Bad actors gain in power and prominence -> polarization increases -> stakes grow -> imperative to own your enemies -> willingness to engage in bad faith arguments to defend your own side -> loss of trust in "independent" institutions and experts -> bad actors gain in power and prominence -> polarization increases -> stakes grow -> imperative to own your enemies -> willingness to engage in bad faith arguments to defend your own side -> loss of trust in "independent" institutions and experts -> bad actors gain in power and prominence -> polarization increases -> stakes grow -> imperative to own your enemies -> willingness to engage in bad faith arguments to defend your own side -> loss of trust in "independent" institutions and experts -> bad actors gain in power and prominence -> polarization increases -> stakes grow -> imperative to own your enemies -> willingness to engage in bad faith arguments to defend your own side -> loss of trust in "independent" institutions and experts -> bad actors gain in power and prominence -> polarization increases -> stakes grow -> imperative to own your enemies -> willingness to engage in bad faith arguments to defend your own side -> loss of trust in "independent" institutions and experts -> bad actors gain in power and prominence -> polarization increases -> stakes grow -> imperative to own your enemies -> willingness to engage in bad faith arguments to defend your own side -> loss of trust in "independent" institutions and experts -> bad actors gain in powe... ... ... ... ... ... ...
Yascha Mounk
Yascha Benjamin Mounk (born 10 June 1982) is a German and American political scientist, academic, and author. He is Associate Professor of the Practice of International Affairs at the School of Advanced International Studies at Johns Hopkins University in Washington, D.C. In July 2020, he founded Persuasion, an online magazine devoted to defending the values of free societies. More on Wikipedia
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A wonderful way to finish a difficult year:
The Identity Trap was chosen as a Best Book of 2023 by publications including The Economist, The Financial Times, and Prospect Magazine.
If you want to understand the new ideology transforming our culture, please give it a look. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
sophia aram
@SophiaAram
La clairvoyance de @Yascha_Mounk sur "la gauche identitaire" est salutaire.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Hello, Paris.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Shockingly, Elon Musk's commitment to free speech does not appear to be entirely consistent.
(On the bright side, I'm feeling more confident than ever in my new rule of thumb: Everyone in American public life eventually lives up to the most absurd caricature of themselves.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And no, the fact that Musk isn't a consistent defender of free speech does not imply that we shouldn't fight for a genuine culture of free speech—any more than the fact that many campaigners against corruption turn out to be deeply corrupt implies that you shouldn't get rid of corruption.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One day a few weeks ago, I did three interviews about The Identity Trap.
The first interviewer insisted that racially segregated affinity groups in schools are a figment of my imagination.
The other two both told me their children were divided into such groups in their schools
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
my daughter's middle school has 'affinity groups.' about 20% of the day spent doing stuff in groups. divided by sex, sexuality and also jewish/not jewish and race. she picked the asian group. their poster is all about pagodas and pandas and sushi
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
François Durovray
@durovray
Un livre lumineux, une analyse implacable de la dérive wokiste dont le résultat est inverse au but recherché. Un brillant plaidoyer pour le libéralisme politique et l’universalisme. Une grande bouffée d’air frais à lire absolument !
👏 @Yascha_Mounk @EdLObservatoire -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The poster implying that Rishi Sunak is a "coconut" because he does not act in the ways that "brown" people "should" is both stupid and offensive.
But that just shows how dangerous it is to ban offensive speech. If robust criticism of a sitting Prime Minister is not allowed, then what is? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The firing of Mike Eisen as editor of eLife was wrong.
To understand why, you need to take a view of free speech that's consistent *and* broad—one that protects people even if their speech is controversial and their actions imperfect.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/11/israel-palestin…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Eisen's firing is quickly becoming one of the canonical examples of this moment.
One thing this piece does is to give much more detail of how it came about—and to show the very interesting ways in which Eisen's own thoughts on "cancel culture" have evolved. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The Identity Trap is back in stock!
Please read this book. I've been reluctant to post about it in the past weeks, but I promise it will help you to understand the ideology that created this moment—and how we can push back against it in a principled, effective way.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And with that, I'm going to take a little break from this platform. I may be back on occasion to post articles and other content. But don't expect me to be around to comment day-to-day for a while.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It is a little on the nose that Pakistan is in the process of expelling 1.7 million (!) Afghans, many of whom will be violently persecuted by the Taliban, and nobody in the world seems to care one iota about their suffering.
Reuters World
@ReutersWorld
Afghans return to Taliban rule as Pakistan moves to expel 1.7 million www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/afghans-return-taliban…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🙏🙏🙏
Caitlin Flanagan
@CaitlinPacific
Or as @Yascha_Mounk calls it, "the short march"
His new book The Identity Trap is great -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Hamas murdered over 1,400 people in an indescribably sadistic manner.
Its leaders have made it very clear that they will continue to murder Israeli civilians if given the chance.
Israel has every right to defend itself.
But that is all the more reason for Israel to operate in accordance with the rules of war. Its attacks must have military targets. And they must—even if Hamas uses human shields in a craven attempt to create bad publicity for Israel, as the terrorist organization undoubtedly does—go to great lengths to minimize civilian casualties.
The actions and the words of the Israeli government increasingly call in doubt whether it is complying with this imperative. That is a strategic error, which will undermine the international support Israel needs to sustain its security beyond the coming weeks. It is also a moral error, which has already cost the lives of many civilians—whose deaths, like that of any other innocents, deserves to be mourned in their own right, without context or qualification. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yascha: "Siri, define 'back-handed compliment'."
Siri: "Your book was listed as a Best Book of 2023... by the 'non-obvious book awards.'"
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Kidding apart, this is a lovely recognition for The Identity Trap! And the list puts me in the company of many writers I greatly admire.
Thank you! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Universities must protect free speech. This means they can’t punish students for saying stupid things, however offensive.
But part of protecting free speech is to punish students who violate the rules that make free speech possible for everyone else. This includes punishing those who violently disrupt talks—and it also includes punishing those who tear down fliers depicting children kidnapped by Hamas.
The answer to this moment isn’t to give up on a culture of free speech on campus. It’s to enforce the rules that sustain it in an impartial manner—something most campuses have woefully failed to do.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The current reality on many campuses is:
Someone anonymously accuses you of a sexist or racist microaggression? You’ll be subjected to an intimidating interview with our “bias response team”.
You violently disrupt a lecture or tear down posters put up by other students in the name of some activist cause? Nothing happens to you.
This selective application of rules and laws is not just inconsistent; through the strategic use of partial enforcement, it effectively sets up an institutionally sanctioned set of views which are sacrosanct, and an institutionally proscribed set of views that are off limits.
In short, they are a clear and outrageous violation of free speech and academic freedom.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(To be clear, violently disrupting a lecture is a worse attack on free speech than tearing down a poster. The punishment for the latter should therefore be less severe.
But both are forbidden, and need to be punished, for the same reason: Rather than being an expression of speech, they consist in the suppression of the speech of others.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I have a whole chapter on the policies and social norms we need to mount an energetic defense of a culture of free speech in ways that (unlike some of the recent pushback, e.g. in Florida) don’t themselves undermine it in The Identity Trap, by the way.
a.co/d/9U1ZkSR -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It’s not anti-Semitic to criticize the Israeli government.
It’s not anti-Semitic to put the current conflict in historical context.
It’s not anti-Semitic to mourn the death of Palestinian civilians.
But if you describe the slaughter of 1,400 civilians as “military action” or call for a ceasefire without mentioning the toddlers who are still in the clutches of a terrorist organization, people will rightly wonder why you don’t seem to give a single shit about the lives of innocent Jews. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is bullshit.
But I fear it may turn out to be electorally effective bullshit.
Trump is going to run on saying that Afghanistan, Ukraine and Hamas would not have happened under his watch. And a lot of voters will believe it.
Ron Filipkowski
@RonFilipkowski
Trump Speech Recap:
1. Everything bad that has happened everywhere in the world would not have happened if he was president.
2. Everything good that has happened everywhere in the world is really not that great but would be if he was president. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Kyle Smith
@rkylesmith
New terms just dropped: wobo (woke bourgeois), bobar (bourgeois barbarians. Read @Yascha_Mounk with David Brooks. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/brooks?r=sdz4
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For years, it was considered “impolite” to criticize Manichean thinkers, from Kendi to Thunberg, who claim to care about important causes while spouting simplistic slogans.
If there’s one good thing about these awful weeks, it’s that the damn on that omertà is finally breaking. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is admittedly not in the list of the world’s top 7,000 problems but…
…it’s monumentally stupid and mildly annoying that Europe and America don’t sync when they change to winter time, so for one random week the time difference is one hour less than everyone assumes. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
These are two consecutive tweets on my timeline.
The speed at which the institutions we need for society to function are self-sabotaging is remarkable. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To be fair, he only praised Hitler on numerous occasions over the course of 11 years; it’s not like he has done anything as unforgivable as publishing a controversial op-ed by a sitting United States Senator.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Academic freedom absolutely does *not* entail professors giving students better grades for parroting their political point of view.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is just a straight-up abuse of the authority with which universities invest teaching faculty for pedagogical purposes.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Paging @TheFIREorg and @glukianoff. We need you for a cleanup in Aisle 5.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
America is less and less willing or capable to lead the free world.
But instead of stepping up and filling the void, Europe is sleepwalking into global irrelevance.
The continent desperately needs to get serious about security, education, and economic innovation.
Simon Grimm
@Simon__Grimm
Try spotting the European tech sector
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"Mama?"
"Yes?"
"I don't feel so good."
"I know. It's over soon."
"I need water."
"You can drink soon."
"Mama?"
"What is it, my beauty?"
"Do you think they also killed other people in the kibbutz?"
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The cover of the new issue of @DIEZEIT's magazine, taken from a mother's phone call with her hiding children.
Why have German media found ways to convey the horror of the terror attack in a haunting and humane way—while American media have largely failed at the same task? -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
This conflict weighs so heavily on me. I have Jewish friends and I have Muslim friends. I have a deep affinity for Israel and for Arab culture, and do a lot of work in the Middle East.
But let’s be clear about some things. Anti-Israel + Pro-Palestine demonstrations erupted around the world *before* Israel responded.
BEFORE.
Let's recap that sequence of events.
1. Palestinian militants wake up in the morning and decide to go and murder Israeli civilians, take hostages, and declare their intent to destroy Israel
2. Demonstrations erupt around the world supporting Palestine and condemning Israel
3. Israel responds to this threat
Go back over it again in case there is any ambiguity.
There is no moral grey area to inhabit here. No fog of war that one can hide behind.
Palestinian militants murdered civilians. In cold blood. They raped Israeli women. They set children on fire and beheaded them. Grandmothers were raped so brutally their pelvis was broken. A pregnant woman had her baby cut out of her stomach and beheaded, only to then suffer beheading herself. Palestinian militants murdered Jews, on a mass scale, in the most barbaric and heinous ways possible. And then vowed that they would keep going, to the thunderous applause of their sympathisers living in the West.
Members of our intelligentsia and elite students openly cheered Hamas, laying the blame *entirely* at the feet of Israeli policy. They justified the most barbaric atrocities under the banner of liberation and decolonization.
If you can't see the problem with that, I don't know what else to tell you.
It is easier of course to just keep quiet, to not talk about it. But I am compelled to.
Because 90 years ago, no one spoke up.
Yet.
It is important to recognize that this is war, and in this war, there are people are dying on both sides - children, women, civilians.
Many people have been trying to build bridges to bring about peace – and all their work crumbled just like that. The world before Oct 7 was a different world. Peace in the Middle East was achievable and now, we’re back to reliving ancient hatreds between the sons of Abraham.
One of the problems with discourse today isn’t just about the things we say; sometimes it’s about the things we don’t say.
Even when we think that “our side” may have not been totally right, we hold back from criticizing because we fear weakening the moral standing of “our side.”
So on one side, they cannot criticise Hamas, and on the other, they cannot criticise the Israeli government / IDF. But Hamas isn’t Palestine, and the Israeli government isn’t Israelis / Jews.
This distinction is important. And for those who say “but Palestinians support Hamas overwhelmingly,” please ask yourself exactly what choice you would have if you were born into the same cultural and social milieu?
You’ve heard the phrase the “bigotry of low expectations.” Sometimes it is compassionate to expect less.
Moral clarity is important, but so is being compassionate and not giving up on humanity.
When will we beat swords into plowshares and spears into pruning hooks? When will we no longer take up sword against each other, nor train for war anymore?
I recall the words of Rudyard Kipling:
“What profit to kill men?”
“Very little - as I know; but if evil men were not now slain; it would not be a good world for weaponless dreamers.” -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"There is only one solution / Intifada revolution."
I suppose we should count ourselves lucky that "intifada revolution" does not have an extra syllable, so these cosplaying psychopaths had to settle for "one" instead of "final." -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If this turns out to be true (as well it may), it is both immoral and… really stupid.
And, no, I can’t imagine that @thomaschattwill, @glukianoff, @JonHaidt or any other principled defender of free speech will disagree with me on that.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Some people are acting as though the stories of cancelation in the past days contradict what advocates of free speech believe.
They do the opposite. I have warned progressives about the fact that they won’t always miraculously be on the winning side of cancel campaigns again and again. I have a whole section about this in The Identity Trap.
Like in other areas of American life, the solution is to make sure that everybody enjoys genuine freedom of speech—not to turn the fight over who can say what into a zero-sum conflict between different ethnic, religious or ideological tribes. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
People who walked out of Dave Chappelle’s show are too easily offended. But those who quote that story as some great gotcha fundamentally misunderstand free speech (or pretend to do so).
Audience members are free to leave an event. They are not free to stop it from going ahead with persistent disruption (something that didn’t happen in this case). And the reason why Chappelle is associated with free speech fights is that, in the past, employees at Netflix tried to get his special pulled and he was unable to perform shows because theaters cancelled on him at the last minute due to pressure from employees!
So, look, it’s a bit ridiculous to walk out of a Chappelle show because you’re offended. But it’s just not at all the same as employing the “heckler’s veto” or (what I propose we call) the “staffer’s veto.” -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is overly dramatic. We need a bigger breadth of voices on American campuses, and Hogan could help provide that.
But I think universities vastly underestimate the existential threat that ideological capture poses to their functioning.
If even moderate conservatives like Hogan no longer want to be associated with them, it’s hard to see how they’ll be able to sustain tax-exempt status and federal funding in the long-run.
Governor Larry Hogan
@GovLarryHogan
This morning, I informed @Harvard that I must withdraw my offer to participate in fellowships this Fall. I cannot condone the dangerous anti-Semitism that has taken root on their campus.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The world's most important news outlets got the Gaza hospital bombing terribly wrong.
Journalists often blame "misinformation" for falling trust in media. But that won’t work when major news organizations mess up as badly as they did last week.
My latest @TheAtlantic.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
The media got the hospital-explosion story wrong, @Yascha_Mounk writes. Amplifying dubious Hamas claims about Israel’s role had real-world consequences and showed why trust in traditional news sources has been falling. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/10/gaza-hospital-e…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Swiss Elections:
The far-right Swiss People’s Party wins big. The Greens crater.
Switzerland is pretty politically distinct from other European countries. But I suspect that most of Europe will swing to the right in the coming months.
In the wake of mass solidarity rallies with Hamas, and rising fears of Islamist terrorism, anti-immigrant sentiment in many countries, including France and Germany, is palpably growing—and not just on the fringes.
(The one exception is Britain, where people are very fed up with the Tories, and the Labour leader has defined himself in opposition to the party’s far-left.)
Europe Elects
@EuropeElects
Switzerland, national parliament (lower chamber) election today:
6:00 PM CEST gfs.bern seat projection for SRG SSR.
UDC/SVP~RE: 61 (+8)
PS/SP-S&D: 40 (+1)
LC/DM-EPP: 30 (+2)
PLR/FDP-RE: 29
LV/G-G/EFA: 22 (-6)
PVL/GLP-RE: 11 (-5)
PEV/EVP-ECR: 2 (-1)
UDF/EDU-*: 1
LEGA~ID: 1
Others: 3 (+3)
➤ europeelects.eu/switzerland
#ef23 #wahlch23
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(To be clear, in the Swiss system, winning is relative: The country has basically been governed by a grand coalition of the four major parties since the beginning of living memory. So the election won’t change who’s in charge—but it will give the Swiss People’s Party more power.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is the reason why the pedagogical practices that many elite private schools have adopted of late, like racially segregated affinity groups or encouraging students to “own” their “whiteness,” infuriate me.
If you know anything about the world, you know how dangerous it is to teach kids to define themselves by the group into which they’re born—and how easily such a culture can lead to the worst forms of zero-sum conflict.
Lee Fang
@lhfang
Despite an uptick in tribalism and polarization in the U.S., I am extremely thankful for our major institutions and culture striving to be secular and race-neutral. The identity sectarianism of Middle East conflicts is jarring. And frankly v foreign to modern America.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Harvard students: “Israel is solely responsible for Hamas brutally murdering 1,400 civilians.”
Writer for Vox and New York Magazine: 𝘏𝘰𝘭𝘥 𝘮𝘺 𝘣𝘦𝘦𝘳. 𝘏𝘮. 𝘏𝘰𝘸 𝘤𝘢𝘯 𝘐 𝘣𝘦𝘢𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘥𝘦𝘱𝘳𝘢𝘷𝘪𝘵𝘺 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘢𝘵. 𝘖𝘒, 𝘐 𝘨𝘰𝘵 𝘪𝘵: “‘Zionists’ are responsible for the Holocaust.”
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I don’t want journalists fired over a single tweet, no matter how stupid and vile.
But one of the things that makes cancel culture so corrosive is that it turns everything into a zero-sum conflict—and reveals very clearly who counts and who doesn’t.
Does anyone seriously think that a writer who suggested that slavery was “really” the responsibility of Africans would continue to be employed by Vox or New York Magazine? Of course they wouldn’t.
But hey. It’s Jews. They’re white. And privileged. And guilty. So you can say whatever you want about them without consequence.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It’s the same problem with university statements.
I’d much rather that universities stop making statements about world affairs.
But that doesn’t make it hypocritical to notice when they rush to issue statements about all kinds of stuff…. unless the victims happen to be Jews. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For this week's episode of The Good Fight, I talked to Jonathan Rauch about why people are less happy in middle-age, and how to accelerate the boost in life satisfaction that many people experience after 50.
It's a very different conversation from the ones I usually have on the podcast. And also one of my absolute favorites.
www.persuasion.community/p/rauch -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Actually astonishing that, because of the extremism of the Republican Party and the depth of dysfunction in Congress, America currently does not have ambassadors in Israel, Lebanon or Egypt.
State Department Spokesperson 2013-2025
@statedeptspox_a
The work our U.S. ambassadors do is critical for our national security. But they can’t do their work if they aren’t confirmed.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
George Orwell on “grifters”:
“The Catholic and the Communist are alike in assuming that an opponent cannot be both honest and intelligent. Each claims that the heretic, if he is not simply a fool, is secretly aware of ‘the truth’ and merely resists it out of selfish motives.”
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I always find it simultaneously depressing and reassuring that the worst sins of contemporary “discourse” turn out to be long-standing features of political debate.
No one helps us see this more clearly than George Orwell.
(This quote is from “The Prevention of Literature.” -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
People who think Israelis and Palestinians belong to two different races are just absolutely wild.
Tell me which of these guys are "brown" and which are "white".
Don’t Boo…Revolt!
@BreeNewsome
The existence & experience of Jewish people of African descent in Israel is also conveniently ignored as is Netanyahu’s recent call to expel Eritreans.
This is about expelling people based on their physical proximity to whiteness
b/c it’s a white colonialist apartheid system. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Tried to explain the lunacy in Congress on German radio. Mostly failed.
Partially my fault, I’m sure. But also, the entire drama seems so weird to outsiders that the moderator kept asking, with rising levels of incredulity: “Are you *really* saying what I think you’re saying?!” -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Incredible interview in which an Arab journalist asks all the hard questions about Hamas that so many activists in the West refuse to consider.
One of the results is to expose in painful clarity how little Hamas cares for the well-being of Arabs in Palestine, Lebanon and beyond.
Arash Azizi آرش عزیزی
@arash_tehran
Great Al Arabiya journalist grilling Hamas’s Khalid Mashaal from an Arab perspective
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The speed with which the institutions that a healthy democracy needs to function—from newspapers to universities—are squandering the trust of the public is truly remarkable.
All of us will pay a hefty price for their dereliction of duty. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yes, we’re far out from the election.
But Morning Consult is a serious organization. And these numbers are very worrying.
Consider me officially very worried.
Morning Consult
@MorningConsult
Trump leads Biden in key swing states, per our survey with @business:
AZ
Biden: 43%
Trump: 47%
GA
Biden: 43%
Trump: 48%
MI
Biden: 44%
Trump: 44%
NV
Biden: 46%
Trump: 43%
NC
Biden: 43%
Trump: 47%
PA
Biden: 45%
Trump: 46%
WI
Biden: 44%
Trump: 46%
morningconsult.biz/3Q5dfhS -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Caitlin Flanagan
@CaitlinPacific
This is an excellent conversation between two very smart men,
If you've been looking at college campuses this week, and wondering "how did all of this happen?" @Yascha_Mounk 's new book, The Identity Trap provides the answer - somehow managing to be both comprehensive and concise.
Charles C. W. Cooke
@charlescwcooke
On this week’s episode, I talked to @Yascha_Mounk about his book, ’The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time.’ I asked where identity politics comes from, how it spread so fast, why it’s a problem, and what happens if it’s not checked. www.nationalreview.com/corner/where-did-identity-politics…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Big win for the Jews.
Welcome, Shash. We’re proud to have you. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
CNN, BBC and NYT all sent push alerts blaming Israel for killing hundreds of civilians at the hospital.
If, as now looks likely, it is confirmed that the cause was a misfired rocket from Islamic Jihad, will they send push alerts correcting the original story?
Of course not.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I’m hopeful about indications that the death toll may turn out to be lower than originally stated. Because it means fewer innocents died.
If any ounce of you regrets this news because it scuppers your narrative, it’s time to take a very long and very hard look into the mirror.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is the CURRENT headline of the New York Times.
The website does not outright blame Israel for the blast anywhere. But any casual reader would get the impression that it is Israel's fault.
Once again, five minutes on here will give you better and more layered information. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Max Boot 🇺🇦🇺🇸
@MaxBoot
Hamas claims Israeli air strike hit hospital, killing hundreds. Israeli sources blame an errant Hamas rocket. I treat both stories with skepticism & await fuller information before drawing any judgments. But of course that's not how this site operates. Either way, a tragedy.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I have both good and frustrating news about The Identity Trap.
The good news: It's been selling better than the publisher expected.
The frustrating news: As a result, it's now out of stock.
Please don't let that stop you from ordering the book. I promise it's worth the wait!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If you order The Identity Trap at your favorite book seller's now, you should be get it within the next ten days.
And if you're impatient, you can always choose to get it right away on an e-reader or listen to it on Audible!
Thanks for your patience and for your support... -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Thomas Chatterton Williams
@thomaschattwill
“Any humane outlook on the world must recognize that civilians never deserve to suffer due to the group into which they were born or because of actions committed by those who claim to speak on their behalf.“
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The Deep Roots of the Left’s Deafening Silence on Hamas
There are serious ideological reasons why parts of the left have gone so badly astray. The implications go far beyond the conflict in the Middle East.
~~
On October 7th, the world witnessed the worst slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust. Hundreds of attendees at a music festival were murdered in cold blood. Families hiding in their homes were burned alive. Jewish mothers and fathers were, in an eerie echo of the 1940s, imploring their children to stay quiet lest their would-be murderers should detect their whereabouts. Nearly two hundred people remain in the clutches of a terrorist organization that announced its genocidal intentions in its founding charter.
Many people, of all faiths and convictions, have recognized the enormity of these crimes. Numerous world leaders denounced the terrorist attacks in clear language. Private citizens shared their grief on social media. Millions mourned. But despite the outpouring of support, there has also been a large contingent of people and organizations who stayed uncharacteristically silent—or went so far as to celebrate the carnage.
Even as British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak found clear words about Hamas, for example, the BBC have steadfastly refused to call the Hamas fighters who killed over 1200 people by the name rightfully reserved for those who deliberately target innocent civilians for political ends: terrorists. Meanwhile, many schools and universities, nonprofit organizations and corporations that have over the past years gotten into the business of condemning and commemorating all kinds of tragedies, both small and large, fell uncharacteristically silent.
Some of the most famous universities in the world—including Princeton, Yale and Stanford—only released statements after they came under intense pressure on social media. At Harvard University, it took pressure from alumni and an outraged thread on X by Larry Summers, a former president of the institution, to prompt his successor into belated action.
Worse still were the people and organizations who actively celebrated the pogroms. Multiple chapters of the Democratic Socialists of America, which continues to count Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez among its ranks, encouraged their followers to attend rallies that glorified Hamas’ terror as a righteous form of resistance. As its San Francisco chapter wrote on X, the “weekend’s events” should be seen as part and parcel of Palestinians’ “right to resist.” The Chicago chapter of the Black Lives Matter movement even glorified the terrorists who murdered scores of people at a rave in southern Israel, pairing a now-deleted image of a paraglider with the caption: “I stand with Palestine.”
Meanwhile, academics from leading universities were busy defending these terrorist attacks as a form of anti-colonial struggle. “Postcolonial, anticolonial, and decolonial are not just words you heard in your EDI workshop,” a professor in the school of social work at McMaster University, in Canada, wrote on X. “Settlers are not civilians,” a Yale professor who has written for mainstream outlets including The Washington Post and The New York Times, maintained.
All of this raises a simple question: How could such a notable portion of the left side with terrorists who openly announce their genocidal intentions? Why have key institutions proven so reluctant to denounce one of the worst terrorist attacks in living memory? What, to them, renders the victims of these attacks so much less worthy of solidarity than those of the many other atrocities they have full-throatedly condemned?
The ideological roots of the great obfuscation
In the past days, people have offered many possible explanations for this selective silence. Some focus on outright antisemitism. Others emphasize that an understandable concern over the immoral actions that Israeli governments have taken in the past have blinded many activists to the suffering of innocent Israeli civilians. Others still point out that institutional leaders want to avoid eliciting angry reactions from activists, preferring to stay silent on a sensitive issue out of simple fear for their jobs.
Each of these explanations contains a grain of truth. Some people in the world really are consumed by one of the world’s most ancient hatreds. Others are indeed hyper-focused on everything that Israel has done wrong, a stance that is easier to understand in the case of Palestinians whose ancestors have been displaced than it is in the case of leftist activists who have for many decades found the missteps of the one state that happens to be Jewish worthy of much greater condemnation than similar, or greater, missteps perpetrated by any other. Finally, it is indeed true that many university presidents, nonprofit leaders and corporate CEOs have, among the institutional meltdowns of the past years, come to believe that they must avoid controversy at all costs if they are to keep drawing their generous paychecks.
But the double-standard that has in the past days become so obvious on parts of the left also has a more profound source, one that is ideological rather than practical or atavistic. Over the past decades, a new set of ideas about the role that identity does— and should—play in the world have transformed the very nature of what it means to be on the left, displacing an older set of universalist aspirations in the process.
This novel ideology, which I call the “identity synthesis,” insists that we must see the whole world through the prism of identity categories like race. It maintains that the key to understanding any political conflict is to conceive of it in terms of the power relations between different identity groups. It analyzes the nature of those power relations through a simplistic schema that, based on the North American experience, pits so-called whites against so-called “people of color.” Finally, it imposes that schema—in a fashion that might, in the academic jargon of the day, ironically be called “neo-colonial”—on complex conflicts in faraway lands.
The trouble with structural racism
Many advocates of the identity synthesis rightly point out that an account of racism which focuses purely on individual beliefs or motivations runs the danger of concealing important forms of injustice. Even if everyone has the best of intentions, the after effects of historical injustices can ensure that many immigrant students attend underfunded public schools or that many members of ethnic minorities suffer disadvantages in the housing market. It therefore makes sense, they argue, to add a new concept to our vocabulary: structural racism.
As the Cambridge Dictionary explains, structural racism consists of “laws, rules, or official policies in a society that result in and support a continued unfair advantage to some people and unfair or harmful treatment of others based on race.” By pointing out that some forms of racism are “structural” in this way, we are better able to capture—and hopefully remedy—circumstances in which members of some racial groups suffer significant disadvantages for reasons other than individual bias.
This is plausible insofar as it goes. To understand contemporary America, it is indeed helpful to add the notion of structural racism to our conceptual toolbox. But in recent years, many advocates of the identity synthesis have gone one step further: they have begun to claim that this more recent concept of structural racism should altogether supplant the older concept of individual racism.
Rather than acknowledging that there are two different conceptions of racism, each of which helps to elucidate real injustices in its own way, parts of the left have come to conceptualize racism in an exclusively structural form. “Racism,” one online guide puts the growing consensus, “is different from racial prejudice, hatred, or discrimination” because it must involve “one group having the power to carry out systematic discrimination through the institutional policies and practices of the society and by shaping the cultural beliefs and values that support those racist policies and practices.”
In its most radical form, this claim entails that it is impossible for a member of a historically marginalized group to be racist toward a member of a historically dominant group. Because racism does not have anything to do with individual beliefs or attributes, and members of groups that are comparatively powerless are incapable of carrying out “systematic discrimination” against members of groups that are comparatively powerful, even the vilest forms of hatred need not count as racist. As an article in Vice put it, “It’s literally impossible to be racist to a white person.”
The result has, again and again, been a form of selective blindness when members of minority groups have expressed bigoted attitudes toward supposedly more privileged groups, including those that are themselves minorities. This inability to recognize the importance of the more traditional conception of racism makes it impossible to name what is happening when members of one minority group are the victims of hate crimes committed by members of another minority group that is now considered to suffer from greater disadvantages. In December 2019, for example, two terrorists killed a police detective and then murdered three people at a kosher grocery store in Jersey City, close to New York. They had a long trail of posting antisemitic content on social media; one assailant was a follower of the Black Hebrew Israelites, a movement which holds overtly antisemitic beliefs. But because the assailants were black, and the victims perceived as white, many news outlets failed to categorize the shooting as racist, or to treat it as a hate crime, for an astoundingly long period of time.
The trouble with white privilege
The idea that all racism is structural is deeply damaging because it makes it hard for institutions to open their eyes to forms of discrimination towards members of groups that are supposedly dominant. In practice, it is made even worse by the fact that many people on the left have now embraced a very simplistic notion of who is dominant and who is marginalized—one that imposes American conceptions of race onto situations in which they distort rather than illuminate underlying realities.
In North America, the most salient—though by no means the only—racial divide has for centuries been that between whites and blacks. In assessing which group is supposedly privileged in a foreign conflict, many Americans therefore think it is enough to figure out who is “white” and who is a “person of color.” This makes it impossible for them to understand conflicts in which the relevant political cleavage does not neatly pit whites against blacks (or, more broadly, “whites” against “people of color”).
Whoopi Goldberg, for example, has repeatedly insisted that the Holocaust was “not about race.” Since, from an American point of view, both Jewish and non-Jewish Germans are white, she found it impossible to get her head around an ideology that centers around racial distinctions between them. “You could not tell a Jew on a street,” she wrongly claimed. “You could find me. You couldn’t find them.”
In the case of Israel, this has led most observers to assume that there is a clear division in racial roles between Israelis and Palestinians: In their mind, Israelis are white, Palestinians “people of color.” And since white people have historically held power over non-white people, this reinforces the impression that it is impossible for Israelis to be victims of racial hatred.
But this perspective once again turns out to be so simplistic as to verge on the delusional. Ms. Goldberg was wrong to believe that Nazis were unable to spot Jews; though some Jews did manage to survive by passing themselves off as “Aryan,” many Nazis—and their collaborators in Central Europe—were highly effective at spotting people whom they suspected of being Jewish.
More importantly, the assumption that most of the victims of last Saturday’s terrorist attacks were “white” Jews with roots in Europe is simply wrong. It’s not just that there are black Israeli Jews whose ancestors immigrated from Ethiopia, or that Hamas’ victims included many migrants from Thailand and Nepal; it’s also that Israel as a whole is now home to more Mizrahi Jews, who hail from the Middle East, than Ashkenazi Jews, whose ancestors long lived in Europe.
I will leave it up to others to speculate on whether the visual differences between Jewish and non-Jewish Germans are more or less stark than those between Arabs and Mizrahi Jews. But the prominence of Mizrahi Jews also betrays yet another way in which attempts to fit the Israel-Palestine conflict into a simplistic conceptual scheme go badly wrong.
The trouble with Decolonialism
The actual demographic composition of the country makes claims that Israeli civilians should be seen as settlers who are fair game for terrorist attacks doubly cynical. They are cynical because no political cause, however righteous, justifies the deliberate targeting of babies and grandmothers—neither on the Israeli nor on the Palestinian side. And they are also cynical because the great majority of Mizrahi Jews have, since the end of the Second World War, been violently displaced from the Middle Eastern countries in which their ancestors had lived for hundreds of years, with no country other than the world’s only Jewish state willing to offer them a safe harbor.
Postcolonial apologists for terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah love to invoke Frantz Fanon’s glorification of violence. The problem is not just that their tendentious reading of his work overlooks the ways in which violence can be morally corrosive and politically destructive; it’s also that the implied analogy between the so-called pied noirs (white settlers in Algeria who could safely return to the French metropolis if they chose to do so) and Mizrahi Jews (who would be neither welcome nor safe if they were to return to Iran or Iraq, to Morocco or Algeria) is so misleading as to be perverse.
And yet, this misleading analogy governs how many on the left ascribe the role of victim and perpetrator, explaining why dozens of student groups at Harvard could claim that Israel is somehow “entirely responsible” for Hamas’ decision to murder more than 1,000 civilians. At a deeper level, they even help to explain how left-wing activists and academics can contrive to perceive a deeply authoritarian and overtly theocratic regime that is explicitly hostile to sexual minorities as a progressive movement.
According to many progressives, what determines whether a movement should count as left-wing or right-wing is based on whether it claims to be fighting on behalf of those they believe to be marginalized. Since Hamas is an organization of underprivileged “people of color” fighting against “privileged” “white” Jews, it must be seen as part of a global struggle against oppression. Even though its program—which incidentally includes the violent suppression of sexual minorities within the Gaza strip—is reminiscent of some of the world’s most brutal far-right regimes, those marching in support of Hamas consider them to be part of the global struggle for progressive values. As Judith Butler, a central figure in this intellectual tradition, said in 2006, it is “very important” to classify both Hamas and Hezbollah as “social movements that are progressive, that are on the Left, that are part of a global Left.”
It’s time for a reckoning with bad ideas on the left
Over the past few days, some observers have started to recognize how badly parts of the left have gone astray. Many leftist academics were genuinely horrified to see their friends and colleagues celebrate the murder of babies. There has been widespread outrage at the decision of influential movements like Black Lives Matter to idolize terrorists. Shri Thanedar, a U.S. Congressman, has publicly renounced his membership in the DSA.
This is a good start. In a free country, anyone must be free to express their support of extremist organizations, however vile; the move by many European governments to suppress pro-Hamas protests or to jail those who glorify the terrorist attacks is a betrayal of the liberal principles on which our opposition to that execrable organization should be based. But mainstream institutions can and absolutely should stop uncritically embracing organizations, like BLM, that openly glorify terrorists. And citizens should demand that moderate political parties, like the Democrats, cease to tolerate in their midst members of organizations, like the DSA, that equivocate about the moral permissibility of mass murder.
Black lives matter, greatly. Colonialism remains one of the greatest historical injustices. Even before this week, though, it should have become clear that the recognition of these important facts is fully compatible with serious concerns about the organizations that now speak on behalf of the Black Lives Matter movement, and about a postcolonial discourse that all too often glorifies violent resistance to anybody who, however simplistically, is judged to be an “oppressor.”
Many advocates of the identity synthesis are genuinely motivated by good intentions. But key parts of this ideology now provide cover for forms of racism and dehumanization of vulnerable groups that should be anathema to anybody who genuinely cares about the historical values of the left. It is time for the many reasonable people who have bit their tongue as these ideas took on enormous power in mainstream institutions to raise their voice against them.
The suffering to come
Any humane outlook on the world must recognize that civilians never deserve to suffer due to the group into which they were born or because of actions committed by those who claim to speak on their behalf. I feel as much empathy for the Palestinian children who are dying in bombardments of Gaza as I do for the Jewish children who were killed in Hamas’ attack on Israel. Insinuations of collective responsibility are vile, even when voiced in response to a disgusting terrorist attack. Each civilian death is a tragedy on the same moral order.
While every civilian victim is in equal measure undeserving of their tragic fate, moral philosophers have for centuries recognized a key distinction governing the conduct of war. Military action that is directed against military targets may be legitimate; while some civilian deaths are foreseeable as a consequence of such attacks, soldiers must undertake to minimize them as far as possible. By contrast, military action is always illegitimate when the killing of innocents is the goal, not an unintended side effect.
This set of standards helps to explain how spectacularly Hamas, the organization that started the current war with a long-planned surprise attack that killed over a 1,000 men and women, toddlers and grandmothers, Ashkenazim and Mizrahim, Jews and non-Jews, Israelis and Thais and Americans and Canadians and Germans and Chinese, failed to obey the most basic moral rules. Now, it should also guide our assessment of Israel’s unfolding actions in Gaza.
This is a war Israel did not choose, and it has every right to defend itself. No democracy would tolerate on its borders the presence of a terrorist organization that has just demonstrated its willingness to engage in the indiscriminate slaughter of its civilian population; it would be the height of hypocrisy for people living in the safety of Berlin or Paris, of London or New York, to expect Israelis to do so.
But the military offensive against Hamas is extremely difficult because the terrorist organization has deliberately based so much of its military infrastructure in the midst of civilian settlements; because it is now doing what it can to stop its own people from moving away from military targets; and because Egypt, worried about the potential for Hamas fighters to destabilize the government or even perpetrate terrorist attacks within its own borders, has refused safe passage for most Gazans. All of this explains why it is so hard for Israel to accomplish its legitimate goals without causing numerous civilian casualties. But it does not constitute permission for Israel to adopt the logic of collective punishment by cutting off access to food and drinking water ahead of a full-scale invasion, or absolve the country’s armed forces from doing what they can to minimize the number of civilian casualties. As and when Israel fails to do so, full-throated criticism of its government is fully justified.
The left has the potential to speak powerfully to this moment. To do so, it needs to jettison the ideological jargon that has made so many supposed idealists fall for the ever-present temptation to contrive reasons why the suffering of one side is outrageous while the suffering of the other side is glorious. To retain our moral composure in the ugly days and weeks now on the horizon, we must recover a moral universalism that, even in the darkest hour, reminds us of our shared humanity—and unhesitatingly laments the death of innocents, irrespective of the group to which they belong. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The Deep Roots of the Left’s Deafening Silence on Hamas
There are serious ideological reasons why parts of the left have gone so badly astray. The implications go far beyond the conflict in the Middle East.
~~
On October 7th, the world witnessed the worst slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust. Hundreds of attendees at a music festival were murdered in cold blood. Families hiding in their homes were burned alive. Jewish mothers and fathers were, in an eerie echo of the 1940s, imploring their children to stay quiet lest their would-be murderers should detect their whereabouts. Nearly two hundred people remain in the clutches of a terrorist organization that announced its genocidal intentions in its founding charter.
Many people, of all faiths and convictions, have recognized the enormity of these crimes. Numerous world leaders denounced the terrorist attacks in clear language. Private citizens shared their grief on social media. Millions mourned. But despite the outpouring of support, there has also been a large contingent of people and organizations who stayed uncharacteristically silent—or went so far as to celebrate the carnage.
Even as British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak found clear words about Hamas, for example, the BBC have steadfastly refused to call the Hamas fighters who killed over 1200 people by the name rightfully reserved for those who deliberately target innocent civilians for political ends: terrorists. Meanwhile, many schools and universities, nonprofit organizations and corporations that have over the past years gotten into the business of condemning and commemorating all kinds of tragedies, both small and large, fell uncharacteristically silent.
Some of the most famous universities in the world—including Princeton, Yale and Stanford—only released statements after they came under intense pressure on social media. At Harvard University, it took pressure from alumni and an outraged thread on X by Larry Summers, a former president of the institution, to prompt his successor into belated action.
Worse still were the people and organizations who actively celebrated the pogroms. Multiple chapters of the Democratic Socialists of America, which continues to count Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez among its ranks, encouraged their followers to attend rallies that glorified Hamas’ terror as a righteous form of resistance. As its San Francisco chapter wrote on X, the “weekend’s events” should be seen as part and parcel of Palestinians’ “right to resist.” The Chicago chapter of the Black Lives Matter movement even glorified the terrorists who murdered scores of people at a rave in southern Israel, pairing a now-deleted image of a paraglider with the caption: “I stand with Palestine.”
Meanwhile, academics from leading universities were busy defending these terrorist attacks as a form of anti-colonial struggle. “Postcolonial, anticolonial, and decolonial are not just words you heard in your EDI workshop,” a professor in the school of social work at McMaster University, in Canada, wrote on X. “Settlers are not civilians,” a Yale professor who has written for mainstream outlets including The Washington Post and The New York Times, maintained.
All of this raises a simple question: How could such a notable portion of the left side with terrorists who openly announce their genocidal intentions? Why have key institutions proven so reluctant to denounce one of the worst terrorist attacks in living memory? What, to them, renders the victims of these attacks so much less worthy of solidarity than those of the many other atrocities they have full-throatedly condemned?
The ideological roots of the great obfuscation
In the past days, people have offered many possible explanations for this selective silence. Some focus on outright antisemitism. Others emphasize that an understandable concern over the immoral actions that Israeli governments have taken in the past have blinded many activists to the suffering of innocent Israeli civilians. Others still point out that institutional leaders want to avoid eliciting angry reactions from activists, preferring to stay silent on a sensitive issue out of simple fear for their jobs.
Each of these explanations contains a grain of truth. Some people in the world really are consumed by one of the world’s most ancient hatreds. Others are indeed hyper-focused on everything that Israel has done wrong, a stance that is easier to understand in the case of Palestinians whose ancestors have been displaced than it is in the case of leftist activists who have for many decades found the missteps of the one state that happens to be Jewish worthy of much greater condemnation than similar, or greater, missteps perpetrated by any other. Finally, it is indeed true that many university presidents, nonprofit leaders and corporate CEOs have, among the institutional meltdowns of the past years, come to believe that they must avoid controversy at all costs if they are to keep drawing their generous paychecks.
But the double-standard that has in the past days become so obvious on parts of the left also has a more profound source, one that is ideological rather than practical or atavistic. Over the past decades, a new set of ideas about the role that identity does— and should—play in the world have transformed the very nature of what it means to be on the left, displacing an older set of universalist aspirations in the process.
This novel ideology, which I call the “identity synthesis,” insists that we must see the whole world through the prism of identity categories like race. It maintains that the key to understanding any political conflict is to conceive of it in terms of the power relations between different identity groups. It analyzes the nature of those power relations through a simplistic schema that, based on the North American experience, pits so-called whites against so-called “people of color.” Finally, it imposes that schema—in a fashion that might, in the academic jargon of the day, ironically be called “neo-colonial”—on complex conflicts in faraway lands.
The trouble with structural racism
Many advocates of the identity synthesis rightly point out that an account of racism which focuses purely on individual beliefs or motivations runs the danger of concealing important forms of injustice. Even if everyone has the best of intentions, the after effects of historical injustices can ensure that many immigrant students attend underfunded public schools or that many members of ethnic minorities suffer disadvantages in the housing market. It therefore makes sense, they argue, to add a new concept to our vocabulary: structural racism.
As the Cambridge Dictionary explains, structural racism consists of “laws, rules, or official policies in a society that result in and support a continued unfair advantage to some people and unfair or harmful treatment of others based on race.” By pointing out that some forms of racism are “structural” in this way, we are better able to capture—and hopefully remedy—circumstances in which members of some racial groups suffer significant disadvantages for reasons other than individual bias.
This is plausible insofar as it goes. To understand contemporary America, it is indeed helpful to add the notion of structural racism to our conceptual toolbox. But in recent years, many advocates of the identity synthesis have gone one step further: they have begun to claim that this more recent concept of structural racism should altogether supplant the older concept of individual racism.
Rather than acknowledging that there are two different conceptions of racism, each of which helps to elucidate real injustices in its own way, parts of the left have come to conceptualize racism in an exclusively structural form. “Racism,” one online guide puts the growing consensus, “is different from racial prejudice, hatred, or discrimination” because it must involve “one group having the power to carry out systematic discrimination through the institutional policies and practices of the society and by shaping the cultural beliefs and values that support those racist policies and practices.”
In its most radical form, this claim entails that it is impossible for a member of a historically marginalized group to be racist toward a member of a historically dominant group. Because racism does not have anything to do with individual beliefs or attributes, and members of groups that are comparatively powerless are incapable of carrying out “systematic discrimination” against members of groups that are comparatively powerful, even the vilest forms of hatred need not count as racist. As an article in Vice put it, “It’s literally impossible to be racist to a white person.”
The result has, again and again, been a form of selective blindness when members of minority groups have expressed bigoted attitudes toward supposedly more privileged groups, including those that are themselves minorities. This inability to recognize the importance of the more traditional conception of racism makes it impossible to name what is happening when members of one minority group are the victims of hate crimes committed by members of another minority group that is now considered to suffer from greater disadvantages. In December 2019, for example, two terrorists killed a police detective and then murdered three people at a kosher grocery store in Jersey City, close to New York. They had a long trail of posting antisemitic content on social media; one assailant was a follower of the Black Hebrew Israelites, a movement which holds overtly antisemitic beliefs. But because the assailants were black, and the victims perceived as white, many news outlets failed to categorize the shooting as racist, or to treat it as a hate crime, for an astoundingly long period of time.
The trouble with white privilege
The idea that all racism is structural is deeply damaging because it makes it hard for institutions to open their eyes to forms of discrimination towards members of groups that are supposedly dominant. In practice, it is made even worse by the fact that many people on the left have now embraced a very simplistic notion of who is dominant and who is marginalized—one that imposes American conceptions of race onto situations in which they distort rather than illuminate underlying realities.
In North America, the most salient—though by no means the only—racial divide has for centuries been that between whites and blacks. In assessing which group is supposedly privileged in a foreign conflict, many Americans therefore think it is enough to figure out who is “white” and who is a “person of color.” This makes it impossible for them to understand conflicts in which the relevant political cleavage does not neatly pit whites against blacks (or, more broadly, “whites” against “people of color”).
Whoopi Goldberg, for example, has repeatedly insisted that the Holocaust was “not about race.” Since, from an American point of view, both Jewish and non-Jewish Germans are white, she found it impossible to get her head around an ideology that centers around racial distinctions between them. “You could not tell a Jew on a street,” she wrongly claimed. “You could find me. You couldn’t find them.”
In the case of Israel, this has led most observers to assume that there is a clear division in racial roles between Israelis and Palestinians: In their mind, Israelis are white, Palestinians “people of color.” And since white people have historically held power over non-white people, this reinforces the impression that it is impossible for Israelis to be victims of racial hatred.
But this perspective once again turns out to be so simplistic as to verge on the delusional. Ms. Goldberg was wrong to believe that Nazis were unable to spot Jews; though some Jews did manage to survive by passing themselves off as “Aryan,” many Nazis—and their collaborators in Central Europe—were highly effective at spotting people whom they suspected of being Jewish.
More importantly, the assumption that most of the victims of last Saturday’s terrorist attacks were “white” Jews with roots in Europe is simply wrong. It’s not just that there are black Israeli Jews whose ancestors immigrated from Ethiopia, or that Hamas’ victims included many migrants from Thailand and Nepal; it’s also that Israel as a whole is now home to more Mizrahi Jews, who hail from the Middle East, than Ashkenazi Jews, whose ancestors long lived in Europe.
I will leave it up to others to speculate on whether the visual differences between Jewish and non-Jewish Germans are more or less stark than those between Arabs and Mizrahi Jews. But the prominence of Mizrahi Jews also betrays yet another way in which attempts to fit the Israel-Palestine conflict into a simplistic conceptual scheme go badly wrong.
The trouble with Decolonialism
The actual demographic composition of the country makes claims that Israeli civilians should be seen as settlers who are fair game for terrorist attacks doubly cynical. They are cynical because no political cause, however righteous, justifies the deliberate targeting of babies and grandmothers—neither on the Israeli nor on the Palestinian side. And they are also cynical because the great majority of Mizrahi Jews have, since the end of the Second World War, been violently displaced from the Middle Eastern countries in which their ancestors had lived for hundreds of years, with no country other than the world’s only Jewish state willing to offer them a safe harbor.
Postcolonial apologists for terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah love to invoke Frantz Fanon’s glorification of violence. The problem is not just that their tendentious reading of his work overlooks the ways in which violence can be morally corrosive and politically destructive; it’s also that the implied analogy between the so-called pied noirs (white settlers in Algeria who could safely return to the French metropolis if they chose to do so) and Mizrahi Jews (who would be neither welcome nor safe if they were to return to Iran or Iraq, to Morocco or Algeria) is so misleading as to be perverse.
And yet, this misleading analogy governs how many on the left ascribe the role of victim and perpetrator, explaining why dozens of student groups at Harvard could claim that Israel is somehow “entirely responsible” for Hamas’ decision to murder more than 1,000 civilians. At a deeper level, they even help to explain how left-wing activists and academics can contrive to perceive a deeply authoritarian and overtly theocratic regime that is explicitly hostile to sexual minorities as a progressive movement.
According to many progressives, what determines whether a movement should count as left-wing or right-wing is based on whether it claims to be fighting on behalf of those they believe to be marginalized. Since Hamas is an organization of underprivileged “people of color” fighting against “privileged” “white” Jews, it must be seen as part of a global struggle against oppression. Even though its program—which incidentally includes the violent suppression of sexual minorities within the Gaza strip—is reminiscent of some of the world’s most brutal far-right regimes, those marching in support of Hamas consider them to be part of the global struggle for progressive values. As Judith Butler, a central figure in this intellectual tradition, said in 2006, it is “very important” to classify both Hamas and Hezbollah as “social movements that are progressive, that are on the Left, that are part of a global Left.”
It’s time for a reckoning with bad ideas on the left
Over the past few days, some observers have started to recognize how badly parts of the left have gone astray. Many leftist academics were genuinely horrified to see their friends and colleagues celebrate the murder of babies. There has been widespread outrage at the decision of influential movements like Black Lives Matter to idolize terrorists. Shri Thanedar, a U.S. Congressman, has publicly renounced his membership in the DSA.
This is a good start. In a free country, anyone must be free to express their support of extremist organizations, however vile; the move by many European governments to suppress pro-Hamas protests or to jail those who glorify the terrorist attacks is a betrayal of the liberal principles on which our opposition to that execrable organization should be based. But mainstream institutions can and absolutely should stop uncritically embracing organizations, like BLM, that openly glorify terrorists. And citizens should demand that moderate political parties, like the Democrats, cease to tolerate in their midst members of organizations, like the DSA, that equivocate about the moral permissibility of mass murder.
Black lives matter, greatly. Colonialism remains one of the greatest historical injustices. Even before this week, though, it should have become clear that the recognition of these important facts is fully compatible with serious concerns about the organizations that now speak on behalf of the Black Lives Matter movement, and about a postcolonial discourse that all too often glorifies violent resistance to anybody who, however simplistically, is judged to be an “oppressor.”
Many advocates of the identity synthesis are genuinely motivated by good intentions. But key parts of this ideology now provide cover for forms of racism and dehumanization of vulnerable groups that should be anathema to anybody who genuinely cares about the historical values of the left. It is time for the many reasonable people who have bit their tongue as these ideas took on enormous power in mainstream institutions to raise their voice against them.
The suffering to come
Any humane outlook on the world must recognize that civilians never deserve to suffer due to the group into which they were born or because of actions committed by those who claim to speak on their behalf. I feel as much empathy for the Palestinian children who are dying in bombardments of Gaza as I do for the Jewish children who were killed in Hamas’ attack on Israel. Insinuations of collective responsibility are vile, even when voiced in response to a disgusting terrorist attack. Each civilian death is a tragedy on the same moral order.
While every civilian victim is in equal measure undeserving of their tragic fate, moral philosophers have for centuries recognized a key distinction governing the conduct of war. Military action that is directed against military targets may be legitimate; while some civilian deaths are foreseeable as a consequence of such attacks, soldiers must undertake to minimize them as far as possible. By contrast, military action is always illegitimate when the killing of innocents is the goal, not an unintended side effect.
This set of standards helps to explain how spectacularly Hamas, the organization that started the current war with a long-planned surprise attack that killed over a 1,000 men and women, toddlers and grandmothers, Ashkenazim and Mizrahim, Jews and non-Jews, Israelis and Thais and Americans and Canadians and Germans and Chinese, failed to obey the most basic moral rules. Now, it should also guide our assessment of Israel’s unfolding actions in Gaza.
This is a war Israel did not choose, and it has every right to defend itself. No democracy would tolerate on its borders the presence of a terrorist organization that has just demonstrated its willingness to engage in the indiscriminate slaughter of its civilian population; it would be the height of hypocrisy for people living in the safety of Berlin or Paris, of London or New York, to expect Israelis to do so.
But the military offensive against Hamas is extremely difficult because the terrorist organization has deliberately based so much of its military infrastructure in the midst of civilian settlements; because it is now doing what it can to stop its own people from moving away from military targets; and because Egypt, worried about the potential for Hamas fighters to destabilize the government or even perpetrate terrorist attacks within its own borders, has refused safe passage for most Gazans. All of this explains why it is so hard for Israel to accomplish its legitimate goals without causing numerous civilian casualties. But it does not constitute permission for Israel to adopt the logic of collective punishment by cutting off access to food and drinking water ahead of a full-scale invasion, or absolve the country’s armed forces from doing what they can to minimize the number of civilian casualties. As and when Israel fails to do so, full-throated criticism of its government is fully justified.
The left has the potential to speak powerfully to this moment. To do so, it needs to jettison the ideological jargon that has made so many supposed idealists fall for the ever-present temptation to contrive reasons why the suffering of one side is outrageous while the suffering of the other side is glorious. To retain our moral composure in the ugly days and weeks now on the horizon, we must recover a moral universalism that, even in the darkest hour, reminds us of our shared humanity—and unhesitatingly laments the death of innocents, irrespective of the group to which they belong.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If you prefer to read this in a more traditional format, please follow this link.
And while you are at it, please subscribe to receive more essays from me and many other contributors at @JoinPersuasion.
www.persuasion.community/p/yascha-the-deep-roots-of-the-l… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
That's it.
With 70% counted and the outstanding vote likely favoring the opposition, the race is over. The democratic opposition is almost certain to have a majority.
Forming a coalition will not be easy. Serious challenges remain.
But Poland is on the path back to democracy.
Europe Elects
@EuropeElects
Poland, national parliament election results (70.66% counted):
PiS-ECR: 37%
KO-EPP|RE|G/EFA: 29%
TD PL2050/PSL-RE|EPP: 14%
NL-S&D: 8%
Kon~NI: 7%
BS-*: 2%
PJJ-*: 2%
➤ europeelects.eu/poland
#polska #wybory2023 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It feels particularly fortuitous to pass a plane of Lot, the Polish national carrier, at O’Hare right now.
Welcome back to the world, Poland!
🇵🇱🎉 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If this exit poll proves right, it is the end of the far-right, populist government in Poland—and a great day for democracy in Europe.
It’s far too early to be sure. But coupled with unusually high turnout, the signs are pointing in a surprisingly positive direction.
🤞🤞🤞
Europe Elects
@EuropeElects
Poland, IBSP exit poll:
PiS-ECR: 34% (-10)
KO-EPP|RE|G/EFA: 31% (+4)
TD PL2050/PSL-RE|EPP: 14% (new)
NL-S&D: 10% (-3)
Kon~NI: 8% (+1)
BS-*: 2% (+1)
PJJ-*: 1% (new)
+/- vs. 2019 election
Fieldwork: 15 October 2023
➤ europeelects.eu/poland
#polska #wybory2023 -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Coleman Hughes
@coldxman
My guest today is Yascha Mounk (@Yascha_Mounk). A few episodes ago, I had Christopher Rufo on the podcast to discuss his analysis of why wokeness came to dominate so many institutions. Yascha's asking the same question in this book, but he's coming to a different answer. Yascha focuses less on people like Herbert Marcuse and more on intellectuals like Michel Foucault, Edward Said, Derrick Bell, and Kimberlé Crenshaw. We also talk about why there are so many former Marxists in the writing world, but so few people who convert to Marxism later in life. We talk about how Foucault's critique of language differs from George Orwell's critique of language and much more. I hope you enjoy this conversation as much as I did.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In Chicago? Not sure how to while away the rainy day?
Come hear me talk to @glukianoff and @RIKKISCHLOTT about The Identity Trap & their must-read book, The Cancelling of the American Mind.
Bonus: it’ll be moderated by the one and only @CaitlinPacific.
www.chicagohumanities.org/events/attend/cancel-culture/ -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Don’t forget this moment.
I never want to hear that nice, sensible, reasonable people should just ignore bad ideas on the left ever again.
It’s time to fight back against the new ideology that ate big parts of the left—in a way that’s principled, gracious, and uncompromising.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
When I set out to write The Identity Trap, my (then)-agent pleaded with me to choose a different topic. Friends warned me that I would burn my reputation. Every incentive was to shut up.
This week has reminded me exactly why I found it impossible to do that.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Anyway.
I haven’t really posted about my new book this week because it frankly feels distasteful.
But if you’re reeling right now; if you want to understand what happened to the left; and if you want to learn how to argue back in a principled way, please read the Identity Trap. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
.@Yascha_Mounk explains exactly how this came to pass, in The Identity Trap. It is non-partisan non-polemical intellectual history, crucial for understanding the changes in the academy since 2012.
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/712961/the-identity-trap… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
People rightly angry at leftists making excuses for Hamas should focus on pressuring elected officials who belong to the DSA to follow @RepShriThanedar’s example, not on outing randos who nominally belong to Harvard student organizations that signed some statement, however vile.
Congressman Shri Thanedar
@RepShriThanedar
I renounce my membership in the DSA
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Oh, shut up.
Lindsey Graham
@LindseyGrahamSC
We’re in a religious war and I unapologetically Stand with Israel.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This week has just been fucking awful.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In Britain and America, young people are more left-wing than the old.
But this is not the case elsewhere.
In the recent elections in Hessen, the youngest voters were twice as likely to vote for the far-right AfD.
Young people also gave fewer votes to left-wing parties overall. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It’s not only @Harvard.
I have reviewed the Twitter and Instagram accounts of @Yale, @Princeton, @Columbia, @Stanford, @Dartmouth and @JohnsHopkins.
Not a single one of them has issued a statement about the atrocities committed by Hamas.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
While ignoring the deliberate slaughter of hundreds of civilians, these same universities did find the time to commemorate a variety of causes from Indigenous Peoples Day to Sustainability Week.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Harvard has now issued a statement.
Perhaps others will follow.
(I’m going to sleep but will update in the morning.)
Harvard University
@Harvard
“We write to you today heartbroken by the death and destruction unleashed by the attack by Hamas that targeted citizens in Israel this weekend, and by the war in Israel and Gaza now under way.” Read the full statement from University leadership. hrvd.me/MiddleEast237t
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Perhaps the last 72 hours have reminded some people why it would be a profound moral and political mistake to (as many interviewers have demanded of me in the past weeks) abstain from criticizing noxious ideas on the left just because there’s an even larger threat from the right.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A striking contrast between German and American papers:
Der Spiegel: “A targeted massacre - at least 260 confirmed dead at festival near Gaza”
Die Zeit: “Hamas Now Has an Awful Ransom”
NYT: “Israel Battles Militants as Netanyahu Warns of Long War”
WaPo: “Both Sides Reeling.” -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Hardly the most important thing today. But in key regional elections, support for the ruling German government has cratered.
In Bavaria, support for all left-wing parties has fallen to a combined 25%. In Hessen, a traditional social democratic stronghold, it fell to about 33%.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The center-right FDP, a junior partner in the otherwise left-leaning governing coalition, has lost about half of its support.
One cautiously good piece of news: While the far-right AfD has gained votes in both Bavaria and Hessen, it performed a little less well than feared. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Twitter has become terrible.
But the depressing truth of it is that anyone who spends five minutes of here gets a basic sense of the barbarity of what just happened in Israel.
Anyone who spends five minutes browsing the headlines of NYT, WaPo, WSJ and Guardian has no idea.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Justin Trudeau publicly recognized this as a terrorist attack over an hour ago. Emanuel Macron did so six (!) hours ago.
Why can mainstream newspapers still not do the same? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
“ground assaults”
A shameful media failure.
Alec Siegel
@beardedbard92
I’ve been listening to our major news channel all morning. The anchors are having conversations with children whose parents were just taken hostage or murdered in their living rooms. This is not complicated. Pure barbarism, nothing else.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Remarkable how similarly, and how similarly inaccurate, all the major newspapers are describing what just happened in Israel on their front pages.
All are talking, vaguely, about “militants” who are “launching attacks”; not about the apparent murder and kidnapping of civilians.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The top two stories in the Washington Post:
Moral clarity for Ukrainians, moral relativism for Israelis.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yes, mpapers must take care not to report rumors or falsehoods. Yes, the Middle East conflict as a whole is very complex.
But it appears overwhelmingly likely that what just occurred was a mass atrocity, which involved deliberate targeting of non-combatants.
Make. That. Clear. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Hello, London!
Just arrived to beautiful weather and am greatly looking forward to conversations about The Identity Trap @LSEpublicevents, @howtoacademy, @MagazineUnheard and Second Home.
Come to one of my talks—and let me know if you want me to swing by your show or podcast!Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Tuesday at @howtoacademy with Edie Lush.
howtoacademy.com/events/yascha-mounk-the-identity-trap/
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And, last but certainly not least, Wednesday at Second Home with @helenlewis!
www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/the-identity-trap-yascha-mounk-in-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
What a beautiful piece of writing.
As a writer, you’re always happy when someone says nice things about a project you’ve spent years working on; but you’re *really* happy when they get the book so well that they help you see it in a new way.
This is one of those occasions.
James Bloodworth
@J_Bloodworth
Our common humanity will be the thing that liberates us, not the narcissism of small differences.
My review of The Identity Trap by @Yascha_Mounk
www.jamesbloodworth.com/p/book-review-the-identity-trap-by -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This interview was so much fun!
Ephie Bernstein
@EphieBernstein
@Yascha_Mounk has been actively hitting the interview circuit to promote his new book, The Identity Trap. His interview here with @nickgillespie is the best one, in my opinion. It is worth your time to listen to it.
reason.com/podcast/2023/10/04/yascha-mounk-avoiding-the-i… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Sadly, young adults are VERY wrong about this.
There are plenty of problems with universities. But Americans with BA degrees now:
* Earn 70% more
* Are less likely to be in pain, to be lonely, or to get divorced
* Live 6 (!) years longer
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/10/education-inequ…
unusual_whales
@unusual_whales
The % of young adults who said that a college degree is very important has dropped to 41% from 74% over the last 10 years, per the NYT.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Is this a causal effect from going to college?
The literature doesn’t have a clear answer on this. But for what it’s worth, Anne Case and Angus Deaton, whose research has uncovered many of these findings, suspect that the credentialing effect is the biggest driver. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The headline thing is enormously stupid and annoying.
But presumably we’ll create a new norm for how to share articles including its headline in the body of the tweet?
So things will be a bit suboptimal for everyone but the change will be smaller than Musk hopes or we fear? -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Josh Kraushaar
@JoshKraushaar
Shocking anecdote at the beginning of Yascha Mounk’s new book: “The Identity Trap”:
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“Educational status has now overtaken other metrics, including race, in predicting one of the most important socioeconomic outcomes you can imagine: how long you get to live,” writes @Yascha_Mounk: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/10/education-inequ…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In New York and don’t have evening plans yet?
Come to the @streickercenter to hear me discuss The Identity Trap with Pamela Paul!
streicker.nyc/events/mounk -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In key respects, one metric now predicts more about the lives that Americans will live than gender or even race: education.
Whether or not you have a BA now not only determines how you will live; it even determines when you will die.
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Americans now live less long because so many suffer "deaths of despair" like overdoses and suicides.
But who is most likely to suffer those? Or to die from cancer? Or cardiovascular disease?
Americans without BAs.
Have-BAs live in Japan. Don't-Have-BAs live in Bangladesh.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Here's how important education has become according to Case & Deaton:
In 1990, white Americans without BAs outlived black Americans with BAs.
Today, by contrast, white and black Americans with BAs are close together, and white and black Americans without BAs are close together.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Please read the full article, with many more interesting facts and findings, in @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/10/education-inequ…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Or, better still, go back to the impressive and important research on this by Angus Deaton and Anne Case.
www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1518393112
www.brookings.edu/articles/accounting-for-the-widening-mo… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Fascinating.
A video of Leipzig, one of the biggest and most affluent cities in East Germany, taken just before the dissolution of the German Democratic Republic in May 1990.
Gert Wöllmann
@Gert_Woellmann
🔊
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
By way of comparison, first thing that comes up on YouTube for a city tour through Leipzig today.
youtu.be/w1yvJM4iyIY
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(To avoid misunderstandings on the first tweet: I meant the video was taken in May 1990; German reunification was officially 33 years ago, nearly to the day, on October 3rd 1990.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yes, this is a case of nutpicking... but when I read this PhD student demanding that humanities scholars not love books because they contain "dangerous" ideas, I couldn't help but think of Heine joyously boasting to the censors searching his luggage about his dangerous mind.
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
penguinpress
@penguinpress
“The most comprehensive and reasonable story of this shift that has yet been attempted . . . @Yascha_Mounk has told the story of the Great Awokening better than any other writer who has attempted to make sense of it.” @washingtonpost
www.washingtonpost.com/books/2023/09/27/identity-trap-yas… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The straightforward answer is $100. ($30 in cash and $70 in goods.)
The slightly more subtle answer is that you have to subtract the profit margin from the loss of goods, which is about 1%-3% for grocery stores.
So you get a loss of between $99.30 and $97.90.
non aesthetic things
@PicturesFoIder
What’s the correct answer?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Of course you could endlessly complicate this further.
Is the profit margin mostly determined by the cost of goods?
Are their additional costs from reconciling the discrepancy in cash register? Etc.
Kind of a good example of how math problems train you to think inside a box. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Mustafa Akyol
@AkyolinEnglish
Identity politics in the West has gone too far, pushing individuals into groups, imagining & provoking endless conflicts between them, only to undermine conscience, responsibility, rule of law, and liberty.
Yasha Mounk’s new book is a welcome critique of this dangerous trend:
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🎉🎉🎉
The Identity Trap is officially out!
A novel ideology about race, gender and sexual orientation has taken on enormous power.
Many who advocate for it have noble intentions. But it is a trap.
It would mean the world to me if you read this book. penguinrandomhouse.com/books/712961/the-identity-trap-by-… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
First book giveaway in quite some time: I've got three copies of "The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time" By Yascha Mounk to give away to my newsletter subscribers, whether free or paid.
jessesingal.substack.com/p/win-a-copy-of-the-identity-trap-a -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Noam Dworman
@noam_dworman
Just posted my interview with @Yascha_Mounk .
We discuss his new book, "The Identity Trap", woke politics, Trump, threats to democracy, race, @coldxman , Foucault... all of it.
youtu.be/rqqoGeJBBis
Here's a little trailer courtesy of Premiere AutoCaption.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Cathy Young 🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
@CathyYoung63
Fantastic event at @CityCollegeNY with @Yascha_Mounk and @janecoaston discussing Yascha's book, "The Identity Trap." Couldn't get a photo with both those great people but here they are separately
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Full house!
(Those who aren’t here can watch it on @cspan @BookTV soon.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Looking forward to my book talk today at @CityCollegeNY, in conversation with the great @janecoaston.
In New York? No afternoon plans? Come see us at 3pm!
moynihancenter.ccny.cuny.edu/news-events/book-talk-the-id… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Recorded an interview with a progressive YouTuber in a friend’s apartment, with this background.
Half of his subscribers loved the interview. The other half claimed the poster in the background means I must secretly be part of the manosphere.
The internet is a wild place. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Really loved this looong conversation about The Identity Trap—and much else—with Sam Harris.
www.samharris.org/podcasts/making-sense-episodes/336-the-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Looking forward to my book talk today at @CityCollegeNY, in conversation with the great @janecoaston.
In New York? No afternoon plans? Come see us at 3pm!
moynihancenter.ccny.cuny.edu/news-events/book-talk-the-id… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Shorter version of this thread:
Not every enemy of your enemy is your friend.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I really wish Musk did basic research before mouthing off.
No, people don't primarily attack the AfD because it has cozied up to Putin. (Though it certainly has.)
They do so because it is a racist party, one that's far more extreme even than right-wing leaders like Le Pen.
🧵 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I really wish Musk did basic research before mouthing off.
No, people don't primarily attack the AfD because it has cozied up to Putin. (Though it certainly has.)
They do so because it is a racist party, one that's far more extreme even than right-wing leaders like Le Pen.
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
There are many more quotes like this from senior AfD leaders.
Americans consistently underestimate how much more extreme far-right Europeans are on topics like race than, say, MAGA politicians.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Is Musk secretly on the AfD's political line?
It's possible. But if we take some of his recent tweets at face value, his instincts on immigration are miles apart from their worldview.
And I wish he had taken the time to realize that before mouthing off. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Critics of the identity trap are sometimes accused of falsely worrying about "reverse racism."
But the reason to reject this stuff is not that it's racist against whites; it's that the assumption that reading is quintessentially white is racist against every other ethnic group.
Mythinformed
@MythinformedMKE
“Things that white families do, like reading to their children”
Woke k-12 teacher is opposed to schools promoting positive activities like families reading to kids, because that’s what white people do.
She thinks they should instead be focused on “oppressive and racist policies”. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Nick Troiano
@NickTroiano
“Right-wing populists and the advocates of the identity synthesis see each other as mortal enemies. In truth, each is the yin to the other's yang…[E]veryone who cares about the survival of free societies should vow to fight both.” - @Yascha_Mounk
www.amazon.com/Identity-Trap-Story-Ideas-Power/dp/0593493184 -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
NEW PODCAST: 'The Identity Trap' by @Yascha_Mounk www.thefire.org/news/podcasts/so-speak-free-speech-podcas… via @TheFIREorg
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Glen Kappel
@uli09
Quite interested to discuss the role of “strategic essentialism” along with how this topic relates to something like tactical solidarity
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Verity Libra
@LibraVerity
Would love to talk with you about the role tumblr plays in all of this.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The cottage industry of, presumably AI-generated, summaries of books is quite something!
These were published, respectively, three days after, two days after, and one day BEFORE, pub date. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I'd love to talk to more of my readers!
So I had an idea: If you'd like to chat about The Identity Trap, post a picture of the book—and, if you like, a favorite quote—as a response and/or retweet.
I'll randomly select 5 people with whom to discuss the book.
Can't wait!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Pictures of the ebook or audiobook count, of course!
And if the conversation ends up being with a cute puppy rather than a smart human, I can't say that I mind that either...
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Just realized that my post was ambiguous: I meant that I'd schedule five 1-1 conversations, not one group conversation!
And these conversations would be in a few weeks, so no need to have read the book already! -
Yascha Mounk reposted
New York Times Opinion
@nytopinion
“To build a better society, we must overcome the prejudices and enmities that have for so much of human history boxed us into the roles seemingly foreordained by our gender, our sexual orientation, or the color of our skin,” writes @Yascha_Mounk. www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
.@Yascha_Mounk's book The Identity Trap is the best thing I've read to explain the intellectual origins of the identitarianism that became so powerful in the 2010s. The book really can guide us out of the trap.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Please buy my book and help me stay ahead of the Psylocybin Mushroom Bible (and the less crazy Naomi).
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The political economy of housing is so screwed.
1) If a politician promised to raise the price of bread, no one would vote for him; but people will if he promises to "keep up home values."
2) Voters who want lower housing prices don't understand how to bring them about AT ALL.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's amazing how much of the economic squeeze on living standards for middle-class people—and, in the wake of that, political dysfunction—is downstream from this one feature of contemporary public policy that is kind of just dumb but fiendishly difficult to solve.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Right.
Because most Americans have so much of their net worth invested in their homes, they want the price to go up.
And because Americans want the price of housing to go up, all of us are stuck paying astronomical sums for subpar housing.
James Surowiecki
@JamesSurowiecki
Most Americans don't have a lot of their wealth invested in bread. Most Americans do have a lot of their wealth invested in their homes.
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Dr. Arthur Brooks
@arthurbrooks
Strong recommend!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Please buy my book and help me stay ahead of the Psylocybin Mushroom Bible (and the less crazy Naomi).
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“When decision makers appear out of touch with the values and priorities of most citizens, demagogues thrive,” writes @Yascha_Mounk: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/woke-ideology-h…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“When decision makers appear out of touch with the values and priorities of most citizens, demagogues thrive,” writes @Yascha_Mounk: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/woke-ideology-h…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In other words:
"I capitulated. But my capitulation was not sufficiently emphatic, so to keep the peace within the team, I had to go capitulate some more."
Chris Anderson
@TEDchris
Turns out there are a few more things I need to say about the storm that’s blown up over Coleman Hughes’ TED Talk. It would mean a lot if you would read this through to the end! 🙏
The first is how unfair it is that Adam Grant got dragged into this. After Coleman gave his talk in Vancouver, our team asked Adam privately whether social science supported Coleman’s argument about color blindness and he referred us to a paper that had surveyed the field. We briefly shared some of his concerns with Coleman but we should have shared Adam’s full, nuanced summary of the evidence, because his overall stance is indeed backed up by the paper. As the researchers themselves write: “Multiculturalism is more consistently associated with improved intergroup relations than any identity-blind ideology.” psycnet.apa.org/record/2019-54272-001 And now, for his efforts, Adam has been falsely accused of trying to suppress the talk and of misinterpreting the research. This really upsets me. Adam is a wonderful scientist who goes where the data points. Please, leave him out of this.
Clearly, there’s no shortage of people who are mad at TED (and at me). The post below has more than 1200 comments, some supportive, but many furious over their perception that this is just another case of an organization being captured by woke employees. I think they're missing some key context. Let me share a little more of the story as I personally have experienced it.
Pretty much every single media organization in America, if not the world, has found it challenging to navigate the last few years. That certainly includes us. The world’s escalating political division, accelerated first by cable news, then by social media, has put relentless pressure on organizations to move sharply left or sharply right. Most of our content is nonpolitical — and that’s the way it will stay. But when we have entered political waters, that content in recent years has indeed been more likely to use the language and ideas of progressives than conservatives. And that fact, in itself, has been a cause of intense debate internally. We’re a nonpartisan nonprofit organization, and our mission is to offer powerful ideas to everyone in the world, not just those from within one political group. Speaking personally, as TED’s ultimate decision maker, I am determined that we hold to that mission.
This is exactly why we invited Coleman Hughes to TED this year. He’s a compelling voice, capable of articulating what are generally regarded as right of center ideas with great confidence and clarity. We want a growing diversity of ideas at TED, even those not everyone here agrees with, provided they are contributing to an important discussion.
Some commenters below just don’t understand how anyone could be upset by a talk arguing for color blindness. This speaks to their own lack of immersion in the rich debate that has swirled on this topic in recent years. See, for example, a wonderful TED Talk from 2014, “Color blind or color brave?”, arguing that we’ll never achieve true equity unless we proactively take race into account in our decision-making. Check it out. It’s persuasive: go.ted.com/6WzH
If someone's spent their whole life experiencing a playing field that is tilted against them, proactive policies to un-tilt that field are a ray of light. A talk arguing to dump those in favor of color-blindness can therefore seem not just wrong, but truly dangerous. So I get why some members of the TED community — and also some of our team — were upset by Coleman’s talk. I see comments from people saying “That’s their problem, just fire them.” Give me a break. I love this team. They’re smart, creative, curious and kind, and they work for TED because they believe in the importance of ideas and in TED’s mission. I think it’s healthy that there are sometimes heartfelt debates within the org. When those arise, the right stance is to try to work through them so that we can all learn. That's exactly what happened in this case.
Speaking personally, I really long for a shift in our culture. And I don’t think I’m alone. I see a growing number of people yearn for something better than having our conversations dominated by the angry and the judgmental. What if we tried giving each other the benefit of the doubt? There are so many people out there acting in good faith, trying to build a better future. Instead of looking for an excuse to tear each other down, how about we listen, learn and seek to find common ground? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I can’t believe this needs to be said but…
…you can be an anti-fascist without supporting Antifa.
I, for one, am. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
This just arrived!
"The roots of the new ideology that is changing the key rules and norms of mainstream institutions lie in the transformation of the core commitments of many self-described progressives. [ ... T]hey increasingly embrace a vision of the future in which... -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Have we passed “peak woke”?
This is a question I keep getting. And there are some good reasons to think that it might be.
But I think the answer is no.
Here’s why.
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Here’s the big picture:
It’s a mistake to treat each victory or defeat of the identity synthesis as a bell-weather.
Because the defining intellectual argument of the next 25 years will be over whether liberal or identitarian ideas and norms will govern mainstream institutions.
(This is different from the defining political fight, which will likely pit liberals against the authoritarian right—a fight that liberals can only win by resisting misguided and deeply unpopular ideas on "their own" side.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
So liberals need to get serious about pushing back within mainstream institutions.
That's part of why I wrote The Identity Trap: It's designed to help you understand why the identity synthesis is so appealing—and to explain why it is nonetheless a trap.
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/712961/the-identity-trap… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This was one of the smartest hostile-ish (in a perfectly civil manner) interviews of me about The Identity Trap so far.
If you want to see someone really kick the tires of my arguments, and judge for yourself whether they hold up, here’s a good place to start.
New Lines Magazine
@newlinesmag
NEW: Is identity politics the way forward — or a trap? In his new book, @Yascha_Mounk argues the latter.
He and @FaisalAlYafai break down the debate reshaping the progressive movement on The Lede podcast. newlinesmag.com/podcast/identity-liberalism-and-the-new-l… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
New York Times Opinion
@nytopinion
“To build a better society, we must overcome the prejudices and enmities that have for so much of human history boxed us into the roles seemingly foreordained by our gender, our sexual orientation, or the color of our skin,” writes @Yascha_Mounk. www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is as pure an example of "180ism" as you can find.
There are many reason to criticize the Chinese government. Referring to the CCP helpfully distinguishes that government from the Chinese people.
But because Republicans are doing it, Philip Bump thinks it must be evil!
Post Politics
@postpolitics
The rise of ‘Chinese Communist Party’ as a pejorative www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/09/28/desantis-repub…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Please buy my book and help me stay ahead of the Psylocybin Mushroom Bible (and the less crazy Naomi).
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If, on the other hand, I should be overtaken by @JonHaidt and @glukianoff, I would happily accede to my fate.
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Making Sense Podcast
@MakingSenseHQ
NEW PODCAST EPISODE
Sam Harris speaks with Yascha Mounk about identity politics.
www.samharris.org/podcasts/making-sense-episodes/336-the-… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Bridget Phetasy
@BridgetPhetasy
I welcome @Yascha_Mounk back to the show to discuss his new book, The Identity Trap, and the rise of a set of ideas about race, gender, and sexual orientation in the last 10 years that have changed the world, the allure of the identity trap and why it is counterproductive and so much more. #walkinswelcome
youtu.be/E7Srm_rHGEE -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
Just received my copy of The Identity Trap by @Yascha_Mounk, whose work I’ve long admired. I had very high expectations. His introductory chapter, The Lure and the Trap, just blew me away. An essentially perfect statement of the problem.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Really loved this looong conversation about The Identity Trap—and much else—with Sam Harris.
www.samharris.org/podcasts/making-sense-episodes/336-the-… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Helen Pluckrose
@HPluckrose
Reading @Yascha_Mounk's The Identity Trap. Shall report back. So far, I am in full agreement.
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Meghan Daum
@meghan_daum
This week on @TheUnspeakPod: author, @JoinPersuasion founder, and (at the moment) VERY public intellectual @Yascha_Mounk. You're hearing him everywhere this week, but you should hear him here first! podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-unspeakable-podcast/id1…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“When decision makers appear out of touch with the values and priorities of most citizens, demagogues thrive,” writes @Yascha_Mounk: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/woke-ideology-h…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I too am against capitalists having political power.
I don’t think, however, that giving that power to unelected despots improves matters.
The fact that others feel the same way might have something to do with these “ideological attacks.”
Branko Milanovic
@BrankoMilan
The ideological attacks on China can be only understood if you realize that 1 China is a capitalist economy where 2 capitalists do not have political power. The attack is not motivated by 1, but by 2. As Adam Smith warned against, capitalists should *not* be given political power
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Don’t mean to be overly snarky. @BrankoMilan is always interesting, thought-provoking, and willing to challenge conventional narratives. Looking forward to having you back on my podcast soon to discuss at greater length!)
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Michael Savage
@GrumpyArt
Current view.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The tweets about the debate are not making me regret not watching the debate.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Really loved this conversation with the always-insightful @davidaxelrod.
Among other things, it helped me think through some of the things the Biden campaign could do to lower the chances that Trump wins in 2024...
David Axelrod
@davidaxelrod
Enjoyed chatting with @Yascha_Mounk on The Good Fight podcast! www.persuasion.community/p/axelrod
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
So lovely to start seeing The Identity Trap out in the wild!
Thank you, @novelneighbor. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
For the @washingtonpost, I reviewed Yascha Mounk's new book The Identity Trap, which traces the roots of political "wokeness" to an "identity synthesis" in progressive ideology, abetted by other cultural and psychological trends. www.washingtonpost.com/books/2023/09/27/identity-trap-yas…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Cathy Young 🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
@CathyYoung63
ICYMI, new from me at @BulwarkOnline:
I'm "anti-woke." Here's why Chris Rufo's anti-woke revolution is not the answer.
plus.thebulwark.com/p/chris-rufo-dreams-anti-woke-revolution -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Carl
@HistoryBoomer
Great interview of @Yascha_Mounk by @nickgillespie for @reason! I haven’t read Yascha’s book “The Identity Trap” but his overview made me very eager to buy it and check out his exploration of the intellectual roots and current state of identity politics.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A wonderful review of The Identity Trap in the @washingtonpost:
“The most comprehensive and reasonable story of this shift that has yet been attempted… Mounk has told the story of the Great Awokening better than any other writer who has attempted to make sense of it.”
🎉🎉
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
For the @washingtonpost, I reviewed Yascha Mounk's new book The Identity Trap, which traces the roots of political "wokeness" to an "identity synthesis" in progressive ideology, abetted by other cultural and psychological trends. www.washingtonpost.com/books/2023/09/27/identity-trap-yas…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🎉🎉🎉
The Identity Trap is officially out!
A novel ideology about race, gender and sexual orientation has taken on enormous power.
Many who advocate for it have noble intentions. But it is a trap.
It would mean the world to me if you read this book. penguinrandomhouse.com/books/712961/the-identity-trap-by-…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The book:
* Tells the story of where these ideas came from.
* Shows how they were able to become so influential.
* Critiques their main applications, from free speech to cultural appropriation.
* Makes a plea for a humanist liberalism more likely to remedy serious injustices.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
My ambition was to write the most level-headed and comprehensive critique of the left’s embrace of this novel ideology.
The Washington Post agrees, writing that it is "the most comprehensive and reasonable story of this shift that has yet been attempted."
www.washingtonpost.com/books/2023/09/27/identity-trap-yas…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
You might be inclined to agree with my skepticism about these ideas." You might be inclined to disagree, perhaps strongly.
But I promise I treat these ideas with the respect they deserve, and that you will learn a lot from reading The Identity Trap.
🙏🙏
www.amazon.com/Identity-Trap-Story-Ideas-Power/dp/0593493… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
Great conversation between @Yascha_Mounk & @nickgillespie at the @reason speakeasy.
#3 Takeaway: incredulity toward metanarratives.
#2 Takeaway: don’t fall into the identity trap.
#1 Takeaway: Buy Yascha’s book. It may be the most important book of 2023. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Erika Sanzi
@esanzi
This episode with @meghan_daum talking to @Yascha_Mounk is SO EXCELLENT and will be helpful to parents trying to understand the ideologies that led to schools separating kids/staff by race and being so focused on group identities like race, gender, ethnicity.
I learned a ton. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Finished an interview about The Identity Trap in which the host claimed that the idea that extreme views have influence over mainstream institutions was completely fanciful.
Opened this app.
Saw this.
The Free Press
@TheFP
After @coldxman gave a TED talk on color blindness, the audience applauded; some people even stood up, and those who disagreed with him offered thoughtful criticisms.
But then some TED employees complained, and the talk was suppressed online. thefp.pub/3EPq0Im -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In New York? No evening plans yet?
Come hear me talk about The Identity Trap with @nickgillespie!
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
Tickets still available (but barely)! Tonight at 6.30pm, a live taping of @reason Interview pod with @Yascha_Mounk at The Blue Building 222 East 46th Street! $10 tickets include beer, wine, soda, food, provocative thinking! www.eventbrite.com/e/reason-speakeasy-yascha-mounk-ticket…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Noam Dworman
@noam_dworman
twitter.com/Yascha_Mounk/status/1706378431376556032
@BretWeinstein, I think @Yascha_Mounk (disclosure, I know him) is correctly representing your positions. After research, I made this video to demonstrate.
It's edited. If you'd like me to include something from the cutting room floor, send me the TC and I'll redo.
This is "insinuation" by anyone's definition.
If you believe it, own it. Maybe you're right?
Or, tell us forthrightly what you think about 9/11?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
No, as I explained to you privately, I will not correct my New York Times article because... it didn't say anything about you that's wrong.
Bret Weinstein
@BretWeinstein
Questions for @Yascha_Mounk:
Did you attempt to contact me before publishing your hit piece in the NYT? If not, why not?
Why have you still failed to correct the piece?
Will the book version be corrected?
The NYT piece without a paywall:
web.archive.org/web/20230922193254/https://www.nytimes.co… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Thank you for your thoughtful comments, @Tyler_A_Harper. I have enjoyed much of your recent writing.
However, I must say I don't quite understand your argument here because a) surely, ideas do often end up being influential; and b) I talk a lot about power in the book!Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Finally, I have MANY former students who majored in the humanities & are now working for McKinsey or Goldman! So do some people I went to grad school with.
(And of course a bunch of others majored in economic but took lots of courses in, say, comp lit.)
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
His answer – that young graduates, bathed in "theory," went on to be hired at elite corps – doesn't add up. He points out that McKinsey/Goldman Sachs, etc. hire from the theory-laden Ivies. I'm sorry, but the management consultants are not former Comparative Lit. majors LMAO. 3/
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Anyway. Thanks for reading, and hope to have the opportunity to discuss in person sometime.
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Christian JB
@christianjbdev
"Many attacks on so-called wokeness are motivated by bad faith. They fundamentally misrepresent its nature. But that is no reason to deny how a new ideology has acquired such power in our society."
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/woke-ideology-h… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“When decision makers appear out of touch with the values and priorities of most citizens, demagogues thrive,” writes @Yascha_Mounk: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/woke-ideology-h…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Much of my academic training is in intellectual history.
So to understand the ideas about group identity that have become powerful so quickly, I did a TON of reading.
Here's the true story of the origins of "woke"—and how it explains many themes of today's left.
A loooong 🧵.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Kimberlé Crenshaw added another key term to the repertoire of critical race theory. “Intersectionality,” she argued, helps to explain the way in which different forms of discrimination reinforce each other.
She also gave a compelling example. New legislation introduced during the civil rights era allowed Americans to sue their employers for discrimination if they experienced significant dis- advantages based on “protected characteristics” like race, gender, and national origin. During the 1970s and 1980s, many women and many African Americans made use of these provisions to protect themselves from discriminatory practices. But as Crenshaw demonstrated, the law as it was interpreted at the time did not provide adequate protection to people who suffered disadvantages because of a combination of protected characteristics.
But other scholars in the tradition later expanded this idea well beyond its original use. To them, the fact that each person exists at the intersection of different identities came to imply that outsiders could, even if they carefully listened to their stories, never come to understand,say, a homosexual Latino or a Black woman. In some of its uses, intersectionality thus came to stand for in the profound incommensurability of human experience.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One way to judge an intellectual history is to ask whether it can actually explain the present.
Describing “wokeness” as “cultural Marxism” doesn’t do that. Doing so simply doesn’t help to illuminate the main themes of progressive politics today; it doesn’t get what makes the ideology tick.
This account does. I offer a more formal definition of the identity synthesis elsewhere in my work—perhaps I’ll tweet about that sometime as well—but the themes explained in this thread help to explain what’s going on. Because much of progressive politics today is rooted in:
* A rejection of objective truth and universal values (cf. Foucault.)
* The use of a politicized form of “discourse critique” (cf. Said.)
* An embrace of “strategic essentialism” that inspires much of the progressive separatism we see in schools and activist spaces (cf. Spivak.)
* A commitment to race-sensitive public policy and the belief that America has not made any progress on questions like race or sexuality (cf. Bell)
* A deep skepticism about the ability of people in different groups to understand each other (cf. Crenshaw.)Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This thread is very long. But it’s a very abridged version of the intellectual history.
Please read my longer excerpt of The identity Trap in @TheAtlantic today.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/woke-ideology-h…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is a brief excerpt from Part 1 of The Identity Trap.
In the next 3 parts, it:
* Shows how these ideas took over the mainstream
* Critiques their application in areas from free speech to cultural appropriation
* Explains how liberals should respond
www.amazon.com/Identity-Trap-Story-Ideas-Power/dp/0593493… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In this particular case, it’s sadly useless to blame “Russian propaganda and Russian misinformation.”
This is a costly own-goal all of Trudeau’s making. And it’s ordinary Ukrainians who are bravely defending their country against an invading army who will pay the price…
Mackenzie Gray
@Gray_Mackenzie
Speaking for the first time since a Ukrainian Nazi Veteran was appalled during the Zelensky speech, Justin Trudeau says “this is deeply embarrassing to the Parliament of Canada and by extension to all Canadians,” adding it is “extremely upsetting that this happened” #cdnpoli
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This also shows the price of ruling elites being stuck in airtight information bubbles.
Yes, most attacks on Ukraine are warmed-over BS. But shouldn’t *someone* in the Canadian parliament know just enough about them to realize how fully this would play into those narratives? -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Charlie Sykes
@SykesCharlie
Our democratic order is facing a two-front war. While the immediate crisis may be from the right, the left is presenting its own threats—which only help make far-right populism stronger. Political scientist and democracy hipster Yascha Mounk joins me. www.thebulwark.com/podcast-episode/yascha-mounk-the-ident…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Morning Joe
@Morning_Joe
"The rigid focus on group identity that now dominates much of the public debate makes it harder for people from different groups to get along."
— Author Yascha Mounk dives into his new book 'The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time' on.msnbc.com/3RwlIwT -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Rachel Lu
@rclu
So interesting to talk to @Yascha_Mounk about his new book on identity politics, here on the @LawLiberty podcast.
If you’ve read Mitchell, Hanania, Caldwell etc on this general subject, you should read Mounk’s book too, for balance.
lawliberty.org/podcast/an-unholy-postmodern-synthesis/ -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Andrew Yang🧢⬆️🇺🇸
@AndrewYang
On andrewyang.com/podcast Atlantic writer and author of the new book “The Identity Trap: a Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time” Johns Hopkins professor @Yascha_Mounk joins to talk identity-based vs. universal appeals, why the latter approach is better and the path forward.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Is this you, Bret?
(Video below. Highlights from transcript included here.)
Bret Weinstein: "I see a pattern of anomalies that refuse to dissipate on inspection..."
Michael Shermer: "To me, the theory that this was an inside job by the Bush administration is a distraction from the real issue..."
Weinstein: "But some of the anomalies aren't little things that got unearthed because people are looking at every detail."
Shermer: "Like what?"
Weinstein: "Well, it's a cliché at this point, but the way Building 7 falls. Doesn't make any sense to me--"
Shermer: "Yeah, it does. I think so. And you know who also knows? The insurance companies that had to pay the claims off. They investigated this..."
Other things Weinstein says later in this conversation:
* "Those cell phone calls have never made much sense to me"
* "The making of phone calls in 2001 from a plane, calls that did not frustratingly drop almost instantly, does not add up."
If all of this isn't *insinuating* that people who believe 9/11 was an inside job may be right, I don't know what would.
youtu.be/7C7Q9UF3PRE?t=6457
Bret Weinstein
@BretWeinstein
No, Yascha, you're logically incompetent.
If I say "I don't believe the magic bullet. There must have been a second gunman." Have I insinuated the CIA killed Kennedy?
Obviously not.
To say the 9/11 commission advanced a conspiracy theory is a simple statement of fact.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Some people on this platform clearly don't know the meaning of the word "insinuate."
Alexandros Marinos 🏴☠️
@alexandrosM
"Of late, he has insinuated that the Sept. 11 attacks were an inside job"
To his credit, Yascha links to a source for his claim.
To his discredit, the source is this tweet:
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Bret's defenders are a wonderful mix of "how dare you say he embraces 9/11 conspiracy theories" and "if you are not a 9/11 conspiracy theorist, you're just dumb."
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
No, as I explained to you privately, I will not correct my New York Times article because... it didn't say anything about you that's wrong.
Bret Weinstein
@BretWeinstein
Questions for @Yascha_Mounk:
Did you attempt to contact me before publishing your hit piece in the NYT? If not, why not?
Why have you still failed to correct the piece?
Will the book version be corrected?
The NYT piece without a paywall:
web.archive.org/web/20230922193254/https://www.nytimes.co…Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
As for my book, an additional reason why it won't be corrected is that... you are not mentioned in it.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Thank you for helping to draw attention to my book though, Bret.
For anyone who wants to read it, here's the link! :)
www.amazon.com/Identity-Trap-Story-Ideas-Power/dp/0593493… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The Identity Trap is out tomorrow!
Please keep (pre-)ordering?
www.amazon.com/Identity-Trap-Story-Ideas-Power/dp/0593493… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I love all podcasts equally but I had so much fun in this conversation with the great @meghan_daum!
Meghan Daum
@meghan_daum
This week on @TheUnspeakPod: author, @JoinPersuasion founder, and (at the moment) VERY public intellectual @Yascha_Mounk. You're hearing him everywhere this week, but you should hear him here first! podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-unspeakable-podcast/id1…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Why is the new Twitter continually showing me content like this from people whom I don't follow and whom I have no earthly desire to follow?
Michael Knowles
@michaeljknowles
I'm beginning to suspect that Joe Biden is a far more evil ruler than either Vladimir Putin or Xi Jinping.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Really enjoyed talking about The Identity Trap on @Morning_Joe with Rev. Al Sharpton, Mara Gay, Mika Brzezinski and Joe Scarborough!
youtu.be/19LGrmeZO3A -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Defenders of the identity synthesis often alternate between claiming that highly controversial ideas don’t exist… or are perfectly fine, actually.
So I have an honest question for @nhannahjones: Do you ever support splitting first graders into different groups based on race? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A few responses to this thread about me by @nhannahjones.
First off, let’s get the misrepresentations of my position out of the way.
Ida Bae Wells
@nhannahjones
So weird to see @Yascha_Mounk claiming the unfairness of PPP loans going to people based on skin color on @Morning_Joe when we have reams of data on how Black business were least likely to receive these loans. www.nber.org/digest/202112/racial-disparities-paycheck-pr…
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is key because my core disagreement with theorists like Derrick Bell is precisely their skepticism about integration!
Here is the title page of one of Derrick Bell’s most influential paper, making the case that “integration ideals” go against the wishes of Black clients!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Hannah-Jones claims that schools separating kids by race is not widespread.
I show that these practices are widespread—and even celebrated by professional orgs, like the National Association of Independent Schools!
Some private schools are also doing this, e.g. in Evanston, IL.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Defenders of the identity synthesis often alternate between claiming that highly controversial ideas don’t exist… or are perfectly fine, actually.
So I have an honest question for @nhannahjones: Do you ever support splitting first graders into different groups based on race?Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Or read at the excerpt from my book in yesterday's @nytimes.
www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Or watch the actual clip to which Hannah-Jones is responding, one in which I had a very interesting and respectful conversation with Rev. Al Sharpton, Mara Gay, Mika Brzezinski and Joe Scarborough.
www.msnbc.com/morning-joe/watch/focus-on-group-identity-m… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
John Avlon
@JohnAvlon
Incisive essay by @Yascha_Mounk - How to Argue Against Identity Politics Without Turning Into a Reactionary www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Dorothea Baur (Dr.)
@DorotheaBaur
"The concept of cultural appropriation is incoherent, making it harder for us to recognise...the 'wrong-making features' of genuine injustices" It creates harms by putting "healthy forms of cultural exchange under a general pall of suspicion" @Yascha_Mounk www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/sep/24/should-we-b…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Angel Eduardo
@StrangelEdweird
“Is it possible to argue against the identity synthesis without falling into the reactionary trap?
Yes.”
Great piece by @Yascha_Mounk here. www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html -
Yascha Mounk reposted
New York Times Opinion
@nytopinion
“To build a better society, we must overcome the prejudices and enmities that have for so much of human history boxed us into the roles seemingly foreordained by our gender, our sexual orientation, or the color of our skin,” writes @Yascha_Mounk. www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
About that poll:
According to Bayesian reasoning, previously existing evidence gives you good reason not to wildly change your beliefs when one new piece of evidence falls significantly outside your expectations.
But it is not a reason to refuse to update your beliefs at all.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
There’s enough evidence on the views of young voters to distrust this poll’s claim that Trump now has a big lead on Biden in that demographic.
But the fact that a high-quality polling organization can show such bad numbers for Biden does likely point to real underlying weakness. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Observer
@ObserverUK
Should we borrow from other cultures? Of course we should, just as we always have | Yascha Mounk www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/sep/24/should-we-b…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One of the ideas that most bothers me in this moment is “cultural appropriation.”
Here’s why we should stop using the term—and embrace mutual cultural influence as a big part of what’s wonderful, not “problematic,” about life in diverse democracies.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Over the last years, many forms of mutual cultural influence have come under a general pall of suspicion.
Bon Appétit magazine even apologized for allowing a gentile writer to publish a recipe for hamantaschen, a traditional Jewish dessert!
Here’s the reasons that’s a mistake.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The joy of mutual influence is not a sin against which diverse societies should be on guard. It is the key promise they hold out to us if we get things right.
To see a much fuller version of the argument, read The Identity Trap:
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/712961/the-identity-trap…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And here’s a brief excerpt from the chapter about cultural appropriation, published today in the @guardian.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/sep/24/should-we-b… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Cathy Young 🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
@CathyYoung63
Great @SykesCharlie interview with @Yascha_Mounk on his new book, "The Identity Trap"
www.thebulwark.com/podcast-episode/yascha-mounk-the-ident… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The advantages of proportional representation are often overstated.
But a real one is that the resignation or incapacitation of a politician doesn’t affect the partisan makeup of the legislature.
Makes it easier for parties to enforce minimal standards of decency and competencePost not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To be fair, as the Ken Paxton saga showed, Republicans would probably rally around a politician like Menendez right now even if he came from an R+10 state…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Fair point.
Elephant_Frog
@elephant_ben
The contrary argument is that politicians in closed list PR are protected because voters can’t target them specifically.
Not sure which is true here.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The advantages of proportional representation are often overstated.
But a real one is that the resignation or incapacitation of a politician doesn’t affect the partisan makeup of the legislature.
Makes it easier for parties to enforce minimal standards of decency and competence -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Nick Cohen
@NickCohen4
What wokeism is and why it won't survive
Long read from me on @Yascha_Mounk's wondeful new book. It is both an investigation of the origins of identity politics and plea for universalism and humanism
open.substack.com/pub/nickcohen/p/the-roots-of-wokeness?r… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How to Argue Against Identity Politics (successor ideology, political correctness, social justice warfare, critical theory) Without Turning Into a Reactionary Crank. "It is time to fight, without shame or hesitation, for a future in which what we have in common truly comes to be more important than what divides us." XLNT piece by @Yascha_Mounk www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Many liberals have realized that "woke" ideas are wrongheaded.
But they worry that speaking out against them will put them on a path to becoming a crank.
Here's a guide for how to argue against the new ideology without turning into a reactionary.
🧵
www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Should you push back against misguided progressive ideas even though Trump is a bigger danger?
Is it possible to oppose "wokeness" without ignoring genuine injustices?
Can you argue against the identity synthesis without falling into the reactionary trap?
Yes, yes and yes.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The identity synthesis is a trap.
If we fall into it, there will be more zero-sum competition between different groups. But it is possible to oppose the identity trap without becoming a reactionary.
If you want to see how, please read The Identity Trap!
www.amazon.com/Identity-Trap-Story-Ideas-Power/dp/0593493184
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And please read the full article @nytopinion!
www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Is @CaitlinPacific the most likable person on the internet?
Yes. Yes, she is. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A lot of adjuncts at American universities are genuinely being exploited. They have every reason to be enraged.
But the ability of tenured, or even tenure-track, professors at elite American universities to pretend that they are exploited proletarians is frankly unseemly.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Professors work hard. Status games in academia suck. There are annoying aspects to our jobs. If you can lobby your university to give you a bigger share of its vast endowment, go for it. Best of luck.
But you have one of the best jobs in the damn world. Stop playing the victim. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Saving Liberalism from ‘The Identity Trap’: An Interview with Yascha Mounk quillette.com/2023/09/19/untitled-3/
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I can see how leaders who are laser-focused on delivering on their mission might end up overworking and alienating their staff.
It’s a little hard to see how leaders who don’t seem interested in getting anything done manage to overwork and alienate their staff.
Kinda impressive
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I think this subtweet may have been more obscure than I anticipated. 😂
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
That was wrong and so is this.
The logic of “what they did was evil, so when we are doing the same now that is just fine” truly escapes me.
(See also the “realist” position on Russia-Ukraine.)
Tony Annett
@tonyannett
Orlando Letelier was assassinated by Pinochet in Washington DC and the US did nothing.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It is very important for the US and the EU to stand in solidarity with Canada against this blatant attempt at extortion.
The stakes here are very high: Will we allow other countries to assassinate citizens on our soil—and then shut up about it for fear of retaliation?
Murtaza Ali Shah
@MurtazaViews
India has suspended visa services for Canadian citizens in massive escalation after India accuses by Canada govt of running death squads against innocent Sikhs and killing of #hardeepsinghnijjar by RAW agents.
Canada intelligence blasts India, must read report: -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It is very important for the US and the EU to stand in solidarity with Canada against this blatant attempt at extortion.
The stakes here are very high: Will we allow other countries to assassinate citizens on our soil—and then shut up about it for fear of retaliation?
Murtaza Ali Shah
@MurtazaViews
India has suspended visa services for Canadian citizens in massive escalation after India accuses by Canada govt of running death squads against innocent Sikhs and killing of #hardeepsinghnijjar by RAW agents.
Canada intelligence blasts India, must read report:
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Genuinely upsetting to see a long-standing democracy like India emulate China’s authoritarian playbook in this way.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is a wonderful piece of writing, which summarizes many themes of The Identity Trap better than I could myself.
Nick Cohen
@NickCohen4
What wokeism is and why it won't survive
Long read from me on @Yascha_Mounk's wondeful new book. It is both an investigation of the origins of identity politics and plea for universalism and humanism
open.substack.com/pub/nickcohen/p/the-roots-of-wokeness?r… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To say that "wokeness" is a form of "cultural Marxism" is like saying that you have taken bats out of baseball.
Once you take out social class, there simply isn’t enough left of the ideology to help you understand the new form of progressive politics.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To understand where the ideology really comes from, and how its origins have shaped the ideas and practices that have taken over so many American institutions over the course of the past decade, read The Identity Trap!
www.amazon.com/Identity-Trap-Story-Ideas-Power/dp/0593493184
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
By the way, believing that wokeness is a form of cultural Marxism is not necessarily some kind of terrible dog whistle. It's a plausible hypothesis—one that just turns out to be wrong as a matter of intellectual history, making it harder to understand and critique this ideology.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
“Anne had seventeen pregnancies, of which five were live. Births. None of her children survived to adulthood.”
It’s really hard to overstate how ignorant the people who believe we live in some kind of unprecedented hellscape are.
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
Queen in the 17th century
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Live births.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I love New York deeply, and will defend many of its idiosyncrasies.
But garbage cans destroying that “pretty, cute neighborhood feeling” provided by random trash bags lying around the sidewalk and attracting rats is on another level.
Aaron Carr
@aaronAcarr
New York City is trying to do what virtually every city in the developed world already does — putting trash in garbage cans — and some NIMBYs aren’t having it because the status quo of trash and rats spewed all over the sidewalks give that “cute neighborhood feeling”… Holy f*ck!
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
𝕁𝕠𝕤𝕙 𝕊𝕫𝕖𝕡𝕤
@joshzepps
What is "wokeness"? Why has the Left shifted from a belief in universalism to an obsession with difference?
In his new book, the brilliant @Yascha_Mounk reveals how a marginal set of ideas came to rule the world.
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/uncomfortable-conversations…
Spotify: spoti.fi/3T9KGAh -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Geoffrey Smith
@lookatlao
Great conversation. Looking forward to the book next week on a 20 hour flight. @joshzepps @Yascha_Mounk uncomfortableconversations.substack.com/p/the-identity-tr…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Eric Kaufmann
@epkaufm
“As a darling of the political left, Mounk’s criticisms of America’s elite universities will probably hit harder”
www.timeshighereducation.com/depth/yascha-mounk-identity-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
❤️❤️🙏🙏
Thank you, @sapinker.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Saving Liberalism from ‘The Identity Trap’: An Interview with Yascha Mounk quillette.com/2023/09/19/untitled-3/
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
The DSR Network
@thedsrnetwork
Yascha Mounk’s latest book, “The Identity Trap,” explores the origins and risks associated with identity politics. @Yascha_Mounk joins @djrothkopf to share his conception of “identity synthesis,” the future of "wokeness," and more.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/deep-state-radio/id12450029… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One more thought:
People are willing to pay for things they feel good about, even if its value is not strictly speaking worth the cost.
Conversely, people really don't want to pay even a pittance for a product towards which they feel ill-will.
That's Twitter's problem.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Reports of Twitter's death have been greatly exaggerated.
But I am highly skeptical that a large enough number of people would pay to use Twitter to make this plan feasible.
If Musk presses ahead, this might finally herald the end of Twitter as the key venue for public debate.
philip lewis
@Phil_Lewis_
Elon Musk suggests he will charge all X/Twitter users a “small monthly fee” to be on the platform variety.com/2023/digital/news/elon-musk-charge-all-x-twit…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
ian bremmer
@ianbremmer
azerbaijan announcing “evacuation” of all armenians from “dangerous” enclave of nagorno-karabagh (that they’ve just attacked).
to be replaced by azeris.
genocide playing out in real time.
will anyone take action?
president erdogan, nato ally of us, has the most leverage. so far unlikely. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
Hey #nyc! Come to a live taping of @reason Interview pod w @Yascha_Mounk talk abt his new book The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas & Power in Our Time. Tues, 9/26. $10 tix includes wine beer soda food. @JoinPersuasion #libertarian #freespeech
www.eventbrite.com/e/reason-speakeasy-yascha-mounk-ticket… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
You can believe both that:
a) Democrats and Republicans are in no way morally equivalent right now; and
b) You should always ask yourself whether you'd be as outraged by (or lenient about) a particular scandal if it involved a Democrat rather than a Republican (and vice versa).
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Another way of putting the same point:
You can both believe that one side of our partisan divide is way worse than the other and be on the guard against the ever-present tendency of partisanship to make absurd excuses for your friends or judge your enemies for faults they lack.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is a question of basic mental hygiene. But as it happens, it's also good advice for how to make effective arguments.
During the Trump years, people would keep dunking on him for trivial stuff. But there were so many real grounds on which to attack him! Concentrate on that!! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Reports of Twitter's death have been greatly exaggerated.
But I am highly skeptical that a large enough number of people would pay to use Twitter to make this plan feasible.
If Musk presses ahead, this might finally herald the end of Twitter as the key venue for public debate.
philip lewis
@Phil_Lewis_
Elon Musk suggests he will charge all X/Twitter users a “small monthly fee” to be on the platform variety.com/2023/digital/news/elon-musk-charge-all-x-twit…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Also, if against all expectations it does work, it would be the beginning of a major shift in the revenue model of social media companies. Prepare to pay for FB, Instagram, TikTok, etc.!
So for regular Twitter users, this is basically a case of heads you lose, tails they win. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Have recorded a lot of conversations about The Identity Trap.
This was the longest, most detailed, and most argumentative (in a good way.)
And it’s only Part 1…
Give it a listen?
uncertain.substack.com/p/the-identity-infection-round-1-w -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
There are many reasons why I don't believe that you can understand the new set of ideas about race, gender and sexual orientation by thinking of them as a form of "cultural Marxism."
Perhaps the most interesting one is that the identity trap lacks Marxism's utopian promise.
Quillette
@Quillette
.@Yascha_Mounk on real (economic) Marxism vs cultural Marxism www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ddx1PTQL370&t=2446s
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If anyone wants to print it, in a moment of boredom I actually wrote a whole little opinion essay about why the norm against inadvertent photobombing no longer makes sense in the age of the iPhone.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Zeit mich unbeliebt zu machen...
Die Absicht zählt. Die Rednerin versuchte zu erklären, warum reiner "Pragmatismus" unzureichend ist und ihr Wert immer vom Ziel abhänge.
War dieses Beispiel dumm? Sollte sie sich entschuldigen? Ja und ja.
Aber sie ist kein furchtbarer Mensch.
Ruben Gerczikow
@RubenGerczi
„Wenn ihr alle Juden umbringen wollt, ist ein KZ bauen eine gute Idee.“
Mich machen zwei Sachen fertig:
Der Satz als Beispiel für Pragmatismus und die fehlende Intervention bei @VoltDeutschland. x.com/DennisKBerlin/status/1703300528657076495/video/1
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Habe gezögert, ob ich mich hier einmischen muss.
Aber die Frau schämt sich. Hat sogar Selbstanklage eingereicht! Und wird doch massiv angefeindet.
Ich finde: Für Fehler muss man sich entschuldigen. Aber steht keine böse Absicht dahinter, sollten sie nie exitenzvernichtend sein. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"Get out of the combat zone where you just say the opposite of whatever your 'enemies' are saying.
I'm very critical of people who just oppose anything that anyone might describe as woke. We need to argue against these ideas on the basis of substantive principles."
The DSR Network
@thedsrnetwork
Yascha Mounk’s latest book, “The Identity Trap,” explores the origins and risks associated with identity politics. @Yascha_Mounk joins @djrothkopf to share his conception of “identity synthesis,” the future of "wokeness," and more.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/deep-state-radio/id12450029… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Rory Stewart
@RoryStewartUK
Thank you @Yascha_Mounk for a fascinating conversation - deep into the parallels between what is happening to the right in both the US and the UK www.persuasion.community/p/stewart
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The case against tenure, in one tweet.
Dr. Sarah Young
@Nonprofit_PhD
1) On TT - Be the fuzzy bunny nobody wants to kick - advice my academic big sister gave me when I started on TT. These people will be voting on your future. You can be the game changer after you get tenure.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(All in all, tenure remains a crucial protection for academic freedom.
But the strongest case against tenure is that it gives you the illusion of great freedom in the far future. And once you're used to playing fuzzy bunny for 15 years, you're too set in your ways to use it.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yes, it's the structural similarity between a lot of what counts as "progressive" today and the ethnonationalism whose principled rejection was once a hallmark of the left which has, from the start, made it impossible for me to get on board with this stuff.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Vivek is wrong about most things, including on immigration.
But it's true that H1-B visas are "a form of indentured servitude." They give employers huge leverage, making it very hard for workers to change jobs.
Canada's point-system is much better.
www.politico.com/news/2023/09/16/ramaswamy-h1b-visa-gop-v…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
H1-B visas are better than nothing.
But if you talk to people on H1-Bs, you'll know that it's a highly precarious and uncertain status—one that often allows companies to keep workers in underpaid and underproductive roles when they could make a bigger contribution elsewhere. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Corey Nathan
@coreysnathan
Is a hotdog a sandwich? Seriously, it's important! @Yascha_Mounk joins us to discuss his book THE IDENTITY TRAP: A STORY OF IDEAS AND POWER IN OUR TIME (@penguinrandom). Arguing agnst being #woke and #cancelculture from a left of center perspective. spoti.fi/3sOfcaB
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I had a great chat with @RoryStewartUK about why it is so difficult for decent people to succeed in today's politics; whether conservatism is worth rescuing; and how to help the global poor.
www.persuasion.community/p/stewart
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
By comparison to the US, UK politics is positively placid.
But I was thinking back to these words a few days ago, when trying to understand why Mitt Romney chose to retire from the Senate. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is as good, and as stupid, an example of what @sapinker has cleverly named the “euphemism treadmill” as you can think up.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A ton of the energy of progressive movements is wasted due to the same fallacy:
For the same reasons that employees will be no less apprehensive of “feedforward” than of “feedback,” a “person experiencing homelessness” will face no less stigma than a “homeless person.” -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In a similar vein, journalists vastly overestimate their ability to lead the average voter to their desired conclusions by framing some issue in a particular way, or banishing some other point of view from polite conversation.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
This is the non-spicy version of this take. But voters, other than maybe college-educated liberals, treat the media with a lot of suspicion. That makes it much less straightforward how the tenor of media coverage affects public opinion.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Reminds me of my lovely, lovely undergraduate teacher who somehow turned positively homicidal when ranting about the college's invasion by *CANADIAN* geese.
Rishi Sunak
@RishiSunak
It’s clear the American XL Bully dog is a danger to our communities.
I’ve ordered urgent work to define and ban this breed so we can end these violent attacks and keep people safe. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Edinburgh Academics for Academic Freedom
@EdinUniAFAF
Definitely one for the reading list - @Yascha_Mounk's book reviewed by @MatthewReiszTHE.
www.timeshighereducation.com/depth/yascha-mounk-identity-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Come hear me talk about my new book, The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time, in New York City!
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
Hey NYC! Come out to see @Yascha_Mounk talk with me for @reason about his important book The Identity Trap on Tuesday 9/26, 6.30pm. $10 tix include beer, wine, soda, food--and great conversation and camaraderie. Limited seating. Details at www.eventbrite.com/e/reason-speakeasy-yascha-mounk-ticket…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"Barack Obama’s favourite* political thinker Yascha Mounk... explains how dangerous styles of thinking developed in the academy have now gone mainstream – and why we should all be worried."
* Citation needed. (But I'll take the compliment.)
www.timeshighereducation.com/depth/yascha-mounk-identity-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I love how bookish French culture is.
BUT: When French people say they’re into books, it’s often just a social pose; they know they’re suppose to.
When Americans say they’re into books, they really are—because there’s very little prestige to be gained from that.
Paul Graham
@paulg
Something I taught 11 yo: When something has no prestige, the people who like it are more likely to have honest motives.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Did I just manage to insult two countries I live in one tweet? Why, yes, I think I did! Sorry, guys; j’en suis vraiment désolé.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Supposed, not suppose; love, not live. Of course I manage to have lots of typos in my one set of tweets about bookishness.)
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Jonathan Kay
@jonkay
For ep. #223 of @Quillette podcast, I intvu'd @JohnsHopkins scholar @Yascha_Mounk about his new @penguinpress book, "The Identity Trap," in which he traces the formation of today's explicitly illiberal progressive movements & offers ideas to help progressives return to liberalism
Quillette
@Quillette
~@jonkay speaks with The Identity Trap author @Yascha_Mounk about the role of Marx, Foucault, Said, and Spivak in shaping today’s illiberal, identity-fixated political mantras—and how we can help lead progressives back to their liberal roots
quillette.com/2023/09/14/tracing-the-intellectual-ancestr… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Justitia
@justitiaorg
Stop Denmark's New Blasphemy Ban
We, the undersigned, comprising a broad coalition of artists, academics, public intellectuals, and activists, are deeply concerned about the Danish government’s newly proposed bill. #dkpol
See the full list: www.persuasion.community/p/stop-denmarks-new-blasphemy-ban -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"Barack Obama’s favourite* political thinker Yascha Mounk... explains how dangerous styles of thinking developed in the academy have now gone mainstream – and why we should all be worried."
* Citation needed. (But I'll take the compliment.)
www.timeshighereducation.com/depth/yascha-mounk-identity-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
As a result of an “equity-based weeding process,” about half of the books in a Canadian high school library have been removed.
“If the shelves look emptier right now it's because we have to remove all books [published] prior to 2008,” one librarian said. www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/peel-school-board-library-…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yes, these stories are boring. I’m bored by them.
But this kind of madness is really taking place in lots of instititions, in America, Canada and beyond.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(So much for the idea that some mild pushback in a few elite institutions over the course of the past year has somehow put an end to these illiberal practices.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I have many disagreements with Mitt Romney.
But a big part of the reason why he decided to retire is that he’s a deeply honorable man.
And that’s a sign of the times: If you’re an honorable person, especially on the right, there’s no place in politics for you these days. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Times Higher Education
@timeshighered
Here's a preview of this week’s cover. Inside the mag:
- Are the odds still stacked against the UK’s ‘challenger institutions’?
- Void left by decline of academic Twitter ‘will be hard to fill’
- @Yascha_Mounk on identity politics v democracy
#tomorrowspaperstoday -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
We all now live in an epistemic bubble of our own making.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To varying extents. Some will enthusiastically engage in willful blindness to protect its boundaries; others will try to pop them as best they can.
But the structure of social media means that this requires constant effort, in which all of us, to some extent, are bound to fail. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
“Few have begun to explain the phenomenon, and in this, Mounk excels. […] Mounk’s painstaking and thoroughly researched account is a revelation.
The Identity Trap is clear, rational and robust.”
www.telegraph.co.uk/books/non-fiction/yascha-mounk-the-id… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
PantsuitPolitics
@PantsuitPolitic
Today we're thrilled to share Sarah and Beth's conversation with @Yascha_Mounk. We've been talking and thinking about his book 'The Identity Trap' for weeks and are excited to invite all of you into the conversation with us.
www.pantsuitpoliticsshow.com/show-archives/2023/9/12/when… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Prophet beats Trump and Marx in German mayoral election.
Deutschland Wählt
@Wahlen_DE
NORDHAUSEN (THÜRINGEN) | Ergebnis
der Oberbürgermeisterwahl
Prophet (AfD): 42,1%
Buchmann (parteilos): 23,7%
Rieger (SPD): 18,6%
Trump (parteilos, CDU): 11,2%
Marx (FDP): 3,0%
Meyer (GRÜNE): 1,4%
Prophet und Amtsinhaber Buchmann ziehen in die Stichwahl.
#nordhausen #obwahl
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Ironically, prophet represents the far-right AfD; Trump the moderate CDU; and Marx the pro-business FDP.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And yes, this is totally real. Though there will be a final round of the election pitting prophet against the boringly named—but politically more palatable—Buchmann (or "book man").
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Alice Weidel, leader of the far-right AfD, which is polling at over 20% in Germany, is asked why she did not participate in a celebration at the Russian embassy.
The reason has nothing to do with Ukraine; it is that she did not want to "celebrate the defeat of my own country."
ARD-Hauptstadtstudio
@ARD_BaB
Habe mich dagegen entschieden, "die Niederlage des eigenen Landes zu befeiern". AfD-Chefin Alice Weidel im ARD-#sommerinterview zur Frage, warum sie nicht – wie Tino Chrupalla – am Tag der deutschen Kapitulation in der russischen Botschaft zu Gast war.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Tino Chrupalla, her co-leader, did attend.
What a hard choice these poor people had to face: They could either show their solidarity with Putin or express their sadness at the defeat of the Third Reich but not both.
What a terrible dilemma! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Nobody is pointing to polls to say that Biden can't win; obviously, he can.
People are pointing to polls to say the race is very tight and that this should worry all of us.
Knowing what to do or not do about this problem is genuinely hard. Pretending it doesn't exist is absurd.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is why all of the Tweets pointing out that Obama was behind in 2011 are absurd.
Obama could easily have lost in 2012! And if he had, his opponent, Mitt Romney, would not have been a threat to the persistence of the American Republic. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Does anyone have a coherent account of what set of factors actually drove excess deaths?
The various neat narratives confidently peddled by various factions on this website all seem in contradiction with this data in one way or another.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Brazil and Mexico do stand out as having (very different) leaders who behaved in an especially irresponsible manner.
On the other end of the chart, Japan, France and Germany all strike me as having greater state capacity in certain respects.
But... this all feels very post-hoc. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Comapred to 50 or 100 years ago:
* Life expectancy is vastly higher.
* Infant mortality is a fraction of what it was.
* The average person is massively better off.
* People are much better educated.
There are serious problems, yes. But this fashionable doomerism is so weird.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is true in America. It is true in Europe. It is true in Asia. It is true in Africa.
It is literally true in just about every corner of the world—except for, I don't know, perhaps North Korea?—that life is vastly better today than it was in the past. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
There are Polish elections in a month.
Nobody in America is paying attention to them but they are really, really important.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2023/09/poland-…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Americans have become obsessed with Hungary and Viktor Orban, mostly because he’s so close to Tucker Carlson, has hosted CPAC, etc.
But Poland is even more important for the future of democracy in Central Europe, and the outcome there remains genuinely uncertain.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Obviously, I too believe that what happened in Hungary is important. But the state of play there is pretty dire and the country is relatively small.
Poland is much bigger & consequential and the outcome remains really uncertain. It deserves a much greater share of attention.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Of all the various things that professors complain about on here—some of it justified, of course—the demand to be compensated for giving a quote to a journalist strikes me as the most embarrassing mix of self-pity and humblebrag.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The root of the problem is that bread is treated as an instrument of profit. The sole solution is to decouple bread from profit and make it a human right.
The Nation
@thenation
The root of the problem is that housing is treated as an instrument of profit. The sole solution is to decouple housing from profit and make it a human right.
www.thenation.com/article/society/gentrification-rhetoric…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In housing, as in other areas, what Germans call a “soziale Marktwitschaft“ comes closest to getting it right.
You need a free market for bread and for housing to create plenty.
And then you need a welfare state which ensures that the destitute don’t go hungry or unhoused. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Hardly a novel observation, I know, but the boundless stupidity of making people board a train which naturally comes with about 50 doors—one that, of course, is already late—
single-file will never cease to amaze me.
Literally no other country does this.
Why, @Amtrak? Why?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Amtrak is a great counter-example to what I like to call “everyday Panglossianism”: the idea that institutions tend to do things that obviously make sense, so when they don’t do something there must be a good reason why they aren’t.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
From a prominent young economist. This in a nutshell is what is wrong with the quantitative social sciences at the moment:
You’re told to play a game. And the game is that you must always choose to answer stupid questions brilliantly, rather than important ones as best you can.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I cropped out the name of the economist because they’re giving the empirically “correct” advice to grad students who want jobs and earn tenure.
But if that’s what the game demands, then it’s really in doubt why any outsider should respect or pay attention to it. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It’s one thing to be critical of Rawls; I myself am much more attracted to other thinkers in the liberal tradition.
But the superior sneering at his work which has become so popular on the academic left (as evidenced by some reactions to this piece) is in every sense sophomoric.
Jacobin
@jacobin
Despite his towering academic reputation, John Rawls’s ideas have had little impact outside the university. That’s a shame: as the failures of neoliberalism have become increasingly stark, Rawls’s egalitarian theory of justice has much to recommend it. jacobin.com/2023/09/john-rawls-theory-of-justice-radical-…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Fun story: I once took a seminar on Rawls with a professor who proudly passed around his copy of the 1st edition of Theory of Justice.
I asked him whether he still considered it, as his marginalia suggested, “bourgeois claptrap.”
Reader, he did not take the question kindly.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Point being:
This professor, who remained a committed leftist, grew to be deeply embarrassed by his sophomoric disdain for Rawls.
Others, even if for good reasons they never come to consider themselves Rawlsians, should too. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Bill Kristol
@BillKristol
News: The Unpopulist of @shikhadalmia links up with Persuasion, run by @Yascha_Mounk, both excellent substacks you should subscribe to.
And perhaps they’ll collaborate on a book: “The Unpopulist Persuasion.” www.theunpopulist.net/p/ron-paul-redux-the-texan-congress… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Once again, my new rule of thumb for public life in America proves right:
Everyone eventually lives up to the worst, most absurd caricature of them.
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
A man who claims he had sex with Barack Obama in 1999 tells his story.
Wednesday. 6pm ET.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The quality of top orchestras is vastly higher today than it was a few decades ago because of the growing supply of musicians who can execute a vast concert repertoire flawlessly.
FischerKing
@FischerKing64
Classical music is dying - you see it by all the grey heads in a concert hall. But it’s not just dying of age/lack of interest. Fewer people transmit the knowledge. Younger people don’t even know it.
Once played students very basic Beethoven/Mozart/Wagner pieces. The effect on some was electric. They didn’t have the language to express themselves or the music, but they hadn’t ever heard anything like this and wanted more.
This music is headed into a sort of dark age, where no one will understand it, only a handful will be able to play it, hardly anyone will compose it. But just to pass it on to kids via concerts and recordings is a sort of service in itself - like monks in the dark ages.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Classical music is no longer part of a canon of high culture that all people of a certain social class must know. And, yes, there are real financial challenges afoot for many orchestras.
But the idea that fewer people can play classical music at a high level is just wrong. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's hard to explain to Americans how much more thoroughly secular even the most religious countries in Western Europe are compared to the United States, both in terms of actual church attendance and in terms of broader social norms.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
My most progressive American friends would be much more shocked by a friend or colleague of theirs having a child out of wedlock than my most conservative European friends.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Relatedly:
Marriage in America is a high-status custom: the more affluent and educated you are, the more likely to be married.
Marriage in France is (kind of) a low-status custom: many of the fanciest people in the country have kids and stable partners but choose not to marry. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Aus aktuellem Anlass: Ein freundlicher Ratschlag an Herrn Merz und die @CDU.
www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2023-08/cdu-strategie-afd…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Der Artikel ist von vor ein paar Wochen.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The real scandal is that we allow politicians to publish things that are obviously ghost-written all the time.
I see why there's a need for elected officials to "say" things they don't have time to write. But there should be a norm for them to acknowledge the real authors.
Roger Severino
@RogerSeverino_
My first assignment as a junior editor at the Harvard Journal on Legislation (1999-2000) was to cite check an article submitted by one Sen. Joseph R. Biden. I was shocked by the plagiarism I discovered. 🧵
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Interestingly, politicians often get in trouble when they go out of their way to pretend they write things themselves.
Germany's Foreign Minister made a huge deal of writing her book on her own. So when it contained plagiarism.. she couldn't acknowledge that it wasn't her fault. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The German Chancellor went jogging, and is looking forward to your memes.
Bundeskanzler a.D. Olaf Scholz
@KanzlerScholz
Wer den Schaden hat…
Bin gespannt auf die Memes. Danke für die guten Wünsche, sieht schlimmer aus, als es ist! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I like Larry Hogan.
I also like Cornel West.
Both of them would be making a terrible mistake by going through with presumptive third party bids in 2024, hugely increasing Donald Trump's chances of taking back the White House.
Governor Larry Hogan
@GovLarryHogan
.@CBSNews: Larry Hogan says he has "not closed the door" to running for president under a No Labels ticket www.cbsnews.com/news/larry-hogan-no-labels-ticket-2024-fa…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This guy must be a great expert on how voters think.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
On a more serious note, it always astounds me how difficult people find it to imagine voters who have a different ideological profile from them.
Yes, there are in fact many traditional Republicans who voted for Biden in 2020 because of Trump but might defect to Hogan in 2024. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Thesis:
By highlighting the very worst wingnuts of every conceivable political or theological persuasion—like this one—social media has encouraged all of us to become overly pessimistic about humanity.
Gary M. Parcel
@parcel_gary
My wife and I removed the labels from all our canned foods. I created a secret code for all of them, so when she needs canned peaches for example, she can come ask me which one it is. This exercise has caused her trust and dependence on me to grow, by leaps and bounds 🙏🏻
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(This particular wingnut thankfully seems to be a parody account!)
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Timur Kuran
@timurkuran
Turkey’s volleyballers, who just won the European Championship by beating Serbia 3-2 in Brussels, are driving crazy the country’s Islamists: bare arms and legs, a lesbian on the squad, and now dancing in public.
Parviz Partokiya
@Partokiya
آهنگ اصلی:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A very plausible scenario for 2024:
Donald Trump wins the GOP nomination and manages to delay his trials.
Joe Biden stays unpopular, then "does a McConnell."
Between them, Cornel West and a No Labels candidate like Joe Manchin win about 5% of the vote.
Trump narrowly wins.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For the record:
"Plausible" means neither "likely" nor "certain."
Some things will definitely go differently. And perhaps Biden actually goes on to win by a clear margin!
But Dems should be doing way more to reduce the significant and scary chance of Trump winning back the WH.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Things Dems can do:
* Biden should not run for reelection
* There should be a real primary
* Dems should pursue working-class voters of all races
* Abandon "faculty lounge politics" (Carville)
Things others can do:
* Pressure West and No Labels not to run in swing states. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
When you’re so “patriotic,” you literally end up celebrating the Soviet Union.
Jackson Hinkle 🇺🇸
@jacksonhinkle
🇷🇺 The New Soviet Man was muscular, selfless, God-fearing, learned and enthusiastic in spreading Communism.
🇺🇸 The American liberal man is fat, atheistic, porn-addicted, transgender, and spreading the work mind virus.
x.com/Abd__Al_Karim/status/1696919707826421949/video/1
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And that’s enough internet for me for the day.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Traditional French food is a lot better than traditional American food.
But the food you can get in any major American city today is a lot better than the food you can get in Paris.
Philippe Lemoine
@phl43
Americans *genuinely* believe they have better food than France. They really believe it. It’s truly extraordinary.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Also, the intensity of responses to that tweet is totally unhinged…)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yup.
Banning Trump from Twitter inadvertently boosted his standing.
Trump rejoining Twitter may inadvertently harm his standing.
AG
@AGHamilton29
Honestly think one of the best things Trump had going for him is no one outside his fan base saw the crazy stuff he posts every day on Truth. We shall see if that behavior translates over to Twitter.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Vivek is everything the French hate about Macron, while also lacking his knowledge or principles.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The unique talent of the people on stage is that, even when they stumble upon a reasonable point, they manage to make it in the dumbest, most simplistic way possible.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The only thing that hasn’t changed on the American right in the last two decades is the predatory ads for investing your savings in gold.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Doug Burgum reminds me of that guy who was applying for a job as an electrician with the BBC and somehow wound up on live TV.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Vivek is the only candidate to say he wouldn’t support Ukraine.
Huge cheers from the audience.
This is what political realignment looks like.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Chris Christie once again winning my grudging respect by passionately making the case against Putin. The audience oscillates between boredom and hostility.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Grudging respect to Chris Christie for going after Trump and defending Pence’s actions on 1/6.
He has no chance of winning and would be a bad a president for all kinds of reasons—but he’s the one person on that stage who’s not running from the fundamental question facing the GOP
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(A few others have defended Pence as well. But Christie is the only who seems to be spoiling for a fight about the issue.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Would you still support Trump if he’s convicted?
Three candidates immediately raise their hands. Then, one by one, (nearly all of) the rest of them do.
Courage in action.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Or “profiles in courage.” Or whatever the right phrase is. Words fail me, at this stage, to be honest.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
My takeaway from the GOP debate: Donald Trump will be the 2024 presidential nominee of the Republican Party.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And I wouldn’t be at all surprised if he picks Vivek as his VP.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Vivek Ramaswamy has so far been astonishingly effective at making himself the center of the debate.
He’s learned a key lesson from Trump’s success in 2016: If you get everyone to attack you, you soak up all the attention—and a big part of the audience will wind up on your side. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Least surprising news of the century.
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Plane carrying Prigozhin crashes, all aboard dead, Tass says — while videos show what seems like the trail of air defense missiles hitting the aircraft. Today is the two-month anniversary of the Wagner uprising. My latest. www.wsj.com/world/russia/plane-carrying-wagner-owner-prig…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One more sign of the cruelty of the man so many abroad strangely admire:
Prigozhin’s murder is unsurprising. Some of his confidantes were presumably equally guilty in the eyes of the Kremlin. But the pilot and the air steward(s) are “collateral damage,” to be killed at will too. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
My new rule of thumb for American politics: Everyone lives up to the worst caricatures of them.
Yoni Appelbaum
@YAppelbaum
Vivek Ramaswamy: "I think it is legitimate to say how many police, how many federal agents, were on the planes that hit the Twin Towers. Maybe the answer is zero. It probably is zero for all I know, right?"
www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2023/08/vivek-ramasw… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
“Meanwhile, the poor Babel fish, by effectively removing all barriers to communication between different races and cultures, has caused more and bloodier wars than anything else in the history of creation.”
- Douglas Adams, Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy.
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
Babel fish is here.
Google Pixel Buds can translate 40 languages right into your ear.
I recommend getting them in yellow -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I know that everyone tries to claim Orwell for themselves, often without good reason, but…
…the idea that Orwell would have agreed that “Eleanor Roosevelt did more damage to the world than Hitler and Stalin combined” is unspeakably absurd.
Lawrence Freedman
@LawDavF
This is a staggering piece of nonsense on a heroic scale from A N Wilson in the Times, quoting Malcolm Muggeridge. Eleanor Roosevelt ‘smug liberalism’ - such as campaigning for civil rights?
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Dr. Arthur Brooks
@arthurbrooks
Can't wait to read this.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🚨🚨
A new set of ideas, often called "woke," has won enormous power over the past decade.
Some have uncritically accepted them. Others have vilified them. Few have critiqued them in a serious manner.
That's what I do in my new book: The Identity Trap. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
David Brooks
@DavidBrooks224
I’ve already read this. It’s superb.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🚨🚨
A new set of ideas, often called "woke," has won enormous power over the past decade.
Some have uncritically accepted them. Others have vilified them. Few have critiqued them in a serious manner.
That's what I do in my new book: The Identity Trap. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
.@andersknospe has been phenomenal. It is rare that a “research assistant” becomes a true thought partner. Anders undoubtedly was. (So you can all blame him for anything that’s wrong with the book…)
If you’re looking for talented young authors for your publication, hit him up!
Anders Knospe
@andersknospe
For the past two years, I’ve been lucky enough to serve as research assistant for @Yascha_Mounk on his upcoming book.
Now, I’m thrilled to say that The Identity Trap is out Sept. 26th.
A quick thread on the book, and my role in it:
🧵
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🚨🚨
A new set of ideas, often called "woke," has won enormous power over the past decade.
Some have uncritically accepted them. Others have vilified them. Few have critiqued them in a serious manner.
That's what I do in my new book: The Identity Trap. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🚨🚨
A new set of ideas, often called "woke," has won enormous power over the past decade.
Some have uncritically accepted them. Others have vilified them. Few have critiqued them in a serious manner.
That's what I do in my new book: The Identity Trap.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Many critiques of "wokeness" are reactionary or simply wrong. But that's no reason to accept these highly influential ideas without serious scrutiny.
In the Identity Trap, I take these ideas seriously; mount a level-headed critique; and offer a better, principled alternative.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If you like my work, please help this book succeed:
* Pre-order it now
* Email your favorite show about the book. (Or, if you are the producer, get in touch.)
* Invite me to speak to your campus, organization, book group
* Retweet this thread
🙏🙏
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/712961/the-identity-trap… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's really striking that colleges which put more emphasis on academic credentials rather than "wholistic admissions," like Chicago and MIT, are much less likely to favor the super-rich.
Wholistic admissions is a scam that pretends to serve noble goals while favoring the elite.
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
“Affirmative action for the v rich” is an elite college phenomenon, but not at every elite college.
Dartmouth, Duke, Penn, and Stanford have truly garish admissions premiums for the 0.1 percent. U-Chicago (notably: where the sports program is meh) doesn’t really have it at all. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
After 2008, public discourse about the economy underwent The Great Disappointment. The new assumption was that things would keep getting worse.
But recent data shows that wages are rising for the poor and the world is getting more equal.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/07/economics-inequ…Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Two graphs show the change in thinking most clearly.
1) Milanovic' original "elephant graph" with data until 2008. It shows few gains for the global poor or the lower middle in rich countries.
2) Milanovic' updated graph with data until 2018. Now, the poor are gaining the most!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
These aren't reasons for complacency.
Recent gains are due to political factors. Future gains depend on political victories.
BUT: Anyone who cares about our economic future should be heartened by the possibility of those victories—and these real gains for billions of people. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It would have been absurd to disinvite Thomas Mann or Marlene Dietrich from public appearances during WWII.
It's no less absurd to banish exiled Russian writers who have publicly opposed Putin’s regime today.
My latest, on Gessen's resignation from PEN.
www.persuasion.community/p/collective-guilt-is-the-most-i…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(I will occasionally post things I write on here but basically continue to be off the platform. It turns out that life is much better without Twitter.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It now seems quite clear that it's only a matter of time until artificial intelligence outperforms humans on skills we once thought of as distinctive to our species, such as composing a beautiful piece of music or writing a moving story.
A major, melancholy milestone in history.
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
🤯🤯Well this is something else.
GPT-4 passes basically every exam. And doesn't just pass...
The Bar Exam: 90%
LSAT: 88%
GRE Quantitative: 80%, Verbal: 99%
Every AP, the SAT...
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Obviously, I didn't mean that the ability to pass some exams = rivaling peaks of human creativity.
But the huge advance in performance from ChatGPT3 to ChatGPT4 does make it seem likely that it's a matter of time until AI rivals human ability in things like storytelling.
Bet?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In the meanwhile, I will happily resume my Twitter hiatus.
Bye for now. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The rioters in Brazil were cosplaying American insurrectionists.
These mob attacks on democratic institutions need to be taken very seriously. But the biggest danger remains that demagogues will return to power via the ballot box.
My latest @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/01/brazil-jair-bol… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Very happy to continue being off-Twitter (as I have been since summer).
But just interrupting my absence to say that I am in awe of the brave Iranian women and men who have won this significant concession from the theocratic regime.
My deepest respect.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Also a public service announcement that I may not see any direct messages you sent me on this platform. You can email me via my website.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
As Orwell observed, political convenience always helps to determine which victims of war crimes are widely commemorated and which widely ignored.
This is a great campaign to, belatedly, remember some victims of Russian aggression to which we should have paid attention all along.
Ani Chkhikvadze
@achkhikvadze
A campaign that deserves your attention. Ukrainian war revived the memory of the atrocities in Abkhazia for many in Georgia. Story of the victims was never told. Please help spread a word. www.gofundme.com/f/Forgotten-Victims-Before-Bucha-Was-Abk…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And with that, I shall resume my Twitter break.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Very much enjoying my break from Twitter. So I'll stay away for a little while longer. Have a great fall!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Also: Slava Ukraini!)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
OK, gonna give this another try.
(Please can we have just a few weeks without terrible breaking news?)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's summer and I'm spending too much time on this website instead of writing or... sitting in the sun.
Bye for now! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It took me a long time to comprehend that the "reading wars" in the United States are about... whether or not students need to actually learn how the English alphabet works.
It's mind-boggling that millions of kids in America have not been taught that.
time.com/6205084/phonics-science-of-reading-teachers/
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Is there any school system in Europe that does not teach people phonics?
I know this is a long-standing debate in the United States. But I've never heard of an equivalent in Europe—not even in Waldorf schools or other places you might expect it.
(May just have missed it?) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
So wishing death upon Salman Rushdie does not violate @Twitter's terms of conditions.
There are two options:
1) Either Twitter must stop its arbitrary regime of censorship. Or:
2) It must be liable for everything published on this platform.
The status quo is intolerable.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To make the policy prescription here explicit:
Protection from Section 230 must be conditional on social media platforms engaging in minimal content moderation which is content neutral.
Otherwise they're just publishers (who happen to have a soft spot for theocratic regimes.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Are you fucking kidding me?
The motive may not yet be proven. But to claim that it is "unclear" is just absurd.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"It's really a mystery what might have happened here. Try as we might, we can't think who could possibly have born any ill will against a writer... whose death would be rewarded with a million-dollar bounty by the theocratic regime that is loudly celebrating the attack on him."
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Again? Really?!
According to police, "an initial investigation suggests Matar has made social media posts in support of Iran and its Revolutionary Guard and in support of Shi’a extremism."
How on earth are his motives unclear? And why are you playing dumb? Have you no shame? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I see that, a day after Salman Rushdie has been brutally attacked, and severely injured, @khamenei_ir is still on Twitter.
Which one is it, @Twitter?
Will you allow freedom of speech for everyone? Or just for the leaders of murderous theocratic regimes?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is the thing about acting line a censor:
Once you start deciding what is too offensive to keep on your platform, you kind of own the stuff you do allow.
So I hope some day y'all will come to be deeply, achingly ashamed of your cowardice and provincialism.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's galling that Twitter doesn't try to apply its standards consistently.
But in truth any platform would fail even if it had the decency to try.
That's precisely why we must not tolerate major venues for public debate being subject to arbitrary and unaccountable censorship. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
So much for the promises (which some people shamefully parroted for partisan reasons) that the Taliban had changed...
To appropriate a fashionable meme, "your belief in the value of freedom is universal or it is bullshit."
www.nytimes.com/2022/08/12/world/asia/afghanistan-taliban… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Finding it really hard to focus on anything while waiting for news on Salman Rushdie's condition.
Please let him pull through this...
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
😭
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I am against censorship on Twitter because I don't see why a bunch of random people in Silicon Valley should decide the boundaries of acceptable speech.
But so long as there is censorship on here, it's doubly disgusting that Twitter allows dangerous bile like this to spread.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is one of the problems with Silicon Valley companies acting as global censors:
If something offends the specific sensibility of young, highly educated Americans, it's likely to get suppressed.
If it is deeply disgusting but does not touch America's culture wars, it stays.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🙄
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
What an awful morning.
Here's to hoping that Salman Rushdie survives.
Here's to hoping that his attacker and his ideological sponsors are swiftly brought to justice.
And here's to hoping that the world shows more courage in the face of this intimidation than it did in 1988. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's summer and I'm spending too much time on this website instead of writing or... sitting in the sun.
Bye for now! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The right-wing coalition in Italy, which is likely to win a majority in elections this September, has just proposed that Italy should switch from a parliamentary to a presidential system.
Have they... not looked at any news about America lately?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The coalition consists of:
* The Brothers of Italy, a postfascist party led by Giorgia Meloni.
* The Lega, a northern independence movement turned nationalist populist led by Matteo Salvini.
* And Forza Italia, the power base for 86 year-old Silvio Berlusconi.
Povera Italia.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(One of the strange things about this proposal is that the right-wing parties likely wouldn't be able to agree about which of their leaders should be president--especially if the presidency would, as per the proposal, have vastly expanded powers.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Following American politics right now feels like watching a car slowly but steadfastly drive off a cliff.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The car might yet stop or swerve. Perhaps it will.
But today, at least, that doesn't feel likely.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For those who are desperate to read something into my tweet that it does not in any way say: No, "both sides" are not equally responsible for the state of America.
But you can think that Trump has it coming to him and also realize that America is in a very dangerous situation. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I ♥️ Italy.
www.nytimes.com/2022/08/09/world/europe/dominos-pizza-ita…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Thing is:
Italy has lots of McDonald's. And I think that's a good thing! Italians are bad at burgers. A BigMac is actually pretty damn good. So this adds to the options Italian diners have.
But just about every damn pizza you get in Italy is a 1000x times better than Domino's. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Deleted a tweet because I had doubts about the authenticity of something I was sharing and, on reflection, decided it wasn't enough to mention that down-thread.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Wasn't doubting the authenticity of the photograph I shared but couldn't be sure that the thing the photograph showed was what it pretended to be.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Update:
"On Tuesday, the police said they had arrested a man who was himself Muslim and who may have targeted at least two of the victims because he was angry that his daughter had married a man from the other major branch of Islam."
www.nytimes.com/2022/08/09/us/albuquerque-muslim-killings…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"The authorities did not elaborate on why they thought the killings may be connected and did not say whether there were any witnesses to the homicides, but they said they believed the Muslim community was being targeted."
This is very worrying.
www.nytimes.com/2022/08/06/us/muslim-men-killings-new-mex… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A few thoughts and principles about the FBI raid in Miami:
1) The rule of law applies to everyone. If Trump committed a crime, he should be punished for it.
2) Prosecutions against possible political candidates always deserve special scrutiny to ensure they are above the board.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
5) One overlooked political risk is Trump getting acquitted, allowing him to claim he was exonerated.
6) We know very little about the FBI's case against Trump so far. Anyone declaring with certainty that it is either appropriate or inappropriate is getting ahead of themselves.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
People.
I am aware that Trump lost in 2020.
But he has a democratic right to run again in 2024. So we will need to beat him at the ballot box again.
Unless he has committed a serious crime. In which case he should go to prison. As I clearly stated.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A few thoughts and principles about the FBI raid in Miami:
1) The rule of law applies to everyone. If Trump committed a crime, he should be punished for it.
2) Prosecutions against possible political candidates always deserve special scrutiny to ensure they are above the board. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
People.
I am aware that Trump lost in 2020.
But he has a democratic right to run again in 2024. So we will need to beat him at the ballot box again.
Unless he has committed a serious crime. In which case he should go to prison. As I clearly stated.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A few thoughts and principles about the FBI raid in Miami:
1) The rule of law applies to everyone. If Trump committed a crime, he should be punished for it.
2) Prosecutions against possible political candidates always deserve special scrutiny to ensure they are above the board.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Never underestimate the ability of people on this platform to willfully misinterpret a Tweet, or to dunk on the second tweet in a thread as though the first one did not exist.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Twitter, do your thing.
Tom Clarke
@tomeclarke
Someone should do a Downfall meme with Trump/Hitler ranting about how the generals aren't like the German generals.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Sigh.
Someone should really watch Downfall.
Jeffrey Goldberg
@JeffreyGoldberg
"The President’s loud complaint to John Kelly one day was typical: 'You fucking generals, why can’t you be like the German generals?'”
'Which generals?' Kelly asked.
'The German generals in World War II,' Trump responded."
From this holy-shit excerpt:
www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/08/15/inside-the-war-betw… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Thanks for the free advertising. Please subscribe to my podcast.
NYTPitchbot
@DougJBalloon
We were listening to Yascha Mounk's "Persuasion" podcast when my four-year-old turned to me gravely and asked "daddy, why are so many professors getting canceled?" When I told him "because of a lack of intellectual diversity at American universities", he started crying.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(We rarely talk about professors getting canceled. But in the last months, we've had great conversations with Peter Singer, Adolph Reed Jr., Anne Applebaum, Jon Haidt, Thomas Piketty, Yevgenia Albats, George Packer, Ram Guha, Noam Chomsky, Fiona Hill, Garry Kasparov, etc.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The amount of animosity that @DrLeanaWen attracts on this website for the crime of being a strong voice for pandemic containment measures when we did not have any vaccines and being a strong advocate for dispensing with them now that we have life-saving vaccines is mind-boggling.
Defiant L’s
@DefiantLs
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I can abide anything other than... people's policy preferences evolving as the circumstances change in a way that does not reliably stay in lockstep with one particular online tribe.🙄
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
That doesn't mean Leana got every call right throughout the pandemic. Of course she didn't. This stuff is genuinely hard. We all know more in retrospect.
But all the incentives today are completely stacked against actually advocating for what you believe even if it's unpopular. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"The authorities did not elaborate on why they thought the killings may be connected and did not say whether there were any witnesses to the homicides, but they said they believed the Muslim community was being targeted."
This is very worrying.
www.nytimes.com/2022/08/06/us/muslim-men-killings-new-mex… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I *love* Italy.
But I once took a flight from Rome to Madrid and, even though I already knew both places pretty well, was just blown away by how much more functional Spain is than Italy.
What Spain has accomplished in the past three decades is very impressive.
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Holy shit
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(I still love Italy more though.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The CDC is repeatedly showing that it is incapable of performing the basic tasks for which it was built over the course of a century.
Anyone interested in state capacity, output legitimacy or... not letting dangerous diseases spread needlessly should push for radical reform.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
There was a big debate about whether the CDC's shocking failures in the early days of Covid were due to Trump's or the agency's incompetence. It was clearly a bit of both.
But the fact that the CDC is making the same kinds of mistakes under Biden shows just how bad things are. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Rawls' overlapping consensus in the age of social media:
When you have always had a very low opinion of someone and everyone suddenly adopts an equally low opinion of that person for completely different reasons which you do not share.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Sorry for this admittedly esoteric joke. At least I amused myself.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Virtually every major public policy debate involves real trade-offs.
One sign of an unthinkingly ideological view is the inability to recognize that such a trade-off exists or to understand why some people might disagree about the best course of action, all things considered.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
You can plausibly think that the best course of action is pretty clear once you've taken all things into account.
But if you can't even understand the nature of the trade-off, or believe that only nefarious motives could possibly motivate the other side, you're an ideologue. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
George Orwell on Amnesty International.
Amnesty International
@amnesty
⚡️ Ukrainian forces have put civilians in harm’s way by establishing bases and operating weapons systems in populated residential areas.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It is astonishing how poor the methodology of papers published in major scientific journals can be as long as there is a strong political demand for the conclusions they license.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I feel like I get what makes Manchin tick. He's a political moderate who hopes to win reelection in a very conservative state. In context his positions are unsurprising.
But Sinema makes little sense to me. Does she think fighting for private equity will get her reelected in AZ?
John Cassidy
@JohnCassidy
No surprise here. Sinema is the go-to Senator for Wall Street/big corporations looking to nix proposals that would hit capital, such as raising the corporate income tax rate and neutering the carried interest deduction.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-03/sinema-seeks-t… via @bpolitics
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Also, the things that Manchin objects to are largely things that people in his state (and, to some extent, American voters as a whole) strongly dislike.
The things that Sinema, a former activist for Ralph Nadar, objects to are.. just things that people on Wall Street don't like? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Amazingly, it kind of seems like Alex Jones is the victim of a conspiracy concocted by his own lawyers?
How's that for irony.
Angelo Carusone
@GoAngelo
Alex Jones lawyers messed up and accidentally sent to lawyers for Sandy Hook families a full copy of everything on Jones’s phone. This then exposed Jones as hiding evidence he should have turned over.
Jones upon learning this: “This is your Perry Mason moment.”
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(I obviously don't mean that his lawyers deliberately shared those messages. But it seems as though the attorney for the other side is strongly insinuating that they did not do anything to make those text messages inadmissible after they screwed up? Or am I missing something?)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Only a political realignment can save America from Trump: "The most direct path out of polarization is for Democrats to occupy the moderate center of American politics and win elections."
@FukuyamaFrancis at @JoinPersuasion.
www.persuasion.community/p/fukuyama-paths-to-depolarization -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Wonderful news. Fingers crossed.
And absolutely shameful that Democrats spent big to support a full-on MAGA candidate over an honorable Congressman who voted for Trump's impeachment.
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
The biggest surprise of the night so far? Pro-impeachment Rep. Peter Meijer's (R) strength in the #mi03 GOP primary. If he maintains this pace in Kent Co., he's got a great chance to hang on.
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
By the way:
If Democrats just wasted a ton of money to boost a failed primary candidate while strengthening Meijer's moderate credentials and turning him into a winning underdog, they seriously undermined their chances of beating him in the general.
It's stupid as well as evil.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Goddamnit.
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
Breaking: John Gibbs (R) lead over Rep. Peter Meijer (R) now up to 1,195 votes (1.8 pts) w/ a big margin in Byron Twp. Gibbs is the strong favorite now. #mi03
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
European countries have adopted sensible rules on abortion through legislation and mobilization.
American politics is depressingly dysfunctional at the moment. But we shouldn't give up hope that America might just manage to emulate what virtually every European country has done. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The views of average voters are a lot more reasonable than political elites in either party tend to assume.
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One more thing, Sohrab.
My parents and grandparents were born in places it'd be easy to dismiss as "silly pieces of geography." So were you.
The least we owe to people like that, even if we can't help them, is to recognize that they're real people with legitimate interests. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If you think we should not help the people of Ukraine, make the argument honestly, in full conscience of their suffering.
Don't obscure the price of your favored policy by hiding the suffering of real people with a dismissive reference to "silly territories."
Sohrab Ahmari 🇺🇸
@SohrabAhmari
You can get as huffy and emotional as you wish. But relative to the potential price of a confrontation between nuclear powers, that's exactly what the Donbas is. And I don't want my loved-ones and neighbors to die for contested territory on Russia's periphery.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Let's by all means have a debate about how (not) to contain the world's most powerful dictatorships.
But to dismiss the aspirations of millions of Ukrainians who are currently fighting for their freedom and independence as "silly pieces of geography" is disgustingly cynical.
Sohrab Ahmari 🇺🇸
@SohrabAhmari
Yes, America’s hawkish uniparty really is gearing up for a two-front, simultaneous confrontation against two nuclear powers over silly pieces of geography — after having wasted two decades and trillions of dollars on failed wars involving goat-herders and various Muslim factions.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One more thing, Sohrab.
My parents and grandparents were born in places it'd be easy to dismiss as "silly pieces of geography." So were you.
The least we owe to people like that, even if we can't help them, is to recognize that they're real people with legitimate interests. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Let's by all means have a debate about how (not) to contain the world's most powerful dictatorships.
But to dismiss the aspirations of millions of Ukrainians who are currently fighting for their freedom and independence as "silly pieces of geography" is disgustingly cynical.
Sohrab Ahmari 🇺🇸
@SohrabAhmari
Yes, America’s hawkish uniparty really is gearing up for a two-front, simultaneous confrontation against two nuclear powers over silly pieces of geography — after having wasted two decades and trillions of dollars on failed wars involving goat-herders and various Muslim factions.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's more difficult for democracies to have a consistent line in foreign policy.
In dictatorships, one person decides what signals to send. In democracies, elected officials can go rogue.
One danger is that dictators often see such actions as coordinated even when they aren't.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
All things considered, the greater difficulty of coordinating foreign policy need not be a disadvantage.
It makes it easier to follow a course of strategic ambiguity, keep open lines of communication with hostile countries and to change strategy.
But the disadvantages are real.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And yes, dictatorships also contain rival faction which are able to signal to the outside to some significant extent. As with everything, the difference between the foreign policy of democracies and dictatorships is nuanced in practice. But the top line difference is important.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Bryan Lowry
@BryanLowry3
Trump endorses “ERIC” without saying whether it’s Greitens or Schmitt. A truly bizarre ending to the battle of Erics.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And because this is Twitter:
I am making a joke about people punting on difficult decisions by endorsing two people at the same time, not insinuating that there is any similarity between these candidates.) -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Eboo Patel
@EbooPatel
In some circles my Muslim kids are more likely to be asked how they’ve been oppressed by Islamophobia rather than how they’ve been inspired by Islam. That’s not how diversity work should operate. I talk about it with @Yascha_Mounk on @JoinPersuasion www.persuasion.community/p/patel
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A simple rule of thumb in politics:
When you're arguing about the definition of words, you're losing.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I genuinely don't know whether the definition of a recession as two quarters of negative growth was generally accepted or "merely" very common.
But the administration should stop quibbling about how people perceive the economy and start emphasizing what they'll do to improve it. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Beerhalls and putsches.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For ten years, I have:
* Written about Orban in many academic articles.
* Discussed him at length in People vs Democracy.
* Reported from Hungary multiple times, including for a BBC Documentary.
* Etc.
But according to Twitter trolls, I only just discovered he's a bad guy 🤣 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Join us tomorrow!
Persuasion
@JoinPersuasion
Join us for our second annual Persuasion Festival, next Sunday, July 31st!
Featuring:
— @MoisesNaim and @albats on global illiberalism
— @coldxman in a live podcast with @Yascha_Mounk
— @NormOrnstein in a conversation on mental health
Full lineup: www.persuasion.community/p/the-persuasion-festival -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Eboo Patel
@EbooPatel
Really enjoyed talking about my book ‘We Need To Build’ with @Yascha_Mounk on his @JoinPersuasion podcast. We discuss why America needs a positive narrative and the central role civil society and interfaith cooperation play in liberal democracy. linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fwww.persuasio…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I do not call people "racist" lightly.
But this speech by Viktor Orban is clearly and openly racist.
The "conservative" intellectuals and Republican politicians who court Orban should be deeply ashamed of themselves.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Source of original screenshot: Official transcript of Orban's speech.
(It's worth reading. Orban remains, as he always has been, one of the most sophisticated representatives of his deeply illiberal ideology.)
miniszterelnok.hu/speech-by-prime-minister-viktor-orban-a…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One more thing:
Americans always say that you can marry someone from a different ethnic group and still be a racist.
I agree.
But there are many people in the world who are so racist that they would never choose a spouse from a different ethnic group.
The difference matters. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
According to PredictIt, the probably of Donald Trump winning in 2024 is higher than the combined probability that Joe Biden or Kamala Harris might win.
And curiously, the same is currently true for Ron DeSantis.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Personally, I think the probabilities for Trump and DeSantis are likely overstated. And the 1/6 committee hearings do seem to have harmed Trump significantly in the Republican primary polls.
But betting markets have a reasonably good record, so they're useful rough indicators.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One sign of the incredible purchase that postmodernism now has in public life, on all sides of the political spectrum: the widespread conviction that you can stop people from caring about bad developments by redefining the terms that describe it.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Everything is very stupid.
Fatima Tlis
@fatimatlis
State-controlled Telegram channels won’t stop bragging about this video. Not sure who is the creator. But wow, just watch it. If the Russians didn’t promote it, I’d think this was a satire. Why do they think this could attract foreigners to move to Russia? “Winter is coming.”
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Disagree. Both of these are recipes for disaster.
A good PhD advisor will a) have substantial comments but b) help students *shape* the overall arch of their dissertation.
Some terrible advisors don't care. Others make it impossible for students to see the wood for the trees.
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
I loved the left kind of supervisor - you learnt much more from them.
The right kind is often lazy (though not always).
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In fact, I'd go so far as to say that the latter is worse.
Students who have a PhD advisor who doesn't care can find help elsewhere.
Students who have a PhD advisor who sends them on one wild goose chase after another are much more likely to despair... and eventually drop out. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
President Barack Obama's summer reading list includes @Yascha_Mounk's The Great Experiment: Why Diverse Democracies Fall Apart and How They Can Endure.
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
I’ve read a couple of great books this year and wanted to share some of my favorites so far. What have you been reading this summer?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is ridiculous on so many levels.
It's nasty. It's straightforwardly libelous.
But what's most striking to me: A worldview that cannot tell the difference between the politics of an Alex Jones and of a @thomaschattwill is just absurdly, ridiculously warped.
Thomas Chatterton Williams
@thomaschattwill
This article is insane and just a lie. @gawker has been harassing me for months now and I just ignore it because it’s not real journalism, but this has to be retracted. I never heard of this movie until now and wasn’t anywhere near Austin at the premiere. www.gawker.com/media/thomas-chatterton-williams-pals-with…
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
MLM
@mathieulefevre_
Fantastic and so well deserved @Yascha_Mounk
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Barack Obama is the American politician I most admire.
So I'm, well, giddy with excitement to learn that he has read and enjoyed The Great Experiment (and decided to include it in his summer reading list)!
Rarely at a loss for words but...
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
I’ve read a couple of great books this year and wanted to share some of my favorites so far. What have you been reading this summer?
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Barack Obama is the American politician I most admire.
So I'm, well, giddy with excitement to learn that he has read and enjoyed The Great Experiment (and decided to include it in his summer reading list)!
Rarely at a loss for words but...
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
I’ve read a couple of great books this year and wanted to share some of my favorites so far. What have you been reading this summer?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Who are the most important living thinkers, scholars and intellectuals over the age of 60?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Join us online for the Persuasion Festival this Sunday!
Hear from great thinkers including @MoisesNaim, @albats, @coldxman, @NormOrnstein, @noUpside and others about all (ok, many of) the things that matter in the world today.
Persuasion
@JoinPersuasion
Join us for our second annual Persuasion Festival, next Sunday, July 31st!
Featuring:
— @MoisesNaim and @albats on global illiberalism
— @coldxman in a live podcast with @Yascha_Mounk
— @NormOrnstein in a conversation on mental health
Full lineup: www.persuasion.community/p/the-persuasion-festival -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Jakubonis “did not know who the speaker was or that the speaker was a political person."
I have no patience for those who minimize violent attacks on politicians they dislike.
But *if* his claims are true, Jakubonis is one heck of an unlucky guy.
www.nbcnewyork.com/news/politics/lee-zeldin-attacker-did-…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Mom: "You attacked someone last night."
Hungover dude: "How bad was it?"
Mom: "He wasn't that hurt."
Hungover dude: "Phew. Nothing to worry about then."
Mom: "Well, you attacked him at a rally. He was running for Governor. And the Feds are at the door."
Worst hangover ever. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
As an undergrad, I mostly studied the history of political thought.
The main thing this taught me is that it's a mistake to dismiss people whose views you dislike as stupid or evil.
That applies to reading, say, Hobbes. It also applies to understanding your political adversary.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And no, this obviously doesn't mean that every person is smart or well-intentioned. Yes, the world contains many idiots and assholes.
But if you think that nearly everyone who disagrees with your is an evil idiot, that says more about you than it does about them. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The second most difficult thing about being a writer is sitting down to write.
The most difficult is transitioning from one (part of a) project to another. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The idea that people in today's America have less access to countervailing viewpoints than did people in Soviet Russia is so wrong that it is, simply, beneath contempt.
SizweLo
@SizweLo
Chomsky: The US is living under a totalitarian culture much worse than Soviet Union
Soviet Russia could access BBC, Voice of America, German TV
Today Americans are not permitted to hear what Russians are saying
The US has imposed constraints on access to info beyond Soviets -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Orwell on Ukraine:
"Pacifist propaganda usually boils down to saying one side is as bad as the other. But if one looks closely at the writings of pacifists one finds they do not express impartial disapproval but are directed almost entirely against Britain and the United States"
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
From one of Orwell's most under-appreciated essays, "Notes on Nationalism."
Written in the context of Wold War II, not Ukraine (obviously), the whole passage on pacifism remains incredibly prescient today. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is why attempts to police public debate in the name of "science" can so quickly go off the rails.
Science is amazing. But the whole point of science is to recognize that no theory is ever beyond suspicion, and that we make progress by superseding what we thought we knew.
Christopher Lane Author
@christophlane
“No evidence” depression caused by low serotonin — an exhaustive new review debunks the “chemical imbalance” theory. Again.
My article on the findings, backstory, and major implications @PsychToday
#psychiatry #medtwitter #depression #ssris
www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/side-effects/202207/decis… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Increasingly convinced that the odd category of "people of color" fries the brains of American writers.
In South Africa, a majority of the population suffered apartheid.
Most "people of color" in America didn't.
The two countries won't be "majority minority" in similar ways.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The two cases would have been *somewhat* similar if most Americans in the 1960s had been black, and gone from living in the segregated south to having full voting rights.
To imagine that the two situations are similar because we call Asians and Hispanics "PoC" is just... wrong.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's also one of many ways in which the supposedly enlightened reference to "people of color" and a "majority minority future" is fueling the very kind of racial panic it pretends to abhor.
www.persuasion.community/p/yascha-mounk-america-wont-ever… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's hard to overstate the distance between the perception of the country by Democratic comms consultants and its reality.
Hispanics are more worried about *election laws* than they are about immigration.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Perhaps it's time for Democratic strategists to internalize that most Hispanics have... um, been in America a very long time and are in fact pretty... um, American?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Many journalists have deeply internalized some weird combination of Gramsci and Foucault: They believe that how they describe the world has an enormous impact.
But thankfully, what people believe mostly does not depend on what the NYT or WaPo write.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/17/media-bias-rol…Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(I don't mean to beat up on this article's author, who's more thoughtful about these things than most.
But I do think a lot of misguided assumptions in politics come from elites thinking that their choice of words has a much bigger causal impact than it does.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is partially a result of projection, I think:
What the New York Times says really does have a hug impact on what people in a small elite circle believe.
So members of that circle naturally assume that other people are at least a little bit like them. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In January of 2021, I warned that a 50-50 Senate would barely allow Democrats to get anything done.
There is nothing surprising about the gridlock we've experienced in the past 18 months.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/01/problem-50-50-s…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's sort of amazing to me how wishful thinking has driven both media coverage and a lot of the White House's tactical decisions during all this time.
-
Yascha Mounk reposted
Sergei Guriev
@sguriev
In our conversation with @Yascha_Mounk , we discuss Russia’s economy, sanctions and how to fight back against spin dictators (and other authoritarian leaders)
Spin Dictators www.persuasion.community/p/guriev?s=r -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Terrorist fist bumps have come a long way since 2008.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And because Twitter is Twitter and people will try to take anything out of context: the tweet is a reference to this ridiculous controversy from the before times.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
On an even more random note:
Has anyone else noticed that Trump seems to have effectively killed the term "gaffe"?
Journalists used to describe every stupid, impolitic, or offensive statement as a gaffe. Now the term has sort of disappeared? -
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“Given the headwinds that any Democrat is likely to face in 2024, and the danger that awaits the country if Trump should prevail,” writes @Yascha_Mounk, “a primary process that determines who can actually win is more vital than ever”: on.theatln.tc/VcHU7AS
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I'm used to people being mad at me on the internet but I'm not used to people being mad at me on the internet because they have somehow concluded that I have a secret agenda to install Bernie Sanders as the 2024 presidential nominee of the Democratic Party. 🤣
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Spoiler alert: I don't.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Trump is a big danger to democracy. And yet, he has a good chance of winning reelection.
What can Dems do to beat Trump in 2024?
@TheAtlantic, I propose a two-part plan:
1) Biden should bow out of contention.
2) Dems must hold a *real* primary contest.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/07/democrats-prima…Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Voters Are Better At Picking Winners than Pundits and Party Grandees
Given the stakes in 2024, a primary that determines who can actually win is more vital than ever.
And from Clinton to Obama to Biden, voters have proved better at that task than pundits or party grandees.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
As ever, please read the whole article and share it with your friends!
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/07/democrats-prima… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In the past months, I've had @anneapplebaum, Noam Chomsky, @PikettyLeMonde, @DMiliband, @albats, @Ram_Guha, Fiona Hill, @Kasparov63, Peter Singer, @JohnHMcWhorter, @FukuyamaFrancis and many others on The Good Fight.
Who should I have on my podcast in the next months?
Ideas👇🙏
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And if you'd like to listen to me talk to any of these great folks, please do subscribe!)
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-good-fight/id1198765424
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Thanks for all these great suggestions! Watch this space...
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For all our many and important differences, human nature is universal. And that is why we should celebrate, not criticize, respectful ways to appropriate the culture of others for ourselves.
I know this view has become oddly controversial. But it's a hill I'm willing to die on.
Historicus Hasidicus
@hasidicus
“L’chaim—To Life” from a Japanese performance of Fiddler on the Roof.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Just overheard a clerk at a book store with a very progressive vibe telling a customer that Michelle Alexander's New Jim Crow is on the "do not reorder" list because it "contains misinformation about Jim Crow"
Have progressives turned on Alexander? Or is this just idiosyncratic?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If that's what this is, I must say I'm equal parts entertained and horrified by the idea of a small-town bookstore owner just decreeing that Alexander is insufficiently progressive for some idiosyncratic reason and banning employees from selling her books?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Britain's Conservative Party has many serious failings.
But it is also an excellent example of how right-wing parties can build governing majorities by diversifying their ranks and appealing to a broad cross-section of the population.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(It is also a seriously under-told story, most likely because it doesn't cleanly fit either side's narrative.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
According to a new report by @MoreInCommon:
* 77% of black Americans say their American identity is important to them.
* The same is only true among 35% of the most progressive Americans.
If the left wants to win, it needs to embrace an inclusive patriotism.
Happy 4th of July!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's sort of amazing how much more divided Americans are by ideology than they are by race on this question (and many other important ones).
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Source:
www.moreincommon.com/media/dtffhla2/2022-4thofjuly-report… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
David French
@DavidAFrench
A dire diagnosis, but fundamentally correct. Each party has to reform itself, often against the wishes of its most zealous members.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Trump is an acute threat to democracy.
Biden and Harris, the most likely 2024 Democratic nominees, are deeply unpopular.
And no one seems to have a plan to turn things around.
Things can always change. But right now, America is headed for disaster.
🧵
www.persuasion.community/p/mounk-america-is-headed-for-di… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Incisive and urgent analysis by @Yascha_Mounk on our current danger. www.persuasion.community/p/mounk-america-is-headed-for-di…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Trump is an acute threat to democracy.
Biden and Harris, the most likely 2024 Democratic nominees, are deeply unpopular.
And no one seems to have a plan to turn things around.
Things can always change. But right now, America is headed for disaster.
🧵
www.persuasion.community/p/mounk-america-is-headed-for-di…Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
1) Trump is a danger to democracy
I thought Trump had lost his ability to shock me. But the revelations of the past weeks have shaken me.
Trump cheered on a physical assault on the Capitol. Allegedly, he even tried to lead it in the flesh.
There are no limits to what he’ll do.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
2)A Second Trump Term Would Be Even More Dangerous.
In 2016, Trump lacked the experience, team and vision to wield power effectively.
In 2024, he'd have experience running the country, lead a loyal team, and be much more focused on undermining checks on his power from Day 1.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Perhaps you disagree with this plan. That’s great. Please suggest your own!
But one thing is certain: When the room is on fire, the worst possible course of action is to keep sitting in your chair and proclaim that “this is fine.”
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
That's it from me.
Please read the whole article.
And while you're at it, please subscribe to @JoinPersuasion.
www.persuasion.community/p/mounk-america-is-headed-for-di… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
About to take a trip to promote the Italian edition of The Great Experiment and attend a few conferences.
Really looking forward to it and... suddenly realized I don't want to worry about The Discourse while doing so.
So I'm taking a little Twitter hiatus. See ya sometime! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Whenever you think that something is just too dumb and obvious for it to happen, it does. Every damn time.
I really wish we weren't living in a bizarro simulation run by some guy who graduated bottom of his screenwriting class.
Rolling Stone
@RollingStone
Herschel Walker admits to having two more secret children. rol.st/3tGMl5L
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I mean, I don't exactly have high moral expectations of the MAGA-crowd.
But don't y'all want to be something more than one-dimensional villains straight out of a caricature dreamed up by your worst enemies?
Have some self-respect, damnit! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Of all the weird pieces of online orthodoxy, I genuinely find this one the most disheartening.
How can you respond to the majority of college students reporting that they self-censor by saying: "Ah well, everyone self-censors all the time anyway!"
How low can our ambition fall?
Ben Stephens
@stephens_ben
'More than eight out of ten [students] reported self-censoring at least some of the time.'
You know who else self-censors at least some of the time? Everyone.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The only thing that can explain this attitude is deep disdain for the vast majority of people.
"People self-censor? Good thing! They're probably bigots anyway."
80% of the nation's highly diverse college population self-censor?
"There must be something wrong with all of 'em!"
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Anyway, please read the article.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/06/campus-free-spe… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Most students fear speaking their minds about sensitive issues. But most students also long for opportunities to make sense of the world together.
Here's how universities can listen to their students and combat the chill on campus.
My latest @TheAtlantic.www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/06/campus-free-spe…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Before you rage-tweet, a brief response to the most common objections.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And, no, obviously not every student needs or wants to have big debates on sensitive issues such as politics and religion.
But it's perverse to dismiss the many students who are keen to discuss the world yet fear that doing so might lead to being shunned by their classmates. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"For most Hispanics, present-time has more value than future-time... Therefore, it would be more appropriate to expect Hispanic employees and students to concentrate on short-term goals."
Racist screed?
Nope, training material from a Diversity, Equity and Inclusion seminar.
😠 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The sad truth is that a) they don't realize, b) they don't care, and c) the they don't realize in good part because they don't care.
Radek Sikorski
@radeksikorski
I wonder if France and Germany realise how much credibility they are losing in Central Europe with their policy on Ukraine.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Demography Is Not Destiny.
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
I've seen enough: Mayra Flores (R) defeats Dan Sanchez (D) in the #tx34 special election, flipping an 84% Hispanic Rio Grande Valley seat red.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A good sign.
(From an interview the incoming executive editor of the New York Times, Joe Kahn, just gave the Washington Post.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I have limited hope that the top brass is going to be able to change this dynamic; but it's heartening that they at least recognize the nature of the problem.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A can of coke from a newsstand in New York City may be the most inflation-resistant consumer item in the world.
So far as I can recall, it was $1 when I first visited the city as a teenager, and it is still $1 now.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In fact, the price is so sticky and universal that you can simply assume it to be correct.
Most newsstands don't display the price anywhere, and I'm sure some of them must ask tourists for $1.50 or even $2.
But if you take a can and proffer $1, it will always be accepted. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Local Area Man Always Agrees with Peers on Everything, Convinced He Would Have Been the One Guy to Stand Up to All Past Injustice.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
There is still a very special pleasure to holding the paper version of an enthusiastic review of your book in the New York Times in your hands...
Not a bad start to my 40s.
(If you haven't yet, please do order and read The Great Experiment!)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And here's the link to the review.
www.nytimes.com/2022/05/13/books/review/francis-fukuyama-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Some people have been saying that we need to make sure Russia does well enough, so Putin can save face.
Well, Russia is now conquering significant parts of Ukraine. You got your wish. Congratulations.
Would you kindly let us in on the next step of your cunning plan?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Or... were you just running interference for Putin?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
3 things I'm thankful for on my birthday:
1) My friends.
2) Choosing to write for part of the day because I love what I do.
3) Having enough financial stability and sufficiently low material desires that I don't know what to tell family members who want to buy me a present.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's my 40th birthday.
To paraphrase Tom Lehrer, it's a sobering thought that, when Mozart was my age, he had been dead for five years. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
About the hearings:
1) They are important whether or not they will change minds.
2) As I've been saying for years, persuading Trump's super fans should never be the goal.
3) The hearings may somewhat raise the salience of concerns that most Americans have about Trump. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's my 40th birthday.
To paraphrase Tom Lehrer, it's a sobering thought that, when Mozart was my age, he had been dead for five years. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One of the surprising and little-known ways in which America is more left-wing than Europe is in how progressive its tax system is.
People at the lower end of the income scale pay WAY more tax in Europe than in the United States.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Annotations:
1) Taxation is decided by individual European states. But this is true in the large majority of European countries.
2) It's not just that people pay more tax overall. The ratio of how much tax someone in 20th percentile pays compared to 80th percentile is higher. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
January 6th was a huge deal. But not quite for the reason many think.
It's unsurprising that a few thousand lunatics were willing to storm the Capitol. But it's deeply scary that Donald Trump failed to recognize his defeat and the Republican Party is still lined up behind him.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A corollary of this:
The most worrying thing about 2024 is not the prospect of political riots (though those may happen).
It's the prospect of a state like Arizona sending the wrong slate of electors to the electoral college and us ending up in a genuine constitutional crisis. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To be fair, Penn Station is the closest that New York, a city I love deeply, comes to being hell.
But... it's just so weird for politicians to casually refer to their own cities, states or countries in derogatory terms.
Most people like the place they're from!
Jimmy Vielkind
@JimmyVielkind
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) and other officials are announcing they'll solicit proposals from architectural firms to renovate Penn Station.
Hochul says there will be skylights, to remind people that "the heavens are out there, still, even if you may be living in hell.”
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
To be amply clear (because Twitter) it's perfectly fine to criticize your own country, even in strong terms! Only lunatics and extremists are blind to the fact that their own country can do wrong.
But this kind of performative self-loathing is... icky and deeply out of touch. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
One of the weird stories of the past decade is how much a dissolution of basic norms of decency has allowed a minority of narcissists to sow nasty personal conflict in thousands of institutions around the country.
We hear about this with famous institutions. But it's everywhere.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I personally feel like this:
In the past, I could not imagine colleagues or institutions randomly turning on me.
Now, I feel that I am perennially one poorly worded tweet or hastily written email or misreported remark away from public drama and social ostracism.
It ain't fun.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I have it comparatively easy: I have a PhD. I speak fluent English. My job is to think about politics.
Imagine what this must feel like for someone who doesn't get elite discourse, has imperfect English, and isn't very political.
The fear of inadvertent blunder is way bigger. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's time for Democrats to "mobilize the base"... by abandoning the far-left policies which, according to the party's most prominent strategists and politicians, were supposed to mobilize the party's base.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This tweet is consciously ambiguous between two different meanings of base: ethnic and ideological.
But that's the sleight of hand which progressives have been playing: They pretended getting non-white voters (ethnic base) to vote required far left policies (ideological base). -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Misleading your readers about whether you have done your basic journalistic due diligence is a much worse offense than retweeting a stupid joke.
A newspaper that doesn't recognize this will very rapidly lose any remaining credibility it enjoys.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
So shouldn't I just ignore this stuff?
I'd love to. Believe me.
But the problem is: Pushing back against these forms of insanity is necessary if we are to stop key American institutions from self-immolating or, for that matter, prevent Donald Trump from being reelected in 2024.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For some reason just pictured Marty Baron lying on a Caribbean beach, sipping a mojito, catching up on the news at his old paper, muttering, to no one in particular, "Thank God I got out," then taking the best nap of his life.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is hilarious.
The New York Post ran an article slamming Foreign Policy for some sponsored content that is morally dubious but... explained the nature of the magazine by mentioning three authors who actually write for Foreign Affairs.
nypost.com/2022/06/05/foreign-policy-magazine-pushes-anal…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Zakaria, Haass and I have all written for Foreign Policy on occasion. But all of us write more frequently for Foreign Affairs. Zakaria has a column at the Washington Post. I am a contributing write at The Atlantic.
Just an all around bizarre way to characterize Foreign Policy. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Societies need rules to function.
And if some people are above reproach, those rules gradually unravel. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I knew that the famous Skokie case was about a planned neo-Nazi protest in a heavily Jewish community.
I knew that the ACLU lawyer who argued for the right of neo-Nazis to protest was Jewish.
I did not know that the leader of that neo-Nazi group was... also Jewish.
🤯 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If this is true, it's an outrageous infringement on freedom of speech.
The officers who issued this threat should at minimum be fired and, if possible, be held criminally liable.
(Not a legal expert so not sure whether there is an appropriate statute... but there should be.)
Brendan Keefe - ANF & InvestigateTV
@BrendanKeefe
The hero mom also says law enforcement warned her against telling her story publicly with a threat of jail time for violating her probation. Speaking to the media is ‘obstruction of justice’ they said. A judge shortened her probation instead, because of her heroic actions.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If you accuse your editor of introducing falsehoods into a story, you better be damn sure they see it the same way.
No one likes to be publicly thrown under the bus, especially when they're not at fault. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The holy trinity of coffee shop amenities: wifi, power outlets, and a bathroom.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
What are the top things universities could do to encourage a culture of free debate and inquiry, not just in the classroom but also in dorms and dining halls?
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For those who say this is a fake concern:
Are two thirds of college students so brainwashed that they completely mischaracterize their own experience?
Or are two thirds of college students so bigoted that we should ignore their concerns because they're all just secret racists?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Also, one of the beauties of not having Twitter on your phone is that you can completely ignore being ratio'ed over, say, asking a straightforward question.
I had not opened Twitter since yesterday and was blissfully unaware of everyone freaking out over this.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The conversation about John Fetterman on here is unseemly.
It's not just that many seem to be reveling in his health problems; it's also that they don't much matter for the office he's running for. Perfect health is much more important for a Governor or President than a Senator.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Obviously, you want people who hold significant power to be in good health.
But there are just way fewer plausible scenarios in which terrible consequences follow from a Senator who is incapable of doing their job for a few weeks or months than would be the case for a President. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If an institution's leaders are so scared of their employees that they won't enforce basic standards, its reputation will suffer.
Even so, their incentive is to do nothing. Reputational damage accrues gradually. But if they anger their employees, they might be gone tomorrow.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This discrepancy between the long-term interests of institutions and the short-term interests of the people who are in charge of them explains a decent chunk of what is wrong with American life today.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is, of course, just a new version of the principal-agent problem.
I wish that some economists would build on the copious research that has been done on this in the context of executives and shareholders to examine this phenomenon and suggest some solutions. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Hassan I. Hassan
@hxhassan
“I like to say that I’m a democracy hipster. I was worried about the stability of our democratic systems before it was cool.” @Yascha_Mounk joins @FaisalAlYafai for this @newlinesmag podcast on how to save America’s diverse democracy. newlinesmag.com/podcast/americas-great-experiment-with-ya… new podcast
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The media freakout about this is as bizarre as it is unsurprising.
But it is actually a very good thing for the country if both Republicans and Democrats genuinely try to earn the votes of Americans drawn from every ethnic group.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
You can simultaneously think that a) anything which makes Trump more likely to win the 2024 election is concerning and that b) we should be hoping for the American electorate to depolarize in ethnic terms as, surprisingly, it has been for the past few years.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The New York Times
@nytimes
People who drank moderate amounts of coffee, 1.5 to 3.5 cups per day, were up to 30% less likely to die during a multiple year study period than those who didn’t drink coffee, new research found. www.nytimes.com/2022/06/01/well/eat/coffee-study-lower-dy…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"How can you love a particular country when all nations suffer from serious injustices?
When someone says that they love their country, they don’t mean that there is nothing wrong with it. They are simply expressing a special affection for what is theirs."
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For the consideration of my British friends once again debating the merits of patriotism today.
(From Ch. 5 of The Great Experiment.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
No caricature they can't live up to. No calumny they can't exceed.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's amazing just how unimaginative, tawdry and... small it all is.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I would rather be ruled by the first hundred people in the Cambridge telephone book than by the assembled punditocracy.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For the last decade, Damon Linker may have been the most undervalued columnist in the country: always sharp, always interesting, always fair-minded,
I'm excited about his new Substack and you should be too.
Damon Linker
@DamonLinker
THREAD:
Yesterday was my last day at The Week—and today I have two exciting announcements. First, I’m going to Substack! Unlike those who have made the move after one kind of mainstream-media cancellation or another, I’m doing so to put my “Eyes on the Right” full time. 1/10 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Of all the different nationalities, religions and professional groups that have been tested in the literature, the people most likely to defect in a prisoners dilemma are... economics graduate students.
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
In one-shot prisoners dilemmas, more than half of people cooperate rather than defect www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5472703/
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(At least that's what Richard Tuck told me in graduate school many years ago.)
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Reminds me of an office hour conversation I once overheard.
Philosopher: What's your intuition in this case?
Student: I don't really have an intuition?
P: Well, in this case, our intuition is X... Now, what about that case?
S: I don't know.
P: Well, here, our intuition is... -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
About to talk about The Great Experiment at @hayfestival.
You can tune in at the link below!
www.hayfestival.com/p-19138-yascha-mounk-talks-to-stephan… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Just gonna note that there's a marked difference in the quality of toilet paper between American and European universities.
It makes sense to have public financing of higher ed. But you just can't expect the average taxpayer to foot the bill for a four-year all-in luxury resort.
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
If we made colleges tuition-free with full public subsidy, that would generate pressure to make them spare and utilitarian (like high schools or community colleges) — every academic department would need to constantly justify its budget to state legislators.
Might be good?Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A simple legislative idea which would utterly transform America's higher education landscape, mostly for the better:
Colleges shouldn't be allowed to "bundle" their core educational offering with gym membership, residential requirements, the services of a bloated admin, etc.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Technically, private institutions should be allowed to do so. But all private or public colleges that do should lose eligibility for federal funding. Which is enough to ensure very far-reaching compliance.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A lot of people have been asking: "Why does the media care more about Ukraine than Syria?"
It's a fair question. But I always feared that people stopped caring about Syria after months of war and would eventually stop caring about Ukraine, too.
That now seems to be happening. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
When Jeremy Corbyn was the leader of the Labour Party, Diane Abbott was Shadow Home Secretary.
So this isn't some off-the-cuff remark about a topic she's never thought about; it's her considered political conviction.
Which says a lot about the world view of the Corbynite left..
Diane Abbott
@HackneyAbbott
Government boast it is opening up visas to the world’s top graduates. But many originally come from third world countries. Why is Britain asset stripping poor countries like this?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The writer's life:
Sometimes you toil away for weeks and have very little to show for it.
Sometimes you spend an afternoon in flow and write 3,000 words.
Today was one of the good days. I'm off to drink some beer with friends. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Imagine all the "Musk Preparing to Run for President" hot takes we'd be enduring right now if he had been born in the United States.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Fascinating.
I heard French friends talk about "bobos" long before I knew anything about David Brooks. So I always assumed that Brooks borrowed the term from the French.
But no, it appears that "bobo," which is used very commonly in France, really does originate with Brooks.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Also, reading Bobos in Paradise for the first time, which everyone always says is really good, and... so far it turns out to be really good?
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Since the day Donald Trump first rant for office, there have been pipe dreams about using some clever mechanism to neutralize the danger he poses (unfaithful electors, FBI probe, Muller report, etc).
But to rid ourselves of Trump, we have to keep beating him at the ballot books.
Tristan Snell
@TristanSnell
BREAKING: Federal Appeals Court rules against Madison Cawthorn, holds that 14th Amendment can be used to disqualify insurrectionists from office.
Bad news for Marjorie Taylor Greene, Lauren Boebert, Paul Gosar, Mo Brooks — and Donald Trump.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Box. The ballot box.
Give me that edit button, Elon.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Also, yes, I very much wish that "rant for office" had been a deliberate pun but, no, it was just yet another typo. 🤣
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The only thought I have about the supposed rivalry between the Brooklyn and the Manhattan factions of New York's "hip" young lit world: Gratitude that I'm too old to be part of either.
www.newstatesman.com/ideas/2022/05/new-yorks-hipster-warsPost not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The most memorable thing about these parties:
I'd be there for six hours. I'd go home. And I wouldn't remember A SINGLE CONVERSATION.
You'd think they'd be full of cringe intellectualizing. But they're just... small talk and petty jealousy.
And no, there was never any dancing.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Would love to run a sociological experiment:
Take some professional "set." Pick random dyads of two members. Ask them how they feel about each other. Derive an index of "network warmth."
I'd bet that, of any set I've ever been a part, the hip lit world would score the lowest. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A universal truth: It's easy to criticize, and hard to build.
(And when the stakes are as high as they are in politics, you better be really sure you know how to build something new before you tear down what now exists.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Has America always been this nuts?
Yes, yes, it's always been this nuts.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(I know this isn't exactly an obscure deep dive into some arcane piece of American history. And I'd read all about it before. But randomly came across this again just now and THEY KIDNAPPED THE WIFE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO STOP HER FROM TALKING TO THE PRESS? How nuts is that?)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Some events are so horrific that you can't grasp their nature by thinking about them, as would be the case if you tried to understand the sun by staring straight at it.
It's only when you ponder a lesser horror at the event's periphery that you start to feel its full magnitude.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Source for the quote:
Megan Greenwell
@megreenwell
The agony of these pediatricians waiting for a mass casualty event that never arrived because an AR-15 doesn’t leave survivors. My god. www.newyorker.com/science/annals-of-medicine/waiting-at-a…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Democrats should avoid becoming the party of college-educated voters because most voters are not college-educated.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Not the only or even the most important reason but one it's hard to argue with for anyone who wants to actually, you know, win elections and have a chance to do good for the country.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"The takeaway from Uvalde shouldn’t be that next time we just need perfect cops... The only way to actually protect kids is to make it harder for their peers to get the deadly weapons that have allowed so many shooters to evade so many safety procedures."
www.thebulwark.com/in-uvalde-the-most-enraging-press-conf…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The point I was making in this tweet wasn't that you shouldn't be angry at the cops in Uvalde; by all means, be very angry.
It's that, as @Timodc puts it so well, the solution cannot be that every small town PD reliably avoids catastrophic failure.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A lot of people are mad about a small town police department bungling its response to a horrific mass shooting.
But the real problem is that the safety of young children should not depend on a small town police department knowing exactly how to respond to a mass shooting. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🤔
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Source: www.economist.com/the-americas/2022/05/26/a-divided-colom…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Two ways of thinking about a Twitter feed:
1) Express (all) your main views and sentiments.
2) Offer followers new or surprising views or insights.
I try to aim for 2). And that means I often don't tweet things I feel strongly about because everyone else is already doing so.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This seems related to, but is different from, being contrarian.
I don't wake up trying to think of contrarian takes. I just don't see the value of tweeting something if I don't feel I have any new insight to add (though I do, of course, at times fall short of that standard.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A lot of people are mad about a small town police department bungling its response to a horrific mass shooting.
But the real problem is that the safety of young children should not depend on a small town police department knowing exactly how to respond to a mass shooting. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Just had a call with a friend in Europe.
I often play "America interpreter." Some things that seem puzzling about America actually make sense. Others, while bad, are closely bound up with what's good.
But when it comes to school shootings, my skills as an interpreter fail me... -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Reminds me of the time I saw a comedian make fun of a stern audience member with the amazing line: "You look like you have to get up early tomorrow morning to go rename a public school."
San Francisco Chronicle
@sfchronicle
The word “chief” will no longer be used in reference to job titles in the San Francisco Unified School District in an effort, school officials said, to avoid the word’s connotation with Native Americans. A replacement term has not been determined.
www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/SFUSD-drops-the-word-chief…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I believe it was the one-of-a-kind Dave @Attell.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Judging by the state of my inbox, the pandemic did not, despite the assurances of many pundits, end the era of in-person conferences.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Whoever wrote this headline deserves a raise.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Nearly as good as this famous beauty.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It hardly seems like the most important thing tonight, but Brian Kemp's thumping victory over David Perdue in the Georgia primaries is a small sign of hope that the most extreme voices don't necessarily win out in the Republican Party every single time.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Even more encouragingly, Brad Raffensperger, who was probably the single most courageous Republican official in November 2020, and did a lot to foil Trump's attempt to steal the election, is doing very well, and may even avoid a run-off against Trump-picked Jody Hice.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
America somehow manages to be, all at once, the world's most powerful country, its most dynamic economy, its scientific powerhouse, a deeply polarized society whose members increasingly loath each other, and a fraying republic with extremely dysfunctional political institutions.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And, no, for the millionth time, to recognize that America is now perilously polarized, and that this is part of what makes it so hard to strike common sense compromises on the most basic issues of public policy, does not entail believing that "both sides" are equally to blame.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I love the U.S. Constitution.
But many countries manage to guarantee fundamental rights to their citizens without turning debates in countless important areas of public policy into a winner-take-all fight which is adjudicated by unelected judges and makes compromise impossible.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(Yes, this is a subtweet regarding multiple depressing, infuriating and heartbreaking news events in the past weeks.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Fascinating when people's psychological predisposition for paranoia gets them accolades because it happens to be fashionable right until the moment when the paranoia goes a little too far, or ceases to be fashionable, and they are suddenly seen as the crank they always were.
Jason S. Campbell
@JasonSCampbell
On YouTube, Naomi Wolf says that the WHO will occupy the U.S. next week, and that could trigger a civil war
www.mediamatters.org/charlie-kirk/youtube-naomi-wolf-says…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Also, as someone who clearly doesn't spend enough time on YouTube or TikTok, how does this "I just happen to be sitting in a car sharing my thoughts about the world" shtick work?
Do you hire someone to drive you around while you "spontaneously" record these videos? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Peak 2022.
More Butter 🧈
@morebuttertv
Seth Green’s Bored Ape NFT, which was set to star in its own animated show, was stolen through a phishing scam.
Green no longer owns the commercial rights to the NFT and thus the show cannot move forward.
🔗: www.buzzfeednews.com/article/sarahemerson/seth-green-bore…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Doesn't seem like the world missed much.
FFV
@FF_V12
.@SethGreen new trailer for his new show, keep your eyes peeled👀
@BoredApeYC @GutterCatGang @veefriendsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Very late to this particular round of Bill Maher discourse and just starting to what That Video.
But... I can't possibly be the first one to notice that two times 41.6% is not in fact 82.2%? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Learned so much about how the idea of race has transmuted over the past century—and why anyone who opposes racism should be deeply skeptical about the ways we now casually use the idea of race—from this conversation with the great Adolph Reed, Jr.
www.persuasion.community/p/reed
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Reed's critique of equity:
What he calls "disparatarianism" suggests that "the society could be one in which 1% of the population controls 95% of the resources, and it would be just, so long as 12% of the 1% were black and 14% were Hispanic, and half women, and so on."
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Reed on "race reductionism":
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Continue to feel deep admiration for those Russians who stand up, however belatedly, to Vladimir Putin's war.
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
BREAKING: 🇷🇺 Russia’s Counsellor to the United Nations in Geneva has resigned.
Boris Bondarev: “Never have I been so ashamed of my country.”
UN Watch is now calling on all other Russian diplomats at the United Nations—and worldwide—to follow his moral example and resign.
🧵: -
Yascha Mounk reposted
James O'Malley
@Psythor
I’m very sorry for wading in on Flag Discourse Day, but I’m currently reading @Yascha_Mounk’s new book on making diverse democracies work, and I think his explanation of “cultural patriotism” explains why the British left struggles so much with this stuff.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"The violence has *colored* perceptions that the subway is unsafe."
Yeah, I mean someone being murdered on the subway in the middle of the day will do that...Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I get why so many journalists now think of their job as doing what they can to, say, save democracy or get people to take vaccines. I share those goals.
But it so happens that journalists writing news stories in such a way as to advance those goals is a very bad way of doing so.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The truth here seems nuanced by the way.
I find that I am now less at ease on the subway than a few years ago. But on the whole, NYC is still astonishingly safe. I get where the journalist is coming from.
It's just not their job to try and imply what the "correct" view is. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Why is farming in the UK predominantly white?
Well, one reason probably is that many immigrants grew up as the offspring of poor farmers, came to Britain to give their children a shot at a better life, and those children are now doctors, lawyers and engineers.
Sky News
@SkyNews
Why farming in UK is predominantly white - and what's being done to increase diversity news.sky.com/story/why-farming-in-uk-is-predominantly-whi…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"If literature possesses a special power, it is this: that one can read a book by a writer of a different time, a different country, a different race, a different language, and a different culture, and encounter a sensation that is one's very own.
That is literature."
- Yu Hua
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
From Yu Hua's "China in Ten Words," which I'm listening to on Audible at the moment. It's excellent.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I have made my strong preference for the Democratic over the Republican Party plenty clear in countless articles.
But it's still amazing to me how many responses to this article basically boil down to: the only real problem is that half of Americans are evil.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
America is now more polarized than any other developed democracy in the world.
Will Americans always hate each other this much? Do things have to get even worse before they can get better? Or is there a way back from the brink?
My latest @TheAtlantic.
🧵www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/05/us-democrat-rep…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
You can think that a) polarization is a deep problem without believing that b) both major political parties are equally bad.
If your brain is so addicted to hating the other side that you are incapable of seeing this, then you are, with all due respect, part of the problem.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Anyway, I'd be grateful if you read and share the article!
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/05/us-democrat-rep… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Schrödinger's Hungary:
According to the new right, Hungary is simultaneously to be celebrated for being Europe's last bulwark against liberalism, and defended as a perfect liberal democracy.
🙄
Michael Brendan Dougherty
@michaelbd
Hungary is a liberal democracy. That’s the tweet.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Being a writer isn't always easy, especially in an age in which strangers can misrepresent your views, make weird assumptions, or send nasty messages.
But, deep down, it is such an incredible privilege to be able to devote one's life to thinking and writing about the world. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Jeffrey Goldberg
@JeffreyGoldberg
"I have long had the sense that American levels of partisan animosity were exceptionally high. Although I’d seen animosity between left and right in other nations, their hatred never felt so personal or intense as in the U.S."
-- @Yascha_Mounk:
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/05/us-democrat-rep… -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Since 2005, average levels of polarization around the world have increased from 2.0 to 2.4 (on a scale of 0-4).
In the United States, they have increased from 2.0 to 3.8.
For America, McCoy told me, "I am very pessimistic... The situation of the United States is unique." -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Political science question I've somehow never pondered:
In countries with a system of proportional representation which relies on party lists and has a significant hurdle for parliamentary representation: What happens if all parties fail to clear the hurdle?
Is no one elected?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Most PR systems have ways of dealing with this.
In Germany, for example, half of MPs are elected directly in their districts. So you'd just end up with a small Bundestag. (Plus, if a party wins three districts, it circumvents the hurdle)
But is any PR system vulnerable to this?
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Inspired by this admittedly somewhat silly exchange.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
pRoPoRtIoNaL rEpReSeNtAtIoN 😂
Though that would have the advantage of voters being able to ensure that NOBODY is elected to Congress, just by 10% of people voting for silly parties!
Would be pretty popular, I think! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Lots of good things will come from Asian-Americans being more vocal in U.S. politics.
But should experts really draw maps to ensure that Manhattan's Chinatown and Brooklyn's Sunset Park are in one district, just because both have many Chinese residents?
It makes me very queasy.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Racecraft is everywhere in this country.
And supposedly "neutral" experts act on principles which most citizens in other democracies would find to be very, very controversial (if not perturbing).
Look at how far Chinatown and Sunset Park are apart!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Not to mention that what looks identical to the outsider actually comprises a huge amount of variety.
Manhattan's Chinatown is historically Cantonese. Sunset Park is historically Fouzhounese.
But they're all Asian, so.. they must be part of the same district?
America is weird.Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
pRoPoRtIoNaL rEpReSeNtAtIoN 😂
Though that would have the advantage of voters being able to ensure that NOBODY is elected to Congress, just by 10% of people voting for silly parties!
Would be pretty popular, I think! -
Yascha Mounk reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“Once pernicious polarization has set in, it tends to stay,” writes @Yascha_Mounk. “And even when a country has managed to depolarize in a lasting way, it took a major political disaster to force it”: on.theatln.tc/y0wvrpg
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
America is now more polarized than any other developed democracy in the world.
Will Americans always hate each other this much? Do things have to get even worse before they can get better? Or is there a way back from the brink?
My latest @TheAtlantic.
🧵www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/05/us-democrat-rep…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Having lived in many countries, I have long felt that there is something different about the United States.
Political divisions go deep in Germany and Italy as well. But they are not nearly as personal or nasty as in America.
Now, a new study by @jlynnmccoy confirms this hunch.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Since 2005, average levels of polarization around the world have increased from 2.0 to 2.4 (on a scale of 0-4).
In the United States, they have increased from 2.0 to 3.8.
For America, McCoy told me, "I am very pessimistic... The situation of the United States is unique."Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
...but my fear is simple:
We might already hate one another too much to take the steps necessary to avoid catastrophe.
[End]
Please read the full article @TheAtlantic!
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/05/us-democrat-rep…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And if you're interested in reading more about the reasons to be optimistic, as well as to be pessimistic, about the future of America, please read my latest book!
www.amazon.com/Great-Experiment-Diverse-Democracies-Endur… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I really don't want to have to learn about monkeypox.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Of all the simplistic cliches about America, the one that it is a deeply puritan culture comes closest to the mark...
...perhaps especially among those who think that they are far too sophisticated and enlightened to, themselves, be guilty of puritanism. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
1) Voting for Republicans in the age of Donald Trump because they are supposedly the "kinder" party is absurd.
2) Democrats should seriously introspect about why, despite Trump, so many people perceive them as unkind and divisive. Winning the 2024 election may depend on it.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
(And no, just calling every voter who has concerns about your party a bigot does not count as introspection.)
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Some of the very worst decisions taken during the pandemic came from public health officials ineptly moonlighting as comms strategists rather than sticking to what the science said.
Apparently, they CDC is still playing the same game.
zeynep tufekci
@zeynep
So, CDC is worried updating vaccines might "create an impression that we don’t have a very effective vaccination program".
Having vaccines available only for a long-extinct strain when we could easily update them would surely not be the answer here to fixing that "impression". -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Have we learned absolutely f$&#ing nothing from 2016?!
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Source:
www.politico.com/newsletters/playbook/2022/05/18/takeaway… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A clear majority of Republican primary voters in PA supported either a Muslim man or a black woman.
The Republican Party is ideologically extreme. It's also surprisingly good at building a multi-faith and multi-racial coalition.
Closing our eyes to this won't make it go away. -
Yascha Mounk reposted
Harvard University Press
@Harvard_Press
Why the world keeps getting more equal.
@Yascha_Mounk and @PikettyLeMonde, author of A Brief History of Equality, discuss the reasons to be optimistic about the future of the world economy on The Good Fight Podcast:
www.persuasion.community/p/piketty?s=r -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Writing is hard.
Finding the time to write is even harder. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
.@dwallacewells' thinking on climate change is very interesting.
He made his name by emphasizing an apocalyptic scenario in "The Uninhabitable Earth." Since then, he's become forthright about the fact that this is now unlikely.
See our recent convo here.
www.persuasion.community/p/wallacewells?s=w
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
The door may be closing on apocalyptic climate futures, but also on comfortable ones. Where does that leave us? Already in a world beyond all human experience we are learning to call "normal." My first newsletter for @nytopinion. (1/x) www.nytimes.com/2022/05/17/opinion/climate-change-india-p…
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Nothing to do on a Monday night? This is starting now.
Watch live here.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4_kaStLzw4 -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Perhaps it has, all along, been a bad idea to count on demographic change to deliver victories for your favored political party and celebrate a future in which "people of color" will, according to a bizarre racial scheme that's being treated as objective fact, be in the majority?
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Millions of "people of color" have European ancestors and define themselves as white (but happen to speak Spanish).
Meanwhile, the only ethnic group that is consistently classified as white according to the U.S. Census Bureau is... Arabs.
The whole damn thing makes no sense.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And as for political reality, we now have first (outlier) polls showing Hispanics being *more* likely to vote for Republicans than whites!
Stop. Believing. That. Demography. Is. Destiny.
Stop. Believing. That. America. Will. Be. Majority. Minority. In. Any. Meaningful. Sense. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The Taliban now require all women in the country to wear the burqa in public.
We have failed the women of Afghanistan. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A great piece of news from a German state election today:
For the first time, the far-right Alternative for Germany failed to be reelected to a state parliament because it obtained less than 5% of the vote!
The likely reason: Close ties between the AfD leadership and Russia. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is one of the classic pitfalls of dictatorship: At some point, the leader is so cut off from real life, and his advisers so afraid to tell him the truth, that he has no idea what is going on—even about such vital questions like whether you are, you know, winning the war.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I first met @Kasparov63 around 2012, when he gave a lecture at Harvard. In his characteristically blunt style, he told us about the danger posed by Putin's insatiable ambition.
Most of the audience seemed bewildered. Some ostentatiously rolled their eyes.
A lesson to us all.
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This, by the way, is one key reason why we always need to keep fighting for an open discourse which allows for genuine debate.
At every juncture in human history, the conventional wisdom has been wrong in important respects.
There is no reason to think that now is different. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's just astonishing how much of American culture is now consumed by attempts to get people punished, debates about people getting punished, and campaigns to stop people from getting punished.
The mark of a deeply sick society. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
For this week's podcast, I got a chance to ask @Kasparov63 questions that had always puzzled me about him:
* How did a champion chess player come to care so much about politics?
* And how has he managed to be so right about so many things over the years?
www.persuasion.community/p/kasparov -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Every blue-check on Twitter should be forced to watch a focus group once a week.
What they'd learn is:
* Most Americans dislike Trump
* Most Americans think Democrats are way out there on culture
* Most Americans distrust Republicans on policy
* Most Americans are very decent. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If Democrats are to stop Trump from winning in 2024, they must not repeat the mistakes that led to Youngkin's victory in Virginia.
The first step is to take the concerns of voters seriously rather than dismissing them as made up.
My latest @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/11/virginia-electi… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Once we allow the idea that "inappropriate" or "problematic" books should be banished from libraries, the question of which ones will be made to disappear becomes a sheer competition of power.
That is why everyone should resist this kind of censorship as a matter of principle.
Mike Hixenbaugh
@Mike_Hixenbaugh
Greg Abbott, noting that parents across Texas have become “increasingly alarmed” about “extremely inappropriate” library books, is now calling on districts to remove them. Doesn’t cite specific books, but recent cases have centered on anti-racism, sex-ed and LGBTQ books.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Germany is taking four simply steps to help contain Covid.
Infuriatingly, America is—18 months into the pandemic—still failing to do the same.
If we want to avoid yet another deadly and disruptive winter, the time to act is now.
My latest @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/10/four-measures-a… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I will never get over the fact that a view according to which non-white people are somehow less intellectual or interested in scientific rigor than white people parades as progressive in the United States of 2021.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Police in Britain: "Being Offensive Is an Offence."
The only problem is: Who determines what is offensive? And by what standard?
Thank God for the First Amendment. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
When professional journalists at a prestigious newspaper think it is their job to uncover and put a stop to any "unfettered conversations" that may be happening in the country, you know that something has gone well and truly awry.
The New York Times
@nytimes
Unfettered conversations are taking place on Clubhouse, an invitation-only app that lets people gather in audio chatrooms.
The platform has exploded in popularity, despite grappling with concerns over harassment, misinformation and privacy.
www.nytimes.com/2021/02/15/business/clubhouse-a-tiny-audi… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A Pakistani-American doctor was fired *and is being prosecuted* because he gave an opened vaccine to anyone he could find rather than letting it go to waste.
Apparently, it would have been more "equitable" to throw the vaccine out.
This is madness.
www.nytimes.com/2021/02/10/us/houston-doctor-fired-covid-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Another nail in the coffin of the "emerging demographic majority" for left-wing political parties around the world:
In Germany, a majority of immigrants and their descendants now vote for right-wing political parties.
www.wsj.com/articles/immigrants-and-their-children-shift-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Those who think that they will be able to advance decent values by creating a world in which decent people with decent values are forever judged by their biggest mistake will sadly turn out to be badly mistaken.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
When groups of armed nihilists attempt to destroy federal buildings that are key to the maintenance of the rule of law, it is the responsibility of public officials to identify, arrest and punish them.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Thank you to @KDonfried and so many other colleagues for the two wonderful years I spent as a Senior Fellow @gmfus. I will miss you all!
(My other roles and responsibilities won't be affected by this change.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Donald Trump’s defeat suggests that the first draft of history—written by pundits, politicians, and political scientists over the past four years—was unduly pessimistic.
My case for optimism about America's future.
[Thread]
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/11/joe-biden-wins/… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In nearly every country, authoritarian populists managed to subvert electoral systems by stacking the electoral commission with loyalists—except here.
America's diversity of electoral rules breeds chaos and complexity. It is also the best defense against authoritarian takeover. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Whatever happens, those of us who want to defeat Trumpism for the long haul will need to ask ourselves some very serious questions after tonight.
And no, "half of our compatriots are irredeemable bigots" is not going to cut it. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Waiting for the first American journalist to blame the attacks in Vienna on Austria's famous tradition of laïcite...
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Comedians to the rescue.
Sarah Silverman
@SarahKSilverman
Dipping my toe into a take on cancel culture in episode 2.
#sarahsilvermanpodcast eps 1-5
Here: www.apple.com… -
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Another startling example:
Germany and the German-speaking parts of Switzerland have very similar rates.
France and the French-speaking parts of Switzerland also have very similar rates.
German-speaking and French-speaking parts of Switzerland have very different rates. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Holy s**t.
Over the course of three years, the number of Americans who say that they feel justified in using violence to achieve their political goals has gone up from 8 percent to over 33 percent. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The boss of the NYT op-ed page was fired because he ran a controversial op-ed by a sitting U.S. Senator.
But a few months later, a propagandist for an authoritarian regime gets to argue that a violent putdown of peaceful protests was needed in the same pages.
This is just nuts. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Dear Dean of the Harvard School of Public Health,
Do you think that this kind of content is likely to increase public trust in experts and scientists in the midst of an unprecedented pandemic?
No?
Well, then you should cut out the crap.
Yours,
Yascha Mounk
Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
@HarvardChanSPH
Have you ever thought to yourself, "How do I know that 2+2=4? Why isn't it 2+2+5?" PhD student @kareem_carr talks about numbers and abstraction with @PopMech www.popularmechanics.com/science/math/a69798532/why-some-… @HarvardGSAS
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Read this important and scary scoop by the great @kbennhold (who, among her many qualities, was very kind to me when I was a lowly intern at the International Herald Tribune many years ago).
Katrin Bennhold
@kbennhold
Body Bags and Enemy Lists: How Far-Right Police Officers and Ex-Soldiers Planned for ‘Day X.’
A group of far-right preppers known as Nordkreuz shocked Germany.
I met some of them this year.
Here is what I learned:
Thread 1/10
www.nytimes.com/2020/08/01/world/europe/germany-nazi-infi… -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Companies and nonprofits fire innocent people for imaginary offenses.
Prominent voices alternate between defending cancel culture and denying its existence.
An astonishing number of journalists proudly proclaim that it is time to abandon values like due process and free speech. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
What on earth am I looking at here?
Did these people literally self-flagellate? Did they whip each other? Is this paint?
I'm not sure I can even begin to process which of these possibilities would be the "least" offensive. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Actually, we need a term for people who smear good faith participants in public debate as bigots or try to cancel someone for ridiculous reasons...
"Oh, he's just being an X. Don't pay any attention to him; he's completely discredited himself."
Suggestions? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A small ray of light at the end of a very bleak week:
89% (!) of Americans believe either that the charges against Derek Chauvin are appropriate, or that he should have been charged with a *more* serious crime. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"The estimates in this model show that in many realistic scenarios the scope of the epidemic may overtake the physical and human capacity of the U.S. health system."
I really don't think Americans are remotely prepared for what could be about to happen.
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/17/upshot/hospital-be… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Read this whole thread by the Director of the Center for Public Health Security at Johns Hopkins:
The federal government still isn't implementing a national effort to produce and distribute ventilators.
Doing so now will potentially save many, many lives.
Tom Inglesby, MD
@T_Inglesby
What we need is a massive fed gov program to buy ventilators on unprecedented scale and with unprecedented speed. They don’t need to be the fanciest ventilators on the market. They need to be able to keep ARDS pts alive through course of COVID infection. 10/x
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The residents of Siena, stuck in their apartments, singing a traditional song together.
How I love that city.
How I love that country.
Coraggio, amici.
❤️❤️❤️ -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
These are scary times. And we’re still not doing enough to contain corona. (#canceleverything.)
But the reason to act is not that the apocalypse is nigh; it’s that the right steps will save lives and allow us to weather the storm.
So here’s some much-needed optimism.
[Thread] -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Doctors and nurses in Italy face an impossible dilemma: who to treat and who to let die.
But the moral obligation we face is very clear: We must arrest the crisis before the impossible becomes unavoidable.
Cancel everything. Now.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/03/who-gets-hospit… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The Italian College of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Resuscitation and Intensive Care just published the most extraordinary medical document I’ve ever seen.
To help people from Germany to America understand what we’re about to face, I am publishing translated extracts here.
[Thread.] -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Italy today:
* Whole country in lockdown
* Hospitals completely overwhelmed
* Doctors forced to decide which patients get treatment based on who is most likely to survive
Italy today. Spain, Germany, America tomorrow.
Cancel everything.
Now.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/03/coronavirus-can… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
We now know three things about corona:
* It's way more deadly than the flu.
* It's spreading with exponential speed.
* Only social distancing has been able to contain it.
The upshot: To save lives, we must start radical measures NOW.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/03/coronavirus-can… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I’ve been hesitant to post this thread.
But I’ve slowly come to the conclusion that we are significantly underestimating the likely impact of the corona virus—and what all of us should do RIGHT NOW to avoid a staggering number of preventable deaths.
[Thread.]Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Are you the head of a sports team, the president of a university, or the organizer of a conference?
* Play your games without an audience.
* Hold classes online.
* Postpone your conference.
It might seem like a tough call today. It'll seem like the obvious one soon. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
In India and Poland, populists emboldened by reelection are attacking minorities and destroying the judiciary.
This should shock Americans out of their complacency. Trump’s first term is a poor guide to the horrors that await us if he wins in 2020.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/modis-second-te… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Corbyn claimed that he could rebuild Labour by moving far to the left. He only succeeded in decimating his party and losing the working-class to the Tories.
Unless Democrats learn the lesson of the UK election, they will lose in 2020.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/how-culture-kil…
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Left parties are struggling because their old coalition has broken in two.
The answer is to push for progressive policies on economic issues without giving up on capitalism and to defend minorities without leaving the cultural mainstream.
Me @DemJournal. democracyjournal.org/magazine/54/left-for-dead/ -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Six people were murdered in an anti-Semitic attack in Jersey City yesterday.
While many of the details are still oddly elusive, this seems like a WAY bigger deal than the media are making it out to be.
Why on earth is this story absent from the front pages of most major papers? -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
No, Evo Morales' resignation is not a coup; it is one of the few big victories democracy has won in recent years.
Both leftist dictators, like Venezuela's Maduro, and far-right populists, like Hungary’s Orbán, should be terrified by it.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/11/evo-morales-fin… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
"Liberals are always slow to realize that there can be friendly, idealistic people who have little use for liberal values."
- George Packer.
www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/10/when-the-cul… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Boris Johnson's decision to suspend parliament is the most blatant assault on democracy in Britain’s living memory, and one of the most serious any Western country has faced in the populist era.
Me @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/08/boris-johnsons-… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Over the past years, I’ve participated in dozens of panels, and sat through hundreds more.
Most of them had one thing in common: they sucked.
It doesn’t have to be like that. So here are my six rules for (panel) life.
[Thread.]
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/07/how-not-run-pan… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Dear Producers at RT,
This is what happened the one and only time I will ever appear on your network.
Are you sure you want to keep sending me those invites?
My best,
Yascha Mounk
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cucX1IO78lM -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I strongly disagree with some of Andy Ngo's work. But to suggest "he has a history of battling with anti-fascist groups" is slander.
Ngo criticizes Antifa. Antifa members assaulted him.
It's astonishing that this @nytimes report erases that difference.
www.nytimes.com/2019/07/01/us/portland-protests-mayor-cru… -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
🚨🚨🚨
Couldn't be more excited to join @TheAtlantic as a Contributing Editor.
I'll be joining some of the writers I most admire at a magazine that is, every day and every month, creating a vibrant space for debate among people who understand the huge stakes of this moment. -
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
We assembled a first-of-its-kind dataset of populist leaders, looking at 46 heads of government across 33 countries who were in power between 1990 and today.
And instead of speculating about what populists did to democracy, we actually looked at the historical record. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The defeatistism I’ve seen on Twitter for the past twelve hours is deeply and dangerously wrong: Democrats have just won a huge victory!
Here are six big takeaways from the best day for the American republic since that traumatic Election Day in 2016.
[Thread.] -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
A sad day: One of Germany's biggest and most respected pollsters, Infratest Dimap, shows the far-right AfD as the country's second strongest party, ahead of the Social Democrats, for the first time in history.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Paris, you treated me right (despite the many early mornings).
Thank you so much to the whole team at @EdLObservatoire for an *amazing* book launch.
Je serais de retour bientôt! -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I know, the politics of the European Union are SO much less interesting than the Trump Horror Show.
But Europe’s conservative elites—led by Angela Merkel—are about to sell out the most basic values of liberal democracy in a blatant and very important way. Here’s how.
(Thread.) -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
I can't stomach the triumphalism of those who pretend a few airstrikes somehow make us Syria's saviors.
Nor can I stomach the smugness of those who pretend that doing nothing is obviously moral.
Given how bad all the options are, our main emotion should be humbled despair. -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Full house for my reading at @SchauspielFFM, where I get to talk the crisis of democracy in front of an inappropriately lovely Chagall painting.
Later today: @BiblioDAI in Heidelberg!
#peoplevsdemocracy -
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
This is a remarkable achievement, which we celebrate far too rarely.
Micah Zenko
@MicahZenko
If you're 27 years old, poverty around the world has fallen 390% in your lifetime.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Need a reminder of the human cost of dictatorship? All these are journalists who criticized Putin--and died under mysterious circumstances
-
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
It's looking like Melenchon is the only main candidate not to endorse Macron over Le Pen. Anyone need more proof that the extremes touch? 5/
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
Tonight's election once again shows that the young *are* open to populism. Le Pen + Melenchon got >50% among the young, <20% among the old.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
And yet, at this important moment, Fillon is utterly clear: You have to choose the democrat over the enemy of our political system. 3/4
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
If French run-off ends up being Le Pen versus Melenchon--an unlikely but no longer impossible outcome--the country will be so screwed.
-
Yascha Mounk
@Yascha_Mounk
The #spd's treatment of #greece betrayed its noble history. In protest - and with much sadness - I have resigned. www.thenation.com/article/germanys-social-democrats-are-c…































































































































































































