When the Norwegian state administers identity.
It marks a radical societal shift when the state moves from registering what someone is to registering what someone feels or wishes to be.
The core task of the National Population Register is to keep track of verifiable facts: birth, death, sex, place of residence, mother, father, and citizenship. Now it is also meant to keep track of self-perception.
Sex is the clearest example:
Parliament has decided that an inner, undocumentable experience should take precedence over the sexed body. Not because sex has changed — the body is and does exactly what it did before — but because the law has changed. Because Parliament has decided that this is now how it shall be. We have stepped out of objective reality and into the subjective idea of who and what one is. From matter to spirit.
The six-year-old and the County Governor.
The most absurd illustration of what has happened is found in the age limit tied to legal sex. A six-year-old child can now change their legal sex. Consent from one parent may be enough.
I wonder whether Parliament has understood the consequences this entails.
Six years old. Children start primary school at six, to learn to read, write, and do arithmetic.
On the first day of school they stand expectantly in the schoolyard, freshly groomed, their first school bag on their back.
At the same time, Parliament has enacted by law that these little ones just starting to learn the alphabet are mature enough to change their own legal sex status.
But what if the parents disagree? The legislature has thought of that too — then the County Governor decides. The same administrative body that handles guardianship, appeals, and separation permits will now decide which sex your child "is" — or rather, which legal sex it is in the child's interest to have.
Picture the process. A six-year-old boy says he is a girl. Mother agrees. Father does not. Father has done nothing wrong — he has simply described reality as it is, as it is also recorded in the child's own birth record. Now he is a party to an administrative case against his own child.
It's worth examining closely what the legislature has done here. It has not only shifted the power of definition from biology to subjective idea, thought, or experience. It has shifted the power of definition from parents to child, and given the six-year-old a tool to use against whichever parent says no. The child is not protected by the law. The child is turned into an instrument of the law, in a conflict it has itself triggered and must live with for the rest of its life.
The responsibility is placed on the family member least equipped to bear it. The legislature calls this human rights, in the name of gender and sexual diversity.
From inner life to public category
In just a few years we have built a substantial apparatus to administer something no one can define. The Norwegian Directorate for Children, Youth and Family Affairs (Bufdir) describes gender identity as a person's own experience of which sex they are — while no one can say what "gender identity" actually consists of. Try explaining what "gender identity" is without using the word sex in the explanation. It can't be done. The definition is circular, and it has been made legally binding.
The state has begun administering what used to belong to people's innermost private lives: Who are you? How do you experience yourself? Which sex do you experience yourself as having?
The answer is then translated into legal status, documents, statistics, public services, healthcare, schools, working life, language, and institutions. Identity is no longer private. It has become administration.
But administration has requirements. The state must know something. It must count and categorize. It must make rules and distribute rights and duties. It must know who is a child and who is an adult, who is Norwegian and who is not, who is a man and who is a woman, who is a parent, who is an employer or employee, who is a patient or a practitioner.
So now the state produces statistics on bodily matters — disease progression, incidents of violence, exposure to violence, mortality, and wage gaps — where one of the variables measures not the body but self-perception.
The numbers look just as precise as before. They have simply lost their connection to what they're supposed to describe. A category that can be changed on request cannot be used to measure anything.
Who gets to ask the question
What happens when an unclear category becomes legally binding is not that the category becomes clearer. It is that it becomes elevated above discussion, and critical or questioning inquiries become inappropriate.
The institutions have already set the frame. Words have been swapped out, guidelines written, courses held. And the individual who says "I don't believe this" is met not with counterarguments, but with an HR case, cancellation, and institutions that — with ample help from politicians and political parties — can destroy the reputation of anyone who asks, doubts, or refuses to accept that "gender identity" is the same as reality.
Relevant questions and discussions about what reality consists of (the substance) are turned into a narrative where the people asking the questions are seen as dangerous.
This is how the friction that democracy actually consists of and depends on gets broken down. Disagreement is not a flaw in the system — disagreement is a necessary component for sustaining conversation and democracy.
But in the case of "gender identity," disagreement has been redefined as an offense and as hatred, as a legal problem. Then the discussion is over before it begins, because with Parliament's help it has been made dangerous to take part in.
And meanwhile, the casework goes on. The forms are filled out, the decisions are made, the statistics are kept. No one has decided that the body doesn't exist. But Parliament has stopped registering it.
Then we are back to the six-year-old. Not as an illustration in a debate, but as a child. A child who has been given a tool it does not understand, in a conflict it cannot foresee, and a decision that can follow it into adulthood if it is put on the trans track and the irreversible harms that can bring.
Questions for the Prime Minister and Parliament
Jonas Gahr Støre is at the helm. It is his government that has adopted the action plans, his ministries that distribute the funding, and it is the Labour Party's parliamentary group that, together with the parliamentary majority, has set the age limit at six and left the decision to the County Governor when parents disagree.
So the question is whether @JonasGahrStøre, together with Minister of Children and Families @LeneVågslid, will draw a line and acknowledge that the law has given six-year-olds an authority no six-year-old can bear, that the state can neither fund a conviction nor simultaneously register it as fact, and that a population register must be faithful to facts.
Because it is Parliament that has decided that boys and men can identify their way into the girl and woman category.
This affects the girls' and women's category in sports, spaces where girls and women are naked, crisis centers for women subjected to violence, women's prisons, lesbian, bisexual, and gay people, and media that describe men who commit serious violent and sexual crimes as "she/her" and "woman." It affects freedom of expression, employees' ability to participate in the debate on sex, academia, the arts, and all of us. So no, this is not a marginal matter.
The question is whether Støre is willing to acknowledge that "gender identity" does not belong as a legal category, and to take responsibility for cleaning up the legislation and the consequential errors this has created.
Concrete proposals for how this can be done already exist. Professor Emerita Anne Robberstad has proposed removing "gender identity" from the legislation and revising the law on changing legal sex. @AnneKvinnesak proposes protecting gender identity as a belief, not as a fact, and @wdiNorway has proposed grounding biological sex as the basis in all situations where sex is relevant: legally, administratively, and practically. So solutions are not lacking. What is lacking, at the highest level, is the will to bring actual reality back into the legislation.
#norway #sex #identity
#stortinget