Clearly one of the key auxiliary AI-related services is going to be (and already is) setting up databases and connectors that AI harnesses can use directly. Major legal database providers are already doing this (and I have done this with my own labor law databases).
Matt Bruenig
Matthew Bruenig (born November 22, 1988) is an American lawyer, blogger, policy analyst, commentator, and founder of the left-leaning think tank People's Policy Project. He was a blogger for the American think tank Demos covering politics and public policy, and has written on issues including income distribution, taxation, welfare, elections, the Nordic model, and funds socialism. Bruenig advocates for mass unionization and socialization of wealth within an universalist welfare state. More on Wikipedia
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Important to distinguish between asking AI for information that it pulls from its training data (which is hit or miss) and using agentic AI to search through the very same databases that Lukas is talking about. The latter is extremely powerful because it searches better than you.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Important to distinguish between asking AI for information that it pulls from its training data (which is hit or miss) and using agentic AI to search through the very same databases that Lukas is talking about. The latter is extremely powerful because it searches better than you.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Clearly one of the key auxiliary AI-related services is going to be (and already is) setting up databases and connectors that AI harnesses can use directly. Major legal database providers are already doing this (and I have done this with my own labor law databases).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Tennessee Valley Authority
@TVAnews
Watts Bar Unit 2 has officially entered outage season! 🍂🔧
After an impressive 536-day operational cycle and generating 14.93 billion kilowatt-hours of power, the plant has begun its scheduled refueling and maintenance outage.
During this outage, our teams will complete 10,500 planned tasks, including loading 88 new nuclear fuel assemblies, inspecting reactor, turbine, and generator components, maintaining plant equipment, and installing enhancements! These efforts will help ensure Watts Bar remains a reliable and abundant asset for the Valley!⚡️ -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So for instance, if the UK were to take the insurance aspect of NHS, divide it into two new entities -- NHS-1 and NHS-2 -- and assign 50% of the population to each, then the provider backlogs would go down? Baffling.
-
tré easton
@treeaston
It’s so funny to me when folks on here accuse people of being bought and paid for because of opposition to their pet policy.
Like no babe. I just genuinely think that single-payer is bad policy for a nation of 300 million people who’re reflexively skeptical of government and taxes.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Why would the population size change whether a universal public insurer is the best approach. Already half the population is on public insurance.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If we created five regional public insurers such that each only insured 60 million, would that be ok? There may be a way to make this work if you could clearly articulate your opinion on population sizes
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
These regional public insurers could also manage old-age, survivors, and disability insurance, which would allow us to get rid of the Social Security Administration (having the SSA manage that for 300 million people is presumably inappropriate too).
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What does population size have to do with any of this? You made a specific point about 300 million people but then pivoted to this thing about how these programs have problems (with all of the problems you listed being equally if not more true of private insurance as well)
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right, he's hard to parse here, but if he is saying anything, it's that single-payer, by eliminating uninsurance, will overwhelm the supply of providers. But that is true of any way of eliminating uninsurance, including through expanding private insurance.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But still his point has nothing to do with the overall pop size. The US is bigger than the UK, which means it has more patients *and* more doctors. He seems to think that provider supply doesn't increase with population but that it does increase with number of insurance payers?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So for instance, if the UK were to take the insurance aspect of NHS, divide it into two new entities -- NHS-1 and NHS-2 -- and assign 50% of the population to each, then the provider backlogs would go down? Baffling.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But still his point has nothing to do with the overall pop size. The US is bigger than the UK, which means it has more patients *and* more doctors. He seems to think that provider supply doesn't increase with population but that it does increase with number of insurance payers?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right, he's hard to parse here, but if he is saying anything, it's that single-payer, by eliminating uninsurance, will overwhelm the supply of providers. But that is true of any way of eliminating uninsurance, including through expanding private insurance.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What does population size have to do with any of this? You made a specific point about 300 million people but then pivoted to this thing about how these programs have problems (with all of the problems you listed being equally if not more true of private insurance as well)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
These regional public insurers could also manage old-age, survivors, and disability insurance, which would allow us to get rid of the Social Security Administration (having the SSA manage that for 300 million people is presumably inappropriate too).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If we created five regional public insurers such that each only insured 60 million, would that be ok? There may be a way to make this work if you could clearly articulate your opinion on population sizes
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Why would the population size change whether a universal public insurer is the best approach. Already half the population is on public insurance.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Well let's look at the graphics from these WAR models. Here I take the Split Ticket graphic and then combine all the progressive and moderates into their own group. Put aside the fact that everything is indistinguishable from zero. Just look at the horizontal spread of dots!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In 45% of all the possible primary pairings of moderates and progressives (so just comparing all the dots to one another), the better candidate to pick would be the progressive candidate!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
How Do You Know Which Candidates Performed Well?
My effort at an exhaustive post-election data take. I go over three different approaches -- uniform swings, overlapping elections -- and regression models -- you see in the discourse.
Link below.Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Well let's look at the graphics from these WAR models. Here I take the Split Ticket graphic and then combine all the progressive and moderates into their own group. Put aside the fact that everything is indistinguishable from zero. Just look at the horizontal spread of dots!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In 45% of all the possible primary pairings of moderates and progressives (so just comparing all the dots to one another), the better candidate to pick would be the progressive candidate!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Great showing from the cowboys today. Just one score shy of the best-in-NFC niners, with the ball in their hands at the end of the game.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Van Hollen should run for both Senate Majority Leader and Speaker. This is allowed under the rules afaik and he could argue for the importance of unified control of the legislature.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
David Weigel
@daveweigel
Van Hollen, on his leadership bid, says he wants to end the filibuster and is ruling out President in 2028.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
A good comparator is UI taxes (FUTA). This is an employer side payroll tax. You can choose not to claim UI when you become eligible, but FUTA was still taken out of your paycheck.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you opt out the employer portion of the premium, typically 80%, is still removed from your paycheck as a matter of incidence
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you opt out the employer portion of the premium, typically 80%, is still removed from your paycheck as a matter of incidence
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
A good comparator is UI taxes (FUTA). This is an employer side payroll tax. You can choose not to claim UI when you become eligible, but FUTA was still taken out of your paycheck.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Healthcare is a weird one. You've got Bernie-style M4A which bans duplicative coverage. You've got El-Sayed-style M4A which does not ban it. Then you've got Talarico M4yall which is a public option. Then there are candidates that just want ACA tweaks, Medicaid cut reversals.
These are on a spectrum of course. But is Talarico who is aping the M4A language while pushing a public option really in the moderate bucket here? Sincerely I don't know. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I have a scrape of all of the website materials of the competitive senate races so I can just pop in occasionally and ask Claude about them. Here is it identifying places where El-Sayed breaks from "progressive orthodoxy."
-
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Conveniently there are hundreds of House members so you can look at broad aggregates to try to identify patterns
Dirtbag Left
@DirtbagLeft1234
My favorite stat that centrists like Matthew Yglesias are throwing around is that DSA underperformed with a cute little chart. They list Chris Raab as an underperformer, because in 2024 the PA-3 nominee ran unopposed and got 100% of the vote, while Rabb only got 93% of the vote!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I have a scrape of all of the website materials of the competitive senate races so I can just pop in occasionally and ask Claude about them. Here is it identifying places where El-Sayed breaks from "progressive orthodoxy."
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Healthcare is a weird one. You've got Bernie-style M4A which bans duplicative coverage. You've got El-Sayed-style M4A which does not ban it. Then you've got Talarico M4yall which is a public option. Then there are candidates that just want ACA tweaks, Medicaid cut reversals.
These are on a spectrum of course. But is Talarico who is aping the M4A language while pushing a public option really in the moderate bucket here? Sincerely I don't know. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Well he could talk to the players at least. Both groups had models written beforehand (so not opportunistic after-the-fact stuff) and they got different conclusions. Some of how each of them work and diverge is available, but it seems like good fodder for his audience.
-
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Hard to say what the pattern is here
www.theargumentmag.com/p/do-moderates-still-have-an-elect…Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Well he could talk to the players at least. Both groups had models written beforehand (so not opportunistic after-the-fact stuff) and they got different conclusions. Some of how each of them work and diverge is available, but it seems like good fodder for his audience.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You cannot! If you are employed and your employer has ESI which they are legally mandated to have, if you decide not to enroll, they employer does not refund to you the employer portion of the ESI premium. You lost it!
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One thing you could do is spin Social Security off into the Old-Age, Disability and Survivor's Corporation. Keep the required contributions, but now they aren't tax. That would cut taxes by $1.3 trillion per year, making it easy to pay for everything else without raising taxes.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You have two conceptual options here:
1. You can acknowledge that money transferred from you to Cigna and then to providers is not economically different from money transferred from you to Treasury and then to providers.
2. Claim that they are different because the Cigna version is not taxation while the Treasury version is. In this scenario, spinning Social Security off into a private corp while holding all contributions and payouts the same radically reduces taxes.
Which way are you going?Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yes! So the System of Health Accounts, which the OECD uses, actually makes this precise distinction between voluntary and compulsory. After the ACA, due to the employer mandate, ESI goes into the compulsory bucket.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We are having fun with your opportunistic embrace and non-embrace of formalisms. "Employer" payroll tax is a formalism you reject because we really know it comes from workers paychecks. Yet "private insurance premiums aren't taxes" is an equally silly formalism you embrace.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The employer payroll tax is a great example as well because when insurers decide to hike premiums for ESI, what do you think happens to employee wages? They go down (or don't increase by as much), just like a hike in the employer payroll tax.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You cannot! If you are employed and your employer has ESI which they are legally mandated to have, if you decide not to enroll, they employer does not refund to you the employer portion of the ESI premium. You lost it!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The employer payroll tax is a great example as well because when insurers decide to hike premiums for ESI, what do you think happens to employee wages? They go down (or don't increase by as much), just like a hike in the employer payroll tax.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We are having fun with your opportunistic embrace and non-embrace of formalisms. "Employer" payroll tax is a formalism you reject because we really know it comes from workers paychecks. Yet "private insurance premiums aren't taxes" is an equally silly formalism you embrace.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yes! So the System of Health Accounts, which the OECD uses, actually makes this precise distinction between voluntary and compulsory. After the ACA, due to the employer mandate, ESI goes into the compulsory bucket.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You have two conceptual options here:
1. You can acknowledge that money transferred from you to Cigna and then to providers is not economically different from money transferred from you to Treasury and then to providers.
2. Claim that they are different because the Cigna version is not taxation while the Treasury version is. In this scenario, spinning Social Security off into a private corp while holding all contributions and payouts the same radically reduces taxes.
Which way are you going? -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One thing you could do is spin Social Security off into the Old-Age, Disability and Survivor's Corporation. Keep the required contributions, but now they aren't tax. That would cut taxes by $1.3 trillion per year, making it easy to pay for everything else without raising taxes.
-
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
What is the purpose of this commentary?
We just had an election. Nine seats flipped. Only one of the seat-flippers embraced this idea in the campaign. Why the determination to make people mad at the people who just won?
Dr. Abdul El-Sayed
@AbdulElSayed
Democrats will have a 56-seat majority in the US Senate. We need to use it. Pass Medicare for All.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think El-Sayed believes in M4A on the merits and also he ran on it and so naturally needs to at least attempt to deliver on the promises he made to his constituents
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You don't think it would be weird to run a campaign where M4A was 50% of your slogan but then not press for it? It's the flipside of what you are saying about how these other senators have to oppose it. But El-Sayed seems like he needs to be able to say he tried.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know the discursive norms of the moment require everyone to pretend they are doing data science. But if you are going throw out the results of your own regression because they don't match your gut, then just write from the gut like old-timey George Will or Ron Fournier.
-
Jeff Maurer
@JeffMightBWrong
I've reworked my chart from last week to account for how red/blue a state is. This is the new version, and while I'd like you to go to my S*bstack and read the article that explains how I got here (unpaywalled, with jokes!), I'll give you the gist of it here.
🧵1/11Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In this piece, he came up with a so-so statistical effort to adjust for state lean (in response to my critique), didn't like the results and then just threw them out for made up bullshit!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know the discursive norms of the moment require everyone to pretend they are doing data science. But if you are going throw out the results of your own regression because they don't match your gut, then just write from the gut like old-timey George Will or Ron Fournier.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In this piece, he came up with a so-so statistical effort to adjust for state lean (in response to my critique), didn't like the results and then just threw them out for made up bullshit!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
To give a concrete example. The Latino vote swung to Democrats by a much larger amount than the white vote or the black vote. But Latinos are not evenly distributed across states! Thus, you would not *expect* low-Latino geographies to match high-Latino geographies in vote swing.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Adding 7.25 points to Dem vote share uniformly in every geography as your model for "expected vote share" is obviously not a good model for expected vote share! At the very least, you need a demographic adjustment
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
To give a concrete example. The Latino vote swung to Democrats by a much larger amount than the white vote or the black vote. But Latinos are not evenly distributed across states! Thus, you would not *expect* low-Latino geographies to match high-Latino geographies in vote swing.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Adding 7.25 points to Dem vote share uniformly in every geography as your model for "expected vote share" is obviously not a good model for expected vote share! At the very least, you need a demographic adjustment
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Similarly, every dollar someone spends for the public option being proposed here crowds out spending on housing, child care, clean energy, etc. There is nothing about calling these flows premiums rather than taxes that changes the economic reality of crowding out.
-
Majority Democrats
@MajorityDems
“The majority of Democrats did not run on Medicare for All. You think Adam Hamilton got elected in KS by saying he wants to kick everyone off their private insurance?”
We should fight for universal healthcare. Not force a vote on a bill voters don't want.
More from @Lis_Smith:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The thing that crowds out spending on non-healthcare spending is national health expenditures (NHE) regardless of their source. Every dollar that households are required to send to private insurers cannot be spent on housing, child care, clean energy, etc.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Similarly, every dollar someone spends for the public option being proposed here crowds out spending on housing, child care, clean energy, etc. There is nothing about calling these flows premiums rather than taxes that changes the economic reality of crowding out.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The thing that crowds out spending on non-healthcare spending is national health expenditures (NHE) regardless of their source. Every dollar that households are required to send to private insurers cannot be spent on housing, child care, clean energy, etc.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Dallas Texas TV
@DallasTexasTV
Kanye West and Jerry Jones Saturday night at AT&T Stadium in Arlington
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In the right situation, Notre Dame should run their Fake Spike Fumble play, but then use it to advance the ball.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny because under the typical utilitarian reasoning here you go for the infant because of QALYs. An infant one day becomes an adult so the number of adult life-years lost when an infant dies is greater. Amodei is not even thinking clearly within his own framework!
-
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
It's really something how you can get people to universally denounce "donating money to healthcare for the poor" as unthinkably evil if your analysis of which healthcare to donate to is too callous or weird
Julia Black
@mjnblack
whew www.nytimes.com/2026/11/05/technology/dario-amodei-anthro…
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny because under the typical utilitarian reasoning here you go for the infant because of QALYs. An infant one day becomes an adult so the number of adult life-years lost when an infant dies is greater. Amodei is not even thinking clearly within his own framework!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When I went to Finland to discuss Bernie Sanders with their left-wing party, one of the members of our delegation gave a talk about door-knocking and the Finnish attendees said that nobody door-knocks in Finland, that it would be very at odds with Finnish culture and disturbing.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
And then when I peer inward, I see that I actually would not like to have someone knock on my door to tell me about a political candidate. Maybe if it was the candidate themselves, now you got something going. But a random volunteer hitting me with a script, wasting my time?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I thought it was an interesting point. Putting aside the peculiarities of Finland, what reason do we have to think that people like having someone come up cold to their door and then pitch them on things. For pretty much anything else, people find this annoying and offputting.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When I went to Finland to discuss Bernie Sanders with their left-wing party, one of the members of our delegation gave a talk about door-knocking and the Finnish attendees said that nobody door-knocks in Finland, that it would be very at odds with Finnish culture and disturbing.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I thought it was an interesting point. Putting aside the peculiarities of Finland, what reason do we have to think that people like having someone come up cold to their door and then pitch them on things. For pretty much anything else, people find this annoying and offputting.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
And then when I peer inward, I see that I actually would not like to have someone knock on my door to tell me about a political candidate. Maybe if it was the candidate themselves, now you got something going. But a random volunteer hitting me with a script, wasting my time?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It is true. This is not an empirical point. It is a point about how math works. Swinging 10% of Republicans in a state where 60% of voters are Republican is equal to more points than doing the same in a state where 30% of voters are Republican.
Pick a better measure. -
Jeff Maurer
@JeffMightBWrong
The worst-performing Democrats in competitive Senate races were the candidates Bernie endorsed. (link in next tweet, no paywall)
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is not a meaningful measure of performance because the amount of votes you can swing depends on how Republican the state is to begin with. For Markey to equal Colom on this measure, he'd have to win vastly more of the MA Republicans than Colom had to win of MS Republicans.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It is true. This is not an empirical point. It is a point about how math works. Swinging 10% of Republicans in a state where 60% of voters are Republican is equal to more points than doing the same in a state where 30% of voters are Republican.
Pick a better measure. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is not a meaningful measure of performance because the amount of votes you can swing depends on how Republican the state is to begin with. For Markey to equal Colom on this measure, he'd have to win vastly more of the MA Republicans than Colom had to win of MS Republicans.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
People are choosing specifications to support whatever conclusion they like. Not unheard of but it is interesting that this sort of gut/intuition style of punditry is now so formally out of style that people feel the need to pretend they are just looking at numbers
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is not the case. I just rescraped all of the NYT Michigan data again this morning at 730am. Measured by DEM vote share, Sayed was 0.85pp below the statewide house vote. If you do the D-minus-R thing, which basically just doubles that figure, you get 1.85pp below.
daeveningglow
@InlandCaGuy
I just want to stress that I am not into factional warfare and that I wished El-Sayed all the best on a strong victory before I accurately point out that the House vote was +12 and El-Sayed won by +7, which was the biggest difference in any competitive race except Maine.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
El-Sayed Performed About the Same As Other Michigan Democrats mattbruenig.com/2026/11/04/el-sayed-performance/
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
If you're interested in the question of what is a good model for political success, it's useful to compare his performance to other federal candidates for office in Michigan.
He's far from the worst — that's Will Lawrence, white leftist — but he's below average.Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Also now I am growing increasingly fascinated by how much differently people interpret whether you present the outcome in terms of DEM vote share versus D-minus-R, even though, with some small variations due to third parties, D-minus-R just mechanically doubles the number.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But like 6 means a lot more to people than 3 even though they are representing the exact same spread.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
People are choosing specifications to support whatever conclusion they like. Not unheard of but it is interesting that this sort of gut/intuition style of punditry is now so formally out of style that people feel the need to pretend they are just looking at numbers
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
El-Sayed Performed About the Same As Other Michigan Democrats mattbruenig.com/2026/11/04/el-sayed-performance/
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
If you're interested in the question of what is a good model for political success, it's useful to compare his performance to other federal candidates for office in Michigan.
He's far from the worst — that's Will Lawrence, white leftist — but he's below average.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you are curious, here is a 13 min video of me showing how I produce this sort of thing with AI from the not-so-structured NYT election result pages youtu.be/OA9XEVL84Hk
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Same is true of Jocelyn Benson (Governor), Eli Savit (Attorney General), Garlin Gilchrist (Secretary of State), and the Michigan house candidates in aggregate. What do we conclude from this? They were all bad candidates?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
To be clear, I am open to the conclusion that all of the Michigan statewide candidates were terrible. I don't actually know much about them. But I just want to make sure we realize this is what the actual argument has to be.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Were talking about 1pp. Are you really confident that when you dig into the sui generis aspects of it that you can attribute 1pp to left-factionalism? Remember the governor is an incumbent. Do we adjust her score a bit for that? El-Sayed is a Muslim. Any adjustment there?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Were talking about 1pp. Are you really confident that when you dig into the sui generis aspects of it that you can attribute 1pp to left-factionalism? Remember the governor is an incumbent. Do we adjust her score a bit for that? El-Sayed is a Muslim. Any adjustment there?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
To be clear, I am open to the conclusion that all of the Michigan statewide candidates were terrible. I don't actually know much about them. But I just want to make sure we realize this is what the actual argument has to be.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Same is true of Jocelyn Benson (Governor), Eli Savit (Attorney General), Garlin Gilchrist (Secretary of State), and the Michigan house candidates in aggregate. What do we conclude from this? They were all bad candidates?
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
i've been replaced
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I agree of course that Singapore is very wise to use collective ownership of capital to generate revenue as in (2). This is a smart way to raise revenue that other countries should obviously copy.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
1. Much of the Singaporean welfare state is financed through "non-tax compulsory payments" into the CPF. These are akin to payroll taxes but not accounted that way.
2. Singapore generates a bunch of revenue from public ownership of capital, also not counted as tax.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you were to count the flows from (1) and (2) as tax, then the Singaporean tax as share of GDP is just a few pp below the OECD average.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I agree of course that Singapore is very wise to use collective ownership of capital to generate revenue as in (2). This is a smart way to raise revenue that other countries should obviously copy.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you were to count the flows from (1) and (2) as tax, then the Singaporean tax as share of GDP is just a few pp below the OECD average.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
1. Much of the Singaporean welfare state is financed through "non-tax compulsory payments" into the CPF. These are akin to payroll taxes but not accounted that way.
2. Singapore generates a bunch of revenue from public ownership of capital, also not counted as tax. -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Check Out My New NLRB Research AI Tool
www.nlrbedge.com/p/check-out-my-new-nlrb-research-ai -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny as hell that we basically have a system where the private health insurance companies get to dynamically set the payroll tax rates of employers.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny as hell that we basically have a system where the private health insurance companies get to dynamically set the payroll tax rates of employers.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This rhetorical strategy could no longer hold up in the COVID inflation because it was the former claim that actually generated the excitement. Indeed many of the MMT personalities actually went into "greedflation" rabbit holes during that period instead.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But this is a feature of how the movement as such worked, often saying things that sounded to many like they were claiming we could do social democracy with low tax but then other times describing basic 101 macro concepts as what MMT is.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The problem here is that your first tweet just described demand-pull inflation while the second just described Keynesian countercyclical stimulus, basic stuff you'd find in any macro textbook. Is that what MMT is? Greg Mankiw says all this.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The problem here is that your first tweet just described demand-pull inflation while the second just described Keynesian countercyclical stimulus, basic stuff you'd find in any macro textbook. Is that what MMT is? Greg Mankiw says all this.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But this is a feature of how the movement as such worked, often saying things that sounded to many like they were claiming we could do social democracy with low tax but then other times describing basic 101 macro concepts as what MMT is.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This rhetorical strategy could no longer hold up in the COVID inflation because it was the former claim that actually generated the excitement. Indeed many of the MMT personalities actually went into "greedflation" rabbit holes during that period instead.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Pretty banal and common sentiment applied to a variety of technologies that expanded the ability to produce things to much larger groups of people. The printing press is probably the most commonly told story of this sort.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The technology itself is egalitarian because it significantly reduces the gini of abilities. The open question is whether our economic institutions (whether as currently formed or with reform) will ensure this also translates into a reduction in the gini of income/wealth.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Pretty banal and common sentiment applied to a variety of technologies that expanded the ability to produce things to much larger groups of people. The printing press is probably the most commonly told story of this sort.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Consider other valuable traits. Does being especially kind, courageous, humble (etc.) result in receipt of high factor payments? Not particularly. Does this mean they are nothing and useless, like you say intelligence would be if it similarly stop getting big factor payments?
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It is useful for social legitimation that people end up confusing "the possession of a scarce factor that is valuable within the contingent technological environment" with "achievement" and "merit" but it obviously isn't that.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For one thing, you can possess the scarce factor for reasons that have little to do with effort. This is obviously true with intelligence where there are clearly people who are smarter than others despite spending less effort than those others have spent on studying etc.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For most of human history, humans did not exist in a technological environment where intelligence was especially valuable (you'd probably trade smarts for strength and physical endurance during those periods if you could). What does that tell us about the inherent value of it?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I would say "it tells us nothing about the inherent value of it because 'happens to attract large factor payments' is not an indicator of any sort of inherent value, but just the random interaction of markets and technology which seek profits/production not rewarding people"
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Consider other valuable traits. Does being especially kind, courageous, humble (etc.) result in receipt of high factor payments? Not particularly. Does this mean they are nothing and useless, like you say intelligence would be if it similarly stop getting big factor payments?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I would say "it tells us nothing about the inherent value of it because 'happens to attract large factor payments' is not an indicator of any sort of inherent value, but just the random interaction of markets and technology which seek profits/production not rewarding people"
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For most of human history, humans did not exist in a technological environment where intelligence was especially valuable (you'd probably trade smarts for strength and physical endurance during those periods if you could). What does that tell us about the inherent value of it?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For one thing, you can possess the scarce factor for reasons that have little to do with effort. This is obviously true with intelligence where there are clearly people who are smarter than others despite spending less effort than those others have spent on studying etc.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It is useful for social legitimation that people end up confusing "the possession of a scarce factor that is valuable within the contingent technological environment" with "achievement" and "merit" but it obviously isn't that.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The technology itself is egalitarian because it significantly reduces the gini of abilities. The open question is whether our economic institutions (whether as currently formed or with reform) will ensure this also translates into a reduction in the gini of income/wealth.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is anti-democratic behavior
Kellen Browning
@Kellen_Browning
SCOOP: Democrats have insisted they have nothing to do with the other Dan Sullivan on Alaska's Senate ballot.
But aides with the Mary Peltola campaign and DSCC were part of a monthslong secret plan to recruit him to run -- as well as other candidates.
www.nytimes.com/2026/10/28/us/politics/alaska-dan-sulliva… -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
used-car inflation and used-home inflation were together ~100% of it, with home dominating, I was interested in them together because they were both decried as bad economic indicators and as good economic indicators (generally unknowingly through citation of SCF aggregates)
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
the great used car inflation as detected in the SCF
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This was a very heavily-reported upon thing at the time. There was a semiconductor shortage which caused a new car shortage which drove up used car prices
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I am posting this here mostly just because one flavor of "economy actually good" argument that was floating around in 2023/2024 was based on this SCF wealth data which was in part juiced by the fact that used car inflation was scored as a boon to middle class wealth
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
used-car inflation and used-home inflation were together ~100% of it, with home dominating, I was interested in them together because they were both decried as bad economic indicators and as good economic indicators (generally unknowingly through citation of SCF aggregates)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Tommy Vietor
@TVietor08
I hate this condescending whataboutism. Yes Bret, if the interior minister of Japan was a right-wing religious zealot using US taxpayer money for ethnic cleansing, they would probably be better known.
Chris Menahan 🇺🇸
@infolibnews
NYT's Bret Stephens whines that Democrats know "Smotrich and Ben-Gvir" but not "the interior minister of Japan."
Their "obsession" with Israel drives him "crazy."
(Being politically informed on Israel is now anti-Semitic.)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I wrote my undergrad "capstone" paper about problems with Nozick's version of the Lockean proviso (which is central to how he attempts to escape the liberty-destroying nature of initial property acquisition)
-
Malcolm Harris
@BigMeanInternet
I'm just a humble UMD government and politics BA, but do they not usually teach Nozick with Rawls?
Rishi Joe Sanu 🌐🗽🏙
@RishiJoeSanu
Reposting this banger from @ContraPoints.
Leftists overestimate themselves massively. They're not nearly as eclectically well-read as they think they are.
Brett
@BrooklynBrett
I’m a liberal and I’ve read Marx, Engels, Mises, Hayek, Schumpeter etc. I’ve never met a socialist who has read the last three.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I wrote my undergrad "capstone" paper about problems with Nozick's version of the Lockean proviso (which is central to how he attempts to escape the liberty-destroying nature of initial property acquisition)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I am posting this here mostly just because one flavor of "economy actually good" argument that was floating around in 2023/2024 was based on this SCF wealth data which was in part juiced by the fact that used car inflation was scored as a boon to middle class wealth
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This was a very heavily-reported upon thing at the time. There was a semiconductor shortage which caused a new car shortage which drove up used car prices
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That replacing pull up bars is considered a massive neighborhood disruption helps explain why something that is actually much more disruptive, like building housing, is opposed. You don't even seem to disagree with the point!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That replacing pull up bars is considered a massive neighborhood disruption helps explain why something that is actually much more disruptive, like building housing, is opposed. You don't even seem to disagree with the point!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Liz Shuler
@LizShuler
Good luck to our @MLBPA brothers on the @Brewers and @RaysBaseball as the World Series gets underway!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
jen ramos-eisen
@jenramose
NEWS: the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders have unionized and the Cowboys have agreed to recognize the union
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is what happens when you don't use AI to help draft your legislation.
-
Jordan Weissmann
@JHWeissmann
Guys, this foie gras ban is so sloppily written that it would ban Jewish delis from selling chopped chicken liver.
Absolutely vote no on this shit.Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is what happens when you don't use AI to help draft your legislation.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Weird thing is when you click the link, the whole thrust of the intro is that Mehdi is a careerist chameleon who doesn't really have deep views. I don't know if that's true, but seems like it would make the Mehdi Hasan Test hard to apply!
-
Nikhil Pal Singh
@nikhil_palsingh
At this point we're all inured to the ascendancy of right-wing politics, but it is remarkable that this is now respectable opinion within the Atlantic set.
James Kirchick
@jkirchick
The Mehdi Hasan Test for immigration to the United States:
People with the views and associations of Mehdi Hasan should be barred from American citizenship.
My latest in @Commentary
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/mehdi-hasan-th…
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Weird thing is when you click the link, the whole thrust of the intro is that Mehdi is a careerist chameleon who doesn't really have deep views. I don't know if that's true, but seems like it would make the Mehdi Hasan Test hard to apply!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Do they permit stadium workers to wear ear protection. How do they interact with customers if they are blocking their ears?
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If the NCAA can't fix this, the government needs to step in. This a recipe for hearing damage, especially for the stadium workers.
On3
@On3
NEW: Tennessee set the highest scientifically verified dB record in College Football history against Alabama on this play (130.3), the school announced.
(via ABC)Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Stadium workers have to come. It's their job.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Do they permit stadium workers to wear ear protection. How do they interact with customers if they are blocking their ears?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Stadium workers have to come. It's their job.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Louis Riel
@theGhostOfRiel
Ladies and gentleman, I present for your enjoyment,
The right wing saboteur, Neera Tanden.
support in bio.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But you are right that the conservative interest is no longer in promoting the idea that the Church should have a public role in service-providing (not just towards refugees, but homeless, drunks, etc.) and towards more base ethnoreligious chauvinism.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I volunteered with a christian (Lutheran) refugee resettlement org in North Texas. This used to be seen as a conservative-friendly thing because it allowed churches to receive government money to do civil society type initiatives.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So conservatives used to be very interested in Christianity. Christianity is big on the refugee (Mary, Joseph,and Jesus were themselves refugees from Egypt per Matthew, "the stranger" etc). Then separately there is this conservative idea that the Church is better at this stuff.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But then there was this conflict about whether giving public money to churches to do this sort of thing was a violation of church and state and whether it should be done secularly, etc. So doing it this way was seen as an own of the libs, a blow against secularity.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But you are right that the conservative interest is no longer in promoting the idea that the Church should have a public role in service-providing (not just towards refugees, but homeless, drunks, etc.) and towards more base ethnoreligious chauvinism.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But then there was this conflict about whether giving public money to churches to do this sort of thing was a violation of church and state and whether it should be done secularly, etc. So doing it this way was seen as an own of the libs, a blow against secularity.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So conservatives used to be very interested in Christianity. Christianity is big on the refugee (Mary, Joseph,and Jesus were themselves refugees from Egypt per Matthew, "the stranger" etc). Then separately there is this conservative idea that the Church is better at this stuff.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I volunteered with a christian (Lutheran) refugee resettlement org in North Texas. This used to be seen as a conservative-friendly thing because it allowed churches to receive government money to do civil society type initiatives.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Curious about this after seeing Trump going forward with basing some of federal transit funding on fertility
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When you see large negative percentages at the median with wealth, it is almost always a quirk of that group carrying close to $0 wealth at the median to begin with. Wealth is not zero-bounded and medians carry very little of it to begin with. Basically no change here.
unusual_whales
@unusual_whales
BREAKING: Young Americans are falling further behind.
Change in median net worth by age since 2022, per the Federal Reserve:
75 and older: +37%
65–74: -4%
55–64: +3%
45–54: -6%
35–44: +5%
Under 35: -23%
The youngest households saw the biggest drop of any group, while the oldest saw the biggest gain -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One of my go-to bits is to just pop into a conversation and go "did you consider inequality though?" It tends to deliver but only because for some reason nobody ever does
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Here is a replication of the graph followed by a different version of it that, rather than plotting absolute levels, plots what share of the national wealth those levels represented at that time. Very different picture.
Jeremy Horpedahl 🥚📉
@jmhorp
Very exciting to update this chart with the 2025 data!
Millennials at age 40 have about 60% more real net worth than Boomers did at age 40, and almost 100 percent more than Gen X
Jeremy Horpedahl 🥚📉
@jmhorp
THE 2025 FED SCF DATA HAS FINALLY BEEN RELEASED!!!
www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scfindex.htmPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Here it is if you do mean wealth of generation divided by mean national wealth, so that the population-size differences of the buckets don't skew it
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
dividing median by median for wealth is a big mess because virtually zero wealth is held at the median in any slice and wealth has no zero bound. Discussed this extensively with the racial wealth gap as well. If you talking medians, you just aren't talking about wealth at all.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One of my go-to bits is to just pop into a conversation and go "did you consider inequality though?" It tends to deliver but only because for some reason nobody ever does
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
dividing median by median for wealth is a big mess because virtually zero wealth is held at the median in any slice and wealth has no zero bound. Discussed this extensively with the racial wealth gap as well. If you talking medians, you just aren't talking about wealth at all.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Here it is if you do mean wealth of generation divided by mean national wealth, so that the population-size differences of the buckets don't skew it
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Also new in the 2025 SCF is they have a remote work variable for the first time. @ModeledBehavior
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One of the more troubling things that comes from using AI agents for microdata analysis is when they figure out that the codebook/documentation is incorrect and does not match what is actually in the microdata. Wonder how many reports out there are wrong because of this.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For the first time, the 2025 SCF asks questions about whether the family missed payments of various sorts. No surprises here
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Norway's controversial 2021–2024 reforms nearly doubled the tax on business wealth. Firms of affected owners did not invest less, and outmigration was limited to the very top, from @Mariusring www.nber.org/papers/w35854
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The 2025 SCF records the first significant student debt decline
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don't think the point is about slowdown per se. But what this shows is that, in reality, it is not really possible to create departments inside of firms that exist to critique management if that same management can also fire them whenever they want.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don't think the point is about slowdown per se. But what this shows is that, in reality, it is not really possible to create departments inside of firms that exist to critique management if that same management can also fire them whenever they want.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Soviet Visuals
@sovietvisuals
"Family portrait" photo by Vasily Ulitin, Soviet Russia, 1920s.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What is a Public Option?
(link below) -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Conor Coutts
@ConorCoutts
LMAO. Reporter tries the 'data center jobs are temporary' line on a Pennsylvania tradesman literally building one.
His answer: “Every job in my field is temporary.” -
Matt Bruenig reposted
FactPost
@factpostnews
Pete Hegseth trails behind the crowd while running with troops in San Diego
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
WSJ should send a reporter to Alaska where children are given a share of the Alaska Permanent Fund equal to around $120,000 through which they hold shares of whatever the Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation decides they should hold.
-
Greg Ip
@greg_ip
1/ Mind blowing story about Trump accounts by @RichardRubinDC & @ashleaebeling. Under Treasury's new rules, a company can donate stock to a child's Trump account; parents can’t pick the stocks, reject donated shares, or sell for 5 years. Some possible implications...
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
WSJ should send a reporter to Alaska where children are given a share of the Alaska Permanent Fund equal to around $120,000 through which they hold shares of whatever the Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation decides they should hold.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
first time doing data analysis with Astra actually, performs well!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is a good point. It is nonsensical to say people are responsible for the outcomes of their lives when they are forced to make decisions with very high future uncertainty. But this problem with "conservatism" applies with or without AI. This is just all life!
Gregory Conti
@GregoryConti19
This is one of the worst parts of our present moment: living a free, self-directed life according to one's best-laid plans has been rendered impossible due to the uncertainty that AI brings.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
People make decisions about where to live, who to form families with, what topics to study, what occupations to go into with massive uncertainty about how any of it will shake out *in their case* because there is so much that is completely out of their control.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The move of conservatism is generally to, after the fact, try to pinpoint the decisions that "caused" your bad outcome without regard for whether those could have been identified in advance or that there is a range of good and bad individual outcomes for many decisions.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If the failure mode is "bad government making bad rules", then this applies regardless of whether the insurance is "public" "publicly-funded" or "heavily regulated." The arg is a push that doesn't favor or disfavor any of the three models.
-
Logan Bowers 🏗️ 🏘️
@loganb
I’ve never seen single-payer enthusiasts grapple with the fact that it would require permanent liberal domination of the government or else folks would lose lifesaving care.
Seems risky.
Talking Points Memo
@TPM
Because of federal rules, children covered by Medicaid won't be able to access vaccines that are no longer recommended by the federal government, even as children with private insurance will. talkingpointsmemo.com/news/rfk-jrs-relentless-anti-vax-pu…
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The federal government could ban private insurers from covering vaccines. It already largely dictates what private insurers do and don't cover already through the ACA rules. People seem to really lose track mentally of how this works I guess for ideological reasons.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Of course, what exactly is the alternative being proposed here by someone like Logan. Like imagine that somehow we stipulate the government doesn't largely control private insurance coverage packages, what then do we do for those on low incomes?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
They can't get private insurance because of the user fee, right? Do they voucherize it? Is the government in this world both somehow magically unable to regulate private insurance *and* unable to regulate what plans the voucher can be spent on?
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You don't need any expertise to think through this specific aspect of the topic. Health insurance premiums will not drop to $0 (certainly not without government subsidy, which you identify as having control problems). So some kids won't be able to get it. So what then?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The options clearly are:
1. No insurance for them.
2. Government voucher for private insurance.
3. Government-provided insurance.
(1) is not good for vaccine, right? And (2) and (3) permit the government to set anti-vax rules right? So how does this work?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
(For this question put aside the fact that even for people who have money to pay unsubsidized private insurance premiums, there is nothing to stop the government from regulating what those plans cover, and indeed they do so right now)
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I’ve never seen [people who think such things as "health care needs to be heavily regulated"] grapple with the fact that it would require permanent liberal domination of the government or else folks would lose lifesaving care.
Seems risky.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If the failure mode is "bad government making bad rules", then this applies regardless of whether the insurance is "public" "publicly-funded" or "heavily regulated." The arg is a push that doesn't favor or disfavor any of the three models.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I’ve never seen [people who think such things as "health care needs to be heavily regulated"] grapple with the fact that it would require permanent liberal domination of the government or else folks would lose lifesaving care.
Seems risky. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
(For this question put aside the fact that even for people who have money to pay unsubsidized private insurance premiums, there is nothing to stop the government from regulating what those plans cover, and indeed they do so right now)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The options clearly are:
1. No insurance for them.
2. Government voucher for private insurance.
3. Government-provided insurance.
(1) is not good for vaccine, right? And (2) and (3) permit the government to set anti-vax rules right? So how does this work? -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You don't need any expertise to think through this specific aspect of the topic. Health insurance premiums will not drop to $0 (certainly not without government subsidy, which you identify as having control problems). So some kids won't be able to get it. So what then?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
They can't get private insurance because of the user fee, right? Do they voucherize it? Is the government in this world both somehow magically unable to regulate private insurance *and* unable to regulate what plans the voucher can be spent on?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Of course, what exactly is the alternative being proposed here by someone like Logan. Like imagine that somehow we stipulate the government doesn't largely control private insurance coverage packages, what then do we do for those on low incomes?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The federal government could ban private insurers from covering vaccines. It already largely dictates what private insurers do and don't cover already through the ACA rules. People seem to really lose track mentally of how this works I guess for ideological reasons.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Can AI Write a Successful Arbitration Brief?
...
Yes
(link below) -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
not going to happen @optimum
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Jeff Stein
@jstein_sun
NEWS: Trump to host "most EXCLUSIVE DINNER IN THE WORLD" for top 185 purchasers of his meme crypto
Buying $1M (or less!) worth of $TRUMP coin should get you in Nov 22
Trump has pocketed $635 million
Investors down +$4 billion on Trump crypto
Invite ⬇️
www.washingtonsun.com/whitehouse/trump-meme-coin-dinner-c… -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
interesting
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
interesting
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
To be clear, the NLRB rejected that this is a legitimate basis for throwing out union election results
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think it is quite often the opposite, that language itself is a huge impediment to clear thinking. People can become completely obsessed and transfixed with certain words. A wild amount of discourse is fighting over definitions, and labels, and just straight-up equivocation.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
one common thing you see in the discourse is the ability to write "well" (within certain canons of what that means) masquerading as the ability to think or make sense or whatever, it's quite a mess!
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
The head of the philosophy department at Williams College downplays the pedagogical value of writing:
“What if we are mistaken in treating writing as the highest cultivation of thought? The evidence that supports this belief is thin at best. Writing can be useful cognitive scaffolding for memory and self-regulated learning, but the notion that it is the best process for developing thinking skills is a fairly recent idea, traceable to the 1970s writing-across-the-curriculum movement.”Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think it is quite often the opposite, that language itself is a huge impediment to clear thinking. People can become completely obsessed and transfixed with certain words. A wild amount of discourse is fighting over definitions, and labels, and just straight-up equivocation.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The Postal Service is Drowning the NLRB (link below)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This sort of upcoding is literally the exact same fraud that insurance companies do against the US government in Medicare Advantage.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This sort of upcoding is literally the exact same fraud that insurance companies do against the US government in Medicare Advantage.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Gio Huh ✈️ CoRL 2026
@giohuh_
What can Astra do when given a humanoid embodiment?
We built HomeBody to find out. Controlled by GPT Astra, it carries out long-horizon tasks in a previously unseen kitchen—from tidying up across the room to retrieving remembered objects from ambiguous requests—without environment-specific training data or additional policy learning.
Here's how we did it 👀: tml.stanford.edu/homebody/This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
0.75% of GDP is a joke!
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
$2.4 trillion out of a $324 trillion GDP is a drop in the bucket!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
0.75% of GDP is a joke!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
$2.4 trillion out of a $324 trillion GDP is a drop in the bucket!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Good piece. Also need to consider what kinds of never-skilling is a problem. For example, by the time I went to law school, book-based legal research was basically over and my law school never taught us how to do it. We only learned legal database research.
Rachael Bedard
@RBMD1982
I think @ZekeEmanuel and others are wrong about AI replacing physicians, but AI is already playing an important role in my clinical life. I’ve come to rely on @OpenEvidence enormously, and I believe it’s making me a better doctor. At the same time, I worry that frictionless access to clinical decision support is making my learners worse.
I wrote about this for @nytopinion: www.nytimes.com/2026/09/25/opinion/ai-doctor-medical-stud…
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If future law students only learn how to research using agents searching through databases, is that a problem? Or is like how I don't know really how to do book-based legal research.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Occasionally I like to reflect on this partially state-owned enterprise in Norway where 16.69 percent of the shares seem to have been abandoned by some unknown owner. The returns to these shares go to a special account set up for the owner should they ever be found.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Perhaps even more than the blind trust situation, this situation *really* is like a thought experiment in asking what exactly do capital owners *do* for their income. Never see this kind of thing for labor...
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Disagree. I think this is the best and clearest (and interestingly one of the oldest) understandings of its purpose:
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
No matter how you slice it, you see the same thing, which is that around half of people experience income declines while around half experience income increases from one year to the next, which is pretty typical.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Here it is as time series
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Here it is but restricted to 10%, 25%, and 50% increases/decreases of income from prior year.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Income is very volatile. On the most extreme end, over 1 in 10 Americans see their income halved in a single year!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yeah I think it's surprising to a lot of people because most are unaware that people move up and down the income distribution a lot. We tend to pick a part of the distribution (e.g. the 50th percentile) and report that number which ignores the underlying churning.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
By the same token, most are surprised to find that the majority of people who are in poverty in one year are not in poverty the next year.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Only if you understand the welfare state in the anglo/liberal/means-testing sort of way and even then only for welfare needs that present in later life as opposed to early life. Creates no problems at all for the correct universalist socdem welfare understanding.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Not at all. Indeed, wage compression achieves precisely this. As usual, the Nordic combo points the way.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
who is transferring to who? Is it the compressed Nordic wages that are transferring from high-earners to low-earners, or the uncompressed US wages that are transferring from low-earners to high-earners?
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Why is it an unfree market when wage-setting is done through negotiations with labor organizations instead of individual laborers? Is it similarly unfree when wage-setting is done through negotiations with capital organizations (corpations) instead of individual capital owners?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I am not trying to be cute here. I think you are poisoned a bit here with some unreflective hegemony. How wages are struck is a creature of institutional design. All sorts of things go into it. Amusingly, as many will note, the *state* is less involved in wage setting in Nordics
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When millions of people pool their capital into a corporation and then appoint a leader to bargain as a single entity on their behalf, with each receiving the same (per-share) dividends and capital gains, what is that?
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Disagree. I think this is the best and clearest (and interestingly one of the oldest) understandings of its purpose:
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When millions of people pool their capital into a corporation and then appoint a leader to bargain as a single entity on their behalf, with each receiving the same (per-share) dividends and capital gains, what is that?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I am not trying to be cute here. I think you are poisoned a bit here with some unreflective hegemony. How wages are struck is a creature of institutional design. All sorts of things go into it. Amusingly, as many will note, the *state* is less involved in wage setting in Nordics
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Why is it an unfree market when wage-setting is done through negotiations with labor organizations instead of individual laborers? Is it similarly unfree when wage-setting is done through negotiations with capital organizations (corpations) instead of individual capital owners?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
And of course, we can run this back even further and start pondering whether other collective action defection choices are behind the desire to peer-avoid, such as the choice to pursue very inegalitarian income distributions in the society.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
"initial" and "principled" are fake terms here. In general defect-defect is wildly costly for a family in a lot of these cases. Consider scenario where 30% of kids are defecting for peer-avoidance reasons but if none of them defected, they wouldn't "need" to peer-avoid.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you run out a private school tuition across 13 years, each of these families is foregoing potentially a $1 million trust for their child to achieve something they could have achieved through cooperate-cooperate. Depriving your kid of $1 million seems not great!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
And of course, we can run this back even further and start pondering whether other collective action defection choices are behind the desire to peer-avoid, such as the choice to pursue very inegalitarian income distributions in the society.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you run out a private school tuition across 13 years, each of these families is foregoing potentially a $1 million trust for their child to achieve something they could have achieved through cooperate-cooperate. Depriving your kid of $1 million seems not great!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
"initial" and "principled" are fake terms here. In general defect-defect is wildly costly for a family in a lot of these cases. Consider scenario where 30% of kids are defecting for peer-avoidance reasons but if none of them defected, they wouldn't "need" to peer-avoid.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
who is transferring to who? Is it the compressed Nordic wages that are transferring from high-earners to low-earners, or the uncompressed US wages that are transferring from low-earners to high-earners?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Not at all. Indeed, wage compression achieves precisely this. As usual, the Nordic combo points the way.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Only if you understand the welfare state in the anglo/liberal/means-testing sort of way and even then only for welfare needs that present in later life as opposed to early life. Creates no problems at all for the correct universalist socdem welfare understanding.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
By the same token, most are surprised to find that the majority of people who are in poverty in one year are not in poverty the next year.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yeah I think it's surprising to a lot of people because most are unaware that people move up and down the income distribution a lot. We tend to pick a part of the distribution (e.g. the 50th percentile) and report that number which ignores the underlying churning.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
Now more than ever, do not get negatively polarized by the goofy goober arguments floating around
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
obama speaks too slowly, brutal listen, need 2x or 3x even
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
As with many such big think discussions about human nature, "true for some people, not for others" is the obviously true answer.
Ruxandra Teslo 🧬
@RuxandraTeslo
I have written recently about how the anxiety around AI is one of a loss of meaning and agency. I discussed work in this context specifically and am glad to see more comprehensive research on the topic.
www.writingruxandrabio.com/p/curing-cancer-wont-redeem-ai
"As a matter of fact, it is simply not true that most people dislike their jobs or derive no meaning from them, even when those jobs may look unappealing from the vantage point of an intellectual. But I fear that a world of mass unemployment would be destabilizing in ways such surveys do not capture, because they only reveal how much people appreciate jobs at a first-order level. Whereas there are many second-order functions of work that they somewhat take for granted when replying to such surveys.
A job is not merely a bundle of tasks that one enjoys or not. Around it sit a myriad of deeply intertwined social functions like status, independence, recognition, bargaining power, advancement, obligation, and the sense of being needed by others. If we step one level further from the individual, to the societal level, work may even be one of the foundations on which modern political equality rests. A society in which most people possess some economic leverage may allow very different political arrangements compared to one in which a large share of the population is materially supported, but not actually needed.
A book could be written about these social and political embeddedness roles that “work” has, so I will not aim to be exhaustive here. Instead, I will focus on three dimensions that seem especially important: the role of work in social mobility and its deeper role in the American conception of the self, the relationship between human labor and political rights, and the place of work in sustaining agency and independence."
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The more interesting question in these hypothetical worlds is whether you would take this necessarily mixed population and make them all work, even the ones who are happy not to. Creating jobs as hobbies for those who want them would, in the hypothetical, be pretty easy.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Department of War 🇺🇸
@DeptofWar
Last Thursday, we welcomed Logan and Jake Paul to the Pentagon to meet with our warriors.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Data centers in Finland
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Senior PowerPoint Engineer
@ryxcommar
stepping down from your mgmt role before you shit talk the dumb company policy is a real ball knower move
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Kind of interesting from today's round up. Snowflake (of database fame) engineer complained that the company's new API change policy was too vague and they fired him and the Board reinstated him.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Daniel Kay Hertz
@DanielKayHertz
A real idea that someone should fund, or just volunteer and do: Governmental pdf freeing via LLM tools.
From personal experience, there is oodles of data that public sector agencies have but can't act on because it's locked in a million pdfs (or poorly formatted excels). -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's great obviously that people, you know, grow over time and all that. But if you were once aggressively "full of shit" such that you have to do a mea culpa about it, maybe you are a moron and your current thinking is also weak.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This response makes me wonder if the through line here is these people are just broadly not very bright. Economic freedom indexes generally measure rule of law and bureaucratic efficiency. Socialism is about collective ownership not about planning (hence market socialism). Etc.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's great obviously that people, you know, grow over time and all that. But if you were once aggressively "full of shit" such that you have to do a mea culpa about it, maybe you are a moron and your current thinking is also weak.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This response makes me wonder if the through line here is these people are just broadly not very bright. Economic freedom indexes generally measure rule of law and bureaucratic efficiency. Socialism is about collective ownership not about planning (hence market socialism). Etc.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You can see another version of this in Dayen's quadrennial list of big reforms that could be done by executive order. I think part of the motivation is just to say Dems refuse to use the power they have. Biden's big efforts on this front were reversed by courts, but still.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This particular position was taken many years ago as part of saying we don't need new legislation. We just need people appointed to the FTC and DOJ who are serious about the law. Such people were appointed by Biden to not much effect, but the underlying commitment remains.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
More recently you have a somewhat orthogonal quirk of the antitrust grouping where they have this very strong belief that we can achieve a great economy already if only the regulators would use the latent authority they have.
-
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
I think to understand the left of center skepticism of AI Safety you have to remember that lots of people have been convinced these companies have products that no one actually wants and are imminently facing immense financial difficulties
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
More recently you have a somewhat orthogonal quirk of the antitrust grouping where they have this very strong belief that we can achieve a great economy already if only the regulators would use the latent authority they have.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This particular position was taken many years ago as part of saying we don't need new legislation. We just need people appointed to the FTC and DOJ who are serious about the law. Such people were appointed by Biden to not much effect, but the underlying commitment remains.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You can see another version of this in Dayen's quadrennial list of big reforms that could be done by executive order. I think part of the motivation is just to say Dems refuse to use the power they have. Biden's big efforts on this front were reversed by courts, but still.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The new ASEC is out. Guess I'll be doing some graphs. This one shows what share of the poor come from each group.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Here is what it looks like if you remove the elderly from it. A bit more what you probably would think since people tend to forget that old-age benefits do in fact go to those with low (market) incomes.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
work requirements in reality just indiscriminately remove people through admin burdens
Katie Bergh
@Katie_Bergh
As SNAP enrollment in Arizona plummeted over the last year, it was clear that many families were being denied despite being eligible — often because they called & called but couldn't get through to complete the required interview. Now, we have the data:
www.kjzz.org/politics/2026-09-11/data-shows-des-failed-to… -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
getting a kick out of this bill collector
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When I switched ISPs from Optimum, the company went into full scam mode. Only time I've seen worse behavior than this is with a gym membership. I'm not paying this of course, as I told them when I cancelled.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Kansas Football
@KU_Football
It is that deep.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One interesting aspect of some AI harm scenarios (the ones involving malicious people not rogue AI) is that the proximate mechanism of harm is just too many people having too much access to "intelligence." Suggests at some margins extra educational gains would be dangerous.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
alz
@alz_zyd_
Results from a clever AI-interview: people who never want to have kids generally say the reason is it constrains their freedom and personal time. People who may someday want to have kids say they don't have them now because they're expensive
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Probably only country in the world more confused about how to do distributional analysis is Australia. Just a culture completely overwhelmed by basic mistakes. See here for a conceptual explanation of how confused it is www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2021/11/30/illustrating-the-…
Ben Phillips
@BenPhillips_ANU
Great new report by @CISOZ on universal childcare shows 68% of the benefit (subsidy) goes to the top 40% of income distribution. Would increase annual cost by about $6.8b to around $23b and for potentially little gain to children.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There are a couple of great studies about memory based on 9/11 where they asked a group of people to record their memories within a few days of 9/11 and then followed up with them multiple times years later. The short of it is people have extremely unreliable memories!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There are a couple of great studies about memory based on 9/11 where they asked a group of people to record their memories within a few days of 9/11 and then followed up with them multiple times years later. The short of it is people have extremely unreliable memories!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
what NFL season does to TV watching
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny to imagine our inability to see beyond our institution of IP monopoly rents operating as a fetter on technology that could accelerate the sort of innovations the IP monopoly rents are meant to generate
Joseph Allen
@j_g_allen
Apply this situation to the economy and you see why there are big problems ahead
The situation:
-two math whizzes leverage the latest *publicly available* AI to work on solving Navier-Stokes. They’re onto something.
-openAI sees it, wants to win, so puts 10,000 agents from their latest *private* model that is already light-years ahead of what’s publicly available on it
-they solve it in just a few days
The economy problem
-let’s say I leverage the latest publicly available model and find a way to detect skin cancer. I’ve spent tens of thousands on tokens, proven it can work. I get investors and build a company. A path to saving many lives and making hundreds of millions is clear
-openAI (or Google or Meta or Anthropic) see this hundred million opportunity and point their private most-advanced AI model and 10,000 agents toward my idea. In a few days, they win.
Repeat this thought experiment for pharma, legal, medicine, advanced materials, software…
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Some of this discourse just makes me think about Marx watching the industrial revolution blitz over feudal property relations. Why on earth would we maintain IP monopoly rents in a theoretical world where producing such ideas is cheap and easy
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If AI could eradicate IP as an institution, that alone would be a pretty neat accomplishment
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
jacob
@JacobGorb
If you’re a creative Brooklyn NYC is a vibe 🔥🔥
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Tennessee Valley Authority
@TVAnews
Keeping the power flowing doesn’t take a day off. ⚡🇺🇸
This Labor Day, we recognize the dedicated TVA employees and our local power company partners working across the Tennessee Valley to keep the power flowing today and every day. 🇺🇸🛠️
Have a safe and enjoyable Labor Day! -
Matt Bruenig reposted
BLS-Labor Statistics
@BLS_gov
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Paul E Williams
@PEWilliams_
The world’s most advanced models are beginning to emulate Matt Bruenig
Ken
@Ken67547214
It's using the forums as a scratch pad to study poverty statistics?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
The chief economist of Sweden’s blue-collar unions:
“My fear isn’t that AI will eliminate jobs.
My fear is the opposite: that we won’t eliminate unnecessary jobs and inefficient companies quickly enough.”
torbjörn hållö
@torbjornhallo
Skriver i krönika på @GoteborgsPosten om att AI ger möjlighet att satsa på kärnverksamhet & skära på ”lull-lull”
Min rädsla är inte att AI ska slå ut jobb
Min rädsla är omvända. Att vi inte tillräckligt snabbt slår ut onödiga jobb & ineffektiva företag
www.gp.se/ledare/gastkolumn/ai-ar-bra-for-svenska-arbetar… -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
tennis is bigger than war
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
tennis is bigger than war
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is a fun piece as an illustration that nobody really has any idea what the numerator and denominator is supposed to be for "progressivity." The end, where they muse on whether to impute income to SAHMs and put that in the denominator, is peak.
Kyle Pomerleau
@kpomerleau
My friend @alex_durante_ and I wrote a bit more about this issue
The bottom line is that, properly measured, Social Security benefits are progressive.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Sadly, plucking one one particular tax, program or other institutional feature for distributional scrutiny, was convincingly declared meaningless and nonsensical by Nagel and Murphy, and so the whole debate is kind of beside the point as fun as it is.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Sincerely, I think moving away from the *current model* of merit based on *intelligence* might benefit you specifically.
-
Jeff Stein
@jstein_sun
An exhilarating idea from @MattBruenig
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Sincerely, I think moving away from the *current model* of merit based on *intelligence* might benefit you specifically.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Three More Thoughts on AI mattbruenig.com/2026/08/31/more-thoughts-on-ai/
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Keegs 🧮🏗️
@LittleKeegs0
Americans don't trust the government but really like money, can't say I'm surprised
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Paul E Williams
@PEWilliams_
While it's important to note that people do not like the "UBI" term, many of the most popular policies are just other forms of "getting a check from the government."
Top polling items include "Data Dividend", "Guaranteed Jobs Caring for Family", "Universal Retirement Accounts".
Dean W. Ball
@deanwball
People in AI discourse generally ignore the fact that UBI consistently polls very poorly. People want to work.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Never said anything about social conservatives. You are probably confusing my point about the job guarantee being a workfare program (JG has nothing to do with MMT logically). I've pointed out that this is how Hyman Minsky (whose writings they point to) described it.
-
Nathan J Robinson
@NathanJRobinson
It's just false that MMT believes "spending has no consequences." The argument they always made was that spending is constrained ONLY by its consequences rather than by any inherent cap on the amount of money a sovereign government has available to spend.
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
The @wsj published a Craaazy piece invoking me by name, while conveniently failing to inform readers that inflation sits at the core of the MMT project (the second chapter of my book, The Deficit Myth, is literally titled "Think of Inflation.") So, yeah, spending (not just government spending) carries inflation risk (sometimes negligible, sometimes elevated).
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
MMT leaders played a game where they strategically let people believe that they had found some way to do 50% of GDP public spending at a 30% of GDP tax level, which is where the excitement came from. Then for others they just uninterestingly observed monetary seignorage exists.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I assume you are talking about this, where I listed five different approaches countries can and have used to bring financial assets into an SWF, including having their central bank buy things other than bonds when expanding their balance sheet.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When I say that they uninterestingly observed monetary seignorage exists, I mean it's uninteresting because this has been known since literally the Romans. That you think this is novel is sadly again an artifact of them targeting marks.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Never said anything about social conservatives. You are probably confusing my point about the job guarantee being a workfare program (JG has nothing to do with MMT logically). I've pointed out that this is how Hyman Minsky (whose writings they point to) described it.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When I say that they uninterestingly observed monetary seignorage exists, I mean it's uninteresting because this has been known since literally the Romans. That you think this is novel is sadly again an artifact of them targeting marks.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I assume you are talking about this, where I listed five different approaches countries can and have used to bring financial assets into an SWF, including having their central bank buy things other than bonds when expanding their balance sheet.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
MMT leaders played a game where they strategically let people believe that they had found some way to do 50% of GDP public spending at a 30% of GDP tax level, which is where the excitement came from. Then for others they just uninterestingly observed monetary seignorage exists.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We have this whole system of old-age benefits including defined-benefit pensions, IRAs/401ks, and Social Security. If you think there is a crisis of too-high old-age benefits, then you should look at the whole thing and look at where to cut. Yet you only look at SS.
-
Dean W. Ball
@deanwball
The main thing I have to say to the young generation of Americans is that your grandparents and great-grandparents committed a kind of accounting fraud when they ran our country a century ago with social security, and at the time it was a reasonable affordance to grant our leaders, who were dealing with an economic depression and a world war, but nonetheless they did commit the fraud, and they ended up buying all sorts of extravagant things using the fraudulent gains, including what became the thing we now understand to be the high-modern technocratic nation-state, and that is glorious and also bad and all that, but the thing is there’s still the issue about the accounting fraud, whose debt is coming due and is coming due fast.
It is best to consider this with as minimal residue of sentiment as possible, to really sit with it, to stare it coldly in the face.
Unwinding the great fraud of the high modernists is your job, whether you wish it to be or not.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Transferring from the currently-working to the currently-nonworking has been going on since time-immemorial and will continue to do so. How else could any society work given the realities of childhood, old age, disability, etc. You can tweak details but it's all the same thing.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
True that, finance, insurance, and the welfare state made it so that the transfers are spread out across the entire population, which has been a major improvement overall in terms of coverage and adequacy and making transfers smooth and predictable. No change in sustainability.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
No. You don't seem to understand. The thing that is allowing the childless to receive tremendous sums in retirement is *the financial system* not the state. The *financial system* provides literal millions to an average person who redirects child-rearing expenses into a 401k.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Social Security on the other hand provides money to those who, perhaps because they had a large number of children, could not put much into the financial system.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The clear net winners from the universal old-age pension are those who forego 401k riches in favor of having kids. If you'd like to even it out, there is a very obvious mechanism. Tax 401ks/IRAs and put it into Social Security. I wrote the piece! www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/03/01/social-security…
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
what on earth are you talking about, 401k/IRA are retirement accounts you access after age 59.5. To tax them is to tax old-age benefits in a way that hits the wealthy hardest. It's is literally perfectly designed for your stated goals (but those aren't your goals, are they?)
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We have this whole system of old-age benefits including defined-benefit pensions, IRAs/401ks, and Social Security. If you think there is a crisis of too-high old-age benefits, then you should look at the whole thing and look at where to cut. Yet you only look at SS.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
what on earth are you talking about, 401k/IRA are retirement accounts you access after age 59.5. To tax them is to tax old-age benefits in a way that hits the wealthy hardest. It's is literally perfectly designed for your stated goals (but those aren't your goals, are they?)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The clear net winners from the universal old-age pension are those who forego 401k riches in favor of having kids. If you'd like to even it out, there is a very obvious mechanism. Tax 401ks/IRAs and put it into Social Security. I wrote the piece! www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/03/01/social-security…
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Social Security on the other hand provides money to those who, perhaps because they had a large number of children, could not put much into the financial system.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
No. You don't seem to understand. The thing that is allowing the childless to receive tremendous sums in retirement is *the financial system* not the state. The *financial system* provides literal millions to an average person who redirects child-rearing expenses into a 401k.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
True that, finance, insurance, and the welfare state made it so that the transfers are spread out across the entire population, which has been a major improvement overall in terms of coverage and adequacy and making transfers smooth and predictable. No change in sustainability.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Transferring from the currently-working to the currently-nonworking has been going on since time-immemorial and will continue to do so. How else could any society work given the realities of childhood, old age, disability, etc. You can tweak details but it's all the same thing.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
RIP Dolly Parton, one of the top (era-adjusted) celebrities of all time.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Of course, the whole electrician profession in general is engaged in job-elimination, as electricity is used to replace human labor.
-
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
Electricians love the Death Star. You must support building it because there is so much union wiring to be done on the Death Star. Support this, or you hate labor. Nothing else needs built or wired in this country but Death Stars so this is the only possible way to create jobs.
Mike McCarthy
@its_mccarthy
Betting on union jobs making things whose valuation is largely tied to getting rid of jobs. These are contradictory times.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Of course, the whole electrician profession in general is engaged in job-elimination, as electricity is used to replace human labor.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I mean in some sense, even *this* exact polling provides a glimpse into this. M4A does not allow people to keep their current private plan. But also the *current healthcare system* does not allow people to do that....
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Need to run this sort of polling in the other direction as well. Ask people who say they want employer plans whether they think their employer should be allowed to change or eliminate their plan against their wishes. If they say no, then what does that tell us about their views?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There is an asymmetry in this discourse where "contradictory understandings of M4A" indicate that the support isn't real. But if true, then "contradictory understandings of employer insurance" should indicate the same thing. Right?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I mean in some sense, even *this* exact polling provides a glimpse into this. M4A does not allow people to keep their current private plan. But also the *current healthcare system* does not allow people to do that....
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There is an asymmetry in this discourse where "contradictory understandings of M4A" indicate that the support isn't real. But if true, then "contradictory understandings of employer insurance" should indicate the same thing. Right?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Need to run this sort of polling in the other direction as well. Ask people who say they want employer plans whether they think their employer should be allowed to change or eliminate their plan against their wishes. If they say no, then what does that tell us about their views?
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The total incuriosity from the right is so weird. In Sweden, around 80% of kids go to a public child care center. Another 5% attend coops. Kids attending a private center use a government voucher that comes with rules (like a fee cap) and can be revoked for safety reasons.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There is no statute that literally mandates a ratio and they vary a bit place to place. But the reason why they all converge around the nationally-published standards is pretty obviously because the government is dictating the terms as owner and payer even if not as legislator.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It would be interesting to see a piece about whether the state-as-regulator or the state-as-owner/payer is the better model for establishing child care standards. But in the grand scheme of things, NYS trying to do it via regulation is clearly less statist than what Sweden does.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
About 20% of US hospitals are government owned. In Norway it’s around 95%.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
About 20% of US hospitals are government owned. In Norway it’s around 95%.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Mayor Karen Bass
@MayorOfLA
Simone Boyce we got you!
Spot a pothole on your street? Send it our way. Report it to 311, through the MyLA311 app or at lacity.gov/myla311.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If an employee spill a drink on the ground and doesn't clean it and then a customer slips and falls and breaks their arm, should the employer be responsible? Right now they are. You understand employers are paper entities and all of their "actions" are done by employees right?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I do believe that workers should not be subjected to racial or sexual harassment. But for that same reason, I don't like the trainings because they don't prevent such things (and worse, in the current legal environment, they prevent victims from being compensated).
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But the bottom-line here is that what we have is a kludge that sits between making it legal to harass workers and making it illegal to do so, which was inserted by the Supreme Court and pleases nobody except employers who accept it as better than it being fully illegal.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If an employee spill a drink on the ground and doesn't clean it and then a customer slips and falls and breaks their arm, should the employer be responsible? Right now they are. You understand employers are paper entities and all of their "actions" are done by employees right?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is not at all how harassment is defined in federal law. You guys genuinely have no idea what you are talking about.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is not at all how harassment is defined in federal law. You guys genuinely have no idea what you are talking about.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But the bottom-line here is that what we have is a kludge that sits between making it legal to harass workers and making it illegal to do so, which was inserted by the Supreme Court and pleases nobody except employers who accept it as better than it being fully illegal.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I do believe that workers should not be subjected to racial or sexual harassment. But for that same reason, I don't like the trainings because they don't prevent such things (and worse, in the current legal environment, they prevent victims from being compensated).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is a price SCOTUS is willing to pay because it can’t repeal the law but can essentially neutralize most of it through creative interpretation, protecting the bottom line of capital
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
These trainings exist because Supreme Court made it so that if an employer takes preventative measures against discrimination, they can avoid liability for subsequent discrimination that occurs. It was an effort to weaken the civil rights act.
Kat Rosenfield
@katrosenfield
MAGA election denialism is nutty, but I have never been required by law to spend minimum 2 hours undergoing a training at my place of employment where I had to affirm it in 17 different ways in order to pass/be deemed compliant
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It is not required by law. It’s something employers do to avoid paying out workers who get discriminated against.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Thomas and Scalia wrote in dissent that the ruling of the majority did not go *far enough* because it required the employer to make the affirmative defense. They wanted it to be that the discriminatee carried the burden of proving negligence.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So we have a law that says you can’t racially harass someone at work. The Supreme Court didn’t like that but rather than trying to get the law repealed, they made it racial harassment isn’t really illegal if you do a training beforehand. Good lesson in courts behaving badly.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you keep the original law, then employers have an incentive to keep racial harassment from actually happening, figuring out what works. But with the SCOTUS-amendment to it, the incentive switches to ticking a training box without regard for its effect on harassment
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is a price SCOTUS is willing to pay because it can’t repeal the law but can essentially neutralize most of it through creative interpretation, protecting the bottom line of capital
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you keep the original law, then employers have an incentive to keep racial harassment from actually happening, figuring out what works. But with the SCOTUS-amendment to it, the incentive switches to ticking a training box without regard for its effect on harassment
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So we have a law that says you can’t racially harass someone at work. The Supreme Court didn’t like that but rather than trying to get the law repealed, they made it racial harassment isn’t really illegal if you do a training beforehand. Good lesson in courts behaving badly.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Secretary Kennedy
@SecKennedy
Thirty years ago, welfare reform helped millions of Americans move from public assistance to work.
Today, loopholes and weakened requirements have pulled TANF off course. We’re fixing it by restoring meaningful work requirements, closing loopholes, and ensuring TANF helps families move toward work and independence.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Thomas and Scalia wrote in dissent that the ruling of the majority did not go *far enough* because it required the employer to make the affirmative defense. They wanted it to be that the discriminatee carried the burden of proving negligence.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The AI can solve the problem of this lower level worker not being able to write the response but is not able to protect her from prompting it with truthful things that managers know to lie about. It’s a good outcome really in that sense.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don’t think that’s what is going on here. More of a situation where they had a lower level employee write up the response with the help of AI but that employee didn’t know she had to lie about the reason they fired this employee. The output reflected the truthful input.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The AI can solve the problem of this lower level worker not being able to write the response but is not able to protect her from prompting it with truthful things that managers know to lie about. It’s a good outcome really in that sense.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don’t think that’s what is going on here. More of a situation where they had a lower level employee write up the response with the help of AI but that employee didn’t know she had to lie about the reason they fired this employee. The output reflected the truthful input.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Employer fired employee for talking about her wages. When she filed for unemployment, the employer used ChatGPT to generate its response, which included that she was fired for talking wages. Then they tried to say ChatGPT made that part up. Heh. Judge not buying it.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Everyone keeps acting like redenomination does not exist
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
Really important point. Worth spelling out clearly.
1. People want prices to come down.
2. The single best way to quickly reduce prices—not to slow the rate of inflation; to actually bring the general price level down, imminently—is to destroy growth. But while people might say they want the outcome of crushed inflation, I don't think they want the process, because that process probably looks like a recession.
3. The second-best thing you can do is reduce the rate of inflation, while incomes rise, in a growing economy. There are all sorts of ways to do that. Over time, and with enough even growth, that will feel like normalcy and stability. But in the short run, lower inflation doesn't feel like prices going down; it feels like prices going up because ... that's what it is.
4. Trump isn't doing anything useful to slow the rate of inflation *and* he's very clearly telegraphing to voters that he cares more about wealth accumulation, White House interior design, crypto corruption, and regime-change-on-a-lark.
So what I'd say is that addressing America's affordability concerns is very very hard and also Trump isn't getting an B- on that test, or even a D-. He's not even showing up to the test. He's off doing crypto scams 1,000 miles from the exam room. If Trump talked about affordability and affordability policies half as much as Mamdani, even with stubborn inflation, I wonder if that would buy him approval points.
Chris Hayes
@chrislhayes
I think everyone should probably take some time to wrestle w the very fundamental fact that modern policy approaches do not give the president or congress a ton of options for *lowering the general price level* even though that voters are saying they want.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Another way to put it is that if we divide each countries AIC by their GDP. The reason they don't all show the same percentages is almost entirely because of differences in net exports.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know you don’t care but the point is that when choosing to look at AIC rather than GDP, all you are really doing, in cross country comparisons, is bumping deficit countries up and surplus countries down. That’s the whole special sauce of AIC.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Now maybe you think deficits are good and surpluses are bad. But in that case argue *that*. Don’t assume it by switching to AIC and never mentioning that you are just giving US extra points for its huge trade deficit.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In cross-country comparisons, what makes AIC differ from GDP is trade balance. That is true in general. Collective consumption of government doesn't differ much. Capital investment (as share of GDP) doesn't differ all that much. Trade balance does.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I point this out because among certain groups of people, there seems to be a lot of mystification around this, like AIC is reflecting something realer than GDP. But it's mechanically just GDP minus net exports.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Why are you talking about ranks? I am talking about the relative gaps. Like when you see a graph of countries ranked by GDP per capita and then one ranked by AIC per capita, the movements you see in the relative sizes of the bars is ~all net exports.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Another way to put it is that if we divide each countries AIC by their GDP. The reason they don't all show the same percentages is almost entirely because of differences in net exports.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Why are you talking about ranks? I am talking about the relative gaps. Like when you see a graph of countries ranked by GDP per capita and then one ranked by AIC per capita, the movements you see in the relative sizes of the bars is ~all net exports.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I point this out because among certain groups of people, there seems to be a lot of mystification around this, like AIC is reflecting something realer than GDP. But it's mechanically just GDP minus net exports.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In cross-country comparisons, what makes AIC differ from GDP is trade balance. That is true in general. Collective consumption of government doesn't differ much. Capital investment (as share of GDP) doesn't differ all that much. Trade balance does.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Now maybe you think deficits are good and surpluses are bad. But in that case argue *that*. Don’t assume it by switching to AIC and never mentioning that you are just giving US extra points for its huge trade deficit.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know you don’t care but the point is that when choosing to look at AIC rather than GDP, all you are really doing, in cross country comparisons, is bumping deficit countries up and surplus countries down. That’s the whole special sauce of AIC.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So do you think GDP is not a good measure of how rich people are? It measures production and consumption, not how much money anyone has. The only way for a country to, in aggregate, amass more money so defined is through trade surpluses. So is that how we are defining rich?
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Western Europe Is Richer Than the US
(link below)
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Hoping to kill the dumb GDP discourse
peoplespolicyproject.org/2026/08/04/western-europe-better…Post not available here, view on X
Yet Another Matt
@mattxyzed
Yes, by $200
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you count consumption as making a country less rich, then GDP is not a good measure. You want aggregate savings!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So even your answer here says that your goal is to work for 80 hours a week for 10 years, which is half of the "standard" 40 hours a week for 40 years. So even you are trying to cut your work hours via early retirement! You get it!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I am not using it as a positive metric. I used it to probe whether the non-US countries work fewer hours because fewer of them have jobs or because the ones who have jobs have more time off. It turns out it is the latter (except for France)
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
median income has the same leisure problem as GDP has, I can show you EPOP for prime-age adults, but if you read my piece, the point of that graph was just to illustrate that more time of for workers (rather than lower employment) drives their lower hours.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The OECD has that too. I calculated it but didn't put it in the piece because it seemed to be beside the point strictly speaking
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
GDP includes both actually.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So do you think GDP is not a good measure of how rich people are? It measures production and consumption, not how much money anyone has. The only way for a country to, in aggregate, amass more money so defined is through trade surpluses. So is that how we are defining rich?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In the most US-favorable specification, it has it *20%* above what the model predicts. This is before we start poking around at actual institutional details such as 10% of Americans are uninsured. Measured admin expenses. Etc.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In your chart, the US is way off the line. The visual just doesn't look as impressive due to the log scale. Here I did same data but log-log, one cubic, one quadratic. In the most US-favorable specification, US spends $1 trillion more on healthcare than the model predicts.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In the most US-favorable specification, it has it *20%* above what the model predicts. This is before we start poking around at actual institutional details such as 10% of Americans are uninsured. Measured admin expenses. Etc.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In your chart, the US is way off the line. The visual just doesn't look as impressive due to the log scale. Here I did same data but log-log, one cubic, one quadratic. In the most US-favorable specification, US spends $1 trillion more on healthcare than the model predicts.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
GDP includes both actually.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So we can talk of an NFL-pattered distribution and a tennis-patterned distribution. They are very different from one another, but which one tracks desert? Is the NFL stealing from winning teams or is Tennis stealing from losing players who are necessary for the entertainment?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Sports also provides examples of this point in the other direction. The NFL, by far the largest sport in the US, pools about two-thirds of league-wide revenue and distributes it out equally to all the teams, even though some teams win a lot more than others.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Having fun with the OECD API
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Dealt with the AIC stuff today. Way wrong. peoplespolicyproject.org/2026/08/05/us-does-not-win-aic/
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I've argued that the extreme income outcomes on the tails of sports/entertainment are a quirks of how IP law and advertising markets work and that top-player income depends entirely on other players because that is what the entertainment is: players playing each other.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Pointing out that tennis has a winner-take-all reward structure and is a low-variance sport does not negate any of that. In fact it's a great microcosm of my point about contingent institutional design quirks generating extreme tail outcomes.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If tennis purses were structured so that the winner's purse was cut in half while all the other purses were doubled, nothing at all would change about aggregate tennis production, output, entertainment, etc.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So what does that tell us about whether Djokovic's earnings are *deserved*? What is in fact the scientifically correct purse distribution for tennis tournaments, the one that gives each tennis player their exact marginal contribution to tournament revenue? It's comical!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If Djokovic was killed as a child. So there was never a single Djokvoic tennis match ever played, would this have resulted in a world with less aggregate tennis entertainment revenue? Or does the revenue come from the entertainment of competition, i.e. all of the players?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Sports also provides examples of this point in the other direction. The NFL, by far the largest sport in the US, pools about two-thirds of league-wide revenue and distributes it out equally to all the teams, even though some teams win a lot more than others.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So we can talk of an NFL-pattered distribution and a tennis-patterned distribution. They are very different from one another, but which one tracks desert? Is the NFL stealing from winning teams or is Tennis stealing from losing players who are necessary for the entertainment?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If Djokovic was killed as a child. So there was never a single Djokvoic tennis match ever played, would this have resulted in a world with less aggregate tennis entertainment revenue? Or does the revenue come from the entertainment of competition, i.e. all of the players?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So what does that tell us about whether Djokovic's earnings are *deserved*? What is in fact the scientifically correct purse distribution for tennis tournaments, the one that gives each tennis player their exact marginal contribution to tournament revenue? It's comical!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If tennis purses were structured so that the winner's purse was cut in half while all the other purses were doubled, nothing at all would change about aggregate tennis production, output, entertainment, etc.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Pointing out that tennis has a winner-take-all reward structure and is a low-variance sport does not negate any of that. In fact it's a great microcosm of my point about contingent institutional design quirks generating extreme tail outcomes.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I've argued that the extreme income outcomes on the tails of sports/entertainment are a quirks of how IP law and advertising markets work and that top-player income depends entirely on other players because that is what the entertainment is: players playing each other.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Dealt with the AIC stuff today. Way wrong. peoplespolicyproject.org/2026/08/05/us-does-not-win-aic/
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
There is an eccentric definition of "western europe" at work here but the straight US-Germany comparison is interesting.
peoplespolicyproject.org/2026/08/05/us-does-not-win-aic/ -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The OECD has that too. I calculated it but didn't put it in the piece because it seemed to be beside the point strictly speaking
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
median income has the same leisure problem as GDP has, I can show you EPOP for prime-age adults, but if you read my piece, the point of that graph was just to illustrate that more time of for workers (rather than lower employment) drives their lower hours.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right so this actually brings us all the way to the beginning of the thread. I anticipated that one response might be that a country could have high-leisure through high unemployment. So I checked to see if that is what is happening in these countries and it's not!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The second and third chart are there to *decompose* what drives the difference between GDP per capita and GDP per hour worked (it can either be because of lower employment rates or more time off for workers). This is all explained in the piece, which you should try reading.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yes. To take the opposite position is to deny that we can value things by looking at what people are willing to pay for them. If someone is willing to forego (read "pay") one week of wages to vacation at the beach, then that beach vacation must be worth a week of wages *to them*
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Certainly you are free to say a week at the beach is not worth one week of wages *to you* just like you are free to say a Taylor Swift concert experience is not worth $1,000 *to you.* But we don't then count the Taylor Swift concert experience at $0.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If the Germans choose to spend a bunch of their productivity on vacations, then we need to count that. Even if you personally would choose other ways of spending your productivity.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What we are talking about here is just different consumption baskets. It's just that GDP per capita does not count time-off in the consumption basket while GDP per hour does.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right so this actually brings us all the way to the beginning of the thread. I anticipated that one response might be that a country could have high-leisure through high unemployment. So I checked to see if that is what is happening in these countries and it's not!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What we are talking about here is just different consumption baskets. It's just that GDP per capita does not count time-off in the consumption basket while GDP per hour does.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If the Germans choose to spend a bunch of their productivity on vacations, then we need to count that. Even if you personally would choose other ways of spending your productivity.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Certainly you are free to say a week at the beach is not worth one week of wages *to you* just like you are free to say a Taylor Swift concert experience is not worth $1,000 *to you.* But we don't then count the Taylor Swift concert experience at $0.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yes. To take the opposite position is to deny that we can value things by looking at what people are willing to pay for them. If someone is willing to forego (read "pay") one week of wages to vacation at the beach, then that beach vacation must be worth a week of wages *to them*
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The second and third chart are there to *decompose* what drives the difference between GDP per capita and GDP per hour worked (it can either be because of lower employment rates or more time off for workers). This is all explained in the piece, which you should try reading.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
US Is Not Winning Actual Individual Consumption Either
(link below)
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Ok I am done for a bit with this posting burst. I need to get back to lawyering. But one last note for the AIC-heads is read to the end. That graph you all pass around about the US healthcare system is not right. peoplespolicyproject.org/2026/08/05/us-does-not-win-aic/
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I am not using it as a positive metric. I used it to probe whether the non-US countries work fewer hours because fewer of them have jobs or because the ones who have jobs have more time off. It turns out it is the latter (except for France)
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
👇️
Jakeup
@myhandle
if you run out of money you can't go to the waterpark anymore, that's what being less rich means!
(also you jumped from individual to country-level — spending on the local waterpark is making you poorer but the waterpark owner richer, the country's GDP stays flat) -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Listen to yourself. The behavioral mechanism you are positing (high marginal tax affecting decisions of those at the intensive margin) would cut down on “high value” labor hours. So it would drag down GDP per hour!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
sets the value of non-work time at $0, same problem GDP has, and why you need to use GDP per hour worked
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
GDP per hour is published directly by the OECD right next to GDP and GDP per capita. I didn’t massage anything. Literally I didn’t even have to divide one number by another. I just copied the exact series the OECD publishes for this purpose
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Listen to yourself. The behavioral mechanism you are positing (high marginal tax affecting decisions of those at the intensive margin) would cut down on “high value” labor hours. So it would drag down GDP per hour!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
GDP per hour is published directly by the OECD right next to GDP and GDP per capita. I didn’t massage anything. Literally I didn’t even have to divide one number by another. I just copied the exact series the OECD publishes for this purpose
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So even your answer here says that your goal is to work for 80 hours a week for 10 years, which is half of the "standard" 40 hours a week for 40 years. So even you are trying to cut your work hours via early retirement! You get it!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
sets the value of non-work time at $0, same problem GDP has, and why you need to use GDP per hour worked
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
OECD lists GDP, GDP per capita, and GDP per hour in the exact same productivity table right next to one another. GDP per hour is not my conversion (the OECD specifically collects it for this exact reason) and it is no more a conversion than GDP per capita is!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
OECD lists GDP, GDP per capita, and GDP per hour in the exact same productivity table right next to one another. GDP per hour is not my conversion (the OECD specifically collects it for this exact reason) and it is no more a conversion than GDP per capita is!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you count consumption as making a country less rich, then GDP is not a good measure. You want aggregate savings!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Yet Another Matt
@mattxyzed
Yes, by $200
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The two countries have the exact same NEET rate, which is what is typically used to compare youth like this (the two light red bars). Unemployed versus NILF not all that meaningful across country especially for youth.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you move a chunk of the light blue French out of grad school and into work (dark red), the unemployment rate goes down but not because any of the unemployed got a job.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yes we can see this with those light red bars. If anything that NILF bar on the far right is the most troubling yet it’s not counted at all in unemployment. Other difficulty is that the denominator is sensitive to how many kids are in college versus in a job.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This point is completely wrong peoplespolicyproject.org/2026/08/04/western-europe-better…
Avery James
@averyfjames
Truth nuke by Hanania. I will give him credit when he makes a good and underrated point:
www.richardhanania.com/p/gdp-haters-arent-making-serious-…Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The two countries have the exact same NEET rate, which is what is typically used to compare youth like this (the two light red bars). Unemployed versus NILF not all that meaningful across country especially for youth.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yes we can see this with those light red bars. If anything that NILF bar on the far right is the most troubling yet it’s not counted at all in unemployment. Other difficulty is that the denominator is sensitive to how many kids are in college versus in a job.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you move a chunk of the light blue French out of grad school and into work (dark red), the unemployment rate goes down but not because any of the unemployed got a job.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
My AI Content Management System and Copy Editing Setup www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTapHYdew5k
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Reviewing the Searchlight Institute's Healthcare Proposal
👎 Free Primary Care For All headline proposal that does basically nothing
👎 Random and internally incoherent attack on exchange enrollees in non-Medicaid-expanding states
👎 Retains uninsurance
(link below) -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Eastern Bloc Visuals
@eastblocvisuals
A child with a polar bear cub in Chukotka Autonomous Okrug, USSR, 1975.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Colin Mortimer
@colinmort
He unfortunately got your ass there
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I grew up across the street from an enormous GM assembly plant and drone shots of it would also make for great "anthropocene hell" type B roll.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
the bar really is on the floor, plugging a county into an online living wage calculator and then riffing on the results is more half-assed and thoughtless than nerdy surely
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But as easy as it is to say "that's what good-UI would do," it is also reasonable for someone to say "good-UI is impossible in America, it hates welfare too much, it is too paranoid about people on the dole." I don't know what to do about that.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There are so many easy egalitarian policies that would make productivity gains flow to everyone. But the American way is to make productivity gains result in concentrated pain on certain populations. And conflict is a natural result of that. Positive-sum but not pareto-improving.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
NLRB Has Regained its Quorum
www.nlrbedge.com/p/nlrb-has-regained-its-quorum -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Taylor Lorenz
@TaylorLorenz
Is this you or “another brown woman” Neera?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Neera Tanden🌻
@neeratanden
Exactly! Is it some other brown woman or did she just make it up out of whole cloth
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny to think about the math of this. Suppose the American shareholders of ExxonMobil and ConocoPhillips (both publicly-traded companies with dispersed ownership facilitated by the Big 3) are out a few billion dollars. Would war cost Americans more or less than that?
Thomas Massie
@RepThomasMassie
When Trump says Venezuela stole oil from the United States, he’s talking about projects by Oil Companies that were nationalized by the government of Venezuela two decades ago. No one campaigned on using our soldiers to overthrow Venezuela to make these Oil Companies whole again.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Take 5% of what you would spend on the war and give it to ExxonMobil and ConocoPhillips to pay out as a dividend. Everyone wins!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is the thing. It doesn't *always* end that way. This is why you can't have a blanket view. I've gone to this before. You book out skating spots on the website (no actual queueing) and there are spots available pretty close to the date. They make their money on skate rentals.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
disgusting
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is the thing. It doesn't *always* end that way. This is why you can't have a blanket view. I've gone to this before. You book out skating spots on the website (no actual queueing) and there are spots available pretty close to the date. They make their money on skate rentals.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's silly. But of course in the discourse nobody will ever go "yeah I overstated things quite a bit, but I think a less ambitious thesis is still true." What that looks like is "I never said that, I only said the less ambitious thing." Have to accept the W's the way they come.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know his piece was long, but if you read all the way to Section 4 (titled "Everywhere Else"), you'll see that's not true. But if people want to narrow the claims to a few dozen or hundred or so employers, that's great.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's in the intro too if you got that far. This is why my analysis focuses on college degrees, grad degrees, men at the top of the earnings distribution, and aggregate white male employment in the arts/media sector he focuses on.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's silly. But of course in the discourse nobody will ever go "yeah I overstated things quite a bit, but I think a less ambitious thesis is still true." What that looks like is "I never said that, I only said the less ambitious thing." Have to accept the W's the way they come.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's in the intro too if you got that far. This is why my analysis focuses on college degrees, grad degrees, men at the top of the earnings distribution, and aggregate white male employment in the arts/media sector he focuses on.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know his piece was long, but if you read all the way to Section 4 (titled "Everywhere Else"), you'll see that's not true. But if people want to narrow the claims to a few dozen or hundred or so employers, that's great.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I recommend reading to the end of the piece. As far as I am concerned, this period was basically one big land acknowledgement: verbal gesturing that achieves nothing while irritating people. But the irritation is not mostly "material" because very little material things changed.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What Does the Census Data Say About “The Lost Generation” www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/12/17/what-does-the-cen…
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I recommend reading to the end of the piece. As far as I am concerned, this period was basically one big land acknowledgement: verbal gesturing that achieves nothing while irritating people. But the irritation is not mostly "material" because very little material things changed.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Nano Banana's attempt to illustrate the 9th Circuit deciding to rehear a dispute between the ILWU and Machinists over who is owed certain work in the Port of Seattle. In today's roundup! www.nlrbedge.com/p/12152025-union-election-ordered-at
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
is the tweetdeck timeline column completely broken now? Even when "following" is selected, I just get a bunch of stuff I'm not following
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The catch looks pretty pathetic by today’s standards but it was groundbreaking at the time. It was the first time a wide receiver ever jumped.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Soviet Visuals
@sovietvisuals
Moscow, 1986
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There is an even more direct parallel as Charlie Kirk called for Joe Biden to be jailed.
-
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
Wait so now if you have a legitimate political grievance against somebody who has been murdered it is actually ok to dance on their grave. I’m trying very hard to keep up with these evolving civic norms and struggling.
Jack Posobiec
@JackPosobiec
Rob Reiner called for Trump to be jailed over lies
Not surprised Trump said what he said
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There is an even more direct parallel as Charlie Kirk called for Joe Biden to be jailed.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Jerry Jones remains the best GM in football
Micah Parsons
@MicahhParsons11
I may be sidelined, but I am not defeated. This injury is my greatest test—a moment God allowed to strengthen my testimony. I believe He walks with me through this storm and chose me for this fight because He knew my heart could carry it. I’m deeply grateful to the Packers organization and my teammates for their unwavering support, love, and belief in me during this season. I trust His timing, His plan, and His purpose. I will rise again.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
philip lewis
@Phil_Lewis_
Trump on Rob Reiner's death:
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Refining my labor law LLM workflow:
1. Search NLRB Research database to get cases.
2. Drop URL into tool that grabs the JSON and estimates token size.
3. Drop JSON into a Gemini Gem with custom instructions and prompt.
4. Gemini answers with citations and links back to DB.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Another example. In this one, the token count for all 25 documents was too high, so I limited to the most recent 20. Gemini's response puts the links on the citations (they link to the database) in this one, which looks nice.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Creating custom "gems" or "gpts" and making it so users can easily grab the context to attach to their prompting/chatting with it may be the most "open" way to make AI available to users without charging them.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Here is the rest of the answer if you are curious
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
even in retirement
Chen Weihua (陈卫华)
@chenweihua
Yes. China is having zero mass shooting. You then should have more. What an idiot logic.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Chen Weihua (陈卫华)
@chenweihua
Yes. China is having zero mass shooting. You then should have more. What an idiot logic.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Soviet Visuals
@sovietvisuals
Moscow, USSR, 1984.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
My first hit in the industry publication Freight Waves.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Retirement, like all benefits, should not be tied up with a specific employer. Got no problem with annuity-style old-age pensions, as we have with Social Security, but employer-based plans are a trap for the reasons you mentioned, among others.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The most famous "nudge" example -- defaulting to 401k enrollment with auto-escalation -- doesn't actually do very much it turns out.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That "people frequently leave firms" should be considered more often in benefit design...
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Retirement, like all benefits, should not be tied up with a specific employer. Got no problem with annuity-style old-age pensions, as we have with Social Security, but employer-based plans are a trap for the reasons you mentioned, among others.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Google Gemini's 1 million token context window means you can (clunkily for now) finally do the thing I initially build my NLRB Research database to do. Have a LLM lay out labor law with plain language queries. Super helpful. If we can get up to 10 million tokens...
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Give me a labor law question and I'll see if I can get a good answer with it
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Venting about supervisor in a slack channel -->
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That could help. Also semantic search to find cases. I have done a semantic search setup with the database but without being able to send it to an LLM due to small context windows, it wasn’t very useful. Manual RAG is very safe though
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Also giving matching chunks instead of whole case documents to the LLMs really gives you some very poor results. Of course, you could use semantic search and give the whole document (not just the chunk) to the LLM but that's not going to save any tokens.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Partially this is a quirk of legal cases I think because they are often formatted so that there is a long fact section and then later a long legal/analysis section. So they aren't proximate to one another. The chunks don't have all the info you want.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What everyone missed in that discourse is that the child care bits were essentially meaningless and fake, a requirement to submit a plan. Stupid because why enact something that doesn't do anything, but not subject to Ezra's critique which was premised upon them being real.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What everyone missed in that discourse is that the child care bits were essentially meaningless and fake, a requirement to submit a plan. Stupid because why enact something that doesn't do anything, but not subject to Ezra's critique which was premised upon them being real.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib
@RepRashida
Congress has the money and the power to feed every family, house every neighbor, and guarantee health care for every single person but instead, my colleagues choose to line their own pockets by supporting endless war. Our communities deserve better.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
🚂
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
apparently the WSJ will let you start a book review like this, something a child might write
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Partially this is a quirk of legal cases I think because they are often formatted so that there is a long fact section and then later a long legal/analysis section. So they aren't proximate to one another. The chunks don't have all the info you want.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Also giving matching chunks instead of whole case documents to the LLMs really gives you some very poor results. Of course, you could use semantic search and give the whole document (not just the chunk) to the LLM but that's not going to save any tokens.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For sure. Some people are better at using it than others and I'd imagine it is disproportionately used by stupid people (who can't do the work themselves) who end up doing stupid things with it.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The LLM is using the specifically selected cases to answer the question and giving the precise case it is basing each part of its answer on, so you can then go read it. At some point, if you can't make use of something like that, that's a you problem.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yeah I have. What you do is you load all of the material into context and have it tell you which case it is basing each part of the answer on. If a part of the answer looks helpful, then you can look at the case. This as opposed to reading 21 cases.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For sure. Some people are better at using it than others and I'd imagine it is disproportionately used by stupid people (who can't do the work themselves) who end up doing stupid things with it.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
SAHMs can be included in paid/parental leave via establishing a minimum benefit all new parents are eligible for and included in the child care period via home care allowance (which Mamdani has proposed). How it works in Norway/Finland.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
SAHMs can be included in paid/parental leave via establishing a minimum benefit all new parents are eligible for and included in the child care period via home care allowance (which Mamdani has proposed). How it works in Norway/Finland.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That could help. Also semantic search to find cases. I have done a semantic search setup with the database but without being able to send it to an LLM due to small context windows, it wasn’t very useful. Manual RAG is very safe though
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Yeah I have. What you do is you load all of the material into context and have it tell you which case it is basing each part of the answer on. If a part of the answer looks helpful, then you can look at the case. This as opposed to reading 21 cases.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The LLM is using the specifically selected cases to answer the question and giving the precise case it is basing each part of its answer on, so you can then go read it. At some point, if you can't make use of something like that, that's a you problem.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Venting about supervisor in a slack channel -->
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Rachel Cohen Booth
@rcobooth
Universal child care in NYC won't be easy. But it's possible, practical, and could give the United States a desperately-needed blueprint
I wrote for @nytopinion about what @ZohranKMamdani will need to get right -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
"you should be able to hold an opinion and a job" 👍
FIRE
@TheFIREorg
This is Monica Meeks. She is an Army veteran and a lifelong public servant. Monica was fired from her state job over her Facebook comment about Charlie Kirk.
She spent over twenty years defending the rights of her fellow Americans — now FIRE will defend hers.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In short, breadwinner's wage, stripped of its gender discrimination elements, is just an idiot's version of funding child welfare benefits through labor taxes.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What's objectionable about the "breadwinner's wage" idea is that the idea that men should be paid more than women, not the idea of child benefits. The "child benefit" component of this debate should be focused on how best to administer them (hint: not through employers).
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Conservatives gravitate around "breadwinner's wage" stuff in part to trigger people because it's typically understood as pro-gender discrimination and in part because it's a way to do child benefits that they don't scan as welfare (even though it would essentially be that).
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Switzerland is the country that has come the closest to this, but there, the employers join "family compensation funds" that administer child benefits (individual employers don't handle this). But this naturally doesn't cover everyone, so the government picks up everyone else.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The Nordic model just observes that you could have the government simply be one big "family compensation fund" that covers all the kids. Use employer-side payroll tax to fund it if you want to sort of act like it's employers funding the benefits.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In short, breadwinner's wage, stripped of its gender discrimination elements, is just an idiot's version of funding child welfare benefits through labor taxes.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The Nordic model just observes that you could have the government simply be one big "family compensation fund" that covers all the kids. Use employer-side payroll tax to fund it if you want to sort of act like it's employers funding the benefits.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Switzerland is the country that has come the closest to this, but there, the employers join "family compensation funds" that administer child benefits (individual employers don't handle this). But this naturally doesn't cover everyone, so the government picks up everyone else.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Conservatives gravitate around "breadwinner's wage" stuff in part to trigger people because it's typically understood as pro-gender discrimination and in part because it's a way to do child benefits that they don't scan as welfare (even though it would essentially be that).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What's objectionable about the "breadwinner's wage" idea is that the idea that men should be paid more than women, not the idea of child benefits. The "child benefit" component of this debate should be focused on how best to administer them (hint: not through employers).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Teamsters
@Teamsters
🚨BREAKING🚨
Over 200 drivers at Amazon’s DBK1 facility in Woodside, Queens, have organized to join the Teamsters. The newest members of Local 804 marched on company management this morning to demand a Teamsters contract, becoming the latest to join nearly 10,000 Amazon workers across five states who have organized with the Teamsters.
“Seeing hundreds of New York City Amazon workers strike last year was a wakeup call for us. If we want a better future at Amazon, we have to be willing to fight for it,” said José Huerta, a driver at the DBK1 facility. “After months of painstaking work, I’m proud to say that my co-workers and I are finally Teamsters.”
The Teamsters Union will organize Amazon — and workers will secure the rights, respect, wages, benefits, and job protections they’ve earned. -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Did Erika Kirk "inherit" Turning Point USA? Isn't it a 501(c)(3)? I don't really understand what's going on.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
People should have true financial security after just a few years in the workforce and in other countries they do, via robust unemployment insurance benefits.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
People should have true financial security after just a few years in the workforce and in other countries they do, via robust unemployment insurance benefits.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is funny obviously because it's like dumb guy single payer, but what Association Health Plans are actually about is getting rid of the Essential Health Benefits requirements for insurance plans.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Rand Paul on his healthcare plan: "What if you could join Costco? Costco has 44 million members and if one person negotiated for all 44 and they bought a group plan like Toyota or General Motors does, they would be the largest collective entity in the country. They would drive prices down by sheer might."
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It seems possible that social media gets so overwhelmed by AI text and video that people migrate back to normal media at least to some extent
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Nobody claims that poor kids can't learn at all, but poverty does make it harder to learn. The tension arises however because education/human capital is frequently pitched as an alternative to egalitarian distributional policy, which is actually really bad for poverty reduction.
Jonathan Chait
@jonathanchait
Why do so many progressives have an impulse to believe poor children are ineducable? www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2025/12/school-reform-progressi…
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Strong labor movement can you get you wage compression (which is in the predistribution bucket) and that definitely moves the needle (best of the bunch). But wage compression without the socdem welfare state is still extremely unequal and high poverty.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One of the greatest things ever written is James Heckman observing that Denmark's early childhood interventions are successful as stimulating brains but in the final score Denmark's egalitarianism is basically entirely attributable to unions and welfare. www.nber.org/papers/w22465
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Not sure if we've fully left this discourse behind. But this is a good illustration of the point that simply looking at whether prices have risen faster than operating costs doesn't tell you much about the "cause" of the inflation in the ordinary sense.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
No. The amount of taxes paid into the system is not considered at all. I make this point in the linked video, but this person on the left pays 22x more FICA tax than the person the right. He gets no benefits though because eligibility is based on earnings not taxes paid.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That’s not how social security and Medicare work but it’s a common misconception. Of course SNAP recipients also pay tax at various points in their life
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
No. The amount of taxes paid into the system is not considered at all. I make this point in the linked video, but this person on the left pays 22x more FICA tax than the person the right. He gets no benefits though because eligibility is based on earnings not taxes paid.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That’s not how social security and Medicare work but it’s a common misconception. Of course SNAP recipients also pay tax at various points in their life
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Great piece that includes research that Nordic-style egalitarianism results in people having more kids. One way of presenting issue might be that both Egalitarian and "Trad" approaches result in more births than our Muddled approach. But still may not be enough for replacement.
Rachel Cohen Booth
@rcobooth
A new study on 40+ European countries found women increasingly want men to share child care and housework equally—but men's attitudes have barely budged. In countries where this gap was widest, both birth rates and female employment were lower.
"This was definitely not well-documented, not much attention has been paid to it," the study's lead author told me. A Norwegian demographer put it more bluntly: "I've been screaming that we need more research about men for the last 20 years." (1/2) -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
DC Circuit Holds Removal Protections of NLRB Members Are Unconstitutional. Trader Joe's illegally fired a union supporter (graphic below) www.nlrbedge.com/p/12082025-dc-circuit-holds-removal
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The human brain clearly struggles with continuous variables and so we created the idea of a generation to turn age into a categorical variable. Makes no sense but makes discourse more satisfying
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The human brain clearly struggles with continuous variables and so we created the idea of a generation to turn age into a categorical variable. Makes no sense but makes discourse more satisfying
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The child care situation is the easiest win-win policy issue: provide the choice of free child care or a home care allowance. Everyone gets what they want. But socons prefer crying and posturing rather than doing the policy that supports the people they supposedly care about.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I didn't mention childcare benefits in the piece precisely to avoid going down that road. But you can create childcare benefits that includes a home care allowance option for SAHPs, as in my Family Fun Pack. Why social conservatives don't advocate it is an interesting question.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Mamdani has proposed paying stay-at-home parents who take care of their kids as part of his universal child care agenda. Wake me up when you find a conservative doing that.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The child care situation is the easiest win-win policy issue: provide the choice of free child care or a home care allowance. Everyone gets what they want. But socons prefer crying and posturing rather than doing the policy that supports the people they supposedly care about.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Mamdani has proposed paying stay-at-home parents who take care of their kids as part of his universal child care agenda. Wake me up when you find a conservative doing that.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Surely we should encourage people to simply be better people and not act in such a greedy and vicious manner just the same way as we should encourage people to simply be better people and not worry themselves with inequality.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny what things you take as an unchangeable human constant and what things you don't. People can decide not to to be angered by inequality and we should encourage them to do that but they cannot help but stop working if they receive, say, $200k instead of $400k.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When inequality goes up, that makes things worse for those on the bottom end of it because inequality matters for subjective well-being. So it's not right to say things are "getting better for everyone."
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Really important to understand that this is not a semantical point. Why do we say that having more stuff makes things "better"? Ultimately it has to do with a model/theory about the kinds of things that make people happy or unhappy. But inequality makes people unhappy.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think this is hugely mistaken and again that the poverty discourse is so incredibly good about this. People aren't going "inequality is bad and so I am unhappy" but rather experiencing social alienation of various sorts which is hard on people because we are social.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What kind of evidence would convince you that people are made unhappy by inequality (especially being on the bottom end of it)? Here is a video of a monkey who gets furiously pissed when he receives a cucumber while the other monkey receives a grape. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KSryJXDpZo
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's funny what things you take as an unchangeable human constant and what things you don't. People can decide not to to be angered by inequality and we should encourage them to do that but they cannot help but stop working if they receive, say, $200k instead of $400k.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Surely we should encourage people to simply be better people and not act in such a greedy and vicious manner just the same way as we should encourage people to simply be better people and not worry themselves with inequality.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What kind of evidence would convince you that people are made unhappy by inequality (especially being on the bottom end of it)? Here is a video of a monkey who gets furiously pissed when he receives a cucumber while the other monkey receives a grape. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KSryJXDpZo
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think this is hugely mistaken and again that the poverty discourse is so incredibly good about this. People aren't going "inequality is bad and so I am unhappy" but rather experiencing social alienation of various sorts which is hard on people because we are social.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Really important to understand that this is not a semantical point. Why do we say that having more stuff makes things "better"? Ultimately it has to do with a model/theory about the kinds of things that make people happy or unhappy. But inequality makes people unhappy.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When inequality goes up, that makes things worse for those on the bottom end of it because inequality matters for subjective well-being. So it's not right to say things are "getting better for everyone."
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
DC Circuit says removal protections for NLRB members are unconstitutional and so Trump had the power to fire NLRB Member Gwynne Wilcox. Expected but interesting. www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10748283/gwynne-a-wilcox-v-…
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Ross Douthat
@Douthat60
This is broadly correct, pace the original Warren claim the real "2-income trap" isn't that dual income couples end up behind; it's that families who might prefer to live on 1/1.5 incomes end up feeling forced into + being stressed out by a 2-income norm:
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/12/05/why-do-people-fee… -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Maybe some people are mad because they can't afford as nice a car and that's just pure "lifestyle inflation" type things. But if you can't afford to send your kid to camp with her friends, that's a very different thing.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
New piece at @PplPolicyProj. It's my entry into the "$140k is poverty" discourse and the "you used to be able to live comfortably on a single income" discourse more generally. I think I know how to make sense of it that does not require nonsense claims.
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/12/05/why-do-people-fee…
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One way to put it that I ultimately cut out of the piece is imagine your society went from a 20-hour workweek to a 40-hour workweek but not everyone went along with the change. You could accurately say that you used to be able to afford a normal life on 20 hours but now you cant.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But rather than seeing that clearly for what it is -- the standard for a normal life has ratcheted upward with more income/output -- there is a temptation to say that there is hidden costs or inflation or whatever that have fully swallowed increased income etc.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If everyone around me started working 20 hours of overtime each week and I didn't, then that would suck. Even if I followed suit, but didn't want to, that'd also suck. Because inequality sucks. Being alienated from the society sucks.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
People who are skeptical of this in other contexts all of a sudden feel it in this context but cannot express it correctly. If higher percentiles race up their incomes but mine stays the same or only moves up a little, I am worse off given that my proximity to peers matters.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In your case, what you are upset about is the country's weak unemployment benefit system. In other countries, you can receive a high percentage of your prior income for a year or more as you seek a new job.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Maybe some people are mad because they can't afford as nice a car and that's just pure "lifestyle inflation" type things. But if you can't afford to send your kid to camp with her friends, that's a very different thing.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In your case, what you are upset about is the country's weak unemployment benefit system. In other countries, you can receive a high percentage of your prior income for a year or more as you seek a new job.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I didn't mention childcare benefits in the piece precisely to avoid going down that road. But you can create childcare benefits that includes a home care allowance option for SAHPs, as in my Family Fun Pack. Why social conservatives don't advocate it is an interesting question.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Great piece
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
New piece at @PplPolicyProj. It's my entry into the "$140k is poverty" discourse and the "you used to be able to live comfortably on a single income" discourse more generally. I think I know how to make sense of it that does not require nonsense claims.
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/12/05/why-do-people-fee… -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Logan
@_LNVidal
Truly excellent from Bruenig as always
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
New piece at @PplPolicyProj. It's my entry into the "$140k is poverty" discourse and the "you used to be able to live comfortably on a single income" discourse more generally. I think I know how to make sense of it that does not require nonsense claims.
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/12/05/why-do-people-fee… -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Department of State
@StateDept
This morning, the State Department renamed the former Institute of Peace to reflect the greatest dealmaker in our nation's history.
Welcome to the Donald J. Trump Institute of Peace. The best is yet to come. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The discord is that a career woman who has no spouse or kids is not using the government to replace a husband. She has her own income and is not receiving government benefits.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
She's mixing up the "government as a replacement for husband" argument about single parenting with cultural arguments about career-focused women delaying marriage/family. Just struggling to recall the talking points. Frankly, it's weird she's being trotted out to do this stuff.
DealBook
@dealbook
Erika Kirk called it "ironic" that so many women voted for Zohran Mamdani in New York's mayoral election at the 2025 DealBook Summit.
She expressed concern that career-driven women view the government as a "replacement" for family, potentially leading them to delay marriage and having kids.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The discord is that a career woman who has no spouse or kids is not using the government to replace a husband. She has her own income and is not receiving government benefits.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Just a reminder that the mommy wars stuff is a solved problem as a policy matter: Child care benefits for workers; home care benefits for SAHMs. But many proponents of either lifestyle aren't happy with enabling the choice. They want to force one or the other. So we do this.
Emma Waters
@emlwaters
Instead of pandering to The Atlantic, what if @henryolsenEPPC wrote an article exploring what women in my generation want? What if he interviewed some of the many women who work alongside @scottyenor? What if he focused more on what is best for families, and less time on what aligns with the current "American Mainstream."
It's a huge win for @Heritage to have Scott on board, and I'm glad he's here. Note that Scott recently published a series of excellent essays diving into the "eras" of a woman's life. Women want flexibility, and one of the biggest blessings is to have husband's make enough money to make that possible.
My dad worked two jobs, 60+ hours a week, when I was growing up (and still does) so my mom could stay home and homeschool my siblings and me. I’m deeply grateful for their sacrifices, but I also grieve the time I missed with my father. He was gone before I woke up and often didn’t get home until bedtime.
Now, as Jack and I think about our own family, one of our biggest questions is how to find work that can support a large family without both of us needing to be full-time the entire way through. The man or woman who solves the two-income-trap problem will be the hero of my generation.
A genuine debate between Olsen and Yenor would have been great. A disengenuous piece that tries to gain clout from a pro-trans & anti-family Left is just pathetic. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Rachel Cohen Booth
@rcobooth
I'm sorry but this is extremely disingenuous. It would be one thing if he were saying "I want to expand options for parents and support for families" but the arguments highlighted here are about forcing women out of the work force. Not creating new flexibility.
There are a lot of labor policies that would help make raising families and work easier for both men and women. Americans want those. Heritage has historically opposed them. It would be great if the think tank changed its position, but saying "well some women want to stay home, or work part-time" is just not what Yenor is advocating.
Emma Waters
@emlwaters
Instead of pandering to The Atlantic, what if @henryolsenEPPC wrote an article exploring what women in my generation want? What if he interviewed some of the many women who work alongside @scottyenor? What if he focused more on what is best for families, and less time on what aligns with the current "American Mainstream."
It's a huge win for @Heritage to have Scott on board, and I'm glad he's here. Note that Scott recently published a series of excellent essays diving into the "eras" of a woman's life. Women want flexibility, and one of the biggest blessings is to have husband's make enough money to make that possible.
My dad worked two jobs, 60+ hours a week, when I was growing up (and still does) so my mom could stay home and homeschool my siblings and me. I’m deeply grateful for their sacrifices, but I also grieve the time I missed with my father. He was gone before I woke up and often didn’t get home until bedtime.
Now, as Jack and I think about our own family, one of our biggest questions is how to find work that can support a large family without both of us needing to be full-time the entire way through. The man or woman who solves the two-income-trap problem will be the hero of my generation.
A genuine debate between Olsen and Yenor would have been great. A disengenuous piece that tries to gain clout from a pro-trans & anti-family Left is just pathetic. -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Finally read that Free Press piece about the poverty line. For all the tweeting I saw, I somehow missed that all he did was copy over numbers from the MIT Living Wage site. I thought maybe he had actually done something himself.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Anyways, it's the usual stuff. Give the family two child care bills (which are crushing but not life long) and assign them a bunch of median/average spending amounts for various categories (but most people spend less than average and half spend less than median)
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
For various public benefit formulas, HUD publishes the 40th percentile rent of various regions and the ready availability of this has turned it into a de facto cost of housing, even though 39 percent of people pay less than it.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Daily Caller
@DailyCaller
🚨BREAKING: Mike Lindell Files Paperwork To Run For Minnesota Governor
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
hows that any different from now amirite
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Drago Bergholt
@DBergholt
Thanks so much, @MattBruenig — really appreciate your interest in and sharing of our work! 🙏 For those curious about more details on the paper, my coauthor @francescofurla8 has put together a helpful thread here:
Francesco Furlanetto 🇺🇦
@francescofurla8
🥁🥁NEW WORKING PAPER ALERT 🥁🥁
Consumption Inequality, Household Risks, and the Business Cycle
with @DBergholt and Lorenzo Mori
www.norges-bank.no/en/news-events/publications/Working-Pa…
New and surprising results on consumption!
#econtwitter 1/N -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Feeding a case summary to the new google video model, very funny
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
let's go
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It will be really funny if the final result of all of this is retailers passed through tariffs to customers but then the retailers also get refunds for them.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This stuff is so fun.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Fun case in today's roundup. A worker tried to decertify their union, but the 30-day window they have to do that was swallowed by the government shutdown. Decertification petition dismissed.
Also I am having Nano Banana illustrate the cases now.
www.nlrbedge.com/p/12022025-decertification-petition -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In the middle, you've got that going on as well, but presumably it's mostly washing out (moving some people into and out of various consumption percentiles). But at the tails, it's actually driving up consumption inequality.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Wild paper from Norway using their great admin data. www.norges-bank.no/contentassets/1dee30f23d4047c4b1e07cf1…
1. Consumption inequality is higher than income inequality (as it is driven by consumption shocks)
2. People mostly save to weather consumption shocks, not income shocks
3. Recessions lower inequality
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Point three is a welfare state related observation. Top incomes are driven by highly volatile capital income that fall in recession. Bottom and middle see labor income falls but welfare state mostly keeps them steady. Less true outside Norway, but reminds me of COVID superdole.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In any given measurement period, there is a chunk of top-income people spending way more than their income due to consumption shocks and a chunk of bottom-income people spending way less than their income to recover/prepare for a consumption shock in a different period.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In the middle, you've got that going on as well, but presumably it's mostly washing out (moving some people into and out of various consumption percentiles). But at the tails, it's actually driving up consumption inequality.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In any given measurement period, there is a chunk of top-income people spending way more than their income due to consumption shocks and a chunk of bottom-income people spending way less than their income to recover/prepare for a consumption shock in a different period.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you don't like the phaseout rates (I don't), then replace medicaid with universal public insurance and replace EITC/CTC with universal child allowance. What to do with SNAP is a more involved question.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If you don't like the phaseout rates (I don't), then replace medicaid with universal public insurance and replace EITC/CTC with universal child allowance. What to do with SNAP is a more involved question.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
A good lesson in inadministrability
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Thankfully my digital content is clearly not subject to this restriction and all of my revenue from my non-paywalled ventures is tax-free tips.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Should be able to offset factor income decline with transfer income, most obviously UI, to keep demand flowing. But it is possible that anti-welfare hatred is so great, people would rush into a massive depression rather than do it.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Should be able to offset factor income decline with transfer income, most obviously UI, to keep demand flowing. But it is possible that anti-welfare hatred is so great, people would rush into a massive depression rather than do it.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Dispersing new technology takes time in general. Frictions everywhere: suppliers (think about electricity build out for AI), consumer/business adoption (skepticism, sunk costs), legal approval, and sure labor reallocation (though not necessarily because of protection).
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Dispersing new technology takes time in general. Frictions everywhere: suppliers (think about electricity build out for AI), consumer/business adoption (skepticism, sunk costs), legal approval, and sure labor reallocation (though not necessarily because of protection).
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Finally a third way in the building trades versus college education debate.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Name assimilation increases immigrants' earnings A LOT.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right but the point here is slightly different than that. It's that someone who has internalized chocolate bars are $10 feels way worse when overall inflation doubles and they go to $20 than the exact same scenario where the numbers are $1 and $2.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Clear that people react to nominal price changes, not just their own buying power. But might they also be reacting to how big the number changes not just percent change (i.e. get angrier at prices going from $100 to $110 than from $10 to $11)? Lopping a zero off might help!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Redenomination always struck me as silly, but I've definitely warmed more to it as a potential psychological solution. As the price-level base gets bigger, there really is nothing you can do to make the price jumps go down! Even 1% inflation is going to be so many "dollars"!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right but the point here is slightly different than that. It's that someone who has internalized chocolate bars are $10 feels way worse when overall inflation doubles and they go to $20 than the exact same scenario where the numbers are $1 and $2.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
fun
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Donors should give pioneers of practically applying AI to left wing causes money, by which i mean me
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Donors should give pioneers of practically applying AI to left wing causes money, by which i mean me
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
David Trimmer
@DTrim_99
First Turkey Trot, took it nice and slow.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Nick Blake
@NCBlake
Dudes rock 🦃
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Solid turkey trot today. Send me your trot result. I want to know who beat me, other than the 10 year old who passed me on mile 2.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Stoller is in a frustrating position where his policy interest is in a set of corporate practices that cut across the entire economy but that are, within each sector, generally dwarfed in magnitude by other issues. So the within-sector discourse always minimizes what he's into.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The idea that the wage levels in productivity-constrained sectors have to keep up with the wage levels in other sectors or else the workers will leave is a very strong one. Theoretically simple and empirically supported! It is fascinating tho. Big problem for labor-desert theory.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Stoller is in a frustrating position where his policy interest is in a set of corporate practices that cut across the entire economy but that are, within each sector, generally dwarfed in magnitude by other issues. So the within-sector discourse always minimizes what he's into.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The idea that the wage levels in productivity-constrained sectors have to keep up with the wage levels in other sectors or else the workers will leave is a very strong one. Theoretically simple and empirically supported! It is fascinating tho. Big problem for labor-desert theory.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
US higher ed is the highest-quality HE industry in the world and thus we can export it as an extremely high price to foreigners, creating native jobs and reducing trade deficits. You published an article that said we should be pursuing those goals but is mad at higher ed exports.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know you worked in higher education for two decades (read: likely idiot), but surely even you can see that we can't both be price-gouging Chinese students and be subsidizing them. Both claims serve the same expressive purpose for you (Geoff mad!) but they don't hang together.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I sincerely am on the fence here about whether you are genuinely stupid or just playing around. The *export segment* of the American higher education industry does not involve government subsidy/investment because it charges very high tuition!
Geoff Shullenberger
@g_shullenberger
I suppose you could argue that policies encouraging degree factories to sell $300K tuition education to wealthy foreigners constitute a kind of "industrial policy," but contrary to Matt's claim, this mostly creates middle class jobs for administrators, not teachers.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Funny set of paragraphs in Compact today. Exporting educational services to the rest of the world does creates middle class jobs (teaching), promotes the education industry, and balances trade. Yet it's held up as an example of betraying those principles!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is contrasted with an export-promoting "industrial policy" where the price charged to foreigners is subsidized to make it internationally competitive and therefore to build the industry. Right? You know these concepts, right?
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
US higher ed is the highest-quality HE industry in the world and thus we can export it as an extremely high price to foreigners, creating native jobs and reducing trade deficits. You published an article that said we should be pursuing those goals but is mad at higher ed exports.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is contrasted with an export-promoting "industrial policy" where the price charged to foreigners is subsidized to make it internationally competitive and therefore to build the industry. Right? You know these concepts, right?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I sincerely am on the fence here about whether you are genuinely stupid or just playing around. The *export segment* of the American higher education industry does not involve government subsidy/investment because it charges very high tuition!
Geoff Shullenberger
@g_shullenberger
I suppose you could argue that policies encouraging degree factories to sell $300K tuition education to wealthy foreigners constitute a kind of "industrial policy," but contrary to Matt's claim, this mostly creates middle class jobs for administrators, not teachers.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Funny set of paragraphs in Compact today. Exporting educational services to the rest of the world does creates middle class jobs (teaching), promotes the education industry, and balances trade. Yet it's held up as an example of betraying those principles!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know you worked in higher education for two decades (read: likely idiot), but surely even you can see that we can't both be price-gouging Chinese students and be subsidizing them. Both claims serve the same expressive purpose for you (Geoff mad!) but they don't hang together.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I love this new economic nationalism you are into where you are worried that America overcharges the Chinese for educational services that the Chinese gladly pay. Are there any other exports that you want America to charge less for, to give money away to China?
-
Geoff Shullenberger
@g_shullenberger
I suppose you could argue that policies encouraging degree factories to sell $300K tuition education to wealthy foreigners constitute a kind of "industrial policy," but contrary to Matt's claim, this mostly creates middle class jobs for administrators, not teachers.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Funny set of paragraphs in Compact today. Exporting educational services to the rest of the world does creates middle class jobs (teaching), promotes the education industry, and balances trade. Yet it's held up as an example of betraying those principles!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It’s not an “industrial policy” as it doesn’t require any kind of government investment or trade protection. It’s just an export industry like foreign tourism in NYC. If you think you can teach 600,000 students without teachers, I don’t know how to even begin.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I love this new economic nationalism you are into where you are worried that America overcharges the Chinese for educational services that the Chinese gladly pay. Are there any other exports that you want America to charge less for, to give money away to China?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It’s not an “industrial policy” as it doesn’t require any kind of government investment or trade protection. It’s just an export industry like foreign tourism in NYC. If you think you can teach 600,000 students without teachers, I don’t know how to even begin.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You see soft-sided coolers that meet the 12x12x6 rule, which I think is fairly standard (Yankees and Rangers have same rule). See clear bags too (12x12x6 is a big bag). It's such a common thing there are products specifically for it.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It is true of all the businesses in the malls. When I enter the Macy’s, *once inside* it’s just Macy’s. I guess technically not true in a farmers market but only because you are never “inside” a business in a farmers market as they don’t have buildings.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But of course what you are getting at here is that you have other options, not the nature of how buildings work. This is true in MLB stadiums though. You can bring in any non-alcoholic food/bev you want and people do.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
You see soft-sided coolers that meet the 12x12x6 rule, which I think is fairly standard (Yankees and Rangers have same rule). See clear bags too (12x12x6 is a big bag). It's such a common thing there are products specifically for it.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Example of using my NLRB Research database with Google Gemini in an ad-hoc but still speedy way (if I were more enterprising, I'd integrate it all with API calls, but the chatbot is a fixed monthly fee).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But your tweet here does confirm my subsequent tweet in almost eerily perfect way:
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Anyways, from time to time, it appears that a lot of the MAGA populism stuff is more about promoting "red sectors" instead of "blue sectors" than what they actually say. This piece ends by saying tariffs are increasing customers for his inherited metal-stamping business.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Funny set of paragraphs in Compact today. Exporting educational services to the rest of the world does creates middle class jobs (teaching), promotes the education industry, and balances trade. Yet it's held up as an example of betraying those principles!
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Anyways, from time to time, it appears that a lot of the MAGA populism stuff is more about promoting "red sectors" instead of "blue sectors" than what they actually say. This piece ends by saying tariffs are increasing customers for his inherited metal-stamping business.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But your tweet here does confirm my subsequent tweet in almost eerily perfect way:
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Anyways, from time to time, it appears that a lot of the MAGA populism stuff is more about promoting "red sectors" instead of "blue sectors" than what they actually say. This piece ends by saying tariffs are increasing customers for his inherited metal-stamping business.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
tc the teal-toned turtle
@tealtonedturtle
this makes too much sense
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One-of-a-kind bitcoin reporting from Bloomberg wealth
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
One-of-a-kind bitcoin reporting from Bloomberg wealth
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But of course what you are getting at here is that you have other options, not the nature of how buildings work. This is true in MLB stadiums though. You can bring in any non-alcoholic food/bev you want and people do.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It is true of all the businesses in the malls. When I enter the Macy’s, *once inside* it’s just Macy’s. I guess technically not true in a farmers market but only because you are never “inside” a business in a farmers market as they don’t have buildings.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The US just doesn't have the kinds of economic incentives to encourage this kind of innovation
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Land of contrasts
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
just having some fun with Gemini 3 this morning
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
"An axolotl family dressed in pilgrim clothing that is dancing in front of a thanksgiving feast." -- The kids like the AI video if nobody else does
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Can Gemini Pro 3 Figure Out NLRB Law? (Spoiler: Yes.)
www.nlrbedge.com/p/can-gemini-pro-3-figure-out-nlrb -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
let's go?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Related to a long-running beef I have with people who see that some groups have *positional* advantages in the labor market and then conclude that, if everyone was in that group, then they would all somehow have the same positional advantage.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Related to a long-running beef I have with people who see that some groups have *positional* advantages in the labor market and then conclude that, if everyone was in that group, then they would all somehow have the same positional advantage.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Kaitlan Collins
@kaitlancollins
Asked to clarify if he thinks Trump is a fascist, before Mamdani can answer, Trump intervenes and laughs it off, saying, “That’s ok. You can just say yes. That’s easier. It’s easier than explaining.”
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Happening now
www.youtube.com/live/Tk_fn_AV5RA -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
David Brooks has this very backwards. It was the bizarrely weak prosecution of Epstein the first go around that pushed down public trust. Transparency at this point would possibly help mend it some.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
An update on the state of my NLRB Research database. It's undergone major improvements! Consider supporting by subscribing to NLRB Edge or NLRB Research!
(links in the piece)
www.nlrbedge.com/p/nlrb-research-database-improvements -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This does not seem democratic to me
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Pulling out the tax laws and the benefit laws from that huge complex of laws that all work together to create an overall economic system and go "there's the coercive part, I found it" is absolutely dogshit stupidity.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is plausible but people should really just embrace the bleakness it suggests: what people want is for factor payments to generate egalitarian household distributions, but this is utterly impossible, and so they are doomed to wallow in endless frustration and anger.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When the note by the ACH line in my bank account says Walmart, I feel great, but when it says US Treasury, I feel terrible, unless I guess I am a federal employee, then it makes me feel good again (unless I'm conservative, now I still feel bad sort of)
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Such though processes are moronic. Your mind is captured by hegemony. Your fetishizing distinctions that aren't real, that exist to legitimate massive inequality. Stop!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Coercive state power drives both. If you don't believe me, then repeal all of the laws that set up the employment system. Repeal property law, contract law, bankruptcy law, securities law, corporate law, employment law, labor law, ERISA, and on and on. It's just a big system.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Pulling out the tax laws and the benefit laws from that huge complex of laws that all work together to create an overall economic system and go "there's the coercive part, I found it" is absolutely dogshit stupidity.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Coercive state power drives both. If you don't believe me, then repeal all of the laws that set up the employment system. Repeal property law, contract law, bankruptcy law, securities law, corporate law, employment law, labor law, ERISA, and on and on. It's just a big system.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
In collab with PPP, @RashidaTlaib introduced the Economic Dignity for All Agenda:
1. $469/mo universal child allowance that replaces EITC and CTC
2. $2,000 Baby Bonus at/before birth.
3. $250/mo universal benefit for working-age adults (19-67)
(link below) -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
interesting contrast with food stamps and medicaid in OBBA 🤷
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Trump just doesn't care about all the intellectual currents that supposedly make up his movements. So much said about doing economic populism by choking off imports and keeping immigrants out to increase native jobs and then Trump just disregards each on a whim.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
William Lawrence
@WeWillMi
Allow me to re-introduce myself. I'm William Lawrence. I'm running for Congress to represent Mid-Michigan and help flip the House. #mi07
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
'cept me
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
'cept me
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Warren Gunnels
@GunnelsWarren
Republicans: If Mamdani establishes a handful of government-owned grocery stores to make life more affordable there will be bread lines all over NY.
Also Republican Congresswoman: I love saving money at the government-owned grocery store that’s 100% funded by the Pentagon.
Jen Kiggans
@JenKiggans
Sunday afternoons are for grocery shopping at the commissary….! So thankful to the Defense Commissary Agency for taking care of the military families and veterans in Hampton Roads and around the world (and I save an average of $2-$3 off my favorite Tillamook chocolate peanut butter ice cream when I buy it on base!) As we continue to work to lower everyday costs, protecting these types of benefits for our military families continues to be a priority of mine in Congress.🇺🇸
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Jerry Jones trading for George Pickens in the off season proves once again that he's one of the greatest GMs of all time.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
All of the new farms and ranches I invested in under the assurance that tariffs would protect me from foreign competitors sadly did not pan out. Time to move my money into my other reshoring projects that are still tariff-protected. Trump wouldn't dare pull the rug on those.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The @ZohranKMamdani campaign has proposed a millionaire surtax often by referencing the MA FairShare tax. What does the data tell us about this tax three years on?
1. It raised twice as much revenue as projected
2. There is no millionaire exodus
3. It has funded many projects
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Link www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/11/17/do-millionaire-su…
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@ZohranKMamdani
A few days after the presidential election one year ago, we went to Fordham Road in the Bronx.
It was a little different last week.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
I'm debating @MattBruenig for the Econoboi channel on Friday.
Topic: "What is the best policy response to poverty?" -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
They are communicating the strike to people (not everyone is on twitter especially in the 1980s)
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When the unions were fighting Denmark in McDonalds. This was in addition to all of the solidarity strikes in adjacent sectors, which crippled the company. The boycott is not about lack of union power.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
They are communicating the strike to people (not everyone is on twitter especially in the 1980s)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Budget-conscious move at Yankee stadium (and I think all MLB stadiums) is to bring a 16x16x8 inch soft-sided cooler with whatever food/water you want to consume. Can't bring in outside alcohol though.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Budget-conscious move at Yankee stadium (and I think all MLB stadiums) is to bring a 16x16x8 inch soft-sided cooler with whatever food/water you want to consume. Can't bring in outside alcohol though.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
When the unions were fighting Denmark in McDonalds. This was in addition to all of the solidarity strikes in adjacent sectors, which crippled the company. The boycott is not about lack of union power.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Between the major-questions doctrine and the repeated court reversals of administrative agency actions, the "obscure statutory provisions + creative statutory interpretations" approach to executive unilateralism really seems to have been mostly discredited as a viable approach.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
where are we at these days on tariff incidence arguments...
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Economic inequality is not good
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
funny
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
intriguing www.nytimes.com/2025/11/13/us/politics/alaska-phone-votin…
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Claire Healy
@clurhealy
The new Epstein documents are in folders here, most under “images.”
oversight.house.gov/release/oversight-committee-releases-…
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Where can one read the full email dump that went out today
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Where can one read the full email dump that went out today
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Excited to get my class action check today. Legoland is not above the law!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's incredible that the government can run a nuclear power plant. But could it sell produce? I don't know.
Tennessee Valley Authority
@TVAnews
Where did Destin go this time? Smarter Every Day returns to the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant, and this time we go where few ever do, on the refueling bridge, directly above the reactor core during a refueling outage. Maintenance Superintendent Bill Ball joins him for a rare behind the scenes look at the precision, safety, and teamwork that keep one of the nation’s largest nuclear plants running safely and reliably. 🇺🇸
Check it out: tva.me/15lk50XpmN4 -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Tennessee Valley Authority
@TVAnews
Where did Destin go this time? Smarter Every Day returns to the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant, and this time we go where few ever do, on the refueling bridge, directly above the reactor core during a refueling outage. Maintenance Superintendent Bill Ball joins him for a rare behind the scenes look at the precision, safety, and teamwork that keep one of the nation’s largest nuclear plants running safely and reliably. 🇺🇸
Check it out: tva.me/15lk50XpmN4 -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
nf
@nf_11_nj
JD Vance
@JDVance
Forgive my language but this story is complete and utter bullshit. The WSJ should be ashamed for publishing it.
Where is this letter? Would you be shocked to learn they never showed it to us before publishing it? Does anyone honestly believe this sounds like Donald Trump?
Yashar Ali 🐘
@yashar
BREAKING
The Wall Street Journal has reviewed a book put together for Jeffrey Epstein’s 50th birthday, as part of that book a letter was submitted by Donald Trump.
Trump’s letter features a drawing of a naked woman and this text which imagines a conversation between Trump and Epstein.
Full Story: www.wsj.com/politics/trump-jeffrey-epstein-birthday-lette… -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It was clear even in the earlier years something goofy was going on.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It was clear even in the earlier years something goofy was going on.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Thanks to Nico giving him the kick in the but he needed to get into shape. Win win situation. If he were with the mavs, he’d still be struggling to get in shape
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This will be the peak fired for truth. Everyone admits know that Luka was out of shape. And the high-stakes bet delivered the number 1 draft pick. Proof being right doesn't always pay.
NBACentral
@TheDunkCentral
Nico Harrison’s time with the Mavericks could be coming to an end, as his relationship with ownership has reportedly crumbled, per @BannedMacMahon
"it's a matter of when, not if, Nico Harrison will be fired". 😳
(h/t @RealGM )Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Thanks to Nico giving him the kick in the but he needed to get into shape. Win win situation. If he were with the mavs, he’d still be struggling to get in shape
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Biden is not term limited...
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
:-/
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's all very sensitive to precisely how you organize things. It seems like you could spin air traffic control off from FAA into an Air Traffic Control SOE and then regulatorily require the airports to hire them and it would run unaffected in shutdown (i.e. with pay).
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's interesting that the actual federal SOEs -- Amtrak, TVA, and USPS -- are unaffected by shutdown. But then certain federal services like TSA and FAA run just without paying anyone. But then other federal services like National Park Service shuts down.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's all very sensitive to precisely how you organize things. It seems like you could spin air traffic control off from FAA into an Air Traffic Control SOE and then regulatorily require the airports to hire them and it would run unaffected in shutdown (i.e. with pay).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's interesting that the actual federal SOEs -- Amtrak, TVA, and USPS -- are unaffected by shutdown. But then certain federal services like TSA and FAA run just without paying anyone. But then other federal services like National Park Service shuts down.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Juanita Broaddrick
@atensnut
🤣👍🏻
Mr. Star Spangled MAGA
@4thOfJuly365
🤣🤣🤣
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think one way to get paid is to halt air travel until you are paid
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The air traffic controllers should go on strike…
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think one way to get paid is to halt air travel until you are paid
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Anya Parampil
@anyaparampil
Ziwe: “Marry, F, kill: communism, socialism, capitalism?”
Mayor Eric Adams: “I would marry capitalism, Israel.”
Truly one of the most bizarre interview clips I’ve ever seen. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's $24.60 per day ($8.20 per person), which is right at USDA thrifty food plan level (the lowest USDA food plan). The vast majority of people spend more than that on food.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's $24.60 per day ($8.20 per person), which is right at USDA thrifty food plan level (the lowest USDA food plan). The vast majority of people spend more than that on food.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right and it's definitely workable. All of the anti-discrimination laws have the same sort of issues around needing exceptions (such as a moviemaker who needs to cast someone of a specific race for a part) and they are permitted if they are genuinely necessary for the job.
-
Jerusalem
@JerusalemDemsas
Great @MattBruenig piece this AM about the impermissibility of getting someone fired over their political speech.
He proposes a legal solution I'd not heard of before...
www.theargumentmag.com/p/how-to-neuter-the-social-media-mobPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right and it's definitely workable. All of the anti-discrimination laws have the same sort of issues around needing exceptions (such as a moviemaker who needs to cast someone of a specific race for a part) and they are permitted if they are genuinely necessary for the job.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Despite what seems like more frequent discourse about it, the young male NEET situation is back to 1990s levels, though still around double the Nordic average.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Jerusalem
@JerusalemDemsas
Great @MattBruenig piece this AM about the impermissibility of getting someone fired over their political speech.
He proposes a legal solution I'd not heard of before...
www.theargumentmag.com/p/how-to-neuter-the-social-media-mob -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Seems like a lot of the comparative election analysis has things wrong. In 2024, GOP won 30% of the presidential vote in NYC. That fell to just 7% on Tuesday! Huge Dem swing.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
New piece at @TheArgumentMag concerning the problems with firing people for off-duty speech and political participation, including what to do about it. Link below.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
How to neuter the social media mob www.theargumentmag.com/p/how-to-neuter-the-social-media-mob
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The AWS DNS bosses have finally blessed me with restored service. So mattbruenig.com and nlrbedge.com are back.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right. If you want to help finance the school lunch system in part by getting money from affluent people, that can be done via school lunch fees or via school lunch tax. The latter is simply a better way to do it.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Free school lunch zooming along
philip lewis
@Phil_Lewis_
WASHINGTON (AP) — Colorado voters approve income tax increase on higher-earning households to fund meals for all public school students.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Right. If you want to help finance the school lunch system in part by getting money from affluent people, that can be done via school lunch fees or via school lunch tax. The latter is simply a better way to do it.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
😉
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
oh boy
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
good decision
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
fun
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
(((Jacob Bogage)))
@jacobbogage
👀 Scoop: IRS Direct File, the free government-backed program that let you file your taxes for free, is dead.
IRS wrote to state tax agencies saying it would not be operational this coming tax season, per records I've obtained.
IRS Direct File: 2023-2025. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The phrase "negative income tax" expresses nothing at all about what the benefit is, which is basically just food stamps but paid in cash.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Milton Friedman came up with the idea of a means-tested basic cash assistance program with a 50% phaseout rate but decided to give it the most confusing name and explanation you could possibly imagine
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The phrase "negative income tax" expresses nothing at all about what the benefit is, which is basically just food stamps but paid in cash.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
amusing
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Crunching the Numbers on Predistribution
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/10/31/crunching-the-num… -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The death march of linear TV is so undignified. Just shut it down.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Considering writing an introductory labor law book (heavily AI-assisted) based on the premise that the best way to get going is to start with the most frequently cited cases, which I can determine because of my database. Will mix my own judgment as well. But fun start.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We see this in all sorts of areas. People prefer property taxes to be collected monthly via escrow to mortgage companies. People really like the idea in general of hiding the cost of benefits (like health insurance) through "employer contributions"
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I would be opposed to secretly raising the employer-side payroll tax (indeed, I am not sure how one could since employers must have knowledge to comply). That people don't care so long as the tax is just baked into everything is itself an indicator of administrative preference.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We see this in all sorts of areas. People prefer property taxes to be collected monthly via escrow to mortgage companies. People really like the idea in general of hiding the cost of benefits (like health insurance) through "employer contributions"
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I would be opposed to secretly raising the employer-side payroll tax (indeed, I am not sure how one could since employers must have knowledge to comply). That people don't care so long as the tax is just baked into everything is itself an indicator of administrative preference.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
They wouldn't cut. They would just grow nominal wages more slowly, especially if the tax was only gradually raised. The empirics on this are pretty clear.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
They wouldn't cut. They would just grow nominal wages more slowly, especially if the tax was only gradually raised. The empirics on this are pretty clear.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
love stories like this, what do I do with this information
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The tariff situation is interesting because, on the one hand, people don't like higher prices (putting aside other issues of them), while on the other, it's a very opaque form of tax, like the VAT, which the research says people end up being fine with.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I keep thinking the employer-side payroll tax is such an obvious one to target. If you ramp it up gradually, nobody will even notice it.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
It's clear that the current government lacks a functional majority and that it should dissolve to hold a snap election
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
RT @TVAnews: Curious about what happens during a planned nuclear maintenance and refueling outage? Ben Hunt and Bryce Wilder at our Sequoya…
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
James Medlock
@jdcmedlock
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
More and more are asking this question these days
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/10/26/do-predistributio… -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Blogging is a style of writing
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Blogging is a style of writing
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
More and more are asking this question these days
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/10/26/do-predistributio… -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Ohtani couldn't even pitch a complete game?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@ZohranKMamdani
Next year, we'll welcome 125,000 new New Yorkers to our city. But many families don't have what they need to give their babies a healthy start.
Building on @BKBPReynoso's pilot, we'll launch citywide Baby Baskets, providing new parents with essential items and resources. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I was commenting on the welfare state there, not wages. Welfare state does smoothing and equalizing, should not have any aggregate impact on rents. For instance, when we shift 12.4% of wages from workers to the elderly/disabled each month through SS, that doesn't increase rent.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I was commenting on the welfare state there, not wages. Welfare state does smoothing and equalizing, should not have any aggregate impact on rents. For instance, when we shift 12.4% of wages from workers to the elderly/disabled each month through SS, that doesn't increase rent.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The key is just whenever you learn that the policy you thought sounded good is indefensible on the merits (including leftist merits), just shift to saying it's good politics. That will get you to stalemate and so nobody ever has to lose. The universal salve of policy discourse.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The key is just whenever you learn that the policy you thought sounded good is indefensible on the merits (including leftist merits), just shift to saying it's good politics. That will get you to stalemate and so nobody ever has to lose. The universal salve of policy discourse.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That's not the case even under the labor theory of value. The lobster starts with nonzero value which labor is then added to. Marx makes this point directly in the Critique of the Gotha Program.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Alaskans actually love the Permanent Fund and Permanent Fund Dividend. It's wildly popular.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But of course how something "sounds" is mostly a function of how you choose to describe it. The Norwegian quotes provide very lovely language about the importance of everyone benefiting from our common natural resources. And you could invert those to make Maine sound awful.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Graham Platner believes that the value of lobsters, which are a gift of nature that no man creates, should be privatized and paid out as super-profits to a handful of license-holders!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
That's not the case even under the labor theory of value. The lobster starts with nonzero value which labor is then added to. Marx makes this point directly in the Critique of the Gotha Program.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Graham Platner believes that the value of lobsters, which are a gift of nature that no man creates, should be privatized and paid out as super-profits to a handful of license-holders!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
But of course how something "sounds" is mostly a function of how you choose to describe it. The Norwegian quotes provide very lovely language about the importance of everyone benefiting from our common natural resources. And you could invert those to make Maine sound awful.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Alaskans actually love the Permanent Fund and Permanent Fund Dividend. It's wildly popular.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is actually a good illustration of the different conceptual focuses. In Norway, they are looking at the fishers and seeing them as collecting rent from natural resources that belong to everyone. Graham is concerned with making sure small fishers get that rent not big ones.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We have a pretty direct comparison to how Norway manages this with its aquaculture industry (salmon and trout). Consistent with the Norwegian tradition of socializing the gains from natural resources, that industry pays an extra 25% tax on top of the normal corporate tax.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
This is actually a good illustration of the different conceptual focuses. In Norway, they are looking at the fishers and seeing them as collecting rent from natural resources that belong to everyone. Graham is concerned with making sure small fishers get that rent not big ones.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
We have a pretty direct comparison to how Norway manages this with its aquaculture industry (salmon and trout). Consistent with the Norwegian tradition of socializing the gains from natural resources, that industry pays an extra 25% tax on top of the normal corporate tax.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Suing the government in your personal capacity and then having the government, which you run, settle the lawsuit with you for money is the true infinite money trick.
The New York Times
@nytimes
Breaking News: President Trump wants $230 million from the Justice Department for investigating him, people familiar with the matter say. Any settlement might ultimately be approved by senior department officials who defended him or those in his orbit. www.nytimes.com/2025/10/21/us/politics/trump-justice-depa…
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I lived in an apartment complex like this. It was nice and cheap.
Jeff Morris Jr.
@jmj
Everyone talks about AI slop.
No one talks about PE (private equity) slop.
- restaurants that lost their soul
- medical practices that feel like assembly lines
- apartment buildings designed by an Excel formula
The algorithm didn’t kill culture. The margin model did. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
From what baseline do we define revision. I am old enough to remember Barack Obama specifically campaigning on a public option which he immediately revised (i.e. abandoned) after getting into office. It's not the left-wing of the Dem caucus that blocks that ever.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
From what baseline do we define revision. I am old enough to remember Barack Obama specifically campaigning on a public option which he immediately revised (i.e. abandoned) after getting into office. It's not the left-wing of the Dem caucus that blocks that ever.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So what you are going to find here is that, as the socialists have been trying to tell you, "privately-owned institutions" are all reliant on the state in various ways. That's kind of the key problem with the whole theory!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Index investing is not itself a form of socialism, but index investing and public companies prove that vast social ownership of capital is easy to pull off. SWFs prove it further. Notable that after doing "fundamental research," stock pickers don't perform any better!
Cathie Wood
@CathieDWood
Isn’t it sad, if not damning, that institutional shareholders rely on proxy firms to tell them how they should vote?Index funds do no fundamental research, yet dominate institutional voting. Index-based investing is a form of socialism. Our investment system is broken.
ARK Invest
@ARKInvest
Having previously called the Delaware court’s decision “un-American,” @CathieDWood continues to defend Elon Musk’s 2018 pay package and urges the appeals court to “do the right thing" in a new "The Brainstorm."
Watch now!Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What's funny is Trump has done relatively little to America's state-owned enterprises (USPS, TVA, Amtrak) while managing to exert quite a lot of power over private entities like universities, media, tech.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
So what you are going to find here is that, as the socialists have been trying to tell you, "privately-owned institutions" are all reliant on the state in various ways. That's kind of the key problem with the whole theory!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There are other levers here including civil rights enforcement: Trump has been using expansive definitions of Title VI to make fake religious discrimination claims against universities where students protest Israel in order to exert broader control over the universities
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know I am wasting my time here. But the point of that tweet was that whether something is state-owned or not has not proven to be much of an indicator of whether Trump has exerted control over it. He's done relatively little to SOEs while doing a lot to private entities.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Of course, of the three SOEs, Amtrak is the worst performing. TVA is a profitable energy company, one of the largest in the country. While USPS is the best postal logistics company in the world. But that's all beside the point which is about ownership versus state power.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
There are other levers here including civil rights enforcement: Trump has been using expansive definitions of Title VI to make fake religious discrimination claims against universities where students protest Israel in order to exert broader control over the universities
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Of course, of the three SOEs, Amtrak is the worst performing. TVA is a profitable energy company, one of the largest in the country. While USPS is the best postal logistics company in the world. But that's all beside the point which is about ownership versus state power.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I know I am wasting my time here. But the point of that tweet was that whether something is state-owned or not has not proven to be much of an indicator of whether Trump has exerted control over it. He's done relatively little to SOEs while doing a lot to private entities.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What's funny is Trump has done relatively little to America's state-owned enterprises (USPS, TVA, Amtrak) while managing to exert quite a lot of power over private entities like universities, media, tech.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
this one tickled me for some reason, obviously the biggest thing here is these small business owner vendors are just "price gouging" in the way that term has been used recently ...
James Talarico
@jamestalarico
Tariffs are ruining everything — including the Texas State Fair.
$14 for fried oreos.
$15 for a funnel cake chicken sandwich.
$25 for a turkey leg.
DC politicians are pricing Texans out of our own state fair.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Maybe senior discount is cool because a lot who use it would be willing to pay full price and we think about their extra consumer surplus. But when we start going multivariate and getting really accurate, the pricing doesn't generate new consumer surplus opportunities.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
who came up with the idea of rebranding price discrimination as "surveillance pricing"?
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
To be clear, "publicly advertised discounts" are also "based on predictive modeling of willingness to pay" of "granular consumer segments [e.g. seniors]" right? So is it purely how transparent the differential pricing is?
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Is age an aggregate characteristic or a specific one about you that is being used to determine your personalized price? Is what you are getting at here is just the use of multivariate models (instead of univariate models) for estimating willingness to pay?
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think it's very philosophically interesting. It goes to the question of how do we understand "consumer surplus"? So much of our justifications for capitalism is that prices reflect subject value received, but in fact consumer surplus is everywhere...
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Maybe senior discount is cool because a lot who use it would be willing to pay full price and we think about their extra consumer surplus. But when we start going multivariate and getting really accurate, the pricing doesn't generate new consumer surplus opportunities.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I think it's very philosophically interesting. It goes to the question of how do we understand "consumer surplus"? So much of our justifications for capitalism is that prices reflect subject value received, but in fact consumer surplus is everywhere...
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
To be clear, "publicly advertised discounts" are also "based on predictive modeling of willingness to pay" of "granular consumer segments [e.g. seniors]" right? So is it purely how transparent the differential pricing is?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Is age an aggregate characteristic or a specific one about you that is being used to determine your personalized price? Is what you are getting at here is just the use of multivariate models (instead of univariate models) for estimating willingness to pay?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don't think it's quite right to say you need to look at it from different angles. We can just list all of the facts:
1. The welfare state is the biggest factor in overall inequality.
2. Wage compression is the biggest factor in wage-earner inequality. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don't think it's quite right to say you need to look at it from different angles. We can just list all of the facts:
1. The welfare state is the biggest factor in overall inequality.
2. Wage compression is the biggest factor in wage-earner inequality. -
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don’t think it is totally sunk cost. It’s that, once the home price collapses, to leave, they would have to move into a much worse house and so their flow of housing consumption would go way down, so much so that it may even overwhelm the benefit from higher earnings.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Why do workers stay in places facing economic decline? Great paper using Norwegian administrative data to show that the decline in local home prices keep homeowners there (but not renters)
www.norges-bank.no/contentassets/f226339b2ed54eacb0f85bcb…Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If your theory was correct, both renters and homeowners would stay. But that’s not what happens. Instead renter out-migration increases a lot while homeowner out-migration actually *falls* dramatically and in proportion to how much home wealth they have.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
I don’t think it is totally sunk cost. It’s that, once the home price collapses, to leave, they would have to move into a much worse house and so their flow of housing consumption would go way down, so much so that it may even overwhelm the benefit from higher earnings.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
If your theory was correct, both renters and homeowners would stay. But that’s not what happens. Instead renter out-migration increases a lot while homeowner out-migration actually *falls* dramatically and in proportion to how much home wealth they have.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
fair enough
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
29 U.S.C. § 158(d)
@TaylorArluck
Ex-NLRB Chair told @MattBruenig that "the system works as it exists now" and flagged potential constitutional issues -- 1A & Takings Clause -- with bipartisan labor law reform that would quickly create initial 2-yr CBAs via binding, mandatory arbitration. www.nlrbedge.com/p/interview-with-former-nlrb-chairman
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Some people use it badly. Other people cannot figure out how to use it effectively. Common issues with any technology. My elderly father can't figure out how to use a cell phone effectively for instance.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Nice thing is you don't really need to have this debate because the usefulness (if any) will be revealed. I personally use it in every thing I do, legal work, NLRB Edge/Research, statistical coding for PPP data analysis. Make money on all of it.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Some people use it badly. Other people cannot figure out how to use it effectively. Common issues with any technology. My elderly father can't figure out how to use a cell phone effectively for instance.
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What do you care whether I write and revise the python code to calculate some number or prompt an LLM to write the python code and then revise it (if needed)? Same result, just with much less labor/time.
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The coding example is particularly funny because what coding actually looks like is primarily calling libraries that you also don't write. I mostly use pandas for data analysis. I didn't write pandas. I trust that it works as documented. But it's not my code!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
The coding example is particularly funny because what coding actually looks like is primarily calling libraries that you also don't write. I mostly use pandas for data analysis. I didn't write pandas. I trust that it works as documented. But it's not my code!
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
What do you care whether I write and revise the python code to calculate some number or prompt an LLM to write the python code and then revise it (if needed)? Same result, just with much less labor/time.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
She thought she had a clever point about not needing Trump supporters to win, but the reporter was quick to point out that, due to CA's top-two system, she may run against another Dem and so probably would need some. And she just couldn't recover from this fuck up.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
She thought she had a clever point about not needing Trump supporters to win, but the reporter was quick to point out that, due to CA's top-two system, she may run against another Dem and so probably would need some. And she just couldn't recover from this fuck up.
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
MachinePix
@MachinePix
Snailbot is a self-reconfigurable robot using rocker-bogie suspension by The University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen.
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Seen this too many times now. I had to do it. (link below)
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Will you come on my podcast to talk about this?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Will you come on my podcast to talk about this?
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Apparently @Noahpinion wrote on it again today just still fully not understanding that the fact that desert theory requires compensating equal risk takers equally which is by definition not how risk works is my point!
-
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Desert and Capitalism Again
mattbruenig.com/2025/10/03/desert-and-capitalism-again/Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Apparently @Noahpinion wrote on it again today just still fully not understanding that the fact that desert theory requires compensating equal risk takers equally which is by definition not how risk works is my point!
Post not available here, view on X
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
None of that happened. No discussion was had about risk premia (all of my arguments compare hypothetical investments with same risk). On TVOM, I said that if that is your desert base, then capitalism fails again because two people with different TVOM receive the same return (under desert, the one with the higher TVOM should receive a higher return).
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
political econ student
@publicgoodsfan
An interesting complement to this arg is Joan Robinson's article "Some Reflections on the Philosophy of Prices."
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-9957.1958.…
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
Desert and Capitalism Again
mattbruenig.com/2025/10/03/desert-and-capitalism-again/ -
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
NLRB website is down. But all of the NLRB case law remains accessible on my website! nlrbresearch.com/NLRB/NLRB_DB
-
Matt Bruenig reposted
Matt Bruenig
@MattBruenig
None of that happened. No discussion was had about risk premia (all of my arguments compare hypothetical investments with same risk). On TVOM, I said that if that is your desert base, then capitalism fails again because two people with different TVOM receive the same return (under desert, the one with the higher TVOM should receive a higher return).








































































































































































































































































































