The Armed Forces of Ukraine congratulate Lisbon’s Vasco da Gama Bridge on being named the longest bridge in Europe!
Tim Leunig, Baron Leunig
Timothy Charles Leunig, Baron Leunig (born 26 February 1971) is an economist at the London School of Economics's Department of Economic History. After a long career as a civil servant, he became a director at the economic consultants Public First. Leunig was given a peerage in the July 2026 political peerages. More on Wikipedia
-
Tim Leunig reposted
General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine
@GeneralStaffUA
-
Tim Leunig reposted
ORR
@railandroad
🚉 London Liverpool Street is the first station in Great Britain to exceed 100 million entries and exits in a year, reaching 102.7 million in 2025–26.
It's Britain's most used station for the fourth year running.
Full data: dataportal.orr.gov.uk/statistics/usage/estimates-of-stati… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I once held a baby for an hour or so on a flight from Norway to let the clearly exhausted mother next to me eat some food, go to the loo, have a stretch etc. it is hard travelling with a little one…
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
Huge shoutout to the guy with the seat next to us in the economy bulkhead (where the bassinet goes). Boarded for a 7hr flight, saw the baby and his face dropped. He called the stewardess over and plaintively asked if it was still possible to pay for an upgrade. It was not.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
It wasn’t a stretch target it was a promise. Please don’t insult the millions who voted for you.
Ridge & Frost
@RidgeandFrost
🗣️ 'Are you going to meet the target of 1.5m new homes by 2029?' - @SophyRidgeSky
🗣️ 'It has become really challenging... it was always a stretch target' - Housing minister, @mtpennycookThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That the Elizabeth Line is now one in six journeys also tells us that the rest of the network was designed for a Victorian economy, not a modern one.
Paul Lucas
@paul_winginit
A mind blowing stat about the Elizabeth Line is that the line accounts for about ONE IN SIX heavy rail journeys in Britain. It's been so revolutionary.
Alex Kemper
@ajkemps
Flew into Heathrow this week for the first time in a few years. Imagine my surprise and delight upon learning that the good people of the UK have built a new train called the Elizabeth Line that takes you into central London quickly. A true “the American mind simply can’t comprehend” moment
-
Tim Leunig reposted
The Observer
@ObserverUK
The economics of serendipity make the case for office working
The breakthroughs made in an astonishing variety of fields by researchers in one ramshackle MIT building underline a key fact: ideas people need places to meet
✍️ @BenZaranko
observer.co.uk/news/business/article/the-economics-of-ser… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Stone Centre at UCL
@StoneEcon_UCL
The Stone Centre Conference on Optimal Taxation, Policy Design, and Inequalities takes place on 17–18 December at UCL, London. Space is limited and registration is on a first-come, first-served basis. Full details and registration: sites.google.com/view/optimaltaxationpolicydesignand/
@TheIFS @UCLPolicyLab -
Tim Leunig reposted
Rhys Williams﮷
@RhysWilliamsTV
1. Reading Alan Milburn’s review as a Welsh journalist, parts sound familiar.
More flexible assessments, more vocational courses, earlier help for pupils at risk of disengaging.
Wales has tried versions of these ideas. There are lessons for England...including uncomfortable ones 🧵 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Did you find those bits less clear? That is surely the acid test?
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
20% of the Milburn Review is AI. What are the norms on this? Is it basically now just OK?
Instinctively I really dislike it but I have been trying to examine that instinct and see if it is just snobbery.
I have an article coming out with Google's AI Policy Perspectives Substack soon about the issue.
Part of me thinks that if you are going to use AI this heavily maybe there should be some more disclosure about the prompts. What was prompted for this section? Here are some bullet points about some kids, turn them into an emotive couple of paras? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Superb from @DelphineStrauss @FT on migration. Countries will not allow falls in working age populations like this - economies would fail, and taxes rise. The q is not "do we want migrants?", but "which migrants do we need?" www.ft.com/content/12f76b96-6ef9-40fb-924f-60c348935a21?s…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Will Norman
@willnorman
Bus stop bypasses are key features of safe cycle networks around the world.
London data shows there's a v low risk of collision with cyclists at bypasses.
Over 3 yrs there were just 6 reported collisions – that’s just 0.05% of the total pedestrian collisions over that period. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Reform UK claiming four out of five jobs go to migrants is the reverse of the truth: four in five go to Brits.
Saying otherwise obscures the real problem: Brits are leaving workforce faster than they are joining.
I wrote about it earlier this year: frasernelson.substack.com/p/immigrants-no-more-likely-to-…
fleetstreetfox
@fleetstreetfox
The problem here is newsroom churn - there’s no one left to remember they fucked it up last time.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Morrison MP
@ThomasMorrison
He’s not a “disgraced comedian” he’s a convicted rapist.
ITV News
@itvnews
Russell Brand’s wife shares message from disgraced comedian in prison www.itv.com/news/2026-11-15/russell-brands-wife-shares-me…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Delight to listen to @Rachel_deSouza at @EduPolicyInst annual lecture.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Diamant
@michael_diamant
🔥SO YOU WANT TO BECOME A CLASSICAL ARCHITECT? Now you have the chance by studying ONLINE at the Classic Planning Institute's 1 year program. Learn drawing skills and understand the techniques that make classical architecture so beloved.
APPLY NOW AS THE PROGRAM STARTS IN DECEMBER. LINK TO APPLY: www.classicplanning.org/academy -
Tim Leunig reposted
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
This is absolutely true, but it's also probably true that Jane would have built the app even if she'd only made several hundred million not a billion. There's a counterfactual with fewer billionaires, more redistribution, *and* still new product creation.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
This is a classic example of ‘the private sector can never build the houses we need’, which ignores the fact that it used to do so perfectly happily before we assumed (ahem) public control of the land supply and housebuilding allocation.
Matthew Pennycook MP
@mtpennycook
As this piece aptly demonstrates, mainstream public discourse on housebuilding in England is almost entirely devoid of any meaningful consideration of the structural dominance of speculative development models.
The market absorption rate constraints inherent to those models (i.e. developers cannot afford to build and sell homes too quickly in any given local market as doing so would undermine prices and result in a loss on their land investment) mean that build out rates are tied to rising house prices and the existence of sufficient effective demand for homes at those prices.
It is not in dispute that viability pressures are acute in many parts of the country. That's precisely why we've implemented a range of targeted regulatory easements and committed to no major new building regulations for the remainder of the parliament.
However, the simple fact is that the private market as it is currently constituted will not, on its own initiative, produce sufficient housing to meet overall housing need, even if it is highly competitive.
The disruption and transformation of the housebuilding market is essential to delivering high and sustainable rates of housebuilding in the years ahead.
Tej Parikh
@tejparikh90
Britain’s self-inflicted housebuilding crunch.
My latest column for @FT. The government blocks construction with tax & regulation, then commits public funds to offset the damage: as.ft.com/r/bc0fe711-a2ef-4128-ae1a-2e965c25c4e8
With insights from @Ben_A_Hopkinson and Edward Donovan @CPSThinkTank -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What I learned from driving on Australian motorways... timleunig.substack.com/p/more-thoughts-from-australia (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Absolutely delighted to see @RishiSunak announce he will stand for parliament again at the next election. I worked with him in govt, and we need people of his calibre in parliament. [#reachingacrosstheaisle - #notallpoliticsispartisan]
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ian Leslie
@mrianleslie
The great @_HannahRitchie has put together an incredible website IN HER SPARE TIME: "The UK In Charts"
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am confident that this is a very, very good book.
Tirthankar Roy
@RoyHistory1
The British Empire: An Economic History (Leigh Gardner and Tirthankar Roy, Polity, 2026) is now available on sale from www.politybooks.com/bookdetail?book_slug=the-british-empi…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Surely @RachelReevesMP could usefully record herself turning to the camera ???
Ben Ansell
@benwansell
We need some kind of Rachel Reeves turning to the camera gif for these moments.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
Small but, I think, important note (at least in my world).
Since it's GDP day in the UK, some of you who follow these things might be wondering when we're going to air the typical quarterly interview with the Chancellor. After all, there's a long tradition, going all the way back to @George_Osborne's time in office, that when new economic growth figs come out, the Chancellor of the day does a round of interviews with all major broadcasters. This was in stark contrast to what came before, and what sometimes happened in other departments, where ministers could cherry-pick who they wanted to do interviews with.
The way the Treasury did it was somewhat fairer. Every three months, they would put the Chancellor up for interviews. Save for a few exceptional periods, most Chancellors stuck by this convention. And these rounds became one of the main opportunities for the government economic policy to be scrutinised by a range of interviewers.
Sadly, it seems the Treasury have decided to ditch the old tradition and are no longer doing interview rounds with broadcasters. Instead they have decided to just do one broadcast interview today, with the BBC.
This is, of course, their prerogative.
However, I can't help but think it's a bit of a shame. After all, there's lots to discuss about the UK economy right now (much of it quite encouraging!). There are loads of questions we at @skynews, as well as other broadcasters, would like to ask @JohnHealey_MP. But, today at least, we can't!
So... less scrutiny of this government's economic policy, at the very moment we need more of it. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Kay Burley
@KayBurley
Josh went to the LSE with my son.
Challenge his views by all means, but demanding his imprisonment while sneering at his Yoruba name because your spellchecker doesn’t recognise it?
The ignorance is staggering and the hypocrisy even more so.
Your dictionary isn’t the problem here, pet.
Lucy White
@lucyjaynewhite1
Babarinde should be imprisoned for his genocidal language.
The name Babarinde gives me a migraine. When I type it, a squiggly red line appears beneath because it is not even recognised by our dictionary.
Josh Babarinde OBE MP 🏴🇬🇧
@JoshBabarinde
🏴 You don’t have to be White to be English
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Davey
@EdwardJDavey
Being English is not defined by skin colour.
But the census says the only English ethnicity is "White English". Josh Babarinde has proposed a law to change that.
The colour of someone's skin should never determine whether they belong here or how far they can go. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Josh Babarinde OBE MP 🏴🇬🇧
@JoshBabarinde
🏴 You don’t have to be White to be English.
Most of the country agrees.
My cross-party St. George’s Bill reaffirms and reinforces Englishness. It doesn’t redefine it.
GB News
@GBNEWS
MPs push to redefine Englishness with 'Black English' and 'Asian English' Census shake-up
www.gbnews.com/politics/politics-news-mps-redefine-englis… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Time for me to remind people that I once solved this problem @instituteforgov #reshuffle www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/publication/how-to-appo…. If only @andyburnham read my work!
John Rentoul
@JohnRentoul
I thought Andy Burnham promoting Miatta Fahnbulleh to Desnz was all part of the plan, but @PickardJE... www.ft.com/content/1c3e9030-51e6-49f2-8203-2e7a53f710c8?s…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That just isn’t true. From memory all of @sainsburys @Tesco @asda @Morrisons returned their Covid rate support payments from govt. They are all PLCs. (I recollect neither Co-op or @waitrose did so). Life is not as simple as you suggest.
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Most taxi drivers will refuse to take a penny from you if you're going to Great Ormond St Hospital.
Imagine if London Taxis were run by a PLC. The CEO would be duty-bound to put the impact of shareholders first. There'd be none of this kindness.
Alan
@A1an_M
London cabbies lined up on Westminster bridge ready to take veterans home, free of charge, from the Remembrance Sunday service in Whitehall. 👏👏👏
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Any British pollster want to ask the same? Calling @racheljanetwolf @KellyIpsosUK @LukeTryl very interesting, and comparative would be more so.
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
Really interesting (and worrying) polling on French pensions
The electorate estimates that for every pensioner we have 6 workers.
In reality it's 1.8/1... Even in 1960s we weren't close to 6/1.
Melenchon's supporters think its 13/1. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am very liberal, but my liberalism stops well short of saying that a bigamist can import a second wife!!
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
We're a very liberal city. (this does seem a bit much though).
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
UK man abandons wife, marries women in Thailand. Wife finds out, bigamist arrested, found guilty. Remarkably, @ukhomeoffice [@JoWhiteSays] has given his wife a visa, and they now live in Leeds! Really? Really? I mean... www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/bigamist-thai-wedding-i…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Alexander
@DanAlexander21
1/ I'll explain exactly how this happened because I'm the person at Forbes who calculates these numbers.
This is going to take some unraveling, but here's a spoiler: The president's answer here is nonsense.
60 Minutes
@60Minutes
Ross Douthat asks the President how his net worth rose by nearly $3 billion, according to a Forbes estimate, since he returned to office.
Watch the interview Sunday at 7 p.m. ET/PT on 60 Minutes. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my free to read substack looks at how the government could usefully strengthen consumer protection laws when people are sold shoddy goods, like these @clarksshoes. timleunig.substack.com/p/the-law-on-faulty-goods
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dr Anton Howes
@antonhowes
Fun fact: only 30 to 40 tons of graphite for pencils was enough to meet all European demand for the stuff for a good few years in the early 1700s, so the graphite mine at Keswick was only worked every 7 years, under lock and guard the rest of the time to keep up the price.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Calling everyone who cares about education in Western Australia: now is the time to make @doug_lemov a job offer!
Doug Lemov
@Doug_Lemov
It’s early…I’ve been here six hours…but running along the water at golden hour in Perth was pretty perfect. What a beautiful city. Now accepting job offers in WA. 😳😂
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
Yes - I think there many aspects where the Living Wage calculator massively overstates cost of living. Kevin has identified some important ones here - esp use of average expenditure to infer the “living wage” baseline
Kevin A. Bryan
@Afinetheorem
Re: Harvard grad wages, the MIT Living Wage calculator is so bad. We really need some economists to try to do this seriously. For example, say you live in Boston, where the "living wage" for a single person w/ no kids is 70k(!) and w/ 1 kid is 138k(!?). A short thread. 1/5
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Rosamund Urwin
@RosamundUrwin
He’s not the Messiah…
My long read on a now seven year investigation into Russell Brand. Please share!
www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/russell-brand-j7pkfslbf -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In three year KS4 schools, kids drop a lot of subjects a year earlier and get a less broad and balanced curriculum. That is what I think is being ruled out, and rightly so, I think.
Pritesh Raichura
@Mr_Raichura
I think this is a false binary in & a distraction. The distinction between ‘KS3’ and ‘GCSE’ content is pretty arbitrary. For example 1/
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
How @LibPeck & co halved knife crime in London. Good reporting from @RKWinvisibleman @FT [fao - @Tom_EYV]
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A lovely tribute - lest we forget - www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6d7qwr12eg4o
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well, you could join me for a cup of tea in the @UKHouseofLords! That said, our average age might be lower...
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
Unrelated, but Paul LePage is 78. He's ancient to be a first-termer in Congress.
It's so weird to me that these very old people want to spend their final years in DC, as opposed to peaceful retirement with their families. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We found this looking at nineteenth century Swedish cigar workers. Gender neutral piece rates did not mean gender neutral hourly wages because of differences in experience. @LuEconHist share.google/TjUUGuoExAF7szFAE
John A. List
@Econ_4_Everyone
I’m hearing lots of rumblings about gender-blind algorithms.
Careful what you ask for. Uber pays drivers identically per ride, and men still earn 7% more — because the algorithm rewards experience, driving location/hours, and speed, all of which differ by gender. See our recent work: ideas.repec.org/p/feb/natura/00634.html
Gender-blind ≠ gender-neutral. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
This is a city that voted to expand its airport, and national powers blocked it.
This is a city that voted to build substantially on its greenbelt, and national power blocked it.
I back our city to back growth. The enemy of growth has been central government and national power. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I hope people take @DanNeidle up on this.
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Everyone says Russell Brand silenced his victims for years with legal threats.
Let's see those threats.
Lawyers will keep silencing victims and journalists in the shadows until we expose what they're doing. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
About 50, from memory. I bet more stairs are walked up and down at Surbiton per day! More generally, we have much lower standards and expectations at rail stations than tube stations, for no obvious reason.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Does Surbiton station have 100 steps between the platforms and the entrance?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
On Thursday I wrote about the 2014 injunction Russell Brand obtained against a woman who accused him of assault.
I've now obtained the final order. It's breathtaking.
She had no lawyer. No trial. Yet she was silenced for life - even barred from speaking to the police.
🧵: -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Surbiton station is a lot busier than this and we have never had an escalator!!
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
How is it that a Zone 2 tube station that has 7000+ embarking passengers a day can be without an escalator for three months? It’s been like this since September. This is the sort of neglect that a fare freeze leads to.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Strickland
@SamStrickers181
This is back to the old days where outstanding was all about how something felt. If you can’t quantify what a grade constitutes then something is very wrong and this leads to interpretation and inconsistency.
Tes magazine
@tes
Ofsted’s top grade – ‘exceptional’ – is not something it can ‘simply define’, a senior HMI tells teacher-training providers
www.tes.com/magazine/news/general/ofsted-exceptional-grad… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sure, but there is still a lot of conventional teaching in primary schools
johnmoorcraft
@moorcraftjohn
I have an 8yr old so TTRockStars is something that’s been and gone here now she knows them. It is a good platform. My issue I suppose is how a lot of teaching these days has been devolved to apps. I don’t think it’s overthinking to raise a question asking if that’s really the best way. Is technology always progress. I don’t know. Folks should ask though surely!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes you should have a proper exam, because you have some intellectual pride. You should also award marks for attending class.
Pontus Rendahl
@pontus_rendahl
Ok, so the students go full AI on my take home exam on an elective course. It's a completely pointless exercise, and everyone - even those not attending the lectures - will get top marks. A student told me yesterday that all his friends only pick electives with take-homes, don't go to lectures, and ace the exam with AI.
So the question is: should I make it a written sit-in, risking that the course will close down (must have a certain # of students for it to run), or keep everyone happy with a take home?
I'd say about 30% of participants take the course seriously regardless, and learn (and appreciate the course) a lot. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Neil O'Brien
@NeilDotObrien
Next year will be 1,400 years since one of the best SpAd interventions of all time:
aclerkofoxford.blogspot.com/2012/05/venerable-bede-and-bl… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Now I have heard it all. Am MP complaining that kids are spending too much if their own time, out of choice, learning maths!! @TTRockStars is epic!
BBC News (UK)
@BBCNews
Children spending too long on maths app TT Rockstars, MP warns www.bbc.com/news/articles/c64g1vyxq4j5o
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tim Shipman
@ShippersUnbound
I’ve worked with some fantastic journalists in my 29 years on the job. My pride at @Gabriel_Pogrund knows no bounds for example. But what @RosamundUrwin had to go through to get the Brand allegations past the lawyers and over the line is of a different order from anything I’ve ever achieved in this job. She is brave, principled, a great reporter, a beautiful writer and a gutsy human being. I am frankly proud to know her let alone call her a friend. The KC who lost his rag earlier should rot in hell
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sometimes politicians ask civil servants to do things that are ill thought through and cannot work. They then blame the civil service when they don’t. I imagine this is a good example
Tom Jones
@93vintagejones
Scoop: Civil Servants at the DHSC & NHSE had an all-staff call on the abolition of NHS England. Safe to say they aren't enthused...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Thanks for raising this, @DanNeidle. It is offensive in the extreme. I hope she gets justice.
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Now Russell Brand's been convicted of rape, we need to talk about Sylvie Berki. Because she can't speak for herself.
In 2014, Ms Berki said she'd been assaulted by Russell Brand.
But if she talks about it, even now, she risks jail. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Just returning from @berlinairport . What a hassle. Only three non EU passport gates open. Police had to intervene when people who would miss their flight tried to push in. Lots of shouting, looked like a fight at one point... 1/2
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Now sitting on @British_Airways flight 985 at @HeathrowAirport 5. The jetway is broken and the airport does not have enough staff to push the steps the few feet to our plane. The pilot says that there are many jetways broken, and it could be some time. Hopeless. @_NigelMilton
-
Tim Leunig reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
I'm always stunned by the quantity of money in US politics
Per my estimates: Elon Musk’s PAC donations in one US election cycle alone roughly equal all the money that the 61 French presidential candidates have spent across all presidential elections in the 21st century -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Genuinely interesting from @JDVance
JD Vance
@JDVance
One of the things the data analysts on our side obsessed over was "composition"—whether the electorate looked close enough to 2024 for Republicans to win. And despite polls that showed a Democrat blowout, the data kept on telling us the same story: in some states turnout was merely OK, in other states it was downright amazing, and in no state was it catastrophic. There was a genuine sense of optimism on our team: our people were showing up.
So, I asked the smartest data guy I know, does that mean we're going to shock the world? "No," he told me. "We might do better than the polls suggest. But the data is telling us that a lot of Trump/Vance 2024 voters are pissed and planning to vote for the other guys. Our voters are turning out, but they may not vote for us."
Well, that looks prophetic now. Our voters did show up. In Florida, for example, the electorate was 9 points more Republican than Democrat, just a couple points worse than 2024. Undoubtedly there were places we could have done better on turnout. But the main problem is not turnout. The main problem is that many people who voted for Trump/Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026.
There will be a lot of infighting and arguing over what happened and why that is. One of the pollsters I really respect told me that our economic messaging wasn’t sharp enough down the stretch. I’m sure that’s true.
But the real reason we lost is obvious to almost everyone.
Another pollster—one of the smartest people I know in politics, told me yesterday we’d lose the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt negative going into Tuesday, but even I was shocked by this. In his polling, he saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote for Democrats. He asked those voters who had abandoned us what would cause them to come back on our team. The top four answers, accounting for nearly all of the responses were:
1) End the war
2) Focus on cost of living/inflation
3) Put America First
4) Change our relationship to Israel
Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats. This is according to a pollster who nailed the results. While many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict, it turns out her political advice was sound. (She’s also a great person.)
In the next few months, there's going to be a lot of gaslighting. Expect to hear any number of establishment politicians say the solution to our woes is amnesty. I'm open to the idea that we should change enforcement—by focusing more on businesses that hire illegal labor, for instance. But anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you.
The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night.
If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest.
But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there.
I remain hopeful about our country. To the people who are pissed off and want to say, “I told you so”: you’re right, you did tell us so. Take that energy into electing Republicans who share your worldview. To the people who are just pissed at the results, you should be. Let’s take that anger and get back to the work of saving our country. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Absolutely brilliant set of tweets from @SCP_Hughes on how to make a brilliant city, architecturally. Read it and you will learn something.
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
How can we make lovable cities? If you had asked a European architect this question in 1900, they would probably have referred you to a slender, lively book by the Austrian writer Camillo Sitte, translated as ‘The Art of Building Cities’. Published in 1889, ‘The Art of Building Cities’ swiftly came to be revered around the world.
worksinprogress.co/issue/the-forgotten-formula-for-lovabl…
Sitte was repudiated by the modernists and fell into obscurity, but his ideas are beginning to be revived. My cousin @PMArslanagic and I have distilled nineteenth century's finest work on urbanism into five principles:
- Create enclosed spaces
- Keep squares small
- Symmetry is overrated
- Move monuments to the edges of spaces
- Nestle monuments in vernacular fabric -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
So glad to read the paper which basically validates the Forest City model! Purchase at agri prices, work at scale.
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
The plan as it was in 2017 and as it is now. From 1 million homes and 1.1 million jobs to a much smaller development around Cambridge.
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
New post:
We have a guest post from John Kingman + Shriti Vadera on Britain's biggest near-term economic opportunity:
Getting the Ox-Cam Arc back up + running.
They show how it can pay for itself and what it needed to make it happen.
(Free to read)
samf.substack.com/p/the-lost-arc?r=72szy&showWelcomeOnSha… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
This is also a tacit acknowledgement that pension freedoms is rather too free for the governments’ long term liking. Near term the drawdown has been a boom for tax receipts, and the lump sum for consumption. But at £91bn/year (more than doubling in three years!) - and likely to smash through £100bn this year - it throws up some moral hazard of rapid early-retirement divestment, and reliance on means tested transfers later in life. Speculation that this policy (including the tax free lump sum) will change has amplified this pace of drawdown.
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
When is an annuity, not an annuity? When it is “using collective assets to buy higher yielding assets”. Will be fascinating to see the regulatory model behind this one.
Torsten Bell
@TorstenBell
NEW: We are going to resurrect genuine pensions for millions of private sector workers
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The EU allowing in British seed potatoes is very good news. Before Brexit the UK was the main source for European potato growers; we have real strength in this area. So this looks like a win-win. #onceworkedatdefra
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The government is changing the mechanics of self-employed taxation. It could be a fiasco - I set out a better way - timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-tax-the-self-employed (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Ireland will build 40,000 homes this year. At the same rate relative to population England would build 431,000 this year. Anyone claiming 300,000 is a stretch target needs to get a £14.57 @Ryanair flight to Ireland... www.ft.com/content/637d66c0-0b2d-48b2-9d17-f2f5edb86971?s…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Parisian style non-tower block height flats are a viable route to density as well, as Paris shows.
John McTernan
@Johnmcternan
No tower blocks will be built with the BSR in its current form. Without flats you get neither density nor numbers.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
Demanding economic growth has become unfashionable among some people in Europe.
Instead they speak of a “cost of living crisis”.
But it’s really one and the same.
Economic growth means that incomes rise relative to prices.
Economic growth means that the things we need become more affordable. -
Tim Leunig reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
Remarkable archive where a young Macron denounces the older generations for leaving them such a huge public debt
7 years later he became the President who ultimately contributed the most to increasing that debt...
And in large part to pay for pensions!
fblr
@SakumiBLR
En plein classement d'archives à la maison je retrouve un exemplaire du journal des anciens de Sc. Po.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Politics Unleashed
@unleashpolitics
“I regard most of the problems in this country as being laid at the door of Jeremy Hunt.”
Ex-BoE deputy Howard Davies says Hunt’s “unfundable” NI cuts trapped Labour, and have boxed in every budget since.
Fair or unfair? #politicsunleashedThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I always push back on degrowthers for exactly this reason. Economic growth is so useful in so many ways.
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Growth matters, material wealth matters, GDP matters. Not just for material prosperity, but also for everything else. Push back on degrowthers when they want to deny this.
Tony Morley
@tonymmorley
"Line go up" is the pejorative that saved a billion lives and enriched billions more. It's not simply correlation; it's causation. This is the graph the degrowthers want you to ignore.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Where the words “partner content” mean advert in all but name…
PoliticsHome
@politicshome
The Warm Homes Plan can cut emissions without forcing every household down the same path.
Calor argues that ministers should back solutions that work for Britain’s diverse rural homes – including renewable liquid gases and hybrid heating.
Partner content -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have known @LiamHalligan for 34 years. We don’t agree on everything by any means. But I respect him as a fine economist who writes well, and I am sorry that @Telegraph have fired him.
Liam Halligan
@LiamHalligan
I was hoping to be able to announce this in my own time – but the media rumour mill is swirling, I'm being contacted by various reporters and others, and I don't like denying the truth, so ...
I wrote my first "Economic Agenda" column in The Sunday Telegraph 27 years ago, under the editorship of Dominic Lawson – filling-in occasionally during the late-1990s, before being given my own weekly slot from 2003.
Since then, while I've been heavily involved in television, and am perhaps better known as a broadcaster, penning "Economic Agenda" for The Sunday Telegraph each week has been the backbone of my journalistic life.
On Thursday, the @Telegraph rang to tell me my column is being scrapped.
I was asked, and have agreed, to write "Economic Agenda" until the end of November, as per my contract. After that, my Sunday Telegraph column will be no more.
Why this decision has been made, and whether or not my columns were any good, is for others to judge.
All I will say is that, as the first person in my family to attend university, sustaining a weekly column in a leading national newspaper for a quarter of a century has been a source of enormous pride for myself and my family.
Lots of people have been asking me about the future of "Planet Normal" - the hugely-popular Telegraph podcast which I co-created and co-present with the brilliant @AllisonPearson
"Planet Normal" has, over the last 330 weekly episodes, also become a major part of my professional life and my broader identity.
With Allison reportedly leaving the Telegraph as well, there is a lot of speculation about whether or not the podcast will continue to impart "news and views from beyond the bubble" with our usual blend of sharp analysis, humour and occasional outrage !
Well, I am delighted to confirm that Co-Pilot Pearson and myself are deeply committed to our joint podcast – and, above all, to our beloved listeners.
We will, as and when notice periods allow, continue our voyages through space every Thursday – perhaps to "Planet Normal", or maybe to another part of the solar system – so we can "gaze down each week at the madness of Planet Earth", as we have done since the Spring of 2020.
So citizens of Planet Normal, stand ready ! The "rocket-of-right-thinking", the "flying refuge of reasoned views", will soon be launched once again 🚀🪐👨🏭👱♀️🎙️📺
I poured my heart and soul into "Economic Agenda" and "Planet Normal". The Telegraph's decision to scrap them is obviously a huge personal blow. But I will always be grateful for the opportunities the paper has given me.
Above all, I would like to thank the illustrious list of successive Telegraph business editors I've worked with since the late-1990s, many of whom have become and remain good friends - including @Peston @RobertsDan @larmitstead @neilbenet @benjaminmarlow @cg_williams @kamalahmednews @MarkKleinmanSky @jamesrquinn (sorry if I've forgotten anyone, it's been a long time!)
On Friday, even though I almost always write my column from elsewhere, and despite being extremely disappointed by the paper's decision, I decided to go into the Telegraph and write today's column sitting in the newsroom.
I am glad I did - as being at the heart of the paper at such a difficult time allowed for lots of conversations, with everyone from junior production staff to senior reporters and executives, which reminded me that journalism, despite being an industry at the whim of seemingly endless and often brutal commercial and technological upheaval, is not only hugely important to our country, but full of talented, decent people.
See picture below, having just filed my piece, as I was heading out the door ... -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Although I agree that the word investment often just means spending, most of education is investment in the sense that it offers a decent return on investment for the government.
Joe Hill
@jo3hill
The concept of “investment” has been completely stripped of all meaning. It is now just a policy meme that helps people avoid confronting difficult tradeoffs.
Welfare, health and public service spending are not investments in any meaningful sense, they do not accrue anything like financial returns with the exception of some narrow genuine ‘spend to save’ cases, and physical infrastructure investments of the categories where the benefits are so diffuse the State is the only practical backer.
But now ever call for more day to day spending by the Treasury is dressed up in these terms, borrowed from finance, with no real reference to what they actually mean.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
In the 1930s, you could get planning permission to build a block of 12 flats in 3 weeks (and a 3 page application).
It is sensible to use AI to speed up over-complex processes, but it is no substitute for fixing the process.
Cabinet Office
@cabinetofficeuk
Nearly 70% of planning applications are for everyday home improvements.
By cutting paperwork and admin with AI tool PlanAssist, we're aiming to slash processing times from 8 weeks down to 4.
Less bureaucracy, faster answers for families, and getting Britain building 🏠 🇬🇧This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
George Eaton
@georgeeaton
The university crisis is one of the most ignored issues in British politics and was barely mentioned this week.
This is essential from @gsoh31 for @ArguablyMag on how underfunding, marketisation and managerial incompetence created an avoidable disaster – and how it can be fixed. www.arguably.uk/p/how-to-save-britains-universities -
Tim Leunig reposted
Iwan Doherty
@IwanDoherty98
It's quite funny that while the UK government does share a great deal of blame for our productivity crisis arguably our own business leadership is equally, if not more, at fault because of their anti-investment, short termist approach
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If you care about the natural environment, donate money to @boyanslat @TheOceanCleanup. They are outstanding.
Boyan Slat
@BoyanSlat
The Ocean Cleanup is now $40M/year short of what’s needed to stop up to 1/3rd of all plastic flowing into the oceans by 2030.
That’s less than 1% of what America spends on Halloween decorations each year. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My new @UKHouseofLords shoes have broken after 11 wears - very disappointing from @clarksshoes. And they won't give me a new pair unless I can prove the exact day I bought them... Hopeless.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But the @marksandspencer suit is doing fine!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Turns out we can improve growth and the cost of living in one go! Delighted to have worked with the excellent @BritishProgress @dc_lawrence and @robblackie to show the importance of getting more houses built, particularly in London
David Lawrence
@dc_lawrence
What if the best way to reduce the cost of living also turned out to be the best way to boost growth?
In a new paper for @BritishProgress, @timleunig, @robblackie & I find that the Government hitting its housebuilding targets would *reduce rents by £251 a month* in London, within 5 years.
This is a far greater saving for ordinary households than any cost of living measure announced in the Budget.
And the best part? We can do this for free. By streamlining planning restrictions, improving building safety rules and empowering residents, we could hit and exceed Labour's housing targets.
BUT as things stand, the Government's housing targets are not on track, and so households across the UK will not feel this benefit. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If @JohnHealey_MP & @andyburnham want to cut the welfare bill without harming people, they should insist London builds the number of houses they say it needs. That would lower rents and the benefit bill, and mean less homelessness. Me in the @FT www.ft.com/content/00308644-7de4-4a22-bd27-cbeb3ddd11ca 1/2
Rob Blackie 🔶
@robblackie
This knocks on to government spending. The UK spends £37bn on housing benefits - similar to what we spend on policing and prisons. This is roughly double what France or Germany spend on housing benefits.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My @FT column is a summary of work with @robblackie & @dc_lawrence @BritishProgress. Full report here: 2/2 britishprogress.org/reports/hitting-housebuilding-targets…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written something new on housing! A @BritishProgress report by @robblackie @dc_lawrence and me shows hitting the govts (low) London housing targets would lower rents by £250, compared with otherwise. That is big! 1/2 britishprogress.org/reports/hitting-housebuilding-targets…
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If you don't want to read a whole report, but want more than a tweet, I have written it up as an op-ed in @FT: www.ft.com/content/00308644-7de4-4a22-bd27-cbeb3ddd11ca 2/2
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Interesting to discover in the @UKHouseofLords debate earlier today that the inclusion of Rosebank in the OBR/Budget document does not pre-judge @Miatsf decision. The assumption has been in the forecast for years, apparently.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
12 good reasons to love economic growth - and there are many more!
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
What is life like at different levels of GDP per capita?
In this new chart I visualised it for 12 different dimensions. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I fear @DanNeidle tweet 3 will be proven correct
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Let’s welcome into the world the UK’s new 53% tax rate, for pensioners earning between £12,570 and £13,037:
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Here's the real story of this Budget, the can being kicked down the road. This Labour government is apparently planning spending cuts on most areas of public service spending of 2.6% per year between 2028-29 and 2031-32.
Pull the other one. It's got bells on. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Mindblowing chart from OBR. In 2029 real household disposable income per person expected to be just 1% higher than in 2019. What an unbelievably awful decade. It used to grow by 2%+ every year, not 1% in 10 years.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Absolutely right. Rachel Reeves tried low headroom in her first budget. She found that means if ANYTHING moves against you, the rest of year is about what taxes you will raise. That uncertainty hits consumer and business confidence, slows economic growth and makes us poorer. 1/2
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
He has done small relatively sensible tax rises. Tick. But headroom has fallen to £15 billion which is smaller than the average move between forecasts. So he doesn’t have enough to survive one bad roll of the dice.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What Britain needs, above all, is a relentless focus on growth. I didn't get any sense that this was the Chancellors priority today - and that worries me a lot.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
Struck by the softly populist tone this Budget is taking, smaller measures than some previous budgets so far - but more overtly political. Targeting areas public have little sympathy for (landlords, gambling, banks) in exchange for broader (if not deeper) cost of living relief
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Now pretending petrol duty will rise in July. Was supposed to rise in September. Then January. Who really believes it'll ever happen?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Chancellor increases tax rates on rental and savings income by 2%. These tax changes are very much a continuation of the changes Reeves began. Narrows the gap between taxation on employment and other forms of incomes. Good move.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Helen Miller
@HelenMiller_IFS
Allowing the ‘headroom’ to absorb impact of high debt interest costs is reasonable choice - but not costless. It means more borrowing at a time when borrowing is expensive. Lower headroom means less insurance against future bad news
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Hang on @PJTheEconomist! The population has grown more than a fifth over that period, so per person emissions are down about 40%. Historically unprecedented and hugely impressive.
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
This is the key chart. We target territorial emissions. Down 40% since 1990. Great.
But what actually matters for the climate is our consumption emissions. They take account of carbon "embedded" in imports. Down by only 25%. Much less impressive, much less to shout about. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
Skills statements are making a comeback in England.
This approach to assessment is one of the major differences between a knowledge-based and a skills-based curriculum.
It’s a clear sign that the current government are unpicking the successful education reforms of the last 15 years.
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/why-are-we-making-these-mist… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
All high fixed cost operators will aim for very high occupancy. What you need to judge economic buoyancy is the revenue yield per room over time. (Btw I prefer @Butlins)
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
This week's Blighty newsletter is about What I Did On My Holidays
Center Parcs is a runaway success (97.4% occupancy rate!)
This is a sign that many Brits are not too badly scathed by the cost of living...
@TheEconomist subscribers can sign up here: www.economist.com/newsletters/blighty -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
New carers allowance is an improvement for sure, but it is depressing that the government has consciously decided that a 100% tax rate is a good idea.
Paul Lewis
@paullewismoney
Burnham announces a 100% tax rate on carers who work and earn over the limit allowed. Better than the current rule but worse than the 55% tax when people on UC work and higher than the highest marginal rate on high earners (except loss of child care help at £100,000).
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
@SW_Help: why do you keep lying to customers? At 2015 your Waterloo info board said the 2023 to Alton was the fastest train to Surbiton. At 2026 you say “no driver”, so the 2020 would have been faster. Why not tell us that at 2015?
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Then at 2031 you cancelled the service. Some us made the 2033, others are stuck on the 2036 slow train.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is the second time in the last week you have done this to me. Please explain whether it is malice or incompetence on your part.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I half agree... www.hepi.ac.uk/2024/09/26/undergraduate-fees-revisited/
Anna Clarke
@AnnaClarke_____
No point increasing the interest rate for people who've failed to pay it off by middle age - you'd just end up writing a larger debt off a few years later. Better proposal would be to keep people paying until state pension age.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I once proposed the reverse... If you don't pay back until middle age, interest really increases the amount of money owed... www.hepi.ac.uk/2024/09/26/undergraduate-fees-revisited/
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
I'm absolutely there for a proposal that greatly reduces student loan repayments when you're young,and ramps them up as you get older. Paging @timleunig !
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You want thinking outside the box? This week I have written perhaps my most esoteric policy idea - the case for kangaroos in Britain - timleunig.substack.com/p/i-love-kangaroos (free to read)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Hear hear!!
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Your annual reminder of how crap it is that our evenings are about to get plunged into darkness an hour earlier for the winter. It costs us more in energy bills and heightens seasonal blues. Let's keep GMT+1 all year.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Arguing that the private sector is what drives growth isn't a matter of ideology. It's a matter of maths. As beautifully illustrated by this story in the Mirror today. (1/?)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A fine piece of writing by @KuperSimon, on how to understand France at the moment - www.ft.com/content/62b83fcf-efad-418d-ba6a-569344fa7ecb
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The idea that our PM, and all previously living PMs, could be over 65 is impossible to believe. America is a very different place, in so many ways!
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
Barack Obama is 65 years old. Retirement age. Grey hair.
And yet he's 15 years younger than Donald Trump and 18 years younger than Joe Biden. In fact, of the living people who've served as POTUS, he's the only one not in his 80s! -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
This is somewhere between deeply irresponsible and a lie.
HMRC will be able to "seize money" from people who owe tax, aren't disputing it, but just fail to pay. That's people who cause the rest of us to pay more tax.
Robert Jenrick
@RobertJenrick
Under Labour, HMRC will reach into your bank account and seize your money.
Under Reform, you’ll get a £30 rebate if HMRC leave you stuck on the phone for 30 mins.
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 BREAKING: John Healey will announce at the Budget that HMRC will be given powers to seize money directly from the bank accounts of people who fail to pay their tax
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
$795m??? All I get are threats from @VeoliaUK wrongly claiming I owe them £94.43 and threatening me with a CCJ... (All sorted now)
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
I posted earlier today about Iain Stamp, a conman who was sentenced to 12 months jail and fled to Northern Cyprus.
He's suing me in a Wyoming court for $795m (!), and told the court he lives in the UK.
I just used the stupidest trick ever to find out where he really is. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Pleased to say @VeoliaUK agree that despite this letter being posted to my home, I am not responsible for an unpaid rubbish bill for a Chinese restaurant 75 miles away...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't know the location, and maybe this is a good decision, but anyone would think there was no cost of living crisis...
Cllr Joanna Wright
@clrjoannawright
Planning Application for a Lidl superstore on the London Road, Bath REFUSED
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
True in Spain too. Every landlord in Madrid and Barcelona screens the renters now. This is an obvious consequence of rent control. The most vulnerable, ostensible protected by the legislation, are in fact excluded from the rental market: if you cannot be evicted for non payment, then you are too risky a renter.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
A friend of mine had to do a 15 minute interview about his job, income, previous rental history, etc, in order to *view* a flat. Luckily for him, he has a well-paid job, has lived in England all his life, and an impeccable rental history. I feel bad for people who don't.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Absolutely, but that is historically rare for things like cotton mills to gradually shrink - they tend to go bust and bang, a lot of people lose their jobs on one day. Different in sectors characterised by small firms and self-employment.
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
Agree that geog concentration matters - but adjustment entirely through entrants also makes that less socially costly because it’s easier for young people at the start of their careers to move (not cost less! But easier)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
The collapse in violent crime over three decades has been one of the most striking developments of my lifetime.
News is about what’s going wrong, and rightly so. But the bigger picture also matters
From today’s figures:- -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tera Allas CBE | @teraallas.bsky.social
@TeraPauliina
Do we need sovereign AI? That’s the wrong question.
How much should we be willing to pay for what type of sovereignty, at which layers of the AI stack, and for which use cases? This is what we should be debating.
A longer Substack this time—read it here: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Chris Smyth
@Smyth_Chris
Scale of job losses in universities would be seen as a national crisis in manufacturing. Or any other strategically vital industry
Duncan Robinson
@duncanrobinson
One professor who recently left academia said it felt like being a miner in 1982 and it’s hard to disagree
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
The banks say they’re overtaxed. The TUC says they’re undertaxed.
We did the sums across nine countries, and we're going to annoy *everyone*.
The UK isn’t a high-tax outlier. There *is* a case for increasing bank tax. But it comes with risks - and could hit households.
🧵: -
Tim Leunig reposted
George Eaton
@georgeeaton
The green case for building data centres in the UK:
1. They generate fewer emissions than those elsewhere.
2. Increased demand will help reduce electricity prices by spreading infrastructure and transmission costs. www.arguably.uk/p/is-net-zero-still-affordable -
Tim Leunig reposted
Susan Acland-Hood
@SusanAclandHood
To all those who get up every morning and put children and learners first - social workers, teaching assistants, teachers, headteachers, lecturers, College & Trust leaders, local authority and regional leaders, governors, volunteers, and so many more - thank you. 3/4
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Stian Westlake
@stianwestlake
In terms of economics output per £, fixing @LSEEcon’s coffee machine might be the highest impact grant ESRC could make
Antonio Mele
@antoniomele101
The coffee machine at the 4th floor of @LSEEcon has been broken for months, and our PhD students are sarcasm-bombing it
-
Tim Leunig reposted
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
It's nonsense to suggest the new scheme of delegation removes residents' voices from planning.
The opportunity to influence where development happens is the Local Plan. After that, people should be able to get on and build without further interference.
richmond.nub.news/news/local-news/residents-face-losing-t… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Good thread from @BodilUK
Bodil Isaksen
@BodilUK
I found the Children's Commissioner's Childhood Lottery a frustrating read. I have no doubt more children have difficult childhoods in Middlesbrough than Surrey. But excluding obvious confounding factors and selecting on dependent variables is not a good way to make that case.🧵
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
Theoretically, stuff like this is *such* an easy fix in the UK. The Labour Party holds >400 seats in the Commons. They could pass it virtually without effort.
But there's just no interest in a serious, pragmatic rewrite of the tax code.
Alan Smith
@AlanJLSmith
Marginal tax rate of 2,000% 🤯
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I really don’t think that is true. Jackdaw reduces energy used in transporting and compressing gas. Neither, I think is true, for Rosebank. So they are different issues.
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Great point from @StigAbell & @Steven_Swinford on @TimesRadio just now - if you accept the logic for Jackdaw (as you should) there is no reason why exactly the same logic doesn’t apply to Rosebank, or indeed to drilling new fields rather than exploiting old ones.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
BBC Breakfast
@BBCBreakfast
'This won't bring the down the price of gas but it will replace some of the gas we are shipping from other parts of the world'
Greg Jackson from Octopus Energy spoke to #bbcbreakfast after the UK government approved extraction from the Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea -
Tim Leunig reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
When do people experience mental health conditions for the first time?
— The key chart from Hannah Ritchie's new @OurWorldInData article: ourworldindata.org/when-do-people-experience-mental-healt… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
The complacency from the @ukhomeoffice is staggering here. This issue has displaced even financial sustainability as the first thing senior university leaders want to talk about. Something has changed inside the Home Office even if they still deny it.
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/student-visas-ukv… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben James
@BenJames_____
10 Downing Street is recruiting a Director of AI in the No10 Policy Unit, where I work. They will advise the Prime Minister on AI.
This is an important role for the UK! -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This morning @ChrisGiles_ has cheered me up no end with this well-researched and well-argued piece about the future of European gas prices. www.ft.com/content/31df1d21-159c-4c24-be0a-566c00c2d100?s… #reasonstobecheerful
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes! But the best approach is air con that becomes a heater in winter. An energy efficient investment that pays off year round, for the individual and society.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
And ice storage air conditioning, which is at least theoretically possible – not sure how much, if at all, it is used in practice right now, but real time electricity pricing would of course hugely incentivise it.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Good news. Rearranging property rights is exactly what a government should do when existing allocations don’t work well.
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: Andy Burnham has announced changes to car parking fines
- Drivers will have a 5-minute grace period to decide whether to park and 10 minutes to leave after a parking session ends
- A £20 maximum charge on appeal for minor mistakes, such as entering the wrong number plate or not displaying a permit
- Charges will also be cancelled on appeal for breakdowns, medical emergencies or broken ticket machines
- The £100 cap on charges will remain
- The rules will come into force as soon as possible and operators that break them will lose access to DVLA data -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Alberta votes 3:1 to stay part of Canada! What interests me is the low proportion who voted either way on all the other questions - www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/cqy7ln0383pnt
-
Tim Leunig reposted
JerryRigEverything
@ZacksJerryRig
Contender for the best tweet of 2026.
F. Andy Seidl
@faseidl
Ukraine is moving Russian data to the cloud.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Davey
@EdwardJDavey
I am ruling out our party entering into a national partnership with any party that is committed to a dangerous and antisemitic policy like the Green Party’s.
Here is my letter to the Jewish Leadership Council and the Board of Deputies of British Jews 👇 -
Tim Leunig reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
This is what the French parliament looked like after May 1968
One of the most conservative in history -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
My son’s street in Paris. How this improves anything I do not know #mindlessviolence
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Congratulations to both @ClaireCoutinho and @ahawksbee !
Claire Coutinho
@ClaireCoutinho
Delighted to say that Jacob Hawksbee has arrived safely and soundly and everyone is doing well 🥰
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
A nation almost entirely united on this one with *100%* of over 75s saying it’s not ok to play music out loud on a train.
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: The Government has announced headphone dodgers on trains will face fines of up to £1,000 as a nationwide campaign launches today
-
Tim Leunig reposted
David Sheppard
@OilSheppard
Not-so-subtle signalling from the Lib Dem press office ahead of Daisy Cooper’s speech this morning.
Gail’s comfortably winning with the feral lobby hacks, though Gregg’s handicapped in the pastry-off by a lack of sausage rolls -
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
Which? magazine urges people to stop using booking.com on the grounds they are hopeless at detecting scams on their site. Quite right too. Use booking.com at your peril.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Also recommend @rgloveroz "How to ruin a child" although I think it is only published in Australia - www.richardglover.com.au
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Rob Biddulph, Secrets of Happy Children is excellent, as is his Raising boys. Both very cheap from bookfinder.com
Davide
@kingdavec
What other books would you suggest parents read? Esp those with children of primary age.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Very interesting from @ukfuturehealth. It looks to me as though the relatively high price of alcohol is reducing consumption, at least for poorer people.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Link to the (short) report here: links02.ourfuturehealth.org.uk/s/vb/0-MH7NM-ySP5W5t5v-NjV…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Rob Biddulph, Secrets of Happy Children is excellent, as is his Raising boys. Both very cheap from bookfinder.com
Davide
@kingdavec
What other books would you suggest parents read? Esp those with children of primary age.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
From the “economists would do better fighting termites than monopolies” school of thought?
Ryan Bourne
@MrRBourne
When I first left university, I thought competition policy was a vital role for the state. Now I've seen what real world competition regulators do, I think we'd be better off scrapping them.
Matthew Lesh
@matthewlesh
In a blast from the past, Britain’s competition regulator has proposed designating Microsoft’s business software, including Windows, Word, Excel, Outlook and Teams, as having “strategic market status.”
It's like 1998 all over again, except this time the CMA is proposing to regulate a single company precisely in the part of the economy where competition has never been stronger: AI. These kinds of fiddly regulatory interventions are bound to scare away investment and turn the entire scheme into a laughing stock.
SMS status lets the CMA impose bespoke conduct requirements on how Microsoft designs, bundles and sells its products. This gives the regulator broad discretion to direct how software used by more than a million UK organisations is allowed to operate.
The CMA's complaint is that the products are integrated, something CMA-commissioned research found businesses see as a “key benefit” and “relatively good value for money” and “more cost-effective than buying and managing separate licences.” Put plainly, people keep using Microsoft because the products work well together and they’re good value. This is very far from a market failure that requires intervention. It’s also a sector facing immense disruption in the era of AI-led software development.
What's particularly mad is that Copilot is in scope too, even though ChatGPT has more than 1 billion weekly users, Gemini has more than 1 billion monthly users, and in UK workplaces, only about one in ten Microsoft Office users use Copilot. Gemini, Claude and ChatGPT together already have roughly as many workplace users as Copilot, after just two or three years. Just a year ago, the CMA kept Gemini out of Google’s designation because AI was moving too fast to call.
The CMA’s legal test is meant to ask whether Microsoft’s position will be entrenched over the next five years. Five years ago, ChatGPT didn’t exist. Anyone confident about who will lead workplace AI in 2031 should be running a hedge fund, not a regulator.
What's also interesting is that, despite the promises made when this regime was created, this regulation isn’t even well-targeted. The CMA’s real concern, from its cloud market investigation, was meant to be Microsoft’s cloud software licensing. Instead of targeting this issue directly, the CMA has opted for the widest possible net: five separate markets bundled into one ecosystem. The result is that nothing will be done till at least February 2027, and even then, conduct requirements aren't yet specified, which will require further consultations, delaying action well into 2027.
Britain wants to be the best place in the world to build and adopt AI. Preemptively regulating the AI tools businesses are only just starting to use is a strange way to get there. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The previous organisation, MyCSP, was also terrible.
Andrew Duncan
@andrewsduncan1
Why do the government keep giving them new contracts when they cannot handle the existing ones.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Lewis
@paullewismoney
Emails about Capita's scandalous mismanagement of the civil service and teachers pension schemes keep arriving @Moneybox Today we hear from the @NAOorguk about its new enquiry into the scandal with @bbcdanw and NAO's Lee Summerfield, noon @BBCRadio4
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
We don’t use Starlink for our responses inside Russia. We use Starlink to intercept jet-powered “shaheds” that attack our civilians and kill families.
Starlink wasn’t turned off – its speed was reduced. And when the speed was reduced, we were unable to intercept a certain number of jet-powered “shaheds.” We couldn’t use a tool that helps protect people. That’s very painful and frustrating.
We also use Starlink for mid-range strikes against enemy military targets in our temporarily occupied territories. We couldn’t do that when the restrictions were in place. And third, what matters most is people. Our warriors, who spend weeks and months on the front line, receive food and water delivered by drones using Starlink.
Has the speed been fully restored to what it was before? No. Is it being restored now? Yes.
From a conversation with media representatives in Brussels. (2/3) -
Tim Leunig reposted
Senator Thom Tillis
@SenThomTillis
Beyond irresponsible. What part of enforcing a law passed 86-11 by the Senate does the President and his advisors not understand? It’s unconscionable that this administration is capitulating to a Russian dictator who illegally invaded Ukraine and butchers innocent civilians every single day. If the President wants to actually bring down energy prices, he can do it by solving the Iran problem, not by doing a solid for Vladimir Putin.
apnews.com/article/russia-sanctions-trump-ukraine-e50c561… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The address on the envelope was mine...
Kate P
@katesineed
Loads of misdelivered post the past 2 weeks. Our workplace received multiple letters for addresses that aren't even close by nor the same town. And in two cases not even the UK, but the USA and France... 🤷🏼♀️ "Silent protests by staff?" @PostOffice
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ali
@AliKh1886
A certain Rachel asked Nobel laureate Paul Krugman a question at Oxford last night, casually noting the IMF’s praise for UK deficit and debt reduction and the productivity puzzle being revised away. All during her time as Chancellor, as it happens. Laughter and applause.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Lewis
@paullewismoney
Is now the time to convert your pension fund into an income for life - an annuity? £100,000 pension fund will buy a healthy 65 year old >£8k a year, double what it would 10 years ago and highest for 18 years. With @BillyBurrows on @Moneybox noon @BBCRadio4
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
How does this even make sense on its own terms? We use Google Workspace and Slack for all this stuff, like tons of other businesses. Switching and multi-homing is easy. There are no barriers to entry.
Matthew Lesh
@matthewlesh
In a blast from the past, Britain’s competition regulator has proposed designating Microsoft’s business software, including Windows, Word, Excel, Outlook and Teams, as having “strategic market status.”
It's like 1998 all over again, except this time the CMA is proposing to regulate a single company precisely in the part of the economy where competition has never been stronger: AI. These kinds of fiddly regulatory interventions are bound to scare away investment and turn the entire scheme into a laughing stock.
SMS status lets the CMA impose bespoke conduct requirements on how Microsoft designs, bundles and sells its products. This gives the regulator broad discretion to direct how software used by more than a million UK organisations is allowed to operate.
The CMA's complaint is that the products are integrated, something CMA-commissioned research found businesses see as a “key benefit” and “relatively good value for money” and “more cost-effective than buying and managing separate licences.” Put plainly, people keep using Microsoft because the products work well together and they’re good value. This is very far from a market failure that requires intervention. It’s also a sector facing immense disruption in the era of AI-led software development.
What's particularly mad is that Copilot is in scope too, even though ChatGPT has more than 1 billion weekly users, Gemini has more than 1 billion monthly users, and in UK workplaces, only about one in ten Microsoft Office users use Copilot. Gemini, Claude and ChatGPT together already have roughly as many workplace users as Copilot, after just two or three years. Just a year ago, the CMA kept Gemini out of Google’s designation because AI was moving too fast to call.
The CMA’s legal test is meant to ask whether Microsoft’s position will be entrenched over the next five years. Five years ago, ChatGPT didn’t exist. Anyone confident about who will lead workplace AI in 2031 should be running a hedge fund, not a regulator.
What's also interesting is that, despite the promises made when this regime was created, this regulation isn’t even well-targeted. The CMA’s real concern, from its cloud market investigation, was meant to be Microsoft’s cloud software licensing. Instead of targeting this issue directly, the CMA has opted for the widest possible net: five separate markets bundled into one ecosystem. The result is that nothing will be done till at least February 2027, and even then, conduct requirements aren't yet specified, which will require further consultations, delaying action well into 2027.
Britain wants to be the best place in the world to build and adopt AI. Preemptively regulating the AI tools businesses are only just starting to use is a strange way to get there. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tim Montgomerie 🇬🇧
@montie
the possibility of a completely inconclusive result at the next elxn where the seats tally provides no basis for a sustainable or coherent policy programme is hugely underpriced. and with lab ruling out deal with greens and tories saying same about reform a non-result (necessitating a second gen elxn) is becoming more and more likely.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
How to pick a school - this is a good read for any parent with a child in year 5 or 6...
Iain Mansfield
@IGMansfield
Baffled by Progress 8? Confused by Ofsted?
With the school application deadline at the end of this month, I set out a detailed guide to the key factors to consider when choosing a secondary school - and how to interpret them.
www.edrith.co.uk/p/how-to-choose-a-secondary-school -
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
Party to celebrate Ian Hislop's 40 years as editor of Private Eye & 65 years at the magazine. Has anyone currently in public life held the same job for longer? The Eye is the greatest journalistic institution of my lifetime. Long may Ian and the Eye reign.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Pence
@Mike_Pence
Putin doesn’t want peace. Putin wants Ukraine. Enough is enough.
President Trump should rescind the diesel deal with Russia and use the Lindsey Graham Sanctioning Russia Act to impose harsh sanctions on nations purchasing Russian energy, work with our allies to ensure Ukraine has the military support it needs to repel and defeat this Russian invasion once and for all. Slava Ukraini🇺🇸🇺🇦
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
Moments ago, Russian forces bombed a residential neighborhood in the Ukrainian city of Kharkiv, hitting a grocery store.
Three people lost their lives, and nine others, including two children, sustained injuries. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Davey
@EdwardJDavey
Every murder by Putin in Ukraine is now sponsored by Donald Trump.
BBC News (World)
@BBCWorld
Trump waives several Russia sanctions as new US law takes effect www.bbc.com/news/articles/cxr5yvzv7rp0o
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The Case Deaton book is very good, if depressing
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
In The Times welfare project, a few findings - when they emerged - took my breath away.
This graph showing surge in Britain’s “deaths of despair” (due to drugs, suicide, alcohol) is one.
Plunging in Europe. Soaring here. Why?
www.times-comment.com/despair -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Just got a threat of a CCJ. Not addressed to anyone by name and I can't see any reason I would ever owe @VeoliaUK any money. Anyone else had one? I rang but they are only open M-F... A scam? An error? Identity fraud?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If you are a new parent, @ProfEmilyOster is 99p today on kindle... www.amazon.co.uk/Cribsheet-Data-Driven-Relaxed-Parenting-…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Gosh! @vnbateman history of women, power and wealth is only 99p on kindle. Absolute steal! www.amazon.co.uk/Economica-Global-History-Women-Wealth-eb…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Anne Applebaum
@anneapplebaum
If Putin stops fighting, the war ends. If Zelensky stops fighting then his country will be occupied, leaders murdered, language banned, businesses stolen, children kidnapped. That's what happens in Russian-occupied Ukraine.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Kuper
@KuperSimon
France under Le Pen, probable 7 months from now: 1. Abandons Ukraine/leaves NATO military command 2. Stays in EU while breaking all its rules 3. Does fantasy economics - more spending, tax cuts, while promising to miraculously cut deficit 4. Goes after French migrants/muslims
Sophie Pedder
@PedderSophie
Le Pen, yesterday:
“France is on the brink of default. Six months after my election we will end financial aid to Ukraine because we no longer have the means
Perhaps other European Union countries, which are in a better financial situation, can take over”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Cool Glamma 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇫🇯🇦🇺☮️
@shalin43031
LOVE IT!!!!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
The biggest, and stupidest, myth in European politics, particularly popular in France, is that Europe suffers the consequences of "austerity" and "neoliberalism". In the biggest 5 countries in Europe, more than half of the population makes its income from the state, less than half from the private sector. This is what makes the problem of reducing the welfare state so impossible: more than half of the voters are net recipients. No surprise that Italy's budget has not been balanced in 100 years, France's in 50 years (ooh la la, l'austérité!!):
-France: 30 million from the state versus 21m private sector workers. State spending is 57% of GDP, taxes more than half the economy. The budget hasn't been balanced in the lifetime of most French (since 1974).
- Germany: 35 million adults from the state, versus 34 million from the private sector. 10% of the population is registered as severely disabled. Public spending is over half of GDP. Germany has had a continuous budget deficit since 2019.
-Italy: 23 million from the state, versus 20.5 million private-sector workers. Public spending is 51% of GDP. Italy has had a budget deficit every year since 1925, for 100 years.
- Spain more people get their income from the state since 2024: 18.21 million from the public sector versus 17.9 million people working in the private sector. Since 2025, Spain also had more government employees than self-employed workers (autónomos) for the first time in history. State spending is at 45%, budget has not been balanced since 2007.
- UK: 54% of households now receive more in state benefits than they pay in taxes. State spending is 44.5% of GDP, taxes (40%) are at their highest since 1950, the budget hasn't been balanced since 2001, and 1 in 5 new cars is paid by the government through a bizarre state disability scheme (Motability). -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It will be remarkable if and only if it happens! Otherwise it is no more impressive than many New Year's Resolutions.
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
When you plot it like this, it's not hard to see why the IMF singled out the UK for its fiscal consolidation plans. The forecasts are predicated on some very questionable spending assumptions, yes, but still: quite remarkable.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A fine piece of analysis of what the school PISA results tell us about immigration (quoting me, among others)
Jacob Reid
@JacobReid02
Some good news! The UK is a rare bright spot for children from immigrant families in the latest global education rankings. But that baffles policymakers...
Ft analysis from @timleunig @PlattLucinda @MigObs in @business
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-09-10/uk-pisa-scores… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Good piece on the strengths and weaknesses of Italian family firms by @silvia_sb_ in @FT - maybe read it over a @BialettiPerks coffee? www.ft.com/content/1eee5ed8-48dd-4c2e-9eba-a407d98b6a38?s…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Ford
@robfordmancs
One oft overlooked problem with the “Burnham should call an early election” narrative is the collapse of Lab in both Scot & Wales. Even with the modest recent poll recovery, Labour certain to lose dozens of seats - and losing almost all their seats outside Eng is a real risk
Devolved Election Projections
@DevolvedVotes
Under our new Westminster model this works out as:
🎗️ SNP — 46 seats
🔶 LD — 5
🌳 Con — 3
🌹 Lab — 3
The SNP are swamping Labour as they did in 2015, 2017 and 2019 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
1 in 65 men die by suicide is a HUGE proportion. Society needs to talk a low more about this (h/t @nickhillman)
louis appleby
@ProfLAppleby
New suicide figures have been published by @ONS: 5,738 suicides were registered for England in 2025.
75% were in men. 1 in 65 men die by suicide.
And in the details: a politically sensitive concern, a small encouragement & an important point no media have mentioned.
Short 🧵 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
We talk about growth coming from the Oxford-Cambridge Arc. But we’ve cancelled the link road, only built half the railway and then refused to run any passenger trains on it and now we’ve shut Oxford to traffic. This is not a serious country if we want to unlock innovation.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Much to be said for clip ons. Not really sure why schools have ties at all, mind...
Yorkshire Steve
@Yorkshire_Steve
My youngrst's school have gone to clip-ons .... not sure how one of those would fit with HoL etiquette!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Political scientists and economists: we're looking for researchers with deep expertise to come work with us for a unique 4-month fellowship at @AnthropicAI. You'll work closely with us to evaluate, improve, and apply Claude's capabilities in your field. It's going to be extremely fun and interesting work, and definitely worth taking a short leave from your university for if you need to!
More info here:
job-boards.greenhouse.io/anthropic/jobs/5447080008 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Lib Dem Peers
@LibDemPeers
Today @timleunig took his oath and joined the Lib Dem team in the Lords.
The economist spent over a decade in the civil service, advising two Chancellors and serving as chief scientific adviser at the Department for Education.
Now that expertise goes to work in the chamber. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Also a great example of UK vs. USA debate.
.
In the USA it's up to states to decide whether they want self-driving taxis and taxes on them so there's competition between CA and TX and no taxis in NY or MA.
.
And in the UK we just have a once size fits all central government ban.
Henry Burke
@burkehenryt
Great example of the CA vs. TX debate: CA fees and taxes (excluding the bridge toll) amount to just $0.27 more than TX. But the fees are listed separately, which makes it look like more despite the overall cost being basically the same. Freakout about CA taxes ensues
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Disagree! 1) I might well get elected as part of a list system. 2) you don't need to be rejected to have influence 1/2
Nicholas Boys Smith
@boys_nicholas
Ironically, as @timleunig supports an elected 2nd chamber, his (v. welcome) elevation to Upper House is a perfect eg of a key strength of an unelected upper house. Namely, you get wise & intellectually free-thinking people who would never 'make it' through a purely elected system
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Off to join the House of Lords!
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
3) Mainly however I think you fall for the old myth that people who are clever in one area have sounds judgement more generally. The evidence against that idea is explained well by @helenlewis in her excellent "Genius Myth".
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Had to Google how to tie a double Windsor knot...
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
A tie!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
The latest IMF summary of the UK outlook moves GDP growth around between 2026 and 2027 after impressive resilience in H1. For me two things stood out - both related - on the fiscal side.
Firstly, and widely under-appreciated by the commentariat, is how the UK has the most aggressive deficit reduction plan of any G7 economy. Whilst there are plenty of examples of inefficient public spending, the overall profile is more disciplined than developed economy peers.
Secondly, the warning to “stay the course” is code for doubts over the credibility of some of the govt spending restraint pencilled in (but not allocated) at the end of the Parliament given increased defence spending demands. Those decisions tee up a very tough spending review in 2027 particularly for public sector pay - and the potential for backsliding - at next year’s SR.
The govt will hope something turns up over the next six months in the Gulf, and/or global credit markets to make these allocative jobs easier. But Hope is not a (great) strategy.
Overall govt will be happy with how the IMF framed the update but fiscal storm clouds loom for next year. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Off to join the House of Lords!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I know! But as I understand it, the GP has to put me on the list at the hospital for hydrodilatation. Waiting a month to see a GP adds a month to the wait to be treated, and seems a symptom of the NHS working very poorly. It is very painful.
Treading Water
@seasick999
A steroid injection is not the same as hydro-dilitation. A GP can do the former, but the latter is a guided injection by a radiologist.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, hydro-dilatation worked last time for me as well. The NHS waiting list was 6 months, and my local private hospital botched it in the interim... Of course being the NHS there is no way to find out what the waiting list time is...
saralouise
@shepherdsara1
Having suffered with a frozen shoulder twice I learnt that a steroid injection gives huge relief. Some GP’s administer this or they will refer you to a MSK clinic. With the level of pain a frozen shoulder can cause, I would personally try to get an on the day urgent appointment.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
There should be an automatic right to add physical external shutters to any house; conservation areas should have approved designs set out. It’s incredible how effective they are at keeping places cool.
Philip Oldfield
@SustainableTall
Would you just look at these beautiful timber blinds in this social housing in Navarra, Spain
In a warming world, shading should be on ALL housing!
The architects are Taller Basico and MRM Arquitectos. Blinds by Saxun Solar -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
No, because I need a hospital referral for a procedure.
mark polden 🏴🇮🇱🇺🇸
@marcusveniquis
Can you not go to a hospital walk in centre
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I know that, but I care about the NHS being effective!
Adam Stones
@ModerateSauce
Private GP costs about £80, you can afford it.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
Today, Russia expressed its thanks for the lifting of sanctions on diesel exports by dropping five glide bombs on residential buildings in Zaporizhzhia. As of now, sadly, twelve people have been confirmed killed, including three children. My condolences to all their families and loved ones. Another fourteen people have been injured, and two of them are in critical condition – the doctors are fighting to save their lives. The status of twelve more people who may have been there is still being verified. All emergency services are at the scene, and search-and-rescue operations are underway. Overnight, thirteen of our regions came under attack. Residential buildings, infrastructure, and railway facilities have been damaged.
Last night confirmed once again that in Russia, they take any easing of pressure to mean they can keep fighting, to mean they can keep dropping bombs on cities. Different signals are needed. Russia must understand that it needs to stop the war, and for that to happen, Russia must feel its losses. Right now, it is our long-range capabilities that are ensuring this. And we will respond to Russian strikes. I thank everyone who is helping. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
'At a stroke, Badenoch 2026 is throwing away a lot of the gains from Badenoch 2025... Badenoch presented this as a growth policy. It is the reverse.'
V critical verdict from ex-HMT bigwig @jillongovt: www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/comment/kemi-badenochs-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Small boat arrivals are at a four year low and falling fast
Reform UK
@reformparty_uk
The invasion is getting worse under Burnham.
Only Reform UK has a plan to stop the boats forever and save Britain. 🇬🇧 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They will send me for hydro-dilatation! Like last time! It works!!
Kirstie Allsopp
@KirstieMAllsopp
All that will happen is that they will recommend a physio/chiropractor and that will be another wait.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I submitted my symtoms - I am in dire pain and am sleeping badly. They told me to wait a month. As I say, I don't think @NHSEngland is working well.
Ganesh Sittampalam @ganesh@functional.cafe
@eleganesh
My local GP moved over to a triage system where you submit symptoms online (or by phone if you aren't online) and then they work out what to do. It's made a huge difference to responsiveness.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, that is what I wanted the GP to arrange. Just like 5 years ago when I had it in the other shoulder.
Anna Perry
@annaperryparis
I have a wonderful orthopaedic surgeon friend in Paris who did an amazing job on my frozen shoulder with a cortisol injection. DM me if you want his details. Not expensive.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well, you are luckier than I am. I used the online system and was offered 11 November. If I did a manual job I would now be signed off work for a month. The NHS seems pretty hopeless to me.
Howell Harris
@trefeca
Fell (with rather than off) my bike couple of weeks ago, used practice’s online appointment system at 11-30 a.m., appointment practice physio at 3-15, job done. Similar experience with actual GP appointments since new system intro’d & 8-30 phone-queue dash ended. HS is not very N
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I know that a GP is not open on a Sunday. I called them, they told me I had to fill in a form. I filled in the form. They sent me another form. I was offered 11 November as the first appointment.
CRAIG THE BOSS
@parr_craig61423
the GP is not open on a sunday tim.
Call tomorrow morning and they will see you that day -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am in severe pain with (another) frozen shoulder, which will only get worse. I have just tried to book to see a GP and been told that the next appointment is 11 November. The NHS is failing.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Absolutely delighted that @dantomlinsonmp is doing this. FWIW we should also reduce notice periods - 2 weeks is the US norm, and they have a more dynamic economy than we do.
Dan Tomlinson MP
@dantomlinsonmp
We are going to take action on non-compete clauses. These are a blight on the lives of too many employees, and many of us in government have become concerned at the way in which their use is limiting job moves in the tech sector in particular. Innovation, dynamism and higher productivity comes from people being able to move easily into the right job for them - so we have to act.
For those who don't know, these clauses in employment contracts restrict people from moving into a new role immediately after leaving an old one. This forces people into limbo with no pay and no job for months on end.
It is estimated that as many as 5 million workers are subject to a non-compete clause - this holds back our economy, stunts innovation and leaves workers stuck in jobs across the economy, from tech to childcare.
So we are going to legislate to make sure that non-competes will no longer be a barrier to hiring for innovative firms & will no longer restrict unfairly the moves that workers in the everyday economy want to make too.
Detail to follow at the Budget, when BIST will publish its response to the engagement it has been doing on this topic.
www.ft.com/content/297ca864-737c-4112-b368-f21a20cc78d2?s… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Pence
@Mike_Pence
President Trump’s decision to lift sanctions on Russian fuel amidst Putin’s ongoing and brutal attacks on civilian targets in Ukraine makes no sense and is a betrayal of the legacy and leadership of the late Senator Lindsey Graham.
While Ukraine fights for its survival, Putin’s war machine continues to prosecute his terrorist war on civilian populations and innocent Ukrainians are dying every day.
Now, Instead of implementing the tough sanctions Lindsey Graham fought to his last breath to enact, President Trump has announced the United States is lifting sanctions on Russian energy, fueling the Putin’s war machine.
As I saw firsthand in Ukraine last month, Putin is losing this war. Ukraine has fought the Russian military to a standstill and reinvented warfare with drones taking the fight into the heart of Russia.
America should not be throwing a lifeline to Putin’s war machine. Now is the time to stand strong against Russian aggression as we did during the first Trump administration.
Putin doesn’t want peace. Putin wants Ukraine. I have no doubt that if Putin overruns Ukraine, it will only be a matter of time until Russia’s military crosses a border that our troops will have to deal with him.
America is the Leader of the Free World. For our National Security, for the security of our Allies in Europe including Ukraine, President Trump should rescind this deal immediately and return to the strong policies of our four years in the White House; impose harsh sanctions on any nation purchasing Russian energy and work with our allies to ensure Ukraine has the military support it needs to repel and defeat this Russian invasion once and for all. Slava Ukraini🇺🇸🇺🇦 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
A terrible shame. UKICE has done a terrific job bringing serious analysis of a crucial set of issues out of academia and into public domain. A big problem that long term funding for this sort of work is so hard/impossible to find.
Anand Menon
@anandMenon1
An announcement. There will be plenty of time to reflect on what we've achieved, and on the fantastic colleagues who have helped us achieve it. But for now, sad news ukandeu.ac.uk/announcement/statement-from-ukice-director-… 1/2
-
Tim Leunig reposted
createstreets
@createstreets
Martin Lewis has asked the public for simple, inexpensive and broadly uncontroversial changes that could make Britain work a little better.
What better place to start than with putting an end to street scars?
We can hold utility companies to account for scarring our streets with just a few changes to legislation that will:
🚧Make them put pavements back exactly as they found them and increase the fines for failing to do so.
🚧Require them to pay the full cost of restoring damaged pavements to the original standard.
Find out more...
Martin Lewis
@MartinSLewis
Please submit your small ideas for fixing Britain to the small-ideas.org website. It’s a new charitable initiative I’ve set up to try and make sure life’s potholes don’t get ignored. Working with two charities and a cross party panel to turn your ideas into policy then try and make it happen. Please share.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Helen Miller
@HelenMiller_IFS
Since this isn't a good faith response I won't do a blow by blow...
but we obviously didn't say to exclude UC -- we say TPA should include other benefits. that matters
I love data & think people should know that benefits are rising - but there's no need to use dodgy stats
TaxPayers' Alliance
@the_tpa
The @TheIFS approached us late last night about our new benefits bill tool.
They took exception to us saying benefits had increased. Our Benefits Bill majors on current spending, not the change (because the UC migration complicates it; see our FAQs on our site), but the fact is that spending has massively increased.
We don’t hide that - we just include the % change.
Their first point was that we should have excluded Universal Credit, because of the migration. Given UC is the biggest benefit for working people, that's deluded. As the IFS have already admitted, UC migration issues don't impact our numbers for current UC spending - in fact, they even admitted our overall local spending totals are accurate and that disability benefit spending has surged. So you can rest assured these local totals are as shocking as they are correct.
Next, they complained that we should have used real-terms numbers to compare changes with the increase in the median wage...which is a nominal number. This is obviously silly, not least as nominal figures are a legitimate and transparent way of presenting underlying cash expenditure. Furthermore, the Benefits Bill is not intended (nor does it claim) to measure changes in the real purchasing power of that spending. It tells you the amount the DWP is spending, from their own data.
They also questioned why we selected the benefits we did. This is simple: we focus on the six major DWP-tracked benefit streams consistently available at local authority level (UC, PIP, Housing Benefit, DLA, Attendance Allowance, and Carer's Allowance) to give taxpayers the clearest possible picture of what is spent in their area.
Furthermore, the IFS told us we should have included legacy benefits like Jobseekers Allowance and income support. These would make very little difference - the change in Jobseekers Allowance is only £50m across England and Wales
And they mention tax credits (because they've moved over to UC). Those aren't in the DWP Stat-Xplore database and - surprise, surprise - the numbers are for the whole tax year, not the point-in-time data we have for UC. IFS sent us a worked example for Birmingham - and the figures are wrong, because they seem to use the 2023-24 tax year vs the 2 year period for UC. When numbers are changing rapidly due to the final stages of migration, you can't just put together mismatched timeframes. So we stuck with the Stat-Xplore data.
Crucially, even if you accept the IFS's own recalculated figures for Birmingham including tax credits, local spending STILL grew by 15.1% in cash terms over just two years. In what world is a 15% cash surge over 24 months something to celebrate?
The fact of the matter is this: other benefits have migrated onto UC, so the UC increases will be inflated. But when trying to say anything about benefits in Britain, that caveat comes with the territory, which is why we included it transparently in our FAQs and didn’t focus on the % change. All the spending totals you get when you punch in your postcode are (sadly) both correct and shocking.
Like many in the Westminster establishment, the IFS can't see the wood for the trees. Benefits spending has gone up, is too high and needs to come down. Not just for the sake of taxpayers and the public finances, but for those who need targeted support to get back into work.
Saying this upsets a lot of people, but taxpayers need someone to fight this fight, so TPA will, and we won’t apologise for doing so. This tool is designed to take DWP data no one sees and put it in a handy tool anyone can use. That’s why it matters for the public debate.
Check out our latest benefits bill tool by clicking the link below
benefitsdata.uk -
Tim Leunig reposted
Andy Burnham
@andyburnham
I don't care what anyone says, I believe we can end rough sleeping in Britain.
Today is World Homeless Day, and I don't think anyone in this country should be sleeping rough on our streets. Certainly not tonight.
That's why one of the first commitments I made as Prime Minister was to end rough sleeping. Not manage it. Not reduce it. End it.
And I'm putting over £400 million behind a national drive to get everyone in for Christmas.
And to put my own money where my mouth is, I'm making my latest salary donation from my PM salary to The Passage in Victoria, an amazing charity I visited on my very first day in Downing Street.
All this will help make sure that every person sleeping rough is offered a route off the street and a safe place to stay because, in one of the wealthiest countries in the world, people should not be left to sleep outside with nowhere to turn.
This isn't the finish line. We'll keep building the homes, creating the jobs, and reforming the services to stop people reaching crisis point in the first place.
But today, I wanted to say this: we should never accept rough sleeping as normal. Not in Britain, not in 2026, and not while I'm Prime Minister. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
To European policymakers: please pay attention here, this is a no brainer. Banning non-compete agreements is pro-worker, pro-innovation and pro-competition. Every European country that cares to increase innovation should take this step.
etn.
@etnshow
BREAKING: PM Andy Burnham has announced that his government will ban non-compete agreements for startups and scaleups in the UK, via Dom Hallas.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
More populist tosh from the TUC.
There was no "tax break for the banks". The 8% bank surcharge was created to offset the corporation tax cut from 28% to 20%.
So, when corporation tax then went up 5% to its current level, the surcharge went down 5%.
Not a tax break. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
This, from DfT annual report, shows capital spending on roads, rail and HS2.
Spending on HS2 is, year after year, higher than on the whole of the rest of the rail network, and nearly twice total spending on national highways.
Just think what could have been done instead. -
Tim Leunig reposted
David__Osland
@David__Osland
If I were prime minister of country where 440,000 children sleep on the floor because they do not have a bed of their own, abolition of inheritance tax would not be my flagship policy
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Harwood
@tomhfh
There is literally nothing stopping us building like this again, we haven't magically lost the technology. We just have architects who spend seven hard years in education diligently unlearning what looks nice.
Edward Teather
@TeatherEdward
An extension to Oxford designed with "cues from the [existing] skyline" in mind might look something like this. One day we will build spires again.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The gaps are just as big in Australia which already does this.
Ryan Wain
@ryan_wain
Easy to sneer at "PM announces a Google Maps feature" but it forces fuel prices into the open on an app 7 in 10 mobile users already use. Take the PM's own seat, where two forecourts 0.6 miles apart are 10p a litre apart - this gap adds up 👇
We know voters want politicians who do stuff. This is stuff. It will sit nicely alongside bigger structural reform. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They do this already in Australia and there is still a huge variation in petrol prices in every area (And Australia has a lot of petrol stations). People seem surprisingly unwilling to drive 100m to save $5 (aka £2.40).
Andy Burnham
@andyburnham
I know people are worried about fuel prices. And I get it. You get to the pump, watch the numbers climb, and wonder why it's costing so much more than it used to.
The reality is that global events are pushing up costs, and families here at home are feeling the impact.
But I won't accept that there's nothing I can do to help.
That's why from today, you'll be able to see petrol and diesel prices on Google Maps, compare nearby stations and find the cheapest option before you fill up.
It's a small change, but if there's a practical way to help people keep more money in their pocket, I'll do it. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
There are also large majorities in favour of a wealth tax.
Five second questions and answers on complex areas of tax policy are a rubbish guide to anything… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Good news. We need 20 times this all over Europe. The US has 40 GW of AI compute, Europe 2.
Seb Johnson
@SebJohnsonUK
A UK startup has just announced plans to build 40 edge data centres in the UK to power sovereign AI compute.
The UK has got some of the most phenomenal AI researchers and AI companies in the world.
One of the issues that we really have is a complete lack of compute both in the UK and across Europe.
@CivoCloud, the UK cloud provider, has announced plans to roll out 40 edge data centres in the UK to fix this.
The first site is in Hertfordshire and has already been announced. Five more sites have been secured, and will rise to 40 in total.
The sites will deliver a combined one gigawatt of capacity across the country, aimed at inference at the edge rather than training.
This fantastic news. The UK needs a lot more of this.
NICE @markboost -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Reasons to be cheerful...
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
The share of children who died before they were 5 years old in 1950 and 75 years later.
Africa: 33% ↘ 6%
Asia: 25% ↘ 2.5%
Oceania: 9.3% ↘ 2%
Latin America: 21% ↘ 1.5%
Northern America: 3.8% ↘ 0.6%
Europe: 10.5% ↘ 0.4%
Globally: 23% ↘ 3.5% -
Tim Leunig reposted
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
French pensions are literally not possible to sustain, unless you want to wager the entire country on massive AI and automation-fueled economic gains (a risky bet!).
The median French pensioner, right now, has a higher income than the median working-age adult. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
People also tend not to accept the suggestion that skin colour or ethnic background determine whether someone is English. Including an overwhelming majority of Reform voters.
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
Think that’s the toughest I’ve seen a Tory leader been on Reform since their emergence as a serious political force, directly taking on claims about Englishness and identity from some Reform politicians. Feels a significant change in approach.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Chris Giles
@ChrisGiles_
Budgets are all about judgments, not fancy forecasting equations.
These are (my view) of the sensible judgments the OBR and Chancellor Healey need to make later this month
www.ft.com/content/b07bd481-a492-4b95-af55-914176f8d2b6 -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
The “contribution” argument on the triple lock is a poor. For a start, it is very hard for anyone living during their working life not to meet the contributory requirements. And in any event, this entitles you to receive a pension, not to uprating under a specific formula. 1/2
Kitty Donaldson
@kitty_donaldson
EXC: Members of the Shadow Cabinet say Kemi Badenoch should abandon the Tory commitment to the triple lock.
💫”It’s unaffordable in the long term, of course we should keep our options open,” a member of the Shadow Cabinet told The i Paper. “I see why Kemi’s doing it, but I don’t think we should commit to it so far away from an election.”
💫Another member of the Shadow Cabinet warned the Tory policy commitment is unlikely to last until 2029, when the election is due, “unless a miracle happens and the public finances pick up. We’ve still got to find the money for defence.”
💫 But the timing of an election is exactly why Badenoch is sticking to her guns. Even though Andy Burnham and his No 10 team have spent most of the last month hosing down the idea of going to the country before 2029, the Tory leader and her key allies think the Prime Minister could call an election as soon as next May.
💫 The Conservatives are so concerned about an early election that Badenoch has instructed Tory MP Neil O’Brien to draft the party’s next manifesto.
💫According to an aide, Badenoch’s commitment to the triple lock is because she is “very hot on the idea of contribution”.
“It’s the idea that if you’ve paid in, then you have made a contribution and you shouldn’t be penalised for that and that is where we start when it comes to pensions,” the aide added.
💫 As the Tories gather in Birmingham instead of calling this a normal, workaday conference, the party is dubbing it a grandiose “festival of ideas”.
💫Last year, organisers held Badenoch’s keynote speech in a smaller side room to avoid embarrassing photographs of empty chairs, but this year she will deliver it in the city’s International Convention Centre’s 2,200-seater Symphony Hall.
💫This will be the first time a leader’s speech has been held there since former prime minister Theresa May memorably walked out to ABBA’s “Dancing Queen” in 2018.
💫Read the whole piece here: inews.co.uk/news/politics/adenoch-triple-lock-tories-4805266 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
I know. That’s why I prefer the Dilnot solution which means people pay the first £X,000 and the state picks up the sort of catastrophic costs that can lead people to lose everything. Burnham’s solution is both very expensive and fails to provide that protection.
Eric Smith
@EricSmi92780239
Paul, free personal care is not the same as paying for all care costs. The most expensive bits eg residential charges still left with families.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Me escribe un amigo sobre el gráfico del @ft describiendo el resultado de 112 estudios sobre las leyes de control de alquileres, , apuntando al impacto de las leyes de control de alquileres sobre la movilidad social:
"Los de rojo son los chavales de mi pueblo que tienen que quedarse allí porque en Madrid no se construyen casas y en las que hay se tiene que quedar Maricarmen. No entiendo cómo esto puede ser progresista." -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But Birmingham airport does not want to build another runway! They don't use their current runway that intensively!!
mark polden 🏴🇮🇱🇺🇸
@marcusveniquis
A test of how much London wants Heathrow to expand. The mayor and local governance cajoles No10 into it, the residents want it so much they say there is no necessity for consultation, and ground is broken within a year. Otherwise Birmingham gets government approval and starts building. A literal race.
Because this is the problem, things like the lower thames crossing get wrapped up in stupidity.
This is the Just Do It, (like China) generation. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Twenty years ago, before online check in and advance seat reservations, I was seated 5 rows from my three year old daughter. @Iberia did not care less. I don't think a bit of government regulation is a problem here.
Ryan Bourne
@MrRBourne
So more government control of airline pricing by adding another constraint to how they allocate seats?
I'm sure that will make up for another £15bn in tax rises to subsidise other people's inheritances. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ameer Kotecha
@Ameer_Kotecha
Just had a guy on a bike almost crash into me on Marsham Street (maybe 8 mins walk from Parliament) as he was speeding along the pavement on an electric bike. 20s probably, Asian-looking
I tell him to not ride on the pavement as I walk away - angrily, but no shouting or swearing etc
He throws the bike down and comes after me and says "do you want me to shank you?" (aka stab). Tucked into his belt he has a longish piece of metal - seemed to be some sort of blade but I can't be 100% sure what it was in truth. Enough to scare me anyway
I very hurriedly walk away and he yells "yeh run you posh cunt", and at some point he (I think) stops following
I call the police (was in two minds between 101 or 999 ; ended up going for the latter). Operator asked me my name and then how to spell it (hardly seemed the priority)
Tell her what happened. She asks if I am still in danger - I say well I've walked away but the guy is still around I think
She says it's not an emergency so I need to fill out a form on the police website. She says she'll text me the link
I say - there's a guy threatening to stab people and is that not a priority? She says no and to fill out the form. I try to interject but mid-sentence she cuts the call
That's it
Not sure what to think really but as someone who doesn't have many interactions with the @metpoliceuk I just didn't really expect it to be so..dismissive? Maybe they were having a busy Friday night who knows -
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Heathrow:
- Heathrow’s third runway, at £21bn for just the runway, will be 10 to 70 times more expensive than similar projects elsewhere
- Its planning application alone, at £800m, costs more than actual new runways in Madrid, Dublin, Chicago, Brisbane, even Manchester... -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Hearne, CFP™
@dontdelay
The triple lock didn't exist for a single year of this man's working life.
He didn't pay towards a single pensioner ever getting a triple lock increase on their own state pension while he worked.
And yet his vote depends on continuing to be paid triple lock increases on his state pension by current and future workers.
Graham Bridge
@GrahamBridge3
As an 86 yr old Pensioner, who was employed all my working life, I notice Burnham wants to remove the triple lock. He has lost my vote and I wonder how many other Pensioners feel the same.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Birmingham gets what exactly? I literally don't know what you are proposing!
mark polden 🏴🇮🇱🇺🇸
@marcusveniquis
How about @timleunig, if it is not permissioned & ground broken by this time next year, Birmingham gets it.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Really? It is 24 minutes from LHR Terminal 2/3 to Paddington, 32 minutes from LGW to Victoria. What evidence do you have that it will be faster from Birmingham? The longer journey will also be a more expensive. I think you are talking nonsense!
Jordan
@jordanbhx
Lots of people not understanding that post-HS2 it’ll be quicker to get from Bham International Airport to central London than from Gatwick, Heathrow, Stansted, Southend and Luton. If you don’t like it being more convenient because it doesn’t have ‘London’ in the name that’s odd.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Josh Glancy
@joshglancy
A longstanding view of mine is that if you provided perfect Wifi on trains, many people would use it to stream TV or YouTube, adding to noise pollution.
You can do most work on the train already, hotspotting where necessary, plus deeper reading too.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cy016gx1g5zo -
Tim Leunig reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
Future population projections expect that fertility rates stop declining and roughly stabilize.
This new NBER paper asks what evidence we have to expect this. It finds there is none. "Instead, where and when fertility has fallen low, it has tended to keep falling." -
Tim Leunig reposted
Centre for Cities
@CentreforCities
"The idea there's some magic wand where you're going to recreate the days of the cotton mills in these small towns is just cloud cuckoo land" ~ Lord Jim O'Neill
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Greg Jackson
@g__j
37% of new trucks sold in China are now electric. They’re not little vans - they’re 49 tons. Unaffected by diesel prices. Simply not held back by the fossil fuel lobby.
Roger Harrabin
@RHarrabin
This is an extraordinary development. Only a few years ago, the car makers were saying it would not be impossible in the near future to make electric trucks. We must never underestimate the extent to which vested interest is putting the brakes on the Climate revolution
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Helen Miller
@HelenMiller_IFS
Some of the coverage of the triple lock amounts to irresponsible scaremongering IMO
Pensions are not being cut - it's not right to give pensioners the impression that they are
Here's how I'll explain it to my grandma
Institute for Fiscal Studies
@TheIFS
"The new triple lock is not going to put pensioners into poverty. Pensions will still rise in line with average earnings."
🎙️ @HelenMiller_IFS explains how the new triple lock will work in our latest podcast: has the triple lock been fixed?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Burnham quotes make me worry he doesn’t understand how getting rid of triple lock can “fund” social care. Says no tax rises needed. But change to triple lock doesn’t mean spending falls, just rises less quickly. You can’t have free care without tax rises.
giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/actions/redeem/1e7aa730-7f… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Helen Miller
@HelenMiller_IFS
I'm getting grumpy at claims that the old triple lock is a good way to increase the generosity of pensions relative to earnings
If a higher pension is desired -> just state the level &when you want to reach it; don't just hope that at some unknowable future date it happens
Institute for Fiscal Studies
@TheIFS
NEW PODCAST: Has the triple lock been fixed?
🎙️ @HelenMiller_IFS explains why the triple lock is an unpredictable way to increase the state pension, in our new podcast about the Government's announcement, out now: -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well why not commission a reputable polling company to do so then? It is not that expensive, and you are quite rich enough to afford it!
Lord Sugar
@Lord_Sugar
BREXIT : I would like to ask a cross section of the public some simple questions.
1. Do you feel you was mislead to by Johnson and Gove about the benefits of Brexit .
2. Should we have left the EU.
3. Have you seen any benefit being out the EU.
4. Have you or your business suffered in anway .
5. Would you like to rejoin the EU
Please give honest answers and no jokers please
Lord Sugar -
Tim Leunig reposted
Chris Giles
@ChrisGiles_
Central banks always think interest rate rates operate on demand. But what if tighter policy makes people want to work more?
That labour supply effect can be large. People with high debts worked more when Australia tightened, for example
My newsletter: www.ft.com/content/a060e1f6-e669-4657-af63-701053709c2d -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
We need a Conscious Extinction movement to rid the world of the animals and plants that cause the worst disease and suffering.
It's good that smallpox and rinderpest are extinct. It's good that the screwworm fly and malarial mosquitos were extinct in the developed world. So let's extend the logic to other disease-carrying mosquito species, along with lots of other pests, and let's not stop at the borders of the rich world.
Saloni
@salonium
There is no good reason for mosquitoes to exist in wealthy countries today.
New technologies can get rid of the mosquito species that cause diseases like dengue, yellow fever, and malaria; and others can prevent them from carrying those diseases.
worksinprogress.co/issue/mosquitoes-are-a-choice
So why do mosquitoes still exist?
In a new article for Works in Progress, Maya Rosen explains how state incapacity and risk aversion led to over a decade of delays and billions of unnecessary bites in the United States.
Oxitec, for example, engineered an Aedes aegypti mosquito in such a way that its female offspring would die before adulthood. Through sustained releases, they showed they could reduce local mosquito populations by 80% or more, in field trials.
They sought approval from the USDA in 2010, which then passed it to the FDA, which passed it to the EPA. In 2020, the EPA allowed them to conduct limited field trials in the Florida Keys. Two years ago, their experimental permit expired, and they still need another review before it can be used routinely. Their proposed field trial in California was withdrawn after public opposition.
Another company, MosquitoMate, developed a technique involving Wolbachia, which also suppresses local mosquitoes. They then spent over fifteen years working through the system before finally receiving commercial registration nationwide in 2024.
It seems that, sometimes, the barrier to getting rid of diseases isn’t technology at all. It’s policy and political will.
New products shouldn’t get stuck in regulatory review for so long, especially if the delays are about basic questions like which agency has oversight over the product, rather than testing for safety.
Though some of those uncertainties were being addressed, the broader changes haven’t materialized. After Biden’s 2022 executive order, the agencies planned to update how their coordinated framework was implemented. But Trump rescinded the order last year.
Meanwhile, the EPA unit that reviews new mosquito control products is still a small office backlogged in reviewing a wide range of products.
Mosquitoes are a policy choice. We can get rid of them. Will we choose to?
worksinprogress.co/issue/mosquitoes-are-a-choice -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, with an increasing number of pensioners, the cost of pensions is bound to rise...
Josh Bailey
@joshuabailey_
May be of interest @timleunig
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Josh Bailey
@joshuabailey_
Could have a catch-up mechanism if the level drift too far from earnings, along the lines of @timleunig 's proposal timleunig.substack.com/p/the-pensioner-triple-lock (obviously erodes the savings)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
The triple lock is stupid, but if since 2010 we’d had a “double lock” targeting the higher of earnings or inflation instead, and used a three-year moving average, we’d only be spending £11 billion less today. 0.09% higher economic growth over a decade would cover that.
George McGowan
@GjMcGowan
Now is time for my heterodox view that this commitment isn't that expensive and the political capital spent on abolishing it would be better spent on $LIST_OF_PRO_GROWTH_REFORMS
-
Tim Leunig reposted
David Lawrence
@dc_lawrence
The PM is expected to signal an end to the triple lock today. But what are the options for reform, and how much money do they save?
@BritishProgress (namely, @matthewgstubbs) has made a tool to compare the different ideas on the table.
For instance, you can compare @timleunig's '5-year triple lock' with @resfoundation's 'smoothed triple lock' proposal (originally proposed by @TorstenBell and @lauracgardiner) to see that they each would save around £60bn by 2047, and deliver an annual state pension of around £27k (nominal).
As you can see, the amount of money that can be saved – particularly over a longer time-horizon, is enormous. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is an issue the government is right to tackle.
Inveterate Economist
@econ_inclined
What's your estimate for annual cost of asylum seekers granted refugee status having arrived on a student visa? Most reasonable estimates blow a big hole in the fiscal benefit for the government
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Just to be clear, you want VAT taken off all hotel stays, or just hotel stays for those visiting children in hospital? What about petrol duty for those taking a child to the doctor's or hospital?
Patrick Spencer MP
@pspencer_CSNI
I absolutely do.
I’m a low tax conservative Tim.
And I think your tweet criticising @aliciakearns talking about her child was v misguided (and somewhat out of character) from you. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
More than half of British passengers who fly to and from Heathrow live outside London.
BBC Politics
@BBCPolitics
“Principally, it’s a matter for London”
Prime Minister Andy Burnham refuses to commit to building a third runway at Heathrow airport and says “you’ve got to hear the voice of people [in London] first”
#bbclaurak
www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/cj4zwkp2p1ktThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Overseas students raise UK GDP by spending money here. Many UK universities are significant exporters for exactly that reason.
Andrew Neil
@afneil
This is so bonkers I can hardly believe you made it.
A large part of the 2.5m were unproductive — students, dependents etc. So they had little impact on GDP.
But their numbers are included in GDP/capita calculations, so quite the impact on GDP/capita.
I’m amazed you don’t understand this.
No wonder the three Theresa May years were three of the most miserable, shambolic, rudderless in our country’s modern history.
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
This is an absurd argument. It's the other way round. 2.5 million extra people will make a big difference to overall output (GDP), much less of a difference to GDP/head
Andrew Neil
@afneil
The GDP/capita figures are hugely distorted by the nearly 2.5m net migration of the Boris Wave 2021/22/23. Making GDP growth a better guide in comparative performance.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Aubrey Allegretti
@breeallegretti
Treasury minister Dan Tomlinson leans in hard to back Heathrow expansion, after Andy Burnham said it was a matter for London.
The Barnet MP says he watches the planes with his 2-year-old in the back garden and adds: “I am pro more flights over North London in particular.” -
Tim Leunig reposted
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Post-financial crash was an exceptional period where rates were at the zero lower bound. Today's interest rates are significantly lower than the decades from 1975-2008.
Housebuilders should be building without govt stimulus in these quite normal economic times.
Woke Maggie Thatcher 🇵🇸🇺🇦🍁
@ShinMarginalScr
Two things are true re: the British housing market right now.
There are major supply side constraints that need to be fixed, but also, high interest rates are disincentivising people from buying new houses etc. and builders aren’t going to build with existing constraints. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The Tories taxed families like yours staying in hotels for exactly that reason. It is called VAT. Did you ever speak out against that, or are you playing politics? No wonder people hold politicians in such contempt, @aliciakearns.
Alicia Kearns MP
@aliciakearns
For the first time I’ve spoken about my daughter having neurosurgery at four months old.
Why? Because Labour plans to tax families who have to stay in hotels to be near our children while they’re in hospital.
It’s wrong & it’s cruel @lisanandy.
www.thesun.co.uk/news/40504192/labour-tourist-tax-will-hu… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
This is really great.
And it is great to see some of the big debates about education reaching a wider audience.
If only our government were listening...
Ian Leslie
@mrianleslie
The Ruffian has LANDED. Why is the left so bad at education? www.ian-leslie.com/p/why-is-the-left-so-bad-at-education
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Britain's first reservoir for 30 years has been delayed another five years.
Now, Heathrow 3rd runway delayed until 2039
Why? The regulatory purgatory that imprisons UK growth - and will imprison Burnham unless he reforms.
My Times column:-
times-comment.com/hs2 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Luxury retailers want taxpayers to fund a 20% tax break for foreign tourists.
They paid consultancy Cebr to claim this will raise £2.6bn for the UK. That convinced Sadiq Khan and Kemi Badenoch.
But it's false: a free lunch. Four basic errors mask a £600m loss.
Thread: -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But they pay other taxes, notably VAT.
Torben Schust
@TorbenSchust
So all can contribute to the running of the country and judge whether they receive value for money on their investment - much better than the idiocy of folks who contribute nothing demand more public spending
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Supermarket margins show that the cost savings from self service tills are passed to consumers. That you have not noticed does not affect this fact.
Alex Jones
@alexcj
As supermarkets increase self-checkouts and job cuts follow, I've not seen any reduction in prices. Let's see if we get lower insurance premiums as a result if these job losses. I'm not holding my breath.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You really want to administer tax on a teenager earning £8 a week delivering newspapers?
Inveterate Economist
@econ_inclined
What's wrong with that?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is still possible to drive into the centre, from N and S for free, I think?
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
Some national journalists should get down to Oxford at some point soon to see what is really happening to transport in a city that should be powering Britain’s economic recovery.
From next week, many of the main routes into town will be reserved for the exclusive use of locals. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
Great summary of the latest PISA scores from @Samfr
Picks out some details that haven't been reported much.
EG 81% of children in England are in schools that ban phones, much higher than other western countries.
England one of the few countries NOT to see a rise in pupils saying they think learning new things is boring.
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
New post out:
England's schools are now the second highest performing in the world outside the far east, according to the PISA study.
Is this because of policy? Attitude to technology? Cultural factors like immigration? And where can we still improve?
samf.substack.com/p/why-englands-schools-are-doing-so?r=7… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Although if the job cuts lead to lower insurance premiums (as we would expect in a competitive market) you presumably welcome it as a govt minister, since the cost of living is your #1 priority? (Governing is hard)
Torsten Bell
@TorstenBell
Like many people across Swansea Bay, I’m deeply disappointed to learn that Admiral Insurance are to cut 500 jobs from its UK business. I’ve asked for an urgent meeting with the company to talk about what happens next - particularly in Swansea.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
UK Government does hot desking. So does PublicFirst. So does Nesta. I think I get my own desk in the House of Lords, but I have too apply for a coat hook and a locker...
Ryan Bourne
@MrRBourne
Do any employers still do "hot desking"? I remember my first internship had it and it was ridiculously awful and inefficient. Is that fad now over?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You are proposing a zero personal tax allowance??? Again, what idiocy is this???
Torben Schust
@TorbenSchust
Income tax is the exchequers largest income - all folks need to contribute
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is a completely different (and much more defensible) set of issues than the drivel I was criticising.
Arthur Paneal
@Arthur_Paneal
The personal allowance is often presented as encouraging work/ helping low paid... But it means we have higher marginal tax rates than we would otherwise need, and one of its main beneficiaries are those who choose to retire early.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
Ever wondered how proposed Local Government Reorganisation correlates with the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms of 5th-9th century England? Of course not!
But I made a map of it anyway. Compare LGR, devolution and SDS boundaries...now with added "Heptarchy Mode".
apps.curtography.uk/lgr/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
Is the problem the voters not the leaders? Good piece by @JGaneshEsq…. The voters are also more diverse in their tastes and experiences than 40 years ago - harder to please! giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/actions/redeem/7ca6e8ef-30…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What idiocy is this? Why is paying income tax more moral than paying VAT, which we sell to? VAT at 20% is also not the historic norm. Is that a problem?
James Baxter-Derrington
@jamesbaxterd
More than a third of adults don’t pay a single penny in income tax.
That is fiscally unsustainable, morally irresponsible – and not the historic norm.
Forget the fiscal cost of raising the personal allowance for a moment - we need to speak more about the moral toll. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Really? If wages go above the marginal product of labour, wages AND unemployment will rise. Not sure that is a winning idea...
John McTernan
@Johnmcternan
If we reintroduced the closed shop then wages would rise - which would also be helpful!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Bodil Isaksen
@BodilUK
It can be hard to get a sense of what England's strong Pisa results mean. Put it this way: if we performed at OECD average, we'd drop from ~70% Grade 4s at 16 to ~60%. That's >70,000 pupils a year getting a life changing qualification.
shift.bodil.uk -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Although equally if you sorted out the planning system so that more houses were built, rents would fall and fewer people would need to claim UC to live acceptably!
Dr. Jeevun Sandher MP
@JeevunSandher
What this article fails to mention is that 40% of Universal Credit recipients *are working*.
Deindustrialisation means there are lots of low-paid jobs that don’t pay enough to live on. We top up those wages so people can afford a decent life. -
Tim Leunig reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
This is what the Chinese built for the same price and over the same period
Matthew Evans
@MJCEvans1995
Cars and buses go from Oxford Station down Botley Road for the first time in three years!
The project took longer than the construction of The Titanic and saw costs balloon to £237m.
Looks good though. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week in my substack I have written about what we should do about election deposits. The current system is not working well! £/free trial - timleunig.substack.com/p/election-deposits
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
Analysis of the latest cost of homelessness in England.
Headlines:
• £1.5bn spent in 25-26 on TA
• 135,580 families homeless
• 177,530 children in TA
• 4 authorities spending more than their entire council tax take on homelessness
Full breakdown:
apps.curtography.uk/ta/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
This really is nonsensical. Claims £14bn could be raised by increasing CGT to income tax rates.
HMRC estimates that a 10% increase in CGT would *cost* £3.5bn. Exact magnitude can be disputed, but it sure as heck wouldn't raise close to £14bn.
www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/andy-burnham-capital… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Centre for Cities
@CentreforCities
🟡We are at Liberal Democrat Party Conference today and excited to host our Building Better Places event this afternoon alongside our expert panel 👀
@timleunig @BhamCityCouncil @MaceGroup -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Those are only the direct costs. There were indirect economic and financial costs to the city...
Matthew Evans
@MJCEvans1995
Cars and buses go from Oxford Station down Botley Road for the first time in three years!
The project took longer than the construction of The Titanic and saw costs balloon to £237m.
Looks good though. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Are you going to advocate joining the euro??
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Getting our borrowing costs below our neighbours' should be the central goal of government policy, and the central test. Instead, we seem to find ourselves talking about pretty much anything else. Me, despairingly, for @thetimes www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/labour-party-…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
It's irritating to see the lousy Help To Buy scheme getting talked up again. It's ridiculous that we simultaneously have unaffordable house prices and developers unable to build. The problem is supply-side regulations, not demand.
David Smith
@dsmitheconomics
In my Sunday Times column I look at the underperformance of consumer spending, which faces a renewed squeeze. And why John Healey should announce a new Help to Buy scheme:
Why debt-averse consumers are holding back the economy
www.thetimes.com/article/8658ca84-a9ee-4f9b-99f8-30090140… -
Tim Leunig reposted
James Baxter-Derrington
@jamesbaxterd
Tim is obviously right, and anyone dismissing him out of hand is blinded by their emotional response to independence and learned hatred of London
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written about why Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland should think very carefully before they declare that "Westminster is over"... observer.co.uk/news/business/article/independence-from-we…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
"you can't persuade all of the people, all of the time", but I appreciate your courtesy. I was called a woke idiot on Facebook earlier!
Kevin Meagher
@KevinPMeagher
For such a clever bloke, you do write some nonsense.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't mind whether they stay or go, it is a matter for them. But I hope they make the decision in a well informed way.
BELLA CALEDONIA
@bellacaledonia
If our countries are such a strain Tim, why so desperate to keep them?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I will settle for someone paying £330m a year in tax unpatriotically, because the day is £330m less then rest of us have to pay! (Not q his patriotism, btw)
🌻 Go Wild With Annette
@gowildannette
Without taxing wealthy people more, it will be poor and vulnerable people who get hit the hardest. It is time for that to change. You have to ask yourself if an extremely wealthy person leaves the country because of a small percentage of taxes being increased, how patriotic are they?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I remember thinking the same when I went to Massachusetts and New Hampshire in 1994, my first trip to the US. Devolution is very real there.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
The big shock that stays with me from ten days in the USA is the same as the first and only other time I was in the USA. It really is a Federal Republic. Really really really. States and places are in charge much more than the central government in a way that astonishes me.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written about why Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland should think very carefully before they declare that "Westminster is over"... observer.co.uk/news/business/article/independence-from-we…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Agree that passports work really well now. eVisas can be more of a hassle than they should be. Next, I hope, the government will sort out the fiasco that is driving tests!
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Passports have basically been "solved" now. Where you used to have to go to a chemist to get a photo taken, hope they were suitable, get a policeman's signature, and wait weeks to get one, you can now renew online with a self-taken photo in about 5 mins, and it comes in a week.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Still have to wear the suit, but there is progress!
Miquel Ros
@rosmiquel
@timleunig right when you had had your new suit delivered!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Arthur Turrell
@arthurturrell
www.ft.com/content/560fc2ad-5c7e-4878-ae9b-a3183004c394?s…
Great to see this come out—I know incredible levels of hard work have gone into it.
More broadly, it's... quite the change in narrative of what has happened to the UK economy over the last 2 decades. May suggest different policies too (targeting hours) -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
One of the reasons tax politics is broken is that many people on the Left combine a belief in higher state spending with a belief people pay too much tax.
The reality is that people on median/low incomes in the UK pay a low level of tax, by historic and international standards.
Sharon Graham
@UniteSharon
If the tax threshold of around £12,500 hadn't been frozen for the past few years it would have moved up to over £16,000. People at the lower end are paying eye-watering amounts of tax and it needs to change.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmd94epyg210o -
Tim Leunig reposted
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
Opposition parties operate on a shoestring
And it's hard to attract more donations - because if giving to politics is stigmatised as spivvy, only spivs will be happy to do it
We're calling for a culture change -
Tim Leunig reposted
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
Very, very few wealthy people or businesses give significant donations to political parties - last year the Donkey Sanctuary raked in more than every major party combined
This is what gives the tiny minority who do give the potential for outsized influence -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In which @meadwaj shows he paid attention in his @LSEnews lectures!
James Meadway
@meadwaj
Some serious confusion out there, so I'm going to spell it out:
- inflation is the rate of change of prices
- when prices go up, inflation rises, by definition
- supply shocks typically make prices go up
And when supply shocks are repeated, like today, inflation is persistent. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Josh Kirby
@joshkirbywrites
Human bricklayers are on notice...
I got to see robot bricklayers first-hand building new homes in the Netherlands. They can lay 1,000 bricks a day - twice as much as a human brickie - and it takes just a couple of months to train a human supervisor
And they're about to launch a pilot in the UK! This could have pretty major implications for construction costs and times
My report for @thetimes www.thetimes.com/life-style/property-home/article/the-ai-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
ELECTRIFICATION: Really striking chart showing that three-quarters of final energy demand can now be electrified "economically" (ie at lower lifetime cost) – and 90% electrification is technically possible
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
This, a thousand times.
You can complain about the complexity and mess that is the UK tax system,
or you can want ad hoc fixes - like making sure pensioners who only receive the state pension get an extended personal allowance, but no one else does
You can't do both.
Julian Jessop
@julianHjessop
Any income above the Personal Allowance, which is the amount of income on which you do not have to pay tax, should be taxed...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
100% agree with this. Rich liberals need to step up and be counted, for their country and their principles. Donate now!
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
The problem with big money in British politics is that there isn't enough of it
@TheEconomist says this week that liberals who are outraged about Reform's cash bonanza should dig into their own pockets
Better funding is crucial to prepare opposition parties for power -
Tim Leunig reposted
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
I agree with this. So let's do some planning.
Say I need real-terms £20k/year to live well in retirement. How much of that will be covered by the state pension? The unpredictability of the triple lock means I have no idea. I therefore don't know how big a private pension I need. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Not disagreeing! FWIW I think lots of Chinese car firms will go bust (some are not very good) and that will lead to lots of factories for sale in China. BUT remember that companies that produce only in one country are VERY vulnerable to currency swings 1/2
Andrew Neil
@afneil
Almost every Chinese EV manufacturer is losing money. They have no desire to add to their losses by building overseas capacity they don’t need.
The Chery/Nissan ‘deal’ is not yet a done deal. Let’s see what it amounts to in practice. But it will only ever involve the use of existing capacity. Not new capacity.
Chinese EV exports benefit from an intentionally undervalued currency. There is very little currency risk when the Chinese government manipulates it to China’s advantage.
There is simply no prospect of the Chinese coming to rescue the British car industry. They’re out to destroy it. On current trends/policies they will succeed.
While the UK government/policy elite twiddles its thumbs.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
1) Even if there is general overcapacity, some firms may have too little capacity. 2) @Nissan may have offered Chery Motors a very good deal to use part of the underused Sunderland car plant 3) To reduce currency risk (many firms produce where they sell for that reason)
Andrew Neil
@afneil
China already has massive EV production overcapacity in China. And I mean massive (see The Andrew Neil Report: China Shock 2.0). Hence the global export drive.
So why would it build more capacity in the UK? Especially since the UK government has just ruled out tariffs?
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Daihatsu had to pull out of UK etc when the Yen got too strong, and is part of the reason Toyota, Nissan etc produce in France/UK/US etc. FINALLY I think energy intensive manufacturing will mainly go to sunny places, because solar is now the lowest cost power source. 2/2
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well this looks like good news for me!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
1) Even if there is general overcapacity, some firms may have too little capacity. 2) @Nissan may have offered Chery Motors a very good deal to use part of the underused Sunderland car plant 3) To reduce currency risk (many firms produce where they sell for that reason)
Andrew Neil
@afneil
China already has massive EV production overcapacity in China. And I mean massive (see The Andrew Neil Report: China Shock 2.0). Hence the global export drive.
So why would it build more capacity in the UK? Especially since the UK government has just ruled out tariffs? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Iain Mansfield
@IGMansfield
“This is a government that is learning the hard way that one plus one equals two, having been under the bizarre prior belief that this was not the case.”
Superb quote from the inimitable @timleunig.
www.timeshighereducation.com/news/ministers-wont-bow-plan… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Albrecht Ritschl
@AlbrechtRitschl
PISA: It's the English language, stupid!
A provocative substack on immigrant quality and PISA scores by former @LSEEcHist colleague and highly influential UK policy advisor Tim Leunig👇:
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My free to read substack looks at the policy implications of the recent "PISA" results for schools. My answers may surprise you... timleunig.substack.com/p/pisa
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I didn't realise that @reformparty_uk voters were most anti our Royal Family. Interesting polling from @YouGov. yougov.com/en-gb/articles/55269-royal-family-favourabilit…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Legislators can always listen to people with expertise - the people with the expertise do not have to have a vote. Chris Whitty, the greatest public servant I had the privilege to work with, was much listened to, and rightly so.
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
The difficulty with that argument is that democracy actually involves the interplay of different kinds of legitimacy: by election, by expertise, by merit, by due process. We benefit inestimably from having people with real expertise in our legislature who would never or could never stand for election.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Democracy is the only way I know to confer legitimacy on a legislature (as opposed to a health board, police force, or the Bank of England).
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
Take the point seriously for a second, step back from current politics and imagine a reformed (non-cronyistic) but non-elected second chamber. Do you think that election is the only way to confer legitimacy in public policy-making?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think, for once, you are internally inconsistent, @rcolvile. A local govt funding formula that was "purely need-based" is the same as assuming every LA charges the national average for council tax! Then if your LA is more efficient, you get lower council tax. 1/3
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
I agree with Tim on many things but not everything. A funding formula that assumes everyone charges the national average is a recipe for punishing thrift and rewarding waste.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
There is next to no evidence that Wandsworth is more efficient than (say) Dorset (top in England) or Kingston (top in London). Both have high council tax when run by Tories or LDs. Nothing to do with inefficiency, just different grant levels. 2/3
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I never understood why Gordon Brown did not sort out local govt financing back in the day, and I am glad @AngelaRayner has now done so. The new system is fairer, although I agree that it will be a shock for many in the previously oversubsidised areas. 3/3
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is true - and serious govt action on the cost of living needs to be about sensible deregulation, not gimmicks on the cost of going to a theme park.
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
Two things will be simultaneously true and argued over as UK inflation rises over the coming months.
This is a global inflection higher in consumer prices, the UK government (past, or present) are not the initial catalyst.
But it is also true (and very clear in the recent inflation data) that costs of undertaking economic activity that are domestically determined (taxes, levies, price locks, constrained supply of energy, land and capital) have been amplified by government action. This has meant higher UK price growth than peers.
Partisan takes will consider only one of these aspects this morning, and over the coming months. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Allen
@Joe___Allen
Look at these charts from @timleunig (very interesting) PISA column.
First generation immigrant kids in Wales are the equivalent of a year ahead on reading. Second generation are two years ahead.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My free to read substack looks at the policy implications of the recent "PISA" results for schools. My answers may surprise you... timleunig.substack.com/p/pisa
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Indeed, but only because land prices are distorted by affordable housing requirements etc that apply only to housing, and not to industrial land...
JN
@JonNeale
Residential land values are no longer always the highest use value in London, even in inner boroughs.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But manufacturing in London. As opposed to Chatham, where I grew up? @BromptonBicycle has moved from Chiswick to outer London, and now to Ashford, Kent. Seems sensible to me. The first site is now flats...
AB
@botzarelli
It’s easy to underestimate the value of high precision engineering of mechanical components and it being a thing which is capable of being done at scale and at prices which are competitive with China etc.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, that is true. But still, residential typically has higher values still.
Chris Howell
@ChrisHowellFCA
Surely its significantly increasing the value of the land use compared to any other types of industrial unit of which there are loads.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I wish them luck, but this seems a pretty odd use of land in central London. I imagine it is only possible because the council bans houses from that site. Overall these sorts of planning rules are a big part of why the UK is so poor.
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
This is absolutely amazing. Good luck to them!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
Not a dignified ending. Not a good way to go out.
Americans deserve better than this. The politicians' families deserve better than this. No more.
Appodlachia
@appodlachia
Yeah there ain’t nothin going on up there
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Matt Chorley
@MattChorley
Ahead of Friday Newsnight’s move to 7pm, I spoke to @RadioTimes about how I find being at the BBC weirdly freeing, rather than the exhausting process of rustling up hot new fresh takes for the podcast numbers.
www.radiotimes.com/tv/current-affairs/newsnight-matt-chor… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Richard Selfridge
@Databusting
Fascinating PISA analysis from Tim Leunig here - lots of food for thought.
timleunig.substack.com/p/pisa -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Although that makes it harder to understand the non-English speaking country results...
Isca Augusta
@cmonmun
Largely number two, I would say from personal experience, but also there’s a selection bias effect I would think as to emmigrate to a different country requires at least a bit of get up and go, which probably means you’re more likely to push and encourage your children to achieve
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We what what is, we don't know why.
Citizen Cymru
@Prof_Weinidog
Is that because immigrants children are more intelligent than Welsh ones or because immigrant parents put a higher value on educational achievement?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My free to read substack looks at the policy implications of the recent "PISA" results for schools. My answers may surprise you... timleunig.substack.com/p/pisa
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
If the priority is growth then this makes little sense. There are lots of tax cuts that can drive growth (including SDLT, which the Tories previously said they wanted to abolish)
The evidence suggests IHT abolition has little or no impact on growth. www.oecd.org/en/publications/inheritance-taxation-in-oecd…
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: Kemi Badenoch is set to announce the Tories will abolish inheritance tax if they win the next election
[@MillardClothier] -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Wow - looks like another way in with the @andyburnham government means "No change whatsoever". Thought there would at least be a figleaf of change, given all the earlier rhetoric from the new Secretary of State, @LucyMPowell
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
Student loans: The @hmtreasury response to the @CommonsTreasury, which came out at midnight, is a litany of ways to say ‘No’. After two years of saying they’ll change loan terms, is it now time for Ministers to start actively defending the system they run? www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cr4vq7rw27qo
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Flattery accepted gracefully, but it will not persuade me that an unelected legislature is a good idea, @Jesse_Norman !
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
An elected second chamber remains a shockingly bad idea. And @timleunig is a perfect example of one of the reasons why.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I do not think we should have an unelected House of Lords. I would throw them out - and me out!
Tim Worstall
@worstall
What fun that would be. Someone else appoints the senior bishops, who by their very position have a seat in the Lords. So, who is it that should have this power of appointment to the legislature?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am on record repeatedly calling for the House of Lords to be replaced with an elected second chamber. I hope Andy Burnham abolishes me!
Kevin Meagher
@KevinPMeagher
It’s a bit rich for a putative Peer of the Realm lecturing about legitimate mandates, surely?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A delight to be able to quiz and listen to the ever thoughtful @dantomlinsonmp at the @nesta_uk #policylive conference yesterday. He wants growth - hope he delivers it!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think Thatcher chose George Carey over the church's preferred candidate. So I don't think it is a trivial technicality. Also, it is a waste of the PM's time, and it can delay appointments.
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Discrimination against Catholics and Jews should be removed from the statute on core liberal principle. Beyond that, isn't this just a trivial technicality? I presume the PM has no active involvement in the selection of the archbishop.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am on record as supporting an elected second chamber. Out with me! Out with the bishops!
Neil Garratt AM
@NeilGarratt
Tesco doesn't get an automatic right to 2 dozen seats in the Lords, though. If they did, I dare say people would similarly argue the CEO appointment is not a purely private matter.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
NEW: This is a story about just how hard it is to build in Hackney
Hackney's councillors failed to approve the council’s own application to turn ‘community flat’ back into a one-bed council flat.
– The application ran to 128 pages
– "Community Involvement" started 2 years ago
– The replacement meeting room is a four-minute walk away
– Councillors still spent 90 mins debating it and then demanded the council come back with more evidence
www.samdumitriu.com/p/how-hard-is-it-to-build-in-hackney -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
I am getting so fed up with this narrative. It is so desperate, so full of bad faith, and so easily disproved.
Basically, knowledge-based curriculums have succeeded. They work. We have so much evidence that they work.
But now you have lots of people saying "oh well maybe it's worked in a narrow sense, but it's caused all these other problems like mental health, youth unemployment, attendance problems".
No. Scotland and Wales did opposite education reforms to England and have the same or worse problems with mental health, youth unemployment, attendance.
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/schools-arent-to-blame-for-t…
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/do-knowledge-rich-curriculum… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ismael Sanz
@sanz_ismael
En PISA 2009 Irlanda sufrió la mayor caída en lectura de los 39 países que participaron también en 2000. En PISA 2025 saca 500 puntos, primera de la UE y tercera de la OCDE. Cómo lo hicieron?
La respuesta fue la Estrategia Nacional de Alfabetización y Cálculo 2011-2020, lanzada en julio de 2011 para diez años.
Los centros de primaria, desde enero de 2012, dedican una hora más a la semana a la lectura y 70 minutos más a las matemáticas. No una recomendación: una circular con horario.
www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/202… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
What's amazing about the global bond sell-off is how many people are saying rising yields are about strong growth. Seriously!? You think rising yields in Japan, France, Italy or UK are about growth? We're in a global debt shock. Not a global growth shock.
robinjbrooks.substack.com/p/the-dollar-debasement-trap -
Tim Leunig reposted
Boyan Slat
@BoyanSlat
Every time I visit the UK I’m struck by the vast amount of health and safety signage cluttering public spaces. It’s not just ugly, but it probably makes you ignore any safety message that is genuinely important.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The church should be appointing its leaders, not have politicians appoint them. Similarly the board of Tesco, not the PM, should appoint the next Tesco CEO.
Madeline Grant
@Madz_Grant
Why?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My view is that if the Church of England is not willing to treat women and LGBT+ people on equal terms, in accordance with the law, it should lose all rights to act on behalf of the state (e.g. conduct weddings, have influence in state schools, etc).
George Russell
@G_T_Russell
⬆️thanks: what do you consider are the reciprocal obligations of @churchofengland, as a condition of being the "state church" in England, with regard to the ordained ministry of women and LGBT folk?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Obviously what is unacceptable is that any PM - Anglican, Catholic, Hindu - etc should be appointing Bishops.
Jason Groves
@JasonGroves1
NEW: Andy Burnham denounces 'unacceptable' law that bars him, as a Catholic, from undertaking the PM's role in appointing Church of England bishops. Says the 'archaic' law will be changed. In the meantime, the role will be filled by Justice Sec Alex Norris questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-statements/det…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Am I old enough to warrant the description "veteran economist"? @ScotExpress: "Veteran economist Tim Leunig, who was economic adviser to chancellors Sajid Javid and Rishi Sunak, and who invented the Covid furlough scheme, also paid attention to the [Scotland Pisa] scandal."
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I recollect that @educationgovuk had (pre-covid era) evidence that schools that offered BTECs as well as GCSEs had lower absence rates (taking into account other things) - which would suggest that you are right, @LordLucasCD. Not sure on your specific q, however.
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
I will hazard a guess that it may be due to something I have frequently observed but never proved: if a child is allowed to excel at something they love, their whole performance is lifted. Does taking GCSE PE lift Progress 8?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Be very surprised if the time spent teaching English, maths, and science has changed much since then!
Peter Kemp
@peterejkemp
They used to report on this, but not since 2018. Back then you're correct, UK comparatively higher time on science than maths and English.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I believe these estimates account for gender, free school meals status and KS2 scores, for the reasons you imply!
isthisit
@isthisit
To some extent this will just be it being a proxy for being male
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, the IFS has done that.
Peter Kemp
@peterejkemp
You're not going to take a medicine degree on straight Cs at A-level, you might take a computing degree on those grades. Controlling for university and prior attainment in this would be really helpful.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is plausible. Being used to working hard and learning self discipline are both good skills to have m
Rob
@Berty23
My theory based on no evidence apart from sports coaching. Large component is the practical element and getting to a good level in a sport is hard work and needs dedication. Hours and hours of practice so it could be a mindset? Probably wrong.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Bennett OBE
@tombennett71
No child should leave primary school unable to read., unless there is a severe cognitive impairment. Not one.
David James
@drdavidajames
Damning by @alexmassie
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Doug Lemov
@Doug_Lemov
The Finnish myth will never die.
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
@marcportermagee
The NEA said we should all copy Finland. Checking in on that model …
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sadly Scotland has not published returns to different subjects, unlike England.
alexmassie
@alexmassie
Also: kids are *not* doing PE because they are looking at future earnings/prospects! Ask them why PE is popular and they will tell you - "Because it's easy and impossible to fail". (96% a-C at Nat 5; 87% at Higher).
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Comp sci has good returns at degree level, but some subjects are better. Medicine, econ, law and business are better as @TheIFS show share.google/Exry8pWpBfPiBR2e9
Mike Ireland
@mikeireland100
What also makes this interesting is the long term impact. Consider comp sci - if it’s not offered at gcse then you won’t do well or not be allowed to study it at a level. That then precludes you from studying it at a top university where you get the best outcomes & salary
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Thanks for posting that, @LucyHunterB . I should have said that "PE is the third best GCSE to do well in". As to why? Truth is we don't know... 1/3
Lucy Hunter Blackburn
@LucyHunterB
It’s that the earnings impact of one grade improvement is third highest for PE, not just the fact of doing the GCSE. Still an interesting fact to explain, but importantly different. @IGMansfield
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Lots of theories offered in the comments, but no evidence for them. Maybe doing well in PE is a proxy for social class, and more so than in other subjects. Maybe. But no evidence! (I am sceptical) 2/3
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Maybe it is about competitiveness. Maybe... Let me add one more: PE rewarded teamwork in a way no other GCSE does. That might well correlate with economic success, and maybe doing PE GCSE develops that skill. 3/3
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Urban Cycling Institute 🚲
@fietsprofessor
LONDON🇬🇧 is the next major city that shows how reducing car traffic delivers real, measurable public-health gains.
AFTER #ulez zone:
📉 NO₂ down by 38%
🏥 Fewer hospital admissions
☠️ An estimated 40% fall in deaths linked to air pollution
🧒 Kids health shows recovery -
Tim Leunig reposted
Gabe Econ
@GabeEcon
Greg Mankiw releases his econ reading list for his freshman seminar:
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A minimum wage job counts as a positive outcome on that stat. That is a hugely disappointing outcome for someone who with a better school could have had more choice and agency in their lives (and paid more taxes to support the NHS etc).
Paul Rollo
@paul
if the claim is “destroying futures”, shouldn’t we test it against outcomes? 93.5% are in positive destinations at 9 months, vs 85.9% in 2009/10. how do we reconcile that? is PISA telling us something those outcomes miss, or are we mistaking a proxy for the thing itself?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Obvs there are standard correlations of school outcomes and GDP. Causation is hard, and you have persuaded me that education failures are not the constraining factor in the UK.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
What's your favourite source on "poor school outcomes mean lower tax revenues, and higher benefit spending" across countries (or education systems). Not studies within a country.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Agree, although don't mock PE qualificaitons @alexmassie. The data show in England PE GCSE is the #3 best predictor of later earnings - see p. 36 of assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/60c36f0cd3bf7f4bd1…. Beaten only by Maths and Business Studies.
alexmassie
@alexmassie
Unfortunate truths about Scottish education:
The number of high-achieving kids has collapsed by 40% in the past 20 years.
PE is now the third most popular subject at Higher.
Just 40% percent of kids pass English and Maths at National 5 (ie, GCSE).
Scottish 15 year olds are more than a year behind English 15 year olds in Maths and Science.
"Knowledge" is a contested idea in Scottish education.
And the SNP government's response? The situation is "essentially stable".
Column on a great national disgrace. 👇
www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/scotland-education-p… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well, I have spoken about it for a long time!
alexmassie
@alexmassie
It’s been fascinating to see journalists & think tankers in London - @jburnmurdoch, @timleunig etc - catch-up with Scotland’s educational disaster this week. The problems have been apparent for a decade. Perhaps this external shame will help bring change..
www.thetimes.com/article/e17a3386-d463-4338-be11-a01e49d7… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, the decline in Scottish schools standards is one of the great under-reported tragedies of our time. So sad. (And bad for the whole UK, because poor school outcomes mean lower tax revenues, and higher benefit spending)
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
When I started in education politics 35 years ago, Scotland was the object admiration and envy.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have also found many people unwilling to face facts about poor quality school outcomes in Scotland. (Or, as they termed it a decade ago, and maybe still, "the learner journey experience". - aka "A child's time at school"... Jargon like that does not help)
Tomomom
@momobaboon
Interesting. I’m at EAIE in Scotland and listened to a presentation this morning about how education is Scotland’s gem. Certainly punches above its weight in terms of universities, but that schools data is disturbing.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
And if Yvette Cooper reverses Wes Streetings reintegration of NHS-England, there will even be within-party reversals!
John McTernan
@Johnmcternan
Most successful UK government social policies are bi partisan like that - see also social security (Joseph/Fowler/Brown/Duncan Smith), welfare to work (Lilley/Harman). Health has suffered from interruptions on both sides (Dobson/Lansley).
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
PISA covers this. We spend time more on science than most countries, but not more on E & M (at least that was true when I was in DfE, have not checked the current results)
Arthur Paneal
@Arthur_Paneal
How much does curriculum time devoted to Maths, English and Science vary across countries? My primary age daughter seams to spend most of the day on phonics and maths. When I was a secondary school teacher, I noticed a gradual increase in the time devoted to the core subjects
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Claus Vistesen
@ClausVistesen
Your regular reminder that the UK economy needs looser monetary policy and tighter fiscal policy, but is instead getting the opposite. The optimal (individual) response? Save like the Chinese!
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Very hard to see how the @bankofengland can do anything other than raise interest rates. Operation Epic Fury is raising global inflation and harming our economy.
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
The latest estimates for the UK's Energy Price Cap from January would see the nominal cap back at levels last seen in Q2 2023, and an 18% increase from the Q4 26 level (it would be the largest QoQ change since Q4 2022). Strap in for the language from the BoE to change next week as this looks like a more persistent spike in prices than their more benign scenario.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Very hard to see how the @bankofengland can do anything other than raise interest rates. Operation Epic Fury is raising global inflation and harming our economy.
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
The latest estimates for the UK's Energy Price Cap from January would see the nominal cap back at levels last seen in Q2 2023, and an 18% increase from the Q4 26 level (it would be the largest QoQ change since Q4 2022). Strap in for the language from the BoE to change next week as this looks like a more persistent spike in prices than their more benign scenario.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They are not perfect, of course, no measure is. But they correlate well with outcomes such as GCSEs, which in turn are a good predictor of getting a decent job, with all the good outcomes that involves?
Paul Rollo
@paul
are pisa scores the measure of a successful education system? genuine question.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Laurie Macfarlane
@L__Macfarlane
Pisa results aren’t everything, but something has clearly gone wrong with Scotland’s education system over the last 20 years.
Scotland used to top these charts - and it’s an area where blaming Westminster doesn’t wash.
Serious change needed. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I had not realised that British are less worried about education that people in other countries - if your theory is right (e.g. people know about educational outcomes) we should see different results in England vs Scotland. Do we? Genuinely interested to find out...
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
Doesn’t it imply the last 10 years of so of education policy haven’t been a disaster on these metrics vs other countries (and perhaps why British are LESS worried about education in latest ipsos global study than other countries)
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is right: time to celebrate all those involved in English education over the last 45 years. Whatever the PM may think, this country, under all parties, has got something right!
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
2) England is a rare exception.
During the 2010s many other countries (including the other 3 UK nations) changed tack, experimenting with ideas like transferrable skills instead of focusing on tried-and-tested disciplines and methods. It looks like those experiments have failed. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
NYC's murder rate is 3x higher than London's, and it's not just guns: you're twice as likely to die from knife crime in NYC as in London.
Even the safest state, New Hampshire, has a higher murder rate than London, let alone the whole UK. Vermont's murder rate is triple London's! -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
England's education advisors and teachers must be applauded in maintaining academic excellence! 👏
Though this high human capital makes the terrible youth labour market even more tragic.
Brilliant young people are entering a jobs market where skills are poorly rewarded, productivity remains low, often outstripped by high minimum wages, and a welfare system without in-person checks keeps a million young people neither in education, employment or training.
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
2) England is a rare exception.
During the 2010s many other countries (including the other 3 UK nations) changed tack, experimenting with ideas like transferrable skills instead of focusing on tried-and-tested disciplines and methods. It looks like those experiments have failed. -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Thomas
@dmthomas90
England is now the 10th best country in the world for mathematics. The only countries outside of East Asia to beat us were Estonia and Switzerland. We as a country owe our maths teachers (which includes all primary teachers!) a huge well done and thank you.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is right: time to celebrate all those involved in English education over the last 45 years. Whatever the PM may think, this country, under all parties, has got something right!
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
2) England is a rare exception.
During the 2010s many other countries (including the other 3 UK nations) changed tack, experimenting with ideas like transferrable skills instead of focusing on tried-and-tested disciplines and methods. It looks like those experiments have failed. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
And what is interesting is that England has not seen this decline. We and Estonia should be models for any democracy wanting a successful education system
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
🧵1. Attentionpocalypse
A thread on a process of worldwide illiteratization, with some evidence on the mechanism.
Today, the OECD produced evidence of an accelerating drop (by now equivalent to almost 2 years of schooling) in reading scores since 2012. -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Thomas
@dmthomas90
As usual, @timleunig is absolutely right here. English success in education is due to a consistent policy direction over decades, where each government has built on what worked under the last.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
All three parties in England share responsibility for our education success. Labour's Jim Callaghan first PM to give a speech on education, Conservative Ken Baker with the knowledge rich curriculum, and GCSEs not O levels/CSEs, Labour's @Andrew_Adonis with academies and 1/3
Michael Gove
@michaelgove
Good Lib Dem wisdom
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am sure those who have run Scottish Education since 2000 had good intentions. No-one sets out to harm children and destroy their futures. But they have done just that. They need to acknowledge that, repent of error, come to England, see what works, and change course.
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Education was, for generations, Scotland's great advantage point. No longer.
New PISA results out today shows how devolution turned Scottish schools into a labs for experiments - with fateful consequences. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am not claiming Welsh schools are good, only that the stand out failure in the UK is Scotland!
Joe Allen
@Joe___Allen
Rhys Williams﮷
@RhysWilliamsTV
This stood out in my analysis of the underlying data.
Poverty is often cited as the reason for Wales' poor performance, but what about this:
England’s most disadvantaged quarter scored 473 in reading, against Wales’s overall average of 459. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
All three parties in England share responsibility for our education success. Labour's Jim Callaghan first PM to give a speech on education, Conservative Ken Baker with the knowledge rich curriculum, and GCSEs not O levels/CSEs, Labour's @Andrew_Adonis with academies and 1/3
Michael Gove
@michaelgove
Good Lib Dem wisdom
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am sure those who have run Scottish Education since 2000 had good intentions. No-one sets out to harm children and destroy their futures. But they have done just that. They need to acknowledge that, repent of error, come to England, see what works, and change course.
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Education was, for generations, Scotland's great advantage point. No longer.
New PISA results out today shows how devolution turned Scottish schools into a labs for experiments - with fateful consequences.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
@LordBlunkett with the literacy hour and numeracy hour, LibDem David Laws with Progress 8 and the National Funding Formula for Schools, and yes, @michaelgove's curriculum and assessment reforms and @NickGibbUK with phonics. 2/3
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
All three parties share in this success - and I hope this continues. @BeckyFrancis7 curriculum review gives me hope, and I hope the current government makes a big song and dance, but changes little. There are plenty of other issues in our country that need tackling. 3/3
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Wales is much poorer than England or Scotland, so we would expect education results to be worse. That is why I think Scotland is the UK education tragedy, not Wales.
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
And Wales.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Wales is much poorer than England or Scotland, so we would expect education results to be worse. That is why I think Scotland is the UK education tragedy, not Wales.
Jeffrey Jones@OldParish
@Jeffrey62093861
Same applies to Wales ?
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am sure those who have run Scottish Education since 2000 had good intentions. No-one sets out to harm children and destroy their futures. But they have done just that. They need to acknowledge that, repent of error, come to England, see what works, and change course.
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Education was, for generations, Scotland's great advantage point. No longer.
New PISA results out today shows how devolution turned Scottish schools into a labs for experiments - with fateful consequences. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
People running schools in every democracy should now be buying tickets to visit Estonia and England - "the only two countries outside East Asia to come in the top 10 for reading, maths & science." And reading everything written by @daisychristo on the way over...
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
The PISA 2025 results are out today. Some quick insights.
- The major story is very significant global decline. The last PISA study was in 2022, and saw big declines in reading and maths scores from 2018. Obviously the pandemic played a part.
- But this 2025 round has seen further falls even from the 2022 lows!
Things haven't gone back to normal post-pandemic - they've got worse.
Every generation thinks the generation below is less smart - but this time they might be right! -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The story of my buying a suit. I had to dig deep for this one... www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:750300635926…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am sure those who have run Scottish Education since 2000 had good intentions. No-one sets out to harm children and destroy their futures. But they have done just that. They need to acknowledge that, repent of error, come to England, see what works, and change course.
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Education was, for generations, Scotland's great advantage point. No longer.
New PISA results out today shows how devolution turned Scottish schools into a labs for experiments - with fateful consequences. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am very confident that UK use of personal defence drones will be limited to sub-lethal force!!! Glad that is "likely" to be true in America as well...
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Very possibly! Although interestingly, my understanding from my lawyer friends is that they will likely be limited to sub-lethal force in the US, based on this precedent from "spring gun" law: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katko_v._Briney
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I imagine that the outcome of "how much force can a home defence drone use" debate might well be different in the US and the UK, @ahall_research !
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Yes -- we are also going to see the rise of personal home defense drones, followed by a long policy debate over how much force those drones are allowed to use, under what circumstances, and so on.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is a good book - I enjoyed reading it. Definitely worth 99p!
Tom Whipple
@whippletom
Do you want to read my book, about derring do and the electromagnetic war? Do you want to read it, but not if it is priced more than 99p? Good news! Get it this month on kindle.
www.amazon.co.uk/Battle-Beams-secret-science-turned-ebook… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Hill
@jo3hill
It’s a terrible shame we have priced Londoners out of living in London. The ratio of costs to earning growing like this is the clearest measure that supply is too constrained.
Joe Allen
@Joe___Allen
When I was in my mid-20s a typical one-bed flat in Cardiff cost about 32% of median take-home pay for a young person (<30) in full-time work. That figure is now about 42% (£902).
That's a drag on the city’s economy & probably a not insignificant part of our brain drain problem. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (£/free trial) looks at the policy lessons we can draw from the government's recent crackdown on firms flouting the minimum wage. Turns out it is complex, and could be easier - and I have an idea on how to improve things... timleunig.substack.com/p/when-the-law-is-an-ass
-
Tim Leunig reposted
ianVisits
@ianvisits
Kew Gardens offering £10 tickets for visits on Tuesdays
(link to article in reply below)
Kew Gardens in southwest London has launched a £10 ticket offer for visitors to the large walled estate who turn up on Tuesdays. -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Lawrence
@dc_lawrence
Some quick takes on the Chancellor's growth speech today...
I'm pleased to see:
- Fingleton-style review of rail infrastructure costs (see our @BritishProgress graph + map below)
- Extending judicial review reforms from energy to all major infrastructure
- Intention to reduce burden of business regulation by 25% (devil in the detail, of course)
- Ending the "consultation culture" in government, new guidance that legal risk should not be determining factor
- Fiscal devo including greater business rates retention
- Regulatory sandboxing powers to be introduced next year
- Recommitted to implement the Fingleton Review of nuclear regulation
- Recognition of gilts crisis requiring fiscal discipline
Was less keen on:
- Green Book reforms reducing discount rate to 3%. This is a bit of a cheeky way of making projects seem more valuable, and seems out of step with 30 year gilt yields touching 6%.
Would have liked to have seen more on:
- Housebuilding. Planning got a mention, but housing is the biggest constraint on UK growth, particularly in London/SE.
- Energy bills. JR & nuclear reforms deal with longer term cost, but short term policy costs remain.
But overall, it's great to see that the Chancellor clearly gets how fundamental growth is to delivering on the Government's agenda. The real work is to succeed where previous Chancellors have failed, and turn intention into action.
BBC Politics
@BBCPolitics
"I dedicate myself to this mission as chancellor, to make Great Britain, growth Britain again," John Healey says
"I want to see this country as a country of wealth creation," he adds
Follow live: www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/c6x2z89exk4kt?at_bbc_team=editorial -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
particularly important article on Keynesian from Andy Haldane - www.ft.com/content/e1afdbf1-eb21-45c0-ad88-1ec0913b1f7c?s… @fteconomics
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sad to see this level of economic illiteracy from @griffitha (who has no background in econ, I think). Fast growing developing countries always top the growth table, because they have catch up potential. #economichistory101 @LSEEcHist
Andrew Griffith MP
@griffitha
Labour like to compare us with the G7.
In reality, it’s the veterans’ race.
G20 countries like Mexico and India are overtaking us. That can’t be the height of our ambition.
We Conservatives will work every single day on plans to bring back growth and cut the cost of living.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Half of all articles about statistics are below average:
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
According to @BBCNews, @PwC_UK have found that almost 50% of people live in areas with "less spending power than the national average". Either @BBCNews or @PwC_UK need to learn how averages work... Truly shocking. www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/crerw510gdzo
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Some blazers are striped, or edged. That makes this strategy impossible. That is why I think government is right to take action.
John
@wb_biod
Why can't people just buy the clothes in Tesco and iron the badge on like lots of us did in the 90's / 00's?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes @ZiaYusufUK! I understand what happened: Britain gave safe haven to a child from a civil war. That child grew up here, became British, went to uni, became a school governor, a local councillor and now local people might now choose her as their MP. British values in action!
Zia Yusuf
@ZiaYusufUK
The front runner being foisted on the people of Holborn by Labour to replace the former Prime Minister Keir Starmer in our Parliament was born in Somalia.
Do you understand what’s happening? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Weird to discover that if you register with the ICO it offers you a (relatively short) selection of job categories, including "Chief Constable of a Police Force" (do these people really form companies? And "Barking Mad Franchisee". Really??? ico.org.uk/for-organisations/data-protection-fee/register…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
4 of the top 6 best selling UK cars last month are from China - evidence that free trade increases choice and reduces the cost of living for people here. www.carwow.co.uk/news/11237/smmt-new-car-registrations-au… @EdConwaySky
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Why not maker it 99p on kindle? Then you would be supporting reading!
James Marriott
@j_amesmarriott
The New Dark Ages, my book about the end of reading and what it means for our society is out now!
By purchasing it you can help to hold back the spread of the post-literate society (and by refusing to purchase it you will only confirm my thesis!) -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
There were a range of views in the department as to how to understand uniform choice, shall we say.
Stuart Lock
@StuartLock
If the DFE really knew that some schools were inventing expensive uniforms to put poor families off applying, they should have used the law on admissions to have stopped it in those schools. And intervened with their soft power. Not doing so is negligent.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
For once I disagree with @nickhillman. When I was in @educationgovuk it was clear to me (1) some schools were inventing expensive uniforms to deter poor families (2) perfectly easy to come up with a lower priced uniform. 1/2
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
It’s a ridiculous position for any politician who claims they want to devolve power. I’ve been in school governors’ meetings where we have to discuss which bit of uniform we’re going to cull. It’s all a way to dodge important educational questions.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My own preference, in case anyone cares, is to follow China and basically have a "PE kit" style uniform - something kids can actually do exercise in, not our old fashioned pseudo-office approach to 11 year old dress. 2/2
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well, if two southbound are cancelled, surely it is inevitable that two northbound are cancelled? That is how trains work!
George Russell
@G_T_Russell
@LumoTravel utterly astonishing: today (Friday 4 September) two of the four southbound Stirling > Euston services* AND two of the four northbound Euston > Stirling services are cancelled due to staff shortages/repairs. [*one of which my son was due to travel on] @StirObserver
-
Tim Leunig reposted
𒊓𒅂𒁓𒐗𒐕𒐗 Steve the skeptic
@sib313
Try starting with proper analysis of the NHS: blogs.york.ac.uk/healthcare-management-capacity/2024/08/1…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
𒊓𒅂𒁓𒐗𒐕𒐗 Steve the skeptic
@sib313
This is the dumbest argument about the NHS I've seen in years. Total management costs in the NHS are the lowest in any major health system and far below the levels in Tesco or the whole British economy...
lucy johnston
@thelucyjohnston
NHS hospital boards could be costing taxpayers more than £500million a year, researchers claim
@carlheneghan www.gbnews.com/health/nhs-hospital-boards-taxpayer-waste-… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Full marks to @andyburnham.bsky.social for helping with the cost of living. His book with Steve Rotheram, "Head North" is 99p on kindle today! amazon.co.uk/Head-North-Rallying-Equal-Britain-ebook/dp/B…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
According to @BBCNews, @PwC_UK have found that almost 50% of people live in areas with "less spending power than the national average". Either @BBCNews or @PwC_UK need to learn how averages work... Truly shocking. www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/crerw510gdzo
-
Tim Leunig reposted
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
I hereby declare the "learn to code" era officially dead:
Big declines in the number of people studying computer science in the last year or two 📉
Chart from this week’s edition of our newsletter on AI and the labour market www.ft.com/content/9183a122-10b7-4707-a728-b61ab50da378 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You are an economist. In fact, you should apply to be a Fellow of the Royal Economic Society! @RoyalEconSoc
Soumaya Keynes
@SoumayaKeynes
When is an economist not an economist? Do I count? My @FT column this week explores... www.ft.com/content/89f06927-5728-4e24-9a28-621869d03392?s…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
For once, @thomasforth and I disagree. Heathrow is the UK's major long haul airport, and for many people - particularly but not only in the South and Midlands - it is a far more convenient way to travel long haul than flying via Dublin etc. 1/2
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I think that Heathrow is an extremely important local economic asset and the power to decide on its expansion should remain local. I don't believe it meets the test to be of national importance. Markets are great. Competition is great.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I also think the failure of the UK to offer non-stop service to X, Y and Z makes us less likely as a nation to attract foreign direct investment - investment that yields tax revenue and helps us all, wherever we live.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
In a quixotic turn of events, our start of term Substack is on...the relative difficulty of the Guardian cryptic crossword over the last century.
Comparative Judgement is amazing at measuring the difficulty of tests over time. We used it for a study on A-level maths a few years ago. The obvious follow-up was to use it for cryptic crosswords!
Our CEO is Mycroft Holmes level good at cryptics. I am more like a Baker Street Irregular. We recruited a lot of judges via the crossword website fifteensquared and got the help of the Guardian's Boatman setter too (Ashley Knowles).
We had great fun doing this study, and in the post you can see a list of the crossword clues our judges found the hardest. Some of them are REALLY hard!
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/the-difficulty-of-the-guardi… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Everything is more complicated than a tweet!
Keith Turvey PhD
@Keith_Turvey
Well it’s a bit more complicated than that though.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Just for reference, @educationgovuk does not train teachers. Universities and schools train teachers, and have a lot of freedom as to how they do so.
Steve Lawrence
@SteveLawrence_
DfE fails to train teachers in ways which support such approaches.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That sounds like an outcome, not a policy
Steve Lawrence
@SteveLawrence_
Meaningful, productive, enterprise within schools.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Free to read: My 600 word substack discusses why the ban on paying a years rent upfront isn't working, and why the government should U turn. timleunig.substack.com/p/rental-reform
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think it was a coalition era Nick Clegg rule, since scrapped (sadly)
Yorkshire Steve
@Yorkshire_Steve
That seems not to be the case across most of the rest of the state sector (or people find their way around it).
Our head of sixth form and team worked tirelessly to secure appropriate professional role placements for pupils but often struggled unless 'parents knew someone'. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Scrapping employer NI for all under 25s would be pretty nuts? It would be very expensive, and no evidence it worked for the under 21s?
Jonathan Woodhead
@JonathanWoodhe2
Thanks Tim. You are right. There have been calls to extend it to under 25s recently.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
One thing I liked about being in govt was that the rules banned me from having my friends kids on work experience!
Yorkshire Steve
@Yorkshire_Steve
In my experience, the pupils who find it easiest to get work experience placements are those with parents who have contacts.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Saturday jobs declined long before the High St shrunk. If anything there are more evening roles than when I was a kid and Tesco shut at 8pm and few people ate out.
surrey nightmare
@nightmaresurrey
Decline of the high street means there are fewer Saturday jobs . Paperwork / compliance etc for schools & firms is ridiculous - just piling on more pressure on teachers
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
And what will you say to employers?
David Scales
@MrDavidScales
Young people tell me they struggle to get Saturday and holiday jobs, two thirds of companies say they don’t employ 16-17yos. These are young people who present well and have skills. We need to talk to employers on this one.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
UK has reduced net migration by about 75% from peak...
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
reduce and reverse mass immigration
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Anna Clarke
@AnnaClarke_____
I think a ( incorrect?) belief that if you employ under 16s you need to do DBS checks on your entire workforce is a significant reason for not emptying them. It's definitely a reason cited by employers for not taking work experience kids (even though definitely not needed there)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think that happened years ago? (and made no difference)
Jonathan Woodhead
@JonathanWoodhe2
Scrap employer NI contributions for under 21s. One start!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Erik Bootsma🌸🇳🇱
@ErikBootsma
Quick thread of buildings of university architecture departments. 🧵
Harvard
1/ -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
How would you fix this?
David Scales
@MrDavidScales
This is exactly the problem, there has been a decline in Saturday and holiday employment for young people. Couple that with the difficulty for businesses to offer work experience placements and schools to manage the same systems, and here we are. Let’s fix this!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
On NEETS, the Times reports that "Bosses’ next biggest concern was work experience, cited by 40 per cent. " I wonder how many of them offer work experience placements? Or Saturday jobs? Or summer jobs? Just sayin'... www.thetimes.com/uk/education/article/lack-of-soft-skills…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But you have to pay to be in Erasmus, etc etc... Who is going to be kicked out of these things? Would they be worse off? Would the EU?
Miquel Ros
@rosmiquel
This sounds harsh, but it’s true - if you can get pretty much all the advantages of being in without the inconveniences, why join?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
- Small boat arrivals 40% down from peak
- Foreign worker registrations at a 20-year low
- Remigration (foreign nationals leaving) at all-time high of 1,000 a day
It's quite a story. So why will no one in Labour tell it?
My summary of Britain's secret border-control success: -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They do! Far more unoccupied owner occupied houses than private rented houses.
Iwan Doherty
@IwanDoherty98
Not necessarily. Fewer landlords also means more owner occupiers. It'll only drive rents upwards if landlords are acting to compress households
-
Tim Leunig reposted
alexmassie
@alexmassie
Quite right. We certainly shouldn't do anything as stupid as knocking down a Nando's and building 1500 flats on a car park in Barnet. Madness!
Next thing you know, they'll be wanting to build houses near railway stations and, god, where will it all end?
City Hall Conservatives
@CityHallTories
Sadiq Khan’s tower block plans don’t stop at the green belt… @Councillorsuzie visited this leisure park in Barnet which Sadiq Khan is forcing highrise developments onto, without any respect for local residents’ concerns.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
John Van Reenen
@johnvanreenen
Labour share continues to fall in US www.ft.com/content/6f3ada65-c56c-499c-8eb6-008fac58949d?s… Goes alongside rise of superstar firms academic.oup.com/qje/article-abstract/135/2/645/5721266 This is not happening everywhere, though: in UK productivity & wages continue to move together www.johnvanreenen.com/_files/ugd/b451bf_fae1409784c0406ca…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Richard Corbett
@RichardGCorbett
They told us Brexit would save lots of money (that would all go to the NHS). In fact it’s costing us a fortune (and constraining our ability to fund everything).
-
Tim Leunig reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
A few initial thoughts on what has been announced this morning on changes to the early release scheme. First, it has to be acknowledged that this is a very difficult issue for whoever is in office. For decades, sentences have been increased, as has the prison population. 1/
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
One is left with an overwhelming question:
If two BBC reporters, backed by a handful of colleagues, can track down huge people-smugglers & talk to them, how come the State couldn't catch them, with all its resources: 140,000+ police, Immigration Service, Coastguard, MI5, MI6 etc? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think it is underappreciated just how high UK property taxes are. I had a go at designing a better system - I still think my plans have much merit, if @hmtreasury are interested in reform. ukonward.com/reports/a-fairer-property-tax/
Ben Ansell
@benwansell
Here's an example of how flat property taxes of 0.5% and 0.65% compare with similar countries - some higher, some lower. Right now though the UK actually gets more tax revenue from property than any other OECD country, just in a stupid way.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Now that would be a good right! Although it would cause chaos on the network...
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
Does that mean that you can get the train to stop there whenever you demand it?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The @MoJGovUK emailed me to say that, as of today, I am Lord Leunig of Surbiton...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This will be an outstanding book. It will probably be the best book on the British Empire. The authors are first class. @RoyHistory1 @LSEEcHist
Tirthankar Roy
@RoyHistory1
Announcing the publication of Leigh Gardner and Tirthankar Roy, The British Empire: An Economic History (London: Polity). Available for pre-order at www.politybooks.com/bookdetail?book_slug=the-british-empi…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Another view of progress: the enormous increase in autonomy and self-determination.
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
In my last two posts, I emphasized the enormous gains in material wealth and life expectancy that humanity has experienced over the past couple of centuries.
But those improvements are nothing compared with the monumental gains in what I call moral autonomy and self-determination. Two centuries ago, in 1826, the vast majority of people were far less free and far less able to shape their own futures or their communities’ futures.
Let me start with labor. One striking feature of economic history is that, for most of the human past, much labor has not been free but coerced through violence, ranging from the worst forms of chattel slavery to serfdom, peonage, and feudal tenancy. In 1826, for example, around 30% of workers worldwide were subject to some form of violent coercion and to legal limits on the work they may do (this is different from, and more restrictive than, economic limits, such as being a landless laborer with little choice of employer). If you are born in 1826, you stand a strong chance of being born to an enslaved mother in the Americas or to a serf in Russia. Today, the ILO computes that fewer than 1% of workers are coerced in this way.
Let me continue with gender. If you are a woman in 1826, your freedom to choose a husband, an education, an occupation, how many children to have, and to own property is severely limited nearly everywhere. If you are an enslaved or coerced woman, you face a very high chance of sexual assault during your lifetime. Free women suffer these attacks too, with next to no recourse.
Let me move to religion and ideology. If you belong to the “wrong” religion, denomination, or ideology, or if you simply love someone you “should not love,” you risk severe punishment. Even in the U.S., Massachusetts still has an established church and will keep it until 1833 (the First Amendment applied only to the federal government until Everson v. Board of Education, 330 U.S. 1 (1947)). In the U.K., we are three years away from the Roman Catholic Relief Act of 1829 and forty-five years away from the abolition of religious tests at Oxford and Cambridge.
In education and culture, 88% of people are illiterate, and fewer than 2% hold the equivalent of a high school degree. For most, the great works of art and literature play no part in daily life, beyond perhaps a religious image or text seen in the local temple.
Finally, almost nobody outside a small elite participates in political life. In 1826, only the U.S. can be called a democracy, and that stretches the word. With very few exceptions, only white adult men can vote, and even among them, several states, such as Virginia, restrict the franchise to about 50% of white adult males. Some Swiss cantons (but not all!) do better, and Norway, then in union with Sweden, has a relatively broad franchise for men. The United Kingdom (before the 1832 reform), France, and the Netherlands have very restricted franchises. And that is pretty much it. Nothing resembling democracy or the rule of law exists in all of Asia and Africa, most of the Americas, and the rest of Europe. In nearly all the world, you could be arrested at the whim of your ruler, and there was little you could do about it.
I do not want to paint too rosy a picture of 2026. Workers are still coerced. Gender inequalities remain large. In many parts of the world, you still cannot think what you want to think or choose your own romantic life. Democracy has badly backslid over the last two decades. And I am increasingly forced to remind people that due process is the twin sister of liberty.
But if I ask you, behind a veil of ignorance, whether you want to live in 1826 or 2026 (that is, you do not know whether you will be born a king or an enslaved woman, only that the probabilities match the proportions in the global population), you would be crazy to pick 1826. Your life will be short. You will probably be very poor. You will be illiterate, told what to do for a living, who to pray to, and whom to marry, and no one will give a penny for your input into the running of your community. And, you can be arrested at will.
And this absence of moral autonomy and self-determination is worth ten, one hundred, or even one thousand times more than all the extra income that modern economic growth has given you.
My post on life spans:
x.com/JesusFerna7026/status/2091809199223132428
My post on prosperity:
x.com/JesusFerna7026/status/2091471457670869489 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Although self service takes us so much less space that the increased number of them means that the queue moves much faster in a Tesco metro at lunchtime than it did before.
Tim Worstall
@worstall
From an actual economist about self-checkout: "And that's before you even think about the relative opportunity cost of my time vs a shop assistant's, but that would be a bit contentious."
Well, yes, my time is more valuable - on the grounds that I get paid more per hour - than that of the checkout lady. Therefore society is poorer if I do the slower checkout than if she does the faster. QED.
However much shrieking the point engenders it is in fact true. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Matthew Lesh
@matthewlesh
Supermarkets are nothing short of a modern miracle.
A large Tesco Superstore carries around 40,000 product lines, sourced from over 20,000 British farmers and 70 countries, available year-round. A feat of logistics unimaginable just a few generations ago.
Yet in Britain today the supermarket is cast not as a marvel but as a villain, blamed for the very prices it has spent a century driving down.
A strong majority, 70 per cent, believe that supermarkets are making excessive profits. However, this conclusion has largely been driven by misinformation.
The public believes that supermarkets are making 32 pence for every £1 that shoppers spend. In reality, their margins are around just 3 pence per £1 spent, compared with the all-industry net margin benchmark of roughly 8.5 pence.
When you inform voters about the profits supermarkets make, public opinion shifts dramatically. The level of agreement that supermarkets are profiteering drops to 32 per cent, while disagreement rises to 44 per cent.
That represents a fall from +58 to -12 in net agreement that supermarkets are profiteering, an unusually large shift in public opinion from providing just a single piece of additional information.
My latest for @iealondon: economicaffairs.co.uk/p/the-public-is-dangerously-misinfo… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
Remember when the Conservative Party was the party of home ownership?
Now they want to prevent families from exploiting their assets, to stop them building wealth, and object to people providing homes for their adult children and ageing parents.
The Tory Party is the Nimby Party.
Planning Magazine
@PlanningMag
The shadow housing secretary has accused the government of “returning to garden grabbing” with its update to national planning policy that gives “substantial weight” to housing proposals that make effective use of space in existing plots.
www.planningresource.co.uk/article/1968403/cleverly-accus… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes it does, although it is asymetric - because secondary moderns are bigger than grammars, the penalty is diluted somewhat. But getting a high P8 as a boys secondary modern is hard.
Secondary Moderns
@SecModerns
Doesn’t that also imply that Sec Mods (the inevitable partner to grammar schools in selective areas) get an unwarranted penalty?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
And of course being a British Standard, you can't read the actual text without paying £348 to do so... (knowledge.bsigroup.com/products/fire-detection-and-fire-a… if anyone wants to pay £348)
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I recently lost patience with our weekly fire alarm tests disrupting me and checked the laws/guidance on this as I suspected over compliance and sadly,... the UK difference seems to be real.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I bet there is no law that says they had to do this. So much of this stuff is when people think there is a law. Hence I was unable to repeal laws repealing this sort if stuff because the laws do not exist!
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
My favourite example was going to an outdoor book festival held in big open air tents and they still had to tell people where the fire exits were, which was everywhere.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It really doesn't. P8=0 means average progress. Kids are not going backwards.
Ben Shore
@ben_shore
This js a depressing chart. Implies secondary schools with strong HPA intake actually sends them backwards!!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't understand all of it either!
Adam Boxer
@adamboxer1
I'm not smart enough to understand any of this 🤣😭
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
“Where they have been implemented in other countries, rent controls have led to lower availability of private rental housing, reductions in quality, and more households living in properties that do not suit their needs.”
ifs.org.uk/articles/do-rent-controls-work -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Doesn't this graph include grammar schools? As @profbeckyallen has shown, P8 does not work as well as it should for them - they do get an unwarranted bonus.
Yorkshire Steve
@Yorkshire_Steve
Think this chart is interesting within this debate.
Using 2024 data.
P8 for High Prior Attainers plotted against the proportion of pupils who are higher prior attainers in school
The more HPA pupils a school has, the better the school typically does with those pupils. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't think it will be a Matthew Effect, as Michaela's P8 will be compared to other schools with typically richer intakes as high KS2 school secondaries tend to be in rich areas.
Adam Robbins
@MrARobbins
Actually I've thought about this and it does make sense. And while it does happen. The correlation between P8 and prior attainment suggests it happens a lot less than people going up. Probably due to the Matthew effect.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Not really - the P8 for Low Prior Attainment kids will not assume they fill all 8.
themarkscheme
@themarkscheme
Could proportion of learners in an institution with empty slots in the measure play a part here as well? Doesn't this skew more towards those with lower prior attainment? Institutions with a larger cohorts of this type could skew towards alternative provision?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My recollection is that @ofqual intended that the new grades would be more evenly spaced.
Yorkshire Steve
@Yorkshire_Steve
This analysis assumes the old grades were equally 'spaced' in terms of progression and new ones 'squeezed in'.
A different interpretation is that some of the old grades were too broad and the new ones corrected that issue.
Not sure how we'd test that out -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well said @GavinBarwell. My dad walked out, never to be seen again. Mum worked really hard to bring up my sister and me. Why any government would want to penalise people like her is beyond me.
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
I'm a strong supporter of marriage (that's why I voted for same sex couples to be able to benefit from the institution)
But that shouldn't entail discriminating against single parents (who may have had their partner walk out on them, fled domestic violence etc) @BenObeseJecty
Simon Dudley
@SimonDudleyUK
I’m old enough to remember when the Conservatives encouraged and supported married couples and the institution of marriage.
How they have lost their way -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I promise you not in bad faith, but as you wish. Thank you for everything you do as a teacher.
Adam Robbins
@MrARobbins
Seems in bad faith so I will wish you a good day.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Very few pupils used to get the old grades F and G. It was not the case that the same proportion got each grade.
Adam Robbins
@MrARobbins
Cast you mind back to the days of a*-g. Pictured below is the conversation. Look at a C grade. Above it are three grades. Look at the grade 4. Above it are 5 grades. The same proportion of the population for within each spread of grades...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If you are saying "6 and 7 are closer together" then equally it is easier for a kid to slip from an expected 7 to a 6 than from a 4 to a 3.
Adam Robbins
@MrARobbins
So as progress 8 is about moving above the expected target grade (based of std KS2 points score) but definition it is easier to move from 6-7 than 3-4 because the grades are closer together along the norm distribution of ability.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
nb P8 will not correlate with KS2 scores at pupil level - that is by definition/construction. It would correlate with KS2 scores at school level if... 1/4
Adam Boxer
@adamboxer1
A few people have asked about Michaela's prior intake.
According to national and publicly available data, their 2023/2024 intake had a prior attainment score of 107.8
Out of ~2800 non-selective schools, Michaela ranks as the 63rd highest prior intake
That puts it in the top 2-3% for prior intake. It's very high
This does not mean it is selective, or can legally select by pupil ability, and its numbers fluctuate year on year
Progress 8 is *supposed* to take prior attainment into account, but there is a clear positive correlation between KS2 ability and eventual school P8
None of this is to diminish any individual school's outcomes (certainly not Michaela's). It is to, once again, explain why much of what they do hasn't replicated
Two provisos:
1. I am not a professional statistician, and this is a pretty rough analysis
2. That's exacerbated by the fact that I haven't had a lot of time
@Yorkshire_Steve will no doubt correct some of what I have written here
@timleunig might be able to explain why P8 correlates with KS2 (when I think it shouldn't)Post not available here, view on X
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But if you plot that cloud only for schools with similar KS2 average entry points as Michaela, I think you will still find Michaela stands out. 3/4
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Here, for example, is Michaela (top line) vs 4 other schools @FFTEduDatalab judges similar to M. All are in London. Michaela results are far better, despite similar intakes. 4/4 @Miss_Snuffy (schoolslikeyours.ffteducationdatalab.org.uk/ks4/)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Allen
@Joe___Allen
Wales hit "peak baby" just over 100 years ago.
The current annual figure is about 38% of the 1920 total.
Anne Morse
@Anne_red_head
France is estimated to have hit "peak baby" more than 150 years ago.
"Metropolitan France... had far fewer babies in 2025 (610,186) than in 1806 (916,000), when Napoleon won the Battle of Jena." -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
P8 uses actual ks2
Antonin Artaud the 2nd
@Wanga14
So they make over 2 grades more progress than other schools with high ability intakes? Or is it the P8 calculation based on PP/FSM and other markers and expected prior attainment rather than actual
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is just not true. P8 shoes how well your kids do Vs others of the same KS2 starting point.
Adam Robbins
@MrARobbins
I remember when P8 cames out and the claim was it would be beneficial to less able cohorts. People seemed to ignore the fact that they made an extra grade above A* so by definition baked in a bias towards the more able
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is a fine piece by @KateClanchy1, well worth reading.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is not true. Google comparative outcomes. In your defence the secretary of state appears to be under the same misunderstanding!
Nigel Law
@NigelLaw526509
No. Schools are measured by results. GCSEs are ranked with a 1/3 failure rate. If one school improves another must go down somewhere else.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Dnes
@MichaelDnes1
On a site visit to HS2 in Northamptonshire I found a new bit of the railway I'd never heard about - the Turweston Green Bridge.
At first, I thought it was a bat tunnel without the bats. Then I realised it was teaching me a much deeper lesson.
limbostructure.substack.com/p/a-green-bridge-too-far -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Very much worth reading. Thanks @TomHCalver for writing it. Hope @ofqual respond substantively.
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Maths and English passes have surged over the last 30 years. Why?
Fascinating, as ever, from Tom Calver in today’s Sunday Times www.thetimes.com/article/311242c8-80db-4c99-b317-5df1ed4a… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I used to teach Economic History 101 at @LSEEcHist. I used to tell them that is they ever got the chance to go back in time, they should refuse. The past was unbelievably awful, and the future will say the same about our era.
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
In 2028, the median person on Earth will live on more than $10 a day for the first time in history (figures adjusted for inflation and for differences in purchasing power across countries).
In the last decade alone, the share of people above this threshold has risen from 41.3% in 2016 (3.11 billion) to 48.7% in 2026 (4.03 billion). Think about that for a second: we have pushed nearly 900 million people over this threshold in ten years, around 90 million people a year (slightly above the population of Turkey).
At the very bottom, we have also seen progress, though slower. In 2016, 12.6% of the world lived below $3 a day (947 million people). In 2026, the figure fell to 10.0% (826 million). This fall is harder to achieve because the poorest countries also have fast population growth. As fertility falls there, and I think it is already falling, we will cut poverty much faster.
You are probably thinking that $10 a day is not a demanding threshold. True. But in 1990, yesterday in historical terms, only 1.42 billion people lived above it. And this is not just China: 2.6 billion people have crossed the $10 line. On the other hand, in 1990, 2.20 billion people lived below $3 a day.
I checked these figures today because I start teaching Global Economic History at Penn this Wednesday, and I wanted to update the numbers I use. As Joel Mokyr instructs us:
“The responsibility of economic historians is to remind the world what things were like before 1800. Growth was imperceptibly slow, and the vast bulk of the population was so poor that a harvest failure would kill millions. Almost half the babies born died before reaching age 5, and those who made it to adulthood were often stunted, ill and illiterate.”
(“What Today's Economic Gloomsayers Are Missing,” 2014.)
This will be my first lesson to the students on Wednesday: we live in times of historically unprecedented prosperity, and, by and large, things are getting much better every year. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Exactly. These are immigrants who have become British citizens and get treated as such!
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Look, says Chris Philp: 76% of social housing in an immigrant-heavy London neighbourhood is foreign-born!
What he doesn't say: the whole neighbourhood is 78% foreign-born. Private renters: 92%.
Also: 81% of those social tenants already hold UK passports. They are UK citizens. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
The opportunity to fully reimagine academic publishing is there, and we must use it. It makes no sense to have the current process in a world where machines can verify the correctness of formal statements and empirical derivation, and human judgement can focus on relevance. Economics must do like AI/CS have done by centering publishing around conferences such as NeurIPS. Josh and I are happy to entertain a conversation here on that!
neurips.cc
Joshua Gans
@joshgans
Apparently Elsevier, for reasons that aren't apparent, decided to gut the editorial boards of GEB and I have also heard, JET.
This is one of those times where perhaps we should see this as opportunity. Let's face it, now more than ever, the commercial publishers have no moat. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
1/ Encouraging. There's been a really big increase in the size of the civil service since Brexit, alongside a big shift of public sector staff from local to central government control. Reversing it will be painful.
2/ Very good. Hope this sticks.
Dan Bloom
@danbloom1
EXCL: First interview with No. 10 North chief Caroline Simpson
😬 Indicates there'll be "significant" cuts to civil service staff to boost local areas
💸 Leaves door open to mayors paying rebates
🔴 Why, as an apolitical official, she took a SpAd job
🐈 Cardboard cutout of Larry -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Like all London schools it will get London weighting as part of the national funding formula. It will also pay its staff London weighting!
surrey nightmare
@nightmaresurrey
But considerably more than many schools in other areas
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is a state school
NUFC
@nufcnuf
This is just any private school tbh, doesn’t have a rats to do with that weird populist witch
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Really? We have a national funding formula for schools. It will get the same funding as other nearby schools
Misanthrope
@misanthropeyrk
It is hard to overstate how insanely over funded the school is compared to all other schools. That’s the only reason for the results.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is not selective and lots of the kids come from families poor enough to get a free lunch. Kids get about 2 grades better, on average, in every GCSE they take. It is remarkable.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I would also be very interested in a longitudinal study of kids who went to Michaela. Eerything we know about the importance of getting good grades suggests Michaela is transforming lives, but be good to check and quantify the extent. @Miss_Snuffy @rcolvile
Matvei Zakharov
@MatveiZakharov_
Teaching for the exam gets you that.
Michaela is a concentration children of motivated Asian Tiger parents that would perform equivalently well regardless of the school (minus a network effect of having no PRU kids knifing and raping one another).
Longitudinal study needed. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
I think that as a society we need a clearer debate about the standards we think most students are capable of achieving.
I personally think most students can achieve the standard represented by grade 4 in maths & English. I am not pretending it will be easy, and I am not trying to be utopian, but I do think it is possible.
Others will disagree, but because it's bit impolite to say "I don't think some kids can ever get to a grade 4", they come up with euphemisms and it's difficult to have a proper discussion.
But I think we need to be honest and to have the debate! If it really is not possible for a third of kids to reach grade 4 English & maths then that does have big implications for our system!
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/what-should-we-do-about-the-… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Swimming in the Seine - could London do the same? www.ft.com/content/c8fce342-4217-482f-9e74-33eb18b08e6b?s…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
I'm thrilled to be joining @AnthropicAI to research the political economy of superintelligence. AI is progressing fast, and we have a rare opportunity to build it in ways that make free societies stronger.
I'll be conducting new research with the Rule of Law team to understand how we can design AI that bolsters democratic self-governance and enhances individual liberty. I'll be running novel agentic experiments, analyzing large-scale data, and studying what makes AI trustworthy for citizens and policymakers alike.
We’re only beginning to understand the political economy of increasingly capable AI, and there’s a much broader research agenda to develop around it. I’ll continue to run the Free Systems Lab and publish my Substack to help advance that work.
Today is my first day, and I can't wait to dive in! -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Many LSE faculty are foreign nationals, as is common in elite universities. I am sure a few will claim benefits - for example, if they have child with a disability. They will also pay a lot of taxes, and are certainly my friends and neighbours.
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
The argument is that there's a difference between recent arrivals and those who've lived here for years and in many cases paid £££s in taxes. They are our friends, neighbours, colleagues, not "foreigners"
But you know that. Xenophobia is just part of the grift. For shame
Matt Goodwin
@GoodwinMJ
Sorry what’s the argument here —foreign nationals are not really foreign nationals? In which case citizenship no longer exists. In which case nations no longer exist.
God I hate Tories.
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
What's "plain immoral" is retrospectively taking away access to benefits from people we have promisd can spend the rest of their lives here. How dare you call these people "foreigners" - they have lived here for years and many have paid into the system
Robert Jenrick
@RobertJenrick
A Reform UK Government will make British citizenship the condition for receiving benefits.
Forcing British workers to pay for the benefits of foreigners is not just economically illiterate, but plain immoral. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Again - building more houses is the best and most effective wealth tax.
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
It’s important to understand bad housing policy as not simply a transfer from renters to landowners, but also a large net loss to the overall economy — a leaky bucket of upward redistribution.
www.slowboring.com/p/how-to-promote-growth-and-equality -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
If you’re a graduate with three kids earning £60k then child benefit withdrawal plus student loan = 67% tax on the next £1 you earn.
I’m pretty chill about the 45p rate. But I worry a 67% rate stops people working.
(And at £100k the problem is worse)
2/2 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
One of the most under-rated global cultural changes is that upon migrating to England,
Indian Hindu and Sikh women's employment converges with natives.
My hypothesis is that this is due to caste sanctions weakening overseas. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
Insights from A-levels: Maths has 115k entries & Eng Lit just 36k.
20 yrs ago they both had about 50k.
At the risk of sounding like Claude, this isn't just educational change - it's cultural change.
A generation of kids will be far more familiar with quadratics & conditional probability than Mr Rochester & Ophelia.
Bayes is destroying Defoe...
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/the-fall-of-eng-lit -
Tim Leunig reposted
Boyan Slat
@BoyanSlat
Every few months this map goes viral while it doesn’t represent reality at all.
In Meijer et al. 2021 we used a more detailed framework and a much larger dataset of measurements and found it’s actually ~1000 rivers that need to be tackled. If it’d be only 10 we’d be done ready!
Epic Maps 🗺️
@theepicmap
95% of Ocean plastic comes from just 10 rivers, and most people don't know this
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I know Bradford well. I have just experienced Basingstoke and Woking for the first time. Any idea that beauty matters to prosperity is dead to me. I may take some time to recover.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with my fellow economist @ben_moll. For reference the highest annual US GDP growth rate per capita since 1961, excluding rebounds, is 6.31%. 10% and 15% are utterly implausible. (obvs I hope I am wrong!)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This stuff is amazing. I am sure it is going to be the norm in schools quite quickly. As someone who has done a lot of marking over the years I welcome it!
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
Our new Double Marker pilot is proving very popular!
Still have some places left to discuss it next week.
Read more and get in touch.
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/solving-gcse-mocks-with-comp…
cal.eu/daisy-christodoulou-0lbtou/double-marker-find-out-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
At last, confirmation that the new National Planning Policy Framework (#nppf) will be published on Monday. Looks like it's going to make it easier to build reservoirs, which is long overdue given we've not built a new one in over 30 years.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
John Fingleton
@JohnFingleton1
This excellent speech by @danielleiwood of the Australian Productivity Commission on how regulation holds back productivity growth in Australia is just as relevant to the UK. Well worth reading for new minister or advisor interested in growing the economy.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Today's figures show 18% of kids from poor backgrounds in Scotland go to uni. England: 23%.
John Swinney
@JohnSwinney
New UCAS figures show that more Scottish students from deprived areas are going to university.
And under the SNP, university tuition will always remain free - because access to education should be based on the ability to learn, not the ability to pay. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Boyan Slat
@BoyanSlat
We deployed one of our very first Interceptors (the one we used in the 2019 unveil) in this river in the Dominican Republic. It was not a success:
Besides trash, huge amounts of water hyacinths (an invasive plant) wash down the river during storms, which completely overwhelmed the machine.
We learned from this mistake, and since then the presence of organics is one of the (many) things we map before every deployment.
And: we didn’t give up on solving the plastic pollution problem in the Dominican Republic either. Excited to deploy the largest Interceptor to date in Santo Domingo in a few months from now, which should finally get the job done.
The Ocean Cleanup
@TheOceanCleanup
Interceptor upgrades in the Dominican Republic coming soon 🇩🇴
Interceptor 004 will be replaced with a split, 400-meter barrier in early 2027, increasing catch capacity to include invasive water hyacinth. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Although approval would not get us any gas this winter...
John Ewbank
@Ewbank_1
Not approving jackdaw with the situation as it is seems like an act of self-immolation.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
If people continue to stay home alone, and don’t actually strengthen their social skills, and thus remain awkward, anxious, shy, or downright dull, then the chances of a great date may be low.
Never mind if a clever AI matches.
Both may still be bored & put off.
Ole Lehmann
@itsolelehmann
so apparently the founder of Hinge is now building a new AI dating app with NO profiles and NO swiping.
> you talk out loud to an AI matchmaker about who you are, how you love, and what keeps going wrong in your relationships
> then it decides who you should meet
> it’s called Overtone. Justin McLeod left Hinge after 15 years to build it and has already raised $18M
> when you join, the AI interviews you by voice
> it turns that convo into editable “Insights” about your personality, values, communication style, and relationship goals.
> it compares those Insights with other people and calculates a compatibility score called “Resonance”
> based on that, it decides which introductions to send and when, then tells you why it thinks you’d be compatible
> your photos are excluded from the matching model. people only see them after an introduction.
> it also uses signals like activity and responsiveness to improve future introductions.
> once connected, you exchange voice notes and photos, meet IRL, and the AI gets out of the way
> it launches later this year in select cities (waitlist is currently New York, LA, San Francisco, and Austin)
to me this feels more intentional than the current dating app funnel, but also kind of Black Mirror-esque?
it's basically Black Mirror’s “Hang the DJ" episode (where an algo chooses everyone’s partners and runs 1,000 simulated relationships to calculate a 99.8% match)
so idk, i’m kinda conflicted...what do you think? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, I also wear a bike helmet almost all the time - but I think the evidence for and against is mixed, and that is worth acknowledging.
John Fingleton
@JohnFingleton1
not that I am advocating it for London where I wear a helmet
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Some interesting evidence on driver responses to bike helmets - pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30472528/
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Wear a helmet, stick to cycle paths, and make sure you buy minute bundles rather than the flat rate pricing (which is v v expensive).
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We need to think more about likely possible shortages of gas this winter - my thoughts - timleunig.substack.com/p/two-predictions-for-six-months-time (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Norma Cohen
@NormaCohen3
A good ‘First Step’ to bring down the cost of living would be for Burnham and Labour to simply ban Freeholders from appointing Managing Agents. Only those who have to pay service charges should be allowed to appoint. ‘He who pays the piper names the tune’ should be the rule.
BBC Radio 4 Today
@BBCr4today
Andy Burnham says he's accelerating plans to end 'misleading discount claims' and 'subscription traps' as part of his aim to introduce every day fixes to bring down the cost of living.
Political Correspondent Jack Fenwick explains more.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Truly fantastic piece on education and the economy by @jburnmurdoch @FT www.ft.com/content/1c4a641c-42f4-429e-94c2-7d16cac96d49?s…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In the light of @theresecoffey being hacked here, I have changed my password to something much longer. Recommend you do too....
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Paul Cheshire has written a LOT on how to reform planning - for example blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/labours-planning-reform… - www.centreforcities.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Homes-… - spatial-economics.blogspot.com/2020/10/planning-for-futur… -researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/102339/3/Cheshire_hous… and so on. @Johnmcternan / @LordLucasCD / @LSE_SERC will have even more...
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
And ….. what would he actually suggest we do?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My @LSEnews colleague Paul Cheshire has an excellent piece on why @andyburnham is unlikely to hit his housing target - blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/without-radical-plannin…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
OK, I am two months late to this, but this is epic...
Ben James
@BenJames_____
Solar data center mvp is COMPLETE
Hit us up if you want free compute this week.
Fully off grid with starlink + battery + cooling. No wires, no water!
Build thread below... -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes - I had friends who brought up their <1s in the UK, Norway, Switzerland and the US. They were staggered at the extent to which the advice varied, and - as you say - the only consistency was the certainty...
Anna Perry
@annaperryparis
Whenever you move country the rules and recommendations about baby care and child raising change dramatically. However the absolute certainty with which local professionals dispense advice remains constant 😎
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Stamp duty is such a bad and damaging tax that raising pretty much any other tax in order to cut it would be beneficial. Yet ever since Gordon Brown started to do so, pretty much every chancellor has increased it. Rachel Reeves included. So depressing…
John Rentoul
@JohnRentoul
Only thing I would add is that stamp duty is such a terrible tax that cutting it (as well as simplifying it) would be worth higher council tax or income tax – but you could only do that in good times
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sure, but in other countries don't recommend sterilising even if you don't have a dishwasher. (I wonder whether the proportion of parents with a dishwasher is different to that of the population as a whole?)
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Funnily enough I looked this up recently - nearly half of homes don't have a dishwasher.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I recollect that the UK is the only country in the world to recommend sterilising baby's bottles (as opposed to just putting them in the dishwasher) and has no evidence to support that recommendation.
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
Really funny to encounter the newborn baby advice bullshit industry firsthand. You're immediately inundated with contradictory pieces of advice from professionals, and when you go to look it up you often find neither side actually has any evidence to back them up at all.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Looks like it is time to ask @michaelgove for a job writing for @spectator... ;-)
Michael Gove
@michaelgove
Everyone should always read everything @timleunig writes
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Everyone should read this indeed! www.ft.com/content/547bc3c3-6778-42d3-9bed-fcc3d0c28068
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
Everyone should read this.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
www.ft.com/content/547bc3c3-6778-42d3-9bed-fcc3d0c28068 <<< Me in the FT today, discussing qualifications, connections and job markets
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Everyone should read this indeed! www.ft.com/content/547bc3c3-6778-42d3-9bed-fcc3d0c28068
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
Everyone should read this.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
www.ft.com/content/547bc3c3-6778-42d3-9bed-fcc3d0c28068 <<< Me in the FT today, discussing qualifications, connections and job markets
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
www.ft.com/content/547bc3c3-6778-42d3-9bed-fcc3d0c28068 <<< Me in the FT today, discussing qualifications, connections and job markets
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The relative importance of qualifications vs connections - me quoting @annastansbury in the @FinancialTimes, responding to @andyburnham interview with @jimmym - www.ft.com/content/547bc3c3-6778-42d3-9bed-fcc3d0c28068
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But I think you agree that @BenHouchen should be able to make that choice, and that anyone who believes in devolution should think that?
Paul Swinney
@Paul_Swinney
My take is no. It won't help attract higher-skilled businesses in, which pay a premium for access to talent.
As Ben fairly says, if it doesn't work, he'll get voted out. My advice would be to shift focus to the issues that are actually holding Tees Valley back. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
@daisychristo is spot on. We should compare outcomes for Eng-NI-Scot-Wales much more often for education and young people, since they have very different education systems now. Let's see what works!
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
As an aside, any time anyone says that "Gove's education reforms caused xyz", check what happened in Scotland & Wales.
Scotland & Wales did pretty much the exact opposite of the Gove reforms, at the same time. So if the Gove reforms were causal, a first test is that it should show up as divergence between England and Scotland & Wales.
EG - "Gove reforms caused mental health to plummet" - but they're similar across England, Scotland, Wales
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/do-knowledge-rich-curriculum… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
Four short years ago :)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Want to be a better driver? Take a speed awareness course. Only you can't. We should change that - my substack this week - timleunig.substack.com/p/speed-awareness-courses Free to read
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Whether devolution caused the economic overperformance is another, more interesting, question.
.
But I've been astonished at how many and how senior are the economists and policy people in Britain who don't know that the devolved parts of Britain have overperformed economically. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Just written my next substack - timleunig.substack.com - out tomorrow morning. Pleased to see that the AI checker thinks it was written by a human...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I did not realise that by charging for timleunig.substack.com the substack algorithm would promote it more! Make sense, really. (Like @ahall_research I also give away all the money I make from it, in my case to the @AgainstMalaria)
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
I totally agree with this in principle, but not in practice -- the Substack algorithm seems to promote paid substacks/pieces much more aggressively than non-paid. Which would make sense given how their business works (they take a cut of subscription fees).
Since many of us write in order to reach a broad audience, that becomes an important reason to include paid subscriptions.
To accommodate this while not profiting from the writing, I've committed to putting all the Substack fees I earn into a community fund. Wrote more about it here:
freesystems.substack.com/p/free-systems-is-on-a-roll -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Surprising findings... Read on... Since 2000, the poorest tenth of people in Germany have hardly got any richer, while the richest have seen their living standards increase a lot...
Post not available here, view on X
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The idea that the last quarter century is characterised by the rich getting richer at the expense of the poor in the UK is just not supported by the data. The last time that happened was in the 1980s.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
All data from the wonderful team @OurWorldInData ourworldindata.org/grapher/incomes-across-distribution-wb…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Exactly - deliverism matters in public services as well as private services.
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
See my piece on Deliverism Is public service delivery really dead? www.themj.co.uk/public-service-delivery-dead via @themjcouk
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Exactly. If the govt was serious about NEETs they would employ more driving examiners. They could even set the fee to make a £10 profit per test and cut taxes for employers who employ young people! Win-Win!
Ray Georgeson MBE - Borders Liberal Democrats 🔶
@BordersRayLD
Tim is right - driving test scarcity is a huge issue especially in our rural areas and is a drag on economic growth when young folk simply can’t take jobs because public transport is poor & they’re waiting ages for driving tests.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Last night I looked at the availability of driving tests at the 100 nearest test centres in the next six months. Number of centres with an test available? Not one. Our country is failing!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The agents have been banned. Last time my friend was able to pay £50 to one such and get a test. Now they are just stuffed.
Jack Pardoe
@pardoejw
I gave up and gave some useless leach on society money for their machine booked test in the end, because the main system was hopeless. Also know someone who’s had all their ID documents (including birth certificate!) lost by the DVA, leaving them without ID at risk of losing their business due to Company House ID rule changes. I think politicians would gain a lot of votes by promising to transform these orgs within a Parliament. Pay some proven and good commercially minded people competitive salaries to fundamentally reset citizen interface organisations like DVA and HMRC. New orgs should be set up on their place, the existing ones wound down, their managers moved on to something outside of administration of any kind. They’re total basket cases that make citizens’ lives unnecessarily miserable every day through extreme incompetence.
You can probably tell - a passion topic of mine! -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think that the govt successfully outlawed agents - last time my friend was able to use an agent to get one (cost an extra £50). Now they are just stuffed.
Douglas McWilliams
@DMcWilliams_UK
That is also my understanding. But it is also my understanding (which might be wrong) that the big driving schools buy them up from the agents. If I'm wrong I'm happy to withdraw the claim.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Last night I looked at the availability of driving tests at the 100 nearest test centres in the next six months. Number of centres with an test available? Not one. Our country is failing!
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The situation is even worse than a year ago, when I last looked. Thankfully, I had a solution then, and one I still think would work. timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-solve-the-driving-test-cr… (£/free trial)
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Having tried unsuccessfully to find a slot at over 100 centres, I then got this message - "You have been blocked by DVSA security rules." Which adds insult to injury!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Centre for Cities
@CentreforCities
Council tax needs reform.
But replacing it with a single national property tax would centralise local government finance, weaken growth incentives and make fiscal devolution harder.
Devolution, not centralisation, is the better route 👇
www.centreforcities.org/blog/centralising-council-tax-wou… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Although remember that the point of banning Midlands expansion was to try to help the North... (it was also banned in the South)
Nicole dso 🇺🇦
@Nicoledso
The midlands and North have been punished for a very long time. Remember Birmingham and Leicester were wealthier per capita than London and then they literally passed a law that stopped the midlands growing. Banned expansion of factories
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Tim is one of the most original thinkers writing about UK policy. Do give this a read:
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written about why I think the UK government's approach to heat pumps is failing, and what they can do about it. You can read about it in this week's substack - timleunig.substack.com/p/i-want-to-be-cool (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
LSE School of Public Policy
@LSEPublicPolicy
Congratulations to Professor Tim Leunig on his appointment as a Life Peer in the House of Lords.
A Visiting Professor in Practice at the LSE School of Public Policy, this is a well-deserved recognition of his distinguished career.
Find out more: www.lse.ac.uk/news/tim-leunig-made-a-life-peer-in-the-hou… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
"Palantir tool has not cut hospital discharge delays, says study" > this is the best way to decide on Palantir's involvement in the NHS. Ask, is it actually good at the job? giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/actions/redeem/6d4b5423-cf… via @FT
-
Tim Leunig reposted
BBC Politics
@BBCPolitics
Fit schools, hospitals and new homes with air con, say Lib Dems www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0jlz099q9xo
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
👇
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written about why I think the UK government's approach to heat pumps is failing, and what they can do about it. You can read about it in this week's substack - timleunig.substack.com/p/i-want-to-be-cool (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Whether we frack or not, war induced gas price rises wallop UK consumers. We do not have enough frackable gas to be a beneficiary of rising prices (like Norway).
Hilton Holloway
@hiltonholloway
Not if you frack in my home state....
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written about why I think the UK government's approach to heat pumps is failing, and what they can do about it. You can read about it in this week's substack - timleunig.substack.com/p/i-want-to-be-cool (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Great piece by @hwallop that sums up how a modern economy works - www.thetimes.com/business/companies-markets/article/sharp… (£)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written about why I think the UK government's approach to heat pumps is failing, and what they can do about it. You can read about it in this week's substack - timleunig.substack.com/p/i-want-to-be-cool (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Iwan Doherty
@IwanDoherty98
The idea of one national rate is foolish, but glad to see this being discussed because its a move we should make. Always like @timleunig's proposal ukonward.com/reports/a-fairer-property-tax/
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yet another Brexit hit to the UK economy - US imposes a tariff hike on UK, but EU escapes... www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/trump-tariffs-uk-dis…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Huge thanks to @albrgr & @coeff_giving. $1bn is big money and will save so many lives. I am a HUGE fan of @GiveWell, and they are one of the reasons we donate to the excellent @AgainstMalaria. Remember, you don't need $1bn to give, all amounts matter. Click and give!
Alexander Berger
@albrgr
I’m really excited about this: we’re increasing our support for @givewell recs this year from $175M to $1B to help pave the way for an expected surge in funding from others. coefficientgiving.org/research/increasing-our-2026-alloca…
That’s nearly as much as we’ve given based on GiveWell's recs over the last decade+; we think that funding to date has saved ~100,000 lives.
There’s a ton of uncertainty about what the future will bring, but IMO the case for giving ambitiously today looks unusually strong. Let’s get to work! -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Excellent take down by @DanNeidle. Hope @Survation respond appropriately
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Seen that opinion poll in which millionaires say they're in favour of a wealth tax on millionaires?
It's an absolute masterclass in how to get the polling result that you want. And the detail shows the opposite of what we're told it shows.
Thread: -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Wow, this is amazing - well done to Alex and everyone who has taught him! You can make a reasonable claim that he is the best maths student of his age of all time!
UK Maths Trust
@UKMathsTrust
British Pupil Wins International Maths Olympiad, Becomes Most Decorated Participant of All Time
Alex, who is in Year 13 at Tonbridge School, came joint 1st with a perfect score of 42/42, earning his fifth Gold medal at this year’s edition in Shanghai.
These 5 Gold medals, along with 2 Silver medals, means Alex is now the most successful participant of all time in the world’s most prestigious school-age academic competition, which has been running since 1959.
Read more: ukmt.org.uk/british-pupil-wins-international-maths-olympiad -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree - @Dan4Barnet is a good choice for this role. He is someone who is serious about economic growth, thoughtful and open to ideas.
Stian Westlake
@stianwestlake
Great to see @Dan4Barnet reappointed at HM Treasury, and even better that he’s been assigned a specific economic growth brief.
The Treasury has a vital role to play in driving growth - so it’s excellent to see someone who cares about economic evidence leading the charge. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Everything @HelenMiller_IFS says in this thread is right. Cutting business rates helps landowners, not businesses. The govt should be aiming for tax simplicity, that is fair and easy and cheap to administer.
Helen Miller
@HelenMiller_IFS
More business rates relief for pubs & music venues is a continuation of a theme
Business rates used to be simple (1 rate) and stable. Now there are many rates & constant tinkering. This is not a welcome development -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Hill
@jo3hill
The civil service needs to be much more open to outsiders if it is to survive the changes coming in the next decade. Launching a Mid-Career Fast Stream would be the best way to start.
Great to publish this today with @ce_pickles!
Re:State
@restate_thinks
🚨New report: A Mid-Career Fast Stream.
Today we publish a detailed guide for the Government on how to create a new Mid-Career Fast Stream so that exceptionally talented people from outside the civil service have a dedicated route to apply.
re-state.co.uk/publications/a-mid-career-fast-stream/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Hill
@jo3hill
I’m optimistic that the Government will still see sense and buy the Downing Street Industrial Estate so that No10North can have the correct address.
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: No 10 North will temporarily be based at Heron House in central Manchester
Whitehall civil servants have been offered relocation packages to encourage them to move -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Hardy 🇺🇦 🇪🇺♿️🐟 #RightToLove 💙
@BlokeOnWheels
She thought her phone had been stolen and then discovered it hadn't been, it's not like she secretly met with Israeli officials while on UK government business as a member of the Cabinet. Who did that again, oh that's right, it was you wasn't it?
Priti Patel MP
@pritipatel
The British government has sunk to a new low with Andy Burnham appointing a convicted fraudster to one of the most senior roles in government.
This criminal will have access to classified intelligence and sensitive papers, so what vetting has been undertaken by the Cabinet Secretary and senior civil servants, or did Burnham just want to reward his friend and fellow plotter.
Her hard Left views and policies she'll push will also undermine our economic freedoms and harm our economy.
mol.im/a/15991927 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well it depends on what tax rises or what other spending in cancelled surely? And whether markets take fright and we all have to pay more to cover the extra interest bill...
Chris S
@chris_spencer04
Everyone's circumstances are different, but this will save me and my family about £200 a year.
Alongside removing the VAT on electricity that's £240 a year, so £20 a month.
That might not be groundbreaking but it's genuinely helpful.
I'm also pleased to see a PM jumping straight in, starting to target the cost of living. No dithering, just going for it.
Some quick wins already - can't complain -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alec MacGillis
@AlecMacGillis
"London would need to build 1.1 million more homes to reach the western European average of homes per capita. Last year, Vienna built three times more houses than London, despite being a much smaller city." www.wsj.com/real-estate/london-needs-1-1-million-homes-it…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Below is good economic and social history from @s8mb. The past was utterly, mind-blowingly horrible. Three cheers for scientific progress and its handmaiden, economic growth.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
It is pretty devastating to grasp that medieval people loved their children just as much as we do, when 40% of them died before they were ten years old. The past is more horrifying than we can imagine.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
Always the most interesting part of the UK inflation data release is the contribution of domestic items (where import intensity is <10%) as this gives a good read on the role of domestic policy on inflation. Really striking how decisions on regulated prices and taxes each April has been creating step changes in the path for inflation. The NICs change in April 2025 (inflationary), and the Budget measures that landed in April 2026 (disnflationary) continue this trend. This is one of the reasons that the BoE might wait until after the Autumn Budget before its next move as the 2027 outlook will again hinge on such choices.
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
UK inflation in line with expectations in June at 2.6% YoY, the decisions made at the November Budget have contributed to a flattening of the UK price curve in Q2. Still, aggregate price growth on track to exceed 3% this in 2026 which keeps market expectations live for BoE tightening in the H2. Underlying private sector pay growth (now <3%) speaks to these not being demand-driven price pressures.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
Very sad to announce that @timleunig is departing from the Forest City advisory board following his elevation to the Lords. He was one of the very first people to intuitively grasp the benefits of the Forest City idea, and he threw himself wholeheartedly into supporting its aims and helping to bring the project to where it is today. His wit, acumen and ability to problem solve are second to none so he’ll be greatly missed!
www.forestcity.uk/blog/tim-leunig-lords-july-2026 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
The trouble with making it mandatory to hold an election if a ruling party wants to change its PM, is unpopular PMs would simply stay in office longer rather than risk defeat. So we'd have had Blair til 2010; Cameron til 2020; May til 2022; Johnson til 2024; Starmer til 2029.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I primarily use a watering can in any case. And my garden is lovely!
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
I can’t believe I’m going to have to pay £1,000 a day just to water my garden.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Harris 🇬🇧
@MrTCHarris
And why on earth should MPs *not* enjoy an after-works drink, especially at the end of term? These sorts of puritanical posts give me the boak. Usually followed by "Why can't MPs just behave like ordinary people?" nonsense.
Ben Leo
@Benleo
Kicked out of government and then off to the pub for a laugh and a giggle
All while the country remains crippled
Glad to see they’re having a good time
credit @SunPictureDesk -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ryan Shorthouse
@RyanShorthouse
I think it’s wrong to keep describing Louise Haigh MP as a convicted fraudster.
She committed a crime 13 years ago. The crime she committed, for which she received one of the lowest possible sentences - a conditional discharge, does not preclude her from doing the job she has been appointed to. She made a mistake and she should be allowed to move on from it.
Those in public life should be showing that those who have committed relatively minor crimes eventually have a route to a successful life without stigma.
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/07/14/louise-haigh-burnham-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Turner
@DanTurnerTweets
As part of our Harvard-KCL project, we interviewed incoming Chancellor John Healey for his thoughts on regional growth and devolution as it was shaping up under the last government. Read it here 👇sites.harvard.edu/uk-regional-growth/directory/john-healey/ @edballs
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
There’s a tacit conspiracy to never discuss this.
The Tories don’t want to admit they presided over redistribution from high earners to low earners.
And Labour doesn’t want to credit the Tories with it.
Right? Wrong? You decide. But it happened. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
Its a really tough job and (personal view) is that Rachel Reeves did a decent job in trying circumstances, and had a fair dose of bad luck. Arguably the biggest mistake was made prior to the General Election by allowing a Labour manifesto that provided so little wriggle room to address tax and spending issues that were hiding in plain sight.
Rachel Reeves
@RachelReevesMP
It has been the privilege of my life to serve as the Chancellor of the Exchequer.
The economy today is stronger, fairer and more resilient because of the choices we have taken as a Labour Government over the past two years.
Stability restored, investment delivered and reform to our economy under way. I said when I was appointed Chancellor that I would judge my time in office if the lives ordinary working class people have been improved. I’m proud to say that they have.
And to every young woman and girl let my time in office show there should be no ceilings on your ambitions, your hopes or your dreams.
I wish the very best of luck to my successor, Andy and his cabinet. You have my full support, and I will continue to play my part in helping this Labour government deliver the change the country needs. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I wish you personally and the government the very best in delivering this.
Miatta Fahnbulleh
@Miatsf
Today, we start building a new economy, a new political settlement and a renewed sense of hope across the UK.
I am proud to support a Prime Minister who will change the course of the last 40 years.
We will drive power and resources out of Westminster into every postcode & take the radical action needed to turn this country around. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Houses don't take baths, drink tea and wash laundry - people do! Failing to build homes doesn't make water consumption go away. This is so stupid.
Matt Oliver
@mattotele
NEW: Ministers have been told that 1.1m of Labour's promised 1.5m homes are currently undeliverable because there is not enough water to supply them.
Water companies made the warning in a briefing document last week which also claims official forecasts on water consumption are wildly over-optimistic and do not account for rising demand from data centres.
It's a major headache for Andy Burnham as he takes over as Prime Minister with plans for a big government house building programme.
Link to full story below: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Nicholas Boys Smith
@boys_nicholas
There are questions about spread & quality of latest peers but @timleunig is the exception: highly intelligent, humming with energy, original, bursting with brightness & ideas like Diwali day & a lovely guy. Even when I disagree with him, he always leaves me thinking more sharply
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Tim Leunig is a brilliant thinker and we need more people like him in government. He has also been in a variety of government jobs for almost a decade, during which time his paper on North vs South has been mentioned pretty much every single time he is profiled. (1/2)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yup, never been a Tory, evil or otherwise!
Ed Dorrell
@Ed_Dorrell
He's also not an "evil" Tory. Last time I asked someone they reckoned he was a lib dem
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Indeed. I never hid my political background from ministers, but they had a democratic mandate, I sought to understand them and give advice accordingly.
Archie McCann 🔸🔶
@AJRMcCann
if people only advised people they completely agreed with, there would be no point in giving the advice.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Job news - I am off to the @UKHouseofLords to join @EdwardJDavey's team of peers. I look forward to working hard to hold the government to account...
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tej Parikh
@tejparikh90
THREAD (1/5): Andy Burnham & Zohran Mamdani both think building cheap homes can help struggling renters & first-time buyers.
But if they are serious about improving affordability, they should embrace more expensive homes instead...
My column in @FT: www.ft.com/content/d15171ec-6665-40c6-99df-6962bcf4c761?s… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
This by @DanNeidle is a very good explainer of the case for and against a land value tax (like him I am in favour on the grounds that nearly anything is better than Stamp Duty, which is a truly awful tax)
www.thetimes.com/money/tax/article/what-is-land-value-tax… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Always a delight to hear @SoumayaKeynes not just talk about trade, but to sing and play about it... Thanks to the Society of Professional Economists for arranging.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
Interesting (true) line from Rachel Reeves's Mansion House speech last night: "In the past, radical governments without credibility have ultimately failed to win the trust necessary to deliver their agenda...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
How many leaseholders turned freeholders are there? Why are they losers? That seems niche to me.
Angus Fanshawe
@AngusFanshawe
The winners and losers are unclear you say. But we know who they are. Losers are freeholders and especially those leaseholders-turned-freeholders. Windfall to those who have the most expensive flats mainly in London. Who are we trying to help here? It’s a terrrible policy.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
In other news - @CountBinface policies proving popular….
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Whipple
@whippletom
I was pleased to write about this in @thetimes today. (link in his thread). I like it when people just decide to get things done.
Michael Dnes
@MichaelDnes1
I’ve unveiled a secret project today. One that we’ve been working on for the past year.
Something that can add a billion pounds a year to the economy of the north while making the environment better.
And we think we can deliver it at no cost to government.
Ambitious, right? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Dnes
@MichaelDnes1
TLDR: we’re kicking off plans for a road tunnel under the Pennines; removing the traffic from the Peak District National Park; and bringing back the Woodhead railway.
And it all hinges on an engineering secret.
www.thetimes.com/article/24bb67dc-491c-47f9-9bfe-87d7957b…
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c621m9l1qr1o -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with @s8mb. A rising block tariff for electricity is a nutty idea. It would penalise EVs and heat pumps and make hitting net zero much harder.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Counterproductive and bad.
1) We should be trying to make it cheap and attractive to use a lot of electricity. Electric vehicles and heat pumps use a lot, I’m not sure we want to threaten people with an increasing tax for heating their homes with heat pumps in winter.
2) The proliferation of discounts and extra subsidies for low earners is combining to give us a much more steeply redistributive system than the tax and welfare system would suggest on its face. There is a whole shadow system of redistribution that is both inefficient and punitive for people on modest incomes trying to earn more. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Claus Vistesen
@ClausVistesen
@timleunig has good economic intuition, and on this occasion his intuition is exactly correct. Residual ground rents after reforms have now banned them on new leases must go, and sooner rather than later. Here is to hoping that @andyburnham is listening. This is a low-hanging reform fruit ripe for the picking, and would be a great way to start what will undoubtedly be a difficult stint as Prime Minister.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my free to read substack discusses ground rents - timleunig.substack.com/p/ground-rents - might well interest @Miatsf and others working to make @andyburnham premiership successful
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Dnes
@MichaelDnes1
I’ve unveiled a secret project today. One that we’ve been working on for the past year.
Something that can add a billion pounds a year to the economy of the north while making the environment better.
And we think we can deliver it at no cost to government.
Ambitious, right? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
One of the most exciting infrastructure projects in Britain right now. If we could build tunnels like the Norwegians we could build new motorways and railways so cheaply that they could be self-funding. The biggest prize is Manchester to Sheffield. www.thetimes.com/uk/transport/article/explosives-could-de…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my free to read substack discusses ground rents - timleunig.substack.com/p/ground-rents - might well interest @Miatsf and others working to make @andyburnham premiership successful
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Andy Burnham's backed a land value tax for 16 years. This Sunday we'll be publishing an analysis of how an LVT would work in practice.
Plus a model that lets you design an LVT and answer the key questions: Who'd win? Who'd lose? And the big question: can it be done at all? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Hopefully you preferred being interviewed by @RGurumurthy !!
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
I don't usually write personal stuff, but a few words about my experience of being interviewed by Gary Stevenson.
It started with a nice chat, comparing taste in hoodies... then the tone changed. He demanded to know why I'd deleted a tweet criticising him. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Allen
@Joe___Allen
We should try to kick our 'legislate and forget' habit.
For example:
Since 2016 Wales has required sprinklers in *all* new homes. Universal & unusually strict approach. Typically adds £3k to build cost.
But we then just chose not to monitor effectiveness of the new regs. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
Britain is willing to offer developers expensive fixed-price contracts to subsidise innovative forms of clean power, such as tidal or floating offshore wind.
Why don't we offer the same contracts for developers trying to build micro-nuclear reactors? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I read a book a week, but I have never thrown a kettle over a pub. Never even occured to me to consider doing so!
Alys Denby
@alysdenby
Gary Stevenson reads a book a week and once threw a kettle over a pub
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Most families on benefits are in work, and many more could be. They might score it at a different rate, but I don't think you can say "they would not score it".
Guy Miscampbell
@guymiscampbell
B/c they scored the effects of increased workplace participation driven by availability of childcare, which wouldn't be the case for families on benefits either (i) with the same incentives or (ii) at the same level.
So they'd score the cost, but likely no offsetting savings. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Why would @OBR_UK not score this? They have scored childcare in the past.
Guy Miscampbell
@guymiscampbell
The only way we could get this funded/enacted in the budget was that the OBR was willing to score quite large female workforce participation as a result of the childcare offer.
Scoring that would definitely not be applicable here, and therefore mean a large spending increase... -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Davey
@EdwardJDavey
This is a huge and unnecessary mistake, the investigation must finish first.
Kevin Schofield
@KevinASchofield
NEW: Nigel Farage is set to be appointed Steward of the Manor of Northstead, HuffPost UK understands.
This means he is officially no longer MP for Clacton and the government will not block the by-election, as the Lib Dems have demanded. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It isn't obvious to me why society would prefer to spend a lot of money to build more of a type of housing that people like less than alternative forms of housing, no! We also differ on deplatforming people with different views - I would never seek to have your silenced.
Danica Priest🦇🦎🦇🦎🍃💚🍃
@DanicaPriest
We need a substack version of ‘stop giving men microphones’ because not everyone deserves a platform. I kid you not one of Tim’s arguments for not building social housing is ‘50% of people in council housing don’t like it’ 🤦🏻♀️ It’s obvious why that’s a bad argument right?
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (£/free trial) offers policy ideas to Andy Burnham about council housing. Here is a pic of my nan's council house, that I lived in for a while. timleunig.substack.com/p/what-to-do-about-council-housing
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
TL;DR
We love universities so much that we are cutting your funding:
www.officeforstudents.org.uk/media/r5sf44kq/spg-ofs-guida… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (£/free trial) offers policy ideas to Andy Burnham about council housing. Here is a pic of my nan's council house, that I lived in for a while. timleunig.substack.com/p/what-to-do-about-council-housing
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It does, yes. I used the food and expenditure survey to estimate the effects on budgets. Remember, NZ managed to do this, and so could we.
Anna Clarke
@AnnaClarke_____
So that assumes that all the extra money raised from VAT on food is used to offset a VAT decrease on everything else (to 17%). And not, say, to increase public spending or fund other tax cuts? But the increase in food bills would be significant and a difficult sell I think.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, in retrospect I was not clear. That is what I meant. Of course, VAT on lots of other things goes down, and that should be taken into account.
Isca Augusta
@cmonmun
I think it’s just confusingly worded, and the 35p is the “regressive” extra cost. Eg, everyone’s food bill would go up by some amount, but because the poorest spent a higher percentage, theirs would go up 35p more than the average given the percentage they spend.
I’m not sure that’s any clearer tbh -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Aircon saves lives - great research from @_HannahRitchie ourworldindata.org/part-one-how-many-people-die-from-extr…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I guess I would be pretty skint if I tried to buy another five homes...
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
NEW: The Times has established that Nigel Farage and his partner own at least five homes spanning Surrey, Essex and Kent.
All but one were bought with cash since 2000. Farage described himself as "skint" in 2017.
www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/nigel-farage-propert… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My letter in today's @FT: data shows subject choice matters a lot in determining graduate earnings. www.ft.com/content/8318afb8-41ed-4692-a78d-fae79f986c42?s…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Romesh Vaitilingam
@econromesh
The events surrounding the August 2025 firing of the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics produced a sharp increase in economic policy uncertainty; the loss of confidence may have reduced US GDP by roughly $20 billion, @voxeu
cepr.org/voxeu/columns/when-trust-official-statistics-dec… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Steven Swinford
@Steven_Swinford
Breaking:
There are HUGE gaps in the funding for the defence investment plan which will be left for Andy Burnham to resolve, the small print of the document reveals
Here's one that stands out. Starmer has found £10.3billion over four years, predominantly by reallocating budgets from other departments
But that is not enough. The document states explicitly that a further £4.7billion will have to be found in the next Budget - which will be Burnham's first - to finance the plan
Given the state of the public finances, these are big tax rises or cuts that Burnham will have to make
Then added to that there is a commitment to finding £10.7billion of efficiencies between 2026/27 and 2029/30.
These efficiencies are vague, to say the least - a new defence operating model, cutting civil service workforce costs by 10%, automation, greater use of AI, efficiencies in acquisition
So there are two points that flow from this:
1) A huge chunk of the Defence Investment Plan is simply unfunded. Money will have to be found by Burnham, whether through tax rises or cuts elsewhere
2) It is not clear how realistic these efficiencies are. Would love to see the NAO/ public accounts committee get stuck into them. But a huge amount hinges on achieving enormous efficiency savings -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
More evidence, from a large-scale study in China, that using AI hurts learning if it undermines mental effort. When homework time drops due to AI use, so do test scores.
Across studies, a theme: AI tutoring in support of classes is good, using AI to "help" with homework is bad. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Rachel Wolf
@racheljanetwolf
The decline in prospects and situation over the last 20 years has been catastrophic. @PJTheEconomist does a brilliant job setting the scene below, alongside his report. Next week we'll publish more on how other countries have gotten out of economic messes, and what we can learn.
2030 Prosperity Alliance
@2030ProspAllUK
📊Britain has not stopped growing. But growth has become too slow, and too little of it is being felt in people’s lives.
Watch @PJTheEconomist Johnson explain why broad-based growth is the only way out.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with @johnvanreenen. @FT Letter: Why Burnham should keep Reeves as chancellor - giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/actions/redeem/ae7c96c1-df… via @FT
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Fair minded piece on @RachelReevesMP shorter than expected time as Chancellor from @dsmitheconomics - www.thetimes.com/business/economics/article/rachel-reeves…, echoing some of my comments a year ago - www.politicshome.com/opinion/article/rachel-reeves-hero-left
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
At the risk of stating the bleeding obvious, the case for tax reform is far stronger than that for tax increases. Almost everywhere you look there is low hanging fruit for a new Chancellor focused on reforming UK tax. My thoughts in Monday’s @thetimes on that bombshell, and the legacy of Rachel Reeves’ time in the Treasury: www.thetimes.com/business/economics/article/new-chancello…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I would install one of these - except my bedroom is in the roof...
Lewis Bowick
@L__Bow
You can get fully indoor permanent units which just need a hole through an external wall. They'll be a lot better than a single hose portable, though probably not as quiet as a split www.electriq.co.uk/p/iqool-smart15hp/electriq-iqoolsmart1…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
UK single hose, non-invertor AC units are much less efficient than twin hose invertor units, as @EdConwaySky will testify (and boy, does he know his onions about stuff!)
Lewis Bowick
@L__Bow
I don't think British homes have special requirements that aren't served by the standard air conditioners used in cramped flats all over the world. Brits can go and get one installed today, but few have because we historically haven't had many uncomfortably hot days
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Agustin Lebron
@AgustinLebron3
The biggest mindfuck for normies is that if you don't know how to use AI, you can literally just ask it "how do I use you" and it will tell you.
I've seen the lightbulb go on for a dozen people now. My mom, my niece, lots of random non-tech people. It's hilarious to watch. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Boyan Slat
@BoyanSlat
Thanks to the thermal expansion of steel, the Eiffel Tower has never been taller than it is this week.
Nahel Belgherze
@WxNB_
Paris, the capital of France, has recorded more days above 40°C this week than during the 147-year period spanning from 1872 to 2019.
Historic is an understatement. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I reckon there's a 1% to 5% chance that the market pull to invent a really small air conditioning unit that would be easy to retrofit to British homes has never had a reason to exist before and it's just waiting to be invented, like the Dyson vacuum cleaner.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Doug Lemov
@Doug_Lemov
There’s no one better. What a victory for families and teachers.
Education NI
@Education_NI
📢 ANNOUNCEMENT | Tom Bennett OBE, a leading expert in behaviour management, has been appointed by the Department of Education to lead a review of behaviour policy and practice across schools in Northern Ireland.
The review will examine the Department’s existing behaviour policy and will consider how it can be strengthened to better support schools in managing increasingly complex behavioural challenges.
🔗 Find out more: www.education-ni.gov.uk/news/education-minister-announces…
@tombennett71This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Superb from @ChrisGiles_
So-called "economists for Brexit" said we'd grow at 3%pa post Brexit.
Sadly, "mainstream" economics was dead right on long term effects of making trade with our biggest, richest and nearest trading partner more expensive. We are much poorer as a result -
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Interesting piece (via @Psythor) on what a Swiss approach to HS2 might look like - same principle as German electrification, ie just spend a set amount year after year after year... www.freewheeling.info/blog/swiss-hs2
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Steve Davies
@SteveDavies365
Today is another great anniversary of you are any kind of liberal. On 25 June 1846 Parliament voted to repeal the Corn Laws, the culmination of an 8 year long mass campaign led by Richard Cobden and John Bright and run from Manchester. Worth recalling what ‘Manchesterism’ meant.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Jon Burke 🌍
@jonburkeUK
If you want to know why Brexit has been a disaster and was destined to be a disaster, it's because it was masterminded by chancers like David Frost, a guy who doesn't realise that home insulation keeps homes COOLER during heatwaves.
David Frost
@DavidGHFrost
What a pity we've been building all our homes to retain heat, with small windows and miserable tiny rooms, effectively banning A/C, and urging everyone to spend on insulation for the last 20 years.
Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan
@MayorofLondon
As we have experienced this week, extreme temperatures are no longer a future threat. They are a present danger.
Today, I’m launching London’s first ever heat plan: a city-wide plan to adapt our capital, protect communities, and build a climate-resilient city. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
externalities. (recommend any econ 101 course, btw, as it will cover this at least adequately)
Centre Right Liberty
@CtRLiberty
Why is a mandate even needed if EVs are supposedly viable and cheaper to run? Why control and regulate what car companies can make? Surely better to force them to compete in the market for sales
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is very much the case that the ZEV is causing EV sales, yes. Never doubted or disputed that.
Rian Chad Whitton
@RianCFFWhitton
‘In 2025, the average discount on a BEV model was £11,000. However, the payment for non-compliance to the ZEV mandate is £12,000 per model.'
The ZEV works by forcing companies to lose money on EV sales.
autovista24.autovistagroup.com/news/is-a-uk-zev-mandate-r…
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Interesting - EVs now outsell petrol cars (hybrids lead). Same in Europe. www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-uk-sales-of-electric-vehicle… @CarbonBrief @DrSimEvans (I love my EV, easy to drive, no engine vibrations, easier to charge, very cheap to run)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Interesting - EVs now outsell petrol cars (hybrids lead). Same in Europe. www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-uk-sales-of-electric-vehicle… @CarbonBrief @DrSimEvans (I love my EV, easy to drive, no engine vibrations, easier to charge, very cheap to run)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Very interesting work on the effects of anti depressants and children from excellent @uniofwarwick researchers warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/research/centres/cage/new…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Happy Father’s Day! Having spent much of the past week helping to look after a sick and unhappy toddler, my advice to people considering having kids is that the bad parts aren’t nearly as bad as you fear, and you never regret it.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
The case for open source, beautifully put. Great essay, no slop.
Andrew Ng
@AndrewYNg
Over the last two weeks, both the U.S. Government and Anthropic took significant actions that demonstrated their power to control access to AI by restricting what others can do with frontier models. This has been one of those moments that, once seen, will be hard to unsee, and it is significantly accelerating many businesses’ and nation states’ efforts to ensure reliable access to AI that no one else can terminate.
Anthropic first released Claude Fable 5, a version of its Mythos model with additional guardrails, including some restrictions that seem well justified on safety grounds (such as limitations on applying it to hacking, bioweapons, and so forth). However, it also restricted developers’ ability to use it to build competing LLM technology. This move was concerning, given that the whole AI community, including Anthropic, has benefitted tremendously from open research — indeed, the AI revolution was kicked off by my former team (Google Brain) freely publishing the Transformers paper!
Imagine if Microsoft’s terms of use barred anyone from using their tools to build competitive software, or if Google barred using it to search for information to work on competing search engines. Anthropic’s argument that it was unsafe for others to be able to make advances in AI also rang hollow. Initially, Anthropic silently degraded Fable 5’s performance for users detected to be working on LLM research through invisible interventions that weakened the model’s outputs without notifying the user. After significant backlash, it walked back this decision and decided to be transparent when it did this, but it still refuses to use its latest capabilities to help AI researchers.
This move represents a raw demonstration of power by Anthropic. It has used “safety” arguments to hinder potential competitors. Platforms succeed when they are viewed as stable, reliable partners that one can build on. The sudden rule changes by Anthropic (including a mandatory 30 day data retention policy for Fable usage) have made developers wonder about the stability of building on any one proprietary LLM provider, not just Anthropic.
The U.S. Government then shortly followed with an even greater demonstration of power. It used the Commerce Department’s authority to regulate technologies that may be national security threats to restrict exports of Mythos and Fable, requiring a license for use by any foreign national, whether inside or outside of the U.S., including employees of Anthropic. This led Anthropic to disable access to Fable to all users worldwide.
Sam Altman pointed out, referring to Anthropic, “It is clearly incredible marketing to say, ‘We have built a bomb, we are about to drop it on your head. We will sell you a bomb shelter for $100 million.’” But when one engages in this type of fear-based marketing, it increases the odds that the U.S. Government will agree with you and slap export controls on the bomb you say you have built.
To be clear, I don't think Anthropic has built anything like a bomb, and I don't think export controls on Fable are appropriate.
However, following the U.S. Government making this move, many nations, including U.S. allies, saw how the U.S. can suddenly yank their access to AI models. In many capitals around the world, this has spurred discussions on AI sovereignty and how others can ensure uninterrupted access to this critical technology.
For decades, many nations were comfortable having many parts of their supply chain rely on the U.S., China, and other major producers. Once a nation issues a threat, or takes action, to limit other nations’ access, other nations will rationally try to secure alternatives. For decades, semiconductor manufacturing in China made slow progress; once the U.S. moved to limit China’s access, China’s efforts kicked into high gear. Similarly, once China threatened U.S. access to rare earth minerals, U.S. efforts to secure alternatives accelerated. Now that it has become crystal clear that private U.S. companies and the U.S. government can limit, in short order, other nations’ access to frontier AI models, the incentive of others to invest more in alternatives like open source grows significantly. Of course, training frontier models is not easy, so it remains to be seen how successful they are, but we have crossed the rubicon.
Satya Nadella wrote an essay about the importance of building a healthy ecosystem on top of frontier AI technology. I heartily agree with him, and hope this week’s events will ultimately prove to be constructive steps toward this.
I hope we can build a more free, more open world, where research is freely shared, and laws and societal norms shape a level playing field that allows everyone to make progress. A silver lining of the events of these past two weeks is now that everyone better realizes key points of instability of the current system, we can all work to create a more stable foundation.
[Original text: The Batch newsletter] -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Natural gas wholesale price now lower than a year ago, even in nominal terms. tradingeconomics.com/commodity/eu-natural-gas
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Given the policies won't change, I imagine the subsidies will increase as a result of our having to do everything domestically.
Tim Worstall
@worstall
Is there any useful proof that plastics recycling actually adds economic value? Or are we still having to subsidise it and therefore a smaller such industry makes us richer?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
We are in a bizarre situation where new homes are being built in the South but aren’t selling and yet demand is off the charts- millions of young adults are living with their parents. How is this possible?
The reason is clear: housing is just too damn expensive and the bank of mum, and dad has run dry.
The solution? Getting down the four core costs of housing down.
1. Build costs
2. Land costs
3. Planning costs
4. Infrastructure costs
The Forest City’s solution is to focus on the first three.
1. Innovate and use robots to build stunning homes (see the FT)
2. Build on agricultural land and replace fields with nature reserves to ensure a boon for the environment plus space for humans too.
3. Build big in one place and use a Development Corp (like the Olympics and Canary Wharf) to ensure planning happens FAST!
Cheap land usually correlates with high infrastructure costs. So that’s the trade off. But a city, unlike towns or town extensions, have large and commercial centres which can be valuable if you get it right. So high infra should be offset by a valuable commercial centre.
But in the end, only local and central government can resolve to do this. For the sake of millions of young, ambitious Brits, they absolutely have to. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
The misinformation about Andy Burnham’s wife benefitting from EV deals has come up unprompted consistently focus groups we’ve run in Makerfield, seemingly largely from Facebook: some believe it others don’t, but no doubt this stuff has a real impact
About Manchester
@AboutMcr
Ahead of tomorrow’s Makerfield vote-Analysis by the @SMFthinktank found that one in six news items shared in the groups during the campaign is false, with misinformation heavily targeting Andy Burnham aboutmanchester.co.uk/fake-news-is-surging-in-makerfield-…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Another day, another way in which Brexit will make us even poorer - our recycling industry now shut out by the EU - www.ft.com/content/f0d2f6d1-a987-42e1-a389-82472d9a5435?s…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is really important - there is no chance of the rest of the country closing the school attainment gap with London if the number of children regularly not turning up to school is this different. I wrote about how to sort this in @SchoolsWeek schoolsweek.co.uk/how-labour-can-solve-the-attendance-cri…
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Worryingly, the rate of severe school absences is rising. But there's a lot of regional variation, with London performing significantly better ⤵️ www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/losing-innovators-an…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Doug Lemov
@Doug_Lemov
First Australia. Now the UK have decided that social media companies aren’t the ideal people to shape childhood. Will states in the US be brave enough to do the same?
The New York Times
@nytimes
Breaking News: The U.K. government will ban social media for children under 16, Prime Minister Keir Starmer said. www.nytimes.com/2026/06/15/world/europe/uk-social-media-c…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is remarkable!
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Almost every single person on Earth lives with rats. Only 5 million people out of 8 billion live rat free. They are the Albertans.
Alberta is the only significantly human-inhabited place on Earth that is rat free. It achieved this in the 1950s as rats invaded from the East, by introducing a rodent surveillance state, obliging every citizen of the province to report them and terminating any sightings with extreme prejudice. They laid 63,000 kg of arsenic across a 600-kilometre-long, 29-kilometre-wide Rat Control Zone along the province's Eastern border.
Back then, rats were so unfamiliar in Alberta that officials distributed preserved rat corpses to teach people what the enemy looked like. One pest-control officer held public meetings at which he ate warfarin-soaked oatmeal to show it was safe.
And it worked! They held rats off and numbers remained so low that the surveillance and eradication system could keep numbers at essentially zero for years, at extremely low costs – Alberta spends about 11 cents per resident on rat control measures, much less than neighbouring provinces that are infested.
Today, Albertans have grown so unfamiliar with rats that they frequently mistake squirrels, gophers, and other small animals for them: of 875 reported sightings in 2025, only 47 turned out to be actual rats. Pet rats are banned, vehicles entering Alberta are checked, and sightings are responded to with overwhelming force.
Could the rest of the world manage it? Probably not. The secret was to stop them before they could establish themselves. For the rest of us, we probably need gene drives. Read the story of how Alberta won the war on rats at Works in Progress now.
worksinprogress.co/issue/albertas-war-on-rats/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Another evolution in Reform; threatening companies who won’t do what they want.
Serco - like any company or any person - is at liberty not to accept a contract from the government for any reason. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am with @joachim_voth here - air con is great stuff, and Europe should have more of it. We have surplus solar energy when it is hot and sunny, so there is no good reason against it.
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
Some people point out that Europe's hate of AC kills old people prematurely - fair. It's also idiotic even on climate grounds as hot days are sunny and hence, PV is abundant. One neglected issue is cognitive performance. There is good quasi-experimental evidence now that higher
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
AI can now generate a unique textbook for every child based on their interests, which is genuinely impressive.
But interactive whiteboards were genuinely impressive, and they didn't help learning.
The classic failure mode of ed tech is the solution in search of a problem - the genuinely impressive technology that does not solve any of the actual problems schools face.
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/why-personalising-education-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
"Manchesterism" has,
• Built an extra runway at its municipally owned airport for £172m (2001) and is currently building a new terminal.
• Built multiple tram extensions that finish early and on budget.
• Gone from planning application to open in 4 years for a new arena. -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
Why should people of working age have a lower personal allowance than pensioners? Age related allowances were abolished in the 2012 Budget and - even though it provoked a row about ‘the granny tax’ - we stuck to it. They’re unfair, expensive & create additional tax complexity.
The i Paper
@theipaper
Andy Burnham: I’ll keep the triple lock, and give pensioners a tax cut inews.co.uk/news/politics/andy-burnham-keep-triple-lock-p…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Judah
@b_judah
Northern Ireland remaining in the EU single market for goods means we have an entire region running as a counterfactual on how much wealthier we’d have been had we stayed. It’s actually outperformed London.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
People are getting ripped off when their phone contracts end - I have a solution - timleunig.substack.com/p/what-to-do-about-mobile-phone-co… - and my idea is free to read...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I never met Roy Hattersley, but we waved excitedly to each other early on 2nd May 1997. Tony Blair had just won the election spectacularly. I had been to the South Bank to listen to his "New Dawn rising" speech, Hattersley was out walking his dog. He looked very happy!
FT UK Politics
@ftukpolitics
Former Labour deputy leader Roy Hattersley dies aged 93 ft.trib.al/w4h2Hti
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't think a tax cut for pensioners would have been my #1 tax cut, somehow...
The i Paper
@theipaper
Andy Burnham: I’ll keep the triple lock, and give pensioners a tax cut inews.co.uk/news/politics/andy-burnham-keep-triple-lock-p…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Anna Clarke
@AnnaClarke_____
Instead, if councils choose to sell off high value voids, they can keep the proceeds themselves, to build new council housing. If this legislation had been enacted, they'd have had to hand it to central government instead, to fund the Right to Buy for housing association tenants.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is a very fine essay, and made me think differently about some things. Perhaps someone like @prospect_clark would like to publish it?
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Recovering from Thatcherism. > how Thatcherism left Britain the poorest country in Northern Europe, how a return to competition could fix it, and why "just crush the NIMBYs" is a really bad plan for boosting British growth. By me. Just now. tomforth.co.uk/recoveringfromthatcherism/
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
So excited to be part of the Forest City project. Decent family houses at affordable prices, and lots and lots of nature. What is not to like?
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
Today the Forest City project is taking another step to repair Britain’s broken social contract by kicking-off our 4-bed housing challenge.
Is it possible to build a beautiful, stone-faced, generously proportioned, 4-bedroom terraced house at a cost of no more than £250k? Right now, a similarly sized new house on the outskirts of Cambridge will cost a prospective couple at least £600k. Buying a similar sized old home in the centre of the city costs well over £1m. It’s no different in many places in the South.
That’s a disgusting joke; completely out of reach without massive help from parents or mortgaging yourself to the hilt. We refuse to be enslaved to debt any longer.
That’s why we’re using technology and talent to show everyone that you can indeed create something amazing that doesn’t cost a king’s ransom.
Working with two time Sterling Prize-nominated architect, Amin Taha, and architect turned robotics entrepreneur, @GillesRetsin, we are creating the home for the 22nd century using robots that can build the shell of a house in 12hrs. We will change the economic prospects for hundreds of thousands of young working Brits and hope to display the home in Cambridge very soon. You can read more about it in the House & Home section of this weekend’s @FT. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
You can buy it back (nationalisation). Or you can build more and own what you build (municipalisation). That's the choice. One leaves the country with no more energy and water infrastructure. The other could nearly double it. I know where I would start.
Jessica Elgot
@jessicaelgot
A decade-long project to bring water and energy into public control will lie at the heart of Andy Burnham’s agenda should he become prime minister, according to sources close to the Greater Manchester mayor.
Exc from @kiranstacey
www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/jun/13/andy-burnham-pub… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My boss, @RGurumurthy has written something rather more interesting than most people manage, on what a Labour government could look like and ACTUALLY DO - www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/politics/73773/a-plan-for-britain
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Iwan Doherty
@IwanDoherty98
Any party that wants to make the supply case needs to show the public that our current housing stock is simply insufficient.
We can talk about prices, but maybe the more understandable example is the growing number of young adults trapped living with their parents
James Yucel
@JLYucel
🧵 NEW @focaldataHQ: the first map of what Brits actually believe about housing - not just what it wants.
The headline is Britain want more homes, but won't build them.
Why? Only 18% think a shortage is what's causing the crisis. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Maxwell Marlow 🇺🇦
@maxwell_marlow
Good to see the @CommonsHCLG recommend major reform to Stamp Duty.
It’s time for the government to listen and at least overhaul stamp duty, or do the right thing and abolish it. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (£/free trial) discusses what we can do to prevent people keeping £1m+ in assets when they go bankrupt, to the detriment of their creditors. timleunig.substack.com/p/a-proposal-for-bankrupcy
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They don't refuse to downsize, @BenZaranko, they choose not to for a host of reasons. It is called freedom!
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
You’ve probably heard of Henry – the High Earner, Not Rich Yet. But what about his nemesis, Richard – who Retired In a Comfortable House And Refuses to Downsize?
There are quite a lot of Richards out there. They’re the subject of my column for today’s Observer (link below). -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Prices are indeed the ratio of supply to demand.
sean
@sean29772912
Would having 13 million more people in Britain since 1980 have anything to do with it
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Rest assured @Jamie_Blackett I never thought we should be like Singapore when it comes to farming - it was half a sentence taking out of context and put in the public domain by someone with an agenda.
Jamie Blackett
@Jamie_Blackett
This wouldn't be the same @timleunig who opined that we didn't need a farming industry and could be just like Singapore.... just before COVID?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am always impressed at how kind and calm and engaged @DanNeidle is on twitter. He responds respectively to responses like this one, time and again.
Vinlad
@Vinlad84
What a fucking dumb take
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written about housing and poverty, drawing on my childhood experiences growing up in Chatham - read it here. www.brightblue.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/BB-Essay…
Bright Blue
@WeAreBrightBlue
🏡Read an extract from @timleunig 's essay in @LBC :www.lbc.co.uk/article/workers-pensions-buy-house-crisis-o… 🏡
Link to the whole book 👉www.brightblue.org.uk/portfolio/liberalism-liberated/ -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is 100% correct. Andy Burnham has just offered a big tax cut to investors, landlords and land owners, albeit paid for by other investors, landlords and land owners.
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
The market price for doing business from that location is the rent + the business rates. If we just scrap business rates, then within 5 to 10 years the value of the tax cut will get swallowed up by landlords. Businesses will only get better off if they own their premises.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
UK tax has gone up significantly over the last 25 years
But the tax paid by the average UK worker has not
This apparent miracle was achieved by taxing “other people”: higher earners, capital, property, banks, etc
The strategy has run out of road
A 🧵 on what happens next. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written something! So have lots of other people!
Bright Blue
@WeAreBrightBlue
‼️Our latest essay collection on the future of British Liberalism‼️
18 essays in total from emerging and established liberals across party lines, including contributions from @liambyrnemp , @monicabeharding , @andy4wm , @PDJSwallow , @charles_hendry, @vincecable, @RobertBuckland , @TonyJuniper , @normanlamb , @ProfDavidNutt , @timleunig , Professor Paul Gregg CBE, and more.
👇Link 👇
www.brightblue.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/BB-Essay… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
As with all the other stories about politicians and tax, if politicians are going to create complex tax laws for the rest of us, then it's not too much to expect them to follow it themselves.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The only plausible route to lower rents is indeed supply of housing in relevant areas. It is all about supply and demand.
Dan Carden
@DanCardenMP
A growing body of evidence is making the case for action on rent affordability in the private rented sector.
Three important reports published in recent weeks deserve serious attention.
🧵⬇️ : -
Tim Leunig reposted
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
This is a great visualisation of the field-defining work of Katharina Knoll and her collaborators. Knoll showed that:
(a) Before modern land-use rules, house prices were flat in real terms (meaning that housing became far more affordable as incomes rose);
(b) House prices began rising in the postwar era and exploded in recent decades;
(c) The shortage is worst in the UK but the trajectory is basically the same in continental Europe.
Fergus
@F_McCullough
European nations are the finest builders of cities in the world, combining efficiency and liveability with atmosphere and beauty. But today, despite huge demand, Europe is building only half as much housing as it did at its peak. What's gone wrong?
Well-intentioned EU environmental directives are part of the problem, creating a legal straitjacket on growth.
- The 2005 environmental impact statement for the Dublin City Centre light railway extension was 176 pages. Twenty years later, the report for the extension to Finglas is… over 7,000 pages.
- Lack of clarity over goose feeding sites in Dublin has led to permission for 1,200 homes being refused.
- Major infrastructure projects from Galway to Antwerp, and the Baltics to Germany, have fallen afoul of environmental rules.
What's the solution? Today @ProgressIreland has published a report showing how targeted changes to environmental directives can deliver the housing and infrastructure we need -- without costing the earth.
Our specific recommendations include move from a reactive regime to strategic protection, restoring the original purpose of directives, updating tests for public interest, and more.
You can read about them in our report (link below), which we're launching tonight in Brussels. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I hope Kemi will realise this week that anything would be better than propping up a minority reform government after the next election
Rachel Wolf
@racheljanetwolf
Reform have been really off putting in recent days. The dishonest attacks on Kemi (who was excellent yesterday), the panicky undertones to the aggression. They’re behaving like a party behind in the polls and desperate to catch up. Is this about Restore and Elon?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
Black men are twice as likely to get prostate cancer. It is good policy to screen those at higher risk
What we have in this country is two tier politics: people who, whatever their faults, are trying to make things better; and people like Zia who are trying to sow division
Zia Yusuf
@ZiaYusufUK
On the day the whole political establishment claims we do not live in a two tier country, they announce this.
Note, the NHS makes NO drugs available exclusively to white people. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In shock news, an organisation trying to sell you something says you are not buying enough of their product! Pension lobbyists at it again - www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3928m30v89o
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
His tax giveaways were terrible, however, and definitely worsened the fiscal position. I mean, I salute his repentance, but...
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
Some good ideas in this.
The easy rebuttal is 'why didn't you do this when you were Chancellor?'
But in fairness, I think Hunt more than any Chancellor used his short time in the job to fix problems on the supply side (e.g. full expensing, tax cliff edges). -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week I have written up an idea to save taxpayers money - showing why the rule that the railway company always has to provide a replacement bus service is not a sensible one. Free to read - timleunig.substack.com/p/reducing-wasteful-spending-on-our
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
PS Yes, the platform really was that uneven!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Not sure the BBC really understands the difference between causation and correlation - "No English team has ever lost a shootout in a UCL final against European sides. History is on Arsenal's side."
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Iwan Doherty
@IwanDoherty98
Farmland is probably the easiest way to understand why LVT is not passed on
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
How will your country's demographics change this century?
At Our World in Data we built a tool to let you see for yourself.
The UN's assumptions are the starting point.
But then you can adjust the three drivers of change — births, deaths, and migration — to what you expect. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Given that Morrison's failed to turn a profit, hard to see how this would work effectively without taxpayer subsidy...
James Meadway
@meadwaj
Nationalise Morrisons, use it as the foundation for a new, publicly-owned grocery store selling high quality, affordable food. National-level version of the Mamdani plan in New York.
Need to think big in a world with repeated, major shocks to essential supply systems. -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Hollidge
@DavidHollidge
If someone on £75k/year with a 41 hour week with 1 hour guaranteed overtime restructured the contract to earn minimum wage (age 21+ at £12.21/hour) for the first 40 hours which is £25,396.80 and the remaining £49,603.20 is overtime this would reduce their tax by about £17,000!
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: Nigel Farage has pledged to scrap income tax on overtime above 40 hours a week for anyone earning under £75,000
[@Telegraph] -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Just to be clear, the total of @AndyBurnhamGM great achievement with buses is a 3% rise in the number of people using them? That doesn't seem much of a foundation to lead a country...
Jim McMahon OBE MP
@JimfromOldham
Bus usage in Greater Manchester has increased by five million journeys (155m to over 160m) since franchising.
At the same time GM is reducing fares and expanding frequency of its trams; its use has increased from 42m to 46m journeys too.
It’s the start of reversing the decline accelerated after deregulation, and recovering the hit from Covid.
It’s a shame it’s being used by one mayor to criticise another. The focus should be for every area to get the investment and improvement it deserves. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We built HS1 roughly on schedule and on budget. Didn't mean we could do the same for HS2! Why would this be different? (Nb CR2 a much worse route than CR1)
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Welcome to Britain, where we build a massively successful infrastructure project then don't even try to replicate it. London's Crossrail 2 plans are mothballed, and hopes of crossrails in Manchester, Birmingham and Glasgow exist only as twinkles in railway geeks' eyes.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I remember predicting that this would happen in an EH101 lecture 20 years ago. About time!
James Meadway
@meadwaj
This looks huge - the hukou internal registration system had created two tiers of access to social insurance, with c.350m migrant workers essentially excluded. Scrapping it universalises provision (and should be an sig boost to domestic spending, a major economic rebalancing act)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You are right: @reformparty_uk are being silly. It is unfair on people who work half time, who will have to pay tax on overtime. It will also encourage people to work 60h:20h each week rather than 40h:40h.
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
Reform have proposed abolishing tax on overtime for every worker earning less than £75k.
My take:
1. This appears to be an import of Trump’s extremely dumb (but clearly popular) ‘no tax on tips’ policy.
2. If your aim is to boost growth and incentivise work, this isn’t a good use of £5bn. It’s a luxury policy in all honesty: can they honestly say £5bn couldn’t go further elsewhere (either in tax cuts, infrastructure investment, or just improving public services)?
3. This will likely create lots of avoidance opportunities.
4. There will also be genuine cases of unfairness. What about workers with second jobs?
5. This is likely to create a massive cliff-edge problem where taking an extra hour of overtime or getting a raise leaves someone thousands of pounds worse off. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Stunned, appalled, shocked etc to see actual tax reform from a politician. This from Wes Streeting today.
A thread on why capital gains tax is broken. It's too low AND too high. & why this is a good proposal. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well yes, a land value tax would not hit low value land much, by definition. As ever, the devil is in the detail
Mark Tughan
@marktughan
It would be good to understand how LVT could be structured so as not to hurt it hit farms such that they become less viable that they already are. Or is it the case that land with little value will be taxed little? Farms in the expensive Home Counties and south East?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
All tax can be viewed as unfair. Almost all tax reduces growth, because (to put it crudely) you will get less of the thing that you are taxing. Land is the exception. That is why land value tax is widely supported by economists across the political spectrum.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Apparently I am not just dishonest, but very dishonest! Good to know from their Twitter handle however that the comfy chair is not into hate, just baseless insults...
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
There’s a great case for an LVT, but I agree with Tim Leunig. Land isn’t under-taxed - we tax land more than any other OECD country. It’s badly taxed.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I wish you all a lovely bank holiday weekend in the sunshine...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is very exciting. I think this would increase the growth rate of places like Leeds
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
This is exciting.
British tram projects take longer and cost four times as much as they do in Germany.
So Labour have announced a 'mass transit taskforce' (Fingleton for Trams).
The taskforce includes David Milner (who co-wrote the @BritainRemade/@createstreets paper that revealed the huge cost gap.)
And it looks like the Govt will devolve the Transport Works Act Order process so West Yorkshire can grant itself planning permission to build a tram in Leeds (without asking central govt).
This is a key ask of @BritainRemade.
(Credit to @Ben_A_Hopkinson, @JP_Spencer_, and @dc_lawrence for pushing for this.)
www.gov.uk/government/news/new-mass-transit-taskforce-to-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Exactly five years ago, as a Member of the European Parliament, I filed a 22-page complaint with the European Commission arguing that Spain's €53 million rescue of Plus Ultra, a tiny airline with Venezuelan shareholders operating four leased planes on three Latin American routes, was illegal state aid.
The company was not strategic: 0.1% of Spanish aviation passengers, position 77 by passenger volume. The aid was nearly eight times its financial debt and more than three times the maximum the Commission's own rules allowed. The capital that lifted it out of "firm in difficulty" status pre-Covid (a requirement of the aid approval) came from a €6.3 million participative loan from a Panamanian bank, of which €4.1 million was locked as collateral in a foreign account. The actual loan was €2.2 million.
Today the Audiencia Nacional has indicted former Prime Minister Zapatero for organised crime, traffic of influences, and document falsification in the same case. The criminal investigation alleges that the rescue funds were used to launder money from Venezuelan corruption, with €1.5 million in commissions paid through a consultancy owned by a Zapatero associate.
Plus Ultra is what the "entrepreneurial" state looks like in practice. A small concentrated group (Plus Ultra's shareholders and their political contacts) captured a large diffuse rent (€53 million of Spanish taxpayer money). The politicians making the call were not maximising the survival of strategic Spanish industry.
Rules are out and discretion is back on both sides of the Atlantic. Trump grants tariff exemptions firm by firm, takes equity stakes in Nippon Steel and Intel, allocates CHIPS Act funds on terms that are not public. Everyone in the know trades on the news.
When the market fails the easy solution is "let the state intervene". But the state is not composed of angels, but of politicians who are human beings. When designing solutions to "market failure" one has to always wonder "with this design and these incentives, are there reasons to believe the state will be able to do this better"?
I explained the Plus Ultra case here:
youtu.be/_4dPV9HNhkE
Link to my allegations in spanish: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/j3enqku9qmxuiye2au97l/Alegaciones-…
And thread below
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Llevo meses alertando de las irregularidades en el rescate a Plus Ultra. He presentado una denuncia ante la Comisión Europea y el Gobierno ha tenido que dar explicaciones.
Tras estudiarlas a fondo, me reafirmo: Es una ayuda de Estado ILEGAL. Abro HILO con la investigación🔎 1/19 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
The FT has a nice article on London’s decline, which matters for Britain as a whole as it’s our powerhouse.
They have various charts but perhaps the clearest example of struggle is that Lima is shifting to cheaper cuts of meat, as consumers are poorer & more price sensitive -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
The UK is cutting tariffs on food to help with the cost of living.
Good idea, but why make 'targeted cuts' to 100 types of products?
Get rid of the lot. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Yep, this is from @timleunig: www.nesta.org.uk/blog/fiscal-options-untangling-vat/
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The most depressing line I have seen in @FT for some time - skilled wages are half as high here as in the US. (Great article from @DelphineStrauss more generally - www.ft.com/content/1a3d44fa-a4dc-42d5-808a-fbc0aa254f95?s…)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tej Parikh
@tejparikh90
The UK's decision to ban new North Sea licences shows how virtue based policymaking can lead to worse outcomes. It means:
-Importing more from basin neighbour Norway
-A higher carbon footprint
-...& now, relaxing sanctions on Russian crude
My @FT piece:as.ft.com/r/3d0a8eab-9b7a-4df7-a04a-e779d992a24e -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
So long as the LA now pays the extra benefits we all have to stump up because their decision means less and so more expensive housing ...
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Good. National government should not intervene on local government decisions. The local government is responsible.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
According to the relevant local cllr, PINS - aka national govt - has backed the council on appeal.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I thought this was a local decision by Southwark? Which bad central government decision am I missing here?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I admired the minister concerned for wanting to understand, and not being willing to bluff that they already did so.
Simon Cook
@cooksimon
Tbf at least the minister wanted to learn.
But maybe it’s something you should learn *before* becoming a minister -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The proposal was for about 850 houses, of which therefore around 100 would have been social houses. Given the fall in London house values since the scheme was submitted, it is very unlikely that any new scheme will offer more, unless grant funded... 1/3
Richard Livingstone
@Livingstone_RJ
I'm delighted that the planning inspectorate has backed @lb_southwark in turning down Berkeley Homes' Aylesham shopping centre application - which both reduced retail space & provided just 12% social housing.
Well done to the local councillors & residents who made the case.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
@Livingstone_RJ refusal means an increase in council house waiting lists of about 100, higher rents for people living in the area (less supply means higher prices), and so more poverty, and means Peckham won't get the regen these scheme brought with it. 2/3
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I get that local councils are NIMBY, because of the electoral pressures. But it is so, so disappointing when central government - which claims to want more housing - keeps making bad decisions like this. No wonder Berkeley Homes have literally given up buying land.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It was when I was a civil servant, and it was not a Treasury minister...
Mark Kingsley-Williams
@Mark_A_K_W
But @RachelReevesMP said she was an economist at the Bank of England! Say it isn't so.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I fear you are right - lots of good intentions from @RachelReevesMP and @hmtreasury undone by @mhclg and their ministers. Sigh.
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
Labour were elected on a pledge to get Britain building again, but their councillors (Planning Chair btw) block 850+ homes on Brownfield land in the most expensive city in the country.
Labour are unlikely to outbuild the last Govt, let alone build 1.5m homes.
Richard Livingstone
@Livingstone_RJ
I'm delighted that the planning inspectorate has backed @lb_southwark in turning down Berkeley Homes' Aylesham shopping centre application - which both reduced retail space & provided just 12% social housing.
Well done to the local councillors & residents who made the case. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I remember getting a WhatsApp from a minister once, asking me to explain this to them privately. It had been explained to them perfectly well, but they had not believed it. And no, I am not saying which minister!
Rupert Harrison
@rbrharrison
This is amazing. But to be fair even the FT and the Economist seem to assume that their readers don't know that bond prices move inversely to yields - otherwise they wouldn't have to keep wasting valuable word count reminding them the whole time...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Re-industrialisation is a quite remarkable pledge by @AndyBurnhamGM! As you say, @JohnRentoul, it suggests that he is not serious - or has been misquoted. Reindustrialisation is also much harder if we remain outside the EU, customs union, etc.
John Rentoul
@JohnRentoul
Also, “re-industrialisation”? Seriously?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
John Rentoul
@JohnRentoul
You can’t say, “I want to rejoin the EU,” and “I hope it happens in my lifetime,” in Sep and hope to get away with this, 8 months later
Alex Wickham
@alexwickham
BREAKING: Andy Burnham u-turns on his desire to rejoin the EU
“I am not proposing rejoining the EU”
“I respect the decision that was made at the referendum”
“The last thing we should do now is re-run those arguments”
Flips his view from just 7 months ago when he backed rejoin -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But what about winning songs? Does it help to sing in English for Eurovision? (assuming that is the non-national language chosen)
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
Also fascinating to see a trend confirmed, Eurovision singers are once again singing in their national language!
Courtesy of @Hexagone_org -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my free to read substack discusses how the government can reduce the cost of over the counter medicines - timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-reduce-over-the-counter-m…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
One from me along those lines - timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-reduce-social-care-bills-and
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
Europe is ageing, but productivity is barely keeping up, and we're struggling to afford adult social care.
This creates a huge fiscal strain.
It would be a tremendous benefit if governments incentivised high-tech innovations for adult social care.
In the long-run, this could lower government costs, create new markets, & prevent high taxes on the young. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The papers report him subsidising the buses to create the £2 fare, I assume council tax precept.
cookiesnrap 🇪🇺
@HermanZeGerman
What taxes has he raised in Manchester to subsidise buses (genuine question)?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I wrote a paper along those lines, years ago. I called it Right to Move. Can't remember who published it, but you might want to dig it out.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Retirees often move away from city cores… I want to let social tenants do the same, with a cash windfall, to free the homes up for people who do work in London. Entirely voluntary – only you are talking about “relocating” people.
And if 29% are retired and 30% are out of work, that means nearly half of working-age households in inner London, in some of the most valuable homes in Britain, do not work. That’s an extraordinary figure. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Interesting from Andy Burnham. Appears he wants to raise tax to subsidise energy use. That is what he did with buses.
Channel 4 News
@Channel4News
Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham has set out his views on Labour's path forward and the policy challenges facing the country.
Speaking to Channel 4 News' Andrew Misra, Burnham said he wanted Labour to become “a party that they can believe in again, a party solidly on the side of working class people.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Countries get the cabinets they pay for. Singapore pays its Foreign Minister about S$1.1m, around US$800,000. The salary is benchmarked to 60% of the median income of the top 1,000 Singaporean earners. That is why you can get Vivian Balakrishnan, former eye surgeon and hospital chief executive, implementing @karpathy's external brain idea (link below). The speech shows deep understanding of AI and fills one with confidence about Singapore's future.
The UK Foreign Secretary earns roughly £165,000: the MP salary plus a ministerial salary of about £67,000. The ministerial part is frozen since the crisis and is down by roughly a third in real terms since 2010. This is what a junior Magic Circle lawyer earns.
Spain pays its ministers around €85,000. So you do not get a surgeon who has run hospitals. You get a party loyalist who has never run anything.
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
Singapore’s Foreign Minister, Dr Balakrishnan casually explaining how he built his own AI agent (a 2nd brain for diplomacy) using Claude & WhatsApp integration etc. on a Raspberry Pi
“You cannot govern a technology you have only been briefed on.” 🇸🇬This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
No smoking gun, but the preponderance of evidence points to smartphones, not economics, as the culprit for the global drop in fertility:
• In the US and UK, births fell first and fastest in areas that got 4G earliest
• Birth rates were stable in the US, UK and Australia until 2007; in France and Poland until 2009; in Mexico and Indonesia until 2012; in Ghana, Nigeria and Senegal until 2013-15
Each of these inflection points matches local smartphone adoption (see picture).
• The younger the age group, the sharper the drop.
• in-person socialising among young adults is dropping. In SK, by 50% in 20 years
• Sexual dysfunction is higher among heavy social media user
• Effect is largest in culturally traditional societies — Middle East, Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa
• Decline holds across countries hit hard by GFC 2008 and those not hit, fast-growing and not growing.
Excellent again @jburnmurdoch.
www.ft.com/content/fba35eca-df3a-4ad6-b42d-eb08eb7c9ad3?s… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Surely there is an easy way for Labour to win the Makerfield by-election? Keir Starmer promises to resign immediately if Andy Burnham wins, and Wes, Rayner etc say they will back him as PM. "Vote Labour to oust Starmer" sounds like a winning slogan.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dr Alexander Apostolides
@alexapo1980
I have nothing but admiration for Tim Leuning, having been privileged to have been both a student and then running some of the seminars of this legendary Economic History 101 class at the @LSEEcHist where i was a PhD student.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
The Man in Seat 61
@seatsixtyone
DON'T BUY TRAIN TICKETS IN ADVANCE!
On 1 April, govt is quietly changing the National Rail Conditions of Travel.
Off-Peak & Anytime tickets become non-refundable after 23:59 the day BEFORE you travel.
If you wake up & find your event cancelled, NO REFUNDS, even on £100+ tickets. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is genuinely shocking. In 1926 I would expect it, but 2026?
Gita Gopinath
@GitaGopinath
A painting of the end of meritocracy: A meeting of the two largest economies and not one woman at the table.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But it is not true, @GavinBarwell . IGCSEs also have formula sheets! The excellent @daisychristo is the expert on all those.
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
👇 💯
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
You can bet private school kids will still be taught and expected to memorise equations. This dumbing down - by ministerial diktat - will only deepen inequality: a case study in the soft bigotry of low expectations.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Good news about the British economy?!
UK productivity – how much the economy produces per hour worked – grew more in the past year than in the previous seven years combined.
In our recent Substack @GregoryThwaites takes a closer look 📈👇
resolutionfoundation.substack.com/p/uk-productivity-grew-… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree. People who don't pay tax to the UK government should not be rescued at the expense of those of us who pay the taxes!
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
Ed Davey suggests in the Commons that if the UK govt helps evacuate British expats who have moved to Dubai to avoid tax, they should lose their tax advantages.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
It is my biggest gripe with all the industrial policy stuff. It is oh intervention is great. . as long as I am the one dictating it. But that ignores completely the political economy of intervention. I find it stunning that people who are sophisticated about power don't see that once you set up a system where the government is given all those powers you cannot know they get used for good.
That is the wisdom of liberalism and limited government. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The evidence is with @daisychristo here, not @FraserNelson. State schools in England take gold standard qualifications aged 16.
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
This isn't true. Independent schools do IGCSE which also has formula sheets.
In other subjects IGCSE is easier to game than GCSE, eg 40% coursework for English.
Private schools do not systematically choose more difficult exams than state. Maybe in the past, but not now. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Some personal news - I am delighted to announce that I have been appointed an Honorary Professor in the @uclspp (UCL political science, school of public policy). I am very much looking forward to working with them in future... 1/3
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have also been appointed a Fellow of the @RoyalEconSoc. This is a particular delight as the RES funded my PhD, when @ESRC declined to do so. As a free school meals kid I had no ability to cover the costs myself, so the RES changed my life. 2/3
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
None of this means I am leaving any of my current roles, I remain Chief Economist @nesta_uk, Director of Economics at Public First and a Visiting Professor @LSEPublicPolicy. 3/3
-
Tim Leunig reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
Makerfield voted 65% Leave in 2016 (the 75th most Leave seat). Over the next few weeks, there’ll be plenty of news coverage about Brexit (reset negotiations, 10th anniversary). Andy Burnham is a rejoiner. If Reform can’t make Brexit work for them here, it’ll tell us a lot.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Former Tory Minister @GavinBarwell is right that Kemi shows poor judgement here.
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
No amount of impressive rhetorical performances in the Commons will make up for poor strategic judgement. Kemi doesn't seem to realise the survival of many of her MPs at the next election will depend on their ability to attract anti-Reform tactical votes 1/5
James Heale
@JAHeale
And a Tory source tells me: “As soon as she heard about this, Kemi instantly demanded this arrangement be stopped. The group leader was suspended with immediate effect. Kemi was clear she would not put up with this sort of nonsense.”
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Archbishop of Canterbury
@ArchbishopSarah
Today I visited the Sternberg Centre for Judaism. It was good to see the extraordinary educational, theological and community work taking place there.
But it was impossible to ignore the the distressing truth about Jewish life in Britain today. No parent should have to fear for their child’s safety at school or at worship.
Antisemitism must be opposed without hesitation or qualification. We all share responsibility for challenging hatred wherever we encounter it.
www.archbishopofcanterbury.org/news/archbishop-sarah-pled… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alex Armlovich
@aarmlovi
New AGF blog: Tokyo is the world's most affordable megacity--and they're still permitting homes at many times the pace of NYC, London, Paris
Yet land prices are still very high! A 1-acre suburban home in Chiyoda would cost over $100M before you nail the first board
Tokyo shows structures can be affordable if you stack enough of them on pricey land. It also shows that YIMBYism will not crash land markets or impoverish land-rich homeowners in attractive areas
Tokyo also heightens the contradictions of the profit-focused version of the Homevoter Hypothesis: In the highest-demand neighborhoods of the US, the homevoters prioritizing "Boomer suburb vibes" are not just hurting renters, they're costing *themselves* billions of dollars of land value -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My take on this excellent report: stamp duty land tax is a mess and should be sorted out. The law was never intended to place a higher tax burden on someone buying a house for their disabled child, nor should it do so.
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Our report: taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/05/14/why-did-hmrc-not-charge-angel…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
Interesting chart from the @CentreforCities report: the bite is rising everywhere, but the share of workers earning close to the minimum is rapidly rising in low-wage cities -- and not rising in high wage cities. Pres. the MW is cutting into a denser part of the wage distribution
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
Streaming now! Link below.
The UK national minimum wage is heading to 2/3 of median
B/c of the UK’s very unequal economic geography, this means its bite is very high in many parts of the UK
How should we think about this? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Emil Verner
@EmilVerner
This article is a useful reminder that the relatively successful yet comparatively egalitarian Scandinavian economies are quite pro-market. The key is to promote successful private sector businesses that generate growth and make a generous welfare state sustainable. Then you can layer a welfare state on top that expands equality of opportunity and provides a safety net for those who fall between the cracks. The same story broadly applies to my native Denmark, which tightened fiscal discipline and undertook market-oriented reforms in the 80s and 90s.
[The reader can decide who needs this reminder]
www.wsj.com/world/europe/the-worlds-most-surprising-capit… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Helen Miller
@HelenMiller_IFS
Some context for discussions about fiscal rules:
UK already borrows a lot, it’s expensive & under current plans for a fiscal consolidation, Public Sector Net Debt is only due to stabilize (not fall) in coming years
UK’s problem is not restrictive fiscal rules
Some numbers: -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Be good to have this relative to population... I think Sweden is above us, but as you say, this is a good news story.
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
Lots of good news stories like this at present!
The UK's relative strength in terms of venture capital investment, and how to build on it, probably ought to feature more heavily in the economic debate (might be easier when the politics calms down) -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is reopening old wounds, @g__j, but you are right to do so. There is a lot to be said for nodal pricing and zonal pricing!
Greg Jackson
@g__j
According to independent experts, Zonal Pricing would conservatively have saved £50-100/year on household bills (perhaps more if it improved infrastructure decisions) - within a couple of years - whilst making energy cleaner.
The government says its solution - Reformed National Pricing - could save £20-40/year by 2040. A fraction the saving and a decade late.
Zonal pricing was itself a compromise between nodal pricing and the current system.
It's like nodal was the real deal. Freshly squeezed orange juice. Zonal was a nearly as good substitute - orange juice from concentrate, and reformed national pricing is so diluted it's more like flavoured water.
This isn't reopening old wounds - but surely a cost-benefit analysis of zonal vs the alternatives should have been done before the decision.
And this is all assuming that these plans survive incumbent lobbying.... -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
Either govt must make the case for formally banning new North Sea oil licences, in the face of a global shortage of oil.
Or it must abandon its manifesto pledge.
For more background about the N Sea, here is a deep dive from a while back👇
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
📽️ From Donald Trump to Britain's wind power trade body, there's a growing coalition calling for more drilling in the North Sea.
Raising the question: if we DID encourage more exploration, how much oil & gas could we actually get?
Our MEGA primer on the North Sea👇
Ps it's longer than usual, but it turns out this topic has SO MANY misconceptions. Time to put some of them right.
Let me know what you thinkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Good job the Forest City plan includes a train line to Cambridge! And local employment!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
When I reported on Zahawi I got a handful of abusive messages. When he apologised & it turned out I was right, they all stopped.
But Polanski? Wild levels of abuse, which just ramped up when Polanski apologised & it turned out I was right.
Does the Green Party have a problem? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
And now for something completely different. I think a lot about this chart - the share of UK retail sales carried out online. The COVID-19 pandemic basically had no visible impact to what had been a hitherto linear capture rate by online channels. Interesting experiment on adoption rates and the (limited) influence of forced channel shift.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have been accused of all sorts of things in my time, but never being a TechnoFascist bent on destroying our countries national heritage! This weird stuff has really made me smile!
Anne of Green Gardens
@Preservation945
You want to bulldoze it for your TechnoFascist fantasy land
My plan is to support my British colleagues in their work of stopping greedy manipulative deflecting ecocidal consultant scammers, like you, from destroying the little that remains of their natural & historic heritage -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Guess what? If we allow more houses to be built, housing becomes cheaper! Let more evidence that Econ 101 contains very powerful intuitions that are proven right time and again.
M. Nolan Gray 🥑
@mnolangray
For 45 years, Berkeley built virtually no new housing. By the mid-2010s, it was the most expensive college town in America. Shortly thereafter, YIMBYs took over and kicked off a building boom. Today, nominal rents are below 2018 rates—remarkable progress on affordability.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In a free world, companies have the right to invest or not invest here. We might not like it, but it is a reality. So @meadwaj is right on the fact, but I suspect he and I might differ on the implications of that fact.
James Meadway
@meadwaj
This is the development JP Morgan have already demanded they pay no local taxes on. Lest you be under illusions as to who makes the decisions round here.
www.instagram.com/reel/DX6ZpAksKAK/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Artur Nadolny
@ArturNadol7566
THE RETIRED LAWYER WHO DID PARLIAMENT'S JOB AND WON A JOURNALISM AWARD FOR IT
Dan Neidle (@DanNeidle) retired at 49 from Clifford Chance, one of the world's most powerful law firms, where he spent nearly 25 years as head of tax. Most people in that position go quiet and enjoy the garden.
Neidle started a non-profit think tank and spent his retirement doing what journalists, regulators, and parliament couldn't be bothered to do.
In July 2022, he published detailed analysis showing that Chancellor Nadhim Zahawi (@nadhimzahawi) had used an offshore structure to avoid approximately £3.7 million in capital gains tax on his YouGov stake. Then he showed Zahawi had lied about it.
Zahawi's lawyers at Osborne Clarke sent him threatening letters marked "confidential" and "not for publication," demanding he retract the allegations within 24 hours or face defamation action. They told him it would be "improper" and a "serious matter" to publish the letters.
Neidle published the letters.
He also published more detailed analysis. Then he referred the lawyers to the Solicitors Regulation Authority.
@TheSun then revealed Zahawi had secretly settled with HMRC for the exact amount Neidle estimated, plus a 30% penalty. Total: nearly £5 million. Rishi Sunak sacked Zahawi in January 2023 after an investigation found he had breached the Ministerial Code by failing to disclose he was being investigated by HMRC while serving as Chancellor.
Neidle won Investigation of the Year at the British Journalism Awards 2023. He is not a journalist.
The SRA referred Osborne Clarke partner Ashley Hurst to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, marking the first time a solicitor had been referred to the SDT for abusive tactics in libel litigation. In December 2024, the Tribunal found Hurst guilty of misconduct and fined him £50,000.
A retired tax lawyer spotted what a sitting Chancellor was hiding, refused to be silenced by his legal team, was proved right in every detail, won a journalism award, and then got the silencing lawyer sanctioned.
Zahawi got a pension. Neidle got a prize. The lawyer got a fine. The public got to watch.
This is what accountability looks like when institutions won't do it themselves.
Sources: @guardian @BBCNews @FT @TheSun @PressGazette | -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
The OBR already estimates the long-term impacts of public investment on growth, published a full peer-reviewed paper explaining its modelling, and recently listed the topic as a research priority. Pretending everything would be fine if only OBR "believed" isn't going to cut it.
Paul Mason
@paulmasonnews
8/ But the Budget Responsibility Act 2024 was a mistake. The problem is the OBR: it does not believe investment drives growth...this red circle shows where ultimate fiscal policymaking power in Britain lies. It's a joke. If you something to "fall into line" choose that...
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
Here's my interactive map of last week's local election in London showing every candidate for every ward in every borough - all in one place.
smallsites.london/Election2026.html -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
When I taught @LSEEcHist economic history 101 I used to end my course with the words "never bet against the United States". I would still end my course with those words. @lugaricano is right in what he says here.
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
We stopped everything to write an answer (link below) to Paul Krugman's two posts of today (one informal, one with a simple model) arguing that Europe is broadly not falling behind the United States.
The change measured by the Draghi report, he argues, is mostly due to growth in the technology industry, which has distorted GDP numbers without actually leading to higher standards of living. We should believe our eyes when we walk around France and walk around Mississippi.
Krugman is wrong. The measures he uses understate European stagnation. This matters enormously. Divergence with the United States is the strongest evidence for reform in Europe.
1. The growth numbers
Krugman compares the United States, France, and Germany at purchasing power parity in current prices. On that measure, France's and Germany's position relative to America has been roughly constant since 2000.
But current price comparisons miss productivity gains in sectors where prices fall. If America produces twice as much software while the price of each unit halves, the value of American software output looks unchanged even though the volume has doubled.
Most economists therefore use constant prices, which fix the base-year PPP level and apply each country's real output growth on top of it. American output growth has concentrated in tech, where prices have fallen tremendously as productivity rises. In terms of the volume of things produced, America has pulled away from Europe.
2. Is it all the tech industry?
Krugman concedes this tech divergence but says it is not welfare-relevant. The American growth lead is an accounting artefact of measuring more iPhones at base-year prices, not a sign that Americans are actually richer, because Europeans buy the same iPhones at the same world prices.
This is not the right way to think about the world today, as an earlier Paul Krugman would have argued.
His model assumes tradable goods, interchangeable workers, marginal-cost pricing, and no profits. Each assumption fails.
Most of what households buy is non-tradable: housing, healthcare, childcare, education. When American tech firms bid workers from haircutting to coding, American haircut wages rise. Germany has no growing tech sector to do the bidding, so German wages stay flat.
Technology is not priced at marginal cost. Apple's margins are around 40 percent. Anthropic's inference margins are at 70 percent. The major platforms enjoy network effects, switching costs, and lock-in that hold prices well above what a competitive market would deliver. A large share of the productivity gains in technology stays as profit.
A lot of the value of American technology dominance shows up in equity, not in wages. Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, Alphabet, Meta, and Amazon together are worth $21 trillion, more than the entire combined stock market value of all European stock markets. Around 60 percent of US equity is held by American households. The median French or Spanish household holds almost no equity.
The median employee at Meta, a company with almost 80,000 employees, earned $388,000 in 2025.
This advantage is not going to go away. Krugman's own 1991 paper, cited in his Nobel prize, showed that comparative advantage in modern industries is produced by increasing returns to scale, specialized labor markets, supplier networks and the agglomeration of suppliers, workers, and ideas in particular places. Once an industry concentrates somewhere, the concentration is self-reinforcing. Europe is being pushed away from the next round of technology industries (AI!).
3. What about inequality?
Another retort is that GDP per capita hides substantial inequality, and so even if America is rich on average, this is mostly due to the super wealthy.
But despite the US's high pre-tax income inequality, it also achieves higher median incomes than Europe, in part because of such a high base, and in part because it actually redistributes more than many European countries.
The cleanest comparison is median equivalised disposable household income: income after cash taxes and transfers, adjusted for household size and purchasing power. According to the OECD's 2021 numbers, the median American earns 30 percent more than the median Dutchman, about 31 percent more than the median German, and about 52 percent more than the median Frenchman.
4. What about hours worked?
Krugman points out that while American GDP per person is higher, most of this is because Americans work more. For this divergence to be an hours worked story, Americans must work more relative to Europeans now than they did in 2000.
The opposite has happened. Birinci, Karabarbounis, and See in a 2026 NBER paper show that about half of the American-European hours gap that existed in the 1990s has reversed by the end of the 2010s. Americans work fewer hours per person than they did in 2000, while most Europeans work more.
5. Is America not a bad place to live?
Walk around Alabama and France: surely the former cannot be substantially richer than the latter?
American cities often have poorer centres and richer suburbs or exurbs. European cities preserve richer and more attractive historic cores. A visit to a city as a tourist in America compared with a city in France will leave one having seen different spots on the income distribution. Americans in Europe go to the nicest and richest European cities.
Rather than a walking around test, do a driving around test. Go to the periphery of any modern American city and see a level of new-built material wealth that is extremely uncommon in Europe, with thousands of enormous four- or five-bedroom homes. In the South, in places like Nashville and Austin, drive around the downtowns to see hundreds of luxury apartment buildings springing from the ground. This construction boom is replicated virtually nowhere in Europe today.
The other question is generational. Housing often costs more in Europe than in the United States, despite the quality of the housing stock generally being much better. Europe has nice city cores but these are inaccessible to young Europeans.
Consider the salaries available to entry-level workers. The starting pay for a London police officer is $57,000. In Washington, DC, $75,000. The entry-level Deloitte consultant job in Madrid pays around €28,000, roughly $33,000 per year. In Charlotte, the entry-level Deloitte job pays $63,000.
There are many things to dislike about life in America. But relative to 25 years ago, the gap in material wealth has shifted dramatically in America's favor.
www.siliconcontinent.com/p/european-stagnation-is-real -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Imagine being called Yogan Yoganathan... Always elected with fewer votes than the other LibDems here in Kingston.
Tom Whipple
@whippletom
People ask me why I'm not in politics, this is why*
*this isn't why. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is Monday, so I have written a substack. Today's piece (£/free trial) is about tumble dryers, energy efficiency and how to measure inflation - timleunig.substack.com/p/why-ed-miliband-is-right 1/2
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It also has advice for @SuellaBraverman that could literally save her £100s every year! Never let it be said that I don't try to help people, even when their politics differ from mine.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Ultimately while we can all have an opinion on that, the only way to find out is to issue some euro denominated debt and get the market to tell us. The downside from issuing a small tranche seems very low.
Raoul Ruparel
@RaoulRuparel
How much of the differential between UK and Italy (some extent France as well) do you put down to ECB interventions & broad commitment to keep yields in check (via TPI)? Without this, my sense is Italian yields especially wouldn't be too dissimilar to UK? I just wonder how much we'd benefit from Euro issuance given we'd be outside purview of ECB interventions...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My thinking was thinner foreign exchange markets with GBP
William Cooper🇬🇧🇮🇪🇺🇦
@WilliamXnote
Either its kept small so little risk but little benefit
Else we go large, get some benefit - until we don’t - see those “cheap” index linked gilts
And why not JPY or CHF if we are going to take FX risk -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't think we would ever do that - there are some buyers who want sterling assets, so sterling gilt prices would fall if we issued less, making further moved to Eur debt pointless.
John Myers
@johnrmyers
I enjoyed this as ever @timleunig but I would worry about whether we will realistically hold the line at 10% and whether this could risk a slide into ‘original sin’ of issuing entirely in EUR because it looks cheaper in the short run? www.ft.com/content/e709d898-5d0c-4b3c-b0c7-81631c81be0d
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written a piece for the FT about why the UK-EU interest rate differential means the UK government should consider issuing gilts in Euros, simply to save money. 1/2 www.ft.com/content/e709d898-5d0c-4b3c-b0c7-81631c81be0d
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Of course there is a currency risk, but my judgement is that the current interest rate differential makes that worthwhile.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
timleunig.substack.com/p/what-to-do-about-scottish-indepe…
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I seem to have an unusual stubbornness with regards to referendums. I really do think,
• We should keep FPTP at Westminster.
• Scotland should stay in the UK.
• We should remain outside of the EU.
Because that's what was voted for. For at least 20 years. Probably 30. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
In the last 50 years the Tories are the only party to have had a majority in office in Suffolk. Today was their last day holding that record.
Their main campaign in West Suffolk was protesting against Forest City. It was led by @NJ_Timothy. Dozens of Facebook posts, hostile quotes in the local press, maybe ten thousand anti-Forest City leaflets through doors. It was their main campaign issue and they went hard. They basically turned it into a referendum.
It failed. Badly.
Next time, perhaps try hope. You might not want a city, but to say no to train stations, woodland, affordable housing and huge amounts of growth without even sitting down to talk. Well I guess that’s how you lose. -
Tim Leunig reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
> Be the leader of a historic Left-wing government party
>Utterly trounce the incumbent party who have mismanaged the country for over a decade.
>Have near complete national and local political command of your country
>Inherit a broken economy with impossibly hard tradeoffs
>Have no idea how to fix things
>Timid attempts at reforming the welfare state backfire
>In a few months end up becoming the most unpopular leader in your country's history
>Lose local election after local election
>Under your watch the nationalist Right surges to historic heights
>Left-wing Firebrand eats your lunch on the left
>Lose the confidence of your MPs
> Be President François Hollande of France between 2012 and 2017
>Pic Unrelated
.........
> Face near total collapse at the next General Election?
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: Politics UK has predicted the local election result for all council wards
➡️ RFM: 1,580 (+1,580)
🟠 LDM: 950 (+286)
🔴 LAB: 941 (-1,597)
🔵 CON: 572 (-631)
🟢 GRN: 503 (+344)
⚪️ INDP: 213 (-102)
⚪️ MUSLIM INDP: 208 (+177)
Our interactive map 👇 politicsuk.com/news/2026-local-elections-prediction -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
9/10 Put it together. The countries mobilising are Poland, the Baltics, the Nordics: closer to the frontier/fast-converging.
The countries where Draghi reforms are most needed (Italy, Spain, France) feel the weakest shock and carry the heaviest pension claim. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
1/10 The post-Draghi hope was that Putin would supply the urgency to make the reforms to push innovation, single market and competitiveness that Europe lacks. The data does not support that.
A thread.
www.siliconcontinent.com/p/the-two-europes -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Interesting that the @LibDems holding up.
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
Newcastle is arguably more dramatic Labour reduced to just two seats, both Reform and the Greens making major gains at Labour’s expense.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
(To be fair, they didn't teach this sort of stuff when I was at school in the 1980s either...)
Andrew Neil
@afneil
One of the many great days in our wonderful history. Which today’s young folk know nothing about. Watch and be proud. We liberated a great ally (still is) from the greatest evil.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What does it look like if you rebase in 2009?
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
This is a decent sized part of why the SNP have done well in Scotland and both the Tories and Labour have been booted out in the urban West Midlands.
.
I also think that anyone interested in returning Britain to growth and prosperity needs to understand the scale and feel of it. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
To be fair, it is hard to look at things like "housing prices" and "rent" and the trends for and each and conclude that, as young people, they're wholly wrong.
Grant Bailey
@grantjbailey
This one surprised me. Teen girls now say "having lots of money" is important in life at the same rate as boys. There used to be a huge gap.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Dnes
@MichaelDnes1
Do you know that infamous roads project where they’ve spent more than a quarter of a billion pounds on planning, and written nearly 400,000 pages of documents?
Well, it turns out that they didn’t need to.
Government has just played its ace card; and if we’d known they were going to do that, we could have used it to skip almost the whole planning process as we know it. The road would probably be open by now.
How we didn't get there involves a dance around the magic money tree, accountants that are definitely following all the rules, bridges that appear for free, and just who you leave Kent and Essex at the mercy of...
limbostructure.substack.com/p/a-twist-on-the-thames -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
Wind and solar have now beaten fossil fuels in Great Britain for a record 15 months in a row
Just a decade ago, fossil fuels were generating four times more than wind + solar
Now that's flipped: Since the Iran war, wind and solar generated twice as much as fossil fuels -
Tim Leunig reposted
Looking for Growth
@lfg_uk
A resident in Cardiff spoke out against something which really bothers us all.
Noise from a children's park, which he lives next to.
The council was ordered to pay £75 to the homeowner, every week.
By June, he'd received £1,200.
And the park's set to be removed
Is this okay? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
Failed legal challenges have delayed major infrastructure projects like new roads and power stations by a collective 32 years.
Labour recently changed the law to cut the time it takes to throw out anti-infrastructure lawsuits.
And it's working. One parish council sued to try to stop a solar farm.
In the past, the case would likely have dragged on for over a year. But last month, a Judge threw out the case in just two months.
That's just one project, but that's a year saved already. It means new infrastructure will get built quicker and we can reap the benefits sooner.
www.samdumitriu.com/p/the-planning-and-infrastructure-act -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
No-one should project beyond 25 years
Darth Hassett
@darth_hassett
Giles’ point, while very interesting in that it highlights the situation is not hopeless, what it really means is quite striking. For his point to be true, it would require that the 40% tax bracket kick in at minimum wage by the end of this chart. Is that politically feasible?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Utter rubbish. The yellow line assumes tax allowances and benefits rise with earnings. If they rise with prices the debt goes down over time. Subscribe to the @FT and read @ChrisGiles_ . Then you might talk sense.
Tony Ward
@TonyWard867811
The OBR drew this chart.
Yellow line is what the state takes.
Green line is what the state spends.
The gap will be filled by stealing from you, your children and their children.
By 2074, UK debt hits 270% of GDP. The state's own watchdog admits it in writing.
Yesterday the bond market read the chart.
UK 30 year gilt: 5.76%. Highest since 1998. UK 10 year: 5.08%.
The market knows what comes next. When yields rise too far, the Bank of England will step in.
They will print. They will buy. They will debase. They will steal from your children's future and their children.
Just like 2022. Just like covid. Just like 2008.
Savers smoked. Pensioners smoked. Gilt holders smoked.
The pound will lose another generation of purchasing power in months, not years.
You have been betrayed.
And this is only the beginning. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Boyan Slat
@BoyanSlat
A typical week across the various deployment projects @TheOceanCleanup:
- a land owner showing up to land rental negotiations with machine guns
- components stuck in customs
- a contractor accidentally driving their excavator into the river
- plastic survey cameras stolen
- geotechnical survey showing soil is more tricky than thought for the anchor piles
- being notified there a gas pipeline running under a proposed deployment site but no one knows exactly where
This work is never boring. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Philipp Heimberger
@heimbergecon
New QJE paper on France’s mandated profit-sharing: distributing excess profits to workers raises the labor share and reduces the profit share, with little effect on investment or productivity. Gains mainly go to lower-skilled workers; high-skilled pay unaffected.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
Many of you would understand the world much better if you took 4-5 economics classes, or purchased a textbook and made an honest and rigorous effort to understand it.
Many of you appear to think ~0 about incentives, trade-offs, constraints, or second-order effects. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
A pleasing juxtaposition on my timeline of people dumping on this Labour MP for using the phrase "taxing for growth" while people in high-growth Ireland complain about how high their taxes are.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my free to read substack returns to housing, and argues that small additional homes in back gardens could make an important contribution to solving our housing problem. timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-get-more-houses-built Inspiration from @WeCanMakeHomes
-
Tim Leunig reposted
New Scientist
@newscientist
The idea that EV batteries age poorly is a misconception – and a new report has found they often outlive the cars themselves www.newscientist.com/article/mg27035922-600-why-your-opin…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In which @Paul_Swinney shows yet again that he is a good economist!
Paul Swinney
@Paul_Swinney
Would you mind engaging with the argument Charlie rather than throwing insults round like you’re Donald Trump please?
If supply is fixed and you funnel £ into the system then yes prices go up. But if supply was responsive then more £ wouldn’t have the same impact. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Cook
@JoeCookJ
We visited a battery site that could power the whole of Loughborough at peak times. They first applied to connect to the grid in 2020 - 6 years later and it's still an empty field.
All the while expensive gas is adding to bills - watch our film to find out what's gone wrong.
Sam Coates Sky
@SamCoatesSky
EXC: Ministers have unpicked our electricity system … but can they now sort it fast enough?
We hear a lot from this government about the race for renewables because of Russia and the Middle East. But it’s hit a pretty big snag
Important film by @JoeCookJ - part of our series on why Britain needs a functioning political system if it's to fix its problemsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Jon Burke 🌍
@jonburkeUK
Solar panels occupy ~0.1% of U.K land while currently generating 16% of U.K electricity.
Solar panels are also helping family farms to stay in business after the Brexit Kate Hoey helped deliver sold them down the river.
Kate Hoey
@CatharineHoey
Terrible. So many other places they could be put without destroying perfectly good food growing farmlands
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Is Sorcha Eastwood real or a spoof?
PoliticsJOE
@PoliticsJOE_UK
“A lot of this sort of highfalutin economic stuff. It's basically all made up nonsense.
“Labour imposed fiscal rules on themselves."
MP Sorcha Eastwood says Labour’s budgets are nonsense.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Best estimate is that a 1% rise in supply cuts prices by 2% relative to what they otherwise would be
Adrian Schmidt
@adrianmschmidt
Maybe. If you build in the right places at the right cost. But the impact of supply doesn't seem to be large
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Google "affordability still matters nhpau" for the best answer
Henry Pryor
@HenryPryor
A rare moment when I find myself at odds with @timleunig. For some reason I believed that housing COST was down to the cost & availability of credit. I thought the post-Crash era of cheap credit proved that.
Still, every day's a school day. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Also interesting that he managed to last six and a half years as an embattled PM. Remarkable idea today.
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
John Major speaks so much sense in this Newsnight interview. He had huge difficulties in his six and a half years as PM, but almost thirty years on from leaving office he's become the wisest of our nine living prime ministers.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
InvestorFromEurope
@TheDealMakerGuy
Everyone's been waiting for "the European Amazon" for 20 years.
Turns out it might be a discount grocery chain.
Dutch Central Bank just picked Lidl as its cloud provider. Not AWS. Not Google. Not Microsoft. Lidl.
The reason: trust in US tech is eroding across European institutions. Data sovereignty rulings, the political climate, tariff drama. Every quarter the case for sitting on top of US infrastructure gets harder to defend.
So Europe is decoupling. Quietly. Contract by contract. While everyone watches the political theatre.
Lidl pulled in nearly €2B from cloud last year. All infrastructure built inside the EU.
The "European alternative" people have been waiting for?
Turns out it's a grocery chain that's been quietly investing for years.
If a discount supermarket can win central bank cloud contracts, is US big tech's moat in Europe thinner than anyone admits?
Last place anyone was looking. First to deliver. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In the long run what matters is supply. Best to look through the short term froth of temporary low interest rates when they happen. Best of all is to use opportunities like that to increase supply, as absorption is easier.
Ryan Shorthouse
@RyanShorthouse
Tim, do you really believe that low interest rates, the financialisation of housing and stricter mortgage rules post-GFG have had no effect ALONGSIDE low supply in pushing up prices?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Correct. But if we had built more they would have become more affordable, relative to earnings, which worlds have been a better outcome!
Adrian Schmidt
@adrianmschmidt
House prices are little changed in real terms (proportional to earnings) in the last 20 years. Affordability fluctuations over that period mainly reflect fluctuations in mortgage rates.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with Michael O'Leary, @Ryanair.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Jon Burke 🌍
@jonburkeUK
🚨 In 2024, drivers in the U.K killed ~400 pedestrians & cyclists.
🚨 Less than half of killer drivers are charged.
🚨 Around half of convicted killer drivers aren’t sent to prison & just 1% receive life bans.
When will drivers start facing “the full force of the law”, Iain?
Iain Duncan Smith MP Chingford & Woodford Green
@MPIainDS
At long last we have a law for dangerous cyclists and e-bikes. Those who cycle or ride e-bikes recklessly causing fatal accidents to pedestrians or road users can now feel the full force of the law. Matt Briggs and others who have campaigned for justice should be congratulated for their perseverance.
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/04/29/cyclists-kill-pedestr… -
Tim Leunig reposted
John Rentoul
@JohnRentoul
Steve Webb, pensions guru, not impressed with @InstituteGC plan to junk triple lock for state pension www.telegraph.co.uk/money/pensions/state-pensions/tony-bl…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Surprised and saddened to be thought silly by @RyanShorthouse, but thems the breaks, I guess. Supply and demand determine housing costs, so unless you have a plan to reduce demand, it really is all about supply.
Ryan Shorthouse
@RyanShorthouse
The people who believe that the unaffordability of housing is solely caused by - and can only be fixed by - supply-side policies are perhaps as silly as the people who believe that the housing market only has a distributional problem rather than a supply problem.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
The deleveraging of the UK household sector to become net cash is one of the more striking economic transformations of the last 20 years
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
The UK household love of the cash ISA shows no sign of abating. Another £4.4bn added in March. Honing in on half a trillion pounds of deposits.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have had a great pump tumble dryer since 2001. It works perfectly well. Looks like it has saved me some money as well.
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
THREAD: A heat-pump tumble dryer could save households more than £700
Lots of overblown reaction to govt phasing out standard dryers – reminds me of when 2009 Mail frontpage wailed about "beloved" incandescent bulbs
But heat pump dryers are just a much better technology
1/5 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It gets lent out as mortgages etc
Tom Whipple
@whippletom
Stupid question: what happens to the money that goes into the cash isa? I always assumed the bank then reinvested it in stocks and shares - and the cash isa rate was set below the exepcted returns as a reflection of their margin for the volatility risk. Obvs I'm wrong though.
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
The UK household love of the cash ISA shows no sign of abating. Another £4.4bn added in March. Honing in on half a trillion pounds of deposits.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
Many people do not seem to want data centres built near them, despite the fact that they don't cause that much traffic and often generate a lot of local tax revenue. I suspect it's partly because they're ugly! My proposal:
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Heat pump tumble dryers are fine. I have had one for twenty five years. Your argument is as silly as saying there is no need to legislate for seatbelts.
David Turver
@7Kiwi
If heat pump tumble dryers are so good, consumers will buy them without government coercion. The coercion tells us they're not as good.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It is the best we are likely to get!
Nils Braakmann
@NBraakmann
Not the best diff-in-diff though…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Today, we're releasing our first Free Systems product: Bellwether, an API, MCP server, and dashboard to help the media report prediction-market prices more reliably.
Prediction markets can give us access to real-time, continuous, objective probabilities of important world events---but only if we build them to be well-structured, liquid enough, and resistant to manipulation.
Bellwether helps by:
--Reporting prices that are less manipulable because they're based on a volume-weighted average, not the last traded price
--Flagging whether the price comes from a sufficiently liquid market or not, so that the media can avoid reporting on prices that are unreliable or super easy to manipulate
--Standardizing across platforms, to help resolve when contracts for the same event across Kalshi and Polymarket are actually the same, or not
We hope that you'll check it out, let us know what you think, and suggest improvements!
bellwethermetrics.com
This is joint work with @elliotjpaschal and @vania_chowThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am very pleased that England and Wales have made different decisions on no-fault evictions. It will make it easier to work out the effect of the changes in England on rents, if any.
Joe Allen
@Joe___Allen
Genuinely remarkable that England (like Scotland) has now banned no-fault evictions but Wales has kept them.
Gives a sense of how ideas about Welsh Labour vs UK Labour resist a simple Left vs Right explanation. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We 100% need more interconnectors to the continent, where power is typically very cheap in summer.
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
The AQUIND interconnector would tap Britain into some of this cheaper-than-free solar power from France. Of course NIMBYs are opposing it.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
When it is sunny electricity is now free in many parts of the world. This is going to be a huge change in how we think about things.
Julien Jomaux
@JomauxJulien
Left Germany and Right France.
In green, it is the difference between hourly prices in 2023 compared to 2026, for April.
Quite a dramatic change in only 3 years. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Of course. And had we had more elastic supply 1997-2010 and since, then - just as when % fell in the interwar period - we would have got a big boost to supply, rather than a big boost in house prices.
Alex Groundwater
@alexgroundwater
Not when it comes to UK housing. Supply is the very poor relation of wage growth and credit availability. People are not logical about a house’s value… they’ll pay as much as they can afford, aided by debt. ‘00-‘07 is a classic case: substantial building = x2.5 prices 🤔🤷🏼♂️
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, this is correct. Local authorities are too small for this analysis. Christine Whitehead showed that some time ago, I think.
Simon Inman
@SimonInmania
This data is good but I'm not sure that you can conclude much from it. If one LPA in London builds lots of homes, we wouldn't expect the price to crater there Vs the LPA next door. Instead, more people move there and the downward price pressure is spread out across LPAs.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Centre for Cities
@CentreforCities
NEW BLOG | British cities are not dense by international standards, and recent development is not raising average densities in most places.
The question is how planning should respond 👇
www.centreforcities.org/blog/densification-requires-stron… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
When it is sunny electricity is now free in many parts of the world. This is going to be a huge change in how we think about things.
Julien Jomaux
@JomauxJulien
Left Germany and Right France.
In green, it is the difference between hourly prices in 2023 compared to 2026, for April.
Quite a dramatic change in only 3 years. -
Tim Leunig reposted
𒊓𒅂𒁓𒐗𒐕𒐗 Steve the skeptic
@sib313
Popular opinion: "the NHS is a mess because there are more managers than nurses or doctors"
reality: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
When we stopped building
MaxC | Flight Risk Capital
@ColeFusionHQ
A 21 yr old on £28k looking at £1.7k rent isn't doing anything wrong. The numbers just don't work anymore.
Most people in this situation I know either house-share, live at home longer, get help from family or end up with some level of support.
When did income stop covering it. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
There is an affordability problem because there is a shortage. That is literally what happens when there is a shortage. Doesn't matter if it is oil or houses, stuff is expensive when there isn't much of it (relative to demand)
Moving Home with Charlie
@moving_charlie
So the Slow kids turn out to be right @rcolvile
There isn’t a shortage. There’s an affordability problem.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cz676vexyxvo -
Tim Leunig reposted
JN
@JonNeale
“Liverpool was the most densely populated town in the kingdom. For the parish as a whole Duncan calculated 138,224 persons per square mile compared with approximately 100,000 for Manchester, 87,000 for Leeds and 50,000 for London.” - mid 19th C
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Centre for Cities
@CentreforCities
🆕Our new research will explore how thinking spatially about the minimum wage can help labour market policy to function in the UK’s diverse economic geography.
Book your place at our launch event with @annastansbury and Nye Cominetti👇
www.centreforcities.org/event/report-launch-pay-check-min… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Another person completely wrong and the link between housing supply and prices. (Of course if we banned mortgages altogether, prices would fall. Would help people with rich parents a lot.)
Moving Home with Charlie
@moving_charlie
Slowly but surely people are beginning to connect the dots between the housing affordability crisis and excessive lending, leading to a generation being priced out of homes, even when over a million homes stand empty.
We have all, including politicians and ministers, been collectively gaslit into believing that building more houses helps affordability.
It’s now clear that that’s not true.
Only the gradual unwinding of mortgage multiples will allow house prices to return to reasonable multiples of salaries.
The government must do 3 things:
1. Scrap stamp duty for UK citizens buying their only home.
2. Gradually reduce mortgage lending multiple limits
3. End their reliance on the private rented sector for meeting public housing obligations.
All of these measures would result in a boost to the economy and social mobility as well as lower house prices relative to wages. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Always good to have a substantial public policy challenge!!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (£/free trial) discusses hobs and dementia, explains why I bought an induction hob, and sets out what the government should do in this area. timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-reduce-dementia You even get to see inside my kitchen...
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
Sarah Breeden, deputy governor of the Bank, gave a speech last week about risks to financial stability. Her suggestion that stock prices might fall back from all-time highs garnered the most attention. But she also highlighted leverage in the UK government bond (‘gilt’) market.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Mason
@paulmasonnews
Something big happened this week: a judge for the first time used Labour's reforms to Judicial Review to halt time-wasting NIMBY objections to a big solar farm. Process slashed from 24 months to 4. First of many. #buildbabybuild
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Leo Gibbons
@Layo_FH
The urban Left is overwhelmingly dominated by socially conservative preservation campaigns. Nearly all the campaigns I see from the Left in London is them trying to prevent social housing estate regeneration projects, or town centre redevelopments, or even simple things like high street pedestrianisation (like in Deptford).
I find it really interesting.
Novara Media
@novaramedia
“Most of the people I know are quite disappointed with the direction of the Labour party.”
@rivkahbrown visits the Ridley Road market in Dalston, where traders are resisting a landlord’s plans to redevelop the site of a 100-year-old street market and evict stallholders.
One trader says it feels like the landlord and the Labour council are “more working to get us out than working with us".
Another says that the Ridley Road campaign has seen more support from the Greens than any other party.
This is an excerpt from our full report on Hackney and Lewisham. Watch "Will The Green Party Destroy London's Labour Mafia?" on our YouTube channel now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
This little practice produces a stream of good buildings like these, working in the rugged urban vernacular of England's historic industrial cities. Their buildings are completely of their place, like natural emanations of the cities to which they belong.
Ollier Smurthwaite
@OS_Architects
We have some new visuals to share for our Charter House scheme on Churchgate in Stockport for 27 dual aspect homes. Work will start on site later this year. @archi_tradition @Aesthetic_City @stopinstockport
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
“Riddled with wrong assumptions”? Then name one.
Mr Tice has identified zero errors in our reporting. Hasn’t even tried. Just vague whinging about how unfair it all is.
LBC
@LBC
‘How much did you fail to pay?’
Reform’s Richard Tice tells @TomSwarbrick1 that the story claiming he avoided paying £100,000 in tax is ‘riddled’ with ‘wrong assumptions’. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
The Campaign to Protect Rural England contends that the housing crisis is driven by high rents, not building too few houses.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
We reported in January that an unanticipated effect of the Renters' Rights Act was to create a stamp duty liability for about 150,000 tenants.
The good news is that the Government just announced it will legislate retrospectively to fix this: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Iain Mansfield
@IGMansfield
With the history curriculum in the news again today, a reminder about what young people today are actually studying in history - as a reality check to some of the 'why don't they study XYZ?' brigade (on both sides).
% of English secondary schools teaching subjects in Y 7 - 9: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Assaad Razzouk
@AssaadRazzouk
Solar isn't just growing. The scale of its 2025 surge is completely bonkers
>We added enough new solar last year to displace every single unit of gas power generated by 100% of LNG exports through the Strait of Hormuz
>So just 1 year of solar growth wiped out the energy equivalent of the world's most critical fossil fuel chokepoint
>Solar growth was 18x gas growth
>China alone added more solar in 1 year than the entire world in 2023
This isn't a transition. It's a hostile takeover by superior economics. Betting on fossil fuels today is exactly like betting on whale oil while Edison was turning on the lightbulb -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Thoughtful and well informed, as I would expect from @JomauxJulien
Julien Jomaux
@JomauxJulien
New free post : does it make sense to add solar in Europe ?
Link in my profile -
Tim Leunig reposted
Stian Westlake
@stianwestlake
There's an interesting tension between:
(1) the idea that the rise in business degrees with poor graduate outcomes is a bad thing (as argued in this FT piece) and
(2) the very popular belief that Britain's economic problem is poor management skills in average-to-low-end firms and that this can be fixed through government intervention.
www.ft.com/content/e199ae71-f4a2-4abd-9444-de47c456b7ae -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
From the fantastic @London_Centric piece on this. Want to build a cell phone tower in Leeds? The Council will say yes 90% of the time. In London? Councils say yes 40% of the time. That's about hunger for growth and fear of abandonment. We can fix it. www.londoncentric.media/p/why-exactly-is-londons-phone-si…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
How to improve lives for elderly people - and reduce the cost of social care - timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-reduce-social-care-bills-and. If any London based reader wants to try one, www.japanhouselondon.uk has them
Fat Jacques 🏴☠️
@Fat_Jacques
I bought one for my then 82 year old Father in law when we moved him to a bungalow. It makes his life much easier. Very worthwhile. It’s a Grohe Sensia. German, but an excellent price, just under £2,000.
The seller, bidet-shower, and the manufacturer have been excellent at customer service. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
And similarly electricians who fit induction hobs should have a mini gas certificate to remove gas hobs.
L🇬🇧as Ohl
@lukas_ohl
One obstacle is the requirement for an electrician (in addition to the plumber already hired for the job). Maybe there could be a special certificate or training course for plumbers who want to do limited electrical work like this?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They are not VAT exempt if you fit one in your home in advance of having medical need. So if I fit one now, I can't get one without paying VAT. Similarly if I fit one in my house to help an elderly relative I would have to pay VAT.
Arthur Baker
@AW_Baker
I'm confused about the VAT point here. He says they're already VAT exempt for private personal use, and wants VAT exemptions for businesses like cafes. But can't businesses already claim back VAT on stuff like bathroom fixtures?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
Because @HEPI_news is non-partisan, specialist & a home for debate, we take pleasure in publishing pieces that critique our own output. Here is an excellent example from Paul Woodgates, who is picking up the baton that @Tom_Richmond recently laid down:
www.hepi.ac.uk/2026/04/21/a-risky-business/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Andrés Rodríguez-Pose
@rodriguez_pose
Subsidiarity can become an elegant alibi for abandonment. In Geoforum, Grillitsch, Stihl & Hermelin show that powers handed down without resources or infrastructure do not empower places or promote #development; they merely decentralise disappointment. doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2026.104660
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
On land, perhaps... ;-)
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
9 of the 10 biggest battles in Europe in the 19th century involved France. France was the military power by excellence for centuries.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my (free to read) substack looks at the benefits of high tech Japanese toilets. I explain why installing them will help older people maintain their independence and their dignity, and save the country money. timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-reduce-social-care-bills-and
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
True, although on those grounds we should be aware that Renault might decline to sell us spare parts for their cars...
Mark Kingsley-Williams
@Mark_A_K_W
Well obviously power generation on UK land and under UK law does not have the physical, political and legal risks of buying in from France. As seen with covid vaccine blocking by the EU, reliance on a third party always adds risk,
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with you!
Chris Smith
@renewablesmiffy
Interconnectors should be a huge part of our future.
I’d like to know what power system Andrew thinks doesn’t carry a security risk. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I found XLinks impressive when I worked in government. Thanks @rosmiguel
Miquel Ros
@rosmiquel
There is a British company planning an electric subsea link to bring renewable energy from Morocco to the UK, as explained here by @MLiebreich mliebreich.substack.com/p/xlinks
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If cables are a security risk, would you get rid of the current electricity interconnectors to France etc? If Spanish solar anti correlated, would you also not install solar in UK?
Andrew Montford
@aDissentient
1. £5bn to build, plus the cost of the electricity.
2. Supply anticorrelated with UK demand.
3. Impossible to protect, so a huge national security risk. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
This is astonishing nonsense. Nobody has identified any errors in our report. Tice’s lawyer didn’t even comment.
And Tice’s statement translates into English as “you’re right, but I want to talk about something else”.
Gabriel Pogrund
@Gabriel_Pogrund
Whoever said this to @CamillaTominey is either mistaken or deliberately misleading a respected journalist to deter further scrutiny — we have see no legal complaint from Tice and stand by our reporting.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Yann LeCun
@ylecun
Dario is wrong.
He knows absolutely nothing about the effects of technological revolutions on the labor market.
Don't listen to him, Sam, Yoshua, Geoff, or me on this topic.
Listen to economists who have spent their career studying this, like @Ph_Aghion , @erikbryn , @DAcemogluMIT , @amcafee , @davidautor -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
It's become common lately to hear people say that rising attainment in English schools has been bought at a terrible cost - that of rising mental health problems.
How true is this? Is it fair to blame Gove-era curriculum & exam reforms for increased anxiety & unhappiness?
I dig into the international data to see what it can tell us...
substack.nomoremarking.com/p/do-knowledge-rich-curriculum… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A cable to Spain seems very attractive, since the sun in Spain falls mainly on the plain...
Christopher Meder
@EVCurveFuturist
Spain is crushing it ⚡🇪🇸
Solar is delivering the equivalent of 27 nuclear plants during the day. Pumped hydro stores ~3 nuclear plants worth. Batteries already stepping in.
This isn’t a generation problem anymore. It’s storage scale.
Energy scarcity → energy timing. #bess -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is correct, as anyone who has studied auction knows
Jack Pardoe
@pardoejw
Here's a good picture showing why we do things the way we do them (pay-as-clear) - it forces costs down. Pay-as-bid isn't done anywhere really because it's obviously very gameable and would therefore send bills up. If you were an honest player, you'd quickly go out of business.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have never earned £300k, but I imagine a national £300k annual wage cap would lead a lot of well paid city folk to leave for Frankfurt or NY, massively reducing UK tax revenues and requiring austerity. Bad idea @meadwaj !
James Meadway
@meadwaj
Of course they do. It's a good idea.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Harwood
@tomhfh
It's whats so frustrating about living in Britain.
This country could be far, far richer by just applying the sort of econ 101 you would expect an international delegation to offer to a sub saharan African country: energy, housing, infrastructure.
We've already got the difficult stuff that is desperately hard to create from scratch: elite human capital, excellent universities, social trust, weirdly good global biotech/finance/insurance etc.
It's the trivially easy stuff that we continually studiously avoid. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have long held two contrary views. I never thought CarGiant would close. I never understood why the site had not already been sold for housing. Hopefully the latter will now happen...
ianVisits
@ianvisits
The huge used car supermarket Cargiant is closing.
I look forward to plans being put forward for 4,000 homes next to the future HS2 station at Old Oak Common - and NIMBY protests to protect the natural environment of a used car sales warehouse. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
A HUGE, narrative-breaking moment for the UK car market
New EVs are now cheaper than petrol cars on average, says Autotrader
Last yr CCC said price parity was due by 2028 – and it's already here
And EVs are already MUCH cheaper to run than petrol -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am excited about both self-driving cars and self-driving buses!
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
The biggest operating cost of a bus network is its drivers' wages. Self-driving buses would be transformative to the economics of expanding bus service reach and frequency. I'm far more excited about this than self-driving cars.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Plausible. Rail expensive because hard to do (more tunnelling than roads), because unlike roads or ports or planes it will include the vehicles so it is not a fair comparison, and because it was first and we are better at lots of things now
Paul Graham
@paulg
There's never been an investment like the investment in railroads. (This graph has a log scale!)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is good news. It was a sensible policy once, but it is not needed anymore.
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
NEW: The UK govt is scrapping its top-up carbon tax, the "carbon price support" from 2028
Brought in by Osborne to help get rid of coal
Now it brings in Treasury revenue (£400m in 2024/25) + raises elec bills, but doesn't help cut CO2
Will cut power prices by ~0.7p/kWh
1/2 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't think that is right - it is allowing a local authority to use capital money to employ a GP if that is what is best for the community.
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
a) It’s a basic principle that infra levies are used for capital not spending, for obvious reasons
b) This asserts yet more central control over what councils can spend on
c) CIL money is wildly variable across the country (and in many cases is zero)
d) It’s silly, shoddy policy -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
We've just launched it! Our 295 page report detailing how it is possible to build Britain's first city in over 50 years. People doubt Britain can do anything big. But this work shows the UK can be incredibly ambitious and solve real, and urgent problems. We just need to think a little more creatively.
Here's what it finds:
1. Forest City would generate £53bn in output each year. That's a huge value add to the bottom line of the economy and more than the combined output of Oxford, Cambridge and Leeds.
2. It would create the largest single nature reserve on English soil. An amazing legacy for future generations and the environment.
3. 400,000 fully affordable homes to buy and rent that people under 40 who are desperately struggling to afford any sort of life, can ACTUALLY afford.
4. Major solutions to the East of England's road, rail and water infrastructure issues, paid for by the building of the City itself.
Right now, @mhclg is studying the findings.
We want to thank the 40 experts who helped put this together over the last five months. They are true radicals and pioneers all. Below is my reading of the introductory chapter so do have a listen.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
From 1960 to 2024, Sub-Saharan Africa’s population rose from roughly 230 million to 1.3 billion.
Technology & health aid saved millions of lives.
But this may have created “demographic overstretch” - amid adverse climates, low incomes & weak states. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You need to read the proposal. Of course it does not say that, that would indeed be mad!
Simon Clarke
@SirSimonClarke
This sounds totally mad. *Every* single new development, regardless of size? Needing a dedicated new surgery of its own? With no discretion as to other local infrastructure that might be needed more?
What modelling have they done, if any, about the impact on housebuilding, already at a record, devastating low? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Which, in a small way, is what @EdwardJDavey is calling for! At the moment CIL can't be used to pay the wages for a GP, he wants to change that...
Ben Southwood
@bswud
One of the reasons that the UK has such a severe housing problem is that several goods – healthcare, major highways, railway stations and lines – are provided inelastically by central government, so new homes cause genuine competition over them.
The historic way to solve this in the UK and elsewhere has been to fund local public services with local revenues, such that development pays its own way. Places that expand rapidly in the modern world, like France before 2018, and Texas today, tend to have strong local tax bases and more services provided by local government (or, in some cases, privately).
Do this well enough, and local government can actually be an important part of the 'growth coalition' or 'growth machine' that keeps the economic flywheel going, as in the US before the 1970s, or the French nuclear buildout in the 1980s.
worksinprogress.co/issue/growing-the-growth-coalition/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Looking for Growth
@lfg_uk
A group of NIMBYs have courageously grouped together to try and block the development of...
...a cancer hospital.
The UK's cancer survival rates are up to 25 years behind other European countries.
Is this acceptable? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Stas Bichenko
@sbichenko
Here's a direct link to the RBKC website to add a comment supporting the development: www.rbkc.gov.uk/planningsearch/cases/PP/26/00240
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Fredrik Hjelm 🇸🇪
@FredrikHjelm4
The most underrated economy in the Western world right now is Sweden.
I’m not being patriotic, I’m looking at the numbers.
GDP growth forecast for 2026: 2.7%. That’s ahead of the US, the entire Euro area, UK, France, and Germany. Not by a little.
Government debt at 34.8% of GDP. The Euro area sits at 88.5%. The US is at 125%. We have fiscal room that most Western governments would kill for.
Budget deficit at -2.4%, the tightest in the peer group. France and the UK are running -5.5%. The US is at -7%. And Sweden’s deficit is partly Spring Budget expansion from a low-debt base, not structural weakness.
Inflation at 1.6%, below the Riksbank’s 2% target. Core ex-energy is around 1.1%. The Riksbank is paused at 1.75%, one of the lowest policy rates in the developed world.
I know the political conversation in Sweden often feels like everything is broken. Some things genuinely are.
And part of it is that media has a Sweden story it likes (crime gang rape!!!) and this doesn’t fit it.
But the macroeconomic position? It’s strong. Stronger than almost anyone in our peer group.
The uncomfortable question is what we actually do with that position. Because fiscal space only matters if someone uses it.
I would hit the gas, and let Sweden build and thrive. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Don't we have a surplus of GPs at the moment who can't get jobs?
Anna Clarke
@AnnaClarke_____
Ed Davey is right that there are big problems with access to GPs - and that this fuels opposition to new homes. But the way to solve that is to train and fund more GPs - otherwise developers end up funding empty buildings.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Kane 謝凱堯
@kane
Waymo is so good at saving lives that if it were a new drug in trial, it would hit the bar for being unblinded and made immediately available to the control group for ethical reasons.
@MorePerfectUS would prefer to keep killing pedestrians.
More Perfect Union
@MorePerfectUS
NEW: If Waymo gets its way, 2 million workers will be out of work.
When Waymo gets a firm hold on a city, wages go down. Some drivers now have to work 12 hours day, 7 days a week just to get by.
This isn't inevitable — but Big Tech is spending millions to make you think it is.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
On Wednesday the Forest City project releases our 295 pg report, ‘We Can Build a City’. It is the work of over 40 people. A labour of passion and dedication to solving the UK housing crisis, the lack of growth and infrastructure, and the impoverishment of nature. All these people put their skills to this task for free. They are true radicals in a time with such little hope for the future.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My recollection is that there are relatively few physics grads, and my assumption is that too high a proportion become academics, who if they stay in the UK are poorly paid.
max tempers
@maxtempers
Why does physics have such poor returns? It's not something I've observed anecdotally. Is there just a massive cohort of physics grads working minimum wage jobs I don't know about?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
I was interviewed by @ntvde on UK power prices. Article reportedly reached 200,000+ readers, clearly a topic of huge interest.
Gas still sets prices >90% of time today making electricity expensive.
But: @neso_energy expects this to fall to ~15% by 2030.
www.n-tv.de/wirtschaft/Darum-hat-Grossbritannien-die-zwei… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The data should be made public, and I hope the UK requires that. But I suspect it will prove that autonomous vehicles, which are always alert and literally have eyes in the back of their heads, are safer than human drivers.
Andy Boenau
@Boenau
According to Waymo's published data, their technology is preventing injuries & deaths.
My view is that if this is true, and I have yet to see a debunking of their data, then we safety advocates should be welcoming the technology.
If Waymo is lying or manipulating data, then write about how they're doing that! Instead the analysis in this recent Streetsblog article is limited to "the authors of the Waymo safety report work for Waymo!"
FFS, are we going to toss out all the NYCDOT reports about how their bike lanes improve safety? Are we going to toss out the decongestion pricing reports because they were written by the transit employees who want transit to succeed? I hope not!
Here's what we've been told by Waymo:
✅ 170.7 million rider-only miles driven without a human driver (equivalent to roughly 200 human lifetimes of driving).
✅ 92% fewer serious injury or worse crashes compared to human drivers in the same cities and conditions (0.02 incidents per million miles vs. 0.22 for humans; 35 fewer such crashes).
✅ 83% fewer airbag-deployment crashes in any vehicle (230 fewer crashes).
✅ 82% fewer injury-causing crashes overall (544 fewer crashes).
✅ 92% fewer pedestrian injury crashes compared to human benchmarks.
✅ 85% fewer cyclist injury crashes.
✅ 81% fewer motorcycle injury crashes.
✅ No fatalities caused by the Waymo Driver across these 170.7 million driverless miles.
✅ At current scale (over 4 million miles per week), Waymo prevents 1 serious injury crash every 8 days.
If data is manipulated or false, then report on that. Otherwise you come out looking like someone who only likes safety benefits that aren't shaped like a car. It's going to set back Vision Zero advocacy in states across the country that are on the fence about allowing autonomous vehicle operations.
Waymo does have a profit motive.
So do corporations who build homes, distribute food, host concerts, publish books, and make medicine. Not all of them are the same and some are downright awful.
Always challenge motives and incentives.
What's interesting about Waymo is that they have a financial incentive in being the absolute safest form of motorized vehicle on the street. They'll lose business if their software is just as dangerous as an average human driver. But that in no way means streets must be overtaken by motor vehicles (theirs or any other brand).
What do we want? 92% fewer pedestrian injury crashes compared to humans? 85% fewer cyclist injury crashes? Then come up with a way to let AVs into cities across the country. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Benedict
@carto_graph
It’s a great model:
- Take some neglected suburban railway lines
- Electrify and resignal them
- Join them together with a few km of tunnel under the city centre
Hey presto, you’ve got a 78km-long metro system.
worksinprogress.co/issue/the-magic-of-through-running/
Jon Stone
@joncstone
the Tyne and Wear Metro is so good and it's completely ridiculous that every big city in the UK doesn't have its own version
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The failure of the Islamabad peace talks increases the chance that we will run out of petrol. My substack (£/free trial) shows how we can cope better than we managed in 2012. timleunig.substack.com/p/how-to-ration-fuel
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Always great to be praised in public by a former boss. And yes, I am absolutely still a member of the @LibDems. I enjoyed working for @michaelgove - who knew that trying to recruit me to the @Conservatives would have been a waste of time!
Harry Fletcher-Wood
@HFletcherWood
The value of people - including those who don't agree with you or align with you politically, notably @timleunig
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Jonathan Haskel
@haskelecon
Agree Tom. Attended same conference as @timleunig and took a driverless car; fantastic and potential massive congestion saver
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tuna
@antea04
I'm a data scientist @OurWorldinData and I need help from a botanist or someone local to Kyoto, Japan! 🌸
We present one of the world’s longest climate records: 1,200 years of peak cherry blossom dates in Kyoto.
The researcher who maintained it, Professor Yasuyuki Aono, sadly passed away last year. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Anna Clarke
@AnnaClarke_____
Building *only* social housing is perfectly possible (private housebuilders can build it for you if you like). But it requires around £100,000 subsidy per new home. I'd quite like to see the Green Party's plans for how to fund it.
Saul Staniforth
@SaulStaniforth
"The unrealistic thing is to expect property developers.. to build us out of this crisis.. what we really need is a party.. who say we need to build social housing, council housing.. it will require intervention [&] thats absolutely what we must do"
@ZackPolanski yesterday -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
And here's something I wrote on why Cambridge should be allowed to fail. Take your pick! tomforth.co.uk/embracefailure/
Ben Ramanauskas
@BenRamanauskas
There is a lot of talk about expanding/developing Cambridge. Here is something I wrote a while back on why Cambridge should be allowed to grow.
www.bennettschool.cam.ac.uk/blog/unlocking-cambridges-pot… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You could do that as well - the tenant has the right to match the highest bid
Xris Xeating
@chriskeating
What prevents the landlord from overpricing? Does the tenant get a second right of refusal if the sealed bids price is lower than the asking price?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tymofiy Mylovanov
@Mylovanov
Imagine Amazon — but for combat drones. Ukraine built it. Commanders log in, browse hundreds of drone models, pay with brigade credits and receive delivery in 5-10 days.
Successful strikes earn bonus credits. No other military in the world does this — NYT. 1/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
Looks fascinating!
Soumitra Shukla
@soumitrashukla9
Very happy to share a new paper with Guido Friebel, Yao Huang, Jin Li, and Andrew Zhang on how AI could change the structure of internal labor markets.
We show that cutting junior hiring when AI arrives may weaken the pipeline that creates future seniors and lead to “lost cohorts” of juniors and cycles of shortage and glut over time. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Full markst to @FT for their reporting on this. I also hope they get full costs. Justice must be done.
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
I hope the FT gets indemnity costs. They must have spent a fortune on this.
But even then, it wouldn’t be enough to deter Odey and others like him from trying to silence critics with libel actions.
Failed libel actions should carry a painful cost. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I can see how this might work. You put the flat on the market at a price you choose, but you can't sell it to anyone except the tenant for a month. That gives the tenant time to make a decision, and get a mortgage. If they decline, sell it to someone else.
Sam Taylor
@staylorish
How is this supposed to work? Is the landlord compelled to sell at this “fair market rate”? How is that calculated?
And if they are not compelled to sell, and think they can get a better offer, won’t the landlord just wait out the exclusivity period, & then put it on the market? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I will bet you £10 the Greens don't win where I live, @meadwaj !
James Meadway
@meadwaj
1. The Greens can win anywhere.
2. And Reform-Green-not voting switchers are the critical next voters to win. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Looks bad, @lugaricano. I have never seen anything like this in Europe. Can you imagine @Ryanair @British_Airways @easyJet @AirFranceUK all setting the same price? I cannot.
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Wow! I have never seen this. Is this supposed to be normal in the US? Never seen this level of successful tacit (I guess!!) cooperation in prices only life! With four players!? (@florianederer , @CompetitionProf)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
@timleunig has proposed that failed defamation cases should result in an automatic damages award in favour of the defendant. It's the kind of thing economics love but lawyers hate.
In this instance, the economists are correct! -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
An update on the attempt by a tax barrister to sue me for £8m.
Last month, the High Court threw out the claim.
The Court then made a highly unusual order: Mr Kamal was required to pay all of our costs, £146,644.
And today I received payment in full. -
Tim Leunig reposted
JN
@JonNeale
In the early 60s 35pc of people in towns near London commuted by bicycle. It was even 25pc in a new town like Crawley. Yet the cycle was almost ignored in post war town planning. Surely one of the great failures of the era. (From Boom Cities, Otto Samaurez-Smith)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Clem Cowton
@ClemCowton
Only part of the answer to this is “build more grid”. We’d need to build much less grid - £27bn less -
if we implemented a market reform that is common in other countries, called “locational pricing”. It allows the system to make use of existing infrastructure more efficiently.
Robin Hawkes
@robhawkes
Great Britain threw away 5GW of available wind power during Storm Dave and replaced it using gas 🔥
That's one and a half Sizewell C-sized nuclear power stations, or four Dogger Bank A-sized wind farms.
Or to put it another way, it's a shit load of power.
Why throw it away? Because our straw isn't big enough…
Constraints on the electricity transmission network between Scotland and England (as well as further north in Scotland) mean that we can't move enough energy across the border without overloading the system.
Imagine a cup constantly filling with water, if your straw is too thin then you won't be able to drink enough water before the cup overflows. In our case the straw is the electricity grid at the border, and the water is the energy generated by the wind farms in Scotland.
Any overflowing water would be bad news for the grid so we do everything we can to avoid it.
The result is that we pay generators in Scotland to reduce their output so the cup doesn't overflow. Wind farms are usually picked for this because they are the cheapest to switch off and can provide the volumes of energy needed to resolve the constraints.
However, the electricity is still needed in the south (it's still thirsty) so what happens next is that we replace that lost wind energy at the last minute with electricity generated via (usually) gas. This is not only a waste of low-carbon energy, it's also expensive.
You can see this play out on my map and in the attached visual:
🚦 Traffic-coloured lines show boundary constraints
🟡 Yellow rings show wind farms that were turned off
🔴 Red rings show gas plants that were turned on
I'll post a link to the map in the thread. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
Richard, that’s a shame especially since you haven’t read the full proposal yet. We have supporters from Reform to the Greens. And as a business man I’d have thought you’d support the future of British businesses who are DESPERATE for cheaper energy, lower taxes and space to innovate right next to Cambridge. Two of the best economists @PJTheEconomist and @timleunig are backing it for just this reason.
Richard Tice MP 🇬🇧
@TiceRichard
Dreadful proposal for new city over 45,000 acres near Cambs
Reform are against this terrible idea digitaleditions.telegraph.co.uk/data/2398/reader/reader.h… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
A forthcoming Brookings paper finds the AI adoption gap between the US and Europe mirrors the IT gap of the 1990s. The reason is not technological. The firms that decentralize authority and reward performance adopt AI. The rest don't. My post on why.
open.substack.com/pub/siliconcontinent/p/what-explains-he… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Most pleased to get a link in @timleunig's latest blog on what Liverpool might learn from San Francisco. The centres of big British cities (except London) have indeed densified enormously (and are continuing to do so). timleunig.substack.com/p/what-can-liverpool-learn-from-san
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Can you weight these by population, and add London?
JN
@JonNeale
I need to get my favourite chart out again....
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Free markets are the best way to create wealth AND reduce poverty ever discovered.
One of the big puzzles of history is how the same lesson has to be learned again and again. Poland, China, India, and now Argentina are the latest experiments.
Argentina with Milei:
- Poverty down: 53% to 28%.
- Inflation down: 200% to 33% (and continuing to fall
- Growth up to: 4.4% last year.
- Govt surplus: first in 123 years.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/04/03/poverty-milei-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Clem Cowton
@ClemCowton
This is a big problem because Britain is about to embark upon a £70bn transmission grid upgrade programme whose (already questionable) business case is predicated on very strong growth in electricity demand. Without that growth, grid spend pushes household bills up even further.
Robert Boswall
@RobertBoswall
Electricity demand growth is still not materalising.
Over Christmas reports projected 3% year-on-year growth. But DESNZ has released their 2025 numbers and UK has regained ground but we are only back at the per capita level of 2023. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with @DuncanStott
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Possibly the best 'tax' currently being levied. Urban land is a finite resource. If you want to use it to make money, you absolutely should be paying the council for the privilege.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
This seems good to me.
Youth clubs seemed naff to me when I was a teenager, but the evidence is that they do reduce crime and improve school outcomes: teenagers in London areas where youth clubs were shut in the 2010s were 17% more likely to commit crimes, and did worse in their exams, than teens in comparable places where they stayed open. (ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2024-11/WP202451-The-effec…)
I assume some of these kids have quite unpleasant home lives – cramped homes, shared bedrooms, and/or family members who aren't very nice to be around – and want somewhere else to be in the evenings. Better at one of these playing video games or football than hanging around on the street.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cp9v7z3j40eo -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Really excited to be part of this. A real chance to make a difference to the housing crisis and to the economy of one of our most productive areas.
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
We're incredibly humbled to have @PJTheEconomist, one of the UK's most respected economists, join our advisory board for Forest City.
For the last two month's he's been an invaluable guide to Joe, myself and the Forest City economics team. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I don't know the answer to why the government is not pursuring a San Fran/Silicon Valley approach to the North West of England... Scotland could plausibly do it on the M8 Glasgow-Edinburgh route as well.
Nick Harrison
@NickHarrison73
Good to hear your optimism on the North @timleunig.
I agree there is untapped talent, way cheaper housing, and a great standard of living for those who live / move there.
An interesting idea to enable more building to double down on growth. What do you think is standing in governments way? Seems like an obvious win.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Years ago I wrote some very pessimistic stuff about prospects for Northern cities. History has proven me wrong. This week my free to read substack looks at the lessons of Silicon Valley to make our Northern cities even more successful - timleunig.substack.com/p/what-can-liverpool-learn-from-san
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Years ago I wrote some very pessimistic stuff about prospects for Northern cities. History has proven me wrong. This week my free to read substack looks at the lessons of Silicon Valley to make our Northern cities even more successful - timleunig.substack.com/p/what-can-liverpool-learn-from-san
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Greg Jackson
@g__j
This post is bang right on one thing - you buy a wind turbine or solar panel and you have power for 20 years.
No one can hold you hostage and you don’t have to keep paying.
If you buy a barrel of oil or a cubic meter of gas it’s gone the moment you use it.
Renewable energy is there for decades. Fossil fuel is disposable. It’s a subscription product from very unreliable providers. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A lovely piece on English choral music - which I also love - from @NeilDotObrien. Happy Easter! open.substack.com/pub/almondtree/p/in-quires-and-places-w…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
UK VAT law is bonkers - exhibit 94
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Four court hearings, probably £1m+ of fees, all to work out if large marshmallows are a "sweetened prepared food which is normally eaten with the fingers", and therefore subject to VAT.
Spoiler: they are not. Because "A > B and C > D, (A + C) > (B + D)" -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is an epic and very very funny piece of reporting from @FinancialTimes
Timo Vainionpää
@TimoVainionpaa
A spokesperson could not be reached for comment (possibly because she doesn’t exist)
The curious case of Emilia Carrière, alleged comms professional
www.ft.com/content/05c9515a-d183-4e9f-aab9-8b3c6899ff25 via @ft -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Did not know that! I wrote a fair fuel stabiliser plan when I was in HMT. Mine was a 180 day rolling average. I still think a FFS is a good idea... Glad that @EdwardJDavey and @LibDems are pushing a version of it.
Mike Brewer
@MikeBrewerEcon
The Fair Fuel Stabiliser! @rbrharrison's invention, I believe?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
Why does the UK have such a bad fly-tipping problem?
In the Guardian, George Monbiot blames deregulation and not enough spending on enforcement.
To me, the cause is obvious. Britain has the highest landfill tax in Europe.
The returns to flytipping are just higher here. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
There is a very strong case for taxes on fuels - whether petrol or gas and electricity - varying inversely with the global price. Well done to @EdwardJDavey for putting this forward.
Ed Davey
@EdwardJDavey
Cost of living announcement x.com/i/broadcasts/1jGXgeypdNVKZ
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
More consistent prices over time give people much clearer signals about whether it is financially sensible to live a long way from work, whether to buy an EV, a hybrid or a straight petrol, whether get a heat pump, etc.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Want to get an extra 10mpg? Interesting piece from @Kyle_Fortune @autocar. £200 a year saving for the average petrol motorist... www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/features/beat-petrol-price-hik…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Self-driving cars are going to be revolutionary for people like this lady. When we get full self-driving, people will be able to drive home from the pub as well. Technology improved lives. H/t @lugaricano
Sawyer Merritt
@SawyerMerritt
This 93 year old has found new freedom after she bought a new @Tesla Model Y with FSD. She also uses Grok navigation.
"Although she has always been a good driver, my mom can now drive without the fear or fatigue that can naturally come with age. No more relying on others for every trip. No more feeling stuck. This is true mobility that can spark new adventures in a still adventurous women!"
(via Dan Doyle's Family Channel. Full video below)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
m🪐rganic
@subarustevenz
Problems like this simply shouldn't be accepted. The line was finished 16 months ago and the best we get is a 'hope' trains are running by the second half of the year
Chris Ogilvie
@OgilvieCJ
East-West Rail: A new £7Bn line connecting Oxford & Milton Keynes was finished 16 months ago.
But it remains without trains & useless to families who moved to be next to it”
“We live three minutes from Winslow station - and can’t catch a train.
🆓⬇️
www.thetimes.com/article/533fdc44-de3d-44af-939c-64d810ab… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
With all the claims of Mickey mouse degrees etc, worth remembering that when bad times hit, it is people without degrees who are hit hardest.
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
A quick pull of the UK data suggests there hasn't been a similar relative rise in college graduate unemployment rate in the UK - anyone has thoughts on why the difference?
(Pulled from: explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-statisti…) -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (£/free trial) sets out the best way to help people with energy bills this winter. I think it is new and better than the other ideas out there... timleunig.substack.com/p/what-the-chancellor-should-do-about
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If you are a civil servant or a journalist I will get you a free subscription - sign up with your work email and I will upgrade you.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Legal Style Blog
@legalstyleblog
There has been a lot of interest in and confusion about the British constitution. I am pleased, therefore, to present this simple and not at all tongue-in-cheek guide to understanding the constitutional settlement of 1688.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You are 100% spot on, @StatisticUrban when you say "UK housing policy makes America look like a building paradise." I wish it weren't so...
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
> 500 homes
> by 2032
Oh lord. UK housing policy makes America look like a building paradise. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The most exciting thing for me this week is the launch of the 2030 Prosperity Alliance. Run by my Public First colleague and old friend, @PJTheEconomist, it is a non-political group that aims to get Britain going again.
Post not available here, view on X
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Lack-lustre UK growth gives us the chance to catch up with countries that are richer than us. That was true in the 1970s, and it is sadly all too true now. I look forward to being part of the 2030 Prosperity Alliance, offering my experience as an economist and a policy maker.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If you want to be join us, to go to www.2030prosperityalliance.co.uk, and sign up. Together we can achieve a decade of national prosperity.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
To a large extent I think the grit etc is captured in the degree class - we know that kids from poorer backgrounds outperform at Uni relative to grades. I also think easier to be knocked off course if you have less background social capital.
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
I think per the point Imran Rasul made at the event, there’s good reason to believe you might even see the opposite of what we find b/c of positive selection on unobservables (grit, motivation, talent) for someone who grew up in poverty to make it to a given degree program
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Thanks for asking @Dixit4Neeraj, and thanks @Sam_Dumitriu. References in my chapter in free to read niesr.ac.uk/publications/pro-productivity-policies.
Neeraj Dixit
@Dixit4Neeraj
"The transport economics literature reports that investment in roads has particularly high returns — £1mn spent on roads typically has four times the return of spending the same amount on railways." How was this conclusion arrived at? What methodology?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think the paper is great, but did anyone ever think the effects of background would be completely washed out by education?
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
We often think that the effects of class background are washed out by education. But we show that two people who did the same subject at the same university at the same time, and got the same grade …. end up earning quite different amounts when they enter the labour market
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This might be right, but the graph should be in pence, not % for us to assess it. @oliver_wright @Steven_Swinford
Steven Swinford
@Steven_Swinford
Exclusive from @oliver_wright
Sir Keir Starmer’s claim that Britain’s petrol retailers are “profiteering” from the war in the Middle East by price gouging is not supported by evidence, an investigation by The Times suggests
An analysis of fuel price rises at more than 6,000 petrol stations since the conflict in Iran began found that retailers had, on average, increased the cost of petrol by 12.1 per cent. Of those, only nine forecourts increased their petrol prices more than double the national average (24 per cent or more)
The pump price increase is less than the 18 per cent rise in the wholesale price since the US attacks on Iran began.
The findings cast doubt on claims by Starmer and Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, that petrol retailers have been exploiting the crisis in the Middle East to make additional profits at the expense of customers.
www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/petrol-retailers-not… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In which @TeraPauliina proves she is a much geekier parent than I am!! :-) :-) :-)
Tera Allas CBE | @teraallas.bsky.social
@TeraPauliina
With zero personal knowledge of the UK university system, this is how I helped my daughter decide — using LEO (and other) data! www.linkedin.com/pulse/choosing-university-course-geeky-w…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am planning to install a domestic battery this summer - perhaps 16kWh. I think the sums add up...
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Batteries keep getting cheaper and cheaper too. Also better and better (faster charging, more cycles, longer life, better performance when it's cold or hot, etc...). Feels important.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Given England's position in PISA etc, it is absurd to say that average progress in our schools "is probably terrible", @policy_uk. As you know, I like you and respect you, but you are talking out of your backside here, as with your earlier tweet I urged you to delete.
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
So it’s helpful in showing outliers, with the caveat that ‘average progress’ at 0 could be terrible (and probably is). Statistics damn statistics. Bring back simple nominal outcomes of average attainment at Key Stage 3 tests in Year 9 and GCSE for every school.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree, and when I was in @educationgovuk I ran a randomised control letter writing trial to overcome exactly that. It worked! papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3305176
tony grimes
@toegrimes
My personal experience here is that when I was applying for university at start of 90s no one told me what a good university was so I just went on vibes. I’m sure the middle class parents were directing their kids. I’m sure that accounts for some of this
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In which @policyUk discovers that half the children in England make less progress than the average child. That is literally how averages work!
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
I still don’t think this anything to be happy or proud about ! Relative to the performance of the average school, children in half of our comprehensive schools do not progress
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is utterly wrong and completely misleading. A negative progress 8 score does not mean a school destroys value. It means it adds less value than the average. @policy_uk please delete your tweet, therefore! Thank you.
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
Tim’s own Progress 8 model shows the school destroys value between Year 7 and Year 11. This is not uncommon in our comprehensives. 👍
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In a good comp? The evidence says yes!
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
But you did! Would you have succeeded as greatly in a comprehensive?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Very few of these people will have gone to grammar school. It shows what a good education system can do.
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
Just shows what a grammar school education can do! ;)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is super interesting research, but for me the big take away is that poor kids like me earn 96% of the salary of a middle class kid in the same industry. Not perfect, but much higher than I might have thought. #englandisgoodplacetogrowupevenifyouarepoor
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Graduates who grew up in deep poverty are less likely to attend the most selective universities, and more likely to receive lower degree marks than their more advantaged peers.
Read 'The long shadow', published today 👉 www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/the-long-shadow/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
This applies to the North Sea too.
Even if North Sea drilling has no impact on gas prices, domestic production still helps because of the impact on exports/sterling.
More gas exports mean a stronger pound and a stronger pound means that all the stuff we import gets cheaper. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Brexit has likely done more economic damage than feared.
Recent evidence suggests the economic cost of Brexit may be approaching twice the 4% impact assumed by the OBR.
The Chancellor has signalled a shift in approach to EU trade, but the effect will depend on how far the govt goes on alignement. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But that is true pretty much everywhere. French electricity prices had been falling for a while, now they are rising. Global markets are like that.
Jamie WhiteBelly
@climbnpenguin
Bills down in April, up by July. The only predictable thing about UK energy policy is its unpredictability.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Ramanauskas
@BenRamanauskas
Good and sensible (as always) Substack from Tim.
More radically, I'd add that the government should (temporarily) abolish all tariffs and quotas on imports.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Three ways to ease the costs of living - my free to read substack - timleunig.substack.com/p/the-cost-of-living
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Helen Barnard
@Helen_Barnard
3 sensible ideas we should be doing regardless of the current circumstances.
Impacts, especially in the short term, likely to be small though, and not particularly targeted on those most likely to struggle to afford essentials if prices spike.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Three ways to ease the costs of living - my free to read substack - timleunig.substack.com/p/the-cost-of-living
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Three ways to ease the costs of living - my free to read substack - timleunig.substack.com/p/the-cost-of-living
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This year one of my lecturers won the Nobel Prize (@Ph_Aghion) and now @HyunSongShin has been appointed Governor of the Bank of Korea. Both were outstanding teachers, as well as fine researchers www.ft.com/content/e70ea434-f585-4271-bb75-7265b3f02a37. Such a privilege!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Pretty much all countries are worried about energy bills at the moment! Certainly almost all in Asia and Europe. Even France has seen electricity prices rise 20% above December's lows, and I imagine their gas bills are rising like ours. tradingeconomics.com/france/electricity-price
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
Haha I’ve just had a load of emails telling me ‘your energy bills are going down in April’. This perpetual chaos in gas and electricity prices is ridiculous. In what other countries do households continuously fret about their electricity bills ?!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
For about 12 weeks since I moved to the US (a year ago!) parts of the federal government have been shut down. I've found it particularly dispiriting that people don't really kick up a fuss and there is no general expectation that the government should function.
Ella Dorsey
@Ella__Dorsey
Y'all... I've NEVER seen Hartsfield Jackson this bad. This is what security looks like this morning (Friday). We've talked to people that got to the airport at 3am that missed their 6am flight.
@ATLNewsFirst @GAFollowers -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
If you give Claude Code access to your work calendar and Slack, you can pretty easily set it up to scan your calendar for tomorrow and tell you things like (a) where you need to be for your first appointment, (b) what you likely need to wear (tie/no tie, heavy coat/none), (c) any clashes you need to resolve, and (d) any documents you might need to read.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Do you buy anything that uses steel? If so, @hmtreasury has decided to raise your cost of living in a direct and unambiguous manner, making you. #badnews from @EdConwaySky.
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
🚨Clearly there's loads of news today so there's a chance this gets ignored but... it is a BIG deal.
Britain, the country that invented free trade as we know it, is raising steel tariffs to 50%.
Biggest tariffs since Brexit. A massively symbolic moment. news.sky.com/story/watershed-moment-as-uk-levies-steel-ta…
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I wonder whether other sectors will get protected like this over the next couple of years, further raising the UK cost of living?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well worth reading from @hale_shale @resfoundation
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
🚨 Out now - the Resolution Foundation response to the Chancellor’s 2026 Mais Lecture.
@hale_shale argues that the priorities set out by Rachel Reeves yesterday form a credible framework for supporting stronger growth, but important gaps remain.
Read it here: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Romesh Vaitilingam
@econromesh
Fifty years ago, economic research took a turn towards issues of community, place, family, religion & identity; this was associated with novel empirical methods including experiments, large datasets & growing focus on social norms & strategic interactions
ucleconbrief.co.uk/2026/01/26/beyond-markets-and-states-c… -
Tim Leunig reposted
ianVisits
@ianvisits
Gifted to the nation for use by a government minister, just outside London, can be found a modest mansion that’s also open to the public, but only for a couple of weeks a year.
www.ianvisits.co.uk/articles/tickets-alert-tours-of-dorne… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I think this is now wrong. North English Cities are now just as dense as their European equivalents like Amsterdam, Hamburg, Copenhagen, etc... with extremely strong economies. There are some different patterns within that density I admit, but I don't think it matters much.
Centre for Cities
@CentreforCities
Britain's housing crisis and the economic growth of its major cities hinge on embracing higher urban density.
This involves constructing more mid-rise residences in city centers, including London, backed by bold planning reforms and proactive public leadership👇 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Maybe - but it does reduce the incentive to work/work more hours/get promoted...
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
A social tariff that provides discounted prices for low-income families is the best way to deliver targeted energy support this winter.
We modelled several alternatives, but none were as effective at targeting low-income households with high energy bills as a social tariff (in green). -
Tim Leunig reposted
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Failing to pursue closer integration with the EU creates tension with the Government’s growth ambitions.
The Brexit impact on GDP per person may be bigger than feared; the impact on GDP per person may well sit above 4 per cent already.
Read more ➡️ www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/mountain-climbing/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
"you don't see so many kids up trees"
that was one of the most striking things anyone said to me in indonesia.
a guy remarked that when he was a kid, they'd climb the trees, nick the mangos.
but now, so many are on their devices, eating confectionary in wrappers. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
This is great news if it happens. Cambridge and Oxford are special cities that should be a lot bigger, more beautiful, and well connected to the rest of the country.
YIMBY Alliance
@yimbyalliance
🚨OxCam update:
At today's Mais Lecture, @RachelReevesMP announced that the Government will consult on a development corporation for Greater Oxford.
This news comes one month after the announcement that there will be a new development corporation for Cambridge. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Of course, this really shows that our tax system is in need of reform and simplification.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
There is finally a “no dividend S&P 500” ETF - something I’ve looked for for a long time.
If an equivalent became available in Britain, we could avoid the 35.75–39.35% dividend tax rates and pay the 24% Capital Gains Tax rate instead. Huge savings!
www.roundhillinvestments.com/etf/xdiv/ -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Traditionally a price control is simply the government setting a price. I think a decade ago, for example, Greece has a fixed 1 Euro rate for a 500ml bottle of water. We had price controls 1973-79., the US too. There was no government subsidy involved.
James Meadway
@meadwaj
How else would a control work?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A subsidy is very different to price controls!
James Meadway
@meadwaj
Easy enough to create a subsidy (and not sure why everyone is freaking out about that)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
"The UK triple lock is the singlest stupidest policy in the entire Western world" << anyone want to propose some alternatives for @lugaricano to consider?
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
The UK triple lock is the singlest stupidest policy in the entire Western world, and the most damaging to the future of a country. Of course, it is also untouchable and almost undiscussed in the UK press. @mattyglesias does a big favour to the UK public here.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I literally could not get on the tube at rush hour last time I tried. How does that help people get home? What @s8mb and I proposed was faster tubes to get people home more quickly!
Imelda Finnerty
@blisswords
People have to get to work. Get home to eat and see families. Do not raise tube fares.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
To be clear, are you proposing minimum (upward) price controls to encourage supply? I am confused as to your proposal...
James Meadway
@meadwaj
The supply of fertiliser being reduced is why you introduce the price control…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have lots of NIMBY opinions! No airport on Hyde Park! No car park at the top of Snowdon! No Heliport on Ben Nevis summit! Don't build a housing estate on Hampstead Heath! No gigafactory in Richmond Park! And yes, no fracking either. #commonsense
Maurice Cousins
@MDC12345678
I never thought I’d hear @timleunig advancing NIMBY arguments.
CapX
@CapX
Extract from the North Sea. Don't rely on Qatar. Or the US.
On the latest episode of The Capitalist podcast, @timleunig talks with @marcsidwell about why he thinks Britain's energy answer is closer than you think – and why fracking is still off the table in the UK. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Having had to catch a peak hour tube twice recently (I usually bike) I agree with @s8mb. As well as investing in faster more frequent tubes, we could use the money to provide more buses, bus lanes and cycle routes to get London moving.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
My unpopular opinion is that TfL should raise peak tube fares more. In the mornings, stations and trains are uncomfortably overcrowded and it's often difficult to get a seat. Higher fares would help with that and raise more money to invest in newer rolling stock.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Price controls on fertiliser will reduce the supply of fertiliser, which would reduce food output and raise food prices. Not sensible from @meadwaj
James Meadway
@meadwaj
This is the right line to take, but government needs to get ahead of this now - windfall profits need to be windfall taxed immediately. And we need proposals brought forward for controls on key input prices - not only domestic energy, eg fertiliser is a problem down the line.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Really important set of facts here from @shivmalik England has not been concreted over. And much farmland is seriously nature depleted.
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
63% of England is used for agriculture
20% is moors and lakes
Just 8.7% is developed (this includes gardens and parks)
London has more tree cover than Suffolk. The pic below is from Hackney.
Private developers are failing yes, but it’s farming’s relationship with nature that needs rectifying urgently if we’re going to reverse nature depletion. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Solar panels may help reclaim the desert: interestingevidence from China. share.google/ijUqmU0QO1fOYxImv
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sort of - there is greater day to day and week to week unpredictability with wind here than with summer solar in Spain.
Alistair McGirr
@alistairmcgirr
Whilst the relative variability point true, it’s worth noting that much like the profile of solar being well matched to needs in the ‘sun belt’ (ie air-con), the profile of offshore wind is well suited to need for countries like the UK in the ‘wind belt’ (ie cold dark winters).
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Tell me something I don't know!
Here&There
@here_there
It’s not difficult Tim…..European gas prices correlate as Europe is short gas and short gas storage. Germany has as mad an energy policy as the UK
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We clearly need back up, and we need some baseload (see Spain), but equally clearly "more" renewables is a perfectly reasonable position.
Andrew Montford
@aDissentient
You cannot be in favour of renewables until you have determined if there is a viable solution to the problem. You imply that there isn't one currently. Your support for renewables is therefore an article of faith, not a rational position.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
To the best of my knowledge, @LionHirth and I agree? Both of us think Marginal Pricing is a sensible way to structure markets, for example. Not sure who claimed wind is 9x cheaper than gas - not me, doubt it was @DrSimEvans either.
Andrew Montford
@aDissentient
I suggest you read @LionHirth, who is actually an energy economist, rather than the man behind "wind is nine times cheaper than gas" (lol).
Start here:
www.linkedin.com/posts/eurelectric_marginal-pricing-and-t… -
Tim Leunig reposted
CapX
@CapX
Extract from the North Sea. Don't rely on Qatar. Or the US.
On the latest episode of The Capitalist podcast, @timleunig talks with @marcsidwell about why he thinks Britain's energy answer is closer than you think – and why fracking is still off the table in the UK. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I am all in favour of more renewables, but it is easier in Spain, because solar is more predictable there than wind here, and because they don't have the same size winter demand peak. Our challenge is harder!
Jamie WhiteBelly
@climbnpenguin
Spain's chart says it all. Decouple from gas, decouple from chaos. Renewables aren't charity, they're infrastructure. UK taking notes or just taking the hit?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is an excellent piece from the ever-worth-reading @DrSimEvans from @CarbonBrief. When gas prices are high, the cause of high energy prices is not the system used to set prices.
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
NEW: Why does gas set the price of electricity – and is there an alternative?
Make yourself a tea (or grab a beer??) and enjoy my Friday longread on marginal pricing, ideas for market reform – & how to break the link btwn gas & power prices for good
www.carbonbrief.org/qa-why-does-gas-set-the-price-of-elec…
1/8 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
I see some weird things but this takes the biscuit. A vulnerability in the Companies House website, that let anyone view the private dashboard of any one of the five million registered companies, see directors' personal details.
And modify them.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They do different GCSEs and A levels. When kids in England and Northern Ireland take the same tests, kids in England do better - see PISA scores - @policy_uk really should know better on this by now.
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
Northern Ireland’s stand-out performance at GCSE and A Level compared to the mostly-comprehensive rUK has been consistent since the early 1980s 👍
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, definitely have a look at my plan for Heathrow - policyexchange.org.uk/publication/bigger-and-quieter-the-…
Thatcherite Princess
@ThatcheriteBish
@timleunig wrote a paper back in 2013 with proposals for a 3rd and 4th runway
policyexchange.org.uk/publication/bigger-and-quieter-the-… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Nesta
@nesta_uk
Does the UK tax system need a total overhaul? 💸
On the latest episode of The Policy Fix podcast, @TheIFS's @HelenMiller_IFS and @timleunig argue we need a consistent vision.
Watch the full episode to explore what real tax reform looks like. ➡️ www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlPDlpN0fxE&list=PLndaoe-spJFxBl3… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If @JohnFingleton1 is happy, so am I. Maybe UK growth will happen! Fingers crossed...
John Fingleton
@JohnFingleton1
I am pleased to see the government response to Task Force on Nuclear Regulation.
First, it has been published on time which sends a positive signal about priorities.
Second, the detailed and considered response shows that the Government is serious about reform.
Third, almost every recommendation is to be taken forward fully.
All of this should help bring about a substantial reduction in cost and delivery schedules for new nuclear. This should spur greater confidence for investors in nuclear in the UK.
A few recommendations will be taken forward in a different way that in our report, as we envisaged. The role of the Implementation structure will be critical in continuing to ensure that this is prioritised. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The renewable energy revolution is remarkable, with solar in particular now so cheap that it is the default anywhere sunny.
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Do you get whats coming? #solarhockeystickofhope
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Nesta
@nesta_uk
🎉 The Policy Fix is LIVE.
Nesta’s new podcast digs into the UK’s biggest policy problems and how we can fix them.
🎧 Episode 1 out now - how to fix the UK tax system with @timleunig and @TheIFS's @HelenMiller_IFS.
Watch the full ep ➡️ www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlPDlpN0fxE&list=PLndaoe-spJFxBl3… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Another morning, another 1800 high density central homes for Leeds have sailed through planning. Standard morning. > Kirkstall Road: Green light for next part of Dyecoats development - West Leeds Dispatch share.google/Zf0Q1AyuYC5QCluZQ
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
I find it hard not to have as a central scenario where oil prices will remain very high for a long time, higher than the market current prices.
I am no expert on geo-politics and defense technology, but this is what I think I have learned:
Fully protecting ships in the strait of Hormuz is basically impossible. Not enough time to stop missiles or drones.
There is no reason, whether or not Trump declares that war is over, to think that Iran will not continue for some time to threaten to destroy the ships that try. Why should they stop?
The risk will thus remain sufficiently high that most non Iranian ships will not take the risk.
Thus, the shortfall of 20 million barrels a day is likely to last for long.
The scope for increased supply from elsewhere is very limited in the short run. Perhaps 2 million barrels at the most.
The 400 million barrels reserve release can only add 3-4 million barrels or so daily.
The short run elasticity of demand for oil is very low, at most -0.1, and probably less.
This suggests to me prices closer to 150-200 dollars per barrel (or more, but I hesitate to give higher numbers…) than to the current market price.
To repeat. I am no expert (As an economist, I have a bit more sense about the next step, namely what such a price would to the world economy). I would be more than happy to be proven wrong. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Antonio Mele
@antoniomele101
This is a great point, @arindube , and I am really guilty of not sharing more about what I have been up to on the teaching side of things, given that this is what they pay me for! Let's get back on track with a mega post.
At @LSEEcon, we've been running a series of structured experiments to figure out exactly how GenAI changes the production function of economics education. We moved past the "cheating" panic early (although we didn't really have one in our programmes) and started actively rebuilding our pedagogy around these tools. Here's what we're doing and what we're learning, and btw we will be presenting our work at CTREE 2026 in Las Vegas in late May if you are in town.
The AI Economics Professor
With Ronny Razin, we built a specialised, course-aligned AI tutor. The key idea Ronny had: best way to verify if a student actually understands a concept is to ask them to explain it interactively. Clearly this does not scale to the class size we have at LSE (Ronny teaches his course to 850 first-year students). But we can scale with AI! The key pedagogical principle is that the chatbot uses a Socratic framework. It refuses to hand out final answers. Instead, students are prompted with an exercise, and the chatbot asks them to identify the next step in a mathematical or logical derivation themselves, guiding them through the reasoning rather than short-circuiting it. It adapts to the students' level, for example by clarifying concepts or notation if needed.
This gives students access to 24/7 personalised tutoring, levelling the playing field for those who might hesitate to speak up in small classes or office hours, and solving Bloom's "2-sigma problem" in economics education. Notice that we didn't train the bot or fine-tuned t to our course material. We just provided a system prompt embracing the Socratic approach, and the solutions to the exercise students had to solve. That's it. Off the shelf LLM model (it was Gemini 2.5 Flash).
We did run a small experiment for a game theory exercise, where students had to work out strictly dominated strategies, and pure and mixed strategy Nash equilibria. The feedback we received is overwhelmingly positive: students found it useful to work through the reasoning with the chatbot, and it helped them understand the material better. We are also in the process of establishing if the use of the chatbot improves marks in the final exam, although we don't have a full analysis yet. But I can say that this was a very good year for the distribution of marks in this course, way above the average of previous years. If this proves as good as it looks, next step is to scale this to more courses, potentially expand to similar disciplines in LSE, and potentially expand to other universities. Stay tuned.
AI Feedback Experiment
Providing high-quality, scalable formative feedback is one of the hardest problems in our job. It's incredibly labour-intensive, and the result is that students often get too little feedback, too late to act on it. Main problem, again, is scale. Can we use AI to enhance our feedback process? We did an experiment with @MichaelGmeiner2 in one of our MSc courses.
Michael is a great teacher. In his Econometrics course, he teaches students how to write referee reports, and provides feedback to each one of them on 5 submitted referee reports. We thought, why don't we provide two feedback reports for each submission, one AI-generated and one human-generated? This will allow us to evaluate how good the AI feedback is with respect to human feedback (well, Michael's feedback, which is superhuman in my view, but ok).
And so we did. We didn't say which is which to students, to avoid any kind of bias. And again, we just cooked up a prompt for the LLM to generate feedback on the referee report, we provided the AI with the paper to referee, the referee report submitted by the student, and nothing more.
We found out that students rated the AI-generated feedback as less useful than the human-generated, although not by a lot. Main problem with the AI-generated feedback is that it is too generic, and does not address the specific TECHNICAL issues that the student may have missed in their report. It is also too positive, and does not provide the student with the critical feedback that they need to improve. In particular, students highlighted that the AI feedback did not enhance their critical thinking, and did not address methodological problems in the research article they were refereeing.
Some of these aspects can be addressed with a better prompt, and we are working on it. The technical and methodological issues can also be addressed by providing a summary of what the teacher expects students to criticise in the paper, although there may be additional challenges in this approach (what if the student finds something else to criticise that the teacher did not think of? it happens all the time).
Students also mentioned they think the two pieces of feedback are complementary, and they will be happier getting both that just one of them.
This points in the direction of a hybrid approach, where AI is used to enhance the human feedback process, rather than substituting it. The caveat is, of course, that we haven't used the most recent models, we didn't try with mixture-of-experts and all the tricks in the book.
Teaching Python & RELAI Principles
Perhaps our biggest curriculum shift: with @JADHazell we pioneered teaching AI coding tools to first-year students. In the first year macro course that Joe teaches, we introduce students to Python coding for economic analysis. This year, we decided to move in a different direction: since the advent of AI coding agents, we believe it is more important to be able to READ and ORGANISE code than writing it. It is more important to be able to explain your intent to the AI coding agent, and verify that intent has been reflected in the code, than to be able to write the code yourself and test it. But how can you teach students that have never seen a line of code to do that?
Introducing Reverse Engineering Learning with AI (RELAI). Start with a full snippet of Python code. The student is told to prompt the AI to explain what the code does. Once the student understands what the code does, it can asks about the syntax and the programming concepts behind the snippet. Then can ask a study plan for those concepts, if needed. Then can try to enquire the AI about what would happen if I change this line or this parameter. Then it can experiment itself by changing the code, and debug with the help of the AI. Finally, the student can ask the AI to produce new code, based on what was learned, and the new intent. I call this the EXPLORE approach: Examine the code, eXplain what it does, Probe deeper, Link to economics, Output prediction, Recreate understanding, Extend with modification.
Once students are familiar with AI coding agents, they are assessed with a challenging coursework that Joe created. The assignment has a part that is difficult to do without AI, but should be feasible with AI. There are open ended questions where students have to go beyond the simple repetition of what was learned in the course, possibly explore new datasets and questions, etc.
We think this approach can help integrate AI coding agents into the curriculum in a meaningful way, and help students develop a deeper understanding of coding tools in a faster and more efficient way. Coursework is on the way, so we will be able to evaluate the impact of this approach in the next few months. I personally believe RELAI can be adapted to other topics and subjects, and can become one of the way we interact with AI when learning something new.
Read more about our approach here: python-ec1b1.vercel.app
AI as a productivity tool
This is where you can really go nuts.
I have used AI to produce new teaching material for several workshops and courses. Slides, assignments, exercises, etc. The last few exams were written with AI tools, creating a series of questions first with suggested solutions, and then choosing the most appropriate ones.
I use a coding agent (@cursor_ai ) with access to my teaching materials and past exams, so that it is aware of the content and style. You get a very good exam draft in minutes, and can edit, change questions, generate new ones, etc. It used to take me days to write a good exam, now it takes me a few hours in the afternoon.
I used Cursor to do deep research about a new course I wanted to design. I asked for topics, examples, current research in the field that I may not have been aware of, similar courses' syllabi, and in general what was the state of the art in the field. I got a very long list of topics that I could choose from to design my own course, based on my taste, interest and what I think my students should know. I could generate different versions of the same course for different levels (UG, MSc and PhD).
Conclusion
We are still at the early stages of this journey. We are learning a lot, and we are still figuring out how to best use AI to enhance our teaching. One important thing you may have noticed is that we first define our pedagogical approach and then we integrate AI tools to support it. The other principle should be, design not for the tools you have now, but the ones you will have in a few months or years.
If you have comments, or have been running similar experiments, I will be happy to hear from you.
Arin Dube
@arindube
I have read a ton from economists in my TL about use of AI in their research workflow.
Much less about teaching. Would love to hear what folks' experience has been on that front. (Not problems of students using AI: I mean use of AI in teaching workflow, the good and the bad.) -
Tim Leunig reposted
Richard Meyer
@RichardMeyerDC
Why is this either or? The problem is that by limiting supplies, you are still entirely dependent on foreign sources for your marginal supplies, which in turn drives the cost of electricity. This is true in the U.S. Northeast, and the UK is following suit.
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
Analysis: Why clean energy will cut UK gas imports by (much) more than North Sea drilling
The latest debate over new licenses has been lacking one key ingredient: Perspective
Here's our take in chart form – and I'm happy to debate the numbers
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-why-clean-energy-will-cut-uk… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Henry Hill
@HCH_Hill
The sector's defenders have done themselves absolutely no favours by adopting a maximalist "no such thing as a bad university/degree" position, leaving their reputations at the mercy of the visa mills.
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
Alarming story from @georginaquach:
At one UK university, the scramble to attract lucrative international students to the new London campus saw thousands admitted without the necessary English or academic skills, widespread use of ghostwriters, and fraudulent attendance logging -
Tim Leunig reposted
Leo Gibbons
@Layo_FH
It’s really really bad for society that the general public do not understand the economics of house building (study after study shows that even luxury flats, make housing overall, more affordable), but it’s particularly terribly when politicians don’t.
Marc Francis
@MarcFrancisTH
Just catching up with Mayor Rahman’s announcement that he intends to allow more than 50,000 more flats to be built if he is re-elected. Most of these will be private and so do nothing to help local people. Tower Hamlets moves to unlock 52,000-home pipeline www.towerhamlets.gov.uk/News_events/2026/March/Tower-Haml…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
Analysis: Why clean energy will cut UK gas imports by (much) more than North Sea drilling
The latest debate over new licenses has been lacking one key ingredient: Perspective
Here's our take in chart form – and I'm happy to debate the numbers
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-why-clean-energy-will-cut-uk… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is 100% true. I favour getting the last bit of gas out the North Sea, but more renewables are good in themselves and reduce the rate at which we need to run down the North Sea reserves. Badenich and Farage are at best confused.
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
ANALYSIS: Badenoch and Farage might not want to admit it, but Conservative and Reform plans to scrap net zero whilst boosting the North Sea would actually make the UK even more reliant on gas imports 🤔
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-why-clean-energy-will-cut-uk… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Allen
@Joe___Allen
Anti-housing campaigners in Cardiff have been very successful in selling the idea the city is being over-developed.
In reality just 605 homes were completed here in 24-25.
That's one third of this one development in Leeds. And one third of what we were completing 20 years ago.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Another morning, another 1800 high density central homes for Leeds have sailed through planning. Standard morning. > Kirkstall Road: Green light for next part of Dyecoats development - West Leeds Dispatch share.google/Zf0Q1AyuYC5QCluZQ
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
There's a popular idea on the left of British politics that councils can boost their local economy massively by 'buying local' and directing their procurement spend towards local businesses/co-ops.
It's known as the "Preston Model" after the council that pioneered it. And Preston has thrived in recent years, Preston’s wider region has higher productivity than anywhere else in Lancashire, Merseyside or Cumbria.
The big problem is local procurement spend is way too small to explain it. Preston Council’s entire budget is just under £30 million a year. That is less than half a percent of Preston’s GDP in 2023 of £6.2 billion.
So why is Preston doing well? My colleague (and ex-Preston resident) @Michael_J_Hil explains it is down to the real Preston Model: homes and roads.
- Preston has consistently smashed its centrally-imposed housing targets.
- Since local housing targets were introduced in 2018, Preston has exceeded its target by a substantial margin every year.
- And between 2021-2024, it had the highest overperformance in England.
Building homes is often controversial. So how do Preston overcome NIMBYs? They leverage development to build roads.
Local taxes on housebuilding, Central Govt incentives (New Homes Bonus), and land sales are all plowed into major local road projects.
And even if locals are at best, indifferent to new homes, they are keen to see their local transport infrastructure upgraded. In some cases, new homes have unlocked projects that have been promised (but unfunded) for decades.
Future housing growth is set to unlock a new railway station.
Too often new homes are built, but infrastructure doesn't follow. And then we wonder why locals are opposed. Preston shows that when you can tie development to better roads (and soon railways), opposition melts away.
In that sense, Preston is a model for the country.
www.samdumitriu.com/p/the-truth-about-the-preston-model -
Tim Leunig reposted
John Rentoul
@JohnRentoul
“It was almost as if, for the US president, lifting tariffs to their highest level since the 1930s was not enough to wreck the world economy, so more was needed” @dsmitheconomics www.thetimes.com/business/economics/article/dont-rule-out…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Interesting stuff from pollster and Labour MP Chris Curtis on why Labour won and what that means for Labour - chriscurtismk.substack.com/p/who-actually-were-the-hero-v…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
No, but if we don't train them now, they probably remain untrained for life, given low rates of mature students. That is also a gamble...
Iain Mansfield
@IGMansfield
Totally! We should look at how to improve the wider economy to improve growth.
But continuing to train more and more graduates in the hope it will produce growth is like watering a plant in the rain - number of graduates is not a rate limiting factor for us at the moment. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
When most other countries in the world are seeing high returns to graduates, it seems sensible to ask why the UK economy is not finding good uses for them and getting the same returns.
Iain Mansfield
@IGMansfield
If we had built more railways than we needed, we should *stop building railways* and use those resources to do something more productive.
Arguing that in such a situation we should just keep building more and more railways because to do otherwise would be 'defeatist' is bizarre. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Even if the 8000 is out by a factor of 2, battery costs are still very low. But heh, it is a free world, and you are welcome to believe anti-tech, anti-Net Zero stuff you like. History will judge! (PS I get the maker's miles per kWh from my Kia e-Niro.)
Mark Kingsley-Williams
@Mark_A_K_W
That's like expecting to get the same mileage as a car maker claim. Never happens in the real world. Nor will it with batteries on the grid at any scale. As the transition required for Net Zero is found, by even the most ardent and deluded follower, to be a hugely expensive and undesirable pipe dream.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is why I have repeatedly said that batteries are very plausible for night to day (or similar) but no use for summer to winter.
Carl 𓅪
@Carl__P_
We would need 2 months of electricity cover with batteries. A month to cover those large down periods and another month as we need to have a month back up.
That's 54Twh as UK total electricity usage last year was circa 340Twh.
At the costs you quote that's nearly 6 trillion dollars. More than the whole of the UK GDP.
It's a fantasy with current technology and the limits of thermodynamics. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Which is why a lot of places will also use batteries, that are now under $100 per kWh, with 8000 cycle lifetimes.
ObamaWellington
@ObamaWellington
I get why that sounds attractive and we probably will end up with some plants doing something like that... but on an industrial scale having to 3x the capacity of your energy intensive plant so it can avoid pricy power, plus large storage facilities will be costly and inefficient
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
No idea what high status beliefs are, or whether I hold them. I just crunch numbers: 17kWh 8000 cycle battery for £1100 is about 1p per kWh moved from night to day. deligreencs.com/products/free-shipping-battery-box-51-2v-…. Let's see who is right!
Mark Kingsley-Williams
@Mark_A_K_W
No, they’re not. You’re allowing your high status beliefs and desires to cloud judgement.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You are asking me to predict battery prices? That is hard. I think by 2030 for sure, and maybe next year. 16kWh batteries are now as low as $100/kWh, with 8000 cycles. So that is only a couple of cents per kWh stored. That looks pretty attractive to me already.
Steve Gravytrain
@GravyTrainBrit
Could you please suggest a date. Close is vague. Next year? 2030? 2050?
How does very varied allow industrial users to invest and plan?
Who decided we needed very varied electricity prices? Consumers and industry like certainty. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Batteries for domestic and industrial users are close to being economic now, so I expect rapid adoption and then electricity prices will be pretty constant 24/7, but very varied over the year (and perhaps at weekends)
Steve Gravytrain
@GravyTrainBrit
So the obvious question is in which year do you predict batteries for overnight storage will become cheap enough to transform baseload economics for 24/7 industrial users at scale?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Maybe you could do this somewhere sunny - one process during the day, one at night. But not one in summer and one in winter...
Andrea Matranga 🇺🇦🌻
@andreamatranga
One thing I wonder if new industrial processes will be developed which better take advantage of intermittent energy. E.g. if you're making glass, maybe it make sense to melt all the feedstock when energy is cheap into an insulated lake of fire and then cast bottles at leisure
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The price of day to night storage (as opposed to summer to winter) is falling really, really rapidly.
Andrew Montford
@aDissentient
Since solar plus storage is not cheap, a country that offered cheap electricity only during the day would only attract businesses that wanted to work single shifts.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
For the sorts of energy intensive bulk commodity manufacturing that is currently leaving the UK (See @EdConwaySky for details), energy costs are very, very important.
Xris Xeating
@chriskeating
Tim, how important actually is energy price to high value industry?
A lot of the discourse assumes energy prices are really really important. But I've never seen this really explored. I always thought energy grew less important the more value added in the chain -
Tim Leunig reposted
Chris Smith
@renewablesmiffy
China is producing solar power cheaper than Gas, Coal and Nuclear.
He’s absolutely spot on with his assessment as inconvenient as it is to some -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
When electricity is really, really cheap, a location is attractive to a lot of energy intensive industries.
Andrew Montford
@aDissentient
I'm don't think you are going to get high-temperature heat from solar.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
And at the right price I would happily have the UK govt sign a CfD with you to extract gas from the North Sea!
Copelama
@copeland_martin
It is insanity to say that CFDs are not subsidies - in part for the reasons that @7Kiwi and others make that there has only been one year when payments went the other way, but also for the obvious reason that it massively changes the risk metric - we would happily take a government guaranteed fixed gas price to develop more gas fields, but instead we take all the downside risk and then have a windfall tax imposed to take away the upside…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Really?? You think that UK nukes and gas powered electricity in the UK could be cheaper than solar in Very Sunny Countries? I don't see any evidence to support such a claim, much as I too wish it were true
Robert Boswall
@RobertBoswall
I wouldn’t say “whatever we do”, nuclear has structural advantages for industry with high capacity factors, small land usage, and the ability to produce direct process heat. We also have sufficient strengths that we could maintain comparative advantages in certain industries if we just unfettered gas. Solar has its weaknesses too.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, we use interconnectors a lot. Sometimes electricity is cheaper here than in France and vice versa, so we trade. We also buy gas from Norway via an interconnector (aka pipe)
Here&There
@here_there
Given the amount of installed GW wind and solar capacity we have why @timleunig do we use the interconnector so much?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sort of: hydro can't cover a prolonged period of high demand. Also, v limited potential - we could not cover 2 weeks of UK electricity demand from hydro.
Iwan Doherty
@IwanDoherty98
Hydro?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
It will depend on the cost of interconnectors - China has pretty awesome solar potential overall.
JN
@JonNeale
Does that also apply to areas of China, like Sichuan, that are cloudier than much of the UK?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is for CfDs as a whole. You would get different results if you look at each AR round separately.
Centre Right Liberty
@CtRLiberty
The only time CfDs have paid back to consumers was a brief period in 2022 during the Ukraine crisis. See on the LCCC site. CfDs are now paying out a record levels. That’s why every allocation round the govt publishes a ‘budget’ - which is the additional subsidy impact on bills
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Not really. A battery that is charged in summer and discharged in winter is never going to be economic.
Inveterate Economist
@econ_inclined
Depends on how good we get at batteries, surely?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I imagine the AR4 wind is paying out now, given how low that strike price was...
Here&There
@here_there
how many times have the wind operators paid back Tim?
The presence of intermittents (you should look that up as it’s not always sunny and winds) drives up the market price. It’s entirely circular
I think the operators have paid back once and that was peak Ukraine. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I wrote about this in @ObserverUK a couple of weeks ago. Given solar is structurally cheaper than wind, energy intensive industry will migrate to sunny countries, whatever we do.
Robert Boswall
@RobertBoswall
6b. Then by embedding these high prices, with decades of CfDs, Britain loses any competitiveness on the world stage just as other parts of the world are able to deploy solar at scale; because energy is everything.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Wind and solar also have to pay the government when electricity from gas is more expensive than the strike price. Contracts for difference are essentially an insurance context for both sides.
ObamaWellington
@ObamaWellington
Given wind & solar will get sky high strike prices for producing power when prices are 'close to zero' maybe we need to rethink the whole plan. Especially as growing %age renewables make it more & more expensive to keep other capacity for periods when wind & sun are unfavourable.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Apart from gas and coal, there is no energy source that responds well to fluctuating demand.
Steve Wotton 🔶
@stevewotton
I dont understand your conclusion. How can we base our energy needs on a source that cannot respond to demand? Particularly when demand is high in winter, and even when it can, it costs far too much to get it to where people live.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Contracts for Difference are an insurance contract. When energy prices are high, renewable owners pay the govt the difference between the market price and the strike price. When energy prices are low, the reverse happens. Worth reading up on the details of how they work.
Centre Right Liberty
@CtRLiberty
That doesn’t make sense. CfDs are subsidies which guarantee renewables a price above the market price - without this renewables wouldn’t be built. So have to pay more for intermittent renewables which force even higher system costs because of extra grid, backup and balancing
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Baseload is surely the last thing we need, given that much of the time either the sun is shining, or the wind is blowing, and prices will be close to zero for an increasing proportion of the time? (See Spain, as the leading example)
Andy Mayer
@mayerandrew
Sure, and both 1970s oil crises had a profound impact on investment in alternatives. They didn’t however mean forever higher prices.
Meanwhile we don’t need ‘back-up’ in a firm power grid, we need baseload. The rigid thinking that everything is there to service ever expanding renewables is surely the problem? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What does the new crisis in the Middle East mean for UK energy policy, particularly the North Sea? Me in @ObserverUK today
observer.co.uk/news/business/article/energy-security-rest… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is a different point! See my article in today's @ObserverUK observer.co.uk/news/business/article/energy-security-rest…
Gavin Rice
@gavinantonyrice
But the point is we will still need gas for a long time, & we are punishing gas production & generation with windfall taxes, CPS, ETS & VAT - when getting the price of gas power down is essential for cheaper electricity.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is surely what Ed M is saying? Today we are gripped, but the grip is being weakened via renewables and CfDs, and that this is a good thing??
Gavin Rice
@gavinantonyrice
Ed Miliband says we must escape the grip of global gas markets and become self-reliant via renewables.
But @ukonward's new report shows this is unrealistic - the grid still needs gas 97% of the time.
At the time I’m posting this, gas is producing 54% of power on the grid. 3/ -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Literally no - just read the @FT graph in my first retweet!
Freeborn John
@JohnMar93776625
Because they're already high.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
For sure, nothing is free in life, whether that is burning gas everyday, or having more gas or other back-up. But the higher and more volatile are gas prices, the more the case for wind stacks up (and vice versa)
Andy Mayer
@mayerandrew
But increasing the renewables share simply means grid expansion, balancing services, moving more gas from baseload to back-up, all at vast expense. If the trade-off was to nuclear or hydro, and cost competitive from deregulation, Miliband would have a point. The obsession with renewables targets at any cost is the problem.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I hope some of you will find good charities to leave money to...
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
We don’t talk enough about how Boomers and Gen Xers are leaving behind huge volumes of “stuff” for a decreasing group of heirs…. My son will inherit from at least three different households for example, as my brother is childless, I am divorced from his mother etc etc etc … love this library though h/t @wallaceme
Oliver
@oliverhamrin
Just learned about the beautiful personal library of a German mining engineer called Bruno Schröder.
His entire house was covered in custom shelves he built himself, housing his life’s work – a 70,000 book collection.
Bruno died in 2022 at 88, while in the midst of digitally cataloguing his massive collection. Sadly, he had no relatives and the house, including the books, was handed to an estate manager and put up for sale. That’s when his story and these photos surfaced. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Stian Westlake
@stianwestlake
Why I'm a sceptic of Citizens’ Assemblies
I was talking to the v clever @Sam__Enright recently, and made a passing remark about how I'm sceptical of claims that Citizens’ Assemblies are a great way of solving political problems. He asked me why. I thought I’d share my response.
Citizens’ Assemblies are hugely popular among people interested in politics. They're particularly popular both with “sensible” anti-populists and with environmentalists (climate assemblies are especially popular among the latter group).
Here are some reasons I don't like them.
1. Cognitive humility. I think a lot of love for citizens’ assemblies is predicated on the inability by the Citizens’ Assembly Advocate to countenance that voters may genuinely have different preferences to them. The mental model is something like “I believe X. Some foolish voters believe Y, because they are tricked by misinformation/Rupert Murdoch/Russian bots/their own lack of bandwidth. A citizens’ assembly would give them time to reflect on the true facts and conclude X, like me”. I struggle to think of any citizens’ assembly advocate who thinks citizens’ assemblies will reach conclusions they object to.
2. Gerrymandering. CAs seem ripe for gerrymandering. The usual CA model is that experts will provide some education on the subject before citizens deliberate and decide. The expert selection process seems like it'd be stitched up, perhaps not deliberately but by design. Example: consider a CA on how to prevent obesity and encourage healthy “food environments” (something I've heard suggested): it seems very likely to me that the experts would include lots of public health experts with strong ideological priors about the role of markets in providing food (such as the ‘commercial determinants of health’ worldview), who see food mainly as a health issue. But opponents of these positions might not be invited - for example because their funding comes from commercial sources. The choice architecture of the assembly itself is also ripe for coercive design. A transport policy friend told me about a UK CA on road building that found that citizens wanted fewer roads built (a surprising result); it turned out that they had been asked to choose between three options all of which involved less road building, and had picked one. (This problem is exacerbated by problem 1.)
3. Social desirability bias. More conceptually, I worry that CAs impose a bias to socially valorised solutions that overlook people’s selfish but legitimate motivations. Again, take the example of a CA on how to reduce obesity. Obesity is bad and socially costly (esp in systems with socialised medicine). But restrictions on unhealthy food impose a cost on individuals in terms of deliciousness and pleasure. I strongly suspect a civic discussion on obesity would focus on the societal costs and the “wise” view that we should constrain our choices in our long term interests, but underweight ideas like “chips taste yummy” which seem stupid and base - but which are legitimate desires that most people have. So CAs’ conclusions might reflect a kind of false “prosocial wisdom” that doesn't fully reflect people’s true preferences - resulting in policies that people don't actually want.
I’m not saying it’s impossible to design CAs that don’t involve these biases, or that they are not known to CA experts. Arguably, the higher profile the assembly, the harder it is to get away with them (which perhaps means that things like the Irish CA on abortion that was organised as part of the referendum on the subject avoided these problems - I'm don't know enough to say). But they seem pretty fundamental issues that aren’t discussed enough in the casual commentary on CAs that I find myself reading regularly. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The UK has some of the least volatile gas prices in Europe...
Jeremy Cliffe
@JeremyCliffe
Meanwhile, Spain's massive investment in renewables is paying dividends now: with prices for Spanish industry and consumers low and stable compared with other European economies.
www.ft.com/content/ac77915d-7542-4129-aabe-d3a9daff2573 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That is surely what Ed M is saying? Today we are gripped, but the grip is being weakened via renewables and CfDs, and that this is a good thing??
Gavin Rice
@gavinantonyrice
Ed Miliband says we must escape the grip of global gas markets and become self-reliant via renewables.
But @ukonward's new report shows this is unrealistic - the grid still needs gas 97% of the time.
At the time I’m posting this, gas is producing 54% of power on the grid. 3/ -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Under development as we speak - that is why driverless cars are currently driving around London, with drivers at the wheel just in case, and to monitor what the car thinks it should do, and whether that is sensible.
JN
@JonNeale
I’m still puzzled how they work on old streets with parked cars or narrow sections, where only one vehicle can pass either way and hand signals or eye contact are involved and it becomes a negotiation
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Really interesting: @jonathansimons new polling on student loans finds people who are paying back (aged 25-44) are much **less** likely to "be concerned" with the system than people not of the age to be paying back www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:743562137851… @nickhillman
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Self driving cars work fine in foggy wet San Francisco. I am sure they can cope with English weather...
L🇬🇧as Ohl
@lukas_ohl
Self-driving cars work well in dry sunny Arizona or California; it remains to be seen how well they’ll fare on a drizzly grey day in England.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is absolutely correct - when the Nazis won power they used radio extremely effectively to stoke up anti-semitism. www.jstor.org/stable/26372641 has the evidence base (and earlier the Weimar Republic had used radio to suppress Nazi support)
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
Also the radio.
Everyone thinks the radio is this cute old-fashioned harmless technology and it's literally implicated in two of the worst genocides of all time.
The amount of abuse video games get compared to the radio - but even Grand Theft Auto has never been weaponised by a dictator to advance mass murder. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Self-driving cars will revolutionise transport for younger people, since the cost of learning to drive is high (and it is hard), and the cost of insurance is high. It will also help the oldest, who are no longer confident drivers.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I think self driving cars and robot/drone delivery will be common by 2030 and dominate by 2035 if we let them. Which I guess we will. And with them huge employment will be gone. Taxi drivers, delivery drivers, soon enough truck and lorry drivers. And then much else.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
NEW ANALYSIS: UK emissions fell 2.4% in 2025 as coal fell to a 400-year low. Incredibly, we used less coal last year than than in 1600, when Queen Elizabeth I was on the throne and Shakespeare was writing Hamlet.
All the details in our article: www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-uk-emissions-fall-2-4-in-202… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
How to read this chart: the typical Belgian earns as much as the typical Californian but works about 24% less. Pretty smart move to calculate such data for the “bottom 95%” only. Worth exploring further.
Source: sethackerman.substack.com -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Absolutely delighted to announce that after 20 years, @WeAreOpenreach are cabled my road, and I have left @virginmedia, whose prices were shockingly high, and service at best erratic. (See @WhichUK for evidence). Hoping @VodafoneUK will be better all round.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Nothing is wrong with @hmtreasury in this case. Rather they realise the tax rate is killing an industry that with the crisis in the middle east is more important than ever. Backbenchers need to realise government is harder than populist slogans. Hope you told them so, @HugoGye !
Hugo Gye
@HugoGye
A Labour MP tells me: "This is absolutely insane. Politics of giving a tax cut to oil and gas while raising them on working people. What is wrong with HMT?"
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But if a lower rate increases North Sea output, that lower rate would increase revenue to HMT, allowing the government to give us all more money to cushion the effects of higher energy prices...
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
Energy producers are for many emblematic of businesses having broken the social contract. For a Government that urgently needs to reconnect with the public and show it gets their priorities this would be a real political error while the cost of living crisis continues.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
Come and work for me in beautiful Zurich! Hiring for pre-doc positions is open. Details here: Long hours, hard work, tough tasks guaranteed. jobs.uzh.ch/job-vacancies/predoctoral-fellowship-hans-joa…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Maybe they will sort the issue!
Iain Mansfield
@IGMansfield
I wonder how many MPs will try to decline the pay rise to avoid the loss of free childcare that kicks in at £100k.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Don't forget that the Norwegian wealth tax applies to people with £140k in housing wealth. Not heard many people recommending that in other countries at the moment.
Morten N. Støstad
@MortenStostad
Strange response. Wealth taxes are a sensible policy for a tax base with extreme wealth + low taxable incomes. How would you tax them otherwise, Jessica?
Also, Norway's wealth tax is collecting more and more revenue every year. How is that an unworkable gimmick? -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I love @lfg_uk but @nickhillman is right on this one.
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
Looking for Growth really should Google the dataset they’re claiming is secret. It’s widely used. It would be good if it were even more available but this is a conspiracy theory & one failing to get lift off, despite the videos… Perhaps they should focus on looking for growth.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
By which @PJTheEconomist means "this is not realistic, and will not happen"
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
OBR chart showing how chancellor's plans imply spending cuts in many departments in election year. Plans are also for big tax rises in 2028 and 2029.
I do wonder whether this is politically realistic... -
Tim Leunig reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Ask us anything about Works in Progress.
Aria Schrecker
@Aria_Babu
Here’s a sneak preview of the cover for Issue 23 of Works in Progress!
@bswud, @pietergaricano and I are doing an AMA on the magazine. Reply with questions and we’ll answer them on the podcast. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Simon is right. Green Party manifesto promised borrowing on a staggering scale. It was wholly unrealistic and would have been catastrophic if any attempt made to implement it. They have doubled down since. They must now become more realistic.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If you tax middle earners more, and spend more, the markets will be sanguine. It is deficits markets worry about. @PJTheEconomist
clive taylor
@clivetaylo65495
Paul please help me out….really genuine Q.
What could a radical party committed to giving people a much better chance of ‘a nice life’ do without upsetting the markets? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Jamie Martin
@jamieamartin1
There is a security concern with chinese students in the uk, but assuming that's well handled, Tim is 100% correct.
Attracting & *retaining* chinese talent needs to be a crucial goal of uk policy. Especially STEM talent.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Why is this mad? How would it help anyone if these Chinese students paid America to go to Harvard rather than paying the UK to go to Imperial. #loveeducationexports
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What about data for the Sheffield tram system? Much less used, I think? (Don't get me wrong, I support Leeds tram, but like honest data too)
LFG Leeds Chapter
@LFG_Leeds
Time for some data.
Manchester's Metrolink top tram stops are as busy as the busiest *RAILWAY STATIONS* in West Yorkshire.
No doubt about it whatsoever. Build it, and they will come.
What could we get in West Yorkshire?
Find out here: luma.com/buildthetram. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
The weird thing about the plan to put exams on-screen is that it's so far behind the technological curve.
5 years ago I could have seen the benefits.
But now, AI transcription is so good that you can keep handwritten exams & still get all the benefits of typed transcripts. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
To be fair to the @LibDems, this is a serious and decent policy statement reflecting some proper thinking from @IanSollom. Good to see. www.libdems.org.uk/news/article/our-plan-to-fix-the-stude…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Completely agree with @paullewismoney . The VAT therefore should be £20k (or lower) as in most countries. I would then have to register, but it is the right thing to do, ideally with VAT simplification at the same time.
Paul Lewis
@paullewismoney
I guess I’ve been fortunate that’s never affected me as I sell to big companies and they all pay me too but if I cut my turnover to avoid it they would not pay me more! It’s only become an issue since it rose to £90k. Something else to blame RR for! But the obvious solution is to set it at £20,000. Ours is highest in EU and surrounding countries.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Good to see water cremations being introduced in Scotland. Hope England follows suit - www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cd9gkknee0zo
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What should the UK do to make our system of Judicial Review work better? I outline my ideas on my substack today - timleunig.substack.com/p/what-to-do-about-judicial-review (£/free trial)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
No fiscal event tomorrow. Good. But problems haven’t gone away. Policy still to raise taxes and cut spending in election year. Won’t happen. Govt desperately needs a convincing economic narrative & growth policy.
Or populist nonsense will take hold.
www.thetimes.com/article/9138078a-58ff-4b8e-a334-5ffdc58c… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
'At this point, 'building housing reduces rent' is as close to a scientific law of the housing market as we’re likely to find' - @Noahpinion
-
Tim Leunig reposted
International and Monetary Economics Network
@int_mon_econ
This looks like a must-read!
"The Economics of Tariffs" by Ralph Ossa and Stephen J. Redding.
"A central insight from neoclassical economics is that international trade operates like an improvement in production technology. It generates mutual aggregate welfare gains for countries as a whole, but creates winners and losers within countries. Tariffs are a tax on this trading technology and distort the prices faced by domestic consumers and producers. Large countries can use tariffs to improve their terms of trade on world markets. But if all countries try to do so, they can end up with lower welfare than if they cooperated to liberalize trade. ...Empirical findings from the recent waves of U.S. tariffs suggest that most of the incidence of these tariffs has been borne by U.S. importers, wholesalers, retailers and consumers rather than by foreign exporters. These tariffs have led to a large-scale reorganization of U.S. supply chains away from China to third countries. Although this reorganization has substantially reduced China’s share of U.S. imports, the U.S. remains indirectly exposed to China through the imports of these third countries."
www.econ.uzh.ch/dam/jcr:8e21c947-b2ca-41ef-86b2-7f0bfd63f… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
In the past, forests around the world were cut down on a massive scale around the world — but this is no longer the case.
Deforestation continues in large parts of South America and Africa, while the forested area has expanded in Europe, North and Central America, and large parts of Asia. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
delighted that Katherine Braddick is returning to public service. www.ft.com/content/4d4d0923-fe4e-4ed6-ba64-2738e4377cf6
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Hughes
@SimonHughes
In 2004 I was Liberal Democrat London Mayor candidate - with a proposal to pedestrianise Oxford Street. It has taken 22 years for the Mayor to take on my plan. Better late than never. 👏
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is a nutty idea. Why would we want to give a bigger tax break to richer graduates? And to make the tax system even more complex?? Nuts!!! @DanNeidle @Simon_Nixon
Simon Nixon
@Simon_Nixon
Excellent and surely unarguable letter in @thetimes making the case for making student loan debt tax deductible. One only has to think about this for one minute to wonder why on earth this doesn’t happen already…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Doug Lemov
@Doug_Lemov
When you don’t understand how learning works, what feels intuitively right is often exactly and spectacularly wrong.
It’s tedious when an “influencer” makes that mistake. It’s quietly worse when educators do it. But they do it.
If you want to not be destructively wrong you can start with @hruizmartin’s spectacular How Do We Learn? Or @DTWillingham’s iconic Why Don’t Students Like School? Or follow @dylanwiliam who is always generous with explanations.
Jack
@Jackkk
MrBeast explains why the education system is completely broken
“Why are students today being taught the same way their parents were? Look at how much everything else has advanced. When I was in school the teacher would just stand there, read out of a book and write on a whiteboard”
"Now look at Mark Rober’s videos. You can learn complex topics in 20 minutes in a way that’s engaging, fun and you retain it. Just because our parents were taught one way doesn’t mean we need to keep teaching that same way. It makes no sense to me, I think education should be reformed dramatically”
“Students spend so much time in school. If we had real courses made through videos, made learning more hands on and optimised everything with modern technology, kids could probably learn more in 5 hours than they currently do in 8 hours" -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, exactly - back in the day when the W Mids was so successful the govt constrained it, to try to push prosperity further North
Tim Worstall
@worstall
Are those those limits on anyone being allowed to do anything in Brum or Coventry?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
When we looked at what happened when govt had strong regional controls in the 1960s, about 17% moved, and 83% lost (from memory, see work by Prof Peter Scott, Reading, in Floud and Johnson)
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
There is an interesting economics debate to be had here on the extent to which it makes the UK poorer and to which it makes London poorer. Clearly some constrained investment in London is just relocated to cities like Leeds and Manchester that will build. While some is lost.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Lack of hire quality office space in good locations in London is making UK poorer. Here is an idea - maybe we could build more? www.ft.com/content/9c493391-9ce0-4d6d-927b-9c2fc45a2c1f
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We should release MUCH MORE data from the LEO database - which I was instrumental in creating when in govt. It has much more data on (for example) long term income outcomes than is currently released. So yes, release the data to all bona fide researchers to use as they wish.
Dr Lawrence Newport
@lawrencenewport
Worth separating two things here. The screenshot is Graduate Outcomes (surveyed earnings 15 months after graduation), not the LEO measure.
LEO on Discover Uni is a longer-term tax-record earnings view (3 and 5 years after), and what’s public is a disclosure-controlled, partial slice (excludes self-employment, is an average for subject area not course specific)
I agree info alone won’t fix HE incentives, but the ‘release LEO’ argument is really about getting enough granularity to scrutinise outcomes properly, not pretending students currently have zero data. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Lovely pics from broadcaster Tom Scott on solar and wind in China - e360.yale.edu/digest/china-renewable-photo-essay (h/t @Psythor)
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
🚨Rare and exciting opportunity 🚨
We're looking to hire an exceptional economist to work on fiscal policy at the IFS. We don't do this often. It's a chance to shape, carry out and communicate research on some of the highest-profile topics in UK economic policy. [1/4] -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Agree. Similarly, I have just claimed expenses from a US corp. I had to download a W8-BEN, fill it in by hand, wet sign, scan, and attach to my claim. Apparently this approach complies with the US Paperwork Reduction Act, which suggests the Act is not effective.
John Fingleton
@JohnFingleton1
Why is @bankofireland so behind the times on digital? I needed to add my debit and credit card on a new apple watch. Verification requires (a) that I am phsyically in Ireland (b) that I make a phone call to a line that is only open 9-5 (c) that I read out the full credit card number to somebody who has heard three digits incorrectly on the first reading and (d) have a totally different security code to hand. No wonder everybody in Ireland uses Revolut.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Most post grad courses don't have fixed numbers.
Hilton Holloway
@hiltonholloway
Limited places on the courses? How many Brits rejected?
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Why is this mad? How would it help anyone if these Chinese students paid America to go to Harvard rather than paying the UK to go to Imperial. #loveeducationexports
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In which @PJTheEconomist shows he is in a particular mellow mood today - "Not every chancellor ever has been a total idiot." (His substantive point is correct of course, debts matter)
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Statement "govt is not like a household" is true.
But it does not follow that "debt is irrelevant". Govts are constrained. Not every chancellor ever has been a total idiot. If they could have done whatever they'd wanted they would have. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Why is this mad? How would it help anyone if these Chinese students paid America to go to Harvard rather than paying the UK to go to Imperial. #loveeducationexports
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Lack of hire quality office space in good locations in London is making UK poorer. Here is an idea - maybe we could build more? www.ft.com/content/9c493391-9ce0-4d6d-927b-9c2fc45a2c1f
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Max Dubler 🏳️🌈
@maxdubler
The Netherlands banned investor ownership of housing in 2022.
It did not reduce home prices.
New homeowners had higher incomes, were more often Dutch-born, moved shorter distances, and stayed longer than the renters they replaced.
I do not think this was an equitable outcome.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Elizabeth Warren
@SenWarren
Democrats dropped a bill TODAY to stop private equity's housing takeover. Let's get this done.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
ianVisits
@ianvisits
Pay as you go tube fares rise by around 6% on Sunday
But travelcard prices are fixed.
Tip: check your bank account for how much you spent on TfL last year, and see if a season ticket is now viable.
Annual season tickets also include 1/3 off national rail (etc) tickets. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Which is why my plan to expand Heathrow was better - much smaller expansion of the area affected by noise! policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/bigger-a…
John Stewart
@JohnJohnStewart
I know he's only using Heathrow as an example to make a wider point but he misses the key reason why a 3rd runway has not been built. EU figures show that 28% of all people impacted by aircraft noise in Europe live under the Heathrow flight paths.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
回
@3_under_scores_
We now have at least five independent academic research groups using different datasets and different methods coming to the same conclusion: Expanding market-rate housing supply helps low-income renters.
Peter Tulip
@peter_tulip
A common misunderstanding is that supplying expensive new housing does not help the poor.
No. Residents each move up a rung, freeing up housing at the bottom of the ladder.
The latest, of many, papers to show this uses great data from Switzerland. 1/3
frederickluser.github.io/files/Moving_Chains.pdf -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon French
@Frencheconomics
To uprate the state pension by 4.8% and freeze the student loan repayment threshold is one hell of a reveal of the political economy in the UK (and most other DMs).
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
I think it’s under-appreciated how much property prices in central London have fallen.
If we take inflation into account - which we should - this is a 30% fall in value.
London Money
@LondonMoneyFS
No one would have believed you if you told them back in 2013 that buying a £1m property in zone 2 would result in zero capital growth 13 years later
And yet here we are …. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Our World in Data
@OurWorldInData
Was the global decline of extreme poverty only due to China?
The share of the world population living in extreme poverty has never declined as rapidly as in the past three decades.
The decline in China was particularly fast, and given that one in six people in the world lives there, we’re often asked whether the decline in global poverty was only due to the decline in China.
The chart shows the data that answers this question. In blue, we see the global decline. In red, we see the decline if we exclude China from the data. In the world outside of China, 33% lived in extreme poverty in 1990; by 2025, this share was down to 12%.
The large economic growth that lifted 940 million Chinese people out of extreme poverty since 1990 was a major contributor to the global decline in poverty. But the non-Chinese world also achieved a very large reduction.
It is not true that the global decline in poverty was only due to China. Extreme poverty has declined in China and the rest of the world.
(This Data Insight was written by @MaxCRoser and @parriagadap.) -
Tim Leunig reposted
Richard Jones
@RichardALJones
Great piece from @thomasforth on the shrinking graduate premium in the UK. The UK's skills problem is not a problem of supply, it's one of demand; our regional economies are not complex & successful enough to absorb the number of graduates we produce.
tomforth.co.uk/graduatepremium/ -
Tim Leunig reposted
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
The great thing about a system like this is that less prestigious universities would be able to prove they taught maths as well as more prestigious ones. And people could copy what the best universities do, or try and improve on what they do, and learn from each other in a way that just isn't possible now.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
We had something very similar when I was an undergrad in Paris for a year. It eroded the privilege of the Elite institutions. The concours system did the same. So I completely understand why the elite Unis in the UK oppose it. But it would be better for actually learning maths.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
Notably, this is a non-London phenomenon!
We calculated this for each UK region and nation a few years ago, and you see these "demand curves" being traced w declining graduate wage premia as graduate share rises in every UK region EXCEPT London (@DanTurnerTweets @edballs)
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Astonishingly, @jburnmurdoch documents a big drop in the demand for graduates in the UK
-Lower relative quantities
-Lower relative price (wage premium).
In complete opposition to what has been happening everywhere else. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Peter Tulip
@peter_tulip
A common misunderstanding is that supplying expensive new housing does not help the poor.
No. Residents each move up a rung, freeing up housing at the bottom of the ladder.
The latest, of many, papers to show this uses great data from Switzerland. 1/3
frederickluser.github.io/files/Moving_Chains.pdf -
Tim Leunig reposted
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
Yet another dispiriting bit of one-sided reporting from the Guardian, which pitches this as a battle between beleaguered residents and rapacious developers desperate to build on common land—when what they’re actually trying to save is…a car park.
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/feb/20/tunbridge-wells-r… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
"Bradford's City Village Phase One given planning approval" > really pleased to see this. Will be a big risk, but if it works the impact could be huge. www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2r5gyng27o
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luzia 🔸
@_revoluzia_
If you happen to have lived/worked in Westminster for the last 12 months and make exactly between £80,430 and £90,000, then you can rent this nice apartment in Paddington below market rate.
Maybe we could just build some houses instead of coming up with random subsidies like this?
www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/172162709 -
Tim Leunig reposted
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
I’ve shown another lens on this same thing previously: the UK’s top income decile has had a very rough couple of decades (and the top half as a whole has done much worse than the bottom half).
Who works in top-paying jobs? Graduates. That’s the erosion of the premium right there -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A very good piece from @lugaricano
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
I simply want to Denmarkmaxx
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
They may well have all been living in one room, with a shared toilet? Housing is an income elastic good, so we would expect people in the past to have spent less on it relative to food than today. @joachim_voth
Europe Defender 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@oroborous
Fun graph I just found. In the 19th century, a Berlin working father could find housing for his family of five for just 14% of his income. However, he also had to spent another 44% on bread alone and 73% for food overall.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
Want to improve publishing in econ? Here is one simple step that will save countless hours. Reviewing for PNAS, this is what they ask (other science journals are similar): No essay on "how I would have written this", no absurd show-boating for the editor. A bunch of yes-no q
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
That said, we still see most US students choose to complete their university courses.
Mark Kingsley-Williams
@Mark_A_K_W
Recruitment in the UK is extremely small c conservative and risk averse, which is why they outsource assessment to Russell Group unis. Much of it is arse-covering for when a recruit falls short 'but they had a 2.1 from xyz'.
Silicon Valley is happy to hire from before or during undergrad, but that's for empirically testable skills. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well, no-one rushes to offer people a job when they get an offer from a university, so my guess is that employers reckon that you and I taught them useful things when we taught them stuff, @HaroldCarter
Harold Carter
@HaroldCarter
How far does the graduate premium reflect things people learn at university, and how far is it simply that graduates have already been preselected as able (since they have been admitted to specific universities)?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What I absolutely love about @thomasforth is that he imputes both good motives and sense to many people who disagree with him.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Extrapolating the history was precisely where we went wrong isn't it? Increases in graduate numbers had not previously led to an erosion of the graduate premium. Lots of good reasons (I just happen to disagree with them) to think that would continue, as it indeed did in the USA.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I was worried, but it was my best guess. And had I been in the US, that best guess would have proven correct - see @jburnmurdoch recent piece. I think there is a reasonable chance that if growth returns to the UK, demand for skills will pick up again, as per the US.
Douglas McWilliams
@DMcWilliams_UK
I hear what you say. But suspect an economist as good as you should have worried about extrapolating this history. If you expand the supply of most things it normally eventually reduces the price...
-
Tim Leunig reposted
John Stewart
@JohnJohnStewart
Good news! Eurostar to cut boarding times by 30 minutes. The changes will be rolled out with the remodelling of St Pancras as it prepares for the launch of services by SVirgin Trains and Trenitalia of Italy by the end of the decade. www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/02/16/eurostar-to-cut-b…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
Scotland benefits from free university tuition, free personal care services, and smaller class sizes than England. Why? Because the Scottish Government receives 26% more funding per resident than is spent in England on comparable services. The funding gap is now slowly shrinking.
Institute for Fiscal Studies
@TheIFS
NEW: The next Scottish Government will face tough choices as their funding advantage relative to England falls, making it harder to continue providing more generous services and benefits than England.
🧵 THREAD on @fiscalphillips & Martin Brogaard’s new Scottish election report: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Thinking of a career in think tanks?
On Wednesday, we're hosting a webinar for undergraduates or those with similar experience interested in working in the sector. We'll have speakers from numerous organisations sharing their insight and experience.
Register here 👉 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
As an economic historian, all I want is a spreadsheet that offers Pounds Shillings and Pence as a currency option!
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
the fact that MS is still in business tells you a lot about lock-in effects... there isn't a single piece of software that works even half as well as 10 years ago. MS Office? peaked in 2001. Windows? Windows 7. Etc.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes it was. Until recently the grad premium had remained constant as grad supply expanded. That is still true in London (which has most grads) and it is still true for STEM. @thomasforth www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/centers/mrcbg/fil…
Douglas McWilliams
@DMcWilliams_UK
Serious question. Was it reasonable to think that flooding the market with more graduates could be managed without affecting their relative price?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I love the way that this anonymous poster or bot thinks that @FT pays people to write letters! I wish!! Still, it is a free world, and they are not obliged to follow me...
Chłoddy
@OfSymbols
You’re embarrassing your field for a FT fee you utter buffoon.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, inflation at 4% for 20 years has that effect... (under Tory and Labour govts, it was not a party political thing) @worstall
Rob Wilson
@mrrjwilson
So all the savers who had war bonds effectively helped pay off the national debt by losing the real value of their savings?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Clark
@prospect_clark
True … and a reminder that the big decision taken after 1945 was to mostly maintain high wartime tax rates & redirect the proceeds to civilian purposes. Not a wild borrowing splurge
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My letter in today's FT, showing that serious reforming governments, like Labour 1945-51 ran big budget surpluses, contrary to claims from @unitetheunion leader @UniteSharon. No conflict between reform and fiscal probity.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
UK government debt fell rapidly under the Attlee government - from 248% of GDP to 174%. No government since has reduced debt by 12% of GDP per year in office. They deserve some credit for that, @afneil.
Andrew Neil
@afneil
The Attlee government inherited a post-war national debt of 250% GDP — biggest ever in UK history. So it was in no position to borrow recklessly
Even so in six years it ran only two budget surpluses — a big one in 1949, a small one in 1950.
It also pocketed almost $3bn in Marshall Aid, most of which it had spent by 1950 — on top of the almost $4bn it had previously borrowed from the US in 1946.
Other than all that it was the very embodiment of fiscal prudence.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My letter in today's FT, showing that serious reforming governments, like Labour 1945-51 ran big budget surpluses, contrary to claims from @unitetheunion leader @UniteSharon. No conflict between reform and fiscal probity.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is a fine thread from @thomasforth. I too thought that the grad wage premium would stay high when grad numbers increased, as it had done historically, and still does in the US. That was a reasonable thing to think. Sadly it has proven untrue outside London.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
It was pretty reasonable for The Treasury to assume that the graduate premium would stay up in the UK as we added more graduates. The graduate premium actually went up in the USA and all of its major cities. And in London. www.ft.com/content/570d23b3-d286-4cb9-a319-b49cc4056f52
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Increasing non-science grads outside London seems unlikely to generate good returns for those people or the nation (unless they move to London). I wish it were not so, but that is what the data say. Orig analysis from @annastansbury @DanTurnerTweets @edballs
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well, if you don't believe what I say, you could try googling it, rather just suggesting people should not trust me without any evidence on your part? FWIW @FT has proper fact checkers, and I sent them the link to my statement of historical fact contained in this letter.
Babatunde
@babs_aka_w
This guy is a Professor at the LSE. Bear that in mind when a policy-oriented academic asks you to take what they have to say as God-given truth, due to their expertise. Always remember, nothing happened to Rogoff; they have zero skin in the game.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My letter in today's FT, showing that serious reforming governments, like Labour 1945-51 ran big budget surpluses, contrary to claims from @unitetheunion leader @UniteSharon. No conflict between reform and fiscal probity.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Callum Anderson MP
@_CallumAnderson
Good letter … 👇🏽
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My letter in today's FT, showing that serious reforming governments, like Labour 1945-51 ran big budget surpluses, contrary to claims from @unitetheunion leader @UniteSharon. No conflict between reform and fiscal probity.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Thsi week my substack shows how we could run a lot more commuter trains - timleunig.substack.com/p/the-victorians-could-do-this-we-…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My letter in today's FT, showing that serious reforming governments, like Labour 1945-51 ran big budget surpluses, contrary to claims from @unitetheunion leader @UniteSharon. No conflict between reform and fiscal probity.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Archie Hall
@ArchieHall
Here's some British housing nightmare fuel
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Chris Gloninger, CCM, CBM
@ChrisGloninger
Lee, you hack, start/stop systems were invented by Toyota in 1974 and adopted by European automakers in the 2000s. They reduce fuel consumption by 5-8% and cut idle emissions by 100%. They restart in under 400 milliseconds… faster than your foot moves from brake to gas. Your car doesn't 'die.' The engine decouples from the drivetrain via a reinforced starter motor rated for 500,000+ cycles. This isn't Obama. It's thermodynamics. An engine burning fuel at zero mph does zero useful work. That's not politics. That's the first law. You're the EPA administrator and you don't understand combustion efficiency. Terrifying.
Lee Zeldin
@epaleezeldin
There will be no more climate participation trophies awarded to manufacturers who make Americans’ vehicles die at every red light and stop sign. It’s over. The Start/Stop Obama Switch is FINISHED!
Under President Trump’s leadership, manufacturers can build the vehicles Americans actually want, instead of the vehicles that politicians and bureaucrats in Washington demand. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
Cough: She’s attacking @MartinSLewis but she’s got two degrees and all she’s paid so far for her tuition and living costs is £685(!) and she admits taxpayers may end up paying back much of her debt. This isn’t the sob story it’s designed to be. www.telegraph.co.uk/money/consumer-affairs/martin-lewis-s…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
- Brexit
- Pension triple lock
- Huge wave of land and house rules stopped all building and infrastructure projects
- Huge debt and deficit build up
- No significant pro-growth reforms.
The astonishing economic record of the Tory government.
(Housing: @ft @jburnmurdoch today) -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In which Peter Hain says that the problems of unhappy graduates can be solved my making them pay about 3x as much per month, and for all of their life, rather than thirty years - observer.co.uk/news/opinion-and-ideas/article/a-graduate-…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Good to see @hmtreasury appoint @kingsbschool Professor Brian Bell, a serious economic heavyweight, as Government Chief Economic advisor.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Bradfield down under, Forest City near Cambridge - maybe the world is getting serious about building decent places to live, and making life more affordable along the way...
Clare Delmar
@ClareDelmar
a new city proposed down under @leannetritton @MPrinParr @shivmalik @isnit0 www.dezeen.com/2026/02/11/plans-unveiled-australias-first…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
Denmark is subject to the jurisdiction of the ECHR, yet the Danish Government delivers border security. So no
Reform UK
@reformparty_uk
Suella Braverman: The ECHR has totally crippled the government’s ability to deliver border security for the British people.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Robert Peston
@Peston
The tax lawyer, Dan Neidle, who exposed Mandelson’s emails to Epstein. New Rest is Money podcast
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-rest-is-money/id1703785…
@DanNeidle -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Paging @mhclg @SteveReedMP
Clash Report
@clashreport
Germany's Merz:
China builds the world’s largest solar farms within a few months.
In the EU, it takes years just for the project to get approved.
Therefore, I propose to implement a fundamental principle in most permitting processes: Any project that is not treated within a few weeks or months will be regarded approved automatically. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Aziz Sunderji
@AzizSunderji
As a new parent, I spend a lot of time changing diapers and feeding the baby. 15 months ago I wasn't doing any of this. I felt busy then too, so where did all this childcare time come from? I analyzed the Census Bureau's American Time Use Survey to find out how most parents do it. The answer: less sleep and less screen time. The funny thing is, parents report being pretty happy about this tradeoff.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Powlesland
@paulpowlesland
Its official: I’m appearing in City of London Magistrates tomorrow for the heinous ‘offence’ of cycling no-handed.
I guess in some ways it must be good news, as it means @CityPolice must have solved all the robberies, burglaries, fraud, assault, bike theft, dangerous driving and other serious offences. If not, I’m not sure how they could justify spending lots of taxpayers money, days of officer time, and a day of time in our horrendously backlogged courts, prosecuting something which does not appear illegal, which thousands of cyclists do without issue every day and which has not caused harm to anyone else or myself.
Wish me luck! I’ll report back.
Paul Powlesland
@paulpowlesland
I recently got stopped & ticketed by the City of London Police for, & I kid you not, “cycling no handed”. Even though it’s clearly not an offence, the officer said they were ticketing me under the Human Rights Act as I was infringing other people’s Article 2 ‘Right to Life’, in case I fell off & injured them: utterly bonkers stuff.
With bicycle theft basically legalised in the City due to the complete failure of the Police to bother investigating such thefts & people being regularly terrorised in London by e-bike phone muggers, it’s good to see the City of London Police concentrating the resources on what really matters.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
NEW ANALYSIS: China's CO2 has now been 'flat or falling' for 21 months
* Down in 2025
* Still below Mar 2024
* Clean energy wave a key factor
If this is China's peak (TBC) it's the climate story of the century so far…
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-chinas-co2-emissions-have-no… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
Every year, more Sub-Saharan Africans are living in extreme poverty.
GNI per capita hasn't budged in 30 years, yields are stagnating, while fertility remains high, and the ladder of labour-intensive growth has vanished.
A tragic graph from @MaxCRoser -
Tim Leunig reposted
Riccardo Trezzi
@RiccardoTrezzi
The incredible evolution of Italy’s prime-age population. Have you ever heard it discussed? The peak was in 2009. The effects of the subsequent collapse (despite positive net migration) are often confused with Euro entry or the GFC. In just 15 years, we’re back to 1960 levels. How could the Italian economy have grown?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Iwan Doherty
@IwanDoherty98
The Green Party needs to start throwing out members who are actively against carbon free electricity
These sorts of activists are poisonous to the environmental movement
Joseph Wells
@JosephW56436640
The fight against Pylons continues.
National Grid still argues that Pylons are the cheapest alternative, but that is not true!
As @RosieP4 explains on Politics East, these Pylons are bad, and National Grid has ignored every better alternative we put to them! -
Tim Leunig reposted
Helena Horton
@horton_official
Looking at this, seems someone bought a home in 2024 next to a 150-year-old pub in Islington and has now forced it to spend £££ and time having to defend its licence. Should not be allowed. If you buy next to a pub you should expect noise !
democracy.islington.gov.uk/documents/b17050/Second Despat… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
When the telephone was invented, 99% of the country had no use for it. The technology was patented in 1876. Three years later, there were basically no telephones in existence. Thirty years later, there were basically no telephones. Household adoption of telephones didn't pass 50% until the 1940s.
AI is 3 years old. A majority of Americans say they use it every week. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
We don't accept funding or donations of any kind, so we can remain completely independent.
But if you want to support our work, please consider donating to TaxAid, a brilliant charity which provides free tax advice for people in need:
taxaid.org.uk -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Do you think that is why the prices were higher than we would have liked? Supply curves typically slope upwards, more demand means higher prices?
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
NEW: UK's "AR7" renewable auction was the biggest ever – more than 50% larger than 2024's record
AR7 = enough electricity to offset 3/4 of UK LNG imports
Labour's AR6+AR7, combined, contracted more GW than all other rounds put together
More: www.carbonbrief.org/qa-new-uk-onshore-wind-and-solar-is-5… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dr Ioannes Chountis de Fabbri
@ChountisFabbri
Born today in 1894. At the Somme, the young Harold Macmillan was shot in the pelvis & left hand & lay in a shell hole for hours waiting for rescue. He passed the time reading Aeschylus’s Prometheus Bound in the original Greek, from a copy he kept in his tunic pocket. A lost world
-
Tim Leunig reposted
George Greenwood
@GeorgeGreenwood
What Sarah Sackman said at the dispatch box today is simply wrong.
It is not physically possible for journalists to attend every single court and to obtain the kind of information that Courtsdesk provided in searchable form.
This shuts out the press and undermines open justice.
George Greenwood
@GeorgeGreenwood
The Ministry of Justice has ordered the deletion of the UK’s largest court reporting archive.
This risks undermining open justice, and I believe, undermines the public accountability role of the press by worsening transparency in the courts.
www.thetimes.com/uk/law/article/moj-orders-deletion-of-uk… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
CONSULTATION NATION ALERT:
The best way to lower bills is to create more electricity. We actually have loads off the North Norfolk coast but it can’t get onshore until we build pylons. That’s what the Norwich to Tilbury scheme is meant to solve. 3 consultations already. Thousands of conversations with stakeholders. But that isn’t enough. Now we need another SIX months of full consultation. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
You are lucky in Tonbridge. Much slower to Medway where I grew up!
ObamaWellington
@ObamaWellington
hmm, Charing Cross to Tonbridge is a similar distance as the crow flies and takes 46 (42 later on) minutes on the fast services, 6x per hour. Difference being that's a station serving ~50k people rather than Sheffield, the main station in a regional capital many times that size.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Mainly it is trying to run stopping trains and fast trains frequently on one track each way. Same on many Northern lines.
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
Presumably to be that slow the track must be speed-restricted by curves.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
George Yarrow
@george_yarrow
Interesting WhatsApp exchange between Streeting and Mandelson.
WS: "No growth strategy at all."
Very true, but then no-one in Westminster/Whitehall has yet formulated a credible growth strategy.
PM: "The government doesn't have an economic philosophy which is then followed through in a programme of policies."
Ditto, and see my pinned post on the best available starting point.
What I find most interesting is the use of language: 'strategy', 'philosophy', 'programme' -- not 'plan' (ubiquitous) or 'I know how to *run* the economy' (Reeves). For all their individual failings, these guys are at least speaking in the language of governance, not (ubiquitous) managerial English.
As @SteveDavies365 keeps saying, Britain is unmanageable, but not ungovernable. Sadly, not many get the fundamental significance of the distinction here. Even more sadly, there is a dearth of thought-leadership in Westminster/Whitehall.
It is to big an ask of individual voters to expect them to fill the gap, but I have sufficient faith in their capacity for judgment to recognise and respond to thought-leadership, if it were ever to be put in front of them (which is admittedly a big 'if' in current circumstances). -
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Dnes
@MichaelDnes1
Strong agree - the civil service I left was one where everyone was forced to be on the office, then Teamsed the person two desks over (so they could also accommodate the team members in Leeds/Birmingham)
Felt like self-sabotage, not management -
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Hill
@Michael_J_Hil
This all depends on the office. Civil service office working was so bad for my productivity. Tuesday-Thursday there were not enough desks. If I got a desk it was not with my team. No meeting rooms, so hundreds of people in a room, half of them on calls.
Nigel Farage
@Nigel_Farage
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again.
People are not more productive working from home.
It’s all a load of nonsense. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Reeve - 🇬🇧/acc
@isnit0
If the French can do it, we sure as hell can.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Lots of slow trains in the South as well. Try pretty much any train out of Charing Cross...
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
29 miles travelled in just 47 minutes. Wow, an incredible 35 mph! Who knew inter-city trains could move that fast?!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Andrés Rodríguez-Pose
@rodriguez_pose
Six years of the "metromayor" has yielded a thin harvest.
Sweeney in @USJ_online suggests no growth premium—only a local version of the rich getting richer. The fruit of the unfunded mandate: high expectations, hollowed-out pockets doi.org/10.1177/00420980251408416Rodríguez-Pose
doi.org/10.1177/00323217221136666 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Have you ever thought about buying #gold? I tell the story of what happened when I bought gold, and why it was my best ever investment - observer.co.uk/news/national/article/history-predicts-a-f…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Outstanding and correct from @whippletom in @thetimes today, on measles and polio vaccines. www.thetimes.com/article/9399bfae-2d2e-4ccd-aa28-bf17218a…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Civic Future
@civic_future
Today we launch the Civic Future talent programmes to find exceptional people who can break Britain out of stagnation.
Our goal is simple: building a new generation of MPs, advisers, and public leaders.
Apply below.👇 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with @ojblanchard1 about bitcoin, and have written about the behaviour of gold prices in a similar vein for the London Observer - observer.co.uk/news/national/article/history-predicts-a-f…
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
On Bitcoin, and what happened yesterday.
Some assets have a fundamental value, for example future dividends for stocks. Most investors buy them based on their assessment of fundamentals.
Some assets have no fundamental value, or at most a fuzzy one, for example Bitcoin. Most investors buy them on their hope of capital gains.
These investors are much more likely than stock investors to extrapolate past gains, move in herds, leading to extreme volatility. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I have written a column for @ObserverUK on the history of gold as an investment, and why its should now be seen as a risky, not a safe, investment. observer.co.uk/news/national/article/history-predicts-a-f…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
And the early history of Global Counsel can't be separated from Jeffrey Epstein. Jim Pickard and the FT have the story: www.ft.com/content/13d2f9e4-2d8e-49e6-a42f-35febcdc5d1f
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
Hackney Council voted 5:2 last night against the planning dept's recommendation to reject the Shoreditch Works densification scheme. But in a rather baffling twist, the chair said they could not actually accept the scheme, so the decision has been deferred. Some thoughts:
1. Hackney has a lot of great councillors. The committee was extremely conscientious, battling through mountains of technical detail in a meeting that ran non-stop from 6:30pm to midnight. Crucially, they kept sight of the big picture – the fact that, whatever view one may take on certain fine details, this is basically a brilliant and even world-leading scheme.
2. The planning officers seemed like intelligent and decent people, but they had become very wound up over relatively minor details. Most of their attention was absorbed by a tortuous debate about the fact that the developer was only offering a discount to council-favoured businesses on 7 percent of the floorspace, rather than 10 percent as the council prefers. Whatever you may think about this question (and personally I am sceptical about the idea of 'affordable workspace' generally), it seemed like an insane reason to reject the whole development.
3. I was left with renewed unease about the Govt's plans to delegate more decisions to officers rather than councillors. Sometimes councillors have more perspective than officers, and can thus bring some common sense to decision-making. I know councillors can be a bit daft too, but the choice between the two doesn't seem straightforward to me.
4. Time is now very short. Hackney has elections in May and will enter purdah in March. Labour is likely to take heavy losses in the local elections and the council may fall to the Greens. I hope I am wrong, but I suspect the Greens will be hostile to the scheme. There is a pro-building majority on the planning committee at the moment, but they have only seven weeks to get this application back in front of them, and a chair who is determined to block it. The portcullis is falling. The silver lining, however, is that GLA may intervene to approve the scheme. The events of last night surely made that more likely.
5. Is it normal for the chair to be openly hostile to the applicant, and openly biased against them? I haven't seen it before, but maybe I have been lucky in my planning committees. I was very surprised when the chair refused to let the (pro-development) ward councillor for Shoreditch speak, despite its being reqested by another member of the committee. Surely it is natural for the elected representative of the affected area to have a voice?
6. The evening was interesting for those, like me, who are interested in the underlying political economy of land-use restrictions. In general, development control exists to prevent disruption to local people. But southern Shoreditch has hardly any local residents and the local office workers (such as me) are sympathetic or indifferent to the scheme. The council received only 3 letters of opposition, less than the average suburban conservatory extension! Pretty much nobody is opposed to this massive development on account of its having negative effects on them, because it doesn't have any negative effects on anyone.
What we see here, then, is an institutional infrastructure ultimately generated by NIMBYism, continuing to operate even when NIMBYism is absent. I suspect there are many such cases. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Peter Mandelson is telling the truth on one thing: the idea he was bought for a $4k “bursary” or a $75k gift is ridiculous
The real incentive was a post-government payday - one so big he *rejected* a $3–5m-a-year offer
And Epstein enabled that payday
Here’s the evidence. 🧵 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
I have learned a lot about why our Western democracies cannot get anything done through this vignette of the approval process for a building in Hackney Council (I RT yesterday the entire debate thread). The rules and regulations are piled on in absurd ways, so that those with personal agendas (the Council Chair here) can use lots of procedural tricks to derail the whole thing. As @mattyglesias says the "groups" hijack the process to the detriment of the citizens. It is hard to imagine any actual citizen of the ward caring about the arcane objections being raised.
If the Labour government @Keir_Starmer really wants to get the UK unstuck, they will have to tackle these insane rules and processes, even if some local member parties get upset. (A similar thing is true at the European Union).
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
Hackney Council voted 5:2 last night against the planning dept's recommendation to reject the Shoreditch Works densification scheme. But in a rather baffling twist, the chair said they could not actually accept the scheme, so the decision has been deferred. Some thoughts:
1. Hackney has a lot of great councillors. The committee was extremely conscientious, battling through mountains of technical detail in a meeting that ran non-stop from 6:30pm to midnight. Crucially, they kept sight of the big picture – the fact that, whatever view one may take on certain fine details, this is basically a brilliant and even world-leading scheme.
2. The planning officers seemed like intelligent and decent people, but they had become very wound up over relatively minor details. Most of their attention was absorbed by a tortuous debate about the fact that the developer was only offering a discount to council-favoured businesses on 7 percent of the floorspace, rather than 10 percent as the council prefers. Whatever you may think about this question (and personally I am sceptical about the idea of 'affordable workspace' generally), it seemed like an insane reason to reject the whole development.
3. I was left with renewed unease about the Govt's plans to delegate more decisions to officers rather than councillors. Sometimes councillors have more perspective than officers, and can thus bring some common sense to decision-making. I know councillors can be a bit daft too, but the choice between the two doesn't seem straightforward to me.
4. Time is now very short. Hackney has elections in May and will enter purdah in March. Labour is likely to take heavy losses in the local elections and the council may fall to the Greens. I hope I am wrong, but I suspect the Greens will be hostile to the scheme. There is a pro-building majority on the planning committee at the moment, but they have only seven weeks to get this application back in front of them, and a chair who is determined to block it. The portcullis is falling. The silver lining, however, is that GLA may intervene to approve the scheme. The events of last night surely made that more likely.
5. Is it normal for the chair to be openly hostile to the applicant, and openly biased against them? I haven't seen it before, but maybe I have been lucky in my planning committees. I was very surprised when the chair refused to let the (pro-development) ward councillor for Shoreditch speak, despite its being reqested by another member of the committee. Surely it is natural for the elected representative of the affected area to have a voice?
6. The evening was interesting for those, like me, who are interested in the underlying political economy of land-use restrictions. In general, development control exists to prevent disruption to local people. But southern Shoreditch has hardly any local residents and the local office workers (such as me) are sympathetic or indifferent to the scheme. The council received only 3 letters of opposition, less than the average suburban conservatory extension! Pretty much nobody is opposed to this massive development on account of its having negative effects on them, because it doesn't have any negative effects on anyone.
What we see here, then, is an institutional infrastructure ultimately generated by NIMBYism, continuing to operate even when NIMBYism is absent. I suspect there are many such cases. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I'd missed this. There's weight loss tablets (absolutely not for weight loss probably officially) that actually work now in the USA. www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/dec/22/us-regulators-app…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In government I often asked people why we needed more civil servants than the Netherlands to do policy thinking. (And why we needed more ministers)
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I once asked a few people why the Bank of England had 5000 staff while the Bank of Sweden has 500 and,... never really got a good answer. I was convinced of the need for 2x eventually, but could never buy the reasons given for 10x.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Imagine voluntarily doing this to your own country
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Valid questions from @daisychristo
Daisy Christodoulou
@daisychristo
Pondering the FT article on China's "genius plan".
In the UK, why do we have such different attitudes to selection and competition in sports and academics?
If you suggested something like the genius plan in the UK, everyone would be up in arms: too much pressure, too intense, kids need to be well rounded, it will backfire as they will all drop out when they are 20, it will stifle creativity, etc.
But people are mostly fine with equivalent types of early elite selection & prep for sports.
Why is this? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Mandelson leaked No 10 documents to Epstein - who then helped him pursue a $4m job
The latest: taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/02/02/mandelson-epstein-no10-docume… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
WASPI women never had a case. Language of outrage around decision devalues where real outrage appropriate.
MPs in opposition or on backbenches have been cynical in offering support for billions of compensation that was never going to be paid.
www.thetimes.com/article/74a2a0f7-af35-463f-9a04-17429b03… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is the best column Rishi Sunak has written so far. It is well worth reading
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Striking candour here from Rishi Sunak in his Sunday Times column.
He says he moved his focus from 'growth' to 'living costs' - and that Starmer is repeating his mistake. times-comment.com/rs2 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I just don't think @ProfDanielMuijs has invested in crypto or has bought a left-hand drive Ford F-150 for his commute to @QUBelfast... I think it is more likely that someone has hacked his account...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If it is revenue neutral, it will not alter inflation. But it would simplify the tax system and reduce hassles to businesses (particularly small businesses) as well as removing VAT-induced distortions. That will help the economy grow and make us better off.
realhansard
@realhansard
That would be inflationary since 12% would then be charged on groceries.
It would also increase energy bills.
It’s a political non-starter. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
NEW: Previously unreported Epstein emails show Peter Mandelson discussing a Panama-linked tax avoidance structure for a £750k Rio apartment - with Epstein as his "chief life adviser".
Exclusive Tax Policy Associates report: -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Mandatory reading worksinprogress.co/issue/the-housing-theory-of-everything/
Harris Rothaermel
@DeveloperHarris
almost every major problem today is ultimately downstream of housing affordability and availability
housing theory of everything -
Tim Leunig reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
90,000 properties in England/Wales are owned by offshore companies. Almost half unlawfully hide their true ownership
We've found them, mapped them, and published everything
▶️ This 60-second video shows how to find secretly owned property near you
📊 Details & stats below -
Tim Leunig reposted
Julian Jessop
@julianHjessop
Seeing as we're doing "if only Gordon Brown hadn't sold the gold" again... 😉
Brown’s decision made sense at the time because gold, which acounted for around half of the UK's official reserves, had performed poorly as an investment for many years.
The launch of the euro in 1999 also provided an opportunity to diversify the UK’s reserves into a new currency which was widely expected to rival the US dollar.
Moreover, the proceeds from the gold sales were reinvested in assets that paid interest, generating some additional income.
Nor was the UK alone. Many other governments and central banks were also selling gold at the time, for similar reasons. Indeed, there was a Central Bank Gold Agreement (CBGA) to coordinate sales and prevent the gold price from crashing further.
Of course, hindsight is a wonderful thing. But I wonder how many of those criticising Brown now would have been first in line to buy the gold back then and still be holding today...? 🤔 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Samuel Watling
@watling_samuel
"Planning reform alone won’t solve the housing crisis."
Yes it will. In any sane world this statement would be automatically disqualifying for any housing secretary. Britain is cooked.
Matthew Pennycook MP
@mtpennycook
Planning reform alone won’t solve the housing crisis.
To ramp up housing supply, we also need to diversify the housing market, transform the housebuilding industry and use the full power of the state to drive development outcomes 👇🏻
www.ft.com/content/9daeece5-0d17-40ae-82b6-e2b2d81fd189 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Frances 'Cassandra' Coppola
@Frances_Coppola
I'm a WASPI woman (extended cohort). I agree with the government's decision not to pay compensation. It must be final.
Had the WASPI campaign aimed to secure hardship relief for women in genuine financial difficulty because of state pension rises, I would have supported it. But it was never about that. It was always about securing state pensions for comfortably off middle-class women that they were not entitled to and did not deserve. For that reason, I opposed it from the start.
All 1950s born women now have their state pensions, and by 6th April this year, all of the extended cohort added in the Back to 60 legal action will too. So there is no longer any need for hardship relief for WASPI women affected by state pension age rises. There is now no reasonable purpose for the campaign.
The WASPI Campaign rejected the PHSO's recommended compensation the moment it was issued, substituting instead a far more expensive scheme of their own which bore no relationship to the criteria established by the PHSO. Clearly, they would never have accepted simple payment of the PHSO's compensation. I have no doubt this was a factor in the Government's decision to pay nothing.
Had the Government paid the PHSO's recommended compensation, I would have given it to a charity working with young people, who need that money far more than I do.
This dishonest campaign must end. It is time to tell the well-off entitled women who lead and support the WASPI Campaign that the party is over.
Jon Trickett MP
@jon_trickett
I've just spoken in the House of Commons to put on record that I think the government has got it badly wrong on the WASPI issue.
If they think their announcement puts the issue to bed they are mistaken. The fight goes on. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Kelvin MacKenzie
@kelvmackenzie
I’m puzzled. Why did bus driver Mark Hehir receive the sack rather than a bonus for being a hero?
Hehir was driving his 206 in North London when he spotted a male passenger ripping a necklace from a woman passenger and then escaping from the bus.
Like a true hero he jumped out of his cab, ran down the road, tackled the thief who handed the necklace back.
He returned to the bus only to see the thief return to the vicinity of the bus. Hehir approached the robber who threw a punch at him. Hehir promptly knocked him out and then kept his trapped on the pavement until the law arrived.
Both men were arrested but police correctly decided to take no action against Hehir.
But the bus company didn’t view Hehir as a hero.
They said he shouldn’t have left the bus running or the passengers and nor should he have kept the thief trapped on the pavement for that 30 mins.
So they fired him without a payoff. Hehir went to an employment tribunal where he said the public viewed him as a hero.
Correct.
Unbelievably the tribunal sided with the bus company and said his sacking was correct.
So bus drivers mustn’t do the right thing. Just let thieves get away with it. I must be missing something.
And -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ed Davey
@EdwardJDavey
Kemi Badenoch says she doesn’t want centrists in her party.
Instead of focusing on what people actually want, like an NHS that works, she’s choosing to imitate Farage.
If you’re sick of the name calling and just want things fixed, join the Liberal Democrats. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Jason Crawford
@jasoncrawford
Child steps into the street from behind an SUV, directly into the path of a Waymo going at 17mph.
Waymo immediately brakes hard, but hits the child at 6mph. Child sustains minor injuries.
Waymo calls 911 and remains on the scene until police arrive. Waymo employees also call NHTSA to report the same day.
Waymo estimates that a human, even if not distracted, would have hit the child at 14mph:
waymo.com/blog/2026/01/a-commitment-to-transparency-and-r… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
“Out of 1,981 parliamentary candidates nationwide, about 76 are women,
30 registered political parties have submitted nomination lists without a single woman among them”
Sushmita Preetha on Bangladesh’s all-boys clubs www.bssnews.net/national-parlament-election-2026/353897 ht @nomhossain -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with @thomasforth (again) and stand by what I wrote in @ObserverUK about why I expect manufacturing to continue to leave the UK. But interesting to hear other views, as ever.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I agree that the "more or less" is doing far too much work. At the moment, except for industrial electricity users who can switch on and off quickly, it's fracking that's got Texas electricity costs low. But for future investments, I think it'll be solar, and we can't compete.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
"Heavy industry will follow cheap energy away from this grey isle, but we can still excel in the service sector" > good stuff from @timleunig that is drawing the expected outrage, though I have not yet read much of an alternative plan. observer.co.uk/news/business/article/britain-cant-rely-on…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Maybe we disagree about the cause of Texas having cheap energy, but do we agree that industry will be attracted by low energy costs? That is the point I was making. @thomasforth @AndrewSabisky
Andrew Sabisky
@AndrewSabisky
This is just ludicrously wrong. Electricity is cheaper in Texas b/c gas is way way cheaper because of fracking. Plus different policy choices e.g in ERCOT curtailment risk goes on generation not billpayers, no RO or CFDs etc.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
Really good point here. It's very difficult to understand China's economic model without grasping the colossal role of land and housing
Gerard DiPippo
@gdp1985
China’s “consumption problem” is often misunderstood, and the property sector is the missing link. It’s true, in accounting terms, that household consumption is low as a share of China’s GDP. But a common mistake is to equate “high household savings” with idle money sitting in a bank account. That’s not how China’s national accounts work.
Looking at China’s Flow of Funds data, it’s clear that household savings are not just financial savings. For much of the past two decades, savings were overwhelmingly allocated to “gross capital formation,” primarily purchases of new housing and related investment. From 2012–21, household capital formation (property) accounted for about 64% of household savings on average. Those “savings” were generating domestic demand through construction activity, upstream industrial demand, employment, and local government revenues. High savings do not necessarily mean weak demand.
That changed after China’s property downturn. As new home purchases collapsed, households shifted savings away from housing investment toward net financial assets (first bank deposits and, more recently, equities). That portfolio shift may be rational for households, but it does not directly create real economic activity in the way housing investment once did.
This helps explain why China’s domestic demand challenge is harder than it sounds. It’s not just about getting households to consume more or save less. It’s about how to replace a massive housing-investment demand engine. Households can only buy so many new goods, absent the need to stock new homes.
One consequence is that household consumption growth is tilting toward services. I estimate that services accounted for roughly 60% of nominal consumption growth in 2023–25. That supports incomes and employment, but it generates relatively less demand for manufactured goods.
Thus, one key tension with the upcoming 15th Five-Year Plan is its top goal of “building a modern industrial system.” From a demand perspective, the old engine is gone, and the new one looks very different.
Bottom line: when thinking about China’s “consumption problem,” think about the property sector and how to fill that giant hole in domestic demand. It’s not obvious how Beijing does that quickly. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
Big moment for Europe: in December, fully electric cars outsold petrol-only cars in the EU for the first time.
This shows that clear, consistent policy works. Which is exactly why backtracking now would be a mistake. -
Tim Leunig reposted
JamesFennell MBE
@FennellJW
If its to do with an EU directive, then why can Spain, France and Germany build high speed railways so much cheaper and faster than we do? NIMBYism, especially in the South East, is the main factor.
Tom Harwood
@tomhfh
£130 million has been spent on the world's most pointless tunnel.
🇪🇺All thanks to the EU Habitats Directive, which we maddeningly transposed into British law after Brexit.
🦇This is all just to - maybe - protect 300 bats. And make HS2 the most expensive railway in the world. -
Tim Leunig reposted
James O'Malley
@Psythor
New YIMBY Pod!
🦁 NIMBYs vs Bristol Zoo
📋 How @darrenpjones wants to fix a broken civil service
⚡️ And we speak to @timleunig about how we could conceivably build an electricity cable from Texas to the UK! (Among many other things!)
www.abundancepod.com/p/nimbys-vs-bristol-zoo -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
LSE Prof Christine Whitehead found the reverse. More houses being built in your area did not affect local prices relative to houses further away. The effect was dissipated over a wide area.
Russell Curtis
@russellcurtis
Yes…that’s kind of…the point?
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Joe Reeve - 🇬🇧/acc
@isnit0
Wild to think that we only launched ForestCity 3 months ago (to the day)!
So much has happened since then - it really seems like this city is going to happen.
From over 40 experts offering their time pro-bono on feasibility studies, an all-star board, features in almost all national papers, and more we can’t share publicly yet.
Thanks to all who’ve been on the journey with us so far, I can’t wait to share more updates very very soon.
LFG
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
Okay we’ve announced it. We’re building a city. The first major city in the UK for fifty years. And we want the Labour government to back it. We’ve already got amazing prominent supporters. But we need everyone to sign the pledge first to prove real demand. Sign it and read more in the link below!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
John Stewart
@JohnJohnStewart
What you forget in your thread is that the people of Tower Hamlets voted for an ASPIRE Party which had as a prominent part of its manifesto the removal of LTNs. You set out to forestall that democratic vote.
Save Our Safer Streets - Tower Hamlets
@SaveBGstreets
Seeing some confusion about the Court of Appeal decision. 🧵
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
Starmer should tell Burnham that on the NEC he'll back him 100% being G&D candidate, and indeed is so keen on him standing he insists on coming up and campaigning for Burnham all day and every day. Starmer would thereby also answer critics who say he spends too much time abroad!
Rt Hon Nigel Evans
@nigelmp
Love it Michael
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Surely this is a rebuilding, for which no planning permission would be needed? We rebuilt York Minster and Windsor Castle. We have enough real problems without inventing fake ones, @policy_uk
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
Would have taken the British State 15 years just to agree the planning permission
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Carl Hendrick
@C_Hendrick
The reason teachers are tired of seeing it is not because it's a "hoary old maxim", but because it's complete bullshit.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jan/22/back-to-sch… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Helen Miller
@HelenMiller_IFS
📢Exciting (& v. rare) opportunity to join us @theIFS to work on the Public Finances
We'd love to hear from excellent economists who want to play a central role in our high-profile analysis of & reaction to fiscal policy
app.beapplied.com/apply/4t6eys2lxt -
Tim Leunig reposted
Andrew Neil
@afneil
Not sure if the typically myopic US media has quite clocked what an angry shitstorm President Trump has stirred up abroad with his callous, ungrateful, inaccurate gibe about America’s NATO allies staying away from the Afghan frontline.
He’s managed to unite pretty much everybody against him, even his hitherto supporters on the populist right. Even Keir Starmer! -
Tim Leunig reposted
JN
@JonNeale
The West Midlands, population circa 6 million, produced Shakespeare, Darwin, George Eliot, Tolkien, Elgar and Larkin, but no one thinks its inhabitants are uniquely gifted; in fact quite the opposite
sam buntz
@SamBuntz
It’s interesting that Ireland, a country that now has a population the same size as that of South Carolina, roughly 5.4 million, produced the most important modern poet (Yeats), novelist (Joyce), and dramatists (Wilde/Shaw/Beckett) in English.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
Urban female labour force participation is an excellent indicator of the permissibility of women in the public sphere.
By this metric, Bangladesh has seen a decline (down from 33% in 2013 to 24% in 2024), while India has improved (now 25%)
cc. @arpitrage
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
Everyone at Davos is focusing on AI, mostly with regards to productivity in high income countries,
Left unsaid is labour displacement in countries like Bangladesh.
Urban female employment has fallen from 33% in 2013 to 23% in 2024 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
I hope the European Parliament will spare us any talk of geopolitical Europe and finding alternatives to US power after the catastrophic vote to kill Mercosur.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Nick Hillman
@nickhillman
Instead of having two interviewees saying the same thing compèred by a sympathetic interviewer, it would’ve been much better to have had an economics expert like Nick Barr or someone from @LE_Education, @TheIFS or @resfoundation to explain how loans really work and the trade offs
BBC Radio 4 Today
@BBCr4today
Some graduates on so-called 'Plan 2' student loans are forecast to pay back more than they borrowed.
Graduate George told us he doesn't want a work promotion due to the higher interest it will incur on his loan.
Labour MP Chris Curtis also has a Plan 2 loan & speaks to #r4todayThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Imran Rasul
@ImranRasul3
👇A great opportunity to join the team @TheIFS 👇
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
🚨Rare and exciting opportunity 🚨
We're looking to hire an exceptional economist to work on fiscal policy at the IFS. We don't do this often. It's a chance to shape, carry out and communicate research on some of the highest-profile topics in UK economic policy. [1/4] -
Tim Leunig reposted
Andrew Ellson
@andrewellson
A council elected on a mandate to remove LTNs has been told that its decision to axe the schemes was unlawful
I fear this decision won't help restore faith in local democracy..
My story today: www.thetimes.com/uk/london/article/tower-hamlets-low-traf… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
Mind-blowing chart of the week here. Southern Europe has, for perhaps the first time in modern history, a lower headline unemployment rate than Northern Europe.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
Architects are lobbying the Govt to require that builders employ an architect to submit a planning application ('protection of function').
Remember: builders won't have to *listen* to these architects. They just need to pay an architect to sign off their application. Protection of function is *completely toothless* for enforcing higher design standards.
This is in fact *pure rent-seeking* by the sector, a medieval-style tithe on building. There is nothing to recommend this proposal, and the Govt should toss it out without another thought.
www.architectsjournal.co.uk/news/arb-in-talks-with-govern… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Doug Lemov
@Doug_Lemov
England’s school's have achieved competitive advantage over those in the US by stressing knowledge-rich curriculum, more rigorous assessment & teaching informed by principles of cognitive psychology.
Now they’re phone free too. And good for them. English kids deserve that.
The question is: Will US schools keep pace or let themselves fall even further behind? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ant Breach
@AntBreach
We know that this will reduce housing supply because this is what happens in France.
Since 1977, new homes above 170m2 (originally 250m2) need an architect. Ever since, new houses are concentrated at a size just below this threshold to avoid the costs of an accredited architect.
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
Architects are lobbying the Govt to require that builders employ an architect to submit a planning application ('protection of function').
Remember: builders won't have to *listen* to these architects. They just need to pay an architect to sign off their application. Protection of function is *completely toothless* for enforcing higher design standards.
This is in fact *pure rent-seeking* by the sector, a medieval-style tithe on building. There is nothing to recommend this proposal, and the Govt should toss it out without another thought.
www.architectsjournal.co.uk/news/arb-in-talks-with-govern… -
Tim Leunig reposted
John Peters
@johnthejack
It is strange how the property market is hyped by the media generally. Real prices aren't used. Opinions/sources are usually those with interest in boosting prices. Higher prices are always deemed good.
From
(£) www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/weve-often-ha…
where Matthew Parris quotes @timleunig -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
An example of UK government being great. Ministry of Justice needed to do messy data linking more quickly and reliably than existing methods. Developed the system. Released it. Now it's used all over the place, including by us at @TheDataCity. It's great! github.com/moj-analytical-services/splink
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I agree with you, @thomasforth
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Do you know a really good way to make sure that teams doing government are small? Oh wait someone's at the door,
.
.
*Tom is taken away by mental health professionals for talking about local government too much online* -
Tim Leunig reposted
Rory Sutherland
@rorysutherland
My children have left home, I've paid off my mortgage and I'm still working. And now I suddenly get a Senior Railcard. Amusingly, unlike other Railcards, it gets you the same discount in First Class.
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
People aged 65-74 have five times the wealth of those aged 25-34. So why do shop workers and cleaners pay full fare while pensioners ride free?
A good question from Stephen Bleach... times-comment.com/bus -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ant Breach
@AntBreach
Agree - and enjoying this take that the real fare dodgers are the baby boomers:
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
100% this. It is outrageous that the, on average better off, over 60s get these freebies, while on average worse off, younger people subsidise them. Policy remains stuck in the 1970s when older people really were very poor on average. No longer true.
www.thetimes.com/article/1430ade0-999f-4d29-8f53-bad034d7… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
People aged 65-74 have five times the wealth of those aged 25-34. So why do shop workers and cleaners pay full fare while pensioners ride free?
A good question from Stephen Bleach... times-comment.com/bus -
Tim Leunig reposted
Kane Emerson
@KaneEmerson
NEW @BritishProgress and @LabourTogether report!
Project Hawking: how the Government can go big on Britain’s strengths and triple the economy of the Oxford–Cambridge Corridor. -
Tim Leunig reposted
David Lawrence
@dc_lawrence
NEW data shows London housebuilding is at its lowest level since records began in 1990.
Historical data suggests this is the lowest rate of building since World War 2, and the lowest peacetime building since the Industrial Revolution.
We are choking growth in our own capital. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
This huge scheme in Shoreditch is one of London's best – so good that visual preference surveying found a huge majority of the public backing drastic densification. Unfortunately, it appears that officers at Hackney Council are recommending that it be rejected.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (free/£) outlines how and why we should get rid of passports. Not that I am advocating open borders...
timleunig.substack.com/p/lets-get-rid-of-passports -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Yes, @Stellantis know that their EVs are rubbish, so they want to move the goal posts. You should not fall for it, @griffitha.
Andrew Griffith MP
@griffitha
In other words, the exercise of consumer choice. Which sounds like a productive dynamic in any market.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
Hold on to your seats everyone. The next eight weeks are going to be wild for Forest City and our chances of success.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
On all things cheese I'm very happy for Europe to have a monopoly
Financial Times
@FT
US accuses EU of seeking cheese ‘monopoly’ in Mercosur deal ft.trib.al/FkoCnki
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
In response to the new Trump tariffs on Europe--if they stay.
Most countermeasures the EU has considered are costly for the US, but also costly for the EU... Be it export restrictions on pharmaceuticals, higher digital taxes on non resident firms, etc. They should definitely be considered, but one must realize that they would involve some pain.
One measure I can think of however, which could be announced now and implemented relatively quickly, and would be good for the EU, is the creation of a deep eurobond market, reducing dollar dominance. shorturl.at/341aB
It can be done, at little political cost, with benefits for the EU, and costs for the US. (It is worth doing anyway, but announcing it now would show that Europe has some cards to play and is willing to play them) -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Beautifully clear demonstration of the very high cost of HS2, amid unusually easy terrain and with proven technology. giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/actions/redeem/64755eb4-f9…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
glad we agree, sorry to have misunderstood...
Rachel
@RachBLondon
I think you mis-read my comment which was in response to the other commentator who said we should focus on farming practices. I agree building more houses will definitely help and it's what we need to do. I'm less precious about monoculture farmland.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I wrote about this in @ObserverUK a couple of months ago- observer.co.uk/news/business/article/tesla-could-end-up-l…
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
Wowsers Elon!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Centre for Economic Performance
@CEP_LSE
📢 Call for papers: 1st Annual CEP–IFS Labour Conference
London | 15–16 June 2026
We invite papers on wages & inequality, firm wage-setting, monopsony, unions, worker mobility & place-based policies.
Submit by 13 Feb 2026.
🔗 Details & submissions: cep.lse.ac.uk/_new/events/event.asp?index=10550 -
Tim Leunig reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
Better late than never but:
🇩🇪 did way more than just phase out nuclear at home
They spent 2 decades sabotaging nuclear energy across the EU
They pushed to remove nuclear from the green energy list in Brussels, funded anti-nuke think tanks in 🇫🇷...
Relentless in their mistake
The Spectator Index
@spectatorindex
🇩🇪 Germany's Chancellor Merz says it was a 'serious strategic mistake to phase out nuclear energy'.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Amazing that AI can read your handwriting. I don't mean that as an insult - your handwriting is very average...
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
I particularly enjoy the beauty of writing those notes with an original Xerox company pen too. The breakout innovators in so much of this space.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
robert shrimsley
@robertshrimsley
Good, there's too much violent talk in politics.
Kevin Schofield
@KevinASchofield
Badenoch Walks Off During Interview After Refusing 4 Times To Say Robert Jenrick Is 'A Traitor'
www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/kemi-badenoch-walks-off-du… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Building more houses will definitely help the housing crisis. It is basic supply and demand. If we build more relative to income and population growth, prices (and rents) fall. thinkhouse.org.uk/site/assets/files/1616/2008_20nhpau.pdf
Rachel
@RachBLondon
That won't help the housing crisis though.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Philip Aldrick
@PhilAldrick
Trawling through BoE transcripts from 2017 released today was this limerick sign-off from Minouche Shafik, now Starmer’s econ adviser, at her last MPC meeting. Inspired by @AdamPosen who “took to poetry in his final meeting” apparently
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
This is exactly why we a need Forest City
YIMBY Alliance
@yimbyalliance
High living costs are driving young people OUT of Britain.
We urgently need to make housing more affordable to stop more young people leaving! -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Are you an analyst interested in early years education and parenting? If so, my employer @Nesta_uk is hiring.
💷 £37.4k + benefits
📍 Hybrid, London
Apply by 26 Jan or repost👇 sprou.tt/1vymz5BdL6A -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
… as espoused by the Forestry Commission, is to explore which new species may be constructively introduced, adding diversity and resilience to our ecosystem. Towns and gardens are excellent places to do that: easy to observe and to react to any problems.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
… long term temperate forests, where 200+ species co-exist, we have 30, with low genetic diversity, which makes us hugely vulnerable to tree pandemics: each new one makes a big dent in our ecosystem where in more diverse systems such shocks are easily absorbed.
The solution, … -
Tim Leunig reposted
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
“Native only” is counterproductive quasi religious nonsense. Apart from a few tundra-adapted species, all our ‘native’ trees and shrubs are immigrants, crossing from Europe as the ice receded or brought by humans because they were useful. Compared to the world’s healthy, …
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Outstanding work by Paul Swinney on why the Manchester economic boom is probably just a series of data errors aligning. www.economicsobservatory.com/have-the-uks-northern-cities…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Always? Are we sure that native only beats all imported tree species?
Paul Powlesland
@paulpowlesland
Although a lot of that is non-natives (eg London plane) with minimal ecological/wildlife value. If we truly want London to be a forest city, we need to insist on native only planting.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Building houses increases tree cover and biodiversity
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
London has almost three times more tree cover (21%) than mid-Suffolk (8.5%). Fascinating!
woodcentral.com.au/why-london-is-home-to-the-worlds-large… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
All parliaments bind their successors - not just CfDs but also PFI projects, nuclear powerplants, aircraft carriers etc etc.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
No British Parliament can bind its successor but contracts for difference and similar sorts of things do seem able to do so pretty effectively.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
London struggles with petty crime (shoplifting, snatch theft) but levels of serious crime (assault, murder) have just fallen to the lowest since records began.
The drop in murders of under-25s is particularly striking... -
Tim Leunig reposted
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
Local Housing Allowance rates have been realigned to market rents in just two of the last 13 years.
Current Government policy is for them to remain frozen. This risks a record 'affordability gap' opening between LHA rates and the 30th percentile of local rents.
➡️ -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A government keen on growth would read this and act...
Kane Emerson
@KaneEmerson
NEW @BritishProgress and @LabourTogether report!
Project Hawking: how the Government can go big on Britain’s strengths and triple the economy of the Oxford–Cambridge Corridor. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Samuel Hughes
@SCP_Hughes
This was a rather unlovely scheme, but it is nonetheless scandalous that one of the most valuable and best connected sites in England will continue to be used for a handful of ageing sheds.
Constructing London
@constructingldn
Today plans for an refused student development in Paddington, will be determined today via public hearing by the Deputy Mayor for Planning, Regeneration and Skills, Jules Pipe.
This follows an refusal by Westminster City Council in January 2025, by 4-3 despite an recommendation for approval reasons for refusal being the same 2 and 3rd reasons for the initial proposal.
This was subsequently called in by the Mayor of London on the 24th March.
Our write up, of the refused second development proposal.
constructing-london.com/768-student-rooms-proposed-for-pa… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Well, but 9000 days???
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Well! Finally, Europe delivered, in spite of the French NO vote. Mercosur, after 9,692 days of negotiation, is a reality!. Congratulations to all negotiators.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Important, and gives me hope for Britain, a generally successful multi-ethnic society in which we mostly rub along pretty well
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
These are gigantic differences.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Obvs not. That would be silly. Recommend reading their reports. They are good!
Dr Emma Harries
@DrEmilyHarris
Wait. @resfoundation are using ‘polling evidence’ to predict household incomes?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
And your polling evidence for this claim is, what, exactly? @resfoundation are predicting next to no growth in household incomes this year.
Dr Emma Harries
@DrEmilyHarris
Most people already feel better off Tim
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The government's emphasis on inflation is understandable given the polling, but while falling inflation is welcome, growth matters most - me in @ObserverUK - observer.co.uk/news/national/article/starmer-says-more-of… \
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Duncan Stott 🏗️🔰🇺🇦
@DuncanStott
NIMBYs were allowed to halve the amount housing on this site. We still aren't taking the capital's massive housing crisis with the urgency it warrants.
ianVisits
@ianvisits
After a decade of delay, Earl’s Court finally gets planning permission for 4,000 homes
A decade after the Earls Court Exhibition Centre was demolished, planning permission has finally been granted to build homes on the site.
www.ianvisits.co.uk/articles/after-a-decade-of-delay-earl… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
This chart documents one of humanity’s greatest achievements, in my view.
We just lived through the fastest population growth in history.
It would have been impressive if food supplies had merely kept pace — but on every continent, they grew even faster than the population. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Are you a civil servant in search of new policy ideas? Here are 116 ideas for you. Sign up to a free sub and I will give you a complementary upgrade so that you can read them all. timleunig.substack.com/p/my-policy-ideas-so-far-873
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Others can get half of them for free, but you need to pay to read them all. Last year I made £6426.06 - all of which I donated to @AgainstMalaria. So if you subscribe, you help to save lives.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I never found anything this interesting at my grandparents, @_alice_evans ...
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
Found this at my grandparents..
A 1628 Quietus affirms that the dues on Edmund’s Lands had been fully paid to the Crown by the administrator, Elizans (short for Elizabeth).
Refers to “Lord the King” (i.e. Divine Right) and "the Feast of Saint Michael the Archangel" (as a religious calendar). -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
H/t @joachim_voth for this link to an excellent set of tweets
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Here's proof that Claude Code can write an entire empirical polisci paper.
To validate my claim that AI agents are coming for polisci "like a freight train", today I had Claude Code fully replicate and extend an old paper of mine estimating the effect of universal vote-by-mail on turnout and election outcome...essentially in one shot.
After careful prompting, Claude Code:
(1) Downloaded the old paper's repo and replicated the past results, translating our old Stata Code into Python
(2) Crawled the web to get updated official election data and census data
(3) Ran new analyses extending the results through 2024
(4) Created new tables and figures
(5) Performed a lit review
(6) Wrote a wholly new paper
(7) Pushed the whole thing to a new github repo
The whole thing took about an hour.
This is an insane paradigm shift in how empirical work is done.
It also validates the point that several people including @BrendanNyhan made yesterday---it's going to be especially easy to scale observational research with AI.
Thanks to @alexolegimas, @arthur_spirling , and many others who gave me feedback. . -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Certainly better than a restaurant I saw recently "Crypto Burger" - slogan - "eat burgers, trade crypto"...
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
Dogs 🐶 and Cheese 🧀 10/10 this is the best fusion I’ve seen, no other contenders need apply. Need a UK branch pronto.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Are you a @UKLabour supporter serious about policy? If so, you will want to read these @LabourTogether job ads - policy posts, good connections, to £85k and you might get a role in govt out of it.
ThinkLabour
@ThinkLabour
We're hiring for our Policy Unit.
If you love rigorous policy work, political strategy and making the case for how to build a better Britain, we want to hear from you. Roles are at Senior Adviser and Director level.
Apply here: thinklabour.co.uk
Closing date: 14th Jan -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This week my substack (£/free trial) sets out why the UK should have an age restriction on access to university fee loans. We can't afford it!
Higher Education Policy Institute
@HEPI_news
“The government should, therefore, have an age restriction on student loans for university fees.”
Student fees and loans - Tim Leunig’s Policy Substack @timleunig timleunig.substack.com/p/student-fees-and-loans -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think there is a lot of evidence that greater autonomy and independence is a way to reduce population decline in a place, yes.
tedtweets
@tedtweets6
What does this suggest for Scotland (and Wales!)? They need to be independent or ppl will move to SE England?!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think it is the case that excepting Italy every high income country north of the equater has a population that is moving south? Or am I misremembering?
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
A big part of the story here is depopulation of "The North" vs. population growth of "The South". North England's population fell substantially in the 1980s with a lot of people leaving the UK, or moving to the South.
Post not available here, view on X
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The South is gaining population at the expense of the North in Spain as well - www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/11/18/4979
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
In that sense the finding that the UK population is moving South is not very surprising. Most people prefer to live somewhere a little warmer and a little dryer, and in the UK that means the South and the East.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Do you have the same per person?
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
"Welcome to Decline" -- still one of my favourite graphs from last year. In the late 1970s, Britain's economic fate very clearly split in two. How much you blame Thatcher will depend on your politics, but her leadership is useful to understand the timing. tomforth.co.uk/welcometodecline/
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Lawrence Freedman
@LawDavF
I've just updated my previous post on the military intervention in Venezuela. I was right to be sceptical of Trump's claims that VP Delcy Rodríguez was prepared to hand over the country and its oil field to US - as she has now made clear. (£/free trial), samf.substack.com/p/trump-maduro-and-the-panama-precedent
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
Farage has learned literally nothing from what happened to Liz Truss
Ben Riley-Smith
@benrileysmith
NEW: Nigel Farage is considering shutting down the OBR if Reform wins the next general election.
He tells @Telegraph the budget watchdog has reached such a position of influence that it is effectively “dictating policy”.
Scrapping the OBR would be the biggest overhaul of independent scrutiny over the Government’s taxation and spending plans in a generation.
Reform is currently more than 10 points clear of rivals in average opinion polls and has lead since April 2025.
Farage: “With the OBR I worry once again that we have a Blairite-style quango effectively dictating to elected politicians what they should or should not do.
“It seems that in too many areas of our public life the power has moved to judges and quangos and not the government the people choose.”
He added: “We have to discuss whether we would be better off without the OBR. I am giving that very serious thought.”
This is a moment of uncertainty for the OBR, without a chairman after Richard Hughes quit following the leaking of its forecast 45mins before the last Budget.
Increasingly figures on the Left are joining those on the Right questioning the degree to which the OBR’s 5th year forecast is shaping Treasury policy.
But this also potentially opens up Farage to attacks over fiscal responsibility. Downing Street insiders believe Reform is vulnerable on economic competence.
Liz Truss’s decision to skip an OBR forecast for her 2022 mini-Budget was seen to have contributed to the market fallout that followed, which led to her demise.
Farage did not say what system of oversight - if any - could replace the OBR.
It had been the Treasury that made the forecasts (with criticisms it tilted figures to help the political leadership at the time) before George Osborne created the OBR in 2010.
Full story👇
www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/01/02/farage-vows-scrap… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Thank you. I had not heard of one of them, and have no time for the other, but I should know the level of batshit crazy anti-semitism out there. The comments below are terrible as well. I hope 2026 improves for all of us who believe in civilisation and civilised behaviour.
Daniel Finkelstein
@Dannythefink
Just so that people are aware of the turn taken by both Robinson and Fox.
Richard Bartholomew
@Barthsnotes
And now, a "Christmas special", in which Calvin Robinson expounds to Laurence Fox about "Talmudic Jews" (30:50) and how "people like Danny Finkelstein" have "emotionally manipulated the evil events that took place for their own advantage" (21:04) www.youtube.com/watch?v=CN9j2fqde5k
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Luke Tryl
@LukeTryl
Does seem like a triumph of soulless bureaucracy with a dash of some ungenerous local residents thrown in.
Feels like the money spent on “fencing, security and police presence” might be better spent addressing whatever safety concerns they have and letting people enjoy the view
Metropolitan Police
@metpoliceuk
Primrose Hill will be closed on New Year’s Eve this year ⛔There will be fencing, security and a police presence to prevent access.
If you had planned to head there to get a view of the central London fireworks, please make alternative arrangements. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
The past ‘is a foreign country’ and all that
Sir Humphrey
@pinstripedline
The joys of protocol! When BT sent an incorrectly addressed telegram on behalf of the Prime Minister to the Queen Mother on her birthday, the ensuing concerns resulted in a formal complaint to No10!
-
Tim Leunig reposted
YIMBY Alliance
@yimbyalliance
We should scrap the silly rule requiring that even conversions into two flats must have outdoor space for each, explains @timleunig: open.substack.com/pub/timleunig/p/conversions
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
The threat to German auto producers isn't from Chinese cars flooding Germany. It's from Chinese cars flooding to emerging markets (red), where they're killing the market for German cars. That's not something EU tariffs on China are going to be able to fix.
robinjbrooks.substack.com/p/chinas-invasion-of-em-car-mar… -
Tim Leunig reposted
𝓢𝓪𝓶 🦇
@samofsamshire
Add a floor and give them bigger windows.
Two additions that immediately improve aesthetics and quality of life.
Leo Gibbons
@Layo_FH
A new build estate! What are your thoughts?
I think it’s perfectly inoffensive. The pavements are a bit small, there is a lack of trees for my liking, and the houses are bland but they’re not terribly ugly.
I’m perfectly chill with this lack of density in the Tyne & Wear suburbia, but I would be raging if this was built anywhere in Greater London and its well connected outer commuter-belt. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
If only, says every Londoner following you...
Jess
@Jess_Lister
£1800pcm and you too can experience peak East Yorkshire rurality
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I want a simpler tax system that requires neither a great mathematician or a good tax accountant to do my taxes!!
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
Do you want a great mathematician to do your taxes or a good tax accountant? The idea of "skills" for Claude, as the equivalent of applications for an OS, is fascinating.
youtu.be/CEvIs9y1uog -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I cannot imagine conscripting me for the four weeks I did not have a job aged 21 would have helped the army or me or the taxpayer.
Oliver Lewis
@policy_uk
If you’re under 35 with no legitimate reason to be immobile and in receipt of benefits, National Service it should be
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The similarities in the answers is quite remarkable
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
Americans think about 43% of the world is wealthier than them.
Wildly wrong. Americans who make the median full-time wage ($63,128) are in the top 3% of global incomes, adjusted for price differences. Even if they make the 10th percentile wage ($18,890) they’re top 24% globally. -
Tim Leunig reposted
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
But as @jonathansimons and other Public First colleagues showed, universities are brilliant for local communites. Those international students may not stay forever, but they spend money locally, propping up the High Street - quite the opposite of this graphic, @rodriguez_pose !
Andrés Rodríguez-Pose
@rodriguez_pose
British #universities fashion themselves as global engines of excellence. However, as Chaytor and @john_tomaney argue in @po_qu, locally, they increasingly look like extractive industries: educating young people for jobs that exist elsewhere.
doi.org/10.1111/1467-923x.70035 -
Tim Leunig reposted
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
Forest City is incredibly grateful to have the full throated backing of the National Federation of Builders. Since 1880 the NFB's members have been building Britain's cities. And hopefully, before long, they'll be building the next one.
“Forest City 1 is a chance for the UK to reinvent placemaking, land use and the planning system. It can serve as a blueprint for growth, while solving some of the greatest challenges the nation faces such as the housing emergency, nature depletion and the skill crisis. It needs to be taken seriously and we certainly back the proposal.” - Richard Beresford, chief executive of the NFB. (cc @shortthought)
www.pbctoday.co.uk/news/projects/nfb-backs-plans-build-uk… -
Tim Leunig reposted
BishopSarah
@bishopSarahM
May the joy of the angels,
The eagerness of the shepherds, the perseverance of the wise men,
The obedience of Mary and Joseph,
And the peace of the Christ Child be yours this Christmas. -
Tim Leunig reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Interesting!
These authors wanted to know which aspects of the college experience give recent graduates a leg up in the job market.
So they ran an experiment.
In it, they sent 37,000 fictitious resumes to employers and randomized multiple aspects of the college experience.
Specifically, they randomized applicants':
-college major (Biology, Economics, Chemistry, Marketing, Anthropology, Psychology, or Finance)
-college minor (History, Math, or none)
-internship experience (social, quantitative, or none)
-study abroad (in Italy, Argentina, China, Mexico, Japan, Dubai, South Africa, or none)
-computer skills (basic, programming, data skills, programming and data skills, or none)
They then observed who got the most employer callbacks.
They found that in first positions:
-Biology and Economics majors received the highest callback rate, particularly in occupations involving high intensity of analytical and interpersonal skills.
-minors in History and Math did not help applicants get more callbacks.
-Internship experiences that are social skills-oriented positively influence callbacks, yet this is not the case for analytical internships.
-Study abroad experiences enhance callback rates, but where you do your study abroad matters!
-Listing both programming and data analysis skills significantly boosts callback rates.
"Our study provides a comprehensive characterization of which features of the college experience are more and less valuable during the high-stakes, first-job matching process." -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Good luck to everyone cooking a Christmas dinner for tomorrow. In honour of the delayed Leeds tram I will be cooking everything in series, nothing in parallel, and so we'll be eating mid-January.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
These stories, real or not, are cute. But even better is to live in the UK where there are no library fines for kids books!!!
The Husky
@Mr_Husky1
Anonymous
I work at a public library. A teenage boy came to the desk. He looked nervous. "I found this," he said. He put a copy of Harry Potter on the counter. It was lost 3 years ago. It was battered. "I stole it," he admitted. "We didn't have money for books. But I read it. I read it ten times." He pulled out a crumpled $10 bill. "For the fine." I looked at the computer. The fine was way more than $10. I looked at the kid. He was honest. He was a reader. I took the $10. "Actually," I said, "The fine is exactly zero dollars during Amnesty Week." (There is no Amnesty Week). I pushed the money back to him. "Buy your own copy," I said. "And come back. We have the sequel." He comes in every Tuesday now. Libraries are for reading, not for accounting. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
The only solution to really bad behaviour in cases like this is very large fines. If @skytv were fined £10,000 per customer, they would soon follow the law. (Failing that, £100k, etc)
Adam Kucharski
@adamjkucharski
Very angry with @skytv for upselling a new TV package to a customer they’d been notified had dementia - and doing this *one month* after I cancelled on the customer’s behalf because they weren’t aware they’d signed up in the first place.
When challenged, Sky’s customer service response was that the customer technically ‘agreed’ to the upsell.
For me, this raises serious concerns about how vulnerable customers are being treated and whether @Ofcom guidelines for this group are actually being followed. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
* Congestion Down
* Sales tax revenue up
* Vehicle traffic: -11%
* Foot traffic: +3.4%
* Pollution: -22%
* Revenue for mass transit: $548M
NYC Congestion Pricing has been a *HUGE* success -
Tim Leunig reposted
ianVisits
@ianvisits
The e-scooter isn’t new – London was zooming around on Autopeds a century ago
www.ianvisits.co.uk/articles/the-e-scooter-isnt-new-londo… -
Tim Leunig reposted
John Stewart
@JohnJohnStewart
The Government is due to publish its Road Safety Strategy early in 2026. It need not fear bringing in tough measures to deal with offenders. As the survey below it is what the public want. Perhaps the only thing the followers of Nigel Farage and Zack Polanski agree on!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Which builds most will have the biggest effect!
Sam Dumitriu
@Sam_Dumitriu
Spain is running an experiement.
Madrid is attempting to making housing cheaper through increasing the supply of private housing.
Barcelona is trying to do it by capping Airbnbs and rent control.
My prediction: Madrid will get cheaper housing, but the author of this piece will complain that Barcelona's reforms failed because they didn't go far enough.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/dec/22/barcelona-m… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Much worse than that - we would need more teachers (they work long hours during term already). That is expensive, and probably we would recruit worse teachers on average. Kids also learn less per hour as the school day increases - so education would be less productive
Matt Ashby
@LessCrime
Then the question becomes: is this addition to the curriculum worth the cost of paying 600,000 teachers to work the equivalent of an extra half day every week?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
What? Of course they don't. High prices should - in the absence of regulation - indicate that an area is profitable, and therefore more firms will enter/produce more etc. Econ 101 has nothing to do with benefience, as Adam Smith noted...
Paul Powlesland
@paulpowlesland
“Generously”.
Crappy volume developers have a reputation for giving out money out of the goodness of their hearts with no need for anything in return. -
Tim Leunig reposted
Alex Jones
@alexcj
To be fair to Mr Leunig he wasn't arguing that the massive collapse in council house building has not contributed to high prices but that planning controls in the South East have been instrumental in driving regionally higher prices there. Might be true. There's evidence.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Do I get paid by Barratt Redrow? Really? News to me, but thanks for letting me know, @DanicaPriest.
Danica Priest🦇🦎🦇🦎🍃💚🍃
@DanicaPriest
Tim gets paid by Barratt Redrow. He’s not going to actually tell the truth and support council housing
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Again, the changes in the supply of social housing have been similar across the country, but the price effects have not been. Read the Hilber paper I gave you the link to last time if you want to know more about this stuff.
Alex Jones
@alexcj
If we are talking about increasing prices over time, then the changes to supply may be more relevant than the total numbers of such housing?
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This was always the q I used to ask people who wanted their thing added the curriculum - what do you want taken out to make space...
Joe Hill
@jo3hill
The school curriculum is a great example of a collective action problem in policy. In practice, it’s zero-sum. But every campaign group calls for more of their preferred subject, very few can say what they want to cut to make room. Bizarre how much government entertains them.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
1) The N-S price differential suggests planning. See academic.oup.com/ej/article-abstract/126/591/358/5077428 for evidence. 2) We have the world's fourth highest social housing stock. www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/data/datasets/affordable…
Alex Jones
@alexcj
Why planning? Looking at the collapse in numbers of new council house building after 1979 suggests that lack of supply is more strongly related to that than planning.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Air passenger duty is a terribly designed tax - my substack this week (£/free trial) sets out how to sort it out timleunig.substack.com/p/air-passenger-duty
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Dr Lawrence Newport
@lawrencenewport
If anyone doubts how absurd our system is:
Yesterday, 2 years after the ban came in, the final part of the JUDICIAL REVIEW on the Bully XL ban was DISMISSED.
That's right, it took 2 years, over half a million, to find out that gov could do what the law said it could.
Absurd. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Now this will be interesting! An LLM using only information available before they first world war. Hats off to @joachim_voth for this one.
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
How did people in 1913 see the world? How did they think about the future? We trained LLMs exclusively on pre-1913 texts—no Wikipedia, no 20/20. The model literally doesn't know WWI happened. Announcing the Ranke-4B family of models. Coming soon: github.com/DGoettlich/history-llms
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is literally the reverse of the truth. High prices induce supply, they do not prevent it! The fact that prices remain so much higher in the SE than elsewhere showa that planning is throttling supply in some parts of the country.
Ashley Osborne | PRSim | AngelBrics | LEXIT 🇦🇺
@proptechpioneer
Planning is not the reason the UK isn't building more houses affordability is.
UK 1970's avg
- house price to income ~ 2.6 - 3.0
- student debt to income ~ 0%
- rent as % of income ~ 10%
UK 2020's avg
- house price to income ~ 7.9
- student debt to income ~ 170 - 180%
- rent as % of income ~ 34 - 36% -
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Smith
@Paul_SLG
This is great from @rcolvile on the Leeds tram fiasco and what it tells us about Britain.
www.thetimes.com/article/7bbd1813-8293-4b65-8c68-075d9a36… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
This is largely being ignored but it's easily one of the biggest China news of the year.
What China is doing with Hainan - a huge island (50 times the size of Singapore!) - is pretty extraordinary: they're basically making it into a completely different jurisdiction from the rest of the country, and an extremely attractive entry gate for the Chinese market.
You can now import most products in the world (74% of all goods) entirely duty free into Hainan. And, if you transform the product and add 30% value locally, you can then send it to the rest of mainland China completely tariff-free.
So for instance: import Australian beef into Hainan tax free. Slice it and package it for hotpot in Hainan: it can enter all mainland supermarkets duty-free.
They also have insanely low corporate tax rates: 15%, lower than Hong Kong (16.5%) and Singapore (17%) or the rest of the mainland (25%).
That's not all, Hainan now has different rules from the rest of China in dozens of areas:
HEALTH: Basically the rule is that if a medicine or medical device is approved by regulatory agencies anywhere in the world, it can be used in Hainan - even if banned on the mainland. Which undoubtedly makes it THE place in the world with the widest range of medical treatments available.
NO FIREWALL: Companies registered in Hainan can apply for unrestricted global internet access
OPEN EDUCATION: Foreign universities can open campuses without a Chinese partner
VISA-FREE: 86 countries get visa-free entry, probably one of the most open places in the world
CAPITAL: Special accounts let money flow freely to and from overseas - normal mainland forex restrictions don't apply
So they're running a pretty extraordinary "radical openness" experiment there.
They're basically building a "greatest hits" of global free zones: Singapore's tax regime, Switzerland's medical access, Dubai's visa policy - all in one giant tropical island attached to the 1.4 billion people Chinese consumer market.
China Xinhua News
@XHNews
China on Thursday launched island-wide special customs operations in the Hainan Free Trade Port (FTP), the world's largest FTP by area, allowing freer entry of overseas goods, expanded zero-tariff coverage and more business-friendly measures. xhtxs.cn/8VU
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
North England's lack of a genuine separatist movement is a huge cost. Sadly.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is correct. Hydrogen MAY be useful for industrial energy, but it is utterly unsuited to domestic heating via the gas grid. Both heat pumps and biomethane are better options. @ClemCowton @nesta_uk
James Twallin
@twallin_james
Another gas leak.
If the gas networks still can't contain methane after more than a century of practice, why should we trust them with hydrogen? -
Tim Leunig reposted
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
You need to read this. Distressing, moving and important in equal measure
I have @Dannythefink's back - and anyone else whose Britishness is questioned by the extremists on here because of their faith or the colour of their skin
www.thetimes.com/article/d336a831-fc41-4363-ba2e-e40e12c1… -
Tim Leunig reposted
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
And there it is. Embargo is finished. Yorkshire Post press publish first. But I have my suspicions there's quite a lot more to this story than what they're reporting. www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/politics/west-yorkshire-mass…
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
It's really funny that some people got into their head in the late '10s that Amazon was a disliked company (remember the upset at the positive depiction in Nomadland) when it's actually got landslide popularity that almost any public institution would dream of.
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Anton Muscatelli
@AntonMuscatelli
As President of @RoyalSocEd I’m absolutely delighted that the U.K. is planning to rejoin #erasmus. This will provide huge opportunities for U.K. students across the educational spectrum. It will also provide invaluable connections for our country. www.linkedin.com/posts/royalsoced_the-president-of-the-ro…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think you just replaced Chessington World of Adventures with housing. Not sure that is going to happen...
Jenevieve Treadwell
@JenMTreadwell
Today is a great day for housing & planning policy nerds because the Government has given the best Christmas gift we could ask for: a default ‘yes’ for homes around the train stations, INCLUDING those in the Green Belt
Within London alone, that could create over 500,000 homes -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Indeed, which is why I did not do that!
Douglas McWilliams
@DMcWilliams_UK
Mmm. You are one of the cleverest econs in the country. BUT I'm sure you are clever enough to know that a month's figures do not do more than provide a bit of contiguous support for a long term prediction.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Absolutely delighted to be part of Forest City. Let's get the houses we need, in the places we need them.
Shiv Malik
@shivmalik
Very proud to announce our board for Forest City. We're incredibly grateful to have some very talented advisors with us on this journey who all have deep experience in politics, economics or urban planning.
- Dame Patricia Hewitt, former business secretary (chair)
- @timleunig , former economic advisor to two chancellors
- Steve McAdam, architect behind Kings Cross and the Olympics
- Jackie Sadek, chair of the London-Cambridge innovation corridor and former government advisor on urban regeneration
It's a stellar group and they've already managed to achieve a lot in these last few weeks in terms of building relationships and smoothing the way to making Forest City a reality.
I also want to thank local landowner Henry D'Abo for extending his wise hand in friendship to the project and backing us to get this done. -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Last week I wrote my new @nesta_uk Economics Edit column on falling world food prices. Today @ONS says UK food prices fell, lowering inflation and (probably) leading to an interest rate cut. If you want to read all about it before it happens, sign up here: mailchi.mp/a6c78a1be69a/sign-up-to-the-economics-edit
-
Tim Leunig reposted
David Lawrence
@dc_lawrence
These announcements mean Labour's Steve Reed & Matthew Pennycook have gone further than any government in making it possible to build homes in Britain.
It may even be the most significant thing Labour has done for growth so far.
The Conservatives said they'd build homes in London, but they failed. Instead, Gove's legacy was cumbersome building safety regulations and gold-plating of restrictions that made it impossible to build. This has meant that the place we most need new homes (London & SE) has barely increased its supply.
Labour's latest reforms, announced today, have the potential to change all that:
1. 🚉 Approval of homes within walking distance of train stations, including in the Green Belt
2.🏘️ Permission for additional buildings on existing plots (as in Croydon)
3. 🚫 Councils will not be allowed to add additional gold plating of restrictions (with a couple of exceptions)
4. 🔬Small sites exempt from biodiversity net gain (and possibly building safety levy)
Huge congrats to @SteveReedMP @mtpennycook for having the courage and dedication to get this across the line!
YIMBY Alliance
@yimbyalliance
NEW: Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook has just announced the BIGGEST EVER reforms to national policy to deliver more homes! Here are the five biggest: 🧵
-
Tim Leunig reposted
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Looking at advert, knowing about financial services is not an essential criterion. So that’s all right then.
I was at this level in HMT 18 years ago and was paid that amount in cash terms.
Getting good experienced people into these roles matters to us all.
False economy.
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
@hmtreasury are recruiting new Director for Financial Services. It is a senior job - in the top 40 HMT civil servants. Salary £100,000. Which is a way of saying "don't apply if you have ever had a senior position in finance". #notsensible. www.civilservicejobs.service.gov.uk/csr/jobs.cgi?jcode=19… to apply
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Oops they did it again! More evidence of the craziness of UK VAT rules as court rules AFTER 13 YEARS that @Morrisons rotisserie chicken is kept hot (by the packaging) and is therefore liable to VAT. www.ft.com/content/d8d03e15-5cce-4efa-b007-26351a1e12b5 1/3
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Any tax system that requires a 13 year court case to decide the tax status of supermarket chicken is not fit for purpose. We should have VAT on everything, at a lower rate - www.nesta.org.uk/blog/fiscal-options-untangling-vat/ 2/3
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
@hmtreasury are recruiting new Director for Financial Services. It is a senior job - in the top 40 HMT civil servants. Salary £100,000. Which is a way of saying "don't apply if you have ever had a senior position in finance". #notsensible. www.civilservicejobs.service.gov.uk/csr/jobs.cgi?jcode=19… to apply
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Completely right - my reading of the data is that pretty much all courses in all unis pass the returns test = the major exception are (most) creative arts degrees. Unis is poorer areas, catering for local students, also struggle.
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Yes the Times routinely states sample size to add that caveat. It also gives salary range, which is importing (and often quite wide).
The Leo data shows most degrees offer sound RoI. The good universities (like Glasgow) have far more to gain than lose from a -#freeleo! -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
We can easily look at promotions and job departures, of course. Qualitative evidence is harder.
Ralph Lucas
@LordLucasCD
Also, we should be looking at how we can gather (?SLC) and use longer term (5 years plus) discursive data on students and their employers looking back on the broader worth of the course.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I would rather too many hacks used LEO than none! And good papers can hire good researchers to help them.
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
Only issue is trying to ensure intelligent use by hacks ;)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Not content with writing a weekly policy ideas substack (free/£), not content with writing a fortnightly piece for @ObserverUK, I am now writing "the economics edit" fortnightly for @nesta_uk. It is free - you can sign up here: mailchi.mp/a6c78a1be69a/sign-up-to-the-economics-edit
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
LEO dataset has information on grades (KS1, KS2, GCSE, A level, FE), gender, ethnicity, terms on free school meals, IDACI of areas of residence and SEN. So it allows researchers to do a good job of adjusting for most things. We also know which unis applied to.
Ben Page
@Benpagelondon
Also is the data adjusted - as way mortality data are - by what students were like BEFORE entering an institution…class/parental support etc
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A delight to attend @vnbateman latest book launch yesterday, in the rather grand surroundings of the National Portrait Gallery.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
My article today - why every leftwinger should have @RachelReevesMP as their hero. Her fiscal rectitude lowers interest rates, and allows the government to spend more on healthcare etc. Read (free) in the excellent @TheHouseMag www.politicshome.com/opinion/article/rachel-reeves-hero-left (1/2)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
tragically, the Kingston bus station, next to the train station, has been redeveloped with no flats of offices above it. Such a missed opportunity.
ianVisits
@ianvisits
Kingston's bus station reopened this morning after rebuilding works.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
📢NEW report from Public First & @LeedsBS which explores how to reform the planning system to better represent public opinion (1/11)
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Remember - supply and demand matter, so this year looks like a good year for students to be ambitious about which uni and "trade up" via clearing. #results - A levels - BTECs - your future!
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
A long time ago I was a @NuffieldCollege @OxfordEconDept Postdoctoral Research Fellow. It was an amazing experience, and I recommend it to every nearly/newly PhD. Remember - you have to be in it to win it! @econromesh @TimHarford @RoyalEconSoc @ChrisGiles_
Nuffield College
@NuffieldCollege
Now open for applications: Nuffield Postdoctoral Research Fellowships in Economics with @OxfordEconomics, for candidates who have recently finished (or will soon) a relevant doctorate.
Deadline: Sunday 15 September
More info at www.nuffield.ox.ac.uk/the-college/jobs-and-vacancies/nuff… -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
England are trying to be the Keir Starmer of football. Winning each seat/match by the sort of tiny margin that disappoints true believers, but which in total adds up to a massive overall victory... @ProfJaneGreen
Jane Green
@ProfJaneGreen
I’m very disappointed in the venn diagram of my twitter that no-one has yet pointed to the new government and England final correlation.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Sad moment on the doorstep today. An 80 year old lady told me she was turned away at the polling station for owning no relevant photo ID. "We fought for votes for women. I have voted in every election. Now they have taken it away." Hope the next government sorts this out.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Let me count the ways in which "Brexit makes Britain poorer".... Less investment means lower productivity, lower wages, lower GDP, worse public services etc. Our capital stock is now 50% lower per workers than other economies. Tragic. @PJTheEconomist @TeraPauliina
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
Our investment performance since 2016 has been truly awful.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
I think I will live to see the UK rejoin the EU, but it will be a while and our people will suffer economically in the meantime.
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
Deltapoll break down their polls by generation. This was today's Q on "would you vote to rejoin the EU"
Gen Z: 89% Yes / 9% No
Millennials: 67% Yes / 33% No
Gen X: 57% Yes / 43% No
Boomers: 47% Yes / 53% No
deltapoll.co.uk/polls/voteint240526 -
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
@RichardALJones and I don't agree on everything by a long shot, but on this we are in 100% agreement. Student loans cost government more than expected because UK productivity has not grown as expected, so wages have not grown as expected.
Richard Jones
@RichardALJones
Sorry to be the single issue bore on this, but the reason that the fraction of student loans recovered is much less than anticipated when fees were increased in 2012 is that average wages have grown much more slowly than expected, in turn because of flatlining productivity...
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
4 years since furlough was announced - the most useful thing I have done in my life. www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2024-03-20/allegra-str…
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Really great piece from @jburnmurdoch in today's @FT. @thomasforth makes a good point that Democrat mayors deserve praise as well. Repeat after me: "Building more houses makes housing cheaper"
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
Great stuff in the FT on how Texan cities have built more than Californian cities and what impact that probably had on house prices. And I think making the incredibly important point that it is in Republic states that more homes get built. But,... www.ft.com/content/de34dfc7-c506-4a81-b63d-41d994efaa89
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
7 quarters of falling living standards - something that has not happened since records began almost 70 years ago. Our country is in a deep, deep mess.
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
Nick Crafts' death has robbed Economic History of a clear thinker, an outstanding researcher, an excellent writer, a committed teacher and a wonderful colleague and mentor. @EcHistSoc
-
Tim Leunig
@timleunig
This is one of those really important facts whose significance will only be understood in retrospect. Once we stop using marginal land for food, food prices will fall, as it is marginal cost of production that sets price.
Hannah Ritchie
@_HannahRitchie
For millennia, humans have used more and more land for agriculture, taking over wild habitats.
But, we are at a unique point in history: agricultural land use has peaked.
My latest article:
ourworldindata.org/peak-agriculture-land






























































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































