Ray Lewis looking to become a head coach
Following the Deion Sanders-to-Colorado model, Hall-of-Fame linebacker Ray Lewis has emerged as a candidate to become the next head coach at Florida Atlantic University, sources tell ESPN.
Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts of popular accounts freely available. Read more.
Martin Adel Makary () is an Egyptian-American-British surgeon, professor, author, and medical commentator, who served as the 27th FDA commissioner from 2025 to 2026. He has practiced surgical oncology and gastrointestinal laparoscopic surgery at Johns Hopkins Hospital, was the Mark Ravitch Chair in Gastrointestinal Surgery at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, and was the chief of Islet Transplant Surgery at Johns Hopkins. Makary completed his surgical residency at Georgetown University and sub-specialty training in surgical oncology and gastrointestinal surgery at Johns Hopkins under John Cameron, later joining Cameron's faculty practice. He is now Professor Emeritus at Johns Hopkins. More on Wikipedia
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Ray Lewis looking to become a head coach
Following the Deion Sanders-to-Colorado model, Hall-of-Fame linebacker Ray Lewis has emerged as a candidate to become the next head coach at Florida Atlantic University, sources tell ESPN.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Thanks Senator @CoryBooker for your long history of leadership on this issue. You have been a champion, particularly against the systematic poisoning of Black and Hispanic Americans with processed and chemically laden foods through the SNAP and school lunch programs. Let's work together to end this.
For years I have been raising the alarm of the dangers of our current food system. We’re prioritizing corporations feeding us unhealthy products instead of family farmers growing fresh, healthy foods - and we let too many dangerous chemicals flood our food system.
We all must come together to build a system that works for all.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Fattest, Sickest Country On Earth Concerned New Health Secretary Might Do Something Different babylonbee.com/news/fattest-sickest-country-on-earth-conc…
If you think the current medical system is effective in addressing our childhood chronic disease epidemic, then there's nothing of interest here: www.sensible-med.com/p/why-doctors-should-learn-to-stop @Sensible__Med @DrJMarine
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
My new article with @KevinBardosh in @unherd. The medical establishment lost public trust over its covid failure. Now it smears @RobertKennedyJr because he threatens their interests. They should instead support reform to make medicine trustworthy again.
unherd.com/newsroom/rfk-jr-will-disrupt-the-us-medical-es…
Dr. Casey Means has a gift of succinctly explaining what’s wrong with health care today. There should be nothing partisan about finally addressing the root causes of our chronic disease epidemic.
Dr. Casey Means Wows Liberal Audience and Gets Them to CHEER for RFK Jr.'s HHS Nomination
“If we were crushing it [at health], we would not be spending 2x every other country in the entire world and have the lowest life expectancy of any developed country in the entire world.”
“We are the sickest of the top 11 high-income countries in the world. We have the highest infant and maternal mortality rates, and our life expectancy is 10 years less than our friends in Japan and Switzerland right now.”
“The words 'chronic illness,' as far as I know, never came out of the Harris campaign's mouth. And I think that was a real misstep because Americans are, I think, tired of being gaslit about the fact that there's not a problem right now. And when we look around us, we know there is.”
“And Trump has asked RFK to do three simple things. He's asked to get the corruption out of the U.S. health agencies, produce uncompromised evidence-based research for our health guidelines, and reverse the trends of the chronic disease epidemic in two years for children and adults so that we can show up for our 250th anniversary of America stronger than ever. That sounds pretty good to me.”
(Audience Cheers)
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
There is a generational opportunity to reverse the childhood chronic disease crisis and be the healthiest country in the world.
Blind Spots has just been named to Amazon's 20 Best Non-fiction Books of 2024.
Thank you @PeterAttiaMD @kavitapmd @CaseyMeansMD @dhrupurohit @maxlugavere @ShawnModel @SteveForbesCEO @drmarkhyman @drdrew @megynkelly et al for your support! Let's go #maha
www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
Antibiotics save lives. But are also MASSIVELY overused, needlessly damaging the gut microbiome, accelerating superbugs, and costing Americans billions in health care costs. Let's talk about root causes #maha
Nothing like a great discussion with @DrJBhattacharya & @Bryce_Nickels after a long day at the hospital!!
Check out the new documentary film: "Thank You, Dr. Fauci" tydfmovie.com
PREVIEW - Conversations with Jay Bhattacharya: Dr. Marty Makary (author, health care expert)
@MartyMakary describes how, in Oct 2014, he first became suspicious of Anthony Fauci when an Ebola patient was moved from a Texas hospital to the NIH just so Fauci could get a photo op
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
@MartyMakary , just finished reading blind spots. Great read .
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
As America faces deep divides over the election and the direction of our country, one thing remains clear: the chronic disease epidemic needs our attention now more than ever.
This crisis is touching every family, every community, and our healthcare system.
We can spend our energy pointing fingers and deepening divides, or we can come together, identify common goals, and take action.
Let’s work together—across political lines—to find real solutions for our nation’s health and well-being. The future of our nation depends on it.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Dr. Leon Festinger's "milestone psychology experiments showed that humans automatically default to rejecting new information or reframing it in order to ensure that old information in the brain remains true. It's a subconscious effort to avoid the mental distress, or cognitive dissonance, of holding two conflicting ideas at the same time. Being open to new ideas makes one smarter, less prickly, and more affable--key ingredients of success in life."
- Dr. @MartyMakary in "Blind Spots"
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🚨Announcement: We are honored to welcome @MartyMakary to our Advisory Board🚨
Dr. Makary is a surgeon & public policy researcher at Johns Hopkins University, member of the National Academy of Medicine, & author of 3 NYT bestselling books, including his new book "Blind Spots"
The only place I will hug a random drunk guy. Touchdown @Ravens !
Love seeing the dome go purple when I walk out of the hospital. it’s going to be a great game! @Ravens town night
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🚨WOW: Biden comments on Trump's victory
"You can't love your country only when you win. Something I hope we can do is see each other as fellow Americans. Bring down the temperature."
"the health care sector spent over $750 million lobbying the federal government for special treatment just last year." That's roughly 6X what the military-industrial complex spends on lobbying. Good article @chiproytx
2 steps to #healthcarefreedom. 1) End cronyism feeding us poisoned food & making a quick buck off the “cure.” 2) free the system w/ direct primary care & HSA’s to destroy third-parties denying affordable & personal care from the Dr. of our choice. #maha
thehill.com/opinion/4968311-health-care-freedom-solution/
Univ of Chicago will name their cancer center after Pharma giant & mega-donor Abbvie:
The Abbvie Cancer Center
Will they study what's causing cancer?
Or just focus on chemo, radiation & surgery?
Amazing what U. Chicago will do for $75M, even if the new name scares off patients
I have a new piece on the University of Chicago becoming the Abbvie Cancer Center
"Finally, it does not escape me that the University of Chicago is not only a prostitute, but a cheap one at that..."
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/medicine-is-becoming-more-corrupt
NEW CDC REPORT: 85% of health care workers have said NO THANK YOU to the COVID vaccine booster 2023-24 shot for themselves*
This low uptake in acute hospitals follows a massive push by the CDC dir. & FDA commissioner--the nation's chief drug regulator.
www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/73/wr/mm7343a2.htm
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Two generic drugmakers, Apotex and Heritage Pharmaceuticals, have agreed to pay a combined $49 million to settle allegations they fixed prices on numerous medicines. www.statnews.com/pharmalot/2024/10/31/generics-antitrust-…
Not that I just checked, but BLIND SPOTS is outselling Hilary Clinton's new book, despite her massive media tour.
In a cafe in NYC. Love to see it 💪
@MartyMakary #blindspots
So good to spend time with the amazing @JaniceDean to talk about HEALTH. And modern medicine’s giant blind spots today: www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
Why is it so difficult for Americans to lead a healthy lifestyle? @MartyMakary joins @JaniceDean to explain why the experts sometimes get it wrong, as detailed in his new book, 'Blind Spots.'
link.chtbl.com/janicedean?sid=fnr.tw
5 weeks on the NYT bestseller list (now #13) and going strong
This week I finished "Blind Spots" by @MartyMakary and I can say the accolades are well-deserved. Marty does a great job of covering many of medicine's missteps and how physicians/researchers were treated despite being right all along! www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health-ebook/dp…
We have an epidemic of medical dogma
The most dangerous type of misinformation is when government officials like Mandy make false statements. There is no evidence that this fall booster will lower the rate of long covid. The CDC has failed to demand randomized studies. Disgraceful conduct
The private company that controls every medical school should invite @CaseyMeansMD @PeterAttiaMD @drmarkhyman & others to speak about how to reform medical education. www.wsj.com/opinion/medical-school-accreditation-is-outda…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“Although more doses are expected in the coming weeks, this shortage poses significant challenges to outbreak response efforts and hampers efforts to control the spread of the disease." medicalxpress.com/news/2024-10-world-cholera-vaccine-stoc…
Wishing the best health for Xavier Newman 🙏🙏
4 weeks on the N.Y.Times bestseller list and going strong! #maha www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
I love the bedwettingandaccidents.com blog! www.bedwettingandaccidents.com/single-post/blind-spots-br…
New Study: Nonprofit hospitals avoided paying $37B in taxes/yr. While
➡️ FEMA only has $750 for Helene victims
➡️ Nat debt hits record highs
➡️ Sm businesses taxed @ 21-37%
➡️ Some hospitals price gouge
The ruling class has a way of writing their own rules
jamanetwork-com.proxy1.library.jhu.edu/journals/jama/arti…
IMO, A hospital corporation that is evading federal price transparency rules and price gouges patients with predatory billing practices, should NOT be enjoying IRS tax exempt status intended for American charities.
Great work by my @JHUCarey colleagues @GeBaiDC @dr_msocal Elizabeth Plummer @TCUNeeley
GLP-1 drugs could cost Medicare a fortune, diverting funds from other medical services.
If Medicare covers GLP-1s, CBO projects federal spending would rise by $35.5B from 2026 to 2034, with drug costs outpacing savings.
Even with lower per-user costs over time, uptake and long-term use will keep expenses high. Policymakers must weigh the fiscal impact carefully.
3 weeks on the NYT bestseller list and going strong! www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I am glad the FDA Commissioner understand the obesity crisis is caused by ultra-processed food...
He also acknowledges the Orwellian nature of solving this issue by drugging them...
The next step is changing where DOLLARS flow to reflect these views.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Why is America facing record levels of obesity and illness despite advanced healthcare? @ravimgupta sits down with @MartyMakary to dive into medical misconceptions that have impacted public health, explore how our food system, healthcare corruption, and media misinformation are fueling a crisis of trust, and the bipartisan push to fix the system.
Amazing. I will not be buying any @KelloggsUS products, until they address this.
‼️The largest grassroots action on food ingredients in US history.
Through the leadership of @thefoodbabe and @humankarp, more than 400,000 Americans signed a petition for @kelloggsus to use the same ingredients for American children they do in other counties. We also launched shareholder action against the company that made it to the boardroom.
In Europe, the company uses carrot and watermelon juice for coloring. In the U.S., it uses petroleum based colors that are brighter but cause ADHD.
To change our food system, we need to change our suicidal incentives from the top down (which we are working on with our advocacy and @TrueMedPayments which enables tax free spending on the right medicine) and bottoms up advocacy.
We will be delivering these signatures to Kellogg HQ today and hopefully meeting with leadership. I would also urge all families to refrain from buying food with ingredients that knowingly harm kids (artificial colors and added sugars are two good places to start).
Some are saying, “The cereal is still terrible even without the artificial colors.” I don’t disagree, but we need to start racking up SPECIFIC wins. The status quo wants us to stay broad - they have rigged the system through these targeted efforts, and that’s how we will change it.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Health care mask mandates are returning to some regions this fall. But are public health officials considering the downsides? My article in @Sensible__Med @VPrasadMDMPH @drjohnm @adamcifu @MartyMakary @StopMaskingKids Masking Mistakes – Fall 2024 Edition open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/masking-mistakes-fall…
What ignited the modern-day peanut allergy epidemic? An excerpt of my new book published in this week's The Harvard Gazette.
Thank you everyone for your interest in the book (geni.us/blindspots). 3 wks on the New York Times bestseller list & counting! news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2024/10/excerpt-from-blind…
Prolonged school closures were not a failure of science, they were a failure of government
Nice moment at the Pandemic Policy Panel between @MartyMakary and Doug Owens: Makary (correctly) laments that U.S. experts and policymakers ignored European data about reopening schools and Owens responds by (accurately) pointing out hyperlocal control of education made absorbing and acting on data difficult.
A good example of civil discourse bringing important information to the surface.
youtu.be/V2RLBBk83jI?t=2638
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Gates, Clinton, and Obama say governments must censor "health misinformation" to restore public trust. They must not. Doing so prevents knowing what helps and what harms. "The reason people don't trust the medical establishment," says @MartyMakary, "is because it lied to them."
Wow
This person writes for The Atlantic.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🎥 Missed our Site-Nuetral event? Catch up with this key clip where former HHS Secretary @Sebelius explains why a site-neutral payments model does not impact the quality of care. #bipartisanagreement
Watch the full event recording here⬇️
paragoninstitute.org/event/medicare-site-neutral-payments…
Committee report recommends institutional neutrality for university record.umich.edu/articles/committee-recommends-institutio…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Enjoyed talking to @MartyMakary yesterday on the Lost Debate Show for @thebranchmedia about the crisis of trust in our healthcare system. There's more common ground across the political spectrum than conventional wisdom suggests. Listen below 👇
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SdXWNWBxptc
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Surgeon and Professor of Medicine at Johns Hopkins University @MartyMakary joins The @RichZeoli Show for a special long-form discussion about his New York Times bestselling book: “Blind Spots: When Medicine Gets It Wrong, and What It Means for Our Health.”
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I just interviewed the great @MartyMakary about his new book Blind Spots. Spitting facts and explaining the group-thinky mistakes that lead to bad medicine. He's one of the good ones. Tomorrow night.
www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/B0DCW…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The #aca was sold to the American people on false premises.
The Falsehoods of Obamacare: 12 Broken Promises, Seven Million Canceled Plans, and Hundreds of Billion in Debt
🚨NEW🚨paper with @Comm4Prosperity from @brian_blase, @caseybmulligan & @kerpen ⬇️
paragoninstitute.org/private-health/the-falsehoods-of-oba…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Absolutely LOVED his book! Devoured it immediately and got it on audible so I can share my copy everywhere!
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The medical industry censors doctors and scientists in the name of "science." Listen to what Dr. @martymakary has to say about our "health care" industry. @PragerU: l.prageru.com/4ewZXFY
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
WATCH: Joe Rogan's brain explodes when he learns that 80% of US medical schools don't require a SINGLE nutrition course.
"Wow!"
And 95% of the people on the USDA food guidelines have a conflict of interest with the food industry.
Dr. Casey Means was stunned to learn that simply taking 7,000 steps per day “can slash your risk of obesity, type 2 diabetes, Alzheimer's, dementia, and even gastric reflux by 40% to 60%.”
This was something she was never taught in medical school. Americans are only taking 3500 steps per day on average.
Moreover, US medical schools also don't teach students about sunlight and sleep, which is “pretty foundational for human health,” @CaseyMeansMD says.
Doctors are trained to be pill pushers or surgeons, and not much else. This is the state of medicine in the United States.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
.@CaseyMeansMD and @calleymeans mic drop
Joe Rogan Goes Quiet as Dr. Casey Means Drops a Series of Disturbing Health Stats
“We are getting destroyed, and it's very recent, and it's accelerating.”
• “74% of Americans are overweight or obese.”
• “Young adult cancers are going up 79% in the last 10 years.”
• “25% of men now under 40 have erectile dysfunction.”
• “50%, now, of American adults have type 2 diabetes or prediabetes. These were diseases where there was 1% of Americans in 1950 had type 2 diabetes. Now it's 50% of Americans have prediabetes or type 2 diabetes.”
• “Alzheimer's, dementia are going through the roof.”
• “Young adult dementias have increased, like, three times since 2012. So early onset dementias.”
• “One in two Americans are expected to have cancer in their lifetime now, one in two.”
• “One in 36 children has autism now, in the United States. That was one in 150 in the year 2000.”
• “In California, where I live, [Autism rates are] one in 22. One in 22 with a lifetime neurodevelopmental disorder.”
• “Infertility going up 1% per year.”
• “77% of young Americans can't serve in the military because of obesity or drug abuse.”
• “Autoimmune diseases. Some studies are saying they're going up 13% per year.”
• “Heart disease, which is almost totally preventable, is the leading cause of death in the United States, killing around 800,000 people per year.”
“It's basically like all of us are a little bit dead while we're alive,” @CaseyMeansMD said.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Tomorrow afternoon, I'll be hosting Dr. @MartyMakary on The Saad Truth. We'll be discussing his latest book:
www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
I highly encourage everyone to watch this incredible interview to truly understand American health care.
Diseases are ⬆️ rapidly causing widespread suffering--more meds are not the answer. It's time to talk root causes @CaseyMeansMD @calleymeans @joerogan youtu.be/G0lTyhvOeJs
4 weeks ago @megynkelly predicted BLIND SPOTS would sell out nationwide on opening day... and that's EXACTLY what happened!
It's now re-stocked: everywhere books are sold 👉 geni.us/blindspots
2wks on the NYT bestseller list & going strong! TY all for believing in health!
Medicating more children is not the answer. Chronic diseases are surging right in front of our eyes… it’s time to address the root causes.
If an unbiased observer analyzed the stats, they would conclude the U.S. Government declared war on children starting in the 1980's.
Yet nearly every "healthcare expert" is arguing for incremental change - not wholesale reform.
The incredible power of eggs!
Dispelling health misinformation in geni.us/blindspots
So happy to see this wonderful gathering taking place!
I am on chapter 7 of the book on Audible — truly eye opening stuff. Along with the learnings, I’m enjoying an egg in honor of Uncle Sam 😉
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Congrats to my good friend, @MartyMakary, on his new book Blind Spots, which gives a fantastic perspective on the history of medical group think & hubris. These sound like esoteric topics, but the reality is they led and are leading to extensive and avoidable harms to patients & the public.
Though he purposely avoids mentioning it, that the same unfortunate patterns emerged during covid should surprise no one (at least no one who knows their medical history).
Bravo, Marty; 5 stars.
Link to purchase here (I loved the 🎧 version!) www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
Great day @Stanford
So much fun seeing @MartyMakary & @VPrasadMDMPH at the @Stanford Pandemic Policy conference. Both such gifted, humorous teachers; they have changed the way I view many topics in medicine & public health
Check out their podcasts and Marty’s wonderful new book, Blind Spots 1/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Ever wonder how we got in such a screwed up situation in the misguided way that we treat Type 2 diabetes and the resulting suffering of millions?
Well, @garytaubes spells it out for us all in chilling detail in his brilliant new book, 'Rethinking Diabetes'.
The drug, legal in much of the country, is widely seen as nonaddictive and safe. For some users, these assumptions are dangerously wrong.
A topic I cover in BLIND SPOTS, challenging deeply held assumptions: geni.us/blindspots
www.nytimes.com/2024/10/04/us/cannabis-marijuana-risks-ad…
Terrific civil discourse @Stanford on Covid policies. Lots of different points of views.
Some people think we should not evaluate the effectiveness & outcomes of the greatest set of public health interventions in modern history. But scientific discourse is good.
Fantastic opening panel at #pandemicpolicyreform @Stanford “Evidence-Based Decisionmaking During a Pandemic” All-star panel representing diverse views - a much needed dialogue! @MonicaGandhi9 @MartyMakary @AndrewNoymer #anderstegnell
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Get caught up: Kellogg’s Flakes on Promise to Ditch Artificial Ingredients: Health Advocates Say It’s Crunch Time www.michigannewssource.com/2024/10/kelloggs-flakes-on-pro… via @glnnews
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“This may be the greatest farce in modern medicine.” The study showing that HRT causes breast cancer does not show that HRT causes breast cancer! It is the most expensive clinical study in history- known as the Women’s Health Initiative. The NIH had spent approx $1B in taxpayer dollars on the study…only to lead to a wrong health recommendation.
Dr @MartyMakary congratulations for a fabulous book.
#modernmedicalmishaps or #whydrsneedstatstraining
FEMA is paying just $750 to victims of hurricane Helene (the 3rd deadliest in U.S. history), but FEMA will still pay>$10,000 for funeral expenses if you die of Covid (thru 2025)-does not apply if you die of influenza, RSV or West Nile virus, only Covid.
www.fema.gov/fact-sheet/fema-provides-funeral-assistance-…
"We do not have the funds. FEMA does not have the funds to make it through the season."
www.axios.com/2024/10/03/hurricane-helene-fema-funding-ma…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Medicine is full of BLIND SPOTS & here's why...
With @MartyMakary
Tell me your thoughts please?
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
My good friend and JHU colleague Dr. @MartyMakary in his latest book, “Blind Spots”:
"In science, we tend to get in a rut and then dig in. We have to be open-minded."
EXHIBIT 1 = COVID LOCKDOWN DISASTER.
www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Today’s guest is Dr. @MartyMakary, professor at Johns Hopkins. We dive into how blind spots impact health and tips to overcome them.
#thewellnessmamapodcast #healthblindspots
Don’t miss it! 🎧➡ wellnessmama.com/podcast/863/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I read a meta-analysis that downplayed a drug safety concern and I looked up one of the authors and this was their conflict of interest.
I am sure there is no one better to get the bottom of a safety signal
Great being back on the Hill to talk health!
I enjoyed the insightful discussion hosted by @Paragon_Inst with @MartyMakary on his new book Blind Spots today. He shared critical perspectives on how medicine sometimes gets it wrong — such as the peanut allergy and antibiotics — and the implications for our #health. I’m currently on Chapter 5, and already highly recommend it.
Blind Spots: a.co/d/iuBUNQR
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Time to pay attention and demand change.
Why do we get the unhealthier versions of all the junk foods here in the US?
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
You did a great job @MartyMakary and speaking my language… “ the microbiome”.
Honored to be a part of this incredible group of people at the Senate roundtable this week to talk about the blind spots of our nation's chronic disease epidemic
Honored to be a part of this incredible group of people at the Senate roundtable this week to talk about the blind spots of our nation's chronic disease epidemic
Pharma uses placebo in leu of standard effective therapy as the control arm when the want to “rig” a study. Still a major problem in medicine
Can someone explain to me how a placebo arm is ethical in 2024? So patients with cancer were just vomiting and taking placebo? And doctors enrolled? @AaronGoodman33
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Why are there doctors practicing today with C-section rates of 70-80% in low-risk deliveries?" asks surgeon Dr. @MartyMakary.
He says groupthink and "band-wagon thinking" are huge problems within the medical community and the field of science.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Highlights:
REPLAY: American Health & Nutrition: A Second Opinion
If you can’t spend the full 4 hours watching, I’d suggest you watch these quick highlights from Monday’s roundtable.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
There are massive blind spots in modern medicine that no one wants to address, but we must.
It was a pleasure having @MartyMakary on the show to discuss his new book, Blind Spots.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Listen to my friend @MartyMakary. We must reclaim #healthfreedom and #makeamericahealthyagain. @calleymeans @RobertKennedyJr
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
It's a SUPER book!!
Medicine needs more voices like Dr Makary!
Trustworthy, forthright and courageous!
We can fix health care together. People are hungry for big ideas. BLIND SPOTS just hit the NYTimes bestseller list, despite selling out on Amazon on opening day!
(Amazon is now selling the book again during the restocking): geni.us/blindspots
Thank you all! I hope you enjoy the book
We can fix health care together. People are hungry for big ideas. BLIND SPOTS just hit the NYTimes bestseller list, despite selling out on Amazon on opening day!
(Amazon is now selling the book again during the restocking): geni.us/blindspots
Thank you all! I hope you enjoy the book
Looking forward to being back on Capitol Hill for this
How is modern medicine missing the mark?🩺🩺
Find out at our event on Capitol Hill with Dr. @MartyMakary on October 1st at 11:30 AM ‼️
'Blind Spots: When Medicine Gets It Wrong, and What it Means for Our Health'
👉🔗 Register here: paragoninstitute.org/event/blind-spots-when-medicine-gets…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
At our Senate discussion, @CaseyMeansMD and @ChrisPalmerMD shared studies showing 0.5% of our brains by weight are now plastic.
We don’t need 10 years of controlled studies to know what common sense already tells us. Plastic doesn't belong in our brains in mass quantities.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Lamar Jackson. Josh Allen. Sunday Night Football.
Doesn’t get better than this.
#ravensflock #billsmafia
We have poisoned the food supply for our nation's children. @megynkelly gets it when it comes to the modern day childhood chronic disease epidemic. Thank you for using your platform to get the word out. Important clips from @CaseyMeansMD @thefoodbabe: youtu.be/xWKlczFVfuM
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
There cannot be enough attention drawn to these appalling graphics from Vani Hari.
Our food system is compromised.
An honor to testify at the U.S. Senate with physicians @CaseyMeansMD and @ChrisPalmerMD this week on addressing America's chronic disease epidemic with a entirely new approach
Dr. Casey Means: “I learned virtually nothing at Stanford Medical School about the tens of thousands of scientific papers that elucidate the root causes of why American health is plummeting.”
“I did not learn that for each additional serving of ultra-processed food we eat, early mortality increases by 18%.
This now makes up 67% of the foods our kids are eating. I took zero nutrition courses in medical school.
I didn’t learn that 82% of independently-funded studies show harm from processed food, while 93% of industry-sponsored studies reflect no harm.
I didn’t learn that 95% of the people who created the recent USDA food guidelines for America had significant conflicts of interest with the food industry.
I did not learn that one billion pounds of synthetic pesticides are being sprayed on our foods every single year. 99% of the farmland in the United States is sprayed with synthetic pesticides, many from China and Germany, and these invisible, tasteless chemicals are strongly linked to autism, ADHD, sex hormone disruption, thyroid disease, sperm dysfunction, Alzheimer’s, dementia, birth defects, cancer, obesity, liver dysfunction, female infertility and more.
I did not learn that the eight billion tons of plastic that have been produced just in the last 100 years … are being broken down into microplastics that are now filling our food, our water, and we are now even inhaling them in our air, and that very recent research … tells us that now about 0.5% of our brains by weight are plastic.
I didn’t learn that there are more than 80,000 toxins that have entered our food, water, air, and homes by industry, many of which are banned in Europe, and they are known to alter our gene expression, alter our microbiome composition and the lining of our gut, and disrupt our hormones.
I didn’t learn that heavy metals like aluminum and lead are present in our food, our baby formula, personal care products, our soil, and many of the mandated medications like vaccines, and that these metals are neurotoxic and inflammatory.
I didn’t learn that the average American walks a paltry 3,500 steps per day even though we know, based on science and top journals, that simply walking 7,000 steps a day slashes by 40-60% our risk of Alzheimer’s, dementia, type 2 diabetes, cancer, and obesity.
I certainly did not learn that medical error and medications are the third-leading cause of death in the US.
I didn’t learn that just five nights of sleep deprivation can induce full-blown pre-diabetes. I learned nothing about sleep, and we’re getting about 20% less sleep on average than we were 100 years ago.
I didn’t learn that American children are getting less time outdoors now than a maximum security prisoner, and on average, adults spend 93% of their time indoors, even though we know from the science that separation from sunlight destroys our circadian biology, and circadian biology dictated our cellular biology.
I didn’t learn that professional organizations that we get out practice guidelines from, like the American Diabetes Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, have taken tens of millions of dollars from Coke, Cadbury, processed food companies and vaccine manufacturers like Moderna.
I didn’t learn that if you address these root causes that all lead to metabolic dysfunction and help patients change their food and lifestyle patterns … we could reverse the chronic disease crisis in America, save millions of lives and trillions of dollars in healthcare costs per year.
This is a spiritual crisis. We are choosing death over life, we are choosing darkness over light.
We need a return to courage. We need a return to common sense and intuition. We need a return to awe for the sheer miraculousness of our lives.
We need all hands on deck.”
Source: Sen. Ron Johnson’s Roundtable on “American Health and Nutrition: A Second Opinion”
Thank you @thefoodbabe for this powerful presentation everyone should watch
This is my full testimony in Washington yesterday. American Companies Must STOP doing this. It's a moral issue. @Calleymeans @humankarp foodbabe.com/american-food-companies-must-stop-doing-this…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
If we, as Americans—Republican, Democrat, or Independent—can’t have a civil conversation about the health crisis our nation is facing, we are doomed.
The purpose of science is to challenge deeply held assumptions. I believe in doing it through civil discourse.
Fascinating and provocative: How Pediatricians Created the Peanut Allergy Epidemic, by @MartyMakary www.wsj.com/articles/WP-WSJ-0001981373
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Dr. Marty Makary (@MartyMakary) at the American Health and Nutrition Round Table yesterday: “We have poisoned our food supply, engineered highly addictive chemicals that we put into our food, we spray it with pesticides that kill pests. What do you think they do to our gut lining and our microbiome? And then they come in sick, the GI tract is reacting - it’s not an acute inflammatory storm, it’s a low grade chronic inflammation and it makes people feel sick.”
My latest oped: The root causes of America's chronic disease epidemic are in our blind spots
@Sensible__Med www.sensible-med.com/p/the-50-year-failure-of-american-he…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
"Our healthcare system is playing Whac-A-Mole on the backend and we are not talking about the root causes."
@MartyMakary
Fun conversation with my friend @DrJBhattacharya
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzSaTnGZSDY
Enjoy!!
It’s finally here! Thank you @MartyMakary
I am going to be so annoying this Thanksgiving. Knowledge is power, right? 😂🤷🏻♀️
We’ll need him tonight!
Nate Wiggins is ACTIVE
📸: @Ravens
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Highly recommend @MartyMakary provocative new book “Blind Spots” about how medical conventions can sometimes be wrongly established, how the ideas take root, and how these established orthodoxies can be challenged through new science.
Found on Amazon:
a.co/d/2nvUyVW
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I just finished “Blind Spots,” the brilliant new book by @martymakary. I hope that every doctor, medical leader, and medical student will read it. Using diverse illustrations and engaging anecdotes, the author skillfully documents major cultural problems in academic medicine that impede medical progress (arrogance, self-importance, dogmatism, dishonesty, careerism, conformism) and identifies their antidotes (humility, open-mindedness, bias mitigation, honesty, independent thinking). The pandemic has amplified these weaknesses, which must be addressed urgently if we are to reverse the epidemic of chronic disease and the diminishing public trust in the biomedical enterprise.
The real story behind America’s peanut allergy epidemic—an except from BLIND SPOTS in today’s @WSJ www.wsj.com/health/how-pediatricians-created-the-peanut-a…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Dr. @MartyMakary says "the best way to lower drug prices in the United States is to stop taking drugs we don't need".
Watch live: www.cato.org/events/blind-spots-when-medicine-gets-it-wro…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
SAT| Surgeon, professor, and author Dr. Marty Makary (@MartyMakary) discusses his new book "Blind Spots" about the impact of what he calls the "epidemic of medical dogma."
Watch live at 8:00am ET!
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Check out the @CatoHealth book forum on @MartyMakary new book tomorrow (9/20) @ 12 PM to learn more about the breakdown of the medical field
www.cato.org/events/blind-spots-when-medicine-gets-it-wro…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
.@nytimes essay on @MartyMakary excellent new book “Blind Spots: When Medicine Gets It Wrong and What It Means for our Health" on how the medical profession addresses areas of uncertainty, and Makary's prescription for better professional decision making
www.nytimes.com/2024/09/19/opinion/medicine-allergies-res…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Excellent episode. @ZDoggMD and @VPrasadMDMPH talk to author @MartyMakary and discuss the biggest blind spots of modern medicine with topics including hormone replacement therapy, the gut microbiome, flawed nutrition guidelines etc. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-vpzd-show/id1596335407?…
When it comes to health, it's time to replace dogma with science. It's happening... the truth may surprise you. "what begins as opinion can quickly become dogma, especially once the profession has become wed to an idea." @nytimes on my new book BLIND SPOTS www.nytimes.com/2024/09/19/opinion/medicine-allergies-res…
Order the new book today (Amazon has a 2-day restocking delay but you can still buy it on Amazon now!) geni.us/blindspots
The Foods That Fight Inflammation www.nytimes.com/2024/09/18/well/eat/inflammation-food-die…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
In this episode (#317) of The Drive, I speak with Marty Makary, M.D., M.P.H. Marty explores how a new generation of doctors is challenging long-held medical practices by asking critical new questions.
peterattiamd.com/martymakary3/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
「 LIVE 」 By Endorsing A Politician, Scientific American Magazine Injects More Politics & Bias Into Science • Dr. @MartyMakary & Dr. @BrianHookerPhD on @AskDrDrew x.com/i/broadcasts/1OwGWNbeZemKQ
We've got to talk about the root causes of chronic diseases.
We've got to talk about our BLIND SPOTS geni.us/blindspots
DC Friends! Join me Friday @ noon for this event on the new book:
I'm looking forward to discussing your new book with you at length at the @CatoInstitute this coming Friday. It's not too late for people to register for the event at this link. www.cato.org/events/blind-spots-when-medicine-gets-it-wro…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Received this very cool email from my dad about I'm sure just one of the many positive impacts of @MartyMakary 's book The Price We Pay.
I haven't yet learned what the changes in the billing practices were, but I imagine this means there are more parents who can direct their resources away from hospital bills and back to their families (likely including children with serious health conditions) and demonstrates:
1. All of us in healthcare have the ability to make a difference in patients' lives when we identify harmful practices
2. Exposing a problem gets people talking about and working on a solution
If you haven't read "The Price we Pay" it's a fascinating, educational, humorous and sad indictment of the US healthcare system. We may not agree on a solution but can probably all agree that a single mom of 3 in Carlsbad, NM (as described in the book) should not have had her wages garnished and life totally turned upside down because she once visited an ER with morning sickness.
I'm looking forward to reading Marty's next book "Blind Spots" which is coming out in 5 days - I just pre-ordered it
(no I didn't write this post because I got it for free or to get it for free 🙂)
THANK YOU everyone! BLINDS SPOTS is now the #1 new release on Amazon, and #2 bestselling book on Amazon--one week before it hits bookstores!
I'm overwhelmed &grateful for all the support. Let's change the system together to focus on HEALTH!
Let's do this!! geni.us/blindspots
pre-order your copy here: geni.us/blindspots
OK Baltimore, let’s do this!
And just like that, we're 🄱🄰🄲🄺‼️
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This video of me speaking on pharma influence on medical school education was censored on TikTok.
Below are REFERENCES for each statement said in this video. We have to scratch our heads and ask WHY this type of information is being silenced!
1. Fewer than 20% of medical schools require a nutrition course: www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/nutrition-educ…
2. More than 19,000 drugs are approved for marketing currently: www.fda.gov/media/115824/download.
3. $3 million Pfizer grant for Stanford for curriculum while I was a medical student: philanthropynewsdigest.org/news/stanford-receives-3-milli…
4. Chronic diseases are driven by food: www.cdc.gov/cdi/indicator-definitions/npao.html
5. NIH funding includes 8,000 major conflicts of interest since 2012: www.pbs.org/newshour/health/health-researchers-disclose-1….
6. FDA receives majority of drug budget from pharma companies: www.forbes.com/sites/johnlamattina/2022/09/22/why-is-biop…
Preach it sister! 🔥🔥
Dr. Casey Means Drops Some Hard Truths on the Link Between Ultra-Processed Foods & the Rise in GI Cancers Among Younger Adults
"What do those all have in common? They are the gastrointestinal system...No sh*t that our GI cancers are going up. We're eating nothing but toxic food...This is not a mystery. I cannot stand that all the cancer doctors are throwing their hands up like this is a mystery. We're eating 50 metric tons of trash in our lifetime, and we're getting GI cancer."
@CaseyMeansMD @JillianMichaels @RobertKennedyJr
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
.@MartyMakary: "Two-thirds of Americans students say they are distracted by their digital devices during class."
It's time to remove cell phones from the classroom.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
👏 Chen Dun @JohnsHopkinsSPH for this incredible - and insightful - work!
@MartyMakary @HopkinsMedNews @hopkinssurgery @JHUWelchCenter @PVDCouncil
Full text here:
www.ahajournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1161/JAHA.123.033463?downl…
A newly published US Medicare cohort study illuminates trends and factors associated with peripheral vascular interventions from 2011 to 2022 vascularnews.com/claudication-long-term-medicare-study-hi…
@CaitlinWHicks @JAHA_AHA
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Mainstream media playbook: When the culture seems to be turning TOWARDS health, rapidly spin up a BS article (like this one that was published yesterday in TIME) to:
1. SEED CONFUSION: CONFUSION IS KEY - it makes us doubt our convictions about healthy food. Key here is bringing in “experts” who contradict the science and say it’s sensationalized or impractical to implement.
2. NORMALIZE: talk about how nearly 80% of calories come from ultraprocessed food so it can’t be that bad, right? IGNORE that 50% of children now have a CHRONIC DISEASE. Use a meaningless anecdote like the author of the article eating 80% processed food and feeling just fine! 🤦🏼♀️
3. DISTRACT AND SHUT DOWN DISCOURSE BY BRINGING IN SOCIAL JUSTICE: Focus intensely on social justice issues and questions of food access rather than science (“what would people *possibly* eat if we changed the food system towards real food?!”). Rather than focusing on ANY meaningful solutions that are actually good for the health and wellbeing of all people, focus on how changing the current system would lead to more food insecurity. Don’t mention that taxpayer money is what leads these foods and to be cheap through corrupt subsidies, and we actually have a rigged system against people of lower socioeconomic status that is the ACTUAL social justice issue. Don’t mention that we could rapidly steer the billions of dollars of processed food subsidies towards REAL food access for all Americans if there was a will to do so.
4. MINIMIZE THE SCIENCE: mention but then QUICKLY minimize the innumerable studies that say ultraprocessed foods impair hormones, metabolic health, and are associated with early death.
5. DEFINITELY DON’T MENTION CONFLICTS OF INTEREST: certainly don’t talk about funding sources and conflicts of interest at NIH, USDA, FDA, academia, OR THE NEWS OUTLET THAT IS PUBLISHING THE ARTICLE.
DON’T FALL INTO THE TRAP
Cancer, diabetes, autism & chronic disease rates are all going up.
Is anyone asking why??
Learn about the giant BLIND SPOTS of modern medicine.
20 days until the book release. I can't wait!! (pre-order: geni.us/blindspots) TY Katie😀@CaseyMeansMD @calleymeans are spot on
Always wonderful to see @MartyMakary. Very excited about his new book, which is much needed during these times of earned distrust in the medical field.
a.co/d/1eyUE81
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
We’ve done enormous damage to kids with smartphones — we must ban them in schools. @MartyMakary @nypost
nypost.com/2024/08/25/opinion/why-smartphones-should-be-b…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This is a policy that should make sense to everyone. No kid needs their smart phone in class
It’s time to ban cell phones in the classroom K-12 nypost.com/2024/08/25/opinion/why-smartphones-should-be-b…
It’s time to ban cell phones in the classroom K-12 nypost.com/2024/08/25/opinion/why-smartphones-should-be-b…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
"It makes no sense, but our government created this crazy game. Instead of simply paying a fixed amount per procedure, Medicare pays hospitals multiples more than non-hospital surgery centers and doctor’s offices," @MartyMakary writes. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/07/08/medicare-site-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Mainstream media has reported dubious results of a study indicating that the use of multivitamins is not associated with a reduction in mortality risk, but even if this were true, does it really mean they offer no benefit for health?
peterattiamd.com/multivitamin-health-benefits/
There’s a lot of waste in the healthcare system
Study in @EJVES_ESVS (www.ejves.com/article/S1078-5884(24)00490-8/fulltext) of 36K patients with claudication (muscle pain from poor blood flow) suggests infrapopliteal (below-knee) endovascular intervention is overused, often has poor outcomes & should be avoided. @hopkinssurgery @CaitlinWHicks @MartyMakary
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
⭐️ @DrJMarine
Love this quote:
‘encourage our universities and academic medical centers to speak less as institutions and to do more to foster faculty debate on controversial medical and health policy issues.’ www.sensible-med.com/p/for-academic-institutions-silence
Good piece today on the real story about Medicare &drug $$
"a design flaw in Medicare allows manufacturers of certain therapies to keep prices, and the resulting govt payments, high" But the IRA "penalty distorts launch prices and generic comp" @theomerkel www.city-journal.org/article/a-market-based-solution-to-r…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Lamar Jackson returned to Ravens practice today
📸: @Ravens
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
BLIND SPOTS and
LIES
A number of top docs are writing eyeopening books about what's wrong with their profession, why we're so sick, and what we can do about it. I've interviewed these 2 for @FullMeasureNews Highly recommend their books!
@MartyMakary @robertlufkinmd
Blind Spots (Preorder now)
Lies I Taught in Medical School (NYT bestseller)
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Treatments shouldn’t cost more just because they happen at a hospital, @MartyMakary writes. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/07/08/medicare-site-…
Great @JAMA_current article on how the FDA needs to change it's procedures to evaluate AI... "The FDA’s traditional regulatory approach, which depends on the agency’s capacity to meticulously examine a product’s construction, might prove infeasible" jamanetwork.com/journals/jama-health-forum/fullarticle/28… @ScottGottliebMD @drjbajwa
How can the price of a drug infusion differ radically depending on the floor or bldg where it’s done? It makes no sense, but our Medicare created this crazy game. Today’s health-care interests are exploiting this govt policy to make millions of dollars...
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/07/08/medicare-site-…
It's also true for surgery, costing billions and driving up the price of health care.
My latest oped explores a bipartisan health care reform we can all agree on--site neutral payment reform:
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/07/08/medicare-site-…
There's a lot of important health care reform that is bipartisan. Price Transparency is another, as @PtRightsAdvoc founder C. Fisher outlines today:
www.realclearhealth.com/2024/07/08/biden_and_trump_actual…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Some of the best "training" I did to prep for success as an MD:
-- two summers waiting tables
-- 10 years as a caddy
Grit. Relationship management and development. Multitasking. Service.
Why doctors should get the patient the cup of coffee when asked and other 'thats not my job' comments I find troubling
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/thats-not-my-job-an-attitude-i-find
“Partisan bias leads to blind spots”
Doctors and professors at Harvard and Yale think that Biden's debate performance was "stuttering" or caused by cold medications. 🤔
I explain why partisan bias is a problem and show how it is linked to outdoor masking & school closure @Sensible__Med
www.sensible-med.com/p/some-doctors-and-professors-claim
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“Farmers of only four herds — in Texas, Kansas, New Mexico, and Nebraska — have enrolled in a USDA voluntary testing pilot program since its launch on June 3.“ www.statnews.com/2024/06/24/bird-flu-snapshot-usda-secret…
The most amazing thing about this study is that it was funded by the Am Cancer Society (likely donations). While there's no funding to study if many chemo drugs improve overall survival. TY @VPrasadMDMPH for pointing out the flawed assumpt of this research
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/ct-screening-for-lung-cancer-for?…
Great investigative journalism being done by @spencerbrown @townhallcom
"Is this the next FTX?"
@Townhallcom's @spencerbrown explores our allegations against the infamously shady "stablecoin" company @tether:
townhall.com/tipsheet/spencerbrown/2024/06/18/consumer-wa…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Less than half of cancer drugs approved based on a surrogate endpoint are ever found to improve survival in their entire lifecycle.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11043668/
In what society in history are the people censoring the good guys? www.wsj.com/articles/harvard-dean-lawrence-bobo-faculty-s… via @WSJopinion
Amazing
"By 2015, Ebright noted, scientists at a meeting of members of the Royal Society and US National Academy of Sciences had 'singled out' the WIV experiments as the 'most likely of all research in the world to trigger a pandemic."
Thank you to Dr. Filer (former Harvard Medical School dean) et al. for writing this defense of academic free speech in @thecrimson, challenging one Harvard dean’s call to censor speech that may “arouse external intervention into University business.”
Wherein my colleagues and I lambast a recent op-ed by @Harvard Dean of the FAS Division of Social Science Lawrence Bobo, in which he proposes outrageous limitations of faculty speech. www.thecrimson.com/article/2024/6/19/CAFH-punish-faculty-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Transparent #physicianbenchmarking can improve #appropriateness of care in medicine.
I recently publicly published my own personal practice patterns around the treatment of #claudication in @avsgjournal.
Who else wants theirs?!?
#wecandobetter #paded
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S08905096240016…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Government health programs are designed to take money from middle-income families and transfer it to the powerful & connected and health care special interests. While spending us into oblivion and not improving health
@mfcannon @VanceGinn @paulwinfree @MartyMakary @DeanClancy @
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🔎Revisit our research "The HSA Option", co-authored by @brian_blase, and discover how HSAs can enhance #aca plans, giving you control over your health expenses.
paragoninstitute.org/private-health/the-hsa-option/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
"The culture is just like I expected." @KingHenry_2 on his first impressions coming to Baltimore:
We're not getting the full picture on bird flu prevalence. Deja vu Covid, we're seeing some of the same mistakes-Scott is spot on. In my new book geni.us/blindspots, I explain why one universal flu vaccine that covers bird flu is collecting dust @ NIH, stuck in a bureaucracy
Agricultural authorities have slow walked or forestalled testing, and bottled up critical information. The immediate risk is that this virus becomes endemic in herds, and we’ll have to grapple with its persistent threat. This may have been an avoidable public health peril.
NEW: Dozens of dairy cows infected with H5N1 bird flu have died or were slaughtered because they failed to recover.
This is the first time deaths have been reported in cows, according to Reuters, which found deaths in at least 5 states.
4 anti-competitive provisions hospitals should stop slipping into their contracts w/ insurance:
-No steering to quality doctors
-No other insurer can get the same price
-Gag clauses
-No network tiers within a system
Courts striking down for good reason!
open.substack.com/pub/wendellpotter/p/new-york-presbyteri…
Classic way to make a new cancer drug look good in a clinical trial--put the control group on a drug worse than current standard of care. Can create a illusion of benefit. Great piece by @VPrasadMDMPH www.drugdevletter.com/p/is-the-crown-deserved-unsure-plus…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
A little levity… Marshall would have loved this. @charlesornstein @MartyMakary
Ok this clip about navigating the American Healthcare System from the recent South Park ozempic special (which was brilliant) needs to be the opening of every healthcare conference panel
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Marshall Allen was one of the most influential #healthcare investigative #journalists in America. Marshall recently passed away from a heart attack. Watch a video tribute HERE: youtu.be/6JJzIGJ-pGk @charlesornstein @MartyMakary @HeartOTXHeartMD @RyanTedfordMD
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
NEW: Paragon's @JJ_albanese explores the lackluster performance of pay-for-performance programs embedded in fee-for-service (#ffs) #medicare’s provider payment systems.
Beyond Box-Checking: The Case for Dismantling Medicare’s Quality Bureaucracy⬇️🧵
paragoninstitute.org/medicare/beyond-box-checking-the-cas…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Scottie Scheffler shooting -5 at a golf major after being arrested and spending all morning in a jail cell is legit one of the most incredible athletic accomplishments ever.
A new obesity drug, CT-388, passes its phase 1 clinical trial. Roche may soopn have an obesity/diabetes GLP-1 GLP drug that competes with Novo & Lilly. The big question I think about is what do these drugs do to muscle mass/frailty long term? We'll see
www.wsj.com/health/pharma/roche-shares-climb-after-weight…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🚨BREAKING: HHS Suspends Funding and Proposes Formal Debarment of EcoHealth Alliance, Cites Evidence from @COVIDSelect’s Report.
Accountability is here!
Some medical journals are closing shop, which is good. Most are laughing at doctors for editing &writing for free. The result--journals keep 100% of profits as junk science abounds.
I read @Sensible__Med each morning to help break down the latest research
www.wsj.com/science/academic-studies-research-paper-mills…
Produce Without Pesticides www.consumerreports.org/health/food-contaminants/produce-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Medical Debt-Relief Can Backfire on Patients www.realclearhealth.com/2024/05/08/medical_debt-relief_ca…
Super excited to announce my new book BLIND SPOTS now avail for pre-order! It's about the latest medical research we are NOT talking about that we need to talk about:
▶ The Microbiome
▶ Hormone Replacement
▶ Peanut Allg
▶ Blood tests not ordered that everyone needs
▶ Childbirth
▶ Cancer Prevent
▶ The Culture of Medicine
www.amazon.com/Blind-Spots-Medicine-Wrong-Health/dp/16397…
Novo Nordisk rides weight loss drug boom as risks mount www.axios.com/2024/05/02/novo-nordisk-q1-earnings-ozempic…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
💰In 2023, only 7% of #medicare Part B enrollees paid above the standard premium despite policies since 2007 that adjust premiums based on income.
Wealthier enrollees continue to receive significant taxpayer subsidies for their coverage.
#paragonpic #partb
NEW STUDY: Antimicrobial-resistant hospital infections are up 12% during the pandemic, according to a new NIH study. medicalxpress.com/news/2024-04-antimicrobial-resistant-ho…
One untold story of Covid has been the massive overuse of antibiotics driving more bacterial resistance. www.who.int/news/item/26-04-2024-who-reports-widespread-o…
There’s a lot of middleman waste in healthcare, that employers can address in their health benefits choices
🚨 Reimbursement by CVS Caremark to chain pharmacies is 43% HIGHER than for independent pharmacies in rural eastern North Carolina.
How do rural patients get critical drugs when their local pharmacy can't fill due to PBM losses?
*From 4/25 presentation NC State Health Plan mtg.
Picked up a copy of the “Love, Mom” book that everyone is talking about for Mother’s Day in 2wks! Thank you Dr. Saphier and friends for writing it.
'Love, Mom' provides inspiration for mothers of all ages, and is a great gift for new moms heading into their first Mother's Day 🌸 charleston.com/charleston-insider/arts-culture/inspiratio…
New England Journal Paxlovid study: "no significant difference in the time to symptom alleviation" in vax
This trial ended >1.5 yrs ago. Why are the results only being released now??
After $20B taxdollars & a big campaign urging ppl <65 to take it. Amaz
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2309003
Another New England Journal Paxlovid study out this month:
"No evidence of benefit was found in younger adults."
The reported benefit here in ppl >65 may have been due to health interv-seeking bias as it was an observational study, not a clinical trial.
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2204919
Monopolies are bad for health care. Submit a comment to the FTC today: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ajCzsIz24vk&t=1s
Together, these organizations form the backbone of a monopoly that stifles competition, burns out physicians, and accelerates physician loss.
The FTC wants to hear from you about how this monopoly has harmed healthcare. Comment here: healthycompetition.gov
Nurses Protest Use Of AI at Kaiser www.sfgate.com/news/bayarea/article/nurses-protest-use-of…
Every physician should watch this video
Watch this video to help frame this complicated topic for the FTC in your comments. It has some text that might help make your letter to FTC more understandable: youtu.be/ajCzsIz24vk
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
FTC is interested in hearing from you! Please submit comment and share with every physician you know.
www.justice.gov/atr/HealthyCompetition
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
BREAKING: FTC and DOJ Antitrust Division opened new portal to hear about the monopolies controlling healthcare and stifling competition. Please take a minute and make them aware of the ABMS monopoly!
@doctorwes @AaronGoodman33 @chadinabhan @MartyMakary @VPrasadMDMPH
Submit a Healthcare Competition Complaint
www.justice.gov/atr/webform/submit-healthcare-competition…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
New research from @Paragon_Inst shows the extremely outdated methodologies that @HHSGov uses for measuring whether areas have health provider shortages. The workforce, with NPs and PAs, is much different than in the 1970s when these formulas were set.
@MartyMakary @Avik @kerpen
NEW Paragon research examines federal methodology for designating #primarycareshortage areas, casting doubt that it reflects the current #healthworkforce.
'Where Are Provider Shortages? Reassessing Outdated Methodologies' by Bill Finerfrock ⬇️
paragoninstitute.org/private-health/where-are-provider-sh…
On most hospitals being tax exempt:Several of my Johns Hopkins colleagues and I published a study in JAMA showing that some nonprofit hospitals sue and garnish the wages of low-income patients who can’t afford to pay their medical bills. Where’s the community benefit in that?
.@MartyMakary : Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes www.statnews.com/2024/04/14/nonprofit-hospitals-turn-prof… via @statnews
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The fact that @ABIMcert electronically notifies hospital credential offices to dispense strongman threats of loss of privileges to force payments for their org is one example of their racketeering practices and should be investigated by @FTC @linakhanFTC
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
States Aim to Combat Private-Equity Healthcare Takeovers www.wsj.com/articles/state-private-equity-healthcare-take…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I agree with @MartyMakary. Hospitals that do not act like charities should not be treated as charities for tax purposes.
Why are most wealthy hospitals paying 0 federal taxes this year? Most absolutely refuse to schedule appts for Americans seeking care, even cancer Tx, unless they financially qualify. My oped--Congress should condition the tax benefit on true charity care👇🏽
www.statnews.com/2024/04/14/nonprofit-hospitals-turn-prof…
This is going to be good!
Both Lamar Jackson and Derrick Henry have arrived for the first day of the Ravens offseason program
🎥: @Ravens
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
That would hurt a lot of hospitals. It sounds like a brilliant idea. More than 75% of hospitals are not compliant with the Hospital Price Transparency Rule.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This is an excellent post, Dr Makary. Thank you for continuing to illuminate the very broken and greed-driven nature of the shambles we call our American healthcare system
Very much looking forward to visiting Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis this week!
We look forward to welcoming @MartyMakary to @WUSTLmed this upcoming week
Why are most wealthy hospitals paying 0 federal taxes this year? Most absolutely refuse to schedule appts for Americans seeking care, even cancer Tx, unless they financially qualify. My oped--Congress should condition the tax benefit on true charity care👇🏽
www.statnews.com/2024/04/14/nonprofit-hospitals-turn-prof…
Tomorrow, hard working Americans & business owners will pay a good chunk of their earnings in taxes to the govt. Why are wealthy hospitals not paying their fair share?
3 hospital administrators at Mem Sloan Kettering make nearly $20 million in salaries. The hosp will pay no fed taxes as they turn away any cancer patient who does not financially qualify (same procedure @ my hosp). Congress should condition the coveted tax benefit on true charity
It's a disgrace how hospitals add billions in "facility fees" to medical bills for routine care. We need to end price gouging and predatory billing in medicine.
www.wsj.com/health/healthcare/hidden-hospital-fees-cost-p…
New study: a bacteria that normally lives in the mouth was found in 50% of colon cancers. This is consistent with prior research on the interactions between the microbiome and colon cancer, which is rising among young people. www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07182-w.
Great news. Non-compete clauses in doctors contracts should be obsolete. Lawyers do not have non-competes in their employment agreements because it's considered "unethical" in the legal field. What about medicine?
Happy to report that Maryland's non-compete reform bill HB1388 passed the House by a large margin after 10-1 testimony in support! On to the Senate - hearing schedule Thurs March 28 at 1PM. Maryland physicians please consider this issue and support! mgaleg.maryland.gov/mgawebsite/Legislation/Details/HB1388
@ACCMaryland @sxz110 @Cardiology @SrihariNaiduMD @himavidula @NicoleLohrMD @bmorecardiology @MedChiupdates
Really enjoyed this fireside chat between @bariweiss &Harvard’s Roland Fryer on academic peer-pressure to only publish research that supports establishment thinking. His story of staying scientifically objective (& suspension by Claudine Gay) is incredible youtu.be/IQ9tTottjB8
After decades of insisting that every healthy adult >50 take a daily med (aspirin), new evidence suggests more harm than good. Another example of the bandwagon effect--a rec based on limited data that became dogma, now reversed. Great piece by @drjohnm
www.sensible-med.com/p/should-i-change-my-mind-about-aspirin
A Classic by @marshallallen
"I’m a Journalist. Apparently, I’m Also One of America’s 'Top Doctors.'”
Companies cash in by selling honors like “Best Doctor” or “Top Doctor” to physicians.
Experts call it a “scam.”
Giving one to a ProPublica reporter highlights the absurdity. www.propublica.org/article/top-doctors-award-journalist
We still have a mask mandate at Johns Hopkins--makes a mockery of public health recommendations. And people wonder how to restore trust??
Security guards enforcing the policy at the building entrances are wearing masks with their nose hanging out. In clinic, I miss seeing smiles
One of many studies showing the strong link between chronic marijuana use and cardiovascular disease. Weed is not as safe as many people think.
New study finds: Daily use of weed, mostly via smoking, was tied to a 25% increased chance of heart attack and a 42% increased chance of stroke compared with not using weed. Weekly use was tied to a 3% increased chance of heart attack and a 5% increased chance of stroke.
Reporting incidental heart calcifications on CT scans that are not done to look at the heart is a great way to screen for atherosclerosis and even save lives. TY @PamelaJohnsonMD et al. for your work on this. I love common sense solutions in healthcare.
📢Call-to-action for radiologists📢: campaign to improve reporting of incidental coronary artery calcification (CAC) on routine, non-cardiac chest CT. Systematic review of published investigations reveals:
✅CAC often visualized on routine chest CT
✅new diagnosis in many adults
✅some patients have no other risk factors
✅inclusion in impression increases preventive mgt
@JACRJournal @CiccaroneCenter @seamuswhelton @armin_zadeh @KristieJSun @JavadAzadi @LauzeeTweet @ruthcarlosmd @ScottABerkowitz @HopkinsMedicine
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1546144024001972
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Exercise is the best medicine!
🚨Our paper is live today on @JACCJournals
Sex Differences in Association of Physical Activity With All-Cause & Cardiovascular Mortality
🫀Women derived greater gains in mortality risk reduction from equivalent doses of physical activity🆚men
@SmidtHeart
rb.gy/m7l835
For all my students who have been asking, here's the info--One of my favorite books about how hospital billing works. It's empowered thousands of Americans. www.amazon.com/Never-Pay-First-Bill-Health-ebook/dp/B08PC…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Sendak's op Ed in @statnews: "The proposal makes an unconvincing argument that federal investments in AI assurance laboratories at sites like Duke, Mayo Clinic, and Stanford advances health equity.” Senate Finance this morning on A.I. and healthcare. www.finance.senate.gov/hearings/artificial-intelligence-a…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I recently read The Price We Pay by @MartyMakary & An American Sickness by @RosenthalHealth. Both highlighted fundamental issues in our healthcare system.
One issue—price transparency—is the focus of our latest publication in @JPRASurg
www.jprasurg.com/article/S1748-6815(24)00020-2/fulltext
🧵1/
Looking forward to reading more about this
The first human received an implant from @Neuralink yesterday and is recovering well.
Initial results show promising neuron spike detection.
Public health Is local www.discoursemagazine.com/p/all-public-health-is-local
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The head of the World Health Organization says we are doomed to rising rates of diabetes, but we're not, argues science journalist Gary Taubes in his major new book, "Rethinking Diabetes." We just have to radically rethink the role of diet in creating overweight, obesity, and diabetes in the first place.
Performance of over 2,200 hospitals based on the new @LeapfrogGroup billing quality measures added to the annual survey. revcycleintelligence.com/news/medical-billing-quality-lac…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
#texans QB CJ Stroud talks about:
- Players appreciating him giving glory to Jesus Christ
- Praised John Harbaugh for reading Scripture
- Said “There’s a lot of [players & coaches] out here that love the Lord”
Majority of debtors to US hospitals are now people WITH health insurance--these are self-inflicted wounds. It's our job as health professionals to not ignore this issue but instead ask our hospitals to be fair and compassionate. www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/jan/11/hospital-debt-inc…
The price of Ozempic rose by 3.5% to nearly $970 for a month’s supply—one of the hundreds of drug-price increases that pharmaceutical companies have taken at the start of this year www.wsj.com/health/pharma/drugmakers-raise-prices-of-ozem… via @WSJ
Why are these risky experiments still taking place?
New Chinese Study: A Pangolin Coronavirus GX_P2V isolated from the wild. Researchers report "This infection resulted in 100% mortality in the hACE2 [humanized] mice." What is the sci community learning? www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.01.03.574008v1
94% of Americans believe hospitals, insurance &doctors should “be legally required to disclose all of their prices, including discounted prices, cash prices & insurance negotiated rates across hospitals & across plans in an easily accessible place online” thehill.com/policy/healthcare/4397658-americans-favor-hea…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
My latest @Forbes: We Want More Bang For Our Health Care Buck
@JHUCarey @JohnsHopkinsSPH @BSPH_HPM www.forbes.com/sites/gebai/2024/01/08/we-want-more-bang-f…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Unnecessary “junk fees” don’t protect seniors— they just pad pockets. Just like the policy recommendations in #mafortomorrow, @CMSgov’s proposed MA rule protects consumers by eliminating those add-on fees so brokers will focus on seniors’ needs.
www.mafortomorrow.org.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Somebody tell Arthur Smith that it’s the defense’s job to keep the opponent from scoring, not the opposing Head Coach.
This is embarrassing.
Good article on AI in healthcare
My article in current issue of Journal of the American Medical Association ‘Forum’ on best practices for how innovators and regulators should approach novel areas of technology - with lessons that are applicable to artificial intelligence medical devices
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama-health-forum/fullarticle/28…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Federal Government Policy Worsens Generic Drug Shortages
My comments in @FREOPP 2023 Annual Conference: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yny0vSsjQVY&t=2252s Many thanks to @Avik @jwhite_health @brian_blase @GrantRigney
@JHUCarey @JohnsHopkinsSPH @BSPH_HPM
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
1960: < 2 million Americans with diagnosed diabetes
Today: 30 million*
Is this a problem that can be solved by drug therapy?
There must be a better way
My new book, Rethinking Diabetes, is out Jan 2
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre…
#diabetes #wefightdiabetes
* www.cdc.gov/diabetes/data/statistics-report/
@diabetesdaily
@ADA_DiabetesPro
@IntDiabetesFed
@JoslinDiabetes
@diaTribeNews
@Diabetescouk
@BeyondType1
@DiabetesCanada
@ADCESdiabetes
@Diabetes_DRI
@martymakary
@samiinkinen
@bretschermd
@davidludwig
@lowcarbgp
@robbwolf
@drjasonfung
@KenDBerryMD
@SBakerMD
@drmarkhyman
@shellenberger
@DrJBhattacharya
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Words can harm. We shouldn't use phrases like bone-on-bone. Some messaging is more harmful than informative. My guest post on Sensible Medicine.
Thanks for the offer @drjohnm
www.sensible-med.com/p/three-words-that-cause-harm-bone
The most common recommendation of medical establishment for the last 70 years has been to switch to low-fat foods. @garytaubes explains how this was more misinformation than true science in his new book which I really enjoyed reading and highly recommend. www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/561552/rethinking-diabet…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
SEVENTY-FIVE YARD TOUCHDOWN FOR ZAY FLOWERS!!!!!
Tune in on CBS!
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
💥 Francis Collins Says Pandemic Amnesty is Not Enough, Public Confessions Are Needed
"Somebody wrote an article saying maybe we ought to have pandemic amnesty...They were immediately attacked for having said so, because that means you didn't learn anything...The alternative is to do what was done in South Africa after apartheids, where you have a truth and reconciliation opportunity. That means people coming forward and confessing what they did that was harmful in public and asking for forgiveness. That's very different than just amnesty...It'd be really hard to organize, but it might be worth considering as a way to get us past what otherwise is just going to be continual grievance, animosity and vitriol."
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Not sure why they say "link is unclear".
It is clearly linked. It is causally linked.
Whether the benefits outweigh the risks can be debated vs alternatives like bites.
Many quotes on this topic from people with conflicts w car t makers.
FDA alters warning label for Carvykti CAR-T, although link to secondary cancers is unclear. #mmsm www.statnews.com/2023/12/22/myeloma-fda-warning-label-car… via @statnews
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Alzheimer’s researchers found the toxic tau protein warps the shape of the nuclei of nerve cells, or neurons. This alters the function of genes contained inside and reprograms the cells to make more tau. @MedicineUVA #alzheimersresearch
www.uvahealth.com/news/alzheimers-discovery-reveals-dire-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Findings from @JAMANetwork & @MartyMakary’s new report ⬇️
These are just a few examples of how America’s healthcare system is failing patients when it comes to prices and bills.
Here's what the study found in the sample:
▪️33% of hospitals sue patients who can't afford to pay
▪️45% do not provide reliable itemized bills
▪️6% do not provide access to a qualified billing rep
▪️63% did not meet national billing quality standards
We can do so much better.
Our JAMA study out TODAY - A national assessment of hospital billing quality. We found wide variation, ranging from merciful & compassionate practices to price gouging & predatory billing. Billing quality is medical quality. jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/2813347 @LeapfrogGroup @johnarnold
This study follows other JAMA articles we've recently published to raise awareness and increase public accountability for centers price gouging patients at a time when they are vulnerable, violating our oath: jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/2760397. Flatten the curve: jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2783…
Here's what the study found in the sample:
▪️33% of hospitals sue patients who can't afford to pay
▪️45% do not provide reliable itemized bills
▪️6% do not provide access to a qualified billing rep
▪️63% did not meet national billing quality standards
We can do so much better.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
PLAYOFFS SECURED!!!! 😈
ProPublica story out today on our work to apply appropriateness measures to health care to cut the waste & lower health care costs with quality metrics developed by physicians. @CaitlinWHicks @WillBruhn. www.propublica.org/article/thousands-of-patients-may-be-u…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Mycoplasma pneumonia is well described, not new, not mysterious, has treatments, and any pneumonia causes whitening in areas of the lung on radiographic imaging
“White lung syndrome” is a made-up term. Any pneumonia appears as a white opacity on an x-ray or CT, which is partly how the diagnosis of pneumonia is made. But it’s not specific to pneumonia, and it’s certainly not specific to Mycoplasma pneumoniae, which is not “mysterious”. 🧵
Why are taxpayers paying for a 50,000-person study to evaluate the commercial product of a private company? This is what's wrong with healthcare--the GRAIL company would get all the upside(billions) as the American people bear financial risk
www.sensible-med.com/p/us-healthcare-is-headed-for-disasters @Sensible__Med
Medicare will cover the GRAIL test for 50K ppl and use the results to assess its benefit. This means taxpayers will fund the research to see if it saves lives instead of the company. "The decision by Medicare represents a fleecing of America."@VPrasadMDMPH www.sensible-med.com/p/us-healthcare-is-headed-for-disast…
Why aren't kids going to school? COVID taught them some bad habits. www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/voices/2023/11/28/student-…
Why aren't kids going to school? COVID taught them some bad habits. www.usatoday.com/videos/news/nation/2023/06/10/schools-re…
Will be interested to see what comes of this investigation into CAR-T cancer therapy, an expensive therapy that involves extracting immune cells from a patient, re-engineering them to attack cancer and infusing them back into the body.
www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/us-fd…
We have the most medicated generation of children in the history of the world. Glad to see new research on non-pharmaceutical interventions to help kids
For parents who have kids dx with ADHD -
this was interesting. 75% of kids are started on meds without any parent coaching on behavior training.
New research suggests that all kids should be started with parent behavior training (PBT) first.
www.additudemag.com/adhd-behavior-therapy-parent-training…
I don’t consider myself ‘short’ except when I’m hanging out with Megatron @calvinjohnsonjr.
Thanks Calvin for your friendship & your wonderful family. Keep up the great work with your Foundation and businesses!
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Only 1.2% of Americans are uninsured and lack a subsidized coverage opportunity. @DeanClancy @theomerkel @MartyMakary @kerpen @philipaklein @DrJohnCGoodman @sallypipes @gracemarietweet @lanheechen @Avik www.healthaffairs.org/content/forefront/cbo-report-highli…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The entirety of healthcare administration needs to be "Turbo Tax'ed" - to make it simpler to navigate, more transparent, and less prone to high-stake errors. If you're gonna do it, might as well start with the nation's biggest single source of health coverage - Medicaid - and put the best team up to take on the challenge - @singareddynm @ben_wesner & Cydney Kim.
Proud to be backing @hifortunahealth as they build a consumer-first platform for the 90M+ Medicaid beneficiaries who today deal with outdated and counterintuitive software and workflows for enrolling in and maintaining health insurance coverage.
www.axios.com/pro/health-tech-deals/2023/11/15/medicaid-n…
cc @johnlegend @BoxGroup @ycombinator @CyrusMassoumi @elliotcohen @iyahromm @ellenjdasilva @daisydwolf @Annie_m_collins @a16zBioHealth
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The new @EJVES_ESVS guidelines for asx #pad and #claudication are out, and they are EXACTLY what we need right now.
www.ejves.com/article/S1078-5884(23)00741-4/fulltext
Quick spoiler? Check out Frank Veith @VEITHsymposium and my commentary on the topic:
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37839661/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Ravens defense leads the NFL in each of the following categories:
No. 1 in points per game (13.8)
No. 1 in offensive TDs allowed (9)
No. 1 in sacks (35)
No. 1 in yards/play (4.1)
No. 1 in red zone percent (33.3%)
No. 1 in QB rate (69.7)
No. 1 in yards/pass (5.5)
📸: Ravens
New study out today: GLP-1 agonists(e.g. Ozempic) reduced heart attack rates & other health problems in obese people without diabetes.
Problem is the price tag. Most health plans will have to jack up insurance premiums even further to cover the $$
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2307563
Another drug joins the weight loss field. www.newscientist.com/article/2371986-highly-effective-wei…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This is a really good article by @MartyMakary
It strikes me as completely accurate
Peter Mark is acting strange to say it should not matter to women that there is no actual randomized data
www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/was-covid-vaccin…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
BioNTech Slashes Covid Vaccine Forecast as Pandemic Fades www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-11-06/biontech-slash…
I understand why @SenSanders voted against Biden’s pick for NIH director. Over the past 20 years, the average cost of new treatments co-developed by NIH scientists was $111,000
Read my statement below on Dr. Monica Bertagnolli’s nomination to serve as Director of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) ahead of tomorrow’s vote in the HELP Committee.
Data showing schools should be open was evident in July 2020. European data showed no diff in cases/hosp among kids attending school vs those shut out.
U.S. public v. private schools also became a 'clinical trial' of data--All ignored as pub health fear &Union demands prevailed.
Los Angeles Unified kept its schools closed as long as any district in the country. The district conspired with Newsom to deny as many students access to an education as possible. Many never came back.
The damage was utterly predictable and completely avoidable.
97% of Americans have said 'No' to the new COVID19 Booster after public health officials have pushed it hard for months. Speaks to the massive disconnect & loss of public trust. Next time the FDA should require more data than 12 mice for approval. youtu.be/kWYE360TK8g
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Older adults who received last year’s COVID booster and a high-dose version of the flu vaccine in the same visit may have a potential increased risk of stroke, according to a new FDA-funded study. However, experts urge that these results were preliminary.
abcnews.visitlink.me/bUEUXB?cid=social_twitter_abcn
Hospitals terminate Medicare Advantage contracts over payments www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2023/10/27/hospitals-t…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Physicians keep seeing our Medicare rates slashed (down 20% since 2000). Yet, the Medicare program is still facing insolvency. Medicaid spending is the largest share of state budgets. Both programs continue to grow at a faster pace than the overall economy. Can spending be curbed without further harming patients?
Yes. In an excellent @Health_Affairs piece, Deborah Williams, @DrBrian4Health, @MedicareMeddler, @betty_rambur and @gailwilenskycom outline pragmatic, realistic steps to reduce costs without hurting patients.
1- Site neutral payments: Why does a hospital clinic get to charge more for the same office visit as an independent practice. Fix this loophole.
2- Reform GME funding: The money that hospitals get in exchange for training residents is not commensurate with the costs. Hospitals are expanding residency spots without GME funding, so there's clearly a market force at work.
3- Equalize tax treatments for investments: 93% of hospital holdings are unrelated to their core mission. Taxing these gains could provide needed funding for a variety of programs.
4- Fix state funding of federal funding schemes: Since the federal government reimburses states for Medicaid spending, states use a variety of accounting tricks, such as provider taxes and 340B, to get more funding. This is essentially robbing Peter to pay Paul.
Policy is complex, but physicians must understand these issues so we can advocate for financially responsible, patient-centered care. Neurosurgery training is nothing compared to this!
www.healthaffairs.org/content/forefront/reducing-hospital…
@ucsf_ihps @cscla @AnilMakam @VPrasadMDMPH @EconTalker @neurosurgery @SpineNeuro @JPGK_MD @JoanneSpetz
New FDA study reporting Covid vaccine-induced seizures in children.
In reading it, I was curious as to how many more cases the study missed bc they only captured children brought in for care + a clinician documenting/coding for insurance. Thx for sharing @DrJBhattacharya
New @FDA pre-print study: Active surveillance system finds elevated risk of seizures in toddlers and myocarditis in teenagers associated with covid mRNA vaccination.
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.10.13.23296903v1.ful…
Glad to see @mcuban's pharmacy rack up collaborators and shake up an old game of drug price gouging.
www.beckershospitalreview.com/pharmacy/mark-cubans-pharma…
3 yrs after the U.S. was caught unprepared, frantically shopping for medications and supplies in China, the U.S. health care system is still woefully dependent on other countries.
www.beckershospitalreview.com/pharmacy/hospitals-push-bac…
There are a lot of unnecessary blood tests in medicine. Glad to see this work to reduce them
Two years after its implementation, a study shows an @HopkinsKids initiative successfully reduced the amount of unnecessary blood draws in critically ill children in 14 hospitals across the U.S.
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/28089…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Deductibles : ⬆️
Medicare premiums ⬆️
ACA premiums :⬆️
Access ⬇️: 1/3 of 🇺🇸 can’t find a physician.
It’s doesn’t take a detective or a brain surgeon to know that the rent seekers are making a pile of 💰💵💰
NEW REPORT: Health insurance premiums jump to a record $23,968/household.
Health care costs are crushing this country but most employers can save 20-30% on their health spend by making smarter decisions on their benefit design.
www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2023-employer-health-bene…
Get ready
www.supermarketnews.com/nonfood-pharmacy/walgreens-cvs-ph…
NEW REPORT: Health insurance premiums jump to a record $23,968/household.
Health care costs are crushing this country but most employers can save 20-30% on their health spend by making smarter decisions on their benefit design.
www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2023-employer-health-bene…
The clinical importance of nuance versus the sloppy medicine bankrupting this country.
The only positive data for paxlovid was in people who were unvaccinated, high risk, did not have covid previous, & against older strain
No data for quadruple boosted, I had covid, low risk people w/ 2023 strains of covid
A sensible medical system would not even give the Rx
After 5 wks, 2% of Americans have taken the new Covid vaccine (Pfizer's version was FDA approved based on data from 10 mice).
"The US FDA did not ask for appropriate studies"
"Pfizer stock is down, and so is the integrity of the medical profession" @VPrasadMDMPH
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Thank you!
For those interested in the exact data I shared w @galexybrane last night for this article finding myocarditis 6-28x more common post vax than post-covid in 16-24 yo males & up to 13x >in 16-24 yo females +our experience w CDC, I discuss here👇tracybethhoegmdphd.substack.com/p/post-vaccination-vs-pos…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
CDC Covered Up COVID Vaccine Myocarditis Risk, Show Emails And Reports
US government had reviewed Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System cases of post-vaccine myocarditis when CDC’s director falsely claimed, “we have not seen any reports”
by @galexybrane
Former Director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Rochelle Walensky testifies during a House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations and the Subcommittee on Health hearing about the federal response to the coronavirus pandemic on Capitol Hill on February 8, 2023, in Washington, DC. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) is encouraging everyone six months and older to get the newest COVID-19 booster. The benefits for children and young people far outweigh the risks, argues CDC Director Mandy Cohen. “Teen boys have been up to five times as likely to have heart inflammation after having a COVID infection than after getting vaccinated,” Cohen said.
But the best available evidence does not back up Cohen’s claims. The CDC director is relying on a highly flawed study published in the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly (MMWR).
It’s true that this study found teen boys ages 12-17 had two to six times greater risk of heart complications after COVID infection compared to after vaccination.
But the study only looked at electronic health records, which were limited to teenagers who had been admitted to the hospital or who visited a doctor. This means the subjects of the study were not representative of the total number of teen boys who got COVID, the vast majority of whom never went to the doctor.
And other papers show vastly different results.
A study from the American Heart Association on myocarditis (inflammation of the heart muscle) found that, “In men younger than 40 years old, the number of excess myocarditis events per million people was higher after a second dose of mRNA-1273 than after a positive SARS-CoV-2 test.”
A Nordic study of 23 million people found that for young men ages 16 to 24, post-vaccination myocarditis rates were six to 28 times higher than myocarditis rates after COVID infection. The study also found that there were zero myocarditis cases after COVID infection in males ages 12-15.
The consequences of vaccine-caused myocarditis can be serious. A review of clinical records found that ninety-six percent of people under 30 diagnosed with post-vaccination myocarditis were hospitalized. For some patients, symptoms persist. In one study from the US military, seven out of 23 myocarditis patients “continued to have chest discomfort” weeks after vaccination.
Although Cohen insists that children are at high risk of serious illness, the mean Infection Fatality Rate of COVID for people under 20 years old is 0.0003%, and hospitals have grossly inflated the reported number of children with severe COVID. One paperfound that hospital records overcounted the number of pediatric COVID hospitalizations by at least 40 percent.
The CDC’s recommendation that everyone aged 6 months and older get another booster is simply not scientifically or medically sound. The agency received but did not respond to Public’s requests for comment about its misrepresentation of myocarditis risks.
What’s more, a mounting body of evidence shows that the CDC and the White House chose to ignore and cover up evidence of a significant myocarditis safety signal in early 2021, putting young people at risk of serious adverse events. How did this happen?
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The ten mice studied cannot be reached for comment
Dear Dr. Cohen, I’d love to see the clinical data to support the monovalent vaccine (universal) recommendation for young/healthy people and an honest conversation about the true vaccine-induced myocarditis risk:benefit ratio among young males who recently recovered from Covid.
CDC’s partnerships with HBCUs & the Conference of National Black Churches are a critical way to combat vaccine hesitancy and build trust. Hear more 👇
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
@MartyMakary has identified a number of problems with the US healthcare system, including high & rising costs, wasteful spending, and lack of transparency. Self-funded employers in attendance left more informed on these issues and better equipped to lower their healthcare spend.
The end of an era. Rite Aid filed for bankruptcy today, "unable to find the money to settle hundreds of federal, state and private lawsuits alleging it oversupplied prescription painkillers."
www.wsj.com/business/retail/rite-aid-bankruptcy-filing-op…
Monthly Medicare premiums covering physician and outpatient care will rise almost 6% next year as part of a series of hikes CMS announced yesterday. It's high time we address administrative & clinical waste in health care.
www.axios.com/newsletters/axios-vitals-3af95a80-0f94-4564… #axiosvitals
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Hospitals get tax breaks worth far more than the value of the charity care they provide in return, according to a new report from Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.). www.statnews.com/2023/10/10/bernie-sanders-nonprofit-hosp…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman, Penn’s historic mRNA vaccine research team, win 2023 @NobelPrize in Medicine penntoday.upenn.edu/news/katalin-kariko-and-drew-weissman… #nobelprize
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Congress is considering a bipartisan bill to improve and strengthen health care price transparency, as well as fix some unfair billing practices. Learn more:
pirg.org/articles/what-is-the-lower-costs-more-transparen…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
If the CDC's Mandy Cohen wants to increase public trust in her agency, she could start by explaining what happened to the CDC's journal MMWR.
Study by @TracyBethHoeg & @VPrasadMDMPH shows it publishes low quality studies that push an agenda on masks, w/o scientific evidence. www.amjmed.com/article/S0002-9343(23)00580-6/fulltext
Penn is now praising Kariko for her Nobel after demoting her &cutting her pay
"The reversal offers a glimpse of the clubby, hothouse world of academia.. Resistance by Penn & others to Karikó’s work reflects how modern science works" Great piece @GZuckerman
www.wsj.com/health/after-shunning-scientist-university-of…
New Study: Reviews of all mask studies done by CDC and published in their own medical journal MMWR
ALL mask studies in @CDCMMWR
Evidence is weak
0% randomized controlled trials
75% concluded "masks work"
Despite only 15% being significant
CDC does not follow the science, they contribute to low quality science noise @vkprasadlab
www.amjmed.com/article/S0002-9343(23)00580-6/fulltext
Thank you for repealing it. No law should make disagreeing with the department of health grounds for losing one’s medical license
Dr. Khabiti, @TracyBethHoeg, @AaronKheriatyMD, #ramduriseti, other plaintiffs & their lawyers (@LauraPowellEsq, @JeninYounesEsq) are heroes.
A real Mr. Smith goes to Sacramento story.
They beat back @GavinNewsom's draconian anti-free speech in medicine law. Congratulations!
Most U.S. businesses could save 20-30% on their health care spend if they made smarter (bolder) decisions on their benefits design.
www.wsj.com/health/healthcare/these-employers-took-on-hea…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I had 2 Moderna vaccinations and a booster and was hospitalized for acute pericarditis last year. I was afraid for my life.
The medical community minimized vaccine myopericarditis in young men early on. This we now know was a serious mistake.
Back in those days, CDC would have still recommended further boosters for me, despite my pericarditis.
Because I wasn't insane, I didn't get any additional shots. But some companies did mandate additional shots, based on CDC advice, even to men who experienced myopericarditis.
Thankfully this advice has shifted. But this did not happen until after innumerable avoidable vaccine injuries to young men.
These mistakes undermined trust in public health. I now trust public health messaging much less. The vaccines were a godsend for older, at-risk people. The data still show that, even if there is an ever-growing controversy about the effectiveness of boosters, which the public health establishment refuses to test using randomized controlled trial designs.
But the CDC's messaging for young adults continues to lack nuance and undermines trust in public health authorities and harms young people. Nowhere else in the world are the booster recommendations as aggressive--and evidence-free--as they are from the CDC.
I don’t know if my pericarditis was caused by the vaccine, but it is suspicious. I continue to read and learn, and I believe that for older people vaccination might be very important. This despite dissenting views by pro-vaccination figures like Paul Offit, who suggests that even older people should not get boosted.
For me, it’s clear that my COVID vaccinations almost certainly caused more harm than good, and I regret having received them.
I am reading to learn whether in healthy young adult men, any vaccination makes sense.
It is incredibly disappointing to learn that the vaccines that I assured people were safe were not safe, and that I was wrong.
When I was told in comments that the vaccine might have been responsible for my pericarditis, I blocked everyone who suggested it.
I was emotional and closed-minded and wrong.
I should have done better and questioned more and I am sorry.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Just out on my website I catalog (some) errors made by the NYTimes Science reporter that consistently exaggerate the risk of COVID
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“What’s remarkable about the National Institutes of Health’s intense dedication to studying long covid is its simultaneous lack of interest in vaccine-induced myocarditis, recently shown to result in long-term scar tissue in some people.”
Pfizer's new Covid vax was FDA approved based on 10 mice so national uptake could be embarrassingly low. That may be why CDC is not posting real-time vax rates for the new vaccine on their website, as it did/does for the prior Covid vax & bivalent vax
nypost.com/2023/09/27/dont-believe-the-feds-fearmongering…
Pfizer's new Covid vax was FDA approved based on 10 mice so national uptake could be embarrassingly low. That may be why CDC is not posting real-time vax rates for the new vaccine on their website, as it did/does for the prior Covid vax & bivalent vax
nypost.com/2023/09/27/dont-believe-the-feds-fearmongering…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
NIH: "The most crucial priority is to remove fundamental conflicts of interest brought to light by abuses of these positions by Collins and Fauci."
thefederalist.com/2023/08/21/nih-is-due-for-an-overhaul-a…
The more one pulls on the yarn… Fascinating piece by @mtaibbi www.racket.news/p/did-anthony-fauci-impede-the-investigat…
New BMJ Study: “epidemiological research on long COVID has suffered from overly broad case definitions and a striking absence of control groups, which have led to distortion of risk.”
Long COVID research has been of extremely poor quality and highly misleading
Tends to exaggerate prevalence and often lacks control groups
Public understanding is severely compromised
Our article discussing this is widely popular
ebm.bmj.com/content/early/2023/08/10/bmjebm-2023-112338
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
New COVID wastewater data posted yesterday. Declines in all regions. Good sign. biobot.io/data/
Two weeks later, things are looking better. Data as of 9/13. No sign of acceleration. All regions either plateauing or declining. biobot.io/data/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“We are all harmed when our rulers silence criticism,” says @AaronKheriatyMD
Great article on the current state of play regarding the US Gov efforts to censor Americans.
@DrJBhattacharya @MartinKulldorff @JeninYounesEsq www.newsweek.com/white-houses-misinformation-pressure-cam…
If there is a govt shut down, FDA says they will keep 998 employees to work on Covid.
Begs the question: What are they doing??
"Of the staff retained, 998 would be working directly on COVID-19 response activities."
www.hhs.gov/about/budget/fy-2024-hhs-contingency-staffing…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Amazing 🧵about a new paper @VPrasadMDMPH @ShamezLadhani & I had published in @BMJ_EBM
Long covid research has been fraught w methodological errors & vague definitions leading to overestimates of prevalence, undue anxiety and a poor understanding of true lasting covid sequelae
In a bold new paper, three academics criticize how #longcovid has been studied. They say the term itself is so ill defined it should be discarded and that the studies have often been riddled with bias.
By: @VPrasadMDMPH @TracyBethHoeg @ShamezLadhani
🧵⬇️
ebm.bmj.com/lookup/doi/10.1136/bmjebm-2023-112338
I would love to have a conversation with the new CDC director on the precise data she uses to support her claims. E.g. what does she believe the incidence of myocarditis was after the 2nd Moderna shot in young males? (It was so high that parts of Europe restricted it for ppl <30)
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
With the exception of anosmia, I have seen no good evidence that short or long term consequences of Covid are any worse than any respiratory virus *adjusted for how sick you get* (e.g. ards/ vent is never good). The whole research space is dominated by horrifically bad work, and poor thinking. The worst work comes from a single group doing VA data set work that is repeatedly published in nature medicine and covered widely in the news, but absolutely threadbare in methods. Of course, the most parsimonious answer is that it is no worse adjusted for severity of illness. Now that severity of illness is a non-issue, it is a non issue.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The Medical Board of California is attempting to revoke a doctor's license for not wearing a mask and for saying masks don't stop viruses, among other things. This case is not brought under AB2098. It appears they intend to violate 1st Amendment rights regardless.
Just amazing to stop and think how hard the government was working to censor the private social media accounts of doctors who argued for public schools to be open as private schools were for wealthier children.
The Biden administration tried to censor this Stanford doctor, but he won in court nypost.com/2023/09/20/how-dr-jay-bhattacharya-beat-biden-… via @nypost
The U.S. testing-industrial complex continues at taxpayer expense. The U.S. is an international outlier. stocks.apple.com/A4KHkLqHMTOaDmhVMBSuvag
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“Of 13 lactating women receiving the vaccine (20 exposures), trace mRNA amounts were detected in 10 exposures up to 45 h post-vaccination.
Our findings suggest that the COVID-19 vaccine mRNA administered to lactating mothers can spread systemically to the [breast milk] in the first two days after maternal vaccination.
Initially, it was thought that the vaccine mRNA encapsulated in LNPs would remain localized at the injection site and quickly degrade. However, several reports suggest that the LNPs/mRNA can enter the bloodstream and accumulate in distant tissues.”
New W.H.O. report on the growing public health crisis of high blood pressure:
Does not mention studies showing poor sleep can be a cause, increasing vasomuscular tone. Correcting sleep &stress can be therapeutic
Dr Tedros only talking about mass medicating
www.who.int/news/item/19-09-2023-first-who-report-details…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Through two weeks of the season, Lamar Jackson is one of the most accurate QBs in the NFL
Completion Percentage
1) Josh Allen: 76.9
2) Lamar Jackson: 74.5
3) Kirk Cousins: 72.7
4) Jimmy Garoppolo: 72.0
5) Geno Smith: 71.6
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
As scientists we must humbly seek the truth and carefully report the truth, no matter the political winds or the personal consequences. If not, we are not scientists.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Instead of flogging the public relentlessly to isolate and wear useless cloth facial decorations, public health leaders should have been exhorting the public to get outside, breathe fresh air, exercise, lose weight, take care of cardiac risk factors, and improve general health.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Population immunity is a powerful thing.
www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-12531809/Doctors-admit…
I predict 8% of Americans will take the new vaccines that the FDA, CDC, & White House are recommending for every American.
"They are telling every American six months of age and older to get this new COVID vaccine, but they approved it based on almost no data. There’s no human clinical trial data. Pfizer submitted data on ten mice."
More from @MartyMakary via @guypbenson: townhall.com/tipsheet/guybenson/2023/09/18/insane-johns-h…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Was truly floored by what @MartyMakary told me about the new Covid vaccines the administration is now recommending for all Americans over the age of six months. Floored. radio.foxnews.com/2023/09/15/dr-marty-makary-latest-covid…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
At this point, I'm not telling anyone what to do with the vaccine. But @MartyMakary and @TracyBethHoeg do a nice job presenting the FDA data. You can decide for yourself.
The real data behind the new COVID vaccines the White House is pushing nypost.com/2023/09/14/the-real-data-behind-the-new-covid-… via @nypost
Imagine if other drugs were approved based on 10 mice.
Please read and share this article. @MartyMakary and @TracyBethHoeg, two highly respected physicians and researchers who are among the most familiar with all things covid. The first four paragraphs are particularly telling.
This is particularly disturbing considering covid is endemic and there exists no state of emergency. It’s also concerning that the FDA, charged with protecting food and drug safety seems to be unconcerned about its regulatory role with respect to all things covid.
Yet for all other drugs and devices, full approval can only be secured after going through the clinical trials process—a long effort involving thousands of consented participants (in this magnitude) and years more of data analysis. This entire process is designed to assure a safe and effective medical product. If found to be ineffective or unsafe at any point in the process, the trial is either halted or, if approved and rolled out, the drug is usually withdrawn.
Note: I’m glad to see this is finally posting.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
.@MartyMakary & I write for @nypost👇
@US_FDA & @CDCgov approve & rec new vax for all >6mos
Based on🐁antibodies(Pfizer)
& 50 humans(Moderna), 1/50 w/unknown AE related to vax
🇺🇸recs differ widely from Europe
Do FDA/CDC work for the 🇺🇸people or pharma?
nypost.com/2023/09/14/the-real-data-behind-the-new-covid-…
FDA should have rejected these data:
▪️Pfizer's new vaccine was approved based on 10 mice (no human data)
▪️Moderna's new vax was tested in 50 people tracked for just 2wks. One person had an adverse event requiring med attention-Moderna provided no details
nypost.com/2023/09/14/the-real-data-behind-the-new-covid-…
The CDC's incredible absolutism that all Americans must get this novel Covid vaccine is inconsistent with the data.
Why have an FDA if this is our new regulatory process?
@TracyBethHoeg and I reviewed all the data. Here's our analysis (above)
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Rochelle Walensky testified in front of Congress that we did not have Equipoise to run trials of masking kids
We show how that was absolutely false in our new piece
She failed the American people by recommending masking 2 year olds without data.
Sad
authors.elsevier.com/sd/article/S2666-5352(23)00074-5
What if I told you 1 in 50 people who took a new medication had a "medically-attended adverse event" and the manufacturer refused to disclose what the complication was, would you take it? And what if the theoretical benefit only lasted for a 3-mo window after which time the benefit is gone? and that the FDA cleared it without any human outcomes data, would you take it? and that European regulators are not universally recommending the same medication for everyone as the CDC is? and that Drs. Ashish Jha and Mandy Cohen are making unsupported claims that it reduces hospitalizations, long-Covid, and makes you less likely to spead Covid (if the manufacturers made those same claims they could be fined by the FDA for making false marketing claims beyond it's approved indication)
That's the new Moderna Covid vaccine. FDA or Moderna (I can't tell the difference sometimes) should disclose the details of the clinical trial complication rather than keeping it secret.
Worth pointing out👇
Of the 50 study participants that got the Moderna monovalent vax @CDCgov universally recommended today, 1/50 (2%) had a medically-attended adverse event related to the vax
W/unknown clinical benefits how can CDC say w certainty benefits outweigh risks 4 all?
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
In addition to my below advice, among the many competing voices on these issues is @MartyMakary. His data driven and pragmatic approach provides a point of view which merits visibility for anyone interested in this topic.
The @CDCgov has so badly hurt it’s own credibility, people are now questioning their data, their recommendations and it’s undermining to real public health efforts. Regarding the new vaccines for Covid, please talk to your doctor about risk/benefit….1/4
Moderna should have added more people to their study of 50 people. That’s the only way to know if the adverse event they reported is a true warning signal, before the new vaccine was recommended to 300 million people yesterday
Worth pointing out👇
Of the 50 study participants that got the Moderna monovalent vax @CDCgov universally recommended today, 1/50 (2%) had a medically-attended adverse event related to the vax
W/unknown clinical benefits how can CDC say w certainty benefits outweigh risks 4 all?
Amazing how extensive the government cover-up was
In case you missed this bombshell news yesterday:
A senior level CIA officer told Congress in whistleblower testimony that the agency bribed analysts to “change their position” COVID-19 came from a lab townhall.com/tipsheet/katiepavlich/2023/09/12/the-cia-was…
The U.S. is an odd international outlier in pushing the new vaccine on young & healthy people.
Dr @ashishkjha’s 9/12/23 GMA youtu.be/I5nnhN9N8hY discussion of the covid XBB1.5 vax was a FARRAGO OF LIES & MISSTATEMENTS, UNSUPPORTED by ANY randomized, controlled trial evidence from the original covid vax trials, & not even remotely studied for XBB1.5!
"Most people should get their annual covid shot the way they get their annual flu shot."
"It makes the fall, the winter the holidays, just much safer."
"We can manage our way through it (waves of covid) just keeping up with the vaccines."
The BIGGEST LIES: "If you get covid after getting vaccinated it is going to be much milder, you're less likely to miss work, you're less likely to miss school, you're less likely to spread it to others so maybe you're not high risk, so maybe grandma is, if you've gotten the covid shot you're less likely to spread it to her, that makes a really big difference"
"Some people go to develop 'Long Covid', that gets reduced by getting vaccinated, too.” Another misrepresentation. "Long Covid," as demonstrated by the most rigorous observational studies, is a psychosomatic syndrome (other than perhaps transient loss of taste) in the vast preponderance of people who had mild to moderate, non-hospitalized infections, & in that same population, it is impossible to distinguish any such mild "morbidity" from vaccine effects.
The incredible story of how Standford tried to shut down, suppress & censor research it didn't like.
"Stanford Univ. admin leadership intervened and interfered with the study in ways that violated accepted standards of academic freedom" -@DrJBhattacharya
open.substack.com/pub/disinformationchronicle/p/dr-jay-bh…
@DrJBhattacharya is a scientist who remained true to the scientific method despite intense academic bullying from an elite medical establishment (if you've ever wondered who is the medical establishment, read this incredible article and it will be clear).
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
People didn't know because of censorship and slander.
Politicians didn't know because they weren't smart enough to listen to multiple divergent voices.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Newsom on California's extreme Covid restrictions: "We didn’t know what we didn’t know. We’re experts in hindsight."
His kids attended private school in person while millions of kids in CA were barred from school entirely.
www.politico.com/news/2023/09/10/newsom-covid-california-…
There was plenty of time for Pfizer/Moderna to run a randomized trial to prove their new boosters work. Moderna's trial (of just 50 people) began~4 months ago &only reported 14-day side effects. Why didn't they enroll more ppl & report 3 mo. effectiveness? www.wsj.com/articles/biden-waves-another-covid-shot-throu…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
No matter what you thought of lockdowns, everyone owes a debt of gratitude to @DrJBhattacharya, @SunetraGupta and @MartinKulldorff.
Because science cannot function without free speech.
Read @DrJBhattacharya on their legal victory today in @TheFP:
www.thefp.com/p/i-fought-government-censorship-and-won
I wonder if he's referring to the CDC study of 2 hairdressers: www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12497173/biden-mask-covi…
Yesterday the retired NIAID director reappeared on TV to walk back his comments from the previous week. In the intervening 7 days, he appears to have discovered “studies” that show that masks “actually do work.” One is left mystified as to what he actually believes and why.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
ODELL 🔥🔥🔥🔥
New study: Moderna's novel XBB.1.5 booster was given to 50 people. No data reported on efficacy or any follow-up. They could have reported 3-month follow-up (trial started~4 mo. ago). Important before the FDA/CDC recommend it to 300M Americans next week.
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.08.22.23293434v2
The prestigious Cochrane Organization is the latest medical institution affected by partisan ideology. Their crime? They did an objective review of 17 studies on masks and got results the CDC/medical establishment didn't like. Great piece by @DavidStrom
hotair.com/david-strom/2023/08/28/cochrane-review-the-lat…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
US federal court: "FDA is not a physician"
Picture of the week: The double standard of children being forced to mask at some U.S. schools. They can’t just decide they don’t like wearing them, like adults, including the President mol.im/a/12497173
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
1) Partisans and social media influencers are attacking the science on masks, because they want....NEED masks to stop COVID.
It's like a religion--an unseemly religion. And it needs to stop.
But even Fauci had to admit on CNN the obvious.... disinformationchronicle.substack.com/p/zeynep-tufekcis-un…
Even Dr. Paul Offit who advocated hard for Covid vaccine mandates is not recommending the new Covid booster (about to be FDA approved) for healthy people under 75
www.wsj.com/articles/biden-waves-another-covid-shot-throu…
mol.im/a/12496327
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
.@MCPS is bringing back the useless restriction trifecta: Masks! Asymptomatic testing!! And distancing!!!
Parents, it's beyond time to say ENOUGH. Let our children learn in peace!
Masking did nothing for the 276,000 participants in randomized trials or cluster RCTs. The Cochrane review is now being criticized simply because some people do not like the results--but that's not how science works. 1/2
www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD00620…
The prestigious Cochrane organization is being heavily lobbied by partisans to downplay the results. And sadly, the managing editor, who was not involved in the analysis, is caving to political pressure. Their website now doesn't allow you to share the study on social media.👇🏼👇🏼
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Public health should not be a partisan political project. Surely there is a way to find common ground, rather than only platforming one type of viewpoint.
Lori Lightfoot joins Bill DeBlasio on the teaching staff at the Harvard School of Public Health. Thursday she will speak on Covid policy & equity. Interesting how wide the doors open at Harvard for politicians voted out of office, as long as they are from one political party.
Join the #harvardchanstudio on 9/7 at 1 pm ET for an insightful discussion with former Chicago Mayor @LoriLightfoot. She will share her approach to developing policies— including the #covid response—centered on equity and opportunity.
▶️ Register: hsph.me/Lightfoot
KJP says the new Covid XBB vaccine (expected to be FDA approved this week) works. But how can she know since no human outcomes studies were conducted? www.wsj.com/articles/biden-waves-another-covid-shot-throu…
KJP pushes new Covid booster shots. We know that these vaccines work, we know that when people stay up to date with their vaccines, it works.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🧵EXCLUSIVE: Lead author of Cochrane mask review responds to Fauci's dismissal of evidence
When asked about Cochrane's review that showed masks did not stop viral spread, Fauci said "Yeah, but there are other studies."
Tom Jefferson, first author on Cochrane study responds👇👇
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Fauci says “There’s no doubt that masks work”
Jefferson responds, “It might be that Fauci is relying on trash studies...Many of them are observational, some are cross-sectional, and some actually use modelling. That is not strong evidence”
@VPrasadMDMPH @doc_gero @TracyBethHoeg
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
More patients are now getting diagnosed with prostate cancer at later stages, when it is often too late to be cured. A two-decade decline in death rates has stalled. www.wsj.com/health/healthcare/when-screening-for-prostate… via @WSJ
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Link to FULL story: maryannedemasi.substack.com/p/exclusive-lead-author-of-co…
U.S. health officials were passively supportive of arresting people for not wearing masks indoors or outdoors in 2021. Not saying anything about this (and California arresting surfers, Michigan putting sand in teen skate parks, etc.) was a passive endorsement for the crackdown.
Sept. 24, 2021
Five men entered a store in Australia.
For not wearing masks, police beat them savagely and arrested them.
Sweden did not lock down or have mask mandates. It had lower excess deaths than Australia.
Australia's draconian pandemic policies did enormous harm.
3 years into mask mandates:
"When you're talking about the effect on the epidemic or pandemic as a whole, the data are less strong."
-- Dr. Anthony Fauci
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
An amazing @CNN clip, posted by @TheEliKlein where an anchor confronts Fauci with Cochrane's report showing no proven benefit to community masking
Fauci says it works for individuals not populations
Yet, this is also a lie. How? I explain
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/anthony-fauci-co…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Biden is certain that our new Covid booster “works,” but there’s no data. Is this how we approve drugs now? asks @MartyMakary
www.wsj.com/articles/biden-waves-another-covid-shot-throu…
Is bad behavior really here to stay?
www.axios.com/2023/09/01/covid-pandemic-mental-heallth-cr…
Children have become the line in the sand for adults having a political debate...
Disgraceful. Scaring people from sending kids to school is the hallmark of mainstream media. The years of life lost from their colossal stupidity will someday be fully counted and catastrophic. Turning journalism into liberal political pr machine was a big error.
"The fall booster enriches Pfizer and does not generate data for 300 million people who may be curious. It looks like they will double down on their errors." @VPrasadMDMPH @Sensible__Med open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/the-fall-covid19…
NEW STUDY: The new BA286 variant appears to evade prior XBB immunity (and likely the new Covid vax about to be recommended for 300M American teenagers &adults at the 9/12 CDC mtg) but the good news is that it has lower infectivity~a low chance of dominating over current variants.
Sharing some new experimental data on BA.2.86:
1) BA.2.86 is antigenically distinct compared to XBB.1.5.
2) BA.2.86 can significantly escape XBB-infection/vaccination induced antibodies.
3) However, the infectivity of BA.2.86 may be much lower than XBB.1.5 and EG.5. (1/n)
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Nursing homes will have to maintain minimum staffing levels under a Biden administration proposal despite lobbying from the industry, which says it will be too onerous amid a labor shortage www.wsj.com/health/nursing-homes-must-boost-staffing-unde… via @WSJ
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Safety data will be available in 2 years
Efficacy data will never be available
(except for confounded observational data)
Why does the CDC work for Pfizer?
The newest version of the COVID-19 vaccine will be available by the end of September, according to the CDC. wb.md/47wII4n
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Great @MartyMakary column explains why regulators shouldn't treat new covid boosters the same way they treat flu vaccines. Without randomized evidence, clinicians will be giving advice blind to their patients about the fall booster.
www.wsj.com/articles/biden-waves-another-covid-shot-throu…
FDA &CDC pushing the new XBB Covid booster on 300M Americans with zero human outcomes data makes a mockery of the scientific method and our regulatory process.
My latest oped..
www.wsj.com/articles/biden-waves-another-covid-shot-throu…
Amazing. “History is Written by Victors.” -- Winston Churchill www.wsj.com/articles/joe-biden-school-closings-covid-teac… via @WSJopinion
Great article by @TracyBethHoeg detailing misinformation spread by @JAMAnetwork. Dr. Hoeg is a scientific evidence connoisseur. Hard to refute any of the 10 facts she lays out here.
open.substack.com/pub/tracybethhegmdphd/p/because-truth-i…
Students attending the 100 colleges requiring a Covid vax/boost even if you recently had Covid, please share this definitive study with your college leaders:
www.thelancet.com/article/S0140-6736(22)02465-5/fulltext
Why did Pfizer wait 1 yr (just now) to release data on their Covid vaccine trial in pregnant women—a trial that abruptly and mysteriously ended early?
And why is there no infomation on 12 patients? 1/2
Pfizer drip feeds data from its pregnancy trial of covid-19 vaccine
It took over 1 year to publish.
An analysis of the results so far shows the trial was underpowered, poorly designed & incomplete
See comments from Profs @RetsefL & Angela Spelsber
👇
blog.maryannedemasi.com/p/pfizer-drip-feeds-data-from-its…
Pfizer probably saw how strong the CDC was blindly pushing the vaccine in pregnant women without a supporting trial in pregnant women, that they decided there was no need to do the study. So just shut it down and hide the results until now?👇🏼
www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/was-covid-vaccin…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The FDA proposed new guidance that could move clinical trials from university labs to neighborhood pharmacies. But no matter where trials happen, the FDA must uphold the strongest approval standards.
Read AV’s letter here: www.arnoldventures.org/stories/av-submits-letter-on-decen…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
"As the pandemic unfolded, China remained a black box. It slammed the door on any further investigation of the origins of the virus inside China and did not publish accurate data on the pandemic death toll." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/08/22/wuhan-doctors-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Health care CEOs hauled in $4 billion last year as inflation pinched workers, analysis shows www.statnews.com/2023/08/17/health-ceo-salaries-compensat… via @statnews
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“Malaria was once common in the United States, including in Maryland, but we have not seen a case in Maryland that was not related to travel in over 40 years,” apnews.com/article/maryland-malaria-locally-acquired-0fb5…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Public health elites are debating whether we should all wear masks again.
But did you know CDC published a review of the best evidence in May 2020 and showed masks do not prevent influenza viral transmission?
CDC knows masks do not work.
Do not comply.
wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/26/5/19-0994_article
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
💯 by now, most of us know that masks don’t protect U from a virus measured in nanometers. The NIH said it, Fauci said & it even says so on the box! If Biden tries to bring them back I hope they’re ready for a fight because that’s what they’ll get. #bringiton
h/t @MartyMakary
Public health elites are debating whether we should all wear masks again.
But did you know CDC published a review of the best evidence in May 2020 and showed masks do not prevent influenza viral transmission?
CDC knows masks do not work.
Do not comply.
wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/26/5/19-0994_article
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This update from a resident of Maui is very eye-opening and worth a listen.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“We found there may be no short-term advantages with using blue-light filtering spectacle lenses to reduce visual fatigue associated with computer use.”
www.cnn.com/2023/08/17/health/blue-light-glasses-study-we…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Insurers now routinely require doctors to kick back as much as 5% if they want to be paid electronically. Some medical clinics told ProPublica they are now seeking ways to raise their rates, which would pass the costs on to patients. www.propublica.org/article/why-doctors-spend-millions-on-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
A short list of errors in the JAMA Network Open paper on misinformation
At least 4 things they call misinformation are demonstrably true. Its a sad showing for JAMA.
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/jama-network-open-paper-p…
@DrJBhattacharya @TracyBethHoeg @ericweinstein @EWidera @AnilMakam @DrToddLee
Public health officials who demanded prolonged school shutdowns have a civic duty to rescue these ‘missing’ children.
reason.com/2023/08/15/covids-missing-students/
JAMA, CDC, & the government’s Truth™️ agencies spread a lot of misinformation during the pandemic (see 🧵). But when they use the term it’s to justify censoring different scientific opinions—even after they are later supported by solid research.
Excellent @TracyBethHoeg 9-part evisceration twitter.com/TracyBethHoeg/status/1691564067520176568
of JAMA “C19 misinformation” tripe jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2808… incl “C19 death” data via CDC. Overcounting "C19 deaths" problem is FAR worse based on autopsy, med record, & even honest death certificate review www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-32441-7; doi.org/10.1101/2022.01.26.22269805;
www.andrewbostom.org/2020/10/covid-19-death-distortion-in…; doi.org/10.3390/vaccines10050774
Just...wow. How is this @JAMANetworkOpen article on supposed "misinformation" spread by physicians not parody?
I outline in this🧵9 of the more egregious false claims made by the authors
Study should be retracted; it's an embarrassment to our profession jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2808358
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Just...wow. How is this @JAMANetworkOpen article on supposed "misinformation" spread by physicians not parody?
I outline in this🧵9 of the more egregious false claims made by the authors
Study should be retracted; it's an embarrassment to our profession jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2808358
Johns Hopkins Surgeons Develop Protocols to Improve High-Value Care for Patients clinicalconnection.hopkinsmedicine.org/news/johns-hopkins…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
"From virtually the beginning... the gov't adopted a “take no prisoners” strategy on controlling information about Covid. When... Collins & Fauci found their mistaken beliefs... challenged, they set out to silence dissent."
www.city-journal.org/article/censorship-and-the-public-he…
Many deaths in Hawaii were preventable. Hawaii’s alarm system was not activated—a tragic failure of local government. www.deseret.com/2023/8/11/23828527/why-didnt-hawaiis-alar…
College degree work requirements hurt the working class
open.substack.com/pub/freopp/p/how-unnecessary-college-de…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Speechless. Apparently, this “decision” serves two purposes:
1. punishment for the individual deviating from the set narrative
2. example to avoid for the rest of us.
SAD
Agree Dr. Fisher. If the Am Board of Intern Med believed those things, they wouldn't be actively threatening to remove the board certification of doctors who are asking to see clinical data on Covid booster vaccines in healthy students before recommending them.
ABIM "Commitments" hanging on their wall:
"Science Based Medicine and Intellectual Rigor" "Professionalism and Excellence in the Practice of Medicine" "Maintaining Autonomy to Preserve These Values"
Total B.S. They're just to preserve the money flow.
www.change.org/p/eliminate-abims-moc-requirement?signed=true
Prominent medical school dean forced out. His crime? Liking tweets questioning vaccine long-term efficacy, suggesting not all gender transition surgery is indicated, and suggesting universities have large DEI bureaucracies. Ironically, his school is named “Thomas Jefferson Univ”
Incredible. Mark Tykocinski, President of Tom Jefferson University is forced to step down after 'liking' tweets critical of covid vaccines, gender reassignment surgery and DEI bureaucracies.
The medical establishment has torched its credibility.
legalinsurrection.com/2023/07/president-of-thomas-jeffers…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Today's video explores how Preprint Servers are censoring COVID19 manuscripts they disagree with
I prove they have no consistent scientific standard
They also refused to post our analysis of their conduct... weird youtu.be/RvE4kyu35Lw via @YouTube
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
FACEBOOK FILES
White House officials worried that if people had access to all information about the vaccine, fewer people would take it.
So they pressured Facebook to "take down bad news" about the COVID vaccine, EVEN IF IT WAS TRUE.
www.foxnews.com/media/new-facebook-files-reveal-lengths-w…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
New study in @NEJM. Covid does not appear to cause type 1 diabetes:
"Systematic testing for the virus and type 1 diabetes... did not show that Covid-19 precipitated type 1 diabetes, in contrast to studies in which Covid-19 testing was not performed."
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2216477
Glad to see the first gene therapy for Muscular Dystrophy given today @ChildrensNatl
www.miragenews.com/first-commercial-dose-of-fda-approved-…
Biden admin just announced a new office of Long Covid. Medical progress or added bureaucracy? If we set up an office for every medical condition, we should consider one for cystic & solid lesions of the pancreas, which account for 7% of all cancer deaths
www.hhs.gov/about/news/2023/07/31/hhs-announces-formation…
New New England Journal study: The 90% mortality reduction attributed to Covid booster shots in the highly cited 2021 NEJM study was NOT due to the booster shot. It was due to other patient factors.
Sadly, the flawed 2021 study was used to justify booster mandates.
Unreal to check my email about what's trending in @NEJM & see our article is #1 most viewed🤯.
I mean, I agree, the boosted having a 20x lower non covid mortality rate than the non-boosted not being disclosed in such an influential study of the 1st booster published in NEJM (www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2115624) is a huge deal. Such a big deal I had to do the calculation over and over and over. I knew there was bias, but, wow, 94.8% lower non covid mortality among the boosted!? (As skeptical and cynical as I am, I did not see a difference that big coming)
Are people now waking up to how misleading observational vaccine data can be? Clearly the authors knew about the bias in the data at least since they wrote the response where they disclosed the non-covid mortality numbers in March of 2022. I have trouble believing they did not know about it at the time of the initial publication in December of 2021.
The authors of the original study disclosed no ties to Pfizer but from what I can tell Clalit Health Services is comprised of over half of the Israeli population and the Israeli Ministry of Health had the following agreement about evidence collaboration with Pfizer starting Jan 2021- where Pfizer would be involved in preparing and publishing all results (!). Does anyone know exactly which published studies this applied to? ghiaa.org/provision_document/israel-pfizer-real-world-epi…
At any rate, the study published in NEJM we can now see was biased to such an extent, at least I do not think it should have been published. Without a doubt, what is currently written in the article (about a 90% lower covid mortality rate among the boosted is very misleading.... as that was EXPECTED given the underlying differences in health!). We will be writing more on this topic as all of us in medicine should be aware of the potential for these biases.
Very excited this letter @VPrasadMDMPH , Ram Duriseti and I wrote has been able to generate so much attention. Have a great Sunday, friends!
Link to our letter : www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2306683
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Under Gov. @GavinNewsom, California has among the most closed school days in the country. In Cayla J v. State of California, low-income students are suing about learning loss. The state is prohibiting researchers with access to gov. data from testifying.
edsource.org/2023/california-moves-to-silence-stanford-re…
“We RUUUUUUULE. That’s tenure secured, right there,” Dr. Anderson wrote after publishing the Nature Medicine analysis ruling out a lab leak. Weeks earlier, he told Fauci “features (potentially) look engineered... the genome is inconsistent with expectations from evolutionary theory”
He also told the medical journal Nature Medicine that the article was commissioned by Drs. Fauci & Collins.
@mattwridley @Ayjchan www.wsj.com/articles/the-covid-lab-leak-deception-anderse…
A new NEJM article exposes statistical flaws in a prior 2021 NEJM study used to justify Covid booster mandates.
"Science is a neutral tool of getting at truth." -Dr. Prasad
After a long break, I am back on Youtube
Today, I am talking about our NEJM paper that shows the Booster analyses that FDA relied upon were flawed
Check it out
www.youtube.com/watch?v=1MJWgaYfWgA
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Our correspondence is out in @njem written w @VPrasadMDMPH & Ram Duriseti
We show v strong evidence of healthy vaccinee bias in an Israeli study of Pfizer booster vs covid death, which wasn't disclosed
Could explain ALL reported benefit of the booster🧵
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2306683?query=featured…
Thank you! I’m a big believer in civil discourse. Thanks for hosting a great group and great discussion.
An honor to have Dr @MartyMakary of Johns Hopkins speak at the intern lecture series hosted by Rand and @TFASorg. Dr. Makary’s message of “data over dogma” and the disastrous Covid public health policies resonated with young people on the right and the left!
Thankful for objective scientists like @TracyBethHoeg for keeping the New England Journal of Medicine in check. Wow
Our new preprint is out: We reanalyze & expand the highly-influential Boston school mask study by Cowger et al published in @NEJM
- Our expanded sample actually found higher case rates (not significant) in the masking districts
- The authors' original findings did not hold up when not using the very specific Callaway Sant'Anna Diff in Diff methodology which we argue was inappropriate to use given the data they had
-We show districts that dropped masks 1st had the biggest drop in cases (!)
-We found prior immunity could explain up to 2/3 of the variation in case rates (!)
We discuss in detail why causal inference was inappropriate in the original paper (www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2211029?query=feature…) including statements about masks effectively reducing cases or being able to help mitigate structural racism
Very grateful to have been able to work with this incredible team:
@AChandra_TO @ShamezLadhani @VPrasadMDMPH & Ram Duriseti
Hopefully the peer reviewed version of our paper will be available soon. In the meantime, we welcome feedback of course!
Our raw data, as always, are available on my github; link in the article
arxiv.org/abs/2307.11974
(if you ask me our paper should have been published under statistics rather than physics, but I guess arXiv disagreed!)
Thank You! Loved every minute.
.@MartyMakary delivers remarks to hundreds of D.C. interns for the last installation of the Capitol Hill Lecture Series, hosted in partnership with @senatorrandpaul.
Great meeting with bipartisan congressional staffers today at the Capitol Hill speaker series!
Thank you Dr. @MartyMakary for joining #tfas and @senatorrandpaul for the last Capitol Hill Lecture of 2023!
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The Johns Hopkins Center for Talented Youth is not run by Talented People 👇
They are still masking kids in JULY 2023
Imagine, being both incapable of reading evidence AND incapable of looking around at your peers.
"stop the spread" -- PS: it is not possible
America will spend billions on a drug to treat Alzheimer’s, but pennies to study what actually causes it open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/does-anyone-still-car…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
📢 Welcome @Kroger to the Cost Plus Drugs family! 👏
➡️ The teamcubancard.com free Rx benefit card is now accepted at all Kroger Family of Pharmacy locations across the country – that's more than 2,000 stores in 35 states.
🧑⚕️ If you love Cost Plus Drugs low prices but want to pick up your prescription at a local pharmacy, including Kroger locations nationwide, sign up for your Team Cuban Card today!
teamcubancard.com/sign-up/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
NYTimes reporting that ER visits for teenage girls rose sharply during COVID. Were they for life-threatening COVID infections? Of course not: Mental health issues such as suicide attempts. This is tragic yet predictable and we must learn from it.
“During Covid we saw naked allegiance to political figures, regardless of the data. Doctors & the public alike were quick to cite studies to support their ideas, even if the methodological quality would not meet entry criteria for a 7th grade science fair” open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/does-anyone-still-car…
It’s time to stop censorship within the Public-Health Establishment www.city-journal.org/article/censorship-and-the-public-he…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
#electronichealthrecords [#ehrs] were a game-changer — but a new proposal could be deadly. The possible risks to patients are endless when a physician cannot access complete medical information.
thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/4097946-electronic-health-…
@thehill
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Very interesting trend w/ large employers (fortune 150 company) + large labor unions suing their third party administrators (TPAs) claiming that the TPAs have enriched themselves at the cost of the beneficiaries of health insurance @Aetna @ElevanceHealth www.beckerspayer.com/payer/employers-are-increasingly-sui…
NYT cover story today highlights our research on the appropriateness of medical care, spotlighting vascular procedures. Thank you @CaitlinWHicks for leading this work. We CAN address unnecessary care. Before we increase healthcare spending, let’s cut the waste. See 🧵👇🏼👇🏼
Front page Sunday @nytimes - doesn't get much bigger than this. #approrpriateness in the treatment of #claudication is finally getting the public attention it deserves. 👏 @jbsgreenberg @katie_thomas @gebeloffnyt
Follow below for a short #tweetorial on the #cms data behind this
Glad to see @CMSGov @BrooksLaSureCMS proposal to make hospital price transparency regulations more enforceable and more accessible to patients @PtRightsAdvoc www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/cms-considers-hospi…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The onslaught of stories about #overtreatment of #claudication continues. Powerful @nytimes article on the cover today . . . And it really hits home. When will it stop???
#wecanfobetter #appropriateness #paded @VascularSVS @JudithLin4
www.nytimes.com/2023/07/15/health/atherectomy-peripheral-…
"Virginia’s new law flips this unfair pricing power imbalance on its head. When patients can spot vast differences in prices for the same medical services, they can choose affordable alternatives, improving healthcare access and equity." @DelDanHelmer www.wsj.com/articles/virginia-leads-the-way-on-medical-pr…
Silencing Dr. Joyner @MayoClinic was a blow to academic freedom www.postbulletin.com/opinion/columns/column-silencing-dr-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
In a new preprint by Sarah Miller and I, we analyze what predicted hospitals keeping masking mandates in Q1 2023
Covid cases? nope
Covid hospitalizations? nope
How many people voted for Biden? yes!
Masking policy at hospitals is political
Sad!
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.07.11.23292518v1.ful…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Tony Fauci's unredacted email about his conversation with @JeremyFarrar on the lab leak in Feb 2020 should have been part of the public record after the initial FOIA request. The @nih has flouted its FOIA obligations the entire pandemic. An abuse of power.
For those who think the ‘preventability’ of the Covid pandemic is important, here is a powerful new report…
🚨BREAKING 🚨
Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic’s report on the Suppression of the COVID-19 Lab Leak Hypothesis is out!
A few revelations below 👇
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Seattle/King County has already seen 630 fatal overdoses this year, putting us on pace to exceed last year's record high 1,000 (which beat the previous year's record high, etc).
What are we doing in response? Giving out drug paraphernalia, like pipes and needles.
Interesting piece by @JonathanTurley
themessenger.com/opinion/fauci-and-others-may-have-lacked…
We should have seen this coming. Those who warned about this outcome should not have been censored:
Fewer children, more sadness, more suicide www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/fewer-children-more-sa…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The personal story of a podcast listener who sought to gain a better picture of his cardiovascular health – and who saved his own life as a result.
peterattiamd.com/patient-ascvd-story-highlight/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Welcome to Blackstone USA: How private equity is gobbling up the American city and turning residents into collateral, from @valerieestahl.
www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/welcome-blacksto…
This law was designed to ensure that NIH center directors do not serve endless terms like some African presidents (Fauci >> President Mugabe of Zimbabwe). U.S House E&C found this law—and Fauci’s reappointment—was sidestepped by HHS Sec Bacerra. @HouseCommerce @cathymcmorris
🚨 BREAKING: @SecBecerra FAILED to follow the Constitution and the law to reappoint 14 top NIH officials—including Dr. Fauci—when their terms expired in Dec 2021.
These officials held unlawful positions & used authority they didn’t have—including approving $26 BILLION in grants.
New Study: delayed cord clamping in newborns (to increase blood flow)- "Cardiac output, cardiac index.. & stroke volume index were signif increased in the group of infants with delayed cord clamping at 120sec." @ClevelandClinic @CairoUniversity www.thieme-connect.com/products/ejournals/abstract/10.105…
Building on the great work of @drarpineo @TAMU @bswhealth
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Experts said yesterday's anti-censorship court ruling was too badly written to be implemented, but it's already working. The State Department today canceled its regular Wednesday meeting with Facebook, and all future meetings, "pending further guidance.”
www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/07/05/missouri-bid…
Enjoyed my time with @jessgolflessonsover the 4th holiday. One of the best teaching pros in America IMO
How to achieve radius management:) this will help your golf game!
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I am a big fan of Dr. Greenwald's writing, we have featured him quite a bit of @Sensible__Med. This is a fun read.
Answering Reader Questions About Psychiatry open.substack.com/pub/socraticpsychiatrist/p/answering-re…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Regardless of politics, government collusion to censor should outrage all Americans. Kudos to this judge and all those who were targeted by The Man: Biden likely violated First Amendment, federal judge says
www.foxnews.com/politics/biden-likely-violated-first-amen… @caseybmulligan @DrJBhattacharya
Scientists should be scientifically objective, especially when they control NIH funding for the broader research community.
Dr. Fauci, in an attempt to conceal his involvement, asked Dr. Morens to publicly suppress the lab leak theory:
▪️ "...my boss Tony actually ASKED me to speak to the National Geographic on the record about origins"
▪️ "...Tony doesn't want his fingerprints on origin stories."
If you want to understand drug prices, PBM’s, hospitals, doctors, quality measures, the supply chain, medical billing, middlemen, the medication shortages, and the business of medicine 101 from a fresh perspective you won’t hear from the permanent medical establishment…
Healthcare has become a $4.3 trillion industry and extracts a high cost on patients. This book by @MartyMakary looks at drivers of healthcare expenses and ways to decrease waste and increase quality.
www.excellentphysician.com/post/the-price-we-pay
#healthcare
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Public health experts in the US in 2020 literally said a 2 year old has to wear a cloth mask in daycare, except when they nap, & if they don't comply on an airplane, throw the whole family off.
That degree of stupidity is inexcusable, unforgivable; no matter what ancestors did
We tried to improve COVID vaccine labeling for better informed consent — the FDA said no
thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/4037145-we-tried-to-improv…
Mayo Clinic "is the last place one would have imagined trying to marginalize one of its own distinguished scientists"
Great piece by @drjohnm on @MayoClinic's Witch trial of one of it's most accomplished doctors--accused of a thought crime. @Sensible__Med
open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/mandrola-chooses-a-fa…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“For every subgroup in the population, medical science has long held high the principle of requiring data before making strong recommendations. Women should not be treated any differently.”
~ Dr. @MartyMakary in @tabletmag www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/was-covid-vaccin…
Not sure why Covid information was 'classified' in the first place. The public bore the risk.
nypost.com/2023/06/19/10-reasons-we-know-that-covid-19-le…
The Biden admin has released a summary of US intelligence on the links between China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology and COVID-19. But by not revealing the names of the WIV scientists who fell ill in November 2019, President Biden is in violation of the law he signed.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
#vaccines are not all good or all bad. Some are extremely important, some are questionable and some are good for some but harmful to others. As a vaccine safety scientist, I say we need a nuanced debate. @RobertKennedyJr @PeterHotez @joerogan @elonmusk
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This piece from @MartyMakary is exactly right. Was the vaccine safe for pregnant women? PROBABLY YES. But did the CDC have enough evidence to say so with certainty at the time? NO. And thus it should have been more modest in its recommendations. www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/was-covid-vaccin…
Children harmed by extended Covid restrictions deserve special attention and help from the schools that shut them out.
The extended shutdowns were an absolute catastrophe for our kids and this country @caseybmulligan @MartyMakary National test scores plunge, with still no sign of pandemic recovery @YouDecideHealth www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/06/21/national-stud…
Comforting a patient on a ventilator simply by [a loved one, not a fake glove] holding their hand is powerful. Where was organized medicine to speak against cruel hospital visitation policies--a human rights violation promoted by the establishment group think for years, long after we knew visitors posed no appreciable risk and did not deplete PPE. Even if they did deplete PPE, it's good to say goodbye to your loved one, tell them you love them, share any regrets, tell them they will always be in your thoughts, and kiss them. Some hospitals still do not allow visitors to Covid positive patients. Thank you @VPrasadMDMPH @ZDoggMD for speaking out against this human rights violation throughout the pandemic.
Reminder: In April 2021, nurses filled gloves with hot water to hold the hands of dying patients, isolated from family because of hospital protocols.
Every government should adopt human rights legislation to guarantee patients the right to family visits.
www.news18.com/news/buzz/hand-of-god-brazilian-nurses-use…
10 compelling reasons we know that COVID-19 leaked from the Wuhan Lab
nypost.com/2023/06/19/10-reasons-we-know-that-covid-19-le…
U.S. drugmakers are required to print around 90 billion sheets of paper a year to make inserts on how to prescribe medication, which health professionals often don't read www.wsj.com/articles/one-change-could-help-u-s-drugmakers…
"We could move on in a cooperative way... what we need is an international consortium..."
"between 5-50% of the population could die from another man-made virus, so this very serious. This is up there with nuclear arms control" @RandPaul @MariaBartiromo
www.foxnews.com/video/6329687328112
We should have seen this coming. Far more children died from suicide than Covid during the pandemic. CDC dragged their feet on releasing important data—would not release the full dataset until now, despite many requests.
"The Main Covid Lockdown Casualties: Children
Suicide and homicide rates for young people hit a 20-year high"
www.wsj.com/articles/cdc-report-lockdowns-crime-suicide-c… @jamestaranto @WSJ
Far more healthy children died of suicide than Covid during the pandemic
"The Main Covid Lockdown Casualties: Children
Suicide and homicide rates for young people hit a 20-year high"
www.wsj.com/articles/cdc-report-lockdowns-crime-suicide-c… @jamestaranto @WSJ
In an April 2020 television interview, I told@HARRISFAULKNER that an infected Wuhan lab worker was patient zero of the Covid-19 pandemic. NIH called it a conspiracy theory.
New evidence published yest confirms what I said was true--identifies the infected lab workers by name.👇🏼👇🏼
After years of official claims to the contrary, strong new evidence suggests the virus known as SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a Chinese lab. According to multiple sources, the researchers who led gain-of-function research, which increases infectiousness, were the first to be infected.
In Feb. 2020, after a @nypost oped said COVID-19 came from a lab leak, Facebook censored the story. Why? Because "independent fact-checkers" said it was "False information." Not only was it true information, one of the fact-checkers had worked at the lab
nypost.com/2020/04/17/facebook-fact-checkers-foul-again-a…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This is the result of so much covid pseudoscience becoming embedded in the infectious disease field as “fact”. For the field to recover, will need to recognize and purge the falsehoods.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Wuhan lab scientists were the first victims of COVID in the fall of 2019: Report www.foxnews.com/video/6329448836112 #foxnews #specialreport
This is the weaponization of science. Important🧵by @TracyBethHoeg👇🏼
Oh my gosh🤦♀️
When asked about mask data, @CDCDirector really said "the most comprehensive" was a TWO week MMWR study...
The one @AChandra_TO & I reanalyzed (extended in time & to a more nationally repr. sample: 565➡️1832 counties)
& the significant difference did not persist!🧵
An apology would have been better. Just amazing… the U.S. secretary of health & human services
MUST WATCH: @KevinKileyCA absolutely eviscerates HHS Secretary Becerra, "Did forcing 2-year-olds to wear masks save lives?"
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
After years of official claims to the contrary, strong new evidence suggests the virus known as SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a Chinese lab. According to multiple sources, the researchers who led gain-of-function research, which increases infectiousness, were the first to be infected.
"Federal officials used pliant news outlets and social media to declare anything that diverged from CDC diktats to be “misinformation.” The result, and Walensky’s true legacy, is that many Americans came to distrust the CDC’s guidance." by @CarlSchramm
www.city-journal.org/article/can-the-cdcs-reputation-be-r…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Here, @TracyBethHoeg is doing due diligence as a dedicated researcher, working towards the obvious good: to make sure we as citizens have the science based, accountable health authorities, we deserve.
.@TracyBethHoeg's opening statement at today's Congressional hearing on the topic of the assessing the CDC failures.
What do Drs. Anthony Fauci (still working @NIH), Ashish Jha (still WH Covid coord) & Rochelle Walensky (still @CDC) have to say about this?? It’s their policy… in effect today!
The Biden White House is requiring college athletes who won national championships & haven’t gotten the covid shot to wear masks and maintain six feet of social distancing on their White House visits Monday. Indefensible: www.outkick.com/college-athlete-day-at-bidens-white-house…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Congratulations to Djokovic for his 23rd Grand Slam victory!
I have a special admiration for this man not only as an outstanding athlete but also for courageously standing up for the principle of informed consent to medication.
sports.yahoo.com/french-open-2023-novak-djokovic-wins-rec… via @YahooSports
It's not about Covid @ClayTravis
The Biden White House is requiring college athletes who won national championships & haven’t gotten the covid shot to wear masks and maintain six feet of social distancing on their White House visits Monday. Indefensible: www.outkick.com/college-athlete-day-at-bidens-white-house…
great article
A bracing critique of politicized, commercialized science in the covid era by John Ioannidis and colleagues:
"[T]oday's medical science enterprise is not an autonomous, self-correcting global public good..."
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jep.13876
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“Congress poured $178 billion into helping hospitals offset financial losses”
Actually,
🇺🇸 taxpayers paid that 💰
We are owed Transparency
Thanks @PtRightsAdvoc @cathymcmorris @HouseCommerce @VernBuchanan @RepLarryBucshon www.rollcall.com/2023/06/08/once-cushioned-from-lawmaker-…
@CDC just called me to take a survey about my Covid vax experience. They asked MANY quest like:
Are you transgender?
Was the vax easy to find?
Did your doc rec a booster?
Are you a minority?
But they never asked: Did you experience a vaccine complication?
www.norc.org/research/projects/national-immunization-surv…
They could have added 1 quest. @CDCgov contracted the survey out to the Univ of Chi which said its:
“vital for knowing if people are getting vaccinations, making sure kids are up to date, and identifying pockets of need."
They don't seem knowing the data on complication rates.
They don't seem *interested* in collecting data on vax complications.
In conducting such a large national survey, asking 30+ questions like when did u get each dose & which vax, why not just add a simple quest?
If my research team did this survey, it would have been apolitical.
The great irony here is that some hospitals & surgery centers spending millions to show you they care about health equity also do not accept Medicaid patients
Check out our article about 🍒picking and 🍋dropping cases at freestanding ambulatory surgery centers for children driving disparities in care. jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2805576. Need imp policies! @NQUIRES1 @LurieChildrens @NMSurgery @APSASurgeons @AmerAcadPeds @AmCollSurgeons
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
FDA refuses to update the Pfizer COVID vaccine label to note it does not stop transmission, nor to list side effects. thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/4037145-we-tried-to-improv… FDA is industry's agency.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I will take a doctor who fails to adhere to "prescribed messaging" EVERY. DAY.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I am just shocked that this is not a bigger story. @DrMJoyner is an expert on exercise and performance in sports. He made comments in @nytimes about fairness when trans-athletes compete in women's sports and Mayo Clinic punishes him.
INSANE!
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/mayo-clinic-suspends-a-do…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
AstraZeneca had a drug that could have prolonged the lives of control arm patients after they progressed. Outside of the study they marketed it.
But they didn't give them the drug. They just counted their deaths so they could get a win. #asco23
And you celebrate?
#inthenews: New lung cancer study shows taking osimertinib once a day after surgery reduces chance of patients dying by 51%. This demonstrates the importance of dedicated lung cancer research & how it can save lives and give hope for a brighter future. www.theguardian.com/science/2023/jun/04/lung-cancer-pill-…
Very disappointed to see @MayoClinic suspend Dr. Michael Joyner for his opinions on NIH's bureaucracy & testosterone in trans-athletes. In their suspension letter, Mayo said he "failed to communicate in accordance with prescribed messaging" and "failed to consistently work within Mayo Clinic guidelines related to media interactions" www.thefire.org/research-learn/mayo-clinic-disciplinary-l…
In other words, he exercised free speech under the principles of academic freedom. @DrMJoyner is a HIGHLY published and widely-respected scientist I have long admired.
Early during Covid, when we had very few treatments, he led the New England Journal trial showing that concentrated plasma had efficacy against Covid... but no pharma executive gets rich from donated plasma infusions.
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/mayo-clinic-susp…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Some excellent news on the non-compete front from @ACCMinnesota. State advocacy in action! @ACCinTouch @Cardiology @NicoleLohrMD @drmalissawood @SrihariNaiduMD @himavidula Minnesota Lawmakers Pass Prospective Ban on Noncompete Provisions in Employment shar.es/afB1QW
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
.@MartinKulldorff "proposes many questions like, Why did the CDC routinely downplay infection-acquired immunity, despite the robust scientific evidence demonstrating its importance? We should insist on this inquiry."
--MJ Botelho
www.masslive.com/opinion/2023/06/we-need-open-dialogue-ab…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Your MUST READ of the day by @DrJBhattacharya in @tabletmag on the terrifying American govt censorship industry ==>www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/slaying-censorsh… detailing the war against free speech & free thought by govt. More power to free speech warriors @akheriaty @JeninYounesEsq @MartinKulldorff
Glad to see NIH dropping their last mask mandate yesterday, just 4 months after the Cochran review of all prior studies on the topic.
Would be good if the new CDC director stopped CDC’s current recommendation to keep mask toddlers too. youtu.be/I5Xn7SeaUVI
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The PGA Tour and LIV Golf have agreed to a stunning merger that ends the divide that has dominated the sport for the last year. www.wsj.com/articles/pga-tour-liv-golf-merger-saudi-arabi…
Many former politicians/political appointees are now @Harvard Sch of Public Health(e.g. Bill Deblasio) or the Hopkins Bloomberg Sch of Pub Health, but I've never heard of a former politician from the R side getting these sweetheart appointments. Ideological diversity is diversity
I've always loved teaching, and the opportunity to get back to it is something I am excited about. Looking forward to sharing the experiences and perceptions I learned governing through one of the most challenging times in American history with the @HarvardChanSPH community!
Curious if anyone knows of data on how many pilots were fired, or quit/retired early due to the vaccine mandate that ignored natural immunity.
If true, this is concerning.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Can I say a big thank you to everyone for the overwhelming response to the launch of my book today.
‘Oops! Why Things Go Wrong’
I hope people find it useful.
Available now from www.theliffeypress.com and from @easons @Waterstones & @amazon soon. 🙏
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Oncologists call it de-escalation: cutting back on some cancer therapies to improve a patient’s quality of life without hurting their odds of survival. What studies at ASCO showed. www.wsj.com/articles/for-some-cancers-less-treatment-is-a… via @Brabbott42
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
No Forgiveness For Pandemic Sins Until The Guilty Repent thefederalist.com/2023/06/03/no-forgiveness-for-pandemic-…
Schools of public health have become a refuge for exiting politicians &health agency appointees of 1 political party (only). A revolving door of partisan 'experts' at many schools intolerant of ideolog diversity. Lori Lightfoot joins Bill DeBlasio @Harvard
www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/former-chicago-mayor-lori-light…
I wonder how parents feel about the CDC director & the teachers union high-5ing each other over text as Biden announces the CDC school closure policy that the union edited. Important 🧵
Becky Pringle (2/8/21): "It's NEA President, Becky Pringle"
CDC Director: "Saw you're email. We are working on it. Will stay in touch."
Becky Pringle: "Thanks so much."
CDC Director (3/2/21): ":)!"
Becky Pringle: "YES!!!!"
I’m sure vaccine mandates that ignored natural immunity had nothing to do with the American Airlines CEO saying they can’t deploy 150 regional jets because of pilot shortage stocks.apple.com/AuZHmt3EES-Kuj6FdRpqMhQ
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Incredible work all around from the @hopkinssurgery research residents our annual Bulkley Research Day. Congrats to all on fantastic talks, and huge THANK YOU to @AlverdyJohn for joining us as visiting professor and inspiring us as #surgeonscientists @AndrewMCameron @UChicago
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
It's amazing that reporters don't want to cover this 👇. It's a real scandal. Almost looks like FDA is working for Pfizer
FDA released Pfizer from studying lower doses. Based on what? They did this before receiving results from the subclinical myocarditis study in this group.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
If conventional media continues to be the marketing arm of pharma, the media, public health, and the public will all suffer.
3/3
www.illusionconsensus.com/p/update-editor-at-pro-vaccine-…
As we show in this publication, university booster mandates resulted in a net harm.
Using true myocard rates &precise data on Cov hosp rates(not the exagg rates CDC uses), the risk:benefit calculus is clear. Misleading that PH consider incidental Cov during hosp/death as causal.
Just published in @JME_BMJ our group's reply to Dr. Lam & Nichols' published Response to our article "COVID-19 vaccine boosters for young adults: A risk-benefit assessment and ethical analysis of mandate policies at universities"
tl;dr (or cr) version (since not open access)
"In conclusion, we have given a fair representation of the expected harms of the booster dose for young people and provided a conservative overestimate of the benefits of the booster dose against severe COVID-19 in this age group. Thus far vaccination has not been shown to prevent future severe disease in those with infection-derived immunity and this is currently estimated to be over 93% of first-year college-aged people in the USA.
The benefits of the booster in this age group, even to those not previously infected, have not been demonstrated using randomised data.... For these reasons, and because we did not subtract out incidental hospitalisations, we have constructed this analysis conservatively in assuming the upper limit of possible benefits from the booster dose in this age group.
Even in doing so, we have found net harms outweigh net benefits in this 18–29-year-old age group."
w/@KrugAlli @KevinBardosh @sdbaral @ID_ethics @s_keshavjee @TrudoLemmens @VPrasadMDMPH & @MartyMakary
Great team!
jme.bmj.com/content/early/2023/05/24/jme-2023-109163.long
💪🏼
I’m an odd oncologist, maybe. When my patients opt for no chemo, I keep seeing them if they wish. I help w/ symptoms, follow scans over time, & help interpret data about alternatives.
A doctor is a guide. We should continue to guide, even if a person opts for a different path.
"The unvaccinated" was always an intellectually dishonest & scientifically flawed way to view immunity. People were at high, med, low & ultra low (near 0) risk of Covid death and immunity (natural>>vax protection against severe disease) was a major factor in downgrading that risk.
IMO, you were wise to avoid the risks of the 2nd shot (1/662 incidence of a serious adverse event per the Fraiman et al. study) after recovering from Covid, assuming good overall health. PH officials were disingenuous with the public on this topic. And still are.
It didn’t make sense. I had one dose of Pfizer (not comfortable w/side effects), then got omicron (very mild), and shortly after was deemed “unvaccinated” and banned from society in my county.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Jay has been 100% vindicated. The burden on PH was to prove that massive disruptions to life have a net health benefit. Not only did they fail to do that. The net outcome for young people has been catastrophic. PH failed to test nearly everything it implemented by force|sick
Physicians should not be forced to sign non-compete clauses. Glad to see non-competes just got banned for some primary care physicians, despite significant industry lobbying.
www.wfyi.org/news/articles/non-competes-on-primary-care-d…
Glad to see Indiana ban 'facility fees' added to medical bills from some clinics. It's become an open secret that some hospitals have been adding these fees to bills after they buy a physician's practice. www.wfyi.org/news/articles/new-laws-could-lower-indiana-r…
Just amazing. The establishment groupthink bypassed the scientific method of using data and instead arrogantly used political absolutism as they decreed medical dogma and censored respected physicians with different opinions (who ended up being correct). The science is now clear.
This is the best video I’ve seen on @twitter. Watch it. Have any of these people apologized for being 100% wrong on covid and “the science?” Trust me, watch it:
The first time I heard the term “the unvaccinated” I thought it was grossly imprecise. The relevant distinctions were:
1) Immune vs. non-immune
2) High, medium risk and ultra low-risk individuals
Long overdue www.beckershospitalreview.com/legal-regulatory-issues/new…
A good start - need to roll back the obsolete C19 mandates that restrict full participation in the healthcare workforce ASAP. swww.beckershospitalreview.com/legal-regulatory-issues/new…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Just published at BMJ Journal of Medical Ethics
👇👇
@KevinBardosh @ID_ethics @TrudoLemmens @s_keshavjee @VPrasadMDMPH
@MartyMakary @sdbaral @TracyBethHoeg
📢Read our new paper:
Analysis suggests Covid-19 boosters likely to cause a net clinical harm to young adults(18-29 yr), where total severe adverse events (SAEs) will outweigh Covid hospitalizations averted
Booster mandates are unethical because:1/13🧵
jme.bmj.com/content/early/2022/12/05/jme-2022-108449
Our study published in BMJ
📢Read our new paper:
Analysis suggests Covid-19 boosters likely to cause a net clinical harm to young adults(18-29 yr), where total severe adverse events (SAEs) will outweigh Covid hospitalizations averted
Booster mandates are unethical because:1/13🧵
jme.bmj.com/content/early/2022/12/05/jme-2022-108449
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Just saw announcement that Eddie Cornwell will be giving the Scudder Oration on Trauma at the @AmCollSurgeons meeting this fall. A spectacular choice. I owe a lot to him as he gave my first (and only) attending surgeon job at @HopkinsMedicine @hopkinssurgery
Taxpayers funded this research, but NEJM wants to charge you $ to see the results. (NEJM essentially endorsed Biden in 2020).
Journals make millions from Pharma ads &have political agendas. They shouldn't be charging you to see NIH research that you funded
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2206297
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
SPEECH DEVELOPMENT: Always consider #harmreduction in a pandemic response. Which interventions truly help & which ones cause harm without benefit? US was an outlier in such profound restrictions, including masking, in very young
www.wsj.com/articles/speech-delays-more-common-pandemic-c…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
@MartyMakary wrote an excellent book on this. Highly recommend. “the price we pay”. It’s a must-read.
In Baltimore, car theft/jacking is a major problem. So the city is now suing car makers for making cars that are too easy to steal!
I have colleagues at Hopkins who have been victims & wish the city would stop blaming &start addressing the crime epidemic
www.wbaltv.com/article/baltimore-city-suing-kia-hyundai-c…
Great work being done by @CaitlinWHicks to improve quality and reduce low-value care
Thank you @CaitlinWHicks from @JHHVascular @hopkinssurgery for coming and talking to us about assessing value based care in vascular surgery to identify outliers and create quality metrics! Excellent talk and work!
#mcacs2023
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I still find it odd that the FDA director says misinformation is #1 cause of death without any data. I might even call such a claim.... misinformation.
🔥 🔥 🔥
So awesome that the @US_FDA director has chosen combating public misinformation as his priority
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
📺 Must Watch: @RepJasonSmith opened today's @WaysandMeansGOP hearing with a critical message about healthcare price transparency and how it can lower costs for patients and protect them from crushing surprise medical bills when hospitals fail to post their prices.
I didn’t know that
Yesterday, President Biden announced Dr. Monica Bertagnolli as his intended nominee for Director of the NIH. Guess what? From 2015-2021, Bertagnolli received more than 116 grants from Pfizer, totaling $290.8 million. This amount made up 89% of all her. research grants. #therevolvingdoor #kennedy24
It’s not about Covid
Updated list of top universities with/without COVID vaccine mandates.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“The vaccine is designed as a single injection intended for healthy adolescents and adults 10–25 years old.” www.biospace.com/article/gsk-s-phase-iii-meningococcal-va…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Another must read! Big #pbm like Optum choose more expensive drugs for the formularies so they get more "rebate" (actually #kickback) $$
To hide the money they made companies in Switzerland and Ireland to send the money to.
kffhealthnews.org/news/article/pharmacy-benefit-managers-…
If you think ignoring natural immunity in vaccine mandates was not a big deal, please read my piece here. It was a catastrophic error, resulting in thousands of lives lost, careers ruined, and a 4-day school week for hundreds of public schools today. open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/the-political-badge-o…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Important essay w @TracyBethHoeg & @sgdambrauskas @vkprasadlab on the USA's bizarre decision to KEEP recommending masking to 2 year olds
This wartime act of desperation risks being codified in permanent guidelines, further embarrassing public health
authors.elsevier.com/c/1h3o15Q-0lthA0
Over a 100,000 nurses. In NY state alone, 34K quit or were fired due to the vax mandate and yes many had natural immunity. Now hospitals are paying 2-3X more for traveling nurses and passing on the cost to patients in the form of ⬆️ medical bill$$. We should have seen this coming
How many nurses would have kept their jobs instead of being fired if he would have acknowledged natural immunity. They were on the frontlines and many got Covid and recovered long before the shot was available
Should low-risk women really start getting mammograms at age 40? Check out the prophetic words of Dr. David Sackett (father of evidence-based medicine) in this video by @VPrasadMDMPH--who walks through a critical review of mammography.
Medicine needs more objective scientists.
Mammography: A detailed analysis of the evidence
Does it save lives?
youtu.be/-9hQO7X1bmU
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Rep. James Comer Highlights the 'Misinformation' Spread by Public Health Officials During the Pandemic
Makary: "There was a lot of misinformation spread during the pandemic – a lot spread by the CDC."
@RepJamesComer @MartyMakary @MSmelkinsonPhD
Why would Dr. Fauci put such a critical policy decision (of recognizing natural immunity) to a straw poll of 4 loyal friends... instead of reviewing the 100+ studies on the subject?
Here's one doc who voted
How did the consensus against recognizing natural immunity to COVID arise? In a closed-door meeting described here by insider Paul Offit, Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins simply decided against recognizing natural immunity—and that was that. “Consensus”
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Natural immunity against infection is described in undergraduate textbooks, but it was a concept that became so divisive & political during the pandemic, that many people self-censored. Good to see @MartyMakary calling it out.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Clip Dr. Marty Makary and Dr. Smelkinson's complete opening statements on natural immunity
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
"Natural immunity could have been, and I believe should have been, a force multiplier for good...but instead, it was demonized."
Chairman @RepBradWenstrup opens today's hearing on COVID-19 immunity with a message for the Biden Administration.
Why was the science ignored?
Great points by NIH’s infectious diseases scientist @MSmelkinsonPhD testifying before congress with me today
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
My new essay with @DrJBhattacharya:
"If there is a consensus, science challenges it with new hypotheses, experiments, and critical thinking. Ironically, science advances bc it believes it has never arrived; consensus is the hallmark of dead science."
#illusionofconsensus
🧵1/6
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🚨BREAKING🚨
Dr. @MartyMakary reveals @CDCgov, @NIH employees dismissed natural immunity to serve a political agenda.
"Let's not be honest with the public, was that the idea?"
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
My email to the Deen of Alumni Relations at Johns Hopkins Business School Jan 16, 2022. Welcome to the club my friend
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
My email to the Johns Hopkins University alumni association.
@JohnsHopkins @JHU_Alumni @MartyMakary
Why would NIH renew a $2 million grant to EcoHealth after they funded the Wuhan lab?? And why do friends at NIH tell me that Fauci has not retired as he suggested he would do? Is he still the highest paid employee in the govt? mol.im/a/12063851
Great report just out:
"The 7 Deadly Sins" of gain-of-function research by Dr. @LauraKahn1
NIH violated 2 rules on created by the National Acad of the Sciences in a 2004 report entitled “Biotechnology Research in an Age of Terrorism"
gjia.georgetown.edu/2023/03/03/the-seven-deadly-sins-of-b…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
1/New Peer-reviewed study: Journal of Clinical Investigation
"What really killed Covid patients: It wasn't a cytokine storm, suggests study"
"Investigators found nearly half of pts with Covid develop a secondary ventilator-associated bacterial pneumonia"
medicalxpress.com/news/2023-05-covid-patients-wasnt-cytok…
A billion $ for NIH’s publicity machine?
Republicans question into NIH's billion dollar PR spending spree at taxpayer expense sharylattkisson.com/2023/05/republicans-question-into-nih…
Important topic that has not got the attention it deserves: Hormone replacement therapy and the Women’s Health Initiative: re-examining the results, the link to breast cancer, and weighing the risk vs reward of HRT | JoAnn Manson, M.D. peterattiamd.com/joannmanson/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This is a superb thread. Accurate
I wrote a piece on Walensky and scored her just as a scientist
She was 0 for 4
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/walensky-steps-down-at-cd…
Agree w/@MartyMakary & maybe now that she's stepping down we can interview @CDCDirector re:
1. Why 3ft of distance was okay for her own kids but she wanted 6ft in schools as CDC director
2. Why @CDCgov didn't alter their vax recs when they learned about post-vax myocarditis
🧵
Here's how the CDC worked...
www.newsweek.com/why-america-doesnt-trust-cdc-opinion-171…
Why does the mainstream media keep blaming @CDCDirector for poor messaging. The problem wasn’t messaging. 👇🏼👇🏼👇🏼
Here is the Newton Schools letter where she was quoted July 2020 as saying 3ft was "quite safe and much more practical" than 6 feet
6 ft recommendation (based on?) kept millions of kids out of full time school spring of 2021
WHY DID SHE CHANGE HER MIND?
happiekids.files.wordpress.com/2020/09/newton-city-counci…
Powerful 🧵on @CDCDirector’s legacy
When she said this 4/27, they were already investigating 14 cases in the DOD.
& they were aware of at least 60 suspected cases from Israel, mostly in young males after dose 2 & at least one was in the ICU, reported Feb 1st.
Why did they downplay this?
www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/us-cd…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Here is something that all medical peeps on Twitter ought to easily agree on>
No government funded medical research should be behind a paywall.
The results should not be the property of a for-profit journal, they are the property of humanity.
I was reading an article on @AnnalsofIM that was funded by government and about remdesivir for COVID and the PDF is still paywalled
Come on, do better.
Irony of Bill DeBlasio going to teach @HarvardChanSPH as academia purged/bullied faculty that questioned prolonged school closures/lockdowns, masking toddlers, FDA &CDC's cozy relationship w/Pharma, and a 4th jab for healthy children with natural immunity
ktxs.com/news/nation-world/bill-de-blasio-gets-new-gig-te…
The spin machine: Former Biden &Clinton political appointees co-author a NYT piece today saying their friend Dr.Walensky was "working to change" the CDC. No mention of flawed CDC studies, hiding data, school closures, or failure to use randomized trials.
www.nytimes.com/2023/05/07/opinion/cdc-overhaul.html
They made a few good points, but read the NYT political piece, then read the reporting @TracyBethHoeg and I did here: www.thefp.com/p/us-public-health-agencies-arent-following
No government funded medical research should be behind a paywall.
The results should not be the property of a for-profit journal, they are the property of humanity.
I was reading an article on @AnnalsofIM that was funded by government and about remdesivir for COVID and the PDF is still paywalled
Come on, do better.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Yep. Twitter's head of US public policy resigned the other day after revelations she was a willing participant in govt censorship. Her career path was Senate staffer -> Consulting lobbyist -> Twitter lobbyist. She is also married to a former Sr. Justice Dept official.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
"The project of science calls for rigor, humility, and open discussion. The pandemic has revealed the stunning magnitude of the political and institutional capture of science."
@DrJBhattacharya & @Ravarora1 are launching a new podcast & Substack. Wishing them a smashing success!
Rochelle Walensky has been known for her kindness & collegiality in academia. When she started as @CDCDirector she spoke freely--saying schools can be open safely. The next day, the White House (Jen Psaki) condemned her comments saying "she was speaking as a private citizen." Since then, Dr. Walensky has obediently supported all Biden Covid policies, often with flawed research and non-disclosure of critical data on things like the breakdown of child deaths for healthy kids vs. those with special medical conditions, deaths from Covid vs. deaths with an incidental Covid+ test, & hospitalization rates among boosted people <50 vs. those with the primary vaccine series alone.
Her agency also worked to censor others as the CDC put out misinformation on myocarditis, long-Covid, masking toddlers (except when they nap for up to 2hrs, or eat food), boosters in young people, and school closures.
I wish her well in her next endeavor and pray that future CDC directors will speak their minds and stand up for science rather than use it as political propoganda. www.newsweek.com/why-america-doesnt-trust-cdc-opinion-171…
Rochelle Walensky's legacy will be the shattered dreams of a generation of American kids, especially poor and minority kids, whose futures she marred by working to keep schools closed in 2021.
The Short History of Long Covid.
www.realclearhealth.com/2023/05/03/a_short_history_of_lon… @stemplet74
Throwing more money into a broken bureaucracy is not the solution. My comments today on the ~$20B the gov’t spent through the Pandemic & All-Hazards Preparedness Act (PAHPA) before Covid to prepare the country. How well did it work out?
"But the question is, where was the basic clinical research?" -@MartyMakary
bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/5/e059041
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
More @MartyMakary
"How does it spread? Is it from touching surfaces? Do I need to pour 20 gallons of alcohol on my groceries? When are you most contagious? What's the peak day of viral shedding? How long do you have to quarantine for? Do masks work?"
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The search for your next summer audiobook is over! For a limited time, save 50% on the "Unaccountable: What Hospitals Won't Tell You and How Transparency Can Revolutionize Health Care" audiobook by @Agatston_Center, and @MartyMakary. www.audiobooks.com/promotions/promotedBook/251126/unaccou…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
@MartyMakary at the Senate Health Committee during today's hearing on public health emergency preparedness.
"We just had the head of Asper, the Assistant Secretary of Preparedness and Response, say, she needs more hiring power. How about firing power for incompetence or both?"
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Sen. Bill Cassidy Quickly Reclaims His Time From Dr. Marty Makary on the Topic of CDC Data Transparency
"We have not had good access to data. We've asked for hospitalization rates in people under 50 by booster vs. non-booster, just the primary vaccine series, we didn't get it. Why? Probably doesn't support the narrative."
@MartyMakary
About to testify before congress along with CDC Director Walensky and FDA comiss Califf. Can’t wait to speak my mind about the many missteps past and current and how to prevent such a debacle in the future.
"Arrogance is a sin of public health in both perception and practice." -Deadly Sins and Living Virtues of Public Health - National Academy of Medicine nam.edu/perspectives-2012-deadly-sins-and-living-virtues-… via @theNAMedicine
The fed Covid vaccine mandate ends in 10 days. Just 10 more days to finally stomp out Covid!
Teachers, int'l travelers(Djokovic) & fed contractors with natural immunity will no longer be required to get the Wuhan/bivalent vaccine.
www.thefp.com/p/us-public-health-agencies-arent-following
www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2023…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
odd to watch Fauci downplay & misrepresent his position on schools; When DeSantis reopened Apr2020, he did tons of media to fearmonger, and persuaded unions to fight reopening.
Data were clear from Sweden by Q2 2020, & Germany Q3;
Ok to admit your wrong
www.dossier.today/p/dr-flip-flop-a-timeline-of-faucis
Fauci and Weingarten distance themselves from the extended school closure policy they enacted & encouraged open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/revisionist-hist…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Our Laparoscopic Skills in Emergency Surgery course involves a close look at decision-making in difficult clinical scenarios.
Secure your spot today: www.rcsed.ac.uk/education-exams
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
NEW: This Pharmacist Said Prisoners Wouldn’t Feel Pain During Lethal Injection. Then Some Shook and Gasped for Air. www.propublica.org/article/pharmacist-helps-clear-the-way…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
.@elonmusk: "My concern with Twitter was that it is somewhat of the digital town square, and it's important there be both reality and perception of trust for a wide range of viewpoints, and there was a lot of censorship going on, and we uncovered a lot that with the Twitter Files, including a lot of government-driven censorship."
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
It was a human rights violation against children. Their risk of bad covid outcomes was ~0. They sacrificed for scared, cowardly adults. Ultimately nearly nothing was gained (no change in transmission). The full harms have barely been appreciated.
School test results are still lagging behind pre-#covid levels - only 20% of the decline in pass rates have been recovered @TheEconomist
econ.st/3H27jTi
Yes, how did Europe and the rest of the civilized world get schools right during Covid?? And we failed. Thank you @ScottJenningsKY for speaking on behalf of millions of parents and children. 👇🏼💪🏼👏🏼cdn.jwplayer.com/previews/0u2bL5ns
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Headline: One-third of teen girls in US seriously considered attempting suicide in 2021, CDC report says.
Comment: None needed. Just repentance and restoration.
www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/one-third-of-teen-girls-in-us-s…
CDC/Biden admin needs to stop pushing their Novak Djokovic Doctrine
CDC is still trying to require the bivalent vax to travel into the U.S. (that's the vax authorized with no randomized trial data & bypassed an expert vote at FDA).
The Djokovic Doctrine also ignores nat immunity
VACCINE REQUIREMENT: Looks like CDC now trying to ask for bivalent vax (obtained August 2022 or later) or monovalent 2-dose to enter US if foreign traveler @CDCgov-countries have different vax formulas (e.g. Sputnik V); most have dropped vax requirement
thehill.com/policy/healthcare/3976562-cdc-relaxes-covid-r…
Remember during the initial Covid vaccine rollout, a healthy 25-year-old teacher was prioritized over high-risk Americans (even when the teacher already had Covid/natural imm)... so that we could open the schools? Talk about equity. Many schools didn't open for another year+
Great article but @DLeonhardt, one missing detail is that swedish data from the spring of 2020 showed that teachers were not at elevated risk. Unions were not acting in teachers best interest either. They were just setting impossible demands not 2 work.
www.nytimes.com/2023/04/28/briefing/pandemic-school-closu…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Lawmakers in the House and Senate plan to introduce legislation that would fund the purchase of new antibiotics to confront the rise of drug-resistant bacteria and fungi www.wsj.com/articles/congress-considers-paying-developers…
Fauci &Walensky have given many lectures at Hopkins during Covid. Would be nice if JH could once invite @VPrasadMDMPH @DrJBhattacharya or @TracyBethHoeg who were actually right about opening schools, natural imm, toddler masking, child boosters, myo, longCv &Wu lab leak all along
Hopkins will be honoring Dr. Fauci next Tuesday as the Miller Lecture speaker.
Here’s 🤡 Fauci telling @rweingarten the minimal we need to open schools is having teachers wear masks, goggles, gloves, and possibly a disposable garment. This was late July 2020 when Georgia and Florida had already started to reopen.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=WxW0rNnoKnc
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The list of errors made by the covidarati during the pandemic is long and substantial. Kids' futures were ruined. People lost their careers. Lives were destroyed. Reform starts with the acknowledgment of error. Great column by @MartyMakary!
nypost.com/2023/02/27/10-myths-told-by-covid-experts-now-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
A “review of more than a dozen retracted papers from China shows a pattern of revising or suppressing research on early [Covid-19] cases, conditions for medical workers and how widely the virus had spread — topics that could make the government look bad.” www.nytimes.com/2023/04/23/world/europe/chinese-censorshi…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Agree @MonicaGandhi9 - let’s also end the obsolete vax mandate for health care workers and bring them back too. We need them in our hospitals and clinics! @MartyMakary @VPrasadMDMPH @DrJBhattacharya
REINSTATED: City of Chicago Employees Fired For Refusing COVID Vaccine Must Be Reinstated, Judge YES: Vaccines no longer prevent transmission, infection confers immunity, high degree of population immunity now (should also stop vax US entry requirement)
www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/city-of-chicago-employees-f…
Amazing Drs. Fauci & Collins have never called for a hold on all gain-of-function research on deadly respiratory viruses. What's more amazing is how they are sticking to their natural origin explanation of Covid-19, saying it's more likely than a lab leak.
READ: The Origins of Covid-19 Report - We must establish additional guardrails on risky Gain of Function research to make sure lethal research NEVER leaks again. nypost.com/2023/04/17/senate-gop-report-raises-possibilit…
“a lab leak is the only explanation credibly supported by our intelligence, by science and by common sense."
- John Ratcliffe, former Director of National Intelligence
oversight.house.gov/release/covid-origins-part-2-hearing-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
🎯👇
"We're fueling disaster at the foundations of science. If science becomes an elitist engagement where a few people tell others 'I know more than you' that's not science, it's totalitarianism & has nothing to do w/the scientific method"-JPA Ioannidis
www.ihmc.us/stemtalk/episode-151/
For nearly 2yrs, several of us cited the strong data on fluvoxamine and budesonide for Covid. Now even more research is coming out. Many were worried that acknowledging these data wound cause people to choose not to get the vaccine/boosters. But that’s not how science should work
“the proportion of patients who were either hospitalized because of COVID-19 or observed in an emergency setting for more than 6 hours for COVID-19 was lower in the treatment group compared with the placebo group: 1.8% vs. 3.7%” www.healio.com/news/primary-care/20230419/early-treatment…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“It is too early to definitively characterize this season since we are still in the middle of it”www.cnn.com/2023/04/19/health/strep-infections-surge
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Walensky @CDCgov falsely claimed that Cochrane's Editor-in-Chief "retracted" the summary of the review on face masks.
Jefferson, lead author on the Cochrane review said, “Walensky is plain wrong. There has been no retraction of anything.”
@carlheneghan @kerpen @TheChiefNerd
Today FDA authorized another round of Covid bivalent vaccines (#7) for older Americans. My take on FDA pushing an infinity booster strategy without any supporting randomized trial data & ignoring natural immunity: www.foxnews.com/opinion/dont-recommend-fda-infinity-vacci…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Near all of the changes in this thread lack randomized data. Giving one bivalent booster to unvaxd person who already had COVID. Lol. No data support this.
This is just making things up.
Today, FDA amended the EUAs of the Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna COVID-19 bivalent mRNA vaccines to simplify the vaccination schedule for most individuals. www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavirus-c…
What you need to know. 🧵👇
Amazing. We never dropped our mask mandate. Our security force has transformed into the mask police.
Still are! My hospital just brought masks back due to county level “transmission” numbers. Even though we’ve hardly hospitalized anyone for COVID in over a year.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“The drug, if approved, could become the first new type of antibiotic, which is critically important for countering drug-resistant infections” www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/gsks-…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
📰 NEW: Bill would let Colorado enforce federal hospital price transparency rules.
@MegWingerter / @denverpost with the critical case for SB 252!
www.denverpost.com/2023/04/15/hospital-price-transparency…
Dr. Heneghan is a research giant. He was spot on about Covid testing over counting cases and contagiousness. Too bad his voice and many like him were censored. Bad case counts drove bad policy.
The social media censorship of important scientific facts was the outcome of a deliberate government / public health policy aimed at inducing panic and bolstering compliance with lockdowns. Modern day 'book' banning at scale.
I would never poke a bear
Why do hibernating bears, despite prolonged immobility, not get venous thromboembolism?
In a new study, scientists prioritize HSP47 down-regulation.
I am most impressed with the team for sticking needles in hibernating brown bears!! 😲
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5044 @ScienceMagazine
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
This morning I interviewed Tom Jefferson and @carlheneghan
A great summary of EBM
Cochrane Mask Controversy | Tom Jefferson, Carl Heneghan Interview | Wil... youtu.be/P_JTBftjQuA via @YouTube
Looking forward to reading it. I always appreciate hearing what Dr.@stemplet74 has to say.
"Was the mass panic .. in my neighbors a phenomenon of group psychology just as contagious as a pandemic virus .. [with] no idea about the real risks of infection, the benefits of protective immunity, or our constant bombardment with microbes?"
New book by @stemplet74
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“Meanwhile, there are steps everyone can take to aid in the battle..You can do this by taking an antibiotic exactly as prescribed by a doctor and finishing the entire bottle”—assumes antibiotic was prescribed appropriately (which isn’t usually the case) fortune.com/well/2023/04/12/looming-behind-antibiotic-res…
Thank you
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Healthy, athletic 14 yo girl dies 2 days post Pfizer dose 3 diagnosed w/"vaccine-related multiple-organ inflammation."
Why are healthy children being told to get a booster & why is this published in "Legal Medicine" instead of a major medical journal?
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10027302/pdf/main.pdf
NEW STUDY: Probiotics reduced dead bowel in pre-term babies from 6.3% to 1.6%. Congrats to Dr. Chirovulo & her team at Baylor-McKinney & Texas A&M on publishing this important work. The strongest case I've seen for routine probiotics in very PT/LBW babies.
www.nature.com/articles/s41372-023-01657-w
A couple of Twitter accounts out there trying to impersonate me. Blue check is the real account.
I don't believe in censoring medical research just because it MIGHT cause someone to question getting a Covid vaccine booster.
Sadly, that's been the measuring stick of the medical establishment, the CDC, and big tech.
🏴New self-controlled case series of 12-29 yos in England w/findings not inconsistent w/@FLSurgeonGen's study, this finding a 70%⬆️d incidence of cardiac death post dose 2 mRNA vaccine in 12-29 yo males, however it wasn't significant (1.70 [0.98, 2.97])🧵
www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-36494-0
“The biggest defenders of science did the most damage to it.”
open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/debunkers-return-to-t…
FDA to authorize a 2nd bivalent vax after the Biden admin bought 171 million doses, of which 116 million are unused.
"Those doses are going to be expiring and will be thrown out. So it makes sense to have those shots in arms instead of being tossed in the waste basket"
-Dr Hotez
www.foxnews.com/opinion/dont-recommend-fda-infinity-vacci…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
@CDCgov keeps pushing COVID boosters on kids despite real health risks and lack of clinical outcomes data to support the recommendation.
nypost.com/2023/04/04/cdc-keeps-pushing-covid-boosters-on…
Thank you- @MartyMakary
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
We are taking all necessary legal and security precautions to protect ourselves, our journalism, and the right to free speech.
But we can’t do this alone. If you aren’t a paying subscriber yet, now would be a great time to become one. 🙏🏻
www.public.news/p/attack-of-the-censorship-karens
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Masks in hospitals made 'no difference' to Covid infection rates, study finds | Daily Mail Online www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-11946447/Masks-hospita…
Just amazing what data can do! New study: hospital mask mandates did not protect patients from getting Covid
“Found that patients admitted to wards where masks were optional were no more likely to become infected inside the hospital than were patients in units where masking remained mandatory” www.latimes.com/science/story/2023-04-06/masking-up-in-ho…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Another excellent piece by my colleague @MartyMakary: "Throughout the pandemic, one of the greatest sources of COVID misinformation has been the U.S. government." I don't recommend FDA's infinity vaccine booster strategy www.foxnews.com/opinion/dont-recommend-fda-infinity-vacci… #foxnews
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Its amazing that US hospitals have run ZERO! randomized trials to justify this policy which is ongoing into year 3
It's not science, it is a religion
Mask mandates at a large London hospital during the first 10 months of Omicron (Dec 2021- Sept 2022) had no discernible effect on hospital-acquired Covid cases, a new study finds.
drive.google.com/file/d/1oZ29hRam4CXGqUFxe-Lh-_l-VCqQwXFT…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
US FDA is leaking to the press that we may soon be headed for 7 COVID shots for older people.
Why 7? not 9 or 6?
Evidence based medicine is getting kicked in the face by Peter Marks at FDA. It's amazing how weak their principles are.
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/7-covid-19-shots-5-wuhan-…
FDA is getting ready to authorize and push a 7th COVID shot (5 Wuhan, 2 Bi-valent). I’d love to see the clinical data.
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/7-covid-19-shots…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
I may never get over the fact one of the most important findings of the last 3 yrs:
That transmission rates of infected people to others (secondary attack rate) was unrelated to # of vax doses received
was buried in the supplements of this Danish study🤦♀️👇
www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33328-3
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
The CDC keeps pushing COVID boosters on kids despite real health risks
nypost.com/2023/04/04/cdc-keeps-pushing-covid-boosters-on…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Pfizer hid data on waning immunity as millions queued to get vaccinated.
maryannedemasi.substack.com/p/pfizer-hid-data-on-waning-i…
Regulatory filings (accessed by Peter Doshi) show Pfizer had evidence, early into the vaccination campaign, that vaccine efficacy waned, but waited months before alerting the public.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“It’s clear from the documents that these analyses were almost 4 months old by the time they became public,” said Doshi
In that 4-month delay, ~90 million Americans queued to get vaccinated, unaware that data were already in hand, hinting that two doses may not be the final ask.
"WHO is also worried that the absolutism by which the COVID vaccine is being pushed for healthy young people is damaging credibility and resulting in lower rates of regular child immunizations."
My latest piece in today's @nypost
nypost.com/2023/04/04/cdc-keeps-pushing-covid-boosters-on…
"A few wks ago public-health officials beclowned themselves by blocking Djokovic from traveling to Florida to play tennis outdoors."
This Biden admin position embodies everything wrong with public-health policy today:
▪️Ignoring natural immunity
▪️Downplaying vax-induced myocarditis in young males
▪️Ignoring the extremely low risk of Covid in healthy young people
▪️Ignoring data that vaccines do NOT prevent transmission
▪️Creating vax hesitancy through mandates
▪️Damaging the trust with an absurd position
▪️Crying wolf by endlessly renewing the state of emergency
nypost.com/2023/04/04/cdc-keeps-pushing-covid-boosters-on…
Dr Hotez on FDA's new push to give another round of bivalent vaccines:
"Those doses are going to be expiring and will be thrown out. So it makes sense to have those shots in arms instead of being tossed in the waste basket"
I'd rather see efficacy data
www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/03/29/1166629853/t…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
💯 @kerpen
Cornell mandating primary series.
I believe 2 things must change:
1. CDC must come clean - there is no evidence for vax at this point for <50 (like EU doing)
2. Admins at colleges must process their nobility, sense of duty during time of need...and move on...it's over.
@VPrasadMDMPH @KrugAlli @MonicaGandhi9 This has to end. This is full on bananas at this point.
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
A growing body of evidence shows U.S. govt officials, agencies, & contractors demanding Facebook & Twitter censor ordinary Americans. Now, an influential censorship advocate has admitted that she worked for the CIA. Who is she? Why is she so influential?
public.substack.com/p/why-renee-diresta-leads-the-censorship
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
No wonder physicians don’t have a clue what to do with MOC: the goalposts are constantly moving. One constant though: more and more money goes to these gaslighting grifters 👇
Covid vaccine mandates are having a tough time in court abcnews.go.com/Health/wireStory/appeals-court-blocks-vacc…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
How many more weeks do they need to slow the spread?
US Senators that, after 3 years, voted against ending the COVID-19 emergency:
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
👀 CRITICAL READ: How to avoid huge medical bills and lower existing ones
By @allieevolpe with assistance from PRA!
www.vox.com/even-better/23661759/reduce-health-care-costs…
I wonder if they think we just need another year of the state of emergency to finally stomp out the virus
US Senators that, after 3 years, voted against ending the COVID-19 emergency:
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Elon Musk and Others Call for Pause on A.I., Citing ‘Risks to Society’ - The New York Times www.nytimes.com/2023/03/29/technology/ai-artificial-intel…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Do you know whose original idea it was to bring the cherry blossoms to DC?
Take a look for the answer!
🌸 It is springtime — which means the cherry blossoms are here! 🌸
@kwelkernbc reports from Washington D.C. on the story behind the trees and the tradition.
We’re going to be unpeeling this onion for a long time, learning about the many hidden harms of extended lockdowns and 2-3 yrs of social isolation during Covid
ALLERGIES IN BABIES DURING COVID LOCKDOWNS: Studies have shown diverse microbiome (exposure to different infectious agents) help decrease allergies, strengthen immunity- babies born during this time have less diverse gut microbiome, more allergies
www.news-medical.net/news/20230328/Study-links-altered-gu…
When I walk into work tomorr, a security officer will make sure I'm wearing a mask. What's the endpoint? I'd rather my patients be able to see my face when we talk
Great piece by @NBSaphierMD on how some want the Covid state of emergency to go on forever.
www.wsj.com/articles/my-weekly-covid-tests-continue-new-j…
When I walk into work tomorrow, a security officer will make sure I'm wearing a mask. When does it end? My patients should be able to see my face when we talk.
Great piece by @NBSaphierMD on how some want the Covid state of emergency to go on forever.
www.wsj.com/articles/my-weekly-covid-tests-continue-new-j…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“I want the American people to understand that the harms inflicted upon children w/ school closures were unnecessary.”
Thank you, @TracyBethHoeg
oversight.house.gov/hearing/the-consequences-of-school-cl…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“This budget fails to mention price transparency - it’s a real missed opportunity considering all the bipartisan support for more transparency across the healthcare system. I invite @secbecerra to work with us more on this issue.”
-@RepGuthrie to @SecBecerra
Glad to see Ohio cracking down on big pharmacy benefit managers www.axios.com/newsletters/axios-vitals-4f2eb0a4-851d-43fd…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
📣 ICYMI: Yesterday our patient advocates spent the day on Capitol Hill talking about protecting patients with price transparency!
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Tracy is a woman of courage
We need more people like her
And she is one of the few jewels of the pandemic we should all listen to
Thanks Tracy
Dr. Tracy Høeg (@TracyBethHoeg) tells Congress that the highest quality scientific evidence has consistently shown that masks do not work, school closures were not necessary, and six feet of distancing was not based on science:
"We've had evidence prior to the pandemic that masks were largely ineffective at preventing community transmission of influenza and other upper respiratory viruses, and we did not obtain any new high-quality evidence during COVID-19 that masks are an effective mitigation strategy.
We have several confounded observational studies, many of which were actually published by the CDC, that have severe flaws in them, that unfortunately led people to believe that masking children was going to be effective and necessary to keep children in schools.
But the highest quality data we have, for example, from a Cochrane review of randomized studies, has not found evidence that masks are effective. It wasn't science-based, and the six feet of distance was arbitrary... We should have by default kept our schools open, but instead, we required non-evidence-based mitigation strategies as a prerequisite for getting our children back into school."
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Well, outstanding essay and outstanding ending. Please read the whole thing. My excerpts above can't do it justice
www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/guide-understand…
Got my copy… can’t wait to get into it!
I’m excited/relieved/nervous to announce that my book Outlive is officially available today. To celebrate this event, we recorded a special episode of The Drive (# 248).
Order Outlive: peterattiamd.com/outlive/
New podcast: peterattiamd.com/outlivepodcast/
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
“According to educators, this will be a kind of lost generation: under-educated to the point where it drags down their future, and ours.”
Some of us said this from the beginning. We were blackballed & blacklisted. We shouldn’t have been. We were right. www.cbsnews.com/news/covids-education-crisis-a-lost-gener…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
📰Featured in @annarbornews:
A HUGE thank you to @RepDebDingell for her efforts "fighting for healthcare price transparency - an issue supported by over 90% of Americans!"
"'Real world' studies today are still published as one-off, point-in-time analyses. But much more value would come from having results posted to a website with live updates, as epidemiological and vaccination data accrue." onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jep.13839
And all avoidable if public health officials would have used a data driven approach, as many parts of Europe did. For most of the pandemic, when U.S. were closed, European schools were open.
Reading: Lowest in 30 years
Math: lowest since testing began 54 years ago
Mental health: ED visits up 50%
Physical activity: "It's like wet cement"
Future: "This will be a kind of lost generation"
Predictable: totally
Apologies: none
Accountability: none
www.cbsnews.com/news/covids-education-crisis-a-lost-gener…
Every month for 18 months, data accrued on schools that were open vs closed (mostly private vs public). Covid hosp rates were no different, but CDC/Fauci ignored the data month after month
Similarly Euro &US data on schools masked vs unmask showed no diff
This harm👇🏽was avoidable
COVID's education crisis: A lost generation? Reading skills dropped to lowest point in 30 years (4th & 8th)- math; "We've got the data now, and things are bad; they're actually worse than most of us thought", mental health difficulties, violence
www.cbsnews.com/news/covids-education-crisis-a-lost-gener…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
These are not errors of interpretation or preference but demonstrably false numbers
Horrific that the CDC has made these errors and in some cases still not issued correction, and even repeated the errors
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4381627
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Just OUT @SSRN
By @KelleyKga, AH, @TracyBethHoeg @vkprasadlab
An Analysis of Statistical and Numerical Errors Made by the US @CDCgov
The errors are damning. Basic counts of dead kids, causes of childhood death.
Unacceptable incompetence 👇
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4381627
see 🧵
Amazing how extensive the U.S. govt coverup effort continues to be, hiding simple grant proposals and cables currently in the government's possession.
Sen. @SenRandPaul is right. The State Department should stop hiding information regarding gain-of-function work. It should also come clean about its Global Engagement Center and its activities to censor American free speech. Why aren't journalists demanding transparency?
The American people need to know what the State Department is funding. Today I questioned Sec. Blinken on their involvement in COVID research. What is the State Department hiding? Why won't they give these records to the American people?
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
Sen. @SenRandPaul is right. The State Department should stop hiding information regarding gain-of-function work. It should also come clean about its Global Engagement Center and its activities to censor American free speech. Why aren't journalists demanding transparency?
The American people need to know what the State Department is funding. Today I questioned Sec. Blinken on their involvement in COVID research. What is the State Department hiding? Why won't they give these records to the American people?
Is it necessary to keep delaying surgery for 7 weeks after a positive COVID-19 test? According to a new study, the answer is no. dgalerts.docguide.com/ncov-home/article/is-it-necessary-t…
Hope you enjoy the book!
@MartyMakary - J Hopkins. Maybe a bridge to the medical 'establishment' (?). Author of "Unaccountable" - an expose of hospitals.
www.amazon.com/Unaccountable-Hospitals-Transparency-Revol…
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
1000+ downloads so far
I would highly suggest anyone at all interested, download a copy of these CDC errors (shown in table)
In a future substack post, I will explain why
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4381627
Marty Makary MD, MPH reposted
📺“Congress should consider building on existing policies … Price transparency rules empower patients and employers to know prices before purchasing services.”
@brian_blase to House Ways and Means today
👏👏👏
Long Covid is real. But public health officials have massively exaggerated its prevalence as they give >$1B to a long Covid medical-testing complex.
Some cases are legit, but diagnosing fatigue @ 5wks as long Covid is the medicalization of ordinary life.
www.wsj.com/articles/the-exaggeration-of-long-covid-overm…
New Study: "cardiac autopsy findings in five persons who have died unexpectedly within seven days following anti-SARS-CoV-2-vaccination... Our findings establish the histological phenotype of lethal vaccination-associated myocarditis." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00392-022-02129-5
CDC is quietly reversing many of their recs while no one is paying attention. I went out to dinner and felt bad seeing so many young healthy waiters &waitresses still holding on to outdated CDC recs, believing that a cloth mask is protecting them. www.outkick.com/cdc-quietly-ends-recommendation-for-unive…
New York City ordered to reinstate all cops fired over vaccine mandates. It’s about time. nypost.com/2022/09/23/nypd-union-members-axed-over-vax-ma…
An ancient trait of the medical profession is to speak up when we believe something is not in the best interest of our patients. Less absolutism and more humility by health agencies would go a long way in rebuilding public trust. My piece w/ @TracyBethHoeg www.commonsense.news/p/us-public-health-agencies-arent-fo…
Healthcare will need to learn how to treat nurses better. After 30yrs of progress in patient safety, the field was dealt a massive blow in the firing & prosecution of nurse Vaught. In this Podcast, @PeterAttiaMD & I do a deep dive on exactly what happened. peterattiamd.com/martymakary2/
Still hard to believe that our beloved public health officials insisted that young healthy soldiers &veterans be disgraced & dishonorably discharged for having natural immunity and not being vaccinated. They had circulating antibodies to Covid but not the type the govt recognizes
Yesterday - a veteran came up to me at the voting booth and talked about his brother who is facing discharge from the Army. Think about that. #covidhearings
I've been on 5 flights since a Florida judge used a crowbar to pry the travel mask policy out of the tight grip of the CDC. Since then the %masking on my flights has gone from 15% to 3% yest. What's bad for public health is a CDC completely out of step with what people are doing.
NEW ARTICLE: Superb review on the lack of evidence for boosters in young people—considered misinformation by big tech and academic elites. Now people (and the New England Journal) are realizing what the data really said, thx to experts like @DrPaulOffit.
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMe2203329
@DrPaulOffit & other outspoken experts are true heroes, standing up to the politically-charged groupthink. Sadly, under the Biden admin, the FDA has repeatedly bypassed and disempowered their expert advisory committee—a slap in the face of science. www.wsj.com/articles/dangerous-push-to-give-boosters-to-t…
Dr. Offit “advised his 20-something son to forgo the third shot, which the FDA recommends for everyone 12 and over.”
All Americans should consider the implications of the FDA’s new norm (estab in the last 12mo) of bypassing their expert voting process. www.wsj.com/articles/fda-shuts-out-its-own-experts-in-aut…
Maybe the CDC & NIH should have conducted rigorous scientific studies on:
Cloth, N95 &KN masks
Impact of school closures
Covid in healthy kids
Natural immunity
Hospitalizations in boosted young people
Myocarditis/vax dosing interval
...rather than use dogma and tout absolutism.
The White House is not appealing the federal judge ruling striking down travel mask mandates. That's says a lot.
Dr. Gregory Poland, director of the Mayo Clinic vaccine researcher center, developed ringing in the ear after his COVID shot, calls for further study of vaccine complications. @medpagetoday www.medpagetoday.com/special-reports/exclusives/97592
After a year of urging the CDC to increase the interval btw the first 2 mRNA doses (to lower complications & increase durability), the CDC finally did it--changed their rec, acknowledging the longer spacing "may reduce the risk for severe side effects" 1/4 thehill.com/homenews/administration/595459-cdc-updates-gu…
Ever wonder why a quarter of America was knocked down/in bed for a day after their 2nd dose? The interval was too short.
As several of us argued from the start, no vaccine has multiple doses given that close together. But the FDA and CDC were too rigid to listen.
2/4
Agree @VPrasadMDMPH. We’ve been saying this for over a year, but when the NYT discovers what’s happening, then some start to pay attention.
All I know is: if you read the studies they are publishing, the reason they aren't sharing this data is absolutely not that they want to get the analysis right.
The C.D.C. Isn’t Publishing Large Portions of the Covid Data It Collects www.nytimes.com/2022/02/20/health/covid-cdc-data.html
Sorry for your loss. CDC has never made public the details of their sporadic & shoddy investigations into poss vax associated deaths in kids (even talking about them can be taboo). The Covaxin vax application has sadly been collecting dust @FDA since it was submitted on Nov. 5th.
CDC dir told abc "no adverse events among vax recipients, & denied seeing any cases of myocarditis among vax'd kids 5-11. On that same day, however, data from her own agency showed the CDC was aware of at least 8 cases of myocarditis within that age group" www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/how-the-cdc-a…
CDC has repeatedly weaponized science--we need to stand against it, increase public accountability. Our health agencies need radical reform
"the brave new world of science as political propaganda"
Incredible piece by @VPrasadMDMPH. Article of the year IMO
www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/how-the-cdc-a…
Thanks @EricTopol for this summary on natural immunity: erictopol.substack.com/p/ground-truths-on-prior-covid
If they continue to downplay the role of cellular immunity (B & T cells) and only focus on antibody titers, they will think people need a booster every 3 months.
Amen, grateful to the many physicians who kept their scientific objectivity &stood up to the estab bullying. Groupthink hurt us bad: Surface transmission, barbaric hosp visitation policies, closing schools, narrow dosing interval, cloth masks, ignoring nat immunity, boosting kids
Thank you, Dr. Ritz. I am grateful for you and also for many doctors who held onto their principles despite furious gaslighting during the pandemic. If trust in medicine is to be restored after the covidian calamity, it will be through doctors like you.
Starbucks, Boeing, &Delta are hiring back staff they fired under vax mand. Its time to re-instate American workers with an apology. Nat Imm data are in--when employers fired those w/nat imm, they got rid of those LEAST likely to spread the virus! My latest:www.wsj.com/articles/the-high-cost-of-disparaging-natural…
Booster requirements will cause unintended harm to young people. What are we protecting them from??
The NEJM study described an absolute ZERO risk of death in un-boosted, vaccinated people <30. Risk of getting very sick was 0.04% (poss immunosup? =>boost)
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2115926?query=recirc_…
The list of studies on natural immunity continues to grow. brownstone.org/articles/79-research-studies-affirm-natura…
Based on the data: We should not be giving healthy kids a 2nd vax dose at a 3wk interval, esp boys where 1/7K get myocarditis and 1/136 of them died, i.e. from the vax itself(NEJM study). Vax deaths could approximate Covid deaths in boys 5-11 w/no comorbid www.wsj.com/articles/should-vaccinate-children-covid-19-i…
Getting this wrong has resulted in tremendous avoidable harm:
1. Thousands of seniors died waiting for a vax when we were vaxing ppl w/ nat imm
2. Bad guidance to the world
3. Heart complications from vaxing kids w/ nat imm
4. Kids kicked out of sch
5. Distracting from vax effort
Hospitals not allowing people to visit their critically ill loved ones because of covid is a human rights violation. There are things worse than dying, like dying alone. www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/second-opinions/94340
BIG new Israeli study: Natural immunity "offers considerably more of a shield against the Delta variant of the pandemic coronavirus than two doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine" www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/having-sars-cov-2-once-co…
Affirms what i've been saying for a year in 5 opeds
www.wsj.com/articles/the-power-of-natural-immunity-116231…
Yet another misrepresentation of the data by the CDC on natural immunity.
Today in @CDCMMWR www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7032e1.htm?ACSTrackingID…: Risk of #covid19 re-infection is 2.34X greater in unvaccinated. BUT doing the math (based on rough numbers I pulled), only ~0.1% of previously infected got re-infected/2 months; 0.03% of vaccinated got re-infected. BOTH very low risk!
We have to be willing to evolve our positions as new data emerge
@FaulknerFocus @JulieBanderas. Excellent interview with @MartyMakary. One of the things I so admire about Dr. Makary is his humility to admit he called for lockdowns initially and then pivoted on that point. More people need exhibit such humility!
“A pandemic of the unvax” is misleading. Covid risk is in the “non-immune” population.
Natural Imm has proven durable 19 mo. (& going strong) despite naysayers dismissing it every month. Specul that vax imm lasts longer is purely a hypothesis without data www.wsj.com/articles/the-power-of-natural-immunity-116231…
L.A.’s new guidance is not only excessive. It undermines vaccination efforts
Will L.A. do the same when RSV virus kills>350 kids/yr which is every year
Or regulate alcohol when alcohol deaths >85,000/yr which is every yr
My concerns about LA’s decision: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/07/01/la-mask-guidan…
The ObamaCare Effect: Hospital Monopolies www.wsj.com/articles/the-obamacare-effect-hospital-monopo…