon was the issue, because it also gave low prices but also brought unimagined variety and convenience. One click order to get anything in the world overnight, sane people would've been singing its praises, but they specifically targeted them.
Now it's data centers, the main engine of economic growth. Populist rightoids are joining them.
Good thing about the American system is that it's too deadlocked and too subject to special interest influence to wipe out whatever is new. So data centers will make life better, and then they'll hate the next thing. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
My *Unbeatable: The Brutally Honest Case for Free Markets*, forthcoming in 2027 from University of Chicago Press, is all about the big questions.
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
A fundamental lesson from my posts these last two weeks on modernization, industrial policy, and development is that development economics should be about understanding why South Korea got rich but Bolivia did not.
The current field has largely given up on that question. Sharply identified RCTs on small micro programs are a fine way to publish in the AER and get tenure at a fancy university, but a profession that knows everything about microfinance impact evaluations and almost nothing about industrialization has misallocated its own intellectual capital on a pretty heroic scale.
Four images of Seoul: -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Jason Brennan 10 years ago: "Prediction: The typical liberal arts professor who reads Bryan Caplan's new book will just engage in table-pounding about the intrinsic value of education, all while ignoring opportunity costs and the inconvenient fact that most college students learn very little."
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Blast from the past. That's me, @tylercowen, @ATabarrok, and @ezraklein, among others, at Tyler's house 15 years ago.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Valencia lo sabe.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Ironically, the real-world version of the "democratic version" is private property rights without voting or public discussion.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Pretty good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Two wise guys.
Dwarkesh Patel
@dwarkesh_sp
Rome was a massive slave society: about one person in every ten was a slave.
Slaves weren’t a different race, or a different religion, or anything that would make people think they were a fundamentally different type of person.
Many free Romans were aware they were descended from slaves.
But despite all of this, Rome never developed an abolition movement. Free Romans were convinced that slavery was justified. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The media is neither honest nor good.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
NYT reports on Nancy Mace's wild stories about her being a "survivor" without mentioning that there's basically no way any of it is true.
They're portraying this lunatic, along with Boebert and UFO Luna, as a brave truth teller because she wants to bring MeToo to the right. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Mandela was not merely allied with the SACP; he was a member of its central committee. And he lied about it, making him a bona fide crypto-Communist." www.betonit.ai/p/correction_on_mhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Imagine a wealthy man declares, 'I donate blood because I might need it one day.' Why is this a silly claim? Because he’s rich? No! This is a silly claim because no individual, regardless of income, noticeably affects the blood supply." www.betonit.ai/p/whats-really-wrong-with-luxury-beliefs
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"He’s correct, I grant, that elites suffer almost no negative consequences from their crazy political views. But this fact has nothing to do with their elite status. Why not? Because selfishly speaking, virtually no one ever suffers any negative consequences of any political view they happen to hold." www.betonit.ai/p/whats-really-wrong-with-luxury-beliefs
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The real problem is that the "luxury beliefs" idea is deeply confused.
www.betonit.ai/p/whats-really-wrong-with-luxury-beliefs -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The Gini coefficient for my tweets is unbelievably unequal.
My two most-viewed tweets have more views than thousands of regular tweets! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Women will not lower their standards, but a woman can.
Men will not become more responsible, but a man can. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If only "doing normal human nature things" were the heart of conservatism.
Doing normal human nature things is my thing.
Joshua D Phillips
@JoshPhillipsPhD
Maybe doing normal human nature things (socializing, marrying, babies, walking in nature) makes you happy. Weird
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
People who think that higher ed has turned into a big trade school are wildly optimistic. What a huge improvement that would be!
Reality: Most college students acquire near-zero real-world skills. College raises wages because enduring this 4-6-year ordeal signals employability. -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Gene Epstein
@GeneSohoForum
Tony, most 18-22 yr-olds NEVER viewed the humanities as anything they'd voluntarily study if it HADN'T been a pathway to a job. But Adult Ed is popular, as is my www.thesohoforum.org, offering NO career enhancement! So let's have VOLUNTARY education, not INVOLUNTARY!
Tony Annett
@tonyannett
I don’t think that’s the reason. I think the reason is students felt that there no good jobs with humanities degrees, especially in the new financialized economy.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Doing counter factual history with ChatGPT is like hanging out with @PTetlock.
Prompt: "If I asked 'When will there be the First World War?' in 1913, what would your median estimate have been?"
chatgpt.com/s/t_69f51625acd88191837fb1460c2e3758 -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Bentham's Bulldog🔸
@Benthamsbulldog
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When faced with demands for conformity, silently ask, 'What will happen to me if I refuse?' Train yourself to ponder subtle and indirect repercussions, but learn to dismiss most such ponderings as paranoia. Modern societies are huge, anonymous, and forgetful."
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Vivid anecdotes about billionaire dropouts aside, the modern labor market remains extremely credentialist, and there’s no reason to think this will change anytime soon." www.betonit.ai/p/a_non-conformishtml
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
My reply to CFTC call for comments on prediction markets: www.overcomingbias.com/p/on-prediction-market-regulation
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Proto social media outrage.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Blast from the past. That's me, @tylercowen, @ATabarrok, and @ezraklein, among others, at Tyler's house 15 years ago.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Once the re-definition of 'racism' starts to snowball, people will self-censor to avoid becoming victims of semantic inflation. So the policy doesn’t merely persecute people for non-leftist leanings; it stifles the creation and evaluation of any idea that a paranoid fanatic might interpret as 'racist.'"
www.betonit.ai/p/anti-communism-and-anti-racism -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Under the Hollywood Code (1934-1968), the entertainment industry made the U.S. look far more traditional than it really was.
Since then, the entertainment industry has made the U.S. look far less traditional than it really is. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I wish you eternity, brother.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
He's right; today I'm exactly 2/3 of a century old.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Did you know that journalists make money from the stories they write?! How could we possibly trust them?
Jackie (clevfan)
@jackiehaz
We Need to Kick Prediction Market Betting Out of Journalism While We Still Can
theintercept.com/2026/04/28/kalshi-polymarket-news-journa… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Barely above the lizard man constant.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
This seems remarkably low!
I wonder what you’d get asking Republicans about Democrats and vice versa.
Or for more a direct comparison, ask Christians about someone who mocks Christ.
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
6.6% of Muslims in Denmark think that the cartoonists at Charlie Hebdo deserved to die. A further 11% are not sure.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
This seems remarkably low!
I wonder what you’d get asking Republicans about Democrats and vice versa.
Or for more a direct comparison, ask Christians about someone who mocks Christ.
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
6.6% of Muslims in Denmark think that the cartoonists at Charlie Hebdo deserved to die. A further 11% are not sure.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I told these high school econ students that, contrary to many, the subject is NOT "counterintuitive."
It is, rather, counter-emotional.
www.betonit.ai/p/economics-is-counter-emotional-not -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The worst Chinese policy not imposed by Mao.
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
The one-child policy was way more barbaric than most people realize
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Is this the best data on this question? ChatGPT couldn't come up with an answer for me.
Benjamin Wolf 🇺🇦
@benbawan
For the first time in recorded history, more Americans are moving to 🇪🇺🇨🇭🇬🇧 EU+EFTA+UK countries each year than Europeans from those places are moving to the 🇺🇸 US.
The ratio was 4:1 in favour of the US in the early 2000s. It crossed parity around 2022.
This is new. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Once you see CPI bias, you see it everywhere.
Karthik Tadepalli
@karthiktadepall
if only most econ papers had this good of a first paragraph
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
Sex trafficking is basically a made up problem.
nicholasdecker.substack.com/p/either-dishonest-incompeten… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
Of course only an idiot would say Britain was communist. With oil, gas, telephones, coal, steel, railroads, electricity, trucking, canals all nationalized; with a completely state run healthcare system; with no one able to build anything without government permission; rationing on meat, bread, and sundries; no one able to hold foreign currency until 1979; arbitrary freezes on dividends; a 98% tax on investment income; with government ownership of the major producers of transportation; with frequent statutory pay raises and freezes across all industry; a third of all housing state-owned; with industrial planning done by the government, and them taking equity stakes in major industrial concerns; with government spending half the GDP; with every import of industrial inputs requiring government permission from the Board of Trade — yes, truly, only a fool would say that they were communist.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It's not decisive, but large lasting net migration to X from Y despite a high switching cost is a strong sign that the average person prefers X to Y.
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
However! That does not actually identify which is a better place to live, on average, only the marginal returns for movers. Roy model and self-selection type deal
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Very nice essay, but I still predict that under open borders between the US and EU, net migration would clearly be in the US direction, to the tune of about 5M people per year.
Chris Arnade 🐢🐱🚌
@Chris_arnade
If you really want to go down the Euro-poor versus Ameri-poor wormhole, here’s a 3k word essay I wrote about it.
open.substack.com/pub/walkingtheworld/p/is-it-euro-poor-o… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
To be fair, they don't seem eager to get Canadians either.
Unless they annex them.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Indians are literally everything conservatives say they want in citizens.
But they're dark skinned.
So you basically get a perfect experiment.
Are people who complain about immigration just racist?
It turns out, the answer is yes. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Very nice essay, but I still predict that under open borders between the US and EU, net migration would clearly be in the US direction, to the tune of about 5M people per year.
Chris Arnade 🐢🐱🚌
@Chris_arnade
If you really want to go down the Euro-poor versus Ameri-poor wormhole, here’s a 3k word essay I wrote about it.
open.substack.com/pub/walkingtheworld/p/is-it-euro-poor-o… -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Arnade 🐢🐱🚌
@Chris_arnade
This is another example of why walking across an entire city, or a region passing through cities, gives you a better understanding of a place.
When you walk across Milan, or from Dusseldorf to Bonn, you see that Europe isn't nearly as economically wealthy as the US. If you stick to tourist centers -- London, Paris, Milan -- you only see the wealthiest, and not the often dreary suburban apartment block bleah where most people live
Giulio Mattioli
@giulio_mattioli
Income levels in Milan, Italy.
Incredibly concentric and huge differences between the richer city centre and the poorer peripheries tg24.sky.it/economia/2026/04/24/quartieri-piu-ricchi-redd… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
And once you add the public Ivies, where discriminatory policies are especially inexcusable, there are hundreds of thousands of spots.
Neetu Arnold
@neetu_arnold
One of my least favorite discourses that pops up every single year:
Casting high scoring students as lifeless robots to justify the admission of less qualified students
Also pretty dishonest to act like the only elite spots are at the 8 Ivies rather than the dozen or so other comparably elite universities. But the point doesn’t look so convincing when there are at least 35-40K elite spots -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The founders do but the customers don't!
Guive Assadi
@GuiveAssadi
Do you think they know about the other Doner Party?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
😲
cURL-y, vessel-spotter
@CurlyBlueEagle
The Simpsons is not unique in its portrayals of South Asians. Our dear leader Mamdani's mother, Bollywood director Mira Nair, makes movies with similarly clichéd stereotypes of Indian culture, packaged for a Western audience. Monsoon Wedding annoys the fuck out of me.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Anthony
@myonlinetrust
If you think the world is going to end in the next few years, and you own a home rather than renting…you don’t think the world is going to end in the next few years…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Anthony
@myonlinetrust
Owning any equity at all in a home when the end of the world comes is obviously stupid. If you have a home equity loan for 125% of the FMV, okay, you’re not a hypocrite.
Some of these people are authors and can sell their future copyrights. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Bingo, except 10% is too low of a premium for a multi-year bet.
Doctor Subtilis
@thesubtledoctor
How does the bet work? Do you give me money now and later if we live I pay you back plus 10%?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
That's why I only make this bet versus opponents with a public reputation.
Joshua A. Miller
@anotherpanacea
No, because I know how the bet works.
The real problem with Bryan's bet is that some people can take the prepayment and then be unable or unwilling to pay out when the contract elapses. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Facts not in evidence. Everything else in the universe asymptotes, and so will AI.
Alex Spinoza
@x_spinoza
How can both be rounding errors?
AI will either save us all from extinction permanently, or drive us all to extinction permanently. There is no middle path.
The superintelligence birthed by the singularity will have technological powers approaching that of God's. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Everyone in India I talked to credited all the remittances coming into Kerala from its multitudinous migrant workers.
Rishi Joe Sanu 🌐🗽🏙
@RishiJoeSanu
@tylercowen visited Kerala last year but limited it to a houseboat lunch. @bryan_caplan stuck to the North circuit and believed the whole of India was like New Delhi.
The GMU/Mercatus crowd should be all over Kerala considering that it's being celebrated as a communist success -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"No one took the bet. And they were wise not to." dcjournal.com/place-your-bets-on-humanity/
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Waiting for @Vince_Gilligan's call. 😏
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/04/dwarkes… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Congrats Dwarkesh! marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/04/dwarkes…
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I found that being male changes beliefs about economics by roughly 16% as much as a PhD in economics. econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/pdfs/whatmakespeoplethinklike…
Covfefe Anon
@CovfefeAnon
The general knowledge gap between men and women is huge and replicates across many studies
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Daniel J. Smith
@Smithdanj
Important point from Menger. The tendency of markets, outside of government-granted monopolies, is to move from monopoly to competition. The first person to set up an occupation in a town will, by definition, have a monopoly. But higher prices will attract competitors (absent artificial barriers). This is exactly the opposite tendency predicted by many socialists, who argued that competitive markets are always moving towards concentration. But, the movement from 1,000 hardware stores across the U.S., each with its local monopoly, to 2-4 major hardware chains competing in every locality, clearly increased relevant competition and eradicated monopoly.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
troon
@warty_dog
grabby aliens have plausibly had more economic impact than decision markets (in the form of youtube ad revenues), so shouldn't we judge that as a better idea?
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I never lost a moment’s sleep about the collapse of Communism – and nothing that’s happened in the ex-Communist world has given me second thoughts." www.betonit.ai/p/communism_revolhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hablo helado.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I keep telling you, you CAN bet on the end of the world!
The optimist pre-pays the pessimist, it's as simple as that.
www.betonit.ai/p/another-end-of-the-world-bet -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm happy to bet anyone with public reputation on this at 10:1, using this model bet.
AI is far more likely to save us from extinction than cause it, though both scenarios are rounding errors.
www.betonit.ai/p/another-end-of-the-world-bet -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
ChatGPT is pro-Apu. chatgpt.com/s/t_69ef8f7f947081919767a174e580af04
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Struggling for the sake of struggle" is, ironically, a fine description of Fukuyama's opposition to human cloning.
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
We can't imagine a utopia that lacks struggle.
-
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Today is the 30th anniversary of my first post on my best idea: decision markets. mason.gmu.edu/~rhanson/policymarkets.html
www.overcomingbias.com/p/my-best-idea-decision-markets -
Bryan Caplan reposted
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
On AI, it seems it is the left that is moving first to take a position, which is anti. The right doesn't yet have a position, but will predictably react to left's position, to become pro. This supports @bryan_caplan's view that the left is anti-market, while right is anti-left.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Very good.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Once you acknowledge the truism that AI output is speech, almost all regulation of AI is ipso facto illegal. Government has no more legal right to regulate AI than it has to regulate the New York Times. Even if you’re a convinced doomer, you have to admit that the danger of existing LLMs is not 'clear and present,' much less 'imminent.'"
www.betonit.ai/p/llms-and-scotus -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Buy my new *You Have No Right to Your Culture*, now on sale!
Order here: www.amazon.com/You-Have-Right-Your-Culture/dp/B0G5XW6TLK?… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Disagree. Populists embrace a wide range of trade-offs, like "I'm happy to pay extra at the store in order to save American jobs" and "I'm happy to pay more taxes to hire more ICE officers."
What populists don't like is exactly free-market capitalism.
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
Populists across the spectrum, left and right, hate economists. I joked its some puzzle but I think there's a simple reason. It's not about liking capitalism or something.
And the disagreement is almost always about how to reason about problems, not about values.
Populists want solutions. Economists offer trade-offs. I'm not the first to point this out but its a huge distinction.
A carbon tax doesn't solve climate change. It prices carbon so people make better decisions at the margin. To the populist, that sounds like accepting the problem.
Same with manufacturing. A tariff doesn't create jobs. It shifts them, from the millions of workers in industries that buy steel to the 160,000 who make it. To the populist, "protect American workers" sounds like a solution. To the economist, the question is: which American workers?
We can go down the list. Rent control intends to help renters. It produces housing shortages. The populist sees the economist opposing rent control and concludes: you don't care about poor people.
As Sowell put it: "The first lesson of economics is scarcity: there is never enough of anything to fully satisfy all those who want it. The first lesson of politics is to disregard the first lesson of economics."
I think, not surprising, the economists are right.
It's more than just two different approaches. Thinking in trade-offs forces you to trace each step: who actually bears the cost of a tariff, what happens to housing supply when you cap rents, how a carbon tax changes behavior at every margin.
You can't skip ahead to the answer. You have to follow the chain. This is why economists spend careers doing exactly this and still argue about the answers. That's what it looks like when you take the problems seriously.
The populist skips all of this based on some intuition pump. Think of the person on a group project who's so confident in the answer that they never bother learning the material. That's populist economic reasoning from inside the discipline. The confidence comes from not having looked at the trade-offs closely enough to see how hard they are.
Stewart is the populist left. Oren Cass is the populist right, and he's more dangerous because he sounds like an economist, and plays one on TV, without putting in the work of thinking about trade-offs. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I will happily pay $100k for a FULLY self-driving car - one that doesn't even have a steering wheel or pedals.
When do I first own this car? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm debating @MattBruenig for the Econoboi channel on Friday.
Topic: "What is the best policy response to poverty?" -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
This summer, I did one of the @DohaDebates.
Topic: Meritocracy
Me versus @DSMarkovits, Poornima Luthra, and @paragkhanna.
Super fun!
Full version: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gu268yAE-W8
Short version: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HYeKWxpt-I -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Maximally civilized societies don’t just respect members’ rights; they afford the same rights to all intelligent beings. Maximally barbaric societies, in contrast, see nothing wrong with murdering and robbing outsiders." www.betonit.ai/p/what-is-barbarism
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you want to understand the global economy, you'll learn far more from @OurWorldInData than the American Economic Review.
It's not even close! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"The same mentality that looks at petty problems and thinks, 'There ought to be a law' almost never thinks, 'This calls for a $.37 Pigovian tax.'"www.betonit.ai/p/donkeys-cant-sleep-in-bathtubs
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"If you currently earn $50k, @JustinWolfers' coefficient implies you’d need an extra $820,585 per year to increase your happiness by one lousy standard deviation. In math, that’s not '0 effect of income on happiness.' But in English, it basically is." www.betonit.ai/p/the_wolfers_equhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Maybe the best X essay.
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
For anyone wondering why I'm so critical of the Postliberal movement right now, here's a more detailed explanation where I work through my thoughts:
1. I didn't declare war on Postliberalism. Postliberalism declared war on economics, and specifically free-market economics. If you read the Postliberal literature going back for the last 20 years (at least), free-market or "libertarian" economics is the central scapegoat for almost every grievance that Postliberals have with the world, be it real or imagined.
2. For all their grousing about economics, most Postliberals don't understand economics at a fundamental level and don't exhibit any interest in educating themselves about what mainstream economists do or believe. They're as bad as the Marxists in this regard, and the modal Postliberal understanding of the field consists of an eclectic assemblage of conspiracist prejudices and cranky heterodox "alternative" schools of economic thought that they've pieced together based on perceived agreement with their ideological priors.
3. If the Postliberals were content to stay in their own lane of political theory and/or theology, I'd probably still disagree with them but I'd also be inclined to ignore them and leave them to their weird little corner. But again, they decided to declare war on economics - a subject they don't understand - and specifically, they decided to wage that war within what could be called the broader "conservative movement" umbrella.
4. The Postliberals' explicitly-stated objective in their "conservative movement" war - as openly articulated by Deneen, Pappin, and numerous other examples - is to drive the economic libertarians out of the umbrella. Economic libertarians have never been more than a minority faction under that umbrella, dating back to William F. Buckley's coalition with Milton Friedman and a few other like-minded economists in the mid 20th century. But it's been a fairly collegial home for them. They often disagree with others in the umbrella on some social and military issues, but it's always been within the realm of friendly debate. And more importantly, the economic libertarians entered the umbrella in the first place knowing full well that they weren't going to convert a bunch of conservative traditionalists to social libertarianism. So they never really tried that - all they wanted was an overlapping political alliance with conservatives who were mostly friendly to tax cuts, and who would at least pay lip service to deregulation and keeping government out of our economic lives.
5. By contrast, the Postliberals weren't even an original member of the "conservative movement" in the US and they didn't really start showing up at all until the late 2000s/early 2010s at most. Ever since they got there though, they've been on a discord-sowing mission to disrupt that coalition, put themselves in charge, and drive out the economic libertarians.
6. I'd readily concede that economic libertarians don't need to be a part of the aforementioned movement & most manage to do fine as an intellectual camp of their own. But setting aside the scapegoating and unprovoked warfare from the Postliberals, it's difficult to deny that the economic libertarians brought intellectual value to the rest of the conservative movement umbrella. Even if they weren't always listened to, they served as an economic conscience of the right - steering it away from the temptations of big government, adding intellectual rigor and depth for grappling with complex economic issues that inevitably emerge in the political world, and equipping it with arguments to answer the economic left and far-left (the latter being the major foil of the conservative movement in the 20th century due to communism, and remaining so today with the resurgence of socialist doctrine). The economic libertarians also tended to be more resilient than cultural conservatives to the various racist & antisemitic extremes that always hover around the periphery of any political movement, so they helped to keep that in check.
7. Since the Postliberals began their war to drive economic libertarians away, they've also sought to fill the void with other elements of the far-right that they perceive as being more conducive to their cultural and theocratic priorities. In doing so they apply almost no standards (other than ensuring that whoever they're making an alliance with at the moment is not an economic libertarian.) That includes opening the door - previously shut by Buckley and others - to racist cranks, anti-semites, conspiracy theorists, and similar garbage that's now running rampant on the hyper-online right wing "influencer" scene. The evidence of this is overwhelming, from Postliberal promotion of weird little blogs run by white nationalists, to Postliberal celebrations of racist apocalyptic novels like Camp of the Saints, to the Postliberal embrace of racist crackpots like Curtis Yarvin, to Postliberal coziness with authoritarian political figures like Viktor Orban, to an increasing Postliberal tolerance of bizarre boundary-pushing conspiracism (e.g. Tucker Carlson's obsessive promotion of WWII revisionists who openly flirt with Holocaust denial). It's difficult to deny that these new coalition partners have made the conservative intellectual ecosystem worse off. And some parts of it have become toxic sewers full of the worst caricatures that the left could ever dream up about the far-right.
8. Adding to the spillovers from the sewer they've opened, Postliberals have become increasingly strident about attacking other core tenets of the conservative movement's intellectual tradition, namely the American Founding. This hostility was always a latent part of Postliberalism, again going back to the stuff Deneen, Pappin, and others were writing in the 2000s and early 2010s. But as their communitarian and religious brand of "conservatism" has become more assertive, it's also begun to clash more directly with the limited government, individualistic, and, yes, philosophically libertarian dimensions of the American founding - dimensions that are pretty much hard-coded into our constitutional system and founding documents. This has led many Postliberals of late to focus their energies on discrediting the American founding as well by portraying it as another corrupted and overly-individualistic extension of economic libertarianism. In the political sphere, it's also made them perfectly willing to run roughshod over basic constitutional norms and principles in order to obtain greater political power. There is no better illustration of this latter development in action than Deneen protege and self-described Postliberal JD Vance.
9. When you confront Postliberals about any of the problems I've mentioned above, the best you'll ever get out of them is a shrug and a sneer. They're wholly unbothered by what they've unleashed, and many of them seem to relish in it. They view the things they are destroying as obstacles to political power that need to be overcome so that they can better wield it. And they view the racist, conspiracist garbage they are unleashing as an acceptable and even welcome price to pay to position themselves in places of power and influence. Postliberals are wholly unbothered by the unethical practices and behaviors they've unleashed, and the harms they've caused, because in their minds the Postliberal end goal is innately "virtuous" and they are its embodiment.
10. While I don't need the world to have a healthy conservative intellectual ecosystem (and not any more than I need it to have a healthy progressive intellectual ecosystem), I much prefer to live in a world where the conservative ecosystem (and the progressive ecosystem) are at least rigorous, thoughtful, honest about their intentions and disagreements, and willing to tolerate debate in their respective ranks. The toxicity of Wokeness and the Critical Theory turn on the left came about roughly a decade ago because its ecosystem ceased to tolerate dissent in its own ranks, drove out intellectual rigor, and replaced it with a sewer of crazy, vicious, and hate-driven far-left activism. With the Postliberals, I see the same patterns playing out on the right. And both of those developments have unambiguous negative spillover effects on society at large because they are politically assertive in ways that inevitably push the sewage they've cultivated out into the societal mainstream. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
A world of heroes.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"What country has ever suffered from cosmopolitan tolerance run amok? From focusing on people’s common humanity rather than superficial differences? From judging people on their merits instead of their origins?"
www.betonit.ai/p/natives_are_badhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Simply strolling around New York makes nativism intellectually and emotionally hard to sustain. Ubiquitous foreigners educate far more effectively than holier-than-thou preaching ever could." www.betonit.ai/p/natives_are_badhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I hope this is for real.
You always have to wonder.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
BREAKING: The George Mason University Board of Visitors just shut down DEI and affirmed its commitments to merit and non-discrimination in admissions and hiring.
“Ensure that all University programs, policies, practices, and actions in every regard comply with the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and other federal civil rights law. […] This includes, but is not limited to, the consideration of race, color, or national origin in admissions, hiring, promotion, compensation, financial aid, scholarships, prizes, administrative support, discipline, housing, graduation ceremonies, and all other aspects of student, academic, and campus life.”
“Ensure there are no efforts by the University or any of its departments, colleges, or employees to circumvent prohibitions on the use of race, color, or national origin by relying on proxies or other indirect means to accomplish such ends.”
“The University's Office of Access, Compliance, and Community (OACC) is hereby directed to eliminate all programs, trainings, processes not specifically required for federal or state law or University Policy compliance, and if necessary, eliminate staff positions, within 30 days of the date of this Resolution.”
“The Access to Research and Inclusive Excellence (ARIE) program is hereby dissolved and any and all conferences on ‘anti-racism,’ implicit bias, and inclusive excellence that are inconsistent with federal law are prohibited.”
“The University shall immediately prohibit any and all departments, colleges, or employees of George Mason University from requiring diversity statements for any potential employee, for promotion of current employees, for faculty tenure considerations, or for any other purpose.” -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“My main complaint about Why Not Capitalism? is that Brennan doesn’t take Cohen to task for conflating voluntary and involuntary socialism.” www.betonit.ai/p/ownership_for_chtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I tell you from first-hand experience that @GeorgeMasonU is totally guilty. Instead of lawyering up, top admins should admit guilt, resign, and make way for replacements who embrace colorblind neutrality.
www.ed.gov/about/news/press-release/us-department-of-educ… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"When you 'advocate capitalism,' don’t you risk alienating all of the people who hate the status quo but might come to love the free market? It’s possible, but I doubt it." www.betonit.ai/p/should_libertarians_oppose_capitalismhtml
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Never gets old.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“If you’re so smart, why aren’t you rich?” is a less formidable challenge than “If you’re so smart, why aren’t you happy?”
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“If 18% of biologists believed in creationism, that would be a big deal. Why? Because creationism is nonsense. Similarly, if 18% of social scientists believe in Marxism, that too is a big deal. Why? Because Marxism is nonsense.” www.betonit.ai/p/the_prevalence_1html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
In the long-run, even cuts to STEM funding are very good. Top STEM researchers belong in industry, not academia.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"My talk on Selfish Reasons to Have More Kids went well. As far as I know, I’m the only Natal-Con speaker who even claimed to have successfully raised fertility through his work." www.betonit.ai/p/reflections-on-natal-con
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“Even if you believe capitalism is designed to keep workers obediently working for peanuts, where is the profit in fostering a subculture of impulsive sex, poor work habits, substance abuse, violence, and cruelty to children?” www.betonit.ai/p/whos-afraid-of-oscar-lewis
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Timeless.
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Suppose X is an ugly but obvious truth.
What share of people will, if publicly asked, say they believe X? -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Impressive that @BrianLeiter didn't scrub these pro-Chavez posts.
2004: leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2004/08/hugo_chavezs_cr.html
2006: leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2006/02/let_the_dogs_of_1.…
2007: leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2007/02/has_hugh_chavez.html
Video of the 2020 Caplan-Leiter Capitalism versus Socialism Debate: www.betonit.ai/p/leiter-caplan-capitalism-vs-socialism-de… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Hey, @metaculus has a new forecasting tournament! Have a crystal ball? PROVE IT.
www.metaculus.com/bridgewater/ -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
With one notable exception, Metaculus is bullish on me. www.metaculus.com/project/caplan/
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
It is no hyperbole to say that freedom of thought and speech is more repressed today than under McCarthyism. www.betonit.ai/p/loyalty-oaths-compared-an-orwellian-exer…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Very good discussion of an obscure yet thought-provoking passage from Arthur Jensen.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Since people are talking about the meaning and implications of extremely low IQs, I'll add something I think everyone should understand: an IQ of 70 is used to indicate* mental retardation because of what it tends to be caused by in certain populations.
This is a roundabout way of saying that a low IQ indicates mental retardation because of what it means for a person's behavior, which, I'll explain, covaries with its causes.
IQs are mostly normally distributed, and IQs represent the influences of multiple different constructs and causes, but they primarily reflect differences in general intelligence.
But there's a major deviation from normality at the lower-end of the scale. If you sample well enough, you'll see something like this:
The reason is that there are the normal-range causes that produce the normal distribution, and then there are extreme circumstances that produce extraordinarily low IQs. Contrarily, we don't know of anything that produces abnormally high IQs. There's no known one-off mutation that makes someone a genius, but there are many mutations that we now know can make a person extremely unintelligent.
Consider this diagram from a recent paper by @AlexTISYoung:
A few very rare protein-truncating variants have enormous negative effects on a person's educational attainment! But nothing we know of has enormous positive effects.
As the saying goes, it's far easier to break a machine than to throw a wrench in it and make it work. And that makes sense! Your wrench in the gears is likely to break something, not increase efficiency by 50%. If you hit someone in the head hard enough, you can reduce their IQ score, but not in a million years will you turn them into von Neumann.
The reason someone's IQ drops after you bludgeon them is more singular and specific than the reasons IQ varies in the general population. A hit to the noggin may leave someone unable to flex their short-term memory, even if their visuospatial rotation capabilities are unaffected. There's some degree of isolation of function and compensation for deficits in the brain. We know this thanks to many observations, like on the effects of neural lesions (I'll link something fun on this topic with the sources at the end).
When we say that someone with an IQ of ≤70 is mentally retarded**, we're saying that they lack adaptive behavior—that they're not very bright, and so it makes living life hard.
But if a population legitimately has a mean IQ of 70 (and some do!), we'll notice that they're not drooling troglodytes who can't put on their shoes. This is because the reasons for their low IQ are not things that cause specific and extreme deficits, but instead, things that cause normal-range variation, which is far less severe in nature.
One of the ways we know IQ is normally distributed is also a way that we know different causes are at work in certain cases of intellectual disability: sibling comparisons!
In large Israeli (B) and Swedish (A) datasets, we can see that when a person has a mild intellectual disability, their sibling tends to be less intelligent too. You also see this for heights, autism, or any other highly polygenic trait.
But when a sibling has severe—AKA, "idiopathic"—intellectual disability, the distribution of their sibling's IQs is the same as the distribution for the general population.
The deficits in adaptive behavior that result from idiopathic intellectual disability are ones that often make life hard to live in discrete and extreme ways. In some cases, you wouldn't even recognize them as being "retarded" because they have conditions like amnesia, where the person is clearly odd and unfortunate, and they score poorly on an IQ test, but they might sound totally coherent otherwise.
Normal-range causes lead to linear changes in adaptive behavior; idiopathic mental retardation, leads to a discontinuous decrease in adaptive behavior.
Accordingly, an IQ of 70 does not have the same meaning for members of different groups, since if a group with a mean IQ of 70 randomly pulls a person with an IQ of 70, they aren't likely to score like someone who's mentally retarded for idiopathic reasons.
Jensen, incidentally, predicted this sort of result based on some observations he made as an educator.
"My student said he was looking for a good culture-free or culture-fair test of intelligence and had not been able to find one. All the tests he used, whether they were claimed to be culture-fair or not, were in considerable agreement with respect to children diagnosed as educationally mentally retarded (EMR), by which they were assigned to special small classes offering a different instructional program from that in the regular classes. To qualify for this special treatment, children had to have IQs below 75 as well as lagging far behind their age-mates in scholastic performance. My student, who had examined many of these backward pupils himself, had gained the impression that the tests were quite valid in their assessments of white middle-class children but not of minority lower-class children.
"Many of the latter, despite IQs below 75 and markedly poor scholastic performance, did not seem nearly as retarded as the white middle-class children with comparable IQs and scholastic records. Middle-class white children with IQs in the EMR range generally appeared more retarded than the minority children who were in special classes. Using nonverbal rather than verbal tests did not appreciably alter the problem. I confirmed my students observations for myself by observing EMR children in their classes and on the playground and by discussing their characteristics with a number of teachers and school psychologists. My student’s observations proved reliable.
"EMR children who were called ‘culturally disadvantaged’, as contrasted with middle-class EMR children, appeared much brighter socially and on the playground, often being quite indistinguishable in every way from children of normal IQ except in their scholastic performance and in their scores on a variety of standard IQ tests. Middle-class white children diagnosed as EMR, on the other hand, though they constituted a much smaller percentage of the EMR classes, usually appeared to be more mentally retarded all round and not just in their performance in scholastic subjects and IQ tests. I asked myself, how could one devise a testing procedure that would reveal this distinction so that it could be brought under closer study and not depend upon casual observations and impressions."
The distinction between types of mental retardation that are demarcated by their symptoms and, thus, by their causes, is important to understand. It's why an IQ of 70 for a Japanese person is likely to indicate an extraordinarily severe issue in need of attention, while for a Bushman, they won't have any trouble surviving.
A low normal-range IQ score is bad, but depending on its causes, it's likely to come with different symptoms that make it more or less bad. Final note: this does have implications for the use of IQ as a means of mitigating the punishment of serious criminals on death row.
Sources:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168952523001671
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289621000659
www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1508093112
www.emilkirkegaard.com/p/african-iqs-and-mental-retardation
* Indicate, not diagnose.
** This is not how mental retardation is actually diagnosed, despite popular misconception. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
The exchange between @coldxman and @TEDchris reminded me of this. open.substack.com/pub/betonit/p/dear_identity_phtml?r=73ulk
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Back in 2006, I wrote a critique of eugenics-inspired immigration restrictions. In 2010, youthful Richard Hanania wrote this reply under his now-notorious alt-right pseudonym, Richard Hoste. The following essay was my reply to his reply."
betonit.substack.com/p/the_social_andhtml -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Always amazed that smart people don’t abhor the French Revolution.
Europe was laid waste for a QUARTER CENTURY, and for what?! -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
-
Post not available here, view on X
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Read up on the two topics that get the most votes.
"Closely compare Epstein’s exact claims with the evidence the nominators decided to highlight.
"Publish the results of my audit." (2/2) -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Attention!
@brianmdoherty isn't just one of my favorite living historians. I also owe him bigtime for graphic novel education.
Now you can pre-order his new *DIRTY PICTURES* and save 25% on the eBook with code PREORDER25:
www.barnesandnoble.com/w/dirty-pictures-brian-doherty/114… -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you haven't heard, @robertwiblin's @80000Hours podcast is the best. Our latest convo: 80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/bryan-caplan-parenting-wo…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
What is the world's most influential political party that uses the word "Capitalism" or "Capitalist" in its name?
As a positive. "Anti-Capitalist" parties don't count. -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“While I’m not a utilitarian, the utilitarian case against abortion seems very strong.”
www.econlib.org/archives/2015/04/where_are_the_p.html -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Recommended libertarian compromise: The FDA should be shuttered out of an abundance of caution until such time as they master cost-benefit analysis and statistics." - a friend
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"I will never apologize for politely saying or writing anything that seems reasonable to me... except under extreme duress.
"So if I ever do so apologize, please assume extreme duress."
www.econlib.org/a-precommitment/ -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
If you're going to re-open something, don't re-open it with restricted hours. That increases congestion and impedes social distancing.
www.econlib.org/so-congested-no-one-goes-there-anymore/ -
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
According to @TheEconomist, my book with @ZachWeiner is both good and meta-good: www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2019/12/12/the-case-for-…
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Suppose a democratically-elected government will become, with probability X, a Maduro-level dictatorship before the next election. For what values of X is a *bloodless* coup justified?
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I wouldn't take even odds, so that was always the expectation. But we're only a few years into a 15-year bet, so I won't start fretting until 2025 or so. :-)
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
Two of my favorite pages from @standupecon's #cartoonclimate, now (June 5) on sale: econlog.econlib.org/archives/2014/06/cartoon_introdu_1.html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I give @standupecon Yoram Bauman the last word in our exchange on #cartoonclimate: econlog.econlib.org/archives/2014/05/cartoon_introdu_3.html
-
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
"Immigrants are stealing our jobs" is the nativist version of "You didn't build that." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_didn't_build_that





































































































































































































































































































