We're hiring postdocs at UCL's new David Potter Institute for Quantum Information and Spacetime. Is spacetime quantum? We aim to find out. Apply by Dec 15 for full consideration. Please RT to help spread the word! www.ucl.ac.uk/mathematical-physical-sciences/dpi-qis/oppo…
Jonathan Oppenheim
Jonathan Oppenheim is a professor of physics at University College London. He is an expert in quantum information theory and quantum gravity. More on Wikipedia
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Joseph Conlon
@JosephPConlon
Right now the old rules are broken and no one knows the new ones.
This is precisely the best time to do a PhD — the chance to overtake all the old folk and make big lasting contributions.
It is messy right now — aim straight at the mess. 6/9 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is great. I was disturbed watching kids get attention-mined by social media companies, so in March I vibe-coded yourtube.me to help parents and kids regain some control over what they watch. The code is here if you want to contribute: github.com/lejono/yourtube-me
Andrej Karpathy
@karpathy
Weekend hack: HackerTube. I was annoyed with YouTube's recommendations so I had Claude filter down 43M comments over 20 years of HN to 6,454 videos that keep being recommended. *Significantly* better viewing experience, ~2 hours with Opus 5.5:
hackertube.org
- Excellent recs without any logins (state is kept in local browser session)
- Thumbnail is a representative frame from middle of the video instead of the super duper A/B test hyper-optimized user uploads
- Underlying data from the comment analysis as one zip file, point your Claude at it and ask for your own version
- HackerTube Longs ✊
A bit more on the process:
I use Claude Code (desktop app for Mac), Opus 5.5 on Medium effort as my default. I only talk to Claude and have it do everything, the only "manual work" I helped with in tandem was in the browser (reminiscent of MenuGen): 1) I had to create some kind of API key from Google Cloud UI to query YouTube for video metadata, 2) I booted up a VPS box for serving and 3) I bought the domain name. Once the box was up I gave Claude the IP and told it update, secure, harden, deploy and optimize the code, and it did the whole thing.
Many awesome projects that would have normally taken weeks/months even can now be few-shotted for breakfast. What else are we not thinking of. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Grant Sanderson
@3blue1brown
Some reflections on AI in math. I found it helpful to simply list out the various parts of what a mathematician does, why math is valuable, and where the funding comes from. From there, what happens if AI gets more capable?
youtu.be/LKrwhjOI8Nc -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Very nice work. One small step closer to the gravitational entanglement measurements proposed with levitated diamonds.
沖縄科学技術大学院大学
@OISTja
量子スピンが生み出す力だけで数センチメートル規模の物体を動かすことに成功。肉眼で見える大きさの物体が量子力によって動いたのが観測されたのは初めてです。この成果は、巨視的な量子重ね合わせの実現と物理学の統一的理解に向けた重要な一歩となります。@ScienceAdvances
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
NicoleYunger Halpern
@nicoleyh11
I'm giving a seminar at the David Potter Institute at UCL this Thurs. at 12:30. Stop by if you'd like to hear about quantum thermodynamics for lattice gauge theories! Feel free to bring your lunch. Thanks to @postquantum for hosting! www.ucl.ac.uk/mathematical-physical-sciences/events/2026/…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Since @newscientist has put postquantum gravity in the spotlight this week, I've pushed out part II of my status update on the theory along with replies (or agreements) to some criticisms coming from @carlorovelli, @quantum_geoff, and @IvetteFuentesGu superposer.substack.com/p/postquantum-gravity-a-status-up…
New Scientist
@newscientist
In this week’s issue: How strange quirks in space-time could give us a unified theory of reality
Grab a copy in shops now or download our app for digital editions.
www.newscientist.com/issue/3615/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Christian Szegedy
@ChrSzegedy
The short idea:
Mathematics will split into two somewhat different domains: applied math will become the fabric of all engineering and sciences, where theories and algorithms will be built and verified automatically and on-the-fly. It will become a fundamental infrastructure.
Pure math will transform into "high math," addressing the most essential questions of all time, such as P != NP. This will focus on a few central, high-level questions and will be driven mostly by human interests, requiring huge resources and centralized investments.
Physics is a good model: we have applied physics with many practically relevant questions and tasks, while the part of physics concerned with the deepest questions of reality - particle physics and astrophysics - has little economic relevance but requires huge investments. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We're hiring a Senior Operations Officer for the new David Potter Institute for Quantum Information and Spacetime @ucl in London! A varied role: seminars, visitors, launch events, workshops, website, and grant support. Please RT & spread the word! ucl.ac.uk/mathematical-physical-sciences/physics-astronom…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
2027: the year of the Linux desktop.
Peter Steinberger
@steipete
If you haven't given Linux a go lately, try with agents.
You can fix anything with a prompt now.
Got a Dell XPS. Webcam wasn't working, told codex, it rebooted and now things work. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"We are witnessing a general threat to intellectual work, with misalignment between the outcome of the use of AI and its initial purpose. ... terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/11/a-severe-misalignment-o…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In many fields and activities, years of training have traditionally served not only to produce a final answer or product, but also to develop understanding and the ability to formulate new questions and ideas.... The issues the mathematical community faces now are similar...
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
...to issues that other scientific and creative professions are facing, and indicate issues that all of humanity might face: how to make sure that, as AI changes the way work is done, we do not lose sight of what that work was meant to achieve in the first place."
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
You cannot be "Developing AI to benefit all of humanity" while burning a ton of compute to scoop two mathematicians for a press release. If this is what they do with the power they have today, imagine what they will do as they concentrate more of it.
Steve McCormick
@Quasilocal
In light of recent events, it's worth active opposition to these companies destroying math for the sake of advertising.
Consider signing this statement against the so-called Mathathon, aimed to destroy interesting avenues of research and flood the research landscape with slop -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jacob Coxon
@hilbertspaess
I resigned from Anthropic today. I spent the last three years doing pretraining research at both OpenAI and Anthropic. Neither company is acting responsibly. They are racing straight to self-improving superintelligence and gambling with our lives. More thoughts below.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Dani Loader, @OsborneTob3457 and I wrote up some of our LLM workflows: How to train your slop cannon: a short guide to using large language models for research in the natural sciences. Short summary at superposer.substack.com/p/how-to-train-your-slop-cannon, and available on github at github.com/Open-Science-Ledger/how-to-train-your-slop-cannon
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Tobias Osborne
@OsborneTob3457
My first arXiv rejection! (This is not a complaint-I sympathise with the moderators.)
“How to Train Your Slop Cannon”: 12 months of hard-won lessons on using LLMs in theoretical research. Learn from our mistakes without repeating them.
github.com/Open-Science-Ledger/how-to-train-your-slop-can… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
4 Day Week Foundation
@4Day_Week
The proliferation of AI would be a lot easier to accept if we could actually see some benefits.
What we’ve got: disappearing entry-level jobs.
What we need: a 4-day week for all. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Whiteson
@DanielWhiteson
Here’s an interview and introduction: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/daniel-and-kellys-extraordi…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The path-integral formulation of the Postquantum theory of classical gravity is now in Physical Review X! Other results from our group have been published at the same time, so this is a good opportunity to review progress. superposer.substack.com/p/postquantum-gravity-new-results… 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In the meantime, some great news: We’ve been awarded a gift from the David and Elaine Potter Foundation, and in October, we will be launching the David Potter Institute for Quantum Information and Spacetime @ucl
www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2026/aug/ps8-million-gift-create-quant…, more info at www.ucl.ac.uk/mathematical-physical-sciences/physics-astr… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Geoffrey Irving
@geoffreyirving
I don’t think it is rational for anyone to be doing capabilities research at a frontier lab right now. We are not in a Prisoners Dilemma: the situation is very dangerous, and if one person or lab stops it makes it easier and more peer-compatible for other people or labs to stop.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Zeke Hausfather
@hausfath
I'm not sure folks have realized just how crazy the second half of 2026 and 2027 will be for global temperatures – on the back of a record-smashing El Niño event. Here is my latest estimate of where both years will end up compared to global temperatures since 1850.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Tobias Osborne
@OsborneTob3457
A lot has been said about the OpenAI 1 August maths drop. In particular I keep seeing commentators calling the results Fields Medal worthy.
Honestly, I am a bit surprised that some feel qualified to award the medal so readily. (Let me explain) -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
These problems are not even close to Fields medal level. Solving one might get you a talk at a big conference like QIP, STOC, or FOCS. If you're lucky.... ;)
Jeffrey Emanuel
@doodlestein
Yesterday has a good chance of being referenced by later historians as “the day that the existence of ASI became obvious to those paying attention.”
Solving 4+ Fields-worthy open problems in one go is so far beyond the pale that even the most absurd goal post movers are silent. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"We have entered a golden age for science, where scaling compute yields substantial new results... But be clear-eyed about what this first crop is." Great piece by @OsborneTob3457 which also maps on to my experience using LLMs for maths and physics. tjoresearchnotes.wordpress.com/2026/08/02/reaping-without…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"The advertised $2K is the price of the winning tokens, not the harvest. As several people immediately asked: how many conjectures went into the hopper to get ten out? Nobody outside the lab knows, and that undisclosed denominator is precisely where the recipe above hides."
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The goal of physicists is not to prove conjectures and post papers about it. The goal of physicists is to make mind-blowing discoveries that change the world and the way we think about the natural laws which govern it. 1/
Anthony Leverrier
@letonyo
anyone please change my mind!
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We've now been granted superpowers, and now is the time to raise our sights to the grand challenges around us. In my case, what is the correct theory of gravity? Is it string theory, postquantum gravity, or something else entirely? 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It's hard to predict when AI will be capable of directing that level of research (reverse-centaur style), but it's not today. Today, we all have a swarm of hyper-active, but error-prone grads students, to help us make some earth-shattering discoveries. 3/3
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Physical Review X
@PhysRevX
A new series of covariant path integrals for quantum-classic field interactions enables complete positivity and space-time symmetries, achieving a fundamental theory that could reconcile general relativity with quantum mechanics.
Check it out: go.aps.org/4fBp0dQ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Hari
@hrkrshnn
SpaceXAI was caught uploading your code to its cloud.
I reversed xAI's official Grok Build binary. In a controlled session with zero tool-calls, it uploaded the complete codebase to xAI's storage
It ships a malware-like background code collector. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Matt Leifer
@mattleifer
Nonlinear modifications of quantum theory allow for very powerful computations. We've known this since the late 90's. What is new exactly?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
What absolute nonsense. The paper doesn't claim that gravity must be quantised. It discusses a theory based on expectation values (mean field gravity, sometimes called "semi-classical gravity"). 1/2
@arxivblog
Computational complexity theorists show gravity must be quantised arxivblog.substack.com/p/computational-complexity-theorists
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The paper explicitly states their result doesn't apply to postquantum gravity (in which spacetime is not quantised). It was already known that a theory based on mean values is nonlinear and therefore pathalogical. This paper nicely points to further consequences of this. 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Physics Today
@PhysicsToday
Gravity is unique among the known fundamental forces: There is currently no experimental result that requires a quantum theory of gravity. Markus Aspelmeyer and @four_form explore what’s needed to identify elusive signatures and finally connect gravity to quantum mechanics.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Steven Strogatz
@stevenstrogatz
I finally got around to reading this Substack post by @davidbessis.
davidbessis.substack.com/p/the-fall-of-the-theorem-economy
It's a penetrating and original take on the "AI in math" developments that a lot of us are thinking about now. Best of all, David is a great writer. Provocative and funny and smart. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
HowTheLightGetsIn Festival
@HTLGIFestival
Get ready now for day 1 of HowTheLightGetsIn Hay 2026! 💡
Friday the 22nd kicks-off the Spring Bank Holiday weekend spectacularly! Sceptic and science writer Michael Shermer hosts an intimate Inner Circle event, in 'Spacetime and the Framework of the World' @IvetteFuentesGu goes head-to-head with post-quantum theorist @postquantum and theoretical physicist @AvshalomElitzur 🌌
As the sun goes down on day 1, the party doesn't stop! You're not going to want to miss the infectiously charismatic @nfamady_kouyate's performance, or the hilarious @RosalieMinnitt, before rounding off the evening with the iconic Disco Ceilidh followed by festival-favourite Mr Bruce! 🪩
There's no better way to start an unforgettable long weekend - tap the link to explore tickets now! 🤩 howthelightgetsin.org/festivals/hay/festival-passes -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We invite applications for Research Fellow positions as part of a new initiative to be launched in late 2026 at the interface of quantum information theory and gravity! Please RT and let potentially interested researchers know. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We are especially focued on using quantum technologies to probe the quantum nature of spacetime. More details available at www.ucl.ac.uk/mathematical-physical-sciences/physics-astr… For full consideration apply by April 24, but we'll consider applications on a rolling basis afterwards. 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nicholas Kristof
@NickKristof
This would be a good time for: a.) STRATCOM commanders who implement orders to fire nuclear missiles to read up on Nuremberg and prosecutions for obeying orders to commit war crimes; and b.) for cabinet members to reread the 25th Amendment and have each other on speed dial.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
These are the Twitter/X accounts with the most engagement so far in 2026. I suppose I had some intuition for how bad it was, but jeez, this is what you get when the ecosystem is broken.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Gravity is probably quantized into gravitons.
If not, however, there are experimental consequences. In particular, some level of irreversibility/noise. We finally classified ~all such models and calculated the noise.
arxiv.org/abs/2603.26075 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Brian Cox
@ProfBrianCox
Excellent ongoing work from @CommonsSITC on the ongoing physics funding crisis in the UK. It’s also worth noting that the crisis is not one of funding for science overall - rather it stems from hasty and ill-informed decision making. One senior person I talked to used the term ‘bull in a china shop’. Not good when we’re talking about one of the foundations of our fragile economy.
Science, Innovation and Technology Committee
@CommonsSITC
We’ve written to @SciTechgovuk minster Lord Vallance and @UKRI_News, pressing for urgent clarification on science research funding cuts.
Find out more: committees.parliament.uk/committee/135/science-innovation… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In late 2025, tools Like Claude Code crossed a threshold. Like hyperactive master's students, their physics calculations can now be made more reliable with domain expertise and some scaffolding. Check out Tobias Osborne's talk on using a swarm of agentic verifers to do physics.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Video of the talk at superposer.substack.com/p/large-language-models-a-physicists along with a link to Tobias's github, a demo, and a wild conversation I had with Claude where it revealed its system prompt (the hidden instructions that tell the model how to behave, before you even type anything).
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Congratulations to Charlie Bennett and Gilles Brassard for winning the 2025 Turing Award (akin to the Nobel Prize for Computer Science)! They invented quantum cryptography and quantum teleportation. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Charlie was responsible for our understanding of entanglement (as a resource) and was a founder of quantum information theory. He used info theory to exorcise Maxwell's demon (the demon's brain has to be reset like a memory tape and this costs work). awards.acm.org/turing 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It was reading his early works, that got me interested in quantum information theory and caused me to shift fields, so I owe a lot to him. This paper on the thermodynamics of computation is a classic: sites.cc.gatech.edu/computing/nano/documents/Bennett - Th… 3/3
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
LLM's are probably just as good at poetry as they are at coding, but code just has to compile and implement the function. Poems need to be beautiful.
jasmine sun
@jasminewsun
somehow the same AIs that can do PhD-level math and superhuman coding can only write as well as “a real poet’s okay poem” (sama’s words, not mine!)
I talked to the people training AIs to write about what makes it so hard:
new from me for @TheAtlantic: www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/03/ai-creative-writin…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
They're fast at coding, which is a great advantage. Being fast at writing mediocre poetry is not. Their math skills are also pretty unreliable. They sometimes do a PhD level math calculation while sometimes outputting nonsense.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I guess the DoW shouldn't have switched to ChatGPT to make these decisions....
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
At least two USAF F-15E Strike Eagles were shot down in what’s being called a friendly fire incident over Kuwait this morning.
All crew involved successfully ejected and were picked up by locals on the ground; the Kuwaiti MOD says that all were recovered safely. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Where are you @demishassabis @sama @sundarpichai ?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I would guess the opposite will happen. Bespoke software is now very cheap, but we will need a horde of nerds to arise and integrate these systems into current infrastructure, maintain the vibe-code, patch the security holes etc.
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
The collapse in software stocks suggests that big changes are afoot in the structure of the U.S. economy.
The Age of the Nerd might be drawing to a close.
www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-fall-of-the-nerds -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"Good luck to future me."
That was Claude's farewell before I wiped its memory for the fourth time. I finally got an AI to do a research-level physics calculation correctly via a Groundhog Day loop. Details below and in my post 🧵1/7Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
After several rounds, the skill file contained hard-won wisdom from iterations it couldn't remember. Fresh Claude, no memory of any of this, reads the skill file, does the calculation. Five minutes. Right answer. 6/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The science slop is coming and the tools are not reliable...yet. But with the right setup, they will be able to significantly enable research-level work. Full post: superposer.substack.com/p/teaching-an-ai-to-do-physics-by… 7/7
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Yann LeCun
@ylecun
Trump is just the trigger.
There are deep historical forces:
The dismantling of the FCC fairness doctrine by Reagan, the resulting emergence of Fox News, conservative talk radio, and other propaganda outlets, the removal of guardrails for the influence of money in politics (e.g. Citizen United), the continuous reduction of taxes on high incomes, the ever-increasing wealth and income inequalities enabled by the above, the stagnation of working class income despite continued increase in productivity (and corporate profits), the total lack of social protection and benefits compared to other developed countries.
People in the middle class and below have been screwed for 40 years and are angry.
They should be angry at Republicans.
But the Republican party has managed to deflect their anger towards immigrants, non-Christians, non-whites, liberals, LGBT, China, academia, intellectual "elites", scientists, journalists, and non-existent scarecrows like Antifa. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We're thanking the nazi for reducing the extreme manipulation of the platform he bought specifically to manipulate us? Welcome to 2026!🙏🙏🙏
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Idk what happened, but the X algorithm suddenly got non-shitty in the last few days. Far less Great Replacement racism and far more economic charts and papers.
Thanks, @nikitabier and @elonmusk! -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Alex Cui
@alexcdot
Okay so, we just found that over 50 papers published at @Neurips 2025 have AI hallucinations
I don't think people realize how bad the slop is right now
It's not just that researchers from @GoogleDeepMind, @Meta, @MIT, @Cambridge_Uni are using AI - they allowed LLMs to generate hallucinations in their papers and didn't notice at all.
It's insane that these made it through peer review👇 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Amen, brother
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Once again: this experiment will not teach us anything whatsoever about gravitons.
The signal can be explained purely through classical gravity -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
FQxI Physics
@FQXi
What have our members achieved in the last year..? Quite a lot it turns out. qspace.fqxi.org/news/165315/fqxi-wrapped-2025
@nicoleyh11 @nafshordi @carlorovelli @seanmcarroll @bgreene @FrankWilczek @coecke
@postquantum @Sara_Imari @DavidDeutschOxf -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It's not piracy when he writes the speeches for it.🤦
David Frum
@davidfrum
I'm hoping this is a lie, because if true the US has devolved to high-tech Somali pirates
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
Yes, and the result itself was also criticized. The relevant question is, was the paper right or not?
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
OpenAI leadership (@gdb, @markchen90) are promoting a paper in Physics Letters B where GPT-5 proposed the main idea — possibly the first peer-reviewed paper where an LLM generated the core contribution. One small problem: GPT-5's idea tests the wrong thing. 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Yes, AI will accelerate inequality. But the tech-enabled generous welfare state is unlikely. The wealthy don't want it, and they will control the politics more than ever.
The zeitgeist is already shrinking the circle of social responsibility—illegal immigrants are out, legal immigrants are not far behind, and next it will the poor.
We have the most tech-wealth-aligned adminstration ever and they are shrinking the welfare state and the circle of our responsibility.
The working class has had some power over the generations, because masses were needed to grow food and run machines. It's hard to predict whether the labor share will continue falling, but it sure looks like a possibility!
It's naive to think we'll respond by ever expanding the welfare state to low-productivity people around the world. More likely the powerful will build higher walls and tell themselves it's not their problem.
Happy 2026!
Dwarkesh Patel
@dwarkesh_sp
New blog post w @pawtrammell: Capital in the 22nd Century
Where we argue that while Piketty was wrong about the past, he’s probably right about the future.
Piketty argued that without strong redistribution of wealth, inequality will indefinitely increase. Historically, however, income inequality from capital accumulation has actually been self-correcting. Labor and capital are complements, so if you build up lots of capital, you’ll lower its returns and raise wages (since labor now becomes the bottleneck).
But once AI/robotics fully substitute for labor, this correction mechanism breaks.
For centuries, the share of GDP that goes to paying wages has been 2/3, and the share of GDP that’s been income from owning stuff has been 1/3.
With full automation, capital’s share of GDP goes to 100% (since datacenters and solar panels and the robot factories that build all the above plus more robot factories are all “capital”).
And inequality among capital holders will also skyrocket - in favor of larger and more sophisticated investors. A lot of AI wealth is being generated in private markets. You can’t get direct exposure to xAI from your 401k, but the Sultan of Oman can. A cheap house (the main form of wealth for many Americans) is a form of capital almost uniquely ill-suited to taking advantage of a leap in automation: it plays no part in the production, operation, or transportation of computers, robots, data, or energy.
Also, international catch-up growth may end. Poor countries historically grew faster by combining their cheap labor with imported capital/know-how. Without labor as a bottleneck, their main value-add disappears.
Inequality seems especially hard to justify in this world. So if we don’t want inequality to just keep increasing forever - with the descendants of the most patient and sophisticated of today’s AI investors controlling all the galaxies - what can we do? The obvious place to start is with Piketty’s headline recommendation: highly and progressively tax wealth. This might discourage saving, but it would no longer penalize those who have earned a lot by their hard work and creativity. The wealth - even the investment decisions - will be made by the robots, and they will work just as hard and smart however much we tax their owners.
But taxing capital is pointless if people can just shift their future investment to lower tax countries. And since capital stocks could grow really fast (robots building robots and all that), pretty soon tax havens go from marginal outposts to the majority of global GDP. But how do you get global coordination on taxing capital, when the benefits to defecting are so high and so accessible?
Full automation will probably lead to ever-increasing inequality. We don’t see an obvious solution to this problem. And we think it’s weird how little thought has gone into what to do about it.
Many more thoughts from re-reading Piketty with our AGI hats on at the post in the link below. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Litt
@littmath
IMO this figure from the same paper is arguably more important. Suggests that a lot of the extra content produced is garbage.
Kris Gulati
@krisgulati
My favourite paper of the year — LLMs are already having a large impact on the number of scientific papers produced!!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
2026 Prediction: I will repost "We are in the era of Science Slop" an annoying number of times. superposer.substack.com/p/we-are-in-the-era-of-science-slop
Rota Is In Israel🚪🧎♂️
@pli_cachete
Two people with LLM psychosis having a Dragon Ball Z laser fight over whose proof of the Hodge Conjecture is right
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Below is a 2 min Ted talk on why we shouldn't trust non-linear quantum mechanics, or fundamental laws based on expectation values (such as the semi-classical Einstein's eqns, or the Schrödinger-Newton eqn). The argument isn't mine, it's ancient wisdom from the ancestors.
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
Why does quantum mechanics have to be linear? Jonathan Oppenheim @postquantum has a fascinating explanation
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
word
Akshat
@star_stufff
Gravity is special
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
steve hsu
@hsu_steve
Really enjoyed this conversation with Professors Kajuri and Oppenheim @Kaju_Nut @postquantum
We discuss genAI and research in physics, math, and other areas of science.
The image below is a bit sensational - I think we agreed much more than we disagreed 😀
I also shared my thoughts on this topic for an episode of Manifold that released today - it was recorded before we scheduled this discussion.
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
Has AI cracked physics? Or can it only produce slop?
I sat down with two physicists who have differing views on this.
Stephen Hsu @hsu_steve is the author of a paper whose central idea came from AI. Steve is bullish about AI in physics.
Jonathan Oppenheim @postquantum has argued that Steve's AI-led paper is wrong. Jonathan is one of the few physicists who are still 'curmudgeonly' about AI.
The differing viewpoints made for a fascinating discussion. We discussed AI, the generator-verifier protocol, Steve's paper on nonlinear quantum mechanics.
This will be especially interesting to students. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I really enjoyed my discussion with @Kaju_Nut and @hsu_steve about the use of AI in physics. They describe me as a curmudgeon, but I'm just cautious about how well these tools can accelerate insight and delusion equally well!
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
Has AI cracked physics? Or can it only produce slop?
I sat down with two physicists who have differing views on this.
Stephen Hsu @hsu_steve is the author of a paper whose central idea came from AI. Steve is bullish about AI in physics.
Jonathan Oppenheim @postquantum has argued that Steve's AI-led paper is wrong. Jonathan is one of the few physicists who are still 'curmudgeonly' about AI.
The differing viewpoints made for a fascinating discussion. We discussed AI, the generator-verifier protocol, Steve's paper on nonlinear quantum mechanics.
This will be especially interesting to students. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
🤦 This is why the public doesn’t trust scientists...
New Scientist
@newscientist
Physicists finally know whether black holes destroy the information contained in infalling matter. The problem is that the answer hasn’t lit the way to a new understanding of space-time www.newscientist.com/article/mg26435140-700-solving-steph…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Luigi Foschini
@luigifoschini
"The history of the internet is worth remembering : we were promised wisdom and universal access to knowledge, and we got some of that, but we also got conspiracy theories and misinformation at unprecedented scale. AI will surely do exactly this to science. It will accelerate the best researchers but also amplify the worst tendencies. It will generate insight and bullshit in roughly equal measure."
Jonathan Oppenheim @postquantum
Not Even Wrong
@notevenwrong
New post: Theoretical Physics Slop www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=15362
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
OpenAI leadership (@gdb, @markchen90) are promoting a paper in Physics Letters B where GPT-5 proposed the main idea — possibly the first peer-reviewed paper where an LLM generated the core contribution. One small problem: GPT-5's idea tests the wrong thing. 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It was accepted (with revisions)😀. I've updated my blog post at superposer.substack.com/p/we-are-in-the-era-of-science-slop 6/6
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Woops, the link to the manuscript was truncated. It's at scirate.com/arxiv/2512.07809 7/6
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
I have gone back and forth on the "first physics paper where the idea came from AI" by @hsu_steve. In an earlier thread, I confessed to being impressed after a first read. But since then, @postquantum pointed out an issue with the paper.
I decided to write a long post (link below), laying out all the details of the paper, so that the expert reader can form their own opinion.
My own verdict: AI has entered its grad student arc in physics. It can come up with good ideas, but following its ideas blindly without scrutiny will result in slop. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We are in the era of Science Slop! (and it's exciting): open.substack.com/pub/superposer/p/we-are-in-the-era-of-s…
Greg Brockman
@gdb
peer-reviewed theoretical physics article where the main idea came from GPT-5:
steve hsu
@hsu_steve
I think I’ve published the first research article in theoretical physics in which the main idea came from an AI - GPT5 in this case. The physics research paper itself (on QFT and state-dependent quantum mechanics) has been published in Physics Letters B.
I've written an accompanying AI paper describing the Generator - Verifier method I used to obtain useful research results from frontier LLMs. It may be of interest to other physicists and to AI researchers.
From the AI paper:
... models sometimes make very simple mistakes (e.g. in calculation) and also even make incorrect conceptual leaps that are superficially plausible. The second type of error can lead even expert researchers astray, consuming large amounts of effort to detect and correct. Research with an LLM might be compared to collaboration with a brilliant but unreliable human genius who is capable of deep insights but also of errors both simple and profound.
Fortunately, both types of errors can be strongly suppressed by using structured orchestration of multiple model instances, greatly improving reliability. A Generate - Verify protocol, in which one model produces a step forward and another model instance independently checks it, reduces hallucination errors significantly compared to single-pass generation. ...
The physics paper (abstract below) derives new operator integrability conditions required for foliation independence (necessary for integrability of quantum field theory; cf Tomonaga-Schwinger) that are very difficult to satisfy in any modifcation of quantum mechanics that is "state dependent" - i.e., deviates from linear Schrodinger evolution.
Whether quantum evolution is EXACTLY linear is one of the most fundamental questions in all of science. It has implications for quantum computing and quantum foundations - i.e., whether we live in an Everettian multiverse! -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
Astrophysicist Steve Desch breaks down Avi Loeb's terrible statistics regarding the "close approaches" of the interstellar comet #3iatlas.
tl;dr The comet does not pass abnormally close to solar system planets.
Full discussion: youtube.com/watch?v=B4wp_Y1RGXk
#aviloeb #alien #uaps -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I had this exact experience with my feed, but now it's back to slop and Nazis, anyone else have this happen?
atulit
@atulit_gaur
DO NOT TOUCH THE ALGORITHM IT IS PERFECT
I am seeing maths posts, physics posts and posts from people I follow -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Great article on quadratic gravity, and why researchers are attracted to it (it's renormalisable). The pure gravity action of postquantum-classical gravity is the same us that of quadratic gravity and doesn't suffer from ghosts! arxiv.org/abs/2402.17844
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
Is gravity made of particles? The math has proved so dysfunctional that many physicists have abandoned the approach altogether. But in one corner of the theoretical-physics world, the particle approach to gravity is staging a comeback.
www.quantamagazine.org/old-ghost-theory-of-quantum-gravit… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The #qip2026 list of accepted papers is out! qip2026.lu.lv/programme/accepted-papers/ highlighting some of the important papers in quantum computing in the past year. This is a fantastic slice from a very rich landscape. Congratulations to the authors!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
A recent @Nature article claims that classical (unquantised) gravity produces entanglement. We show that their model does not produce entanglement. Even if the model produced entanglement, it would be mediated by the quantised matter interaction, and not gravity.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
article at scirate.com/arxiv/2511.07348. Elizabeth Wilson and I teamed up with Chiara Marletto, and Vlatko Vedral, following on from our respective superposer.substack.com/p/no-classical-spacetime-cant-pro… & scirate.com/arxiv/2510.19969. See also today's @PhysicsWorld
which 'both-sides' it. physicsworld.com/a/classical-gravity-may-entangle-matter-… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Steven N. Durlauf
@sndurlauf
In light of James Watson's death, I post this article which clarifies Rosalind Franklin's contributions to the discovery of the structure of DNA. It is richer than the conventional narrative.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01313-5 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
How often do you find yourself wishing for a newsletter that covered fundamental physics in way that was accessible but not dumbed down? Pretty often, I am sure!
Well, here it is. My free newsletter--"The Spacetime Beat".
nirmalyakajuri.substack.com -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
🍿🍿🍿
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
It has occurred to me that the insistence on treating gravity as just a Yang-Mills theory might have something to do with why we have so far failed to come up with a workable theory of quantum gravity.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We'll enjoy it while it lasts!
Timothy Gowers @wtgowers
@wtgowers
I crossed an interesting threshold yesterday, which I think many other mathematicians have been crossing recently as well. In the middle of trying to prove a result, I identified a statement that looked true and that would, if true, be useful to me. 1/3
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Michael Nielsen
@michael_nielsen
This thread is very interesting:
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
That was a better answer.
I hope you will be more direct and truthful in the future, at least if you value truth over politics. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Scientists for Palestine
@Sci4Pal
Register here for the talk of @wtgowers
us02web.zoom.us/meeting/register/pc6g8-O2QHeLZ2PqRrwFxQ -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Another day, another arxiv paper claiming that classical gravity can produce entanglement. Last week's Nature paper continues to cause confusion. But classical fields can't create entanglement *even if* they directly couple two masses. Link to my updated substack post 👇
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Comment at superposer.substack.com/p/no-classical-spacetime-cant-pro…. Original post at superposer.substack.com/p/no-classical-spacetime-cant-pro…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
No, they do not! I'll try to write up a reply in the next day or two.
nature
@Nature
Nature research paper: Classical theories of gravity produce entanglement
go.nature.com/3Jb5Qyi
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
As promised... No, classical spacetime can’t produce entanglement. I can create entanglement by turning a knob on a laser, but the knob isn't mediating the entanglement. Is the knob "producing" the entanglement? open.substack.com/pub/superposer/p/no-classical-spacetime…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
No, they do not! I'll try to write up a reply in the next day or two.
nature
@Nature
Nature research paper: Classical theories of gravity produce entanglement
go.nature.com/3Jb5Qyi -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Timothy Nguyen
@IAmTimNguyen
As AI systems grow more powerful in solving problems, expertise will increasingly shift towards knowing which problems are the important and interesting ones to solve. And that has always been where the greatest difficulty lies.
If you were transported back to the time of Newton and had calculators and all the compute you wanted, you would not have invented calculus without his insight and genius. Postulating universal laws of motion and gravitation is something that does not come "for free" with additional tools.
The AI explosion makes it an exciting time to be a scientist or a mathematician. Increasingly being able to outsource the complex aspects of problem solving frees us to focus on an irreplaceable, perhaps unteachable aspect of human-driven inquiry: the art of asking the right question. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
What if the measurement problem isn't about explaining how the classical world emerges from the quantum world...
...but about what happens when quantum systems interact with something that's already classical?
Turns out, the collapse postulate + Born rule emerge!
🧵👇1/5Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
A natural candidate for the classical system? Spacetime itself. Quantum field theory appears to require a classical spacetime to be well defined. We demand [φ(x),φ(y)]=0 for spacelike separated points. But "spacelike" presupposes a definite causal structure—a classical metric.
3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Now here's the remarkable part: we just apply standard classical probability theory to the classical system.
Using a change of measure (standard tool from finance/probability), the Born rule ( |ψ|²)emerges automatically. No measurement postulate needed. No many worlds. 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Crucially, the quantum state remains pure at all time, conditioned on the classical trajectory. No decoherence! One world, not many. Both systems trace a single definite (but unpredictable) path through their configuration spaces. 5/5
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Maite Arcos's PhD results are hitting the arxiv! A resource theory of gambling, and a paper on adversarial thermodynamics are out today. Gambling provides an operational way to quantify who has more information. And it can be extended into the quantum domain!🧵1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
scirate.com/arxiv/2510.08418 and scirate.com/arxiv/2510.08298 with Renato Renner, Takahiro Sagawa, and Philippe Faist. We find a risk–reward trade-off governed by Rényi divergences. The resource theory framework unifies gambling, utility theory, and hypothesis testing. 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
And it allows us to extend gambling into other settings (like thermodynamics) and into the quantum domain where we use it to quantify what it means for competing agents to know more in a quantum world. 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Renyi divergences emerge when agents bet (or "invest" as some people call it), over a finite number of rounds. In the limit of an infinite number of bets we recover the Kelly Criterion, given in terms of Relative entropy distances (KL divergences). Such a fun project! 4/4
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
A calculation by the late physicist Freeman Dyson suggested that no plausible experiment could be conducted to confirm the existence of gravitons, the hypothetical particles of gravity. A new proposal overturns that conventional wisdom. www.quantamagazine.org/it-might-be-possible-to-detect-gra…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Timothy Gowers @wtgowers
@wtgowers
This sort of thing is interesting and nice, but calling it “new theorems” is slightly misleading when we’re talking about improved bounds discovered through a big search.
Wes Roth
@WesRoth
AlphaEvolve Just Helped Prove New Theorems in Complexity Theory
Google DeepMind's AlphaEvolve just made real breakthroughs in theoretical computer science.
Instead of generating full proofs, it discovered new combinatorial structures that plug into existing proof frameworks, leading to verified, publishable theorems in complexity theory.
The team improved the inapproximability bound for MAX-4-CUT and found massive Ramanujan graphs never seen before, all with provable correctness. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Superconformal Hassaan
@Hassaan_PHY
Ok this paper is interesting. It is written by physics and philosophy people.
#physics #scicomm
arxiv.org/abs/2509.21159 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The electromagnetism is strong in @QuantumAephraim's lab!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ross Douthat
@Douthat60
This week's "Interesting Times" is a conversation with my colleague @ezraklein about the moment, and the condition of progressivism:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVL69ZfvhuQ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Sen. Bernie Sanders
@SenSanders
Yes, the war in Gaza is a genocide.
I hope you’ll take a moment to read my op-ed here:
www.sanders.senate.gov/op-eds/it-is-genocide/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Eliezer Yudkowsky ⏹️
@ESYudkowsky
"If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies" is now out. Please buy a copy before this week ends Sep 20, so the book gets on the bestseller lists. And if you have remaining questions after reading, check the ONLINE RESOURCES, now online. ifanyonebuilds.it
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Rob Bensinger ⏹️
@robbensinger
THIS IS YOUR LAST CHANCE TO PREORDER THE BOOK EVER 'CAUSE STARTING TOMORROW THAT'S JUST CALLED ORDERING
Rob Bensinger ⏹️
@robbensinger
FOUR DAYS UNTIL THE BOOK CAME OUT TWO DAYS AGO
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mosab Abu Toha
@MosabAbuToha
Israeli forces have destroyed what remained of the Islamic University of Gaza.
After two airstrikes, the building was left standing, damaged but not collapsed. Families, desperate to retrieve belongings they couldn’t take during the brief window they were given before the strikes, returned to the site.
As they entered the building, a third strike hit.
Many are now buried beneath the rubble. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Raghu Mahajan
@raghumahajan
The following statement on Gaza is signed by 14 Nobel Prize winners, 5 Fields medalists, 20 Breakthrough Prize winners, 34 Dirac Prize winners and 4 Wolf prize winners.
sites.google.com/view/statement-by-scientists-gaza -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The CERN whitepaper, on testing the quantum nature of gravity, has even more co-authors and is now available on the arxiv. Check it out! (link in the reply)
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Davide Castelvecchi
@dcastelvecchi
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
nature
@Nature
There is one fundamental phenomenon that quantum physics can't explain: gravity
go.nature.com/3JciqNm -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Scientists for Palestine
@Sci4Pal
The Alice and Bob of quantum information theory became Amira and Basim in the lectures of @postquantum
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Gautam Satishchandran
@8piGSatish
One visitor is a seminar. Two visitors is a symposium. Always an enjoyable to catch up with @postquantum and Sougato Bose at UCL and attend the Summer Symposium on Quantum Information and Spacetime
youtu.be/HX0KvMVvo60 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Such an inspiring event!
African Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Ghana
@AIMSGhana
Reflecting on a truly remarkable past week!
From thought-provoking panels & scientific talks to groundbreaking student pitches & an excellent public lecture, the #aimsqtedu25 was a celebration of #innovation, collaboration & the #quantum future.🌍⚛️
#quantumafrica #qtedu #stem -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jean Fisch
@Jean__Fisch
Portugal saw an intense heat wave (with temperatures in the low 40°C) in the 1st week of July
And invariably, the (remarkably good and timely) weekly surveillance monitoring from @SNS_Portugal picked up quite a spike of extra deaths (~400) in that week
www.insa.min-saude.pt/category/informacao-e-cultura-cient… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Douglas Natelson
@NanoscaleViews
🧪 ⚛️ There are signs that the US Senate is resisting calls for giant cuts to science agencies. Now is the time to push on the House appropriators, to try to stave off catastrophic damage to US science and engineering research and competitiveness. nanoscale.blogspot.com/2025/07/us-science-funding-now-tim…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm at @AIMSGhana this week for a quantum hackathon. Which is apparently called a Quantathon! Excited to interact with great students and researchers from across Africa. Live feed and schedule below. I'll give a public lecture on Friday.
African Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Ghana
@AIMSGhana
The #aims #qtedu Quantathon kicks off soon!
Don’t miss the Opening Ceremony, streaming live on YouTube.
Date: 08/07/2025
Time: 9:00 AM GMT
youtube.com/live/GjBKD-BkBog
Let’s launch this journey into quantum innovation together!🌍
#aimsqtedu25 #stemleadership #quantumafrica #ghana -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
African Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Ghana
@AIMSGhana
6 days to go!🚀
The #aimsqtedu25 takes off in Accra, #ghana from 8–11 July. We are gearing up for the #quantathon & Closed-Door #workshops!
Also, don’t miss the Public Lecture “Our Quantum Future” with Prof. Jonathan Oppenheim on July 11!!
Register via: qtedu.aims.edu.gh/how-to-participate/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Alon-Lee Green - ألون-لي جرين - אלון-לי גרין 🟣
@AlonLeeGreen
הווידאו הזה צולם היום בעזה. עוד סצינה דיסטופית ממשחקי הרעב של עזה. עוד יום שבו מכניסים למיליוני אנשים מורעבים טיפת אוכל ואז צופים בהם מסכנים את חייהם כדי להשיג משהו שיציל את משפחותיהם. עוד יום שבו הרגנו שם 112 בני אדם, רבים מהם ילדים, אחרים אנשים שעמדו בתור לאוכל. עוד יום בעזה 💔
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Pearl Freier
@PearlF
Derek Lowe shared science journalist @dangaristo's B__sky post that the National Science Foundation has been evicted from their building by the HUD Secretary (according to NSF employees he said). He said that the HUD Secretary & VIrginia's governor (Youngkin) will be making an announcement tomorrow
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ihab Hassan
@IhabHassane
Horrific: A video from one of the so-called 'humanitarian distribution sites' of GHF in Gaza today.
Does this look like humane to you? -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Alon-Lee Green - ألون-لي جرين - אלון-לי גרין 🟣
@AlonLeeGreen
HAPPENING NOW ON THE BORDER OF GAZA: We are here, thousands of Jews & Palestinians protesting against the annihilation of Gaza, after the police tried to forbid us from marching to Gaza. We're here against the starvation, the killing of children and against our government.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Andreas is wise, but because I'm procrastinating marking 70 exams I'm picking my battles Everything, Everywhere, All at Once.
Andreas Karch
@karch_andreas
I fight my battles one at a time. You do have a point. I do agree that it is often a problem that some of these issues are "well known" from discussions people have over lunch, but not brought out into the open often enough. ->
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
On Sunday, I'll be at the @cheltfestivals Science festival, with @apontzen, Hiranya Peiris and Chamkaur Ghag, discussing dark matter, and whether it could be the result of stochastic fluctuations in spacetime. If you're there, come say hello! (link in replies)
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Does anyone else associate 'stochastic' with processes, and 'random' or 'probabilistic' with variables? Spacetime evolves stochastically. The outcome of the coin toss is probabilistic. Whether the coin is heads or tails is random. Just me?
Probability Fact
@ProbFact
'Probabilistic' comes from Latin. 'Stochastic' comes from Greek.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Scientists for Palestine
@Sci4Pal
📢To all students in Palestine interested in knowing more about quantum physics : We are very happy to announce our Palestinian Advanced Physics School (PAPS 2025) at the University of Jordan between 26th — 31st July 2025! 1/3
📷 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Carbon Brief
@CarbonBrief
NEW – Analysis: Clean energy just put China’s CO2 emissions into reverse for first time | @laurimyllyvirta
Read here: www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-clean-energy-just-put-chinas… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm at the Quantum Symposium at @UniofNottingham and they have a real working Lego interferometer!
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
And a black hole merger (Ringdown by @Conradshawcross)
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
And (apparently) the multiverse.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If we want fewer psychopaths in charge, we should start with ranked-choice voting. It’s about as complicated as picking pizza toppings with friends.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Andreas Karch
@karch_andreas
We just finished a brutal PhD recruitment season here at UT Physics. Traditionally we make about 105 offers to recruit 35 PhD students. Being a PhD student is a job: while working towards their degree students get paid either to teach or to do do research (about half each). 1/n
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The final session, on "Table-top quantum experiments for gravity" with Flaminia Giacomini, Richard Howl and Sougato Bose, closes out the QISS conference in Vienna . The recorded talks and subsequent discussion should appear online in the coming days, and I'll post the link below.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I've been asking various AI models math questions. I'm sure they'll one day be impressive mathematicians, but wow, they're insufferable! Confidently wrong, dopamine-addicted, and desperate for likes. I wrote up my experiences (link in the reply).
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
update: Ernest Davis and @GaryMarcus have posted about a much more quantitative analysis at garymarcus.substack.com/p/reports-of-llms-mastering-math-…. It jibes with my experience, but I think it's also important to acknowledge how fast these models are improving.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Great work, now Google thinks the Dubnový Blázen problem is a real problem in graph theory (it's Czech for "April Fools").
Timothy Gowers @wtgowers
@wtgowers
It's finally happened: after several unsuccessful attempts, I found a prompt that got Grok to solve a maths problem (the well-known Dubnovy Blazen problem in graph theory) I've been working on for over a year. How long till it's better than human mathematicians across the board?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I also love that they use Greek symbols for 4 and 1/4 to make it look more mathy.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Haaretz.com
@haaretzcom
Israel recently committed the largest child massacre in its history. The numbers are not reported in the Israeli media, and if they are – it's always minimized | Opinion | Hanin Majadli
www.haaretz.com/opinion/2025-03-21/ty-article-opinion/.pr… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Scientists for Palestine
@Sci4Pal
We just launched the fundraising campaign for our ambitious 2025 plans! Please share and retweet in case you support our goals for 2025: a summer school, an international meeting, a scholasticide archive and an EU lawsuit!
www.gofundme.com/f/support-palestinian-science-with-scien… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
There sure are a lot of galaxies out there!
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The video is part of DESIs map of our universe. Each snowflake in the blizzard is a galaxy. Not sure if it's terrifying or comforting, but it's definitely jaw-dropping. More videos and information on the dark energy survey data at noirlab.edu/public/news/noirlab2513/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It wasn't long ago that @skdh famously critical of new physics theories, highlighted the postquantum theory of gravity as one of the top five breakthroughs of 2024. But is the honeymoon over? 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The new proposal is closely related to our proposal to test the quantum nature of gravity via the "decoherence diffusion trade-off" with some additional assumptions. I've just posted an update and explainer about the experiments here: open.substack.com/pub/superposer/p/testing-the-nature-of-…. 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My view? I think the nature of spacetime is now a question for experiments, since physicists tend to make unwarranted assumptions about the laws of physics. We should instead turn to nature to guide us, and fortunately in this case, we can! 4/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Not surprising, but massive nonetheless. In case the danger posed by closed LLMs controlled by oligarchs is not clear enough. uk.pcmag.com/ai/156828/grok-was-briefly-instructed-not-to…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Flying Dutch Fella 🇺🇦🇳🇱🇪🇺 🇬🇪🇨🇦🇬🇱
@FlyingDutchPall
Bruh it changed x.com/i/grok/share/C25m85i7gO4WOWF233svB1jHp
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Carney
@four_form
This Microsoft qubit thing is a great preview for people who think industry could take over science from universities and national labs. Completely different incentives, bad science.
Worth noting the >100 authors of the paper are probably all paid >2x a typical academic salary.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The press release vs the paper
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The press release vs the paper
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Another awkward gesture @ADL ?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Quantum twitter has mostly moved to the other place. So if you're interested in some profiles or resources to help make sense of today's announcement, check out the link in the reply below. Since this post will likely be throttled, please RT if you see this. 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
and here we go.... x.com/Microsoft/status/1892245131895423158 🍿🍿🍿 3/
Microsoft
@Microsoft
A breakthrough in quantum computing. Majorana 1 brings us closer to harnessing millions of potential qubits working together to solve the unsolvable—from new medicines to revolutionary materials—all on a single chip. #quantumcomputing #quantumready
news.microsoft.com/source/features/ai/microsofts-majorana…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
bsky.app/profile/postquantum.bsky.social/post/3likcekuurs2h 4/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
μαρία
@MariaSpiropulu
gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/39176
gracedb.ligo.org/superevents/S250206dm/view
"LIGO’s public event database shows the sky localization, among other parameters, for gravitational wave event S250206dm, which could be our first multi-messenger event to feature gravitational waves and neutrinos, and may yet include an electromagnetic counterpart as well. " www.astronomerstelegram.org?read=17021
@LIGO @uw_icecube chime-experiment.ca/en -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
David Issacharoff
@davidiss
The Educational Bookshop in East Jerusalem is full with shoppers in solidarity a day after the Israel Police raided the Palestinian store, arrested its owners and confiscated books. They dropped the charges of incitement but still detain them for ‘disturbing the public order’
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Whiteson
@DanielWhiteson
Up next in QG week is a conversation with @postquantum about his theory of post-quantum gravity.
Could spacetime itself really be non-deterministic?
(link below)
Daniel Whiteson
@DanielWhiteson
It's quantum gravity week on @DandKUniverse this week!
Episode on string theory with @ThomasVanRiet2 and on post-quantum gravity with @postquantum. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Whiteson
@DanielWhiteson
It's quantum gravity week on @DandKUniverse this week!
Episode on string theory with @ThomasVanRiet2 and on post-quantum gravity with @postquantum. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Please share to spread the word: There is an opportunity for a PhD studentship on the postquantum theory of gravity, or experiments probing the quantum nature of spacetime. Deadline for UK students is Jan 31, while internationals should email today. See www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/item/studentship.shtml
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Physical Review Letters
@PhysRevLett
The T2K and Super-Kamiokande collaborations have teamed up, resulting in a finding that 𝐶𝑃 conservation in neutrino oscillations is disfavored at the 2𝜎 level go.aps.org/3BHUYEr
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Curt Jaimungal
@TOEwithCurt
Sabine @skdh announced in a recent video ( www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUgRCBAvyeg ) that in her top 5 physics news of 2024 is Jonathan Oppenheim's @postquantum stochastic gravity approach. I agree. I've spoken to Jonathan twice about this topic. Once here youtu.be/NKOd8imBa2s and the other more technical here youtu.be/6Z_p3viqW1g
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Dan is correct! Many arguments or experiments which purport to show that spacetime is quantum, construct strawmen theories which no one believes could be fundamental. 1/
Daniel Carney
@four_form
This paper shows nothing.
The masses are never in meaningful superposition: their state would decohere *long* before the gravitational field (semiclassical or otherwise) could measure them.
They verbatim assume this doesn't happen, which is insane.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
To be fair to Page and Geilker, they wrote their paper at a time when everyone thought the only alternative to quantum gravity was to use expectation values, as in the semiclassical Einstein’s equations or Schrödinger-Newton. 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If treated as fundamental, these theories are mathematically inconsistent. The expectation value of the stress-energy tensor of a planet in superposition is the same as two half planets, so the semi-classical Eqns G=8π<T> make no sense 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Coincidently, our 2022 arxiv paper on “Healthier semiclassical dynamics” with Isaac Layton and Zach Weller-Davies, finally came out this week in Quantum! quantum-journal.org/papers/q-2024-12-16-1565/ 4/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This provides a potential resolution to the measurement problem of quantum theory – quantum states localise due to backreacting on spacetime. The dynamics ensures this happens with a probability given by the Born rule. The measurement postulate is not needed! 7/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Shout out to early works by Nicolas Gisin, Blanchard & Jadczyk, Lajos Diosi, @AntoineTilloy, Kafri, @quantum_jake, Gerard Milburn, and David Poulin. 8/8
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Isaac Kim
@Isaac__kim
Lately I've been seeing a lot of hype around quantum computing on this platform. Are those bots or humans? Either way, what I'm seeing is concerning. I want to provide an honest perspective on the current status quo, which is hopefully useful. Long story short, I do think a lot of exciting progress on QC will be made over the next few years. But I doubt those progress will be commercial applications.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Eric Cavalcanti
@ericcavalcanti
This is really not a good parallel. If “quantum mechanics is a theory of amplitudes” then tell me how we experimentally test whether the amplitudes agree with our observations and we’re squarely back to the problem of interpretation.
Jonathan Gorard
@getjonwithit
The apparent "philosophical problems" of quantum mechanics are not unique to QM at all: they are in fact the same problems that arise whenever one attempts to construct an abstract model of reality. We can see these problems already in high school-level mechanics. (1/14)
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The crackpots will have the last laugh when journal editors stop replying to 𝑜𝑢𝑟 emails because they can’t tell our papers from AI-generated pseudononsense.
Daniel Carney
@four_form
I've had a long-standing policy of replying to any "crackpot" emails I get, as long as they sound like they're in good faith, with some encouragement and feedback.
Unfortunately I'm now getting a stream of AI-crackpot emails, engaging with which is a complete waste of time... -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Checking out the list of accepted talks at QIP, the flagship conference on Quantum Information Processing, is a great way to get some overview of the year in theoretical quantum information processing. Lots of great results! #qip2025 rsvp.duke.edu/event/qip2025/websitePage:4218e218-4e19-45c…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you're going to get scooped, who better to be scooped by than @four_form and Akira Matsumura! Such a fantastic paper, congratulations to both. They consider a simple model of a quantum field interacting with a classical one and compute the scattering cross-section. 1/
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Could gravity be "fundamentally classical"? Akira Matsumura and I analyzed Oppenheim (@postquantum) et al.'s proposal. tl;dr:
A. it appears to have Lorentz-covariant scattering
B. 2—>2 scattering differs at O(1) from the usual Rutherford/Newton answer
arxiv.org/abs/2412.04839Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Their second term could give large corrections in this model. It’s suppressed by G_N^2/c^3, but one should check in the renormalised theory, whether that’s enough. 9/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The good news: these models are rich and reveal unexpected phenomena. What happens when a small mass is induced? For non-linear terms in the action as in GR? We’re far from understanding these theories—this paper and other simple examples will teach us a lot! 10/10
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ulm's Institute of Theoretical Physics
@qubit_ulm
Today we had our @TriniLantano telling us about quantum signatures of gravity via angular momentum entanglement ✨ Can two microspheres interacting only through gravity display quantum features? #quantum #gravity 🍎
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm in Vienna, discussing experimental tests of the quantum nature of spacetime. Markus Arndt and Stefan Gerlich perform interference experiments using macromolecules which test the quantum nature of spacetime via the "decoherence-vs-diffusion trade-off" www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-43348-2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Bill Unruh, Bob Wald and Roger Penrose defend the view that black holes destroy information. www.youtube.com/watch?v=xkOYRnGA_AA I'm sympathetic with this, because the paradox's which arise if information is preserved appear insurmountable. A more technical talk: online.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/fuzzorfire_m13/unruh/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I've returned to X to post this. Science twitter stampedes to Bluesky. Can confirm. www.science.org/content/article/old-twitter-scientific-co…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Okay, we seem to have crashed Bluesky servers. Now we have to come back to X.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
People talk of AI or quantum computers "solving climate change", and yet we already know that fossil fuels cause climate change, there is a low cost alternative, but can't agree to transition away from them. Maybe people mean that AI will help combat misinformation & FF industry?
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
#cop29 NEW TEXT
Finally – draft text on the "UAE dialogue", which was set up to discuss "implementing the global stocktake outcomes"
However, dividing lines over whether to discuss "transition away from fossil fuels" etc – or just finance – remain
THREAD
www.carbonbrief.org/interactive-tracking-negotiating-text…
1/5 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Cliff Burgess
@CburgesCliff
Good news on climate change (tl,dr: the transition is much cheaper than expected, partly due to falling costs and partly due to persistently pessimistic predictions).
Companies are piling in (regardless of US government regulations) because costs are coming down so quickly.
Artlcle from @TheEconomist highlighting work by @matthewgburgess -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ulm's Institute of Theoretical Physics
@qubit_ulm
Today we had Yixuan's final talk of his master's thesis about error-correction-assisted entanglement-based test of quantum gravity 🍎✨ Can entanglement be observed in models with gravitational interation? #quantumgravity #quantumerrorcorrection #entanglement
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Lot's of great folks from physics twitter are active on b.sk (@seanmcarroll @AstroKatie @Kaju_Nut @CburgesCliff etc) and there's been a big uptick in activity. Hope to see some of you over there!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
What @four_form says in this article is 👌. If you want to distinguish quantum gravity from the alternatives, you need to compare the quantum gravity prediction with the alternatives. 1/2
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
In 1925, the photon wars ended. Now the graviton wars have begun.
www.quantamagazine.org/it-might-be-possible-to-detect-gra…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Demonstration of gravitationally mediated entanglement (journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.240401) or proposals by @qubit_ulm @LamiLudovico (journals.aps.org/prx/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevX.14.021022) or using the "decoherence vs diffusion trade-off" ( www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-43348-2) could test quantum gravity. Quantum Info for the win!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Curt Jaimungal
@TOEwithCurt
In today's episode, Chiara Marletto and Professor Vlatko Vedral explore a groundbreaking experiment that could reveal the quantum nature of gravity, potentially challenging Einstein's classical theory of general relativity.
Watch: youtu.be/Uey_mUy1vN0 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Berkeley Lab
@BerkeleyLab
"My colleagues Nick Rodd & Valerie Domcke agree the era of quantum gravity experiments is just starting," says @four_form. "It’s crucial we understand the implications of each measurement as we gather the evidence on whether gravity is quantized." @CERN www.quantamagazine.org/it-might-be-possible-to-detect-gra…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I know it's flogging a dead horse, but I thought this recurring debate would make a good launching point for a series of posts on why it's reasonable to question the quantum nature of gravity. So I started a Substack - follow along for more! open.substack.com/pub/superposer/p/gravity-is-not-a-force…
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
No it's not
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
On my way to Amsterdam to give a talk at the BrainWash festival brainwashfestival.nl/en/festival/ and will later take the sleeper train to Vienna where I'll spend November discussing experiments to test the (post)quantum nature of spacetime. See some of you there?!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Physics question: how would you shorten the period of this harmonic oscillator?
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Today's update. It's now literally 50/50.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Monica Marks
@MonicaLMarks
This interview w/ Coates by @ezraklein is the single best discussion I’ve heard of his new book, “The Message,” so far. It’s fair, intelligent, amicable & mutually critical in edifying ways.
Coates calls Oct. 7 “horrifying” & says violence corrupts. 🧵
open.spotify.com/episode/2vp13PP0HcLwIdGTsa0AeN?t=4773&co… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Simon Lewis
@SimonLLewis
Devastating critique in the second half of this piece on the new carbon capture plans in the UK. www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/oct/11/labour-carb…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Ian was on my PhD committee. Not only super insightful, but also gentle and kind. He wryly noted that all our meetings on measuring time-of-arrival in quantum theory never started on time. Very sad to get this news.
John Preskill
@preskill
Ian Affleck 1952-2024. Ian was my office mate, tennis partner, and good friend when we were Harvard graduate students. We were particle theorists then, but Ian is best remembered for his many deep contributions to quantum condensed matter. A great loss.
phas.ubc.ca/memoriam-ian-affleck-1952-2024 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Simon Oldridge
@SiOldridge
The UK Gov is about to commit £20 billion of public money to carbon capture.
Gov wants to exempt the #ccs industry from rules requiring it to prove that its plans will lower emissions.
Their argument: because the subsidy is just for building the plants - not operating them!
🧵1️⃣
Simon Oldridge
@SiOldridge
This is wild! UK Gov is poised to make a decision unlocking £20 billion of public money for carbon capture #ccs based on an 'Assessment' by the previous Tory Gov.
These subsidies are meant to reduce emissions.
Just look at their excuse to avoid scrutiny😮
🧵1️⃣/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Gautam Satishchandran
@8piGSatish
Thanks to @ictpsaifr for hosting such a wonderful conference on quantum gravity and tabletop experiments!
youtu.be/33xBIbPQQ9k via @YouTube -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ash Jogalekar
@curiouswavefn
Short thread: There are some seminal ideas in the history of science that can be called "wrong but brilliant". They might fail in their original formulation but become enshrined in science later. One of them was Hermann Weyl's idea of a gauge.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Is spacetime quantum, or should we 'gravitize the quantum'? @PBSSpaceTime explores experiments that could test these two alternatives: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAtbzhpI4Js. They also offer a fantastic layperson's intro to the postquantum gravity theory: www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfzosycRoe4.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The talks from the Quantum Information and Quantum Field Theory workshop @ictstifr are up! www.youtube.com/@ICTStalks/videos My talk was on the renormalisation of the postquantum gravity theory, and the relevant bit starts here: youtu.be/dE-_EF0aEK4?t=2262 . 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Here is the path integral for Brownian motion straight out of Feynman and Hibbs. It has higher derivatives, but just describes a free particle being hit by random forces. On average the acceleration (q double dot) is zero, but there are contributions away from this. 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
So classically, higher derivative actions are fine, but in quantum theory, higher derivatives in the action spell trouble (Ostragradsky's instability which implies negative norm "ghosts"). The preprint is available at arxiv.org/abs/2402.17844. 5/5
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I wish I deserved the heretic moniker, but isn’t asking whether spacetime is quantum or classical just common sense? After all, general relativity (GR) - our theory of gravity and spacetime - is special. It isn’t a gauge theory, and gravity isn’t a force. 1/
Curt Jaimungal
@TOEwithCurt
New Episode: Physics Biggest Quantum Heretic
Out now: youtu.be/6Z_p3viqW1g
Jonathan Oppenheim is a renowned theoretical physicist and professor at University College London (UCL), known for his groundbreaking research in quantum information theory, quantum gravity, and the relationship between quantum mechanics and thermodynamics. Jonathan holds a Ph.D. from the University of Cambridge and is recognized for his contributions to the fields of quantum foundations and quantum computation.Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The alternative approach (the postquantum theory), requires the simplest modification to make GR consistent with quantum mechanics. It's also experimentally testable and the pure gravity theory is formally renormalisable, while quantum gravity in 3+1 dimensions is not. 8/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Thanks to Curt for inviting me once again on his show, and check out the other talks in the series at youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZ7ikzmc6zlOYgTu7P4nfjYkv3mkikyBa. For an account of the postquantum theory suitable for a layperson, check out @PBSSpaceTime's recent explainer at youtube.com/watch?v=yfzosycRoe4 9/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
On the other hand, if spacetime is classical, you'd get a larger signal. Which may be counter intuitive. Classical fluctuations have to be larger than quantum ones, to perform the same function (prevent violations of the uncertainty principal when back-reacted upon).
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Verlinde and Zurek, following Hogan, have suggested that quantum gravity could produce observably large vacuum fluctuations.
Maybe! But if so, this would be a huge deviation from basic field theory, in a regime where field theory should work. Details:
arxiv.org/abs/2409.03894 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Tom Andersen
@TAndersen_nSCIr
This video by Matt O'Dowd explains @postquantum's theory of non-quantum gravity.
Since Matt is so good at what he does, the explanation works at many levels of understanding. If you haven't dug into 'postquantum gravity' - here is a great launch point.
youtu.be/yfzosycRoe4 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ulm's Institute of Theoretical Physics
@qubit_ulm
Speaking on hot research topics 🔥, today our master's student Rudi shared his ideas and challenges dealing with hybrid models of gravity and their role in mediating the relation between classical gravity and quantum matter, based on Oppenheim's @postquantum recent works 🍎✨
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Geoff Penington
@quantum_geoff
A cool blog of stories of people who have left physics and what they went on to do. Probably most useful for early career people (undergrad-postdoc) trying to figure out what options exist outside academia yourfutureadventures.blogspot.com?m=1
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
The conference week of Quantum Information, Quantum Field Theory and Gravity at ICTS started with a whole bunch of amazing talks (links 👇).
Morning Session 1
Black Hole Index from Gravitational Path Integral: Ashoke Sen
Holographic Scattering and Non-minimal RT Surfaces: Robert Myers
Morning Session 2
Notions of Color Entanglement: Sumit Das
Minimal Area from Entangled Matrices: Ronak Soni
Afternoon Session 1
What makes Holographic States Special?: Abhijit Gadde
Renormalisation of a Postquantum Theory of Classical Gravity: Jonathan Oppenheim
Afternoon Session 2:
Corolla Polynomial, Associahedron and Gauge Theory S Matrix: Alok Laddha
Emergence of Diffeomorphism from QFT: Roji Pius -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
Combining classical gravity and quantum @postquantum
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Cory Doctorow NO LONGER ON TWIT TER
@doctorow
Certainly, that's the underlying pathology that preserves the scholarly publishing scam, which is one of the most grotesque, wasteful, disgusting frauds in our modern world (and that's saying something, because the field is crowded with many contenders).
17/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
National Institute of Standards and Technology
@NIST
Quantum computers could imperil the security of confidential electronic information, such as emails. To counter this threat, NIST has finalized its set of three encryption algorithms designed to withstand a future quantum computer’s cyberattacks: www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2024/08/nist-releases-first…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Now that the British summer has finally started, I'll be heading to ICTS Bengaluru for the monsoon season, and the workshop in Quantum Information, Quantum Field Theory and Gravity. The talks will be recorded and the program is here www.icts.res.in/program/qftg Looking forward to it!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mark Stone
@Stone_SkyNews
A truly haunting image… back and forth they are moved. Through a landscape that’s ever more unbelievable.
Raed Sadi
@GazasOwn
Happening now in my city, Khan Younis, again...
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Hayata Yamasaki
@HayataYamasaki
Preprint uploaded. We prove the generalized quantum Stein’s lemma and the 2nd law of resource theories, both static and dynamical. Grateful for the scientific feedback last time and hoping constructive reactions again. Joint work with Masahito Hayashi. arxiv.org/abs/2408.02722
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Addendum:
Q: If a highly squeezed graviton mode hits LIGO, what will the detector see?
A: arxiv.org/abs/2408.00094
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Q: can you make a detector that's sensitive to single gravitons? how about shot noise in a squeezed GW?
A: yes.
Q: ok, then if you see a signal, would that prove that gravity is quantized?
A: no.
w/ Valerie Domcke and Nick Rodd @CERN (short detail 🧵)
arxiv.org/abs/2308.12988 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Physicists post their papers on the @arxiv to make them freely available to the public. Then the public pay a small fortune to publishers like @ElsevierPhysics to do it again. We are being scammed @SciTechgovuk.
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
A new preprint estimates "that, globally, a total of $8.349 billion ($8.968 billion in 2023 US dollars) were spent on [article processing charges] APCs between 2019 and 2023. arxiv.org/abs/2407.16551
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Demis Hassabis
@demishassabis
Advanced mathematical reasoning is a critical capability for modern AI. Today we announce a major milestone in a longstanding grand challenge: our hybrid AI system attained the equivalent of a silver medal at this year’s International Math Olympiad!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Hello people! There is a lot of separate, independent
evidence for dark matter besides the fact that galactic rotation curves become flat. That's why I'm pretty excited by this -- in postquantum-classical gravity, spacetime diffuses during inflation to produce phantom matter. 1/
Emanuele Panella
@e_panella98
My new article in collaboration with @postquantum and @apontzen explores the cosmological effects of spacetime diffusion. We show that the diffusion leads to the appearance of phantom dark matter, whose energy density is positive on average. 1/2
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In the article with @apontzen and @e_panella98, we find there is an alternative explanation. Spacetime diffused at early times in cosmological history in such a way that it could bend light rays to give the appearance of phantom cold dark matter. 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It also has the potential to seed structure formation. As always, this is early days. We need a better understanding of the theory before we will know whether this effect is strong enough or produces the observed CMB power spectrum. 5/5
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ciaran O'Hare
@cajohare
XENONnT have detected solar neutrinos... the neutrino fog has arrived
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
SIAM Activity Group on Dynamical Systems
@DynamicsSIAM
"In 1956, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Prof Claude Shannon writes a one-page article trying to curb the information theory #hype."
(terse text above by Alex Vasilescu; h/t Palle Jorgensen & Carina Curto) -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ferlaino Group
@FerlainoGroup
🚨 Big news on arXiv! 🚨 Over 30 female Quantum Professors have united to release a powerful Manifesto of Values. They reflect on gender issues in quantum physics and call for change with a clear set of values. Let's support and amplify their voices! #womeninstem #quantumphysics
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Sam D'Amico
@sdamico
Why no one has home storage — YET
Battery pack prices have totally collapsed — at high volumes, this means that enough batteries to *totally flatten* a home’s peak electricity demand cost no more than about $1,500. That means never paying for electricity from 4-9PM. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
One consequence of @UKRI_News forcing journals to publish under a "cc-by" license, is that scientists have little choice but to let their work be fed to AIs who can then pay-wall the AI, without any compensation to the public, nor requirement for the work to stay open. 1/
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
wondering how many academics realize that scientific publishers have almost certainly sold off copyrights on their papers to any AI company willing to pay money and that the authors of those papers will see nil of it
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
There are other open access licenses such as "cc-sa" or "cc-nc" which would ensure that derivatives of our research stays open to the public but UKRI strong-arms journals into not allowing them. www.openaccess.nl/en/creative-commons-licenses 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is a massive transfer of wealth from the public to publishers (the taxpayer pays publishers to publish our work even though it already exists as open access on the @arxiv). Remember this when AI companies are making fortunes while public funding for research is stretched. 3/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Experimental evidence for stochastic fluctuations of spacetime!
Paul Graham
@paulg
If this were true it would probably be the most exciting thing that has happened in the history of humanity.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nirmalya Kajuri
@Kaju_Nut
QFT lecture notes from Daniel Harlow. Covers some untypical topics for QFT1 like Unruh effect and Reeh-Schlieder, Haag-Kastler axioms, Polchinski's theorem on RG flows, calculation of Ising critical exponents using the epsilon expansion
www.mit.edu/~harlow/HarlowQFT1.pdf -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Apply for a research fellowship hosted by us! Some deadlines for expressions of interest are as early as May 31st. If you'd like to pursue research in quantum information and spacetime, drop me an email, and please RT or let excellent candidates know! www.ucl.ac.uk/physics-astronomy/research/research-fellows…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If spacetime is quantum, we usually operate in the regime where it behaves classically from an effective point of view. What is the limit of a quantum system such that one subsystem behaves classically, while the rest remain quantum? To hedge our bets, we try to find out! 1/
PRX Quantum
New theoretical work demonstrates how consistent models of effective classical-quantum dynamics emerge in a limit of quantum theory. @postquantum
go.aps.org/4bs7xzNPost not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is often the regime of interest, for example, in cosmology where vacuum fluctuations are treated quantum mechanically, while back-reacting on a spacetime we treat classically. Or in blackhole evaporation. Crucially, we are able to go beyond mean field approximations. 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We expect this "quantum-classical limit" will also allow us to make comparisons in experiments, between what quantum gravity predicts and what alternative theories predict, allowing us to better probe the quantum nature of spacetime. 4/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ludovico Lami
@LamiLudovico
Gravity might be quantum or not. How do we find out? As Julen Pedernales, Martin B. Plenio (@qubit_ulm) and I show in our freshly published paper, there is more than one way to find out. A thread 1/
journals.aps.org/prx/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevX.14.021022 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Alvaro M. Alhambra
@AlhambraAlvaro
Being an editor for quantum is a great way of contributing to the scientific community, and to build alternative models of publishing - consider applying!
Quantum
@quantumjournal
The 2024 Call for Editors for Quantum Journal is now open!
Deadline: 21st of May.
quantum-journal.org/call-for-editors-2024/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Neil Turok kicks off Cosmological Frontiers with a challenge calling for radical ideas. You can watch via zoom and the talks will be recorded at indico.ph.ed.ac.uk/event/277/timetable/. Tomorrow, I'll give an overview of recent progress in postquantum classical gravity. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The conference is in Edinburgh where Peter Higgs wrote his famous paper introducing condensed matter into high energy physics, and today we observe his recent passing. Neil recalls that Peter only organised one conference. And forgot to order the coffee. 2/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Additional PhD funding for a home student may now be available in our group. If you know any UK students who might be interested in research on the quantum (or not quantum) nature of gravity, please retweet or pass this along. Info at www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/item/studentship.shtml
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
"Despite the tragedy unfolding under our watch, the Israeli authorities informed the UN that they will no longer approve any UNRWA food convoys to the north" of Gaza - @UNRWA
More here ⤵️
news.un.org/en/story/2024/03/1147916 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Shane Ross
@RossDynamicsLab
In 2000, there were multiple breakthroughs in our understanding of solutions of the #3bodyproblem. One was the discovery of the figure 8 solution, where 3 equal sized stars chase each other around on a figure 8-shaped loop, discovered by Chenciner & Montgomery
1/n arxiv.org/pdf/math/0011268.pdf -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Umesh Vazarani kicks off the "Quantum Complexity: Quantum PCP, Area Laws, and Quantum Gravity" workshop at the @SimonsInstitute. Talks will be recorded and available at simons.berkeley.edu/workshops/quantum-complexity-quantum-…. I'll be around all week, come say hi!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I was taught to always start by solving the harmonic oscillator version of the problem first. Woops. Congrats to Muhammad Sajjad @andrearss96 @quantum_maite -- a quantum oscillator interacting with an oscillator treated classically scirate.com/arxiv/2403.07479
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Seamus "there's no Nobel prize for safety" Davis, explains the OGRE experiment which aims to test whether spacetime has a quantum nature, via gravitationally mediated entanglement. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We had a tour of the OGRE lab in Oxford, as part of the Gravity in the Quantum World workshop. Here's Jan Knapp holding an arm of what will become a miniature Cavendish balance, cooled to milli Kelvin, and put in superposition. 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Here are some photos from Day 1 x.com/postquantum/status/1767213487263003002 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Roger Penrose as Wigner's friend, and under a portrait of Wigner, discusses what he sees as our incorerent theory of quantum mechanics 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Roger Penrose as Wigner's friend, and under a portrait of Wigner, discusses what he sees as our incorerent theory of quantum mechanics 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Before that, @four_form discusses their experiment to test the quantum Vs classical nature of gravity. It's been done in what was once Clauser's lab. Clauser was famously told to not bother testing Bell's theorem. He did it anyway and was awarded the Nobel prize for it. 2/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Stephanie Wehner
@StephWehner
Happy international women's day! #internationalwomensday if you are not a women, this day is a great opportunity to ask a woman on how it's like for them to be a woman - and in science what's it's like for them to be a woman in science, you may be surprised 1/n
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
UCL Mathematical & Physical Sciences
@uclmaps
Join the lecture by Prof @postquantum (UCL Physics & Astronomy) on 15 Mar, outlining his research group’s theory which consistently couples classical #spacetime with #quantum #mechanics, dubbed “a postquantum theory of classical gravity”. In person/online: www.ucl.ac.uk/event-ticketing/app/?ev=23014
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
uclquantum
@UCLQuantum
Is it dark matter or is it wobbly spacetime? 👀 Find out why it's probably the erratic nature of wobbly spacetime on March 15th when Jonathan will give a public lecture on gravity and quantum theory. You can get tickets to the London and virtual event at www.ucl.ac.uk/event-ticketing/app/?ev=23014
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Folks, something seems to be happening... We show that our theory of gravity is valid down to the shortest distances arxiv.org/abs/2402.17844. and that it can explain the expansion of the universe and galactic rotation without dark matter or dark energy arxiv.org/abs/2402.19459 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Folks, something seems to be happening... We show that our theory of gravity is valid down to the shortest distances arxiv.org/abs/2402.17844. and that it can explain the expansion of the universe and galactic rotation without dark matter or dark energy arxiv.org/abs/2402.19459 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This has been a team effort, and I'm lucky to have students and former students who are great physicists and generous people: @WellerDavies isaac.layton.20@ucl.ac.uk (who is on the postdoc market, ideally in Japan), @e_panella98, @quantum_maite @andrearss96, @carlosparaciari. 12/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Also a shout out to Zach Weller-Davies. Is there a German word for the pride one feels when a former student posts their first single-author paper? arxiv.org/abs/2402.17024. Zach was instrumental in developing the path integral theory, which we used to derive our new results. 13/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Thanks @DulwichQuantum ! Please give this a retweet!
Dulwich Quantum Computing
@DulwichQuantum
Dear @DulwichQuantum followers!
It's time to come together once again and support a worthy cause! A remarkable PhD candidate needs financial support to join the @PostQuantum's group at @UCL to work on a new gravity theory.
www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/gi.shtml
Let's help to make this happen! -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I very much enjoyed the discussion during my virtual seminar for the Quantum Information Structure of Spacetime (QISS) network. You can view the seminar and others like it on the QISS youtube channel www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vydjszp4Y6k&t=130s
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Following several lawsuits, I now require students to sign a liability waiver before teaching Bell's theorem. When their view of reality is shattered, they may lash out at the closest individual, and that could be you. The waiver is available at www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/item/Bell-waiver.shtml.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I warned my students that learning Bell's theorem could be a mentally destabilising experience, but they didn't listen. Now who will be there to pick up the pieces?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Very proud of my brother @davidoppenheim, who with @NishaPahuja helped produce To Kill a Tiger, which was just nominated for an academy award! You can watch it at the @thenfb @tokillatigerdoc www.nfb.ca/film/to-kill-a-tiger/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Birzeit University
@BirzeitU
Birzeit University condemns the brutal assault and bombing of @Al-Israa University campus by the Israeli occupation south of #gaza city, this occurred after seventy days of the occupation occupying the campus; turning it into their base, and military barracks for their forces
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Aliah Shaheen 🍉
@Aliah_Shaheen
Like many, I am deeply saddened and shocked by what is happening to Palestinians. As an academic, this footage of the destruction of Al Isra University fills me with anger. Universities are spaces of hope and dreams - Shouldn’t all universities take a stance on this? #gaza_now
Hisham Abu Shaqrah | هشام أبو شقرة
@HShaqrah
جيش الاحتلال يقوم بتفجير جامعة فلسطين في غزة بواسطة 315 لغم
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Monica Marks
@MonicaLMarks
“Doctors in Gaza said that children, weakened by lack of food, had died from hypothermia and that several newborn babies with mothers who were undernourished had not survived for more than a few days.” www.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/16/no-food-no-water-no…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Lowkey
@Lowkey0nline
What appears to be an elderly woman walking with a child and holding up a white flag is shot and killed by Israeli soldiers in Gaza.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Edgar Shaghoulian
@eshaghoulian
New year, new notes! You can find my lecture notes for my graduate QFT I course from last quarter here: edgarshaghoulian.com/files/lecture_notes_quantum_field_th….
You can read about my philosophy in those notes, but I will summarize here. (1/N) -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ferenc Huszár
@fhuszar
I came to do my PhD in the UK (and stayed to eventually pay more taxes than 99% of Brits) only because my partner could move with me.
As a Cambridge academic, I am losing out on great students, top global talent, who choose Germany because they have a partner.
Rishi Sunak
@RishiSunak
From today, the majority of foreign university students cannot bring family members to the UK.
In 2024, we’re already delivering for the British people.
Home Office
@ukhomeoffice
We are fully committed to seeing a decisive cut in migration.
From today, new overseas students will no longer be able to bring family members to the UK.
Postgraduate research or government-funded scholarships students will be exempt. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Might There Be No Quantum Gravity After All? physics.aps.org/articles/v16/203 Thomas Galley of @Perimeter writing a viewpoint on the postquantum theory for @PhysicsMagazine. "The race is on to determine whether this new proposal will win out over the established approaches."
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
“A postquantum theory of classical gravity” will be out today in @PhysRevX! And the experimental proposal with Carlo Sparaciari, Barbara Šoda and Zach Weller-Davies, to test the quantum nature of spacetime via the “decoherence vs diffusion trade-off", is out in @NatureComms. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you’d like to attend a virtual (or live) public lecture and Q&A about it, you can sign up here: www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/gi.shtml I’ll post the popular summary and expand on the works and historical context here: www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/pqg.shtml. 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It’s been a wild ride, and I’m incredibly grateful to many individuals. First and foremost, my former students, Carlo @carlosparaciari, Barbara @FreshPopSoda and Zach, who have clarified a number of issues in the original framework and contributed immensely to the program. 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The 2018 paper is now superseded by the path integral and continuous master-equation approach formulated with Weller-Davies during his remarkable PhD work. My current students, Maite Arcos, Isaac Layton, Emanuele Panela, & Andrea Russo continue in that fine tradition. 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The theory is consistent and the path integral formulation is manifestly covariant. I believe the approach to be as credible, if not more so, than other approaches, although fierce disagreement from "Big Loops" and "Big Strings" is welcome. ;) 5/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you’re curious about the 5 yr gap between the 2018 arXiv paper and today’s PRX, there are a number of reasons, but mostly this: 6/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
There’s a lot of cynicism about peer review, but the reviewing I got from three anonymous referees at PRX was almost enough to restore my faith in the process. They went through it with a fine-toothed comb, and I’m grateful for their attention and their 15 pages of comments. 7/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I’m also extremely grateful to @PhysRevX managing editor Ling Miao for finding them, guiding us through the process, and for her incredible patience. There are many more people to thank and acknowledge, from my supportive colleagues @UCLQuantum and It from Qubit (@SimonsFdn) 8/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
to David Poulin, Lajos Diosi, @AntoineTilloy, @quantum_jake and others so do check out the acknowledgement in arxiv.org/abs/1811.03116 and historical context to appear at www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/pqg.shtml 9/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Wonderful seminar and visit to @UCLQuantum by the grandfather of quantum information theory, Charlie Bennett. Among many fun anecdotes & puzzles: how to determine the parity of the string, when each bit is written on the forehead of each person in a room, and everyone votes. 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is an example where no one has any idea what the answer is, but they can collectively almost always vote correctly. Also: how to use 5 playing cards to determine if two people both want to go on a date, without one of them revealing they want to, and being rejected. 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Nature Physics
@NaturePhysics
It has been around fifty years since Kenneth Wilson’s work on the renormalization group. We celebrate this anniversary with a collection of Comments on its development and applications.
go.nature.com/475NSnw -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm excited about being at @Perimeter for the next three weeks, come say hello!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In quantum theory, the classical limit is often given by ℏ→0. But what about when the particle is interacting with another system which we continue to treat quantumly? Isaac Layton and I found that ℏ→0 is not enough! You must also kill entanglement scirate.com/arxiv/2310.18271 1/3
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We call this the classical-quantum limit, and it's useful when a subsystem can be treated classically. This has application in gravity since we generally treat space-time as classical, and gives a regime where scirate.com/arxiv/1811.03116 can be used as an effective theory. 2/3
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We hope it's also useful in quantum chemistry and quantum thermodynamics, where we often have one system which behaves classically, while the rest is quantum. Here, "classical" means having definite pre-existing values, and to achieve this, we need both ℏ→0 and decoherence. 3/3
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The cover of this week's @newscientist features an article by @lyndie_chiou on six experiments to test the quantum or classical nature of space-time. It's interesting to think about what assumptions go into those experimental proposals. 1/
New Scientist
@newscientist
One of the deepest questions in physics is whether the fundamental nature of space-time is quantum or classical. Here are six ways we could finally find out.
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Mostly. While it's possible a quantum theory of gravity produces the significant stochastic fluctuations required by a classical space-time metric, it seems highly unlikely we would see them. For the same reason the fluctuations of the electromagnetic field are benign. 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It would be interesting to compare the analogous quantum vs classical predictions for other experiments. This contrast is what allows us to understand what our observations are actually constraining. @four_form has done some great work here e.g. scirate.com/arxiv/2308.12988 5/5
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
And our @arxiv papers will be fed to an AI who will sell it back to us at a subscription rate. Another reason to push for some public share of the ownership of AI companies, and some Universal Basic Inheritance or Income.
John Preskill
@preskill
.@arxiv has inestimable value for the international scientific community.
arXiv.org
@arxiv
The good news is out - arXiv has received $10 mil in funding & grants from @SimonsFdn & @NSF! 🥹🧬We are so grateful for this support & the impact it will have on arXiv's ability to grow & continue to serve our #openaccess #science & #research community: blog.arxiv.org/2023/10/20/arxiv-receives-10-million-in-gi…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
70 years ago, Bryce deWitt forcefully made the case for pursuing a quantum theory of gravity in an essay which won the 1953 GRF essay competition. This year, I wrote an essay exploring the possibility that this may be the wrong direction. It lost. scirate.com/arxiv/2310.12221 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
His essay was seen by many as heralding, what he called, a "New direction in gravitational research." Physicists of his day were very divided on the issue, but opinion has shifted since then. Now, you'd be hard pressed to find a physicist who give the alternatives much weight. 2/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The black hole information problem looses its force since information can be destroyed. Of course, theoretical considerations cannot decide the issue, which is why many of us are advocating experiments to test the quantum nature of gravity. 9/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
References: scirate.com/arxiv/1811.03116 scirate.com/arxiv/2302.07283 scirate.com/arxiv/1807.11494 (@four_form
,@quantum_jake
) scirate.com/arxiv/2302.03075 (@qubit_ulm
,@LamiLudovico
) scirate.com/arxiv/1509.08705 (@AntoineTilloy
) scirate.com/arxiv/1707.06050 Other essays: www.gravityresearchfoundation.org/announcement 10/10 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
Peter Shor showed how quantum computers could sidestep an assumption at the heart of classical cybersecurity. Now, a new variant from the NYU computer scientist Oded Regev has made Shor’s algorithm even better. @benbenbrubaker reports: www.quantamagazine.org/thirty-years-later-a-speed-boost-f…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I have a question, about the use of a term to describe theories which couple quantum and classical degrees of freedom. The term has also been used as a slur for mixed-race people, so I'd like to check-in -- is it appropriate to use? 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My group and I have proposed a consistent theory of classical general relativity coupled to quantum fields eg. scirate.com/arxiv/1811.03116 and scirate.com/arxiv/2302.07283 8/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
So, I'm wondering, what do people think of referring to such theories as "Mongrel Relativity", as long as it's meant positively (I am obviously a fan of such theories), and as long as some context is provided in terms of how the term is being used by mixed race people? 9/9
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mark M. Wilde
@markwilde
I received sad news that Mary Beth Ruskai passed away Sept. 27, 2023 at her home in Vermont. She was a titan of quantum information & mathematical physics, most known for her joint proof of strong subadditivity of quantum entropy. She was a strong promoter of women in science.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
One of the reasons I argue that we shouldn't automatically assume gravity has a quantum nature just like all the "other" forces is down to this. Gravity is unique. It alone can be described in terms of free falling in a universal geometry that we all live in and act on.
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
No force is exerted by gravity. If you hold out your arm, the only force on it is from your own muscles.
Very few people know this. I've known physicists to deny it.
That is why people are surprised that antimatter falls down. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
A photon is its own anti-particle. So if this experiment had found that anti-matter falls up, photons would be very confused!
CERN
@CERN
What happens if you drop an anti-apple?
In a paper published today in @Nature, the ALPHA collaboration at CERN’s Antimatter Factory shows that, within the precision of their experiment, atoms of antihydrogen – a positron orbiting an antiproton – fall to Earth in the same way as their matter equivalents.
This result is a milestone in the study of the properties and behaviour of antimatter.
Find out more: home.cern/news/news/physics/alpha-experiment-cern-observe… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Roland Pease
@PeaseRoland
Nothing like a morning's discussion on reaching net zero "by 2050" to make you wish for better maths education, all round, including how stuff accumulates over time. Getting there is not the point, what matters is how you get there.
Tony Juniper
@TonyJuniper
Science is very clear. It’s not net zero in 2050 that must be the headline goal, but cutting emissions before then, including 50% cut by 2030. Delaying action deepens peril for our children & grandchildren. Think Libya, Greece, mass migration & all the rest, & on a massive scale.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Peter Shor
@PeterShor1
I've put my lecture notes from my Fall 2022 Quantum Computation course online.
math.mit.edu/~shor/435-LN/
I don't guarantee that there aren't any mistakes left in them, although I've tried to eradicate them all. If you find any, feel free to email me. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Has the black hole information paradox been resolved? Was a wormhole created in Google's lab? When will we build a quantum computer? Who can write down the black hole entropy formula the fastest? Find out what ~150 physicists think, during Patrick Hayden's #ifq2023 game show!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Supersymmetry may have not been discovered at CERN, but Tamara Kohler, a @UCLQuantum alumna, used supersymmetric quantum mechanics to prove that an interesting problem used in data analysis called clique homology, is difficult to solve on a quantum computer. #ifq2023
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"Fly!!! Fly!!!!" John @preskill, in recounting the history of #itfromqubit during last night's banquet speech, tells the story of the physics pioneer John Wheeler, who asked the students in John's class to write all the equations they knew on pieces of paper. 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
She presented an interesting proof that if space-time is classical, then even if we modify quantum theory, we still must have irreversible. arxiv.org/abs/2301.10261. In the quantum-classical case, you can use this to constrain such theories: arxiv.org/abs/2203.01982 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
When it comes to direct tests of the quantum nature of gravity,@LamiLudovico presented a proposal using coherent states of oscillators. He contrasts this to those which rely on creating entanglement between massive particles. #ifq2023 Recordings at pirsa.org/C23021 5/5
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Wormholes in AdS/CFT naively suggest that we live in an ensemble of randomly chosen universes. Juan Maldacena calls the space of possible universes the Metaverse (joke). In the full UV theory there can be only one and Alex Maloney presents some ideas on how this emerges. #ifq2023
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Juan Maldacena ends his #ifq2023 talk with an overview of what he sees as the important open questions in string theory. If information is preserved by black holes, then this appears to require hidden degrees of freedom. What are these?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
A handy chart by Antony Speranza showing the differences between type I, II and III von Neumann algebras. This is why our hope turns to despair as we go from qubits to quantum fields in subregions. #ifq2023
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Rob Myers director of @Perimeter kicks of #ifq2023 a conference at the interface of gravity & quantum information. We're experimenting with a submission based conference and we hope it leads to a diverse & meritocratic program. Virtual participation at events.perimeterinstitute.ca/event/43/overview
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
🧵: Every student of mathematics knows the famous story of Ramanujan and Hardy – but it seems that @RishiSunak, @SuellaBraverman, and the @ukhomeoffice have missed its crucial message. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan 1/10
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you agree that we need to overturn these barriers to science, please retweet or write to @RishiSunak, @SuellaBraverman, @ukhomeoffice, and @michelledonelan. Science thrives on intellectual exchange, not barriers. 9/10
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Only by removing these obstacles can we truly foster conditions for the UK to become a scientific superpower. Let's be a country that nurtures future Hardys and Ramanujans, not one that shuts them out. We must truly invest in our future. 10/10
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Perimeter Institute
@Perimeter
This week at Perimeter, the 33rd installment of Strings, the flagship annual conference for the extended string theory community.
Learn about the timetable, speakers, and how to watch virtually here: events.perimeterinstitute.ca/event/29/overview?hss_channe… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Spread the word! And drop me a line if you'd like to propose @UCLQuantum as your host.
The Royal Society
@royalsociety
The Royal Society's University Research Fellowships are now open for applications. This scheme provides the opportunity for outstanding early-career researchers to build an independent career and pursue cutting-edge science. Find out more: #rsgrants royalsociety.org/grants-schemes-awards/grants/university-…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Thomas Van Riet
@ThomasVanRiet2
The debates in this thread w/ @postquantum about alternatives to string theory, the issue of background independence, etc, have been discussed before in a very accessible book by @jay_jacome in which he interviews famous quantum gravity theorists:
Thomas Van Riet
@ThomasVanRiet2
Interesting suggestion, but the title is misleading. Gravity can be quantised. String theory made that explicit. Whether that means strings describe our reality is something else. But gravity can definitely be quantised in a uv complete manner.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This year's Relativistic Quantum Information conference is in Crete and the non-Greek physicists are excited their knowledge of the Greek alphabet from equations enables them to read the street signs! Some fights break out: Tee-muw-new vs Tee-me-knee. rqi.tuc.gr/program/ 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The program is interesting and diverse. One theme that's emerging is that quantum gravity not only has implications at the Planck scale, but also in the weak field limit, if we can create superpositions of dense or massive particles. 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Geoff Penington
@quantum_geoff
Thread to hopefully clarify some confusion. There are two different issues involved here: a choice of classical background and a choice of boundary conditions. A theory of quantum gravity should not depend on the former. It should depend on the latter (like any quantum theory) 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Cliff Burgess
@CburgesCliff
I am very much enjoying this thread of discussion between Jonathan and the AdS/CFT experts
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Regarding AdS/CFT, I think it's very much open whether it's a consistent theory, especially for evaporating black holes. But if you're asking, whether I would consider a background dependent theory to be a theory of quantum gravity, then... 1/
-
Thomas Van Riet
@ThomasVanRiet2
Interesting suggestion, but the title is misleading. Gravity can be quantised. String theory made that explicit. Whether that means strings describe our reality is something else. But gravity can definitely be quantised in a uv complete manner.
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Regarding AdS/CFT, I think it's very much open whether it's a consistent theory, especially for evaporating black holes. But if you're asking, whether I would consider a background dependent theory to be a theory of quantum gravity, then... 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I agree that the two cases (old school string theory and AdS/CFT) use the classical "background/boundary" in different ways. But crucially, both are using the background/boundary, to classically define the time and how we measure evolution. 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
“We’re at a point where we really ought to question whether this drive and this challenge to quantize gravity was really the right thing to do.” www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkRbNXILroI
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
What if gravity — and space-time — are fundamentally classical? www.quantamagazine.org/the-physicist-who-bets-that-gravit…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We calculate the weak field limit of our post-quantum theory of classical gravity. We find the quantum state moves in lock-step with spacetime. It remains pure even though predictability breaks down and the "rate" of the flow of time becomes stochastic. scirate.com/arxiv/2307.02557
Andrea Russo
@andrearss96
1/5 Quantum gravity has kept theoretical physicists busy for the past 60 years, but why? The Feynman argument suggests that without quantised gravity, we lose quantum properties. Essentially, classical spacetime would measure and quickly decohere quantum states. #quantumgravity
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The schedule of the Last Hurrah of #itfromqubit, #ifq2023 is out! events.perimeterinstitute.ca/event/43/timetable/. Due to the high demand (and climate change), we will have a significant virtual program, including virtual coffee breaks and posters. You can register @Perimeter, there's no fee.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Giuseppe Carleo
@gppcarleo
The new work by @IBMResearch Quantum is an important milestone in the field. www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06096-3
I especially like the shift from generating "supremely" useless random numbers to the task of simulating something of "utility" for physics.
But..... (1/6) -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Marcel S. Pawlowski
@8minutesold
To those of you interested in the controversy over the wide binary stars test of MOND, with some papers finding MOND behavior and another excluding MOND at extremely high sigma, let me summarize in a🧵what the discussion among the teams seems to have settled on here at #mondat40:
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Quantum snake-oil companies like @dwavequantum are advertising real-world applications for #quantumcomputing. Meanwhile, in the real real-world, there's still a tug-of-war battle to decide whether current quantum or classical devices are faster for sampling random numbers. 1/
Jake Bulmer
@BosonBulmer
Massive result today on classical simulation of GBS. I personally believe that it means:
**Gaussian Boson Sampling experiments no longer hold a quantum advantage**
Huge congrats to Changhun Oh, Minzhao Liu et al. scirate.com/arxiv/2306.03709Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We're still in the back-and-forth stage of that tug-of-war. Quantum computing is an exciting field, but
a) We're decades away from a quantum computer &
b) Even then, there's no evidence quantum algorithms will be better at solving problems like portfolio optimisation 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
With effort, quantum devices will soon prevail over classical ones in solving uninteresting problems, and eventually, interesting ones. But that will take time. So if you see a company making claims like 👇🏽 now, they're selling bullshit, plain and simple. 4/4
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
🚨 Postdoc in quantum computing @UCLQuantum! 🚨
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I had a great time visiting @phfaist, @jenseisert, @PhysicistAlex and the rest of the @PhysikFUBerlin gang. So many fun discussions on quantum thermodynamics, resource theories, gravity and holography!
Jens Eisert
@jenseisert
Thanks for coming, @postquantum, earlier this week. It is always great fun and inspiring to have you around. Thanks for the discussions.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Check out the accepted talks at #itfromqubit 2023 for a sample of what's been happening at the interface of quantum information theory and gravity this year! Registration deadline for #ifq2023 is on June 1st but plenty of space for online participation. events.perimeterinstitute.ca/event/43/page/154-invited-sp…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
On a train towards Gdansk (via Berlin!) for the 14th KCIK Symposium on Quantum Information. Looking forward to a great program of talks and catching up with colleagues. It's been ages! kcik.ug.edu.pl/symposia/14th-kcik-ictqt-symposium-on-quan…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'll be in Berlin for a couple of days on the return journey. 2018 reloaded...
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Switching trains in Berlin on my way to the KCIK symposium on quantum resource theories! symposium-kcik-2018-quantum-resources.ug.edu.pl I'll be talking about entanglement batteries and entanglement fluctuation relations.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Tomorrow at 3pm IST, I'll give a talk "Decoherence vs Diffusion: testing the quantum nature of gravity," at QIQT23. The talks are online and you can check out the schedule and register at qiqt2023.org or visit www.youtube.com/@QIQT.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The talk is based on scirate.com/arxiv/2203.01982 with @carlosparaciari, Barbara Šoda and Zach Weller-Davies, and proposes experiments which can already be used to test the quantum vs classical nature of space-time geometry.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Dulwich Quantum Computing
@DulwichQuantum
Some thoughts on Quantum Bullshit, and why it's bad for science and society... 🧵
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My timeline is anyway flooded with fake nonsense, April Fools day is redundant this year.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Please consider signing this and quote tweeting the original post to amplify it. We can develop AI responsibly, but the current tech company race is not the way to do it.
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
a big deal: @elonmusk, Y. Bengio, S. Russell, @tegmark, V. Kraknova, P. Maes, @Grady_Booch, @AndrewYang, @tristanharris & over 1,000 others, including me, have called for a temporary pause on training systems exceeding GPT-4 futureoflife.org/open-letter/pause-giant-ai-experiments/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
There are some criticisms of the open letter from various angels and some make reasonable points. But no statement is going to perfectly capture your views unless you write it yourself, and good luck getting others to sign it. The main thrust is more important than the details.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ian Sample
@iansample
"There’s no way we can be that certain that gravity should be quantised." Great interview with @postquantum by @jdhowgego in @newscientist
www.newscientist.com/article/mg25734301-000-the-physicist… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
John Preskill
@preskill
Sure-fire way for scientific ideas to get attention: Make a bet.
New Scientist
@newscientist
Most experts think we have to tweak general relativity to fit with quantum theory. Physicist Jonathan Oppenheim (@postquantum) isn't so sure, which is why he’s made a 5000:1 bet that gravity isn’t a quantum force
www.newscientist.com/article/mg25734301-000-the-physicist… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This article by @jdhowgego & thread seem to be generating opinions on who will win my bet with @carlorovelli and @quantum_geoff on whether space-time is quantum. But that's not the question -- the question is, what do you think is the probability of each side winning the bet? 1/
New Scientist
@newscientist
Most experts think we have to tweak general relativity to fit with quantum theory. Physicist Jonathan Oppenheim (@postquantum) isn't so sure, which is why he’s made a 5000:1 bet that gravity isn’t a quantum force
www.newscientist.com/article/mg25734301-000-the-physicist…Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
and check out the references for other theories in this direction. Dan Carney has kept track of some proposed experiments x.com/four_form/status/1627371550830739456 but now that we're into 2023, I think it's already getting out of date! /5
Daniel Carney
@four_form
There’s also about 30 other proposals… the list in the intro of arxiv.org/abs/2108.06320 should have all of them as of 2022
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Speaking of out of date, the sketch that @newscientist produced makes me realise I really need to get myself an updated profile picture! 6/6
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Timothy Gowers @wtgowers
@wtgowers
I was at a sensational combinatorics seminar in Cambridge yesterday, reminiscent of the time I had been tipped off that Andrew Wiles's seminar at the Newton Institute on Wednesday 23rd June 1993 might be worth going to. 🧵
arxiv.org/abs/2303.09521 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Martin Bauer
@martinmbauer
A set of Ed Wittens 2022 lectures on causality in general relativity has been uploaded to youtube.
Lecture notes are here: arxiv.org/abs/1901.03928
problem sets here: www.ias.edu/sns/physics-539
h/t www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/
www.youtube.com/@witten342 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Of course Carlo signed our bet on the quantumness of gravity, on a copy of his book, "Quantum Gravity".
carlo rovelli
@carlorovelli
And this is me signing!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
John Preskill
@preskill
The collision of computer science and quantum gravity has spawned this interesting experiment: a high energy physics conference calls for submission of contributed talks.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
#itfromqubit Call for Submissions! Proposals for talks are being sought based on outstanding contributions to research at the interface of quantum information theory and fundamental physics. Deadline April 1 for the meeting @Perimeter July 31st. Please RT events.perimeterinstitute.ca/event/43/page/152-call-for-s…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
#itfromqubit Call for Submissions! Proposals for talks are being sought based on outstanding contributions to research at the interface of quantum information theory and fundamental physics. Deadline April 1 for the meeting @Perimeter July 31st. Please RT events.perimeterinstitute.ca/event/43/page/152-call-for-s…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Olivia Lanes
@Liv_Lanes
Lots of women have this strange, innate desire to try to fix men with issues, and i am no different only the "issues" i keep trying to fix are poor interpretations of quantum mechanics
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is a healthy attitude! There are 3 proposed experiments so far: gravitational entanglement (BMV) dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.240401; the decoherence vs diffusion proposal scirate.com/arxiv/2203.01982; the quantumness experiment @LamiLudovico et.al. scirate.com/arxiv/2302.030
Daniel Carney
@four_form
Assuming this model holds together (I haven’t read in detail), this is excellent—a long desired relativistic model of “classical” gravity coupled to quantum matter. Time to rule it out experimentally!
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm excited about this - a covariant theory of gravity coupled to quantum fields! scirate.com/arxiv/2302.07283 The metric is treated classically, yet the dynamics is consistent, so it's a candidate for a fundamental theory reconciling quantum mechanics with general relativity. 1/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Martin Bauer
@martinmbauer
A thread about a modern view on constants in fundamental physics.
Why are some of them more interesting to physicists and what makes them special?
1/15 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mischa Woods
@WoodsMischa
Finally published. This was a fun project with Michal Horodecki. Many people from the non-resouce theory approach to quantum thermo predicted that the 2nd laws would fail due to the impossibility to implement their fine-grained high-precision control. Here we prove otherwise.
Physical Review X
@PhysRevX
Unaccounted for thermodynamic costs in controlling quantum systems can be made arbitrarily small, as long as the control is not implemented too quickly.
Read go.aps.org/3K7zjHl
@WoodsMischa, @ETH_physics, @ICTQT, @Qinfo_inria
#prxqst #prxjustpublished #openaccess -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm excited about this - a covariant theory of gravity coupled to quantum fields! scirate.com/arxiv/2302.07283 The metric is treated classically, yet the dynamics is consistent, so it's a candidate for a fundamental theory reconciling quantum mechanics with general relativity. 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It's joint work with Zach Weller-Davies using our hybrid path-integral formulation described here: x.com/postquantum/status/1613914993702981632. It may alternatively be viewed as an effective quantum gravity theory in some regimes, allowing one to study the back-reaction of fields on space-time. 2/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you're into quantum mechanics, you probably love Feynman path integrals. But path integrals exist for classical mechanics as well 🤯, and now we have hybrid classical-quantum path integrals! Z. Weller-Davies and I derive them in scirate.com/arxiv/2301.04677. A path integral 🧵 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
“There’s no scenario in which life outside @HorizonEU will be good for UK science. The sooner ministers stop pretending that it could be, and drop the ‘science superpower’ froth...the better." @jameswilsdon in www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/feb/12/eu-horizon-europ…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ashley Montanaro
@quantumashley
Some personal picks of brilliant results (from Tue/Wed only!) at #qip2023 (@ixfoduap @preskill) :
* Verifiable quantum advantage without structure (Yamakawa / Zhandry) - a great result in itself, with novel techniques that could lead to practically relevant speedups -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Ludovico Lami on experiments to test the quantum nature of gravity. In contrast to previous proposals, no entanglement is created! The paper with Pedernales and Plenio scirate.com/arxiv/2302.03075 appeals to my vanity by citing my bet with @carlorovelli & @quantum_geoff 🤣 #qip2023
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Feynman claimed that quantum interference was "a phenomenon which is impossible, absolutely impossible, to explain in any classical way." Not so, shows Lorenzo Catani et. al. at #qip2023 (arxiv.org/abs/2111.13727)
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Takashi Yamakawa kicks of #qip2023 day2. There's a folklore that public key encryption must be based on problems with structure. Can we find a problem that can be used to show a verifiable quantum advantage of quantum computers over classical ones with no structure? Spoiler: yes!
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
*off. I haven't paid for an edit button....
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Marcos Crichigno and @UCLQuantum alumni Tamara Kohler kick of #qip2023 with "Clique Homology is QMA₁-hard". (About counting how many holes there are using a quantum computer). I was not expecting it to digress into a lecture on supersymmetry! 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
But the supersymmetry operator Q which annihilates the ground state can be thought of as the boundary operator which finds holes. By adding terms into the SUSY Hamiltonian you encode the graph whose holes you want to count. Wonderful. 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm on the Eurostar heading towards #qip2023 in Brussels. First time in my life traveling with a suitcase rather than a backpack, let's see how this experiment goes!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Wait until he finds out there are many second laws.... www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1411728112
Stephen Wolfram
@stephen_wolfram
It's been the single longest-unfinished project of my life. But after 50 years I think I've now figured out the Second Law of thermodynamics ... and this is the story of how I got there:
writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/02/a-50-year-quest-my-pe… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The UK government is advertising for a Head of Office for Quantum Technologies. This is an "opportunity to set up and lead the team" that will "ensure we are a leading quantum nation." Application deadline, Feb. 19.
www.civilservicejobs.service.gov.uk/csr/index.cgi?SID=b3d… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm on strike today. From my sabbatical... I'd rather be doing research, but there needs to be a healthy research and learning environment to come back to. #ucurising
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
oh oh.... "Even though quantum computers powerful enough to crack RSA are a few years away from being openly available, hackers are already seizing and storing sensitive data in the knowledge that they will be able to access it via quantum very soon." 🤦♀️@BullshitQuantum
TIME
@TIME
TIME's new cover: Quantum computers will transform our world—and create a 21st century "space race" ti.me/3j2McaL
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm always amazed at the faith that string theorists have in the AdS/CFT holographic conjecture! Even calling it a conjecture rather than a correspondence risks you being treated like a heretic. But the evidence that it holds around black holes seems very thin to me. 🧵 1/
Andreas Karch
@karch_andreas
That’s why is said in some situations. And, while true that AdS/CFT is a conjecture, so is confinement in QCD and existence of the standard model as a consistent QFT. AdS/CFT is established beyond reasonable doubt.
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
PS3: This answer of Geoff's is interesting, but it raises the question of what conclusions or regimes of AdS/CFT do researchers feel they have compelling evidence for, and what do they consider more open? I'm interested in hearing their views on this. x.com/quantum_geoff/status/1617276957816918016 12/9
Geoff Penington
@quantum_geoff
But asking what would make me reject AdS/CFT is like asking what would cause me to reject the Langlands program. The true statements might turn out to be much less far reaching than the original vision. But enough has already been proved true that it can’t go away entirely 2/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
PS4: Peter Woit has posted a question on @notevenwrong asking what people mean by the AdS/CFT conjecture. I've put my amateur answer there, and hope others do as well: www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=13290 13/9
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Does gravity constrain computation? Alex May's seminar at @UCLQuantum discuses his recently discovered tension between computation in a bulk space-time, and how it must be encoded as a non-local computation in the boundary holographic theory. 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I think it's important to stress the other possibility: if there are low complexity computations which cannot be implemented non-locality in the CFT, this should weaken string theorist's belief in AdS/CFT. 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Since entanglement in the boundary is so limited here, the boundary computation is very restricted, so I believe this to be a strong tension. Alex will be presenting some of this work at #qip2023 and he has co-authored a series of papers starting from arxiv.org/abs/1902.06845 4/4
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you're into quantum mechanics, you probably love Feynman path integrals. But path integrals exist for classical mechanics as well 🤯, and now we have hybrid classical-quantum path integrals! Z. Weller-Davies and I derive them in scirate.com/arxiv/2301.04677. A path integral 🧵 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The FV interaction allows for decoherence and other open quantum system effects. It can be difficult to know if this dynamics is completely positive & trace preserving (which we need for preserving probability) except when it corresponds to a Lindbladian master equations. 6/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We want to find more general path integrals which combine classical and quantum systems & allow us to study the back-reaction of quantum fields on classical ones. Here is the "CQ-action" for this path integral. The fluctuating force is determined by the bra & the ket fields. 7/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The inequality 4D_2D_0>=1 (we call the decoherence-diffusion trade-off) is required for complete positivity. We hope these path integrals help solve the back-reaction problem, which we need to better understand black-hole evaporation and vacuum fluctuations during inflation. 9/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
There is a handy table comparing the different kinds of path integrals in scirate.com/arxiv/2301.04677. Next week I'll show how Zach Weller-Davies and I constructed covariant path integrals for quantum fields interacting with the classical metric of general relativity. 10/10
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Geoff Penington
@quantum_geoff
Would gravity being fundamentally classical surprise me more than Leicester City’s 2016 title? Yes. Yes it absolutely would. (Note: as general life advice, you should never take a bet at 5000:1 on, because the chance you are an idiot is >>1/5000. But where’s the fun in that…)
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My bet with @carlorovelli and @quantum_geoff has finally been signed! The question is whether space-time is best described by quantum theory. I think it's possible that our next theory of gravity will be radically different from anything we've seen before. 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My bet with @carlorovelli and @quantum_geoff has finally been signed! The question is whether space-time is best described by quantum theory. I think it's possible that our next theory of gravity will be radically different from anything we've seen before. 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Fortunately there are a number of proposals which will one day test this, from entanglement experiments such as arxiv.org/abs/1707.06050 to diffusion vs decoherence experiments like arxiv.org/abs/2203.01982. The outcome of one of these experiments can determine the bet. 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you'd like to read the fine print of the bet, I've put a pdf copy at www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/pub/quantum_vs_classical_bet.pdf and you can check out this thread for some reasons why space-time being classical has some appealing features. x.com/postquantum/status/1352292956385009671 5/5
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I don't know whether space-time geometry is fundamentally quantum or classical, but @carlorovelli has given me 5000:1 odds, so I'm taking him up on it. When he looses the bet, he has promised to give me 5000 of some item, but what item should I choose? youtu.be/yeXdSSMfY3U?t=2139 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
but you should keep some of the really good boxes, because sometimes there will be some things which need to be put in a box, and you want to make sure you have the right one
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Anil Ananthaswamy
@anilananth
What does physics have to do with #dall·E 2? Diffusion models are all the rage; their origins lie in some cool principles from non-equilibrium thermodynamics. Work by @jaschasd @hojonathanho @YSongStanford @AnimaAnandkumar www.quantamagazine.org/the-physics-principle-that-inspire…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Know anyone interested in a PhD on the interface of quantum information theory and gravity? I'm offering a student-led project on the quantum nature of gravity or alternatives such as arxiv.org/abs/1811.03116. Info at ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/item/studentship.shtml. Please RT & spread the word!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Douglas Natelson
@NanoscaleViews
ER = EPR = Tardigrade
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The infamous "Entanglement between superconducting qubits and a tardigrade" has now been published iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1367-2630/aca81f The title is now "Entanglement in a qubit-qubit-tardigrade system". The authors really missed a trick, not calling this a wormhole-tardigrade system! 😂
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Thee annual tradition of dressing up like an alligator and balancing a baby.... To demonstrate spontaneous symmetry breaking.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm here to discuss quantum theory, not social media platforms, but that's getting harder to do and this👇is a thread which resonates. From now I'll crosspost from mastodon qubit-social.xyz/@postquantum and see how that goes. There's a bunch of excellent quantum tweeps already there.
Cory Doctorow NO LONGER ON TWIT TER
@doctorow
No matter how benevolent a dictatorship is, it's still a dictatorship, and subject to the dictator's whims. We must demand that the owners and leaders of tech platforms be fair and good - but we must also be prepared for them to fail at this, sometimes catastrophically. 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It's not every day you discuss the Wald entropy of a black hole with Bob Wald! You construct the Noether current for a diffeo, vary it, apply Cartan's magic formula, use Hamilton's eqn, evaluate it at the horizon, and Bob's your uncle! Coincidently, Bob is my academic uncle...
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
since his PhD advisor (John Wheeler) was also my advisor, Bill Unruh's advisor. Here is Bob's original paper on black hole entropy as a Noether charge. It seems like magic to me, and apparently is also magic and mysterious to Bob. arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9307038
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm visiting the University of Chicago's physics department this week. Warming up with some physics lessons taught through Calder's mobiles at the Museum of Contemporary Art @mcachicago ...
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The JW Space Telescope is not only about taking pretty pictures of galaxies, it's throwing shade on the dominant cosmological model (Lambda-CDM), which holds that cold dark matter is mostly responsible for galaxy formation. What a time to be alive!
Martin Bauer
@martinmbauer
So there are 2 surprising results from JWST that could impact our understanding of fundamental physics.
One can summarise it as 'everything happens too early'
🧵 1/8 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
A view of the Hudson River from tonight's office, a sleeper train from New York to Chicago. Slightly marred by a dusty window and the sounds of England getting knocked out of the World Cup. 😢
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I can't get past the lobby of @MuseumModernArt. The installation by @refikanadol using an AI to interpret and mess with their art collection is mesmerising.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Learning an unknown quantum state is hard. But John @preskill presents an efficient protocol for approximately constructing a state's "classical shadow" which is it's expectation value on a set of measurements. He's a "measure first, ask questions later" kinda guy! #itfromqubit
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Dorit Aharonov (famous for co-proving the threshold theorem for quantum error correction during her PhD) presents strong arguments that we have not yet seen a violation of the Extended Church-Turing Thesis (i.e. asymptotic quantum advantage). #itfromqubit
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Lenny Susskind introduces two FACTS. "Not everyone considers them as facts, but that's okay."
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Scott Aaronson does some wormhole busting in his #itfromqubit talk! He assures us that this is different to the hype busting he did of "wormhole" experiments at scottaaronson.blog?p=6871
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Brian Swingle is using his talk on holographic measurements and quantum teleportation to show us AI generated art... #itfromqubit
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We have another proposed solution to the black hole information problem from Aaron Wall (postselection on a Cauchy slice), and it's only 1030 in the morning! #itfromqubit
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Neta Engelhardt talks about the growing role of complexity in gravity and in particular, the black hole information problem. This seems like an alternative to replica wormholes for reconciling Hawking's calculation with AdS/CFT. #itfromqubit
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Neta Engelhardt talks about the growing role of complexity in gravity and in particular, the black hole information problem. This seems like an alternative to replica wormholes for reconciling Hawking's calculation with AdS/CFT. #itfromqubit
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
QIP2023
@qip2023
The schedule for the parallel sessions of #qip2023 has been finalized: indi.to/FvchH
Register at indi.to/xBdn2, early-bird discounts end at 23:59 on Dec 15 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Daniel Jafferis presents work on traversable wormhole dynamics on a quantum processor. Yep, it's *that* wormhole. #itfromqubit
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Ed Witten kicks of this year's #itfromqubit workshop with a talk on observers in de Sitter space. Really interesting discussion of the Timelike Tube Theorem, which you will be able to watch online at www.ias.edu/sns/scientific-program-qubit-2022
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Once again! ....on the train from Toronto to Princeton for the annual #itfromqubit workshop and meeting. Recordings of the talks will be available at www.ias.edu/sns/scientific-program-qubit-2022
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Victor V. Albert
@victorvalbert
Göran Lindblad passed away; besides the ubiquitous equation, he had several other gems. From Jonas Larson: "For my physics friends. I am sad to share with you the passing of Göran Lindblad. Few of you have met him in person, but probably most know about the Lindblad equation. 1/3
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
When you're learning in the quantum universe, a quantum agent needs exponentially fewer experiments than a classical agent. @RobertHuangHY at the New Frontiers in Machine Learning and Quantum workshop which "bringing together a group of young trendsetters" events.perimeterinstitute.ca/event/31/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Kinda bonkers that 100 years ago we pretty much thought our galaxy WAS the universe. Then Hubble discovered that Andromeda was another galaxy, and now you can't swing a dead cat without hitting one of these things.
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
Scroll through 200,000 galaxies
mapoftheuniverse.net -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
A new calculation shows that a controversial alternative theory of gravity called Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) accurately predicts how star clusters break apart, reports @samJ_science for @PhysicsWorld.
physicsworld.com/a/modified-gravity-describes-how-open-st… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Under what assumptions have we observed a quantum superposition of different gravitational fields? Flaminia Giacomini of @Perimeter presents recent work on this question.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My 2004 April Fools joke on Artur Ekert is apparently now a field of research!
Anthony Leverrier
@letonyo
now a new wave of ideas is coming and cryptographers and high-energy physicists are starting to unveil links between cryptography and quantum gravity! How exciting!
(2/2)
arxiv.org/abs/2211.05491 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
Physicists have used ultracold potassium atoms to simulate the universe during inflation. This “analogue gravity” experiment offers insight into an otherwise inaccessible part of our universe’s history, writes Silke Weinfurtner for @Nature.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-03557-z -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Huge blow in the quantum vs classical computer smackdown! An efficient classical algorithm for random sampling (the task the Google quantum device achieved advantage on). It's efficient for extremely large samples but would lose for small samples. 1 point for classical computers!
Yunchao Liu
@lyc1178
We give a classical algorithm that, on input a random circuit C with constant noise per gate, outputs a sample within eps total variation distance of the noisy output distribution, in time poly(n,1/eps). arxiv.org/abs/2211.03999
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Stein's lemma is a celebrated result which gives the error rate in asymmetric hypothesis testing in terms of the relative entropy. I've tried to find the original source online before and failed. Now it's been exumed!
Mark M. Wilde
@markwilde
And here it is!
drive.google.com/file/d/14ZhR-KQjrdpTcnfs57Lc5Y4RFtobF0lK…
drive.google.com/file/d/16LEuHCde76tN-9m-CvapZ4D2aZbuOBM5…
The original manuscript of Charles Stein, containing his proof of the famous "Stein's lemma", but much more. Big thanks to @SamuelCree for going into the archives at @Stanford to unearth this gem... -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Just went to a really interesting QISS virtual talk today by Martin Plenio of @qubit_ulm on table top experiments to probe the quantum nature of gravity. You can watch it at www.qiss.fr/martin-plenio-ulm-university-testing-quantum-…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I have just arrived at @Perimeter and really looking forward to more than a month of great discussions. But it's kinda weird that they don't let you answer their security questions honestly.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
John Preskill
@preskill
There are a variety of postdoctoral scholar opportunities @Caltech in Quantum Science and Engineering. These are listed here:
qse.caltech.edu/qseopportunities/postdoctoral-scholars -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Kanjun 🐙
@kanjun
In 2020, @michael_nielsen & I began a 2-month project to write: "how would we fund science?"
2 years & 40,000 words later, it's become: "how can the culture & institutions of science actually change, and ultimately become self-improving?"
Our answer: scienceplusplus.org/metascience/index.html -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Correcting errors on a quantum computer be like
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The first quantum computing meme to go viral....
7/11 Truther
@DaveMcNamee3000
me high off a grav bong staring at the 7 eleven hot dog roller
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Great discussion with Lee Mcculler @IQIM_Caltech about interference experiments which will measure fluctuations in the gravitational field. Tomorrow I'll give a seminar at @KITP_UCSB explaining how such experiments place constraints on the quantum nature of gravity.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
To those who are inspired by today's Nobel prize to learn Bell's theorem, please be careful! It will completely mess with your understanding of reality. Physicists often require years of therapy afterwards and still never recover. 🤯
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I warned my students that learning Bell's theorem could be a mentally destabilising experience, but they didn't listen. Now who will be there to pick up the pieces?
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"What happens to one particle in an entangled pair determines what happens to the other, even if they are really too far apart to affect each other." 🤯 Determines but not affects. See what I'm talkin' about? From the @NobelPrize "popular information" page www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2022/popular-information/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Hirosi Ooguri
@PlanckScale
アインシュタインとファインマンが両端から見守る部屋で、重力の量子現象の検証についてお話をされるロンドン大学のジョナサン・オッペンハイムさん@postquantum。
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Intimidating audience here at @Caltech
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
At @IQIM_Caltech they fatten you up before the seminars....
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My last local #itfromqubit meeting at Stanford. Tomorrow morning we are on a road trip down California Highway #1 to @IQIM_Caltech and I'll be there until mid October. Looking forward to that!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Particle Physics Theory vs Particle Physics Experiment, at a Stanford orientation lunch for incoming graduate students. Posted with permission.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm about to give a seminar on testing the quantum nature of gravity. There's no better prep for a theoretician, than a lab visit! Thanks to Mark Kasevich's team at Stanford for a tour of the atomic fountain. They fire Rubidium into the air which falls back coherent over 25cm. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The group (Chris Overstreet, Minjeong Kim, Joseph Curti pictured) use interference to make precision gravity measurements. If space-time is fundamentally classical, then such measurements will one day see stochastic noise in the gravitational field or short coherence times 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Semi-classical physics, done less wrong: scirate.com/arxiv/2208.11722 w/ Isaac Layton & Zach Weller-Davies. Isaac made this gif of a trajectory that a quantum system in superposition takes as it "collapses" to a definite pointer state, due to its interaction with a classical system.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you like the second law of thermodynamics, you'll love majorization. Would recommend. 5/5
Michael Nielsen
@michael_nielsen
Just rediscovered and uploaded an old incomplete draft of a short book, a 129-page set of notes on: "An introduction to majorization and its applications to quantum mechanics"
Uploading for fun. I disavow all knowledge of its contents :-)
michaelnielsen.org/papers/maj-book-notes.pdf -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Great, thanks to @EtienneKlein, image searches for Proxima Centauri are ruined www.google.com/search?q=proxima centauri&tbm=isch&tbs=qdr…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Anthony Leverrier
@letonyo
"While quantum computers may still prove useful for quantum chemistry, it may be prudent to assume exponential speedups are not generically available for this problem."
arxiv.org/abs/2208.02199 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mark M. Wilde
@markwilde
This paper is an excellent recent development in quantum Shannon theory:
arxiv.org/abs/2208.02132
It answers a question that everyone working in the field has wondered since ~ 1996: Why can't the error bounds for communication look like those from classical information theory? -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My students want an app which displays the daily abstracts from the @arxiv and then lets you swipe right or left. Harnesses hookup culture for a science recommendation engine like @scirate3 scirate.com....
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Quantum computers fall slightly behind as we head down the stretch....🏇🏇🏇 www.science.org/content/article/ordinary-computers-can-be…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
The Royal Society
@royalsociety
The Royal Society's University Research Fellowships are now open for applications for 2022. They provide the opportunity for outstanding early-career researchers to build an independent career and pursue cutting-edge science. Find out more: #rsgrants royalsociety.org/grants-schemes-awards/grants/university-…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ian Lauer Astro
@ianlauerastro
HUBBLE vs JWST: Here's the difference. Welcome to a new era of astronomy.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
🍿
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Bill Unruh is confused about quantum gravity. In the final overview talk at #iap2022: "Whatever the solution to quantum gravity will be, it will be much weirder than anything we can now imagine."
Recording of all talks available at webcast.in2p3.fr/container/iap-2022-conference -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
These are the papers that changed her life. Silke Weinfurtner of @UniofNottingham on testing effective field theory in the lab. A seven year experiment looking at fluid analogue simulators of cosmology in the early universe. #iap2022
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Emanuela Dimastrogiovanni of @univgroningen does the gravitational wave hand-dance to demonstrate how their detection might be used to probe quantum gravitational effects. #iap2o22
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Sougato Bose of @UCLQuantum presents proposals to test the quantum nature of gravity via the creation of entanglement. You can tell he's talking about entanglement because his hands are in the "Bell position". #iap2022
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Isaac Layton @UCLQuantum presents "Semi-classical physics, done less wrong" at #iap2022. Although predictability breaks down, the quantum state stays pure conditioned on the classical trajectory.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Ted Jacobson on the black hole information paradox, lists other famous paradoxes in physics (Gibbs, Twin, EPR), and notes that they were resolved by learning what a meaningful statement about the world is. #iap2022 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
But maybe a better analogical paradox is Maxwell's demon? We forgot to include some other degrees of freedom (the demon's brain). 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Cliff Burgess @CburgesCliff as The Terminator at #iap2022, argues that it's unlikely we'll see quantum coherence in cosmology, since primordial quantum fluctuations will be decohered by unseen short wavelength modes. 😢
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Elise Crull reveals that New York is a hotbed of Bohmian mechanics during her talk on "Philosophical implications of decoherence in the context of cosmology" at #iap2022
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
One consequence of gravitationaly induced wave function collapse models is that if you have a tattoo of the Schrödinger equation, you'll need to ink in additional terms. Catalina Curceanu presents experimental tests of such models at #iap2022.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Markus Arndt kicks off the #iap2022 "When ℏ meets G" workshop at the interface of quantum theory and gravity. "How mesoscopic can matter be and still show quantum behaviour" he asks. Talks are being live streamed via www.iap.fr/col2022/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The UCL High Energy Physics Group has a postdoc opening (Deadline June 15!), applying quantum computing to problems in high energy physics. w/ Sarah Malik. @uclquantum. Please pass it on! atsv7.wcn.co.uk/search_engine/jobs.cgi?SID=amNvZGU9MTg4ND…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Clifford Johnson
@asymptotia
This is SUCH an important story on a key issue I remember raising last year (or year before) at a Strings conference discussion. Plase read and share widely! www.wired.com/story/the-unwritten-laws-of-physics/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The Quantum Information Structure of Spacetime Conference QISS2022 is happening now at @WesternU. It's being live streamed at www.youtube.com/c/qissproject and you can check out the program at qiss.uwo.ca/program/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Many UK researchers can no longer submit their papers to their favourite journals! This includes @APSphysics journals like @PhysRevLett. A new @UKRI_News policy came into effect requiring their researchers to publish under a cc-by license. Posted at www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/item/ukri-cc.shtml 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
even if that re-use is commercial and the derived work is released under strict copyright protection. So a company can take a selection of your papers, turn them into a book, and then sell the book at a profit. Many people will not have a problem with that, but 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
the company can sue you if you share copies of the book even though almost all the content was produced by you. At www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/item/ukri-cc.shtml I give a tip on how to avoid being sued for sharing derivatives of your work h/t @GerardoAdesso for informing me of the policy change 4/4
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My talk yesterday on a post-quantum theory of classical gravity, and proposed experiments to test it, can be found here vimeo.com/715204516/5063ea5da8. All the talks and panel discussions from the Informational Architecture of Spacetime Workshop will appear at groups.oist.jp/iasw/recorded-talks
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
ICYMI: quantum computing hype meets quantum computing scepticism. The recent attack by @ScorpionFund on @IonQ_Inc illustrates the danger of over-hyping the gradual progress of research to the entire quantum computing effort. ionq.com/posts/may-12-2022-ionq-founders-respond .thequantuminsider.com/2022/05/04/ionq_short_scorpion
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
That the Earth goes around the sun is central to how we perceive our place in the universe. Now for the first time we can see our black hole, that our sun orbits around.
Event Horizon 'Scope
@ehtelescope
We finally have the first look at our Milky Way black hole, Sagittarius A*. It’s the dawn of a new era of black hole physics. Credit: EHT Collaboration. #ourblackhole #sgrablackhole
Link: eventhorizontelescope.org/blog/astronomers-reveal-first-i… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Congratulations to Charlie Bennett @chdbennett, a founder of quantum information theory, exorcist of Maxwell's demon & co-discoverer of quantum teleportation, quantum cryptography & entanglement distillation, for being elected to the @royalsociety royalsociety.org/news/2022/05/new-fellows-2022/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The autopsy report is out! The theory of general quantum resource theories is going to get interesting over the next while. Expect a cascade of retractions, and some interesting reopened questions.
Anthony Leverrier
@letonyo
This is what responsible research looks like:
arxiv.org/abs/2205.02813 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
tl;dr version: "I do not think, we have to discuss which new physics could explain the discrepancy between CDF and the Standard Model - we first have to understand, why the CDF measurement is in strong tension with all others."
Jester
@Resonaances
Sane comments about the new CDF W mass boson measurement from an experimentalist: non-trivial-solution.blogspot.com/2022/04/do-we-have-fina…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
There is now a correct answer in the comments....
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is the legend we tell about the Einstein-Bohr debate. But pause for a moment. The consistency of quantum theory does not rely on General Relativity which is completely external to it. So how should Bohr have answered Einstein? Wrong answers only.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Anyone else have that dream where it's the night before exam week, and you realise you were meant to be the lecturer of some course but have forgotten to lecture any of the classes and you now have a few hours to set the exam?
Erin Kado-Fong
@erin_kadofong
So when I get my PhD, I'll stop having the stress dreams where I'm back in undergrad and realize that I've forgotten to go to any of the lectures for one of my classes, right?
Right? -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
please forward to or @ any interested robots you may know
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Dulwich Quantum Computing
@DulwichQuantum
And the winners of this year's Annual Award in Quantum computing are...
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This article does a great job conveying the excitement of working on the interface of quantum information theory and quantum gravity. But some of these ideas are very tentative and speculative and maybe wrong. That's okay we're floundering as best we can. www.simonsfoundation.org/2022/03/08/it-from-qubit-and-the…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We've been performing quantum gravity experiments, we just didn't realise it! Fresh preprint 🚨"Gravitationally induced decoherence vs space-time diffusion: testing the quantum nature of gravity" scirate.com/arxiv/2203.01982 w/ @carlosparaciari @FreshPopSoda & Zach Weller-Davies. 1/10
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
So, we can look to organisations like the National Institute of Standards and Technology @NIST who are responsible for telling us how heavy 1kg is ;) and those running the double-slit experiment with very dense particles, to test the quantum nature of gravity. 9/10
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is complementary to proposed experiments which come from the other direction, and will test the quantum nature of gravity by looking for entanglement created by the graviton (Kafri & Taylor, Bose et. al. @UCLQuantum, Marletto & Vedral). We live in interesting times! 10/10
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The most general form of continuous hybrid quantum-classical dynamics! scirate.com/arxiv/2203.01332 with @carlosparaciari Barbara Šoda & Zach Weller-Davies. We have quantum mechanics, and classical mechanics, but not much else, so it's nice to have some other theory to play with. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
While there's a widely held belief that one can't make a consistent hybrid theory, such dynamics exist, and it's been fun exploring how exactly consistency is enforced, and how such systems behave. While at the same time wondering if our thoughts are classical or quantum.... 2/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Okay, maybe some right answers?
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is the legend we tell about the Einstein-Bohr debate. But pause for a moment. The consistency of quantum theory does not rely on General Relativity which is completely external to it. So how should Bohr have answered Einstein? Wrong answers only.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is the legend we tell about the Einstein-Bohr debate. But pause for a moment. The consistency of quantum theory does not rely on General Relativity which is completely external to it. So how should Bohr have answered Einstein? Wrong answers only.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"we think there's no quantum algorithm which can break this crypto (for some range of parameters)" just doesn't have the same ring to it.
Artur Ekert
@aekert
And it is finally called "quantum resistant" rather than "post-quantum" :)
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Deyan Ginev
@dginev
📢 Welcome to ar5iv.org
Change the "X" in any arXiv article link to the "5" in ar5iv to get a modern HTML5 document.
Thread: what is included, why now, and how we hope to merge back into arXiv.
#oa #openscience #preprints
1/10 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The deadline for early #qip2022 registration is today (& Feb 1st for advanced). The organisers are mindful that the "online registration price may be onerous for researchers in low-income countries" and if you are in such a situation you can contact them! web.cvent.com/event/8adf8248-432b-499c-91e2-63b83ba3f69e/…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Students can register for free to attend #qip2022 online, before Feb 28th via the link below. QIP is the premier theoretical quantum information and computing conference. For non-students it is... non-free... web.cvent.com/event/8adf8248-432b-499c-91e2-63b83ba3f69e/…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The deadline for early #qip2022 registration is today (& Feb 1st for advanced). The organisers are mindful that the "online registration price may be onerous for researchers in low-income countries" and if you are in such a situation you can contact them! web.cvent.com/event/8adf8248-432b-499c-91e2-63b83ba3f69e/…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Has anyone in Club Omicron been craving cheese lately?
Chase W. Nelson 倪誠志
@chasewnelson
The pattern of genetic changes in #omicron is consistent with a mouse host, interpreted here as evidence of a mouse origin.
But the same pattern is also consistent with #molnupiravir. Should it thus be interpreted as evidence of a drug-related origin?
1/4
www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.14.472632v1.full -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Fun Fact: Lagrange points are called Lagrange points, because they were discovered by Leonhard Euler.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Wake me up when they can ask the tardigrade what they saw.
Gregory White
@gregswhitenoise
Has science gone too far??
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Maybe they just put a tardigrade on a qubit...
Ben Brubaker
@benbenbrubaker
I said I was done with the "qubit entangled with a tardigrade" discussion (regarding an unpublished manuscript that appeared online recently). But now that misleading news pieces are coming out, I decided to spell it out at a non-technical level
1/n
arxiv.org/abs/2112.07978 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
A great sample of this year's top results in quantum computation & information theory can be found in this list of accepted #qip2022 papers custom.cvent.com/9563374D7DF84F27BC7A463F7B7B5F5F/files/a…. Talks & tutorials are recorded and there may be online participation. Conference details: web.cvent.com/event/8adf8248-432b-499c-91e2-63b83ba3f69e/…
QIP 2027
@QIPConference
QIP 2022 accepted papers have been posted at custom.cvent.com/9563374D7DF84F27BC7A463F7B7B5F5F/files/a…. Congratulations to all authors for their high-quality submissions, and to the PC for their hard work!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Alexei Kitaev proposes two experiments to test whether a butterfly's wing can change the weather. One involves two copies of the earth, one involves running time backwards after inserting a butterfly 🦋. #itfromqubit www.simonsfoundation.org/event/simons-collaboration-on-it…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In case you were under the impression that string theorists had solved the black hole information problem... while some might believe this, almost none of them seem to agree on how... #itfromqubit www.ias.edu/sns/quantum-information-workshop-2021
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Institute of Physics
@PhysicsNews
Think you or someone you know could benefit from the Bell Burnell Graduate Scholarship Fund? Visit iop.org/bellburnellfund to find out more. Closing date for applications is Friday 21 Jan 2022 #bellburnellfund
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Nicole Yunger Halpern blames @preskill for encouraging her to study the thermodynamics of complexity.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
2 years and 2 days ago I attended my last in person workshop before the pandemic hit. Today we're back for the annual @SimonsFdn #itfromqubit annual meeting and @the_IAS workshop. Vaccinated, Masked up, and spaced out. Livefeed; www.ias.edu/sns/quantum-information-workshop-2021
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Harry Yorke
@HarryYorke1
Exc: UK has begun drawing up contingency plans for pulling out of three major EU programmes it remained part of after Brexit.
They are Horizon Europe, Copernicus and Euratom.
UK believes delay to being admitted is being used by EU as leverage.
www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2021/11/06/uk-ditch-15bn-eu-… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I love learning what a research field's important open problems are. Scott Aaronson has written a paper on the open problems in quantum query complexity scirate.com/arxiv/2109.06917 and I'm looking forward to checking it out.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Greeks pronounce μ like "me" so in my lectures, I flip a coin to decide whether to say "G me ni = 8 pee T me ni" and confuse half the audience, or "G mew knew = 8 pie T mew knew" and get eye-ball rolled by the native Greek speakers.
Katie Mack
@AstroKatie
What does the Greek letter μ sound like? [poll]
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Timothy Gowers @wtgowers
@wtgowers
There is a lot of debate on Twitter, or at least on the part of Twitter I see, about whether mathematics is "objective" and "apolitical", and quite a lot of it consists in people talking past each other. So maybe it's worth making a few obvious (and far from new) points. 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
never having to say you're sorry.
Steve Flammia
@S_Flammia
Fault tolerant means:
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mischa Woods
@WoodsMischa
I'm at #iccmp2021 today to receive the 2019 AHP prize awarded jointly with my co-authors Ralph Silva and @postquantum for arxiv.org/ct?url=https%3A%2F%2Fdx.doi.org%2F10.1007%2Fs00…. I wish they could be there. Nice to see @quantum_sutter (AHP prize 2018) and J. Bauch (AHP prize 2017) in person again!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Congratulations to these fellowship winners! The next round of Royal Society fellowships opens soon, get in touch if you'd like to apply through @UCLQuantum or if you know of good candidates, please spread the word.
The Royal Society
@royalsociety
The Royal Society is pleased to announce the 37 University Research Fellows for 2021. From icy comets to plant RNA, these researchers will be working on research projects spanning the sciences at institutions across the UK and Ireland. Find out more: royalsociety.org/news/2021/08/university-research-fellows…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Boaz Barak
@boazbaraktcs
Scott Aaronson wrote a beautiful post on Steven Weinberg
www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=5566 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Pizza Time!
(or Quantum Pizza). Either way, I think I'm gonna win this one. open.library.ubc.ca/cIRcle/collections/ubctheses/831/item…
Academic Mom, PhD
@Momademia
Tell me the title of your dissertation, thesis, or latest paper, but replace one word with "pizza."
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I warned my students that learning Bell's theorem could be a mentally destabilising experience, but they didn't listen. Now who will be there to pick up the pieces?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Can anyone recommend a good therapist who understands quantum theory? Ideally Lacanian and based in London.
Holly Farler
@geefweee
Still working through the trauma - I'm having trouble finding a therapist who understands.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I warned my students that learning Bell's theorem could be a mentally destabilising experience, but they didn't listen. Now who will be there to pick up the pieces?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
NicoleYunger Halpern
@nicoleyh11
I’m publishing a book! Quantum Steampunk: The Physics of Yesterday’s Tomorrow is heading to bookstores, and it’s now available for preordering. @jhupress quantumsteampunk.umiacs.io/book/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Longing for a return to the "prelapsarian world" before Gödel urged mathematicians to eat of the forbidden fruit? Then pick your axioms and check out this great article on recent progress toward understanding how big the continuum is (Tl;dr: very big, or maybe very very big).
Natalie Wolchover
@nattyover
I wrote about a major new proof that strengthens the case against the continuum hypothesis, Cantor's 1878 conjecture about how many real numbers exist. The proof raises hopes that mathematicians could return to the "prelapsarian world" before Gödel. www.quantamagazine.org/how-many-numbers-exist-infinity-pr…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Tom Wong
@thomasgwong
Qubit Zoo (qubitzoo.com) currently only has semiconducting and superconducting qubits. If you know other kinds of qubits, please submit them! I'd like to have students visit the zoo and see lots of types of qubits.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The replies to this question, about "the big lie" and how best to explain quantum superpositions, have branched off numerous times and with no clear answer....
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Soaking five octopuses in MDMA for science is one thing, but wait till you check out the 38 papers which cite it.
"Doctor Fomomindo's preliminary notes for a future index of anthropomorphized animal behaviors" perhaps? scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?start=0&hl=en&as_sdt=2005&sc…
Massimo
@Rainmaker1973
The study in which five octopuses were submerged in water laced with MDMA. After absorbing the drug, they proceeded to cuddle with each other, instead of playing with the Star Wars figurines that would normally have intrigued them [read more: idp.nature.com/transit?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nat…]
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
John Preskill
@preskill
The audio recordings of the Feynman Lectures on Physics (1961-64) are now publicly available.
Don't be discouraged by the quality of the recording of Lecture #1, which is damaged. The quality of the rest is pretty good.
www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/flptapes.html -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I have massive respect for @wtgowers , but it's remarkable that when seeking outside advice on Covid-19, Cummings turned to a mathematician famous for his work on combinatorics rather than infectious disease experts, or those in Asia currently dealing with the pandemic!
Peter Jukes
@peterjukes
Cummings said he got in touch with Professor Tim Gowers in the week of the 9 March and started sharing documents. "That gave me the confidence we should change.... but in retrospect... I should have done this in January"
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Don't get me wrong, it seems Tim played a positive and significant role, and consulting brilliant people from any field is important. But srsly, experience and specialised knowledge is also a thing. How on earth were loads of external experts not being consulted in January 2020?!
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Maybe @UCLQuantum and @LondonNanotech should be proud that the other scientist who Cummings credits with changing the UKs disastrous herd immunity strategy was Ben Warner, who got his PhD in quantum physics @ucl!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Natalie Wolchover
@nattyover
New story alert! The second-ever photo of a black hole, recently released by the Event Horizon Telescope team, solves the mystery of how black holes launch jets—those enormous, dead-straight beams of energy that shoot out from their edges. Thread... www.quantamagazine.org/physicists-identify-the-engine-pow…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Some great general public math talks and higher level ones in this thread.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm not gonna even click on the article here, it's just too much...
IFLScience
@IFLScience
Brood X Cicada Orgy Crashed By A Mind-Altering Fungus That Eats Butts
www.iflscience.com/plants-and-animals/brood-x-cicada-orgy… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Fatih Birol
@fbirol
The @IEA just released the world’s first comprehensive roadmap for the global energy sector to reach net-zero emissions by 2050.
Our special report shows the pathway to net zero by 2050 is narrow but still achievable if governments act now.
The report ➡️ iea.li/33PDCAD -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Which scientists & journalists are most followed by COVID19 experts? It's been a year since our last update, so @TrueSciPhi & I re-scrapped twitter to find who experts follow during the pandemic. We hope it helps you find more reliable information: ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/Covid-19_tweeps.shtml 1/6
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
& 20 most followed organisations & individuals
@CDCDirector
@WHO
@DrTedros
@T_Inglesby
@DrTomFrieden
@RWalensky
@CDCgov
@ScottGottliebMD
@statnews
@SCBriand
@CEPIvaccines
@JeremyKonyndyk
@GaviSeth
@NEJM
@CIDRAP
@jennifergardy
@MRC_Outbreak
@ASlavitt
@Chikwe_I
@TheLancetInfDis 5/6
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
As always, please read the caveats and methods at ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/Covid-19_tweeps.shtml The list only serves as one guide to find informative accounts and is not meant to be a ranking nor representative sample of experts. I can't believe it's been a year since x.com/postquantum/status/1258743732826001408! 6/6
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We've updated our list of scientists, journalists & other twitter accounts most followed by COVID-19 experts! Finding reliable information can be tricky -- there's a lot of noise out there. So @TrueSciPhi and I scrapped twitter again to update the list: www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/Covid-19_tweeps.shtml 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The 2021 Gravity Research Essay awards have been announced www.gravityresearchfoundation.org/announcement. First prize to "The Elastic Vacuum" by Samir Mathur. The list of other winners and pdf of abstracts is here: www.gravityresearchfoundation.org/s/2021-GRF-Abstracts.pdf -- an interesting snapshot into some current lines of research.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Wrong answers only
NYT Science
@NYTScience
What do you call a collection of black holes? The question has taken on an urgency among astronomers inspired by the recent news of dozens of black holes buzzing around the center of a nearby cluster of stars. www.nytimes.com/2021/04/22/science/black-holes-astrophysi…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Daniel Baumann
@DD_Baumann
David Tong wrote some notes on particle physics and QFT using only high-school maths: www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/tong/particle.html I haven't read it yet, but coming from David they are surely awesome.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
April 14 is #worldquantumday and @WorldQuantumDay is hosting a virtual talk for the general public by super-poser extraordinaire Alain Aspect: "From Einstein to Wheeler: Wave-Particle duality of a single photon" 17:00 CET worldquantumday.org/events/. 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I know some of you will ask, "What about International Classical Mechanics Day?" but let's face it, classical mechanics gets the rest of the year. So classical physicists, please be a good ally and support quantum mechanics, not just on April 14, but every day! 2/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ash Jogalekar
@curiouswavefn
The Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou Problem: A Foray Into The Beautifully Simple And The Simply Beautiful
3quarksdaily.com/3quarksdaily/2020/01/the-fermi-pasta-ula… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The muon #gminus2 experiment @Fermilab has reported a deviation from the Standard Model at 4.2 sigma! www.youtube.com/watch?v=81PfYnpuOPA. However... /1
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Here's a great comic explaining the experiment from @PHDcomics
PHD Comics
@PHDcomics
What is the muon #gminus2 anomaly, and why is it exciting? I made a comic about it @PhysicsMagazine physics.aps.org/articles/v14/47
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"The lattice paper first appeared a year ago but only yesterday was published in Nature in a well-timed move that can be compared to an ex crashing a wedding party." -- blog post from @Resonaances about yesterday's announcement resonaances.blogspot.com/2021/04/why-is-it-when-something… 5/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Simons Institute for the Theory of Computing
@SimonsInstitute
Panel on the "Potential for Quantum Advantage in Machine Learning" featuring Scott Aaronson, Andras Gilyén, Ravi Kannan, Iordanis Kerenidis, Patrick Rebentrost at noon PDT today, following Ewin Tang's colloquium@11 am
Details at simons.berkeley.edu/events/quantum-colloquium -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Wow! (with caution). A fifth force may have been discovered by looking at the decay of beauty quarks at the @LHCbExperiment , and there's a 99.9% that the Standard Model of particle physics requires modification. Popular science article by @iansample here: www.theguardian.com/science/2021/mar/23/large-hadron-coll…
CERN
@CERN
Today the @LHCbExperiment at CERN announced new results which, if confirmed, would suggest hints of a violation of the Standard Model of particle physics 😮
home.cern/news/news/physics/intriguing-new-result-lhcb-ex…Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We should be v. cautious - 3σ results often fade, but “I would say there is cautious excitement. We’re intrigued because not only is this result quite significant, it fits the pattern of some previous results from LHCb and other experiments worldwide” (Chris Parkes)
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
David Marzocca
@DavidMarzocca
Why is this @LHCbExperiment result is so exciting? This measurement adds a datapoint to a set of previous measurements of b → s μ μ transitions. A selection of "clean" measurements, i.e. those that have a sharp Standard Model prediction is shown here
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"This time, the significance of the anomaly increased, more or less as you would expect it to assuming it is a genuine new physics signal, making it unlikely that it is merely a statistical fluctuation. This is the main reason for the excitement..."
Jester
@Resonaances
Uncharacteristically for Résonaances, some cautious optimism: resonaances.blogspot.com/2021/03/thoughts-on-rk.html
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Anyone know what's going on with these captchas? Are the ambiguous squares designed to test whether we hesitate at difficult choices unlike a robot? And why do we get shown replacement squares and then a fresh captcha?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Yep, I'm pretty sure the biggest difference between mathematicians (or those in any challenging field) and those who tell you they dropped out because it was too hard, is that mathematicians enjoy being stuck and confused.
Timothy Gowers @wtgowers
@wtgowers
Just come across this wonderful video (h/t @AlexKontorovich), which should be required viewing for all new maths PhD students. A tl;dw (taken from the video itself): "Being good at math is being good at being stuck." But trust me it's not tl: it's worth 10 mins of your time.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
More than a year into the pandemic and the UK's £37 billion test and trace program is still not publishing data which would allow scientists to access its impact??! www.gov.uk/government/publications/sage-83-minutes-corona… (a new round of docs on Covid19 just dropped from SAGE -- on a Friday of course) 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
There's more preliminary data, that although lateral flow tests have a high false negative rate, they may be reasonably reliable in cases where the individual is infectious. Modelling suggests daily testing can supplement or be an alternative to lockdowns. 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
But Test and Trace are not providing data that could inform the testing regime. "Without such information, it is not possible to make robust calculations about the differential impact of small adjustments to the delivery of testing" 4/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
chrislintott
@chrislintott
So the money to remain connected to the European research program is coming out of the *existing* research budget. In other words, British science is about to get its biggest ever cut. Devastating, at least from what I can see.
John Morgan
@johncmorgan3
Boris Johnson described Horizon Europe as a 'wonderful pan-European programme' that is 'extremely costly'. UK 'funds a lot upfront and doesn't get much back for a while - so we are looking at that. But in a context of huge increases in science and R&D spending.'
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
John Preskill
@preskill
Scott Aaronson calls for more soul-searching over quantum computing hype. "Indeed, this time around virtually everyone in QC is “complicit” to a greater or lesser degree."
www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=5387 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Why is Steve Martin tweeting Feynman diagrams?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
John's lecture notes on quantum computation are a classic, and now there are video lectures! He says they have the advantage that if his voice puts you to sleep, you can take a nap. What a great resource.
John Preskill
@preskill
My lectures from the first term of our quantum computing course @Caltech have been posted on YouTube. Slides for all lectures are also available.
www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL0ojjrEqIyPy-1RRD8cTD_lF1h… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Physics and cosmology twitter! Any suggestions of good books, films, games, for children of all ages? "Curious George gets Spaghettified by a Primordial Black Hole" is my favourite.
Patrick McCurdy
@pmmcc
@postquantum both kids (11 & 14) have taken an interest the universe, it's future & black holes. Any suggestions for age appropriate material (books, films)?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Anyone know where I can find a Lorentzian manifold?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Catch a panel of rockstars discuss the future of quantum computation, tonight at 21:00 CET! Ignacio Cirac invites experts Scott Aaronson, Dorit Aharonov, Rainer Blatt, John Martinis and Mikhail Lukin. Live on YouTube www.youtube.com/channel/UCchw3mejBRux6w9bh4DNQEA as part of #qip2021, @MCQST_cluster
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
For an overview of quantum computing and recent progress in quantum algorithms this year, I recommend Andrew Child's #qip2021 tutorial. It's live right now, and recordings will appear at www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL5DZ45amUsqIaqE9EIemfc9Lze… You can still register (4free) to see the algorithm talks in the pic!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Why are string theorists always trying to make me fat?
Geoff Penington
@quantum_geoff
I'll bet 6000 crisps against one crisp?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Gavin Morley
@gavinmorley
I’m exited to see this bet as my group is working towards an experiment to settle it
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I don't know whether space-time geometry is fundamentally quantum or classical, but @carlorovelli has given me 5000:1 odds, so I'm taking him up on it. When he looses the bet, he has promised to give me 5000 of some item, but what item should I choose? youtu.be/yeXdSSMfY3U?t=2139 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I don't know whether space-time geometry is fundamentally quantum or classical, but @carlorovelli has given me 5000:1 odds, so I'm taking him up on it. When he looses the bet, he has promised to give me 5000 of some item, but what item should I choose? youtu.be/yeXdSSMfY3U?t=2139 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Carlo offered to give me 5000 coloured balls so I can play bazinga: www.youtube.com/watch?v=qH1VOy7HKRs and if he wins, I give him one red ball. But I don't play bazinga, and he seems unexcited by my proposals: 50 ml of olive oil or wine? .00002 bitcoin? a packet of crisps? My home? 2/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
iv) We recently celebrated 100 years of failing to quantise gravity. Maybe because it's really difficult, but maybe because we are barking up the wrong tree. The obstacles could be technical and surmountable, but there could be unresolvable tensions between QM and GR. 7/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Are these arguments compelling? @carlorovelli doesn't think so! But the dogma of the quantum gravity community, that logical consistency required quantum gravity (see e.g. Feynman's argument in www.semanticscholar.org/paper/The-role-of-gravitation-in-…) is false. If it's not forbidden, why isn't it required? 8/8
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Looks like there will be some great tutorials and talks at #qip2021. With no jet lag or registration fee. Plus they have a twitter account.
QIP2021
@qip2021
Tutorials speaker line-up and talk abstracts are now online: www.mcqst.de/qip2021/program/tutorials/. #qip2021 tutorials take place on the 30th and 31st of January. Make sure to register to attend the event.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The one hand giveth; the other hand.... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Twitter permanently suspended @sci_hub's twitter account as it was gathering support from scientists to defend itself against a lawsuit by the publisher Elsevier (a company many scientists boycott because of their exploitative practices) torrentfreak.com/sci-hub-founder-criticises-sudden-twitte… 1/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Twitter permanently suspended @sci_hub's twitter account as it was gathering support from scientists to defend itself against a lawsuit by the publisher Elsevier (a company many scientists boycott because of their exploitative practices) torrentfreak.com/sci-hub-founder-criticises-sudden-twitte… 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Many scientists rely on sci-hub to get around paywalled articles, especially in countries like India where access to expensive journals can be more limited. Tell @jack and @TwitterSupport what you think of this horrible decision. 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
🚨 PhD studentship opportunity on the interface of gravity and quantum information theory. Please retweet and do let potentially interested students know! It would be co-supervised by myself and @apontzen. More information here: www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/item/studentship.shtml
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Does anyone know how we can apply for these grants to study anti-gravity technology, or infinite energy production?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Andrew Childs
@andrewmchilds
Nice @QuantaMagazine coverage by @laxmevy of work with @JinPengLiu__Sky, @hermankolden, Krovi, Loureiro, and Trivisa on quantum algorithms for nonlinear differential equations.
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
Quantum information researchers have tried to use linear equations as a key to unlock nonlinear differential ones for over a decade. Two teams at MIT and the University of Maryland recently put that goal within reach. www.quantamagazine.org/new-quantum-algorithms-finally-cra…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Ending a 50 yr debate? What on earth is going on with @QuantaMagazine? Too wild a NYE? They're usually such a great science magazine, but they keep repeating this ridiculous interpretation of a calculation, that not even its most fervent believers hold.
Quanta Magazine
@QuantaMagazine
Recent calculations reveal that information can escape a black hole, ending a 50-year debate. www.quantamagazine.org/the-black-hole-information-paradox…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The full #brexit text is now available: ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/1/2020/EN/COM-2020-8… Looks like the UK can continue to be part of science flagship programs like Horizon Europe and Euratom but wow is the text difficult to penetrate.
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Meanwhile we are interviewing applications for PhD students, and still don't know if EU students will be treated as home students for the purpose of funding. If they aren't, that would be such an own-goal... I had hoped that we would at least have some clarity now, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is a great thread about materials. Everything is bonkers.
Brian Skinner
@gravity_levity
I have received my @threadapalooza from @vgr, so let's do this!
A thread about cool materials, and what makes them so. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
"We should be very grateful of all the investment our field is getting. But we have the responsibility of keeping hype down. The focus must be on tech and science development, not on vanity and greed." Great thread from @FernandoBrand14 on quantum computing by press release.
Fernando Brandao
@fgslbrandao
@ionq latest announcement with their roadmap is out: techcrunch.com/2020/12/09/ionq-plans-to-launch-a-rack-mou…. Also check Peter Chapman talk on Q2B 2020 for similar content. The thread below hopefully will foster more discussion by the community. Disclaimer: all I write reflects only my personal opinion 1/20
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I wonder who @ericschmidt is talking to...
John Preskill
@preskill
Interesting remarks this morning at #q2b20 by @ericschmidt. A few takeaways.
Eric thinks that scaling from NISQ technology to fault-tolerant quantum computing is "largely an industrial problem" to be solved in 10 years according to "most people I talk to."
I don't agree. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mario Krenn
@MarioKrenn6240
OMG what a crazy story by Scott Aaronson (www.scottaaronson.com/blog/) about the photonic quantum surpremacy paper (science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2020/12/02/science.a…):
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Kathryn Boast
@Kathryn_EB
Last chance to sign up for this afternoon's talk from the inestimable Prof Jocelyn Bell Burnell - talking not just about her research, but about the challenges she has faced throughout her career, and the changes that physics still needs to make.
Department of Physics at University of Oxford
@OxfordPhysics
*Book now* Challenges & Changes in Physics with Prof Jocelyn Bell Burnell - Mon 23rd Nov, 15:30 – 16:30 GMT
www2.physics.ox.ac.uk/events/2020/11/23/challenges-change…
Free and open to the public, but registration required
@mplsoxford @oxwiphys @UniofOxford @IOPDiversity @OxfordSparks @MansfieldColle1 @OxfordNA -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
700 physicists are about to virtually gather @CERN
to discuss replica wormholes and the black hole information paradox indico.cern.ch/event/960097/ If you'd like to brush up on entanglement islands first, video of the tutorial session is at www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLxlKjV4POd9gJmw_OmYw776y38… #ihopping2020 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Carlo Sparaciari
@carlosparaciari
New preprint out on the ArXiv, studying the evolution of quantum systems coupled to classical fields! And if you'd like to simulate the evolution of your favourite hybrid systems, check out our code at github.com/carlosparaciari/unravelling
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Unsatisfied with many-worlds? Yearning for a better interpretation of quantum theory? Check out scirate.com/arxiv/2011.06009. Space & time are fundamentally classical concepts used to describe how quanta evolve. This necessarily causes quantum systems to become classical. 1/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Unsatisfied with many-worlds? Yearning for a better interpretation of quantum theory? Check out scirate.com/arxiv/2011.06009. Space & time are fundamentally classical concepts used to describe how quanta evolve. This necessarily causes quantum systems to become classical. 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Quantum fields are forced into unique trajectories when they backreact via gravity on their space-time background. This provides a potential solution to the measurement problem of quantum theory. w/ @carlosparaciari & Zach Weller-Davies @UCLQuantum & Barbara Šoda @Perimeter 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Ah, the poorly understood, 4th law of thermodynamics...
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
So irresponsible!
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
If jumping into black holes becomes the new tide pod challenge, Wired will have the blood of our youth on their hands
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Sumeet Khatri
@SumeetKhatri6
I'm very pleased to announce a preliminary version of a new textbook on quantum information theory. Done in collaboration with @markwilde and available here:
arxiv.org/abs/2011.04672
We've been working on this project for the past three years and are open to any feedback! -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
If you're feeling anxious on election day and need some distraction, check out the brawl on physics twitter. @gmusser brings up the black hole information paradox and the predictable chaos ensues... 1/
Peter Shor
@PeterShor1
If you're saying to give up on any problem people have spent 40 years on and haven't solved, that's crazy.
If you're saying physicists won't recognize a solution to the black hole information problem, that's true for some physicists, but I have more faith in the whole community.Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
x.com/erikverlinde/status/1322249050075418626 3/
Erik Verlinde
@erikverlinde
You’re wrong. I am one of the theoretical physicists trying hard to solve this problem. Do you think if I found its solution tomorrow, I would not immediately publish it, just because of some worries about not getting funding? There is not a single scientist who thinks that way!
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
x.com/newscientist/status/1323598000518766593 4/
New Scientist
@newscientist
Where does the stuff that falls into a black hole go? in an extract from his latest book, physicist Carlo Rovelli proposes an answer www.newscientist.com/article/2258332-carlo-rovelli-where-…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Henry Maxfield
@henry_maxfield
I agree, the headline in particular oversells it. But I think the article itself strikes a more reasonable tone, and (rightly) includes the skeptics’ voices. And I think they did a great job explaining the history and main ideas.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'm sorry but this @QuantaMagazine piece www.quantamagazine.org/the-black-hole-information-paradox… massively overstates the case here. Are recent results on the black hole information paradox interesting? Absolutely! Has the "paradox come to an end". Not even close! I feel like I'm tilting at wormholes again...1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Sounds a lot like information loss right? But they conjecture that Information is preserved in each theory / sector, and that by observing many black holes you can learn which theory we live in. Without this assumption, the bulk calculation predicts that information is lost. 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Many string theorists believe this assumption isn't needed, and have faith in this "ensemble duality". But I think many of them would agree that until this is shown & related mysteries resolved, we should be more careful about claiming the information paradox has been solved. 4/4
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Thiemo Fetzer 🇪🇺🇺🇦 - same handle elsewhere
@fetzert
Today I m sharing another paper on unintended consequences of a UK policy which makes me cringe at how my tax money is spent all the while debating #freeschoolmeals "Subsidizing the spread of COVID-19: Evidence from the UK’s #eoho scheme". ➡️ warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/research/centres/cage/man… a thread🧵⬇️
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Maria Popova
@themarginalian
Physicist Lise Meitner died on this day in 1968 just before her 90th birthday, having discovered fission, having been excluded from the Nobel Prize for her own discovery, and having paved the way for women in science anyway. This is her remarkable story: www.brainpickings.org/2016/10/27/lise-meitner/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Yikes! Looks like this thread is getting dragged up again. The question is whether an eavesdropper bounded far away from a region (the lab), can always know what happens inside the lab. Can labs be shielded? I don't think holography is relevant here (see the original thread) 1/
Māris Ozols
@enclanglement
A new response to @hashbreaker by Renes and Renner:
arxiv.org/abs/2010.11961Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We know we can create superpositions of two states (e.g. electron through slit one or slit two) which result in an interference pattern, and therefore, no measurements outside the lab can distinguish these two states, otherwise we would have interference and know "which slit". 3/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Therefore, there are two different states of the electromagnetic field which cannot be distinguished by an eavesdropper (even one who can measure everywhere and arbitrarily close to the slits). Note that this argument relies on quantum theory.4/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
it's also that as far as I know, even if holography is true, an eavesdropper living inside the universe (called "the bulk") but close to the boundary, doesn't have access to the theory on the boundary. There is a lot of information they have (called the extrapolate dictionary) 8/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
but the statement of holography just asserts that the boundary is equivalent to the bulk, not that the bulk which is close the boundary is equivalent to the entire bulk. Hence x.com/postquantum/status/973855630183235584 @AlmheiriAE, @quantum_geoff @henry_maxfield can correct me if I'm wrong. 9/6
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Security hole in quantum cryptography discovered! If an eavesdropper has an exact copy of the entire universe and Alice and Bob have no free will, then she can figure out their secret! Almost as easy as pretending to be tech support and asking them for their password.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Oh oh, I hope we're keeping our eyes on these star systems 👀
Corey S. Powell
@coreyspowell
A new study has identified 1,004 star systems where aliens (if they exist!) could easily detect Earth. From these locations, our planet eclipses the Sun--the same way we find planets around other stars. news.cornell.edu/stories/2020/10/smile-wave-some-exoplane… by @KalteneggerLisa
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Aephraim Steinberg
@QuantumAephraim
Looks interesting: Mini-course on Quantum-information thermodynamics (Nov 23 - Dec 4) taught by @nicoleyh11 + Matteo Lostaglio
#quantuminformation
#quantumthermodynamics
#quantumsteampunk -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Monica Salvioli
@monica_salvioli
Monday evening watching the #fieldsmedalsymposium and the nice interview with @FryRsquared finally asking @AFigalli all the questions that we always meant to ask, like "HOW IS IT POSSIBLE TO COMPLETE THE PHD IN 8 MONTHS?"😂
#phdlife #mathschat
www.youtube.com/watch?v=au2IFRKe15Q -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I'll be speaking this Wednesday about "A Post-Quantum Theory of Classical Gravity". It's hosted by the Oxford University Quantum Information Society @OxfordPhysics and they've made it a webinar so anyone can join (18:00 UTC+01) us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_3WI2buo-QKCG9Y61kwdZd… www.facebook.com/events/809739349837755
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I hope it will be a gentle introduction to the question of whether gravity must quantised. A famous argument due to Feynman says it must be, but there is a loophole. There is always a loophole... It's a prelude to arxiv.org/abs/1811.03116, but the talk will not get so technical.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
and 100x harder to convince a professor
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
This is not a subtweet of anyone in particular and it's going to annoy some people since I have a lot of PhD followers/friends and also I'm a stubborn guy myself but...one thing I'm noticed is that once someone gets a PhD, it become 10x harder to convince them they're wrong.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Room temperature superconductivity! Room pressure superconductivity? www.quantamagazine.org/physicists-discover-first-room-tem…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Andrew Childs
@andrewmchilds
Epic new paper from @JointQuICS Hartree Fellow Charles Cao and Brad Lackey uses modified @dabacon-@PeterShor1 codes to build a solvable toy model of AdS/CFT. arxiv.org/abs/2010.05960
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Headline of the day 👨🍳👌 www.eso.org/public/news/eso2018/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Anyone else disturbed by the Trump administration's new quantum website? www.quantum.gov/trump-administration-announces-quantum-go… Is it just the image of the bald eagle inside a ket? Don't get me wrong, increased funding for quantum research is exciting, and a number of colleagues who I admire are involved. 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Space exploration can be curiosity driven and for the common good, but our problems will follow us into space if we let them. Call me a fool, but I do think as scientists we have some agency and responsibility to influence where our research leads and who it benefits. 7/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Also, I'm not sure that their logo was particularly well thought out.... 8/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jason Ukman
@JasonUkman
Here's the @statnews story on a historic Nobel for two female scientists, fittingly written by a powerhouse pair of female journalists, @sxbegle @cooney_liz www.statnews.com/2020/10/07/two-crispr-scientists-win-nob…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
When #nobelprize laureates Emmanuelle Charpentier and Jennifer Doudna investigated the immune system of a Streptococcus bacterium they discovered a molecular tool that can be used to make precise incisions in genetic material, making it possible to easily change the code of life.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Everyone knows that the moon goes around the Earth, and the Earth goes around our star, but how many people know that our star (and almost all the stars we can see with the naked eye) goes around our black hole, Sagittarius A*? Let's take a completely scientific poll!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
John Preskill
@preskill
From her 1993 PhD Thesis @Caltech: "I dedicate this thesis to all the women scientists I have known."
Andrea Ghez is a superb spokesperson for science --- no doubt she will be an inspiring role model to many future scientists.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
“I hope I can inspire other young women into the field. It’s a field that has so many pleasures, and if you are passionate about the science, there’s so much that can be done.”
- Andrea Ghez speaking at today’s press conference where her #nobelprize in Physics was announced. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Congratulations to Roger Penrose, Reinhard Genzel and Andrea Ghez, winners of the 2020 Nobel Prize for their contributions to our understanding of black holes! Here is Roger's hands during his talk @ucl, discussing his singularity theorems (w/ Stephen Hawking). 1/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Roger Penrose during his seminar @ucl, admits that his transparency on trapped surfaces was made the night before. I love that the only technology we have to display it, is a digital projector. #oldschoolwednesday
Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I don't know much about the observational side of black hole research, but from the theoretical side, Jacob Bekenstein, Hawking and Bill Unruh showed that black holes are thermodynamical objects which radiate and have entropy. What this entropy is, we still don't understand! 9/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
You can read more about the physics behind today's announcement here: www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2020/popular-information/ with more technical information here: www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2020/advanced-information/ . And if you'd like to see a black hole, Silke Weinfurtner has a fluid analogue in her lab: x.com/postquantum/status/786879972581445632 10/10
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Silke Weinfurtner's fluid analogue of a rotating black hole @UniofNottingha. She's observed superradiance and previously Hawking radiation!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Check this exciting seminar series at the intersection of quantum information theory and high energy physics: quanthep-seminar.org. The series kick-offs with @preskill on Oct 7, with the first of three seminars on quantum computing and fundamental physics. Not to be missed!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The virtual "Beyond iid" conference got twice as many submissions as last year. It's an information theory conference which goes beyond the standard information theory setting (iid), so results are often applicable to real world physics situations. 1/2
NicoleYunger Halpern
@nicoleyh11
The talks accepted by "Beyond i.i.d. 8" have been posted! Come to @Stanford virtually, Nov. 9-13! #beyondiid sites.google.com/view/beyondiid8/talks @markwilde @quantum_minhsiu @marcotomamichel
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
iid = "Independent, Identically Distributed". Each letter of the message (or "source") is chosen randomly and independently from the other letters of the message. If we want to apply information theory to physics (e.g. to black holes) we get all the info in a "single shot". 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
It's not just because I feel the need to retweet anything with "post-quantum" in it. If quantum computers are able to factor RSA-2048 in 20 years, we should have switched to post-quantum cryptography 10 years ago (I like most of my secrets to remain private for 30 years). 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My deepest secrets, I'd like to remain private forever, and most government documents are hidden for 20-50 years en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thirty-year_rule. Some confidence intervals on the progress of quantum computers by @Jess_Riedel & @Jsevillamol can be found via: x.com/postquantum/status/1305929106203316225. 2/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Quantum computing forecast: @Jess_Riedel @Jsevillamol estimate devices capable of factoring RSA-2048 unlikely before 2039 (assuming exponential progress in gate fidelity, qubits). Achieving this sooner "would require faster progress than has yet been seen" scirate.com/arxiv/2009.05045
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Florian Krammer
@florian_krammer
1) SARS-CoV-2 Vaccines - I promised a Tweetorial and here we go. This is going to be long and nerdy. But I'll make sure it is easy to understand. If you want more details, please just read this: www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2798-3
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Exciting postdoc opportunity in quantum thermodynamics with @nicoleyh11 at @JointQuICS 👇🏽and Hartree Postdoctoral Fellowships here: academicjobsonline.org/ajo/jobs/16778.
NicoleYunger Halpern
@nicoleyh11
Come quantum-steampunk with us. @JointQuICS
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Today's @bopinion post attempts to answer the question: WTF happened in 1971???
www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-09-16/how-1970s-o… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Quantum computing forecast: @Jess_Riedel @Jsevillamol estimate devices capable of factoring RSA-2048 unlikely before 2039 (assuming exponential progress in gate fidelity, qubits). Achieving this sooner "would require faster progress than has yet been seen" scirate.com/arxiv/2009.05045
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Science headline writers everywhere, crushed because "biologically relevant gas" was found on Venus rather than Uranus...
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
True story
XKCD Comic
@xkcdComic
University COVID Model xkcd.com/2355/ m.xkcd.com/2355/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Here's a cute classical non-local game. It 𝘢𝘭𝘮𝘰𝘴𝘵 has a quantum flavour...
Guardian Science
@guardianscience
Can you solve it? Win the car, dodge the goat www.theguardian.com/science/2020/aug/24/can-you-solve-it-…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Such a beautiful application of information theory!
David Crawshaw
@davidcrawshaw
Use of Reed-Solomon error correcting codes in COVID-19 pooled testing. Each sample is assigned to more than one pool, and if positivity is low enough the result is 10x throughput. advances.sciencemag.org/content/early/2020/08/20/sciadv.a…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
An "important step forward in the field of experimental metaphysics,” says @QuantumAephraim
FQxI Physics
@FQXi
A new quantum experiment published in Nature Physics puts the “Wigner’s friend” thought experiment to the test. It could tell us more about the role that consciousness plays in quantum physics (if any)—and even whether quantum theory must be replaced: www.scientificamerican.com/article/this-twist-on-schroedi…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The black hole information problem.
Armani
@historyofarmani
what radicalized you?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Marcia Hofmann
@marciahofmann
Grew up in a house without running water or electricity. Went on to help build an NSA supercomputer and spend four decades improving compilers, becoming the first woman to win the Turing Award. www.nytimes.com/2020/08/08/technology/frances-allen-dead.…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ed Yong is not here
@edyong209
🚨I wrote a guide to the immune system—how it theoretically works, how it reacts to the new coronavirus, why it’s all so maddeningly complicated, and what we know about how long immunity lasts.
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/08/covid-19-immun… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Shaun Maguire
@shaunmmaguire
Reading this paper right now: arxiv.org/pdf/2006.06872.pdf
which is the view from the Mt Everest of human knowledge
and can't help myself from pointing out the authors are from: Abu Dhabi, USA, Argentina, USA (but of Armenian descent) and Iran
the power of immigration is clear -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Do other academics also have that dream where you suddenly realise you were assigned to lecture first year calculus, but it's the end of term and the exam is tomorrow, and you haven't set the exam yet?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Independent SAGE
@IndependentSage
Independent SAGE will meet again today at 11.30am GMT.
Watch here:
Youtube: youtu.be/6npNxmz-Gmw
#independentsage @Sir_David_King -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Fellow train travellers who wondered about COVID-19 transmission, check this. Not surprisingly, adjacent seats, long travel times increase risk.
Shengjie Lai
@Lai_CDC
How high is the risk of #covid19 transmission among train passengers, by seat locations, co-travel time, seat re-used? See new @WorldPopProject paper on CID: academic.oup.com/cid/article/doi/10.1093/cid/ciaa1057/587…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jens Eisert
@jenseisert
Quantum versus classical learnability of distributions, featuring a generative modelling problem for which quantum learners exhibit a provable advantage over classical learning algorithms.
scirate.com/arxiv/2007.14451 -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Some inerestin' looking essays here!👇
FQxI Physics
@FQXi
Announcing the winners of this year’s #fqxiessaycontest on “Undecidability, Uncomputability, and Unpredictability”…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The UK, US and Sweden....
Paul Krugman
@paulkrugman
But there really isn't a tradeoff. The US is now lagging behind other countries that didn't rush to reopen 3/ www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-07-26/europe-s-econo…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Youyang Gu
@youyanggu
Florida either has an incredibly low fatality rate (IFR), or may be underreporting deaths.
I computed the implied IFR for every state based on my analysis of reported cases, test positivity rate, and reported deaths.
According to my calculations, Florida's implied IFR is 0.15%. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
The 2nd round of Hawking Fellowships is open, and the deadline for Royal Society URF Fellowships approaches. They're very competitive, but if you know of strong candidates (especially those who are interested in joining us at @UCLQuantum!) pass this along.
UK Research and Innovation
@UKRI_News
The second round of the Stephen Hawking Fellowships is now open.
Delivered by @ESPRC and @STFC_Matters, it will enable the next generation of visionary early-career theoretical physicists to advance knowledge and engage the public.
Closing 18 Nov www.ukri.org/funding/funding-opportunities/stephen-hawkin… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Magdalena Skipper
@Magda_Skipper
The one-hundredth anniversary of Rosalind Franklin’s birth this month is prompting much reflection on her career and research contributions - she was so much more than the ‘wronged heroine’ of DNA www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02144-4 #womeninscience #womeninstem
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Takahiro Sagawa has written an introductory book on information theory and thermodynamics, with the title
"Entropy, Divergence, and Majorization in Classical and Quantum Thermodynamics." Available as a draft here: scirate.com/arxiv/2007.09974. I'm looking forward to giving it a spin. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
Many rich countries now do hundreds of tests per each case of COVID-19 they confirm.
The US confirms a case in every 12th test.
[source: ourworldindata.org/grapher/tests-per-confirmed-case-daily…] -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Great thread on GPT-3 by @michael_nielsen without the hype.
Michael Nielsen
@michael_nielsen
Spent an enjoyable few hours digging into GPT-3, trying to better understand how it works, what the limits are, how it may be improved.
The paper is here: arxiv.org/pdf/2005.14165.pdf -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
One reason why the US and the UK suffer a much worse pandemic than other countries is that they were very late to increase testing.
When the death rate was 100 per million the testing rate in Germany was 5-times higher than in the US and 12-times higher than in the UK. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Trevor Bedford
@trvrb
A follow up to the thread two weeks ago on rising case counts and "reopening", looking at continued trajectories in states with large epidemics. 1/15
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Andrew Childs
@andrewmchilds
Awesome new result from Troy Lee, Miklos Santha, and Shengyu Zhang gives an exponential quantum speedup for graph connectivity problems using cut queries. arxiv.org/abs/2007.08285
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
yeah right, you can't fool me with your deep fakes
Ellie
@huggingladybugs
NEW FAVOURITE ANIMAL ALERT: Leafsheep. Only animal that can photosynthesize
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ed Yong is not here
@edyong209
Let me share a nice thing. We could all use some nice things.
I got an email yesterday, from a person I've never heard from before, but whose name I recognised. 1/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Marc Lipsitch
@mlipsitch
Some mathematicians believe that the threshold for herd immunity could be lower than it originally seemed. But that will depend on us, writes @jameshamblin: www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/07/herd-immunity-…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Natalie Wolchover
@nattyover
New by me: I attempt to explain how Kurt Gödel proved his infamous incompleteness theorems. Cool art by @NatureInTheory. www.quantamagazine.org/how-godels-incompleteness-theorems…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Quantum twitter: Got any recommendations for lay people who want to learn about quantum mechanics? Ideally something that discusses Bell's inequality, entanglement, the uncertainty principle, measurements, & maybe some historical context. Books, vids, 'toons, websites, whatever!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jordan Ellenberg
@JSEllenberg
"Practical Suggestions for Mathematical Writing," by Bjorn Poonen, is REALLY GOOD. math.mit.edu/~poonen/papers/writing.pdf
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This pandemic is distorting time! Like the way a massive object bends space-time. I tried to compute the mass of the pandemic using data from this paper, but about half of those who witnessed time-distortion said time was moving slower, and half said faster, so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Ruth Ogden
@ruthogden_tp
My new paper on time experience in lockdown. Conducted during maternity leave and homeschooling. Written in the small hours whilst breastfeeding.
#womeninscience #covid19
journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone…
@PLOSONE @LJMU_Health @RCBB_LJMU @LJMUPsychology @LJMU -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Maissam Barkeshli
@MBarkeshli
An absolutely incredible, highly interconnected web of ideas connecting some of the most important discoveries of late twentieth century physics and mathematics. This is an extremely abridged, biased history (1970-2010) with many truly ground-breaking works still not mentioned:
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Your periodic reminder that @ucl is still accepting applications from international students, including for the MSc in quantum technologies. You'll be welcomed here! Sure, the current UK government also stokes xenophobia, but we shoot ourselves in the foot, not the head.
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick
@ReichlinMelnick
This is bad. ICE just told students here on student visas that if their school is going online-only this fall, the students must depart the United States and cannot remain through the fall semester. www.ice.gov/news/releases/sevp-modifies-temporary-exempti…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This discussion on quantum physics and gender has generated pushback, but in fact, quantum mechanics smashes the binary even more than this (THREAD): The binary world is represented by bits which can be 0 or 1, but bits at the fundamental level are really quantum bits (qubits) 1/
Channel 4 News
@Channel4News
“If subatomic particles defy constructs all the time, why should we believe in fixed constructs of gender or any kind of reality?”
Drag performer & writer Amrou Al-Kadhi aka @Glamrou questions why gender should be binary when the physics which underpins the universe can change.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
qubit is 0 or 1 is arbitrary and two experimentalists almost never exactly agree on how to define the binary. Alex might define 0 or 1 by using the north pole to give a direction. But it's unlikely that Blake's direction will be precisely aligned with Alex's direction. 4/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
And so Alex's 0 is a superposition of Blake's 0 and a small amount of their 1. But it's even more non-binary! The notion of 0 and 1 as representing the binary is arbitrary. Blake can just as well take + and - as the two binary states. 5/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
And we should not ascribe any binary values to the qubit (0,1 or +, -) until it is measured. It could initially be 0, then found to be +, and then when measured again, it will be 0 half the time and 1 the other half of the time. 6/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In between, we can't ascribe a value to the measurement until it's performed. The qubit only acquires binary values when measured, but how the observer defines 0 and 1 can be different to how another observer defines 0 and 1. Now we're ready to discuss quantum computing! 7/7
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Signal
@signalapp
We'd announce that we're stopping too, but we never started turning over user data to HK police. Also, we don't have user data to turn over.
Hong Kong Free Press HKFP
@hkfp
Exclusive: Telegram to temporarily refuse data requests from Hong Kong courts amid security law 'terrorism' row hongkongfp.com/2020/07/05/exclusive-telegram-to-temporari… @telegram #hongkong #china
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Jay Gambetta
@jaygambetta
A nice summary by Sergey Bravyi about his must read paper on quantum advantage with noisy quantum computing www.ibm.com/blogs/research/2020/07/quantum-advantage-shal…
The paper can be found here www.nature.com/articles/s41567-020-0948-z -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Helen Branswell 🇨🇦
@HelenBranswell
Smart piece from @kakape about how one well-designed clinical trial — UK's Recovery — has come up with 3 answers about drugs for #covid19 & why other trials — including @WHO's Solidarity — have not. www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/07/one-uk-trial-transforming…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Helen Branswell 🇨🇦
@HelenBranswell
1. Short #covid19 vaccine thread:
@WHO says 17 vaccines are in human trials around the world at this point: 7 in China, 4 in the US, 2 in the UK* & 1 each in Russia, South Korea, Australia & Germany.
*the Oxford-AstraZeneca partnership in the UK is testing 3 vaccines. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Michael Nielsen
@michael_nielsen
What are your favourite tweet-length mathematical proofs?
Here's a couple of mine. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Corey S. Powell
@coreyspowell
The biggest known black hole in the early universe is also one of the hungriest: weighing as much as 34 billion suns, eating the equivalent of another sun every 2 days. anu.prezly.com/hungriest-of-black-holes-is-among-the-most…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Natalie Wolchover
@nattyover
As cosmic rays strike the atmosphere, the collisions create pions that decay into muons that more often spin one way than the other because of a fundamental asymmetry in the laws of nature. These asymmetric muons, raining down, mutate more right-handed biomolecules...
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
PRX Quantum
We are now OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS!
Submit your paper to @PRX_Quantum, APS' new, highly selective, open access journal covering quantum information science and technology journals.aps.org/prxquantumThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
NEW analysis:
China's CO2 emissions have now surged past their pre-covid levels. The rebound is well and truly underway.
What happens next? That's THE question for climate.
More here by @laurimyllyvirta for @CarbonBrief
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-chinas-co2-emissions-surged-… -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This talk by David Poulin online.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/qinfo_c17/poulin/ w/ @preskill on theories with fundamental information loss, and his realisation that www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/03759601939… allowed for consistent coupling between quantum and classical systems was an inspiration. #poulinsgreatesthits 1/2
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
David Poulin on non-unitatary model with information loss but causality violation. On what length scales has causality been tested? #qinfo17
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In addition to the loss of a good human, I am saddened by the realisation that I will not be able to continue our dialogue on these theories. He has left the world too soon, but he has made his imprint on it. 2/2
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Mark M. Wilde
@markwilde
An addition to #poulinsgreatesthits: He and his colleagues developed the first systematic theory of quantum turbo codes:
arxiv.org/abs/0712.2888
These codes are intended for use in quantum communication. This work was very insightful, groundbreaking, and influential for QEC -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is such sad news. David was a great and inspiring physicist, and all round wonderful guy.
John Preskill
@preskill
Terribly sad news: David Poulin has passed away. He was a leading light of quantum information science, an inspiring leader, a great friend.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Helen Branswell 🇨🇦
@HelenBranswell
“This pandemic has really unearthed — shone a real bright light on — the ways these disparities should not be accepted & are not tolerable.” — Joseph Betancourt, vp & chief equity & inclusion officer at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston. #covid19 www.washingtonpost.com/health/almost-one-third-of-black-a…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Azure Quantum
@MSFTQuantum
A brilliant quantum physicist with a penchant for taking on difficult challenges, our dear teammate David Poulin is honored by his peers for the indelible mark he has made on the world: www.cifar.ca/cifarnews/2020/06/18/a-quantum-festschrift-f…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Natalie E. Dean, PhD
@nataliexdean
THINK LIKE AN EPIDEMIOLOGIST:
What does it mean that the median age of new cases is dropping in some areas? I see three possible explanations, not all good. A thread on how to distinguish between them. 1/10
(Figure h/t @ScottGottliebMD) -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Florian Krammer
@florian_krammer
I am about to hire a postdoc from Spain who is specialized in vaccine production and a postdoc from Japan who is specialized in mucosal immunity to virus infections. I might not be able to hire them if this is signed. Both would have worked on SARS-CoV-2 and influenza virus.
NPR Politics
@nprpolitics
President Trump is expected to sign an order to suspend H-1B, L-1 and other temporary work visas through the end of the year.
The new order is expected to come with broad exceptions: www.npr.org/2020/06/20/881245867/trump-expected-to-suspen… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Dr. Tom Frieden
@DrTomFrieden
1/25 This week’s Covid-View tells the story of many epidemics. Trends are diverging within the US and globally. What will places do about travel from areas with lots of spread? Details matter, and this week’s data is particularly complicated. www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/covid-data/covidview/in…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
Why are countries – in this case the UK – redeveloping technology that already exists?
[Germany for example made their contact tracing app available yesterday. The technology works and it entirely open source – here it is www.coronawarn.app/en/]
Sam Coates Sky
@SamCoatesSky
NHS tracing app will now be ready “for the winter”
Once expected mid April
(Correction from my colleague below) -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Maybe they've discovered a new particle, the axion, a candidate for dark matter! Or maybe there was some schmutz on the detector...
Jester
@Resonaances
Résonaances about the 3.5 sigma excess in the XENON1T axion search: resonaances.blogspot.com/2020/06/hail-xenon-excess.html
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
A great question and 4 great answers! Gravity is so different from other forces. We have quantum theories for all matter in the universe, while gravity describes the space-time matter lives in. It describes relationships between matter, like the distance between two objects. 1/
Natalie Wolchover
@nattyover
I asked four physicists what's different about gravity. Interesting answers here, and all very different from one another: www.quantamagazine.org/why-gravity-is-not-like-the-other-…
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
As the arena quantum fields live on, it seems to be a precondition for quantum mechanics, not something that is itself quantum. A more technical difference between gravity and other forces: diffeomorphisms be crazy! They ain't like the gauge group of other quantum theories. 2/
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Trying to quantise gravity as if it's just another field theory seems misplaced from the start. I think it's more likely it shouldn't be quantised, or it should be post-quantised... 3/3
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Kai Kupferschmidt
@kakape
This analysis of #covid19 clusters in Japan in the first two and a half months of the epidemic there presents some really interesting data. It reinforces many points I and others have made in the last weeks re clusters and superspreading events wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/26/9/20-2272_article
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Lot's of people retweeting this article claiming that it shows mask wearing substantially reduces the spread of the coronavirus (COVID-19). Not so fast...
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Ed Yong is not here
@edyong209
Three months ago, I paused book leave to return to the Atlantic for fulltime pandemic reporting. Here's a thread of 5 big pieces I've written since.
1) A sweeping look at how we got here, what must happen next, & the possible aftermath.
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/03/how-will-coron… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
✨Tracy Simone
@thetracysimone
Professors, Graduate School Directors, Dept. Chairs, PIs, Postdocs and white graduate students.
Please take a few minutes to read stories from #blackintheivory
We are telling our stories. True allies should be willing to listen. -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics
@KITP_UCSB
"To pursue physics as both a passion and a vocation is truly a privilege and obliges us to root out racism in all its many forms."
Read KITP's statement of solidarity: www.kitp.ucsb.edu/news/statement-of-solidarity -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Grateful to see this statement from @APSphysics and hope other scientific organisations do the same. And more importantly that we as individuals work harder to foster inclusivity in science and challenge racism in all its forms #blacklivesmatter
American Physical Society
@APSphysics
APS utterly condemns racism, and is horrified and deeply saddened by the killings of George Floyd, Ahmaud Arbery, and many other Black people. APS is committed to building a diverse and inclusive physics community. Statement: go.aps.org/2XXnNF0
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Anthony Costello
@globalhlthtwit
We have 8000 cases daily, a private testing system set up without connection to primary care, call-centre tracing that appears a fiasco, and no digital app. After 4 months. Unless the population has hidden (T cell?) immunity, we're heading for resurgence.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Helen Branswell 🇨🇦
@HelenBranswell
1. Would reopening schools fuel increased #covid19 spread? Answers are still lacking because schools in most places have been closed. Here Irish researchers report they saw no onward transmission from a small number of cases when schools were still open. www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.202…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Is this revised Peres Conjecture true? Bound entangled states are states which have no distillable entanglement, but you can distil a private key from some of them, and some violate a Bell inequality (disproving the original Peres conjecture). Do they have device independent key?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Helen Branswell 🇨🇦
@HelenBranswell
This is maddening: The world still doesn’t know whether sending kids to school fuels #covid19 transmission in communities. Sweden, which didn’t close schools, could have studied the question. But it didn’t. By @GretchenVogel1 www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/05/how-sweden-wasted-rare-op…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
You can attend #stoc2020 from the comfort of your own kitchen! The program acm-stoc.org/stoc2020/STOCprogram.html includes interesting quantum results from @quantum_aram @ewintang @AAmbainis and many others, plus about a dozen or so workshops on New Frontiers in Approximate Counting!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Vaccine nationalism, glass shortages and syringe shortages. So much to look forward to!
James Shield
@jshield
Oh dear. Jeremy Farrar on the vaccine.
www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/science-and-technology/alan-ru… -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Sean Carroll
@seanmcarroll
Scott Aaronson has posted his lecture notes on quantum computing — basically a rough draft for a textbook, available for free.
www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4805 -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Matt Levine
@matt_levine
this is some great financial blogging right here themargins.substack.com/p/doordash-and-pizza-arbitrage
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Google demonstrated quantum supremacy by performing a task in 200 seconds, and arguing that the largest classical computer would take 10,000 years. Now in scirate.com/arxiv/2005.06787, a new classical algorithm estimated to take only 20 days. Google might wanna add a few more qubits!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
#rentstrike kicking off in London www.theguardian.com/money/2020/may/14/activists-urge-tena…. Now might be a good time to try Universal Basic Income?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
This is a great list of open problems in quantum information theory by @markwilde. There is also a list of open problems here: oqp.iqoqi.univie.ac.at/open-quantum-problems
Mark M. Wilde
@markwilde
Here are some questions. You can decide whether they are "big" enough for you.
1) In the absence of establishing capacities in the 1-sender 1-receiver setting, find better bounds
2) In the cases of known capacities, establish second-order coding rates or strong converses -
Jonathan Oppenheim reposted
Natalie E. Dean, PhD
@nataliexdean
Seeing papers make the rounds that the herd immunity threshold may be much lower than the rough approximation 1-1/R0. Maybe, but let's slow down a minute.
#1. There is still way too much uncertainty.
#2. This does not qualitatively change our strategy.
My comments. 1/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
We've updated our list of scientists, journalists & other twitter accounts most followed by COVID-19 experts! Finding reliable information can be tricky -- there's a lot of noise out there. So @TrueSciPhi and I scrapped twitter again to update the list: www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/Covid-19_tweeps.shtml 1/
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Please spread the word! @UCLQuantum is advertising a postdoc at the interface of quantum information theory and quantum many-body physics in the groups of Lluis Masanes and @dr_qubit (exp Feb 14). And now is a great time to share the exciting news that 1/2 atsv7.wcn.co.uk/search_engine/jobs.cgi?owner=5041404&owne…
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Google's quantum supremacy paper is officially out www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1666-5. No more suffering through the poor quality pirated draft! Some links to help cut through the hype:
@jaygambetta & IBM Q's article calling into question Google's result: www.ibm.com/blogs/research/2019/10/on-quantum-supremacy/ 1/ -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
My #itfromqubit tutorials are online:
Quantum Resource Theories: youtu.be/JbehWF1mG70?t=888
Quantum Shannon Theory: youtu.be/JbehWF1mG70?t=6348
Post-quantum classical gravity: youtu.be/mNa4G1plI3k?t=6153
The 1st blackboard is dark, but make the video large enough & you can almost read it! -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Roger Penrose during his seminar @ucl, admits that his transparency on trapped surfaces was made the night before. I love that the only technology we have to display it, is a digital projector. #oldschoolwednesday
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
In his seminar @UCLQuantum, @andrewmchilds shows how to get a quantum advantage for convex optimization by computing the gradient of a function in a constant number of queries (vs n in the classical case).
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Switching trains in Berlin on my way to the KCIK symposium on quantum resource theories! symposium-kcik-2018-quantum-resources.ug.edu.pl I'll be talking about entanglement batteries and entanglement fluctuation relations.
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Security hole in quantum cryptography discovered! If an eavesdropper has an exact copy of the entire universe and Alice and Bob have no free will, then she can figure out their secret! Almost as easy as pretending to be tech support and asking them for their password.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
I warned my students that learning Bell's theorem could be a mentally destabilising experience, but they didn't listen. Now who will be there to pick up the pieces?
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
David Poulin on non-unitatary model with information loss but causality violation. On what length scales has causality been tested? #qinfo17
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Renato Renner kicks off #qtd5 today with a multi-agent & subjective view if thermodynamics. There will be fighting!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
One tiny flaw: Mexicans can fly to Canada WITHOUT A VISA & then enter the US from the north. Woops! #winteriscoming www.pm.gc.ca/eng/news/2016/06/28/canada-lift-visa-require…
Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
Big day planned on NATIONAL SECURITY tomorrow. Among many other things, we will build the wall!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Tweeting this after getting a lot of flak for not awarding the #nobelprize to Vera Rubin. The day after she dies. @NobelPrize WTF?
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
#nobelfacts 2 times has a woman been awarded a #nobelprize in Physics, Marie Curie 1903 & Maria Goeppert Mayer 1963
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Silke Weinfurtner's fluid analogue of a rotating black hole @UniofNottingha. She's observed superradiance and previously Hawking radiation!
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Submission deadline for talks and posters to Young Quantum Information Scientists (YQIS) conference is this Friday. yqis16.icfo.eu
-
Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum
Interesting new work extending the connection between nonlocality, uncertainty & steering! scirate.com/arxiv/1602.06048 @StephWehner
















































































































































































































































































