🇫🇷⛪️🇺🇸 I grew up in France, a very secular country. Why is France so secular? I'd say two main reasons.
The first is 1789. The French Revolution fundamentally changed the relationship between the Church and the state, and, in the French collective imagination, turned the Catholic Church into something close to an enemy of the people and the Republic.
The second is that religion in France is remarkably monolithic. We're historically a Catholic country. Unless you belong to one of the smaller religious minorities (Muslims, Protestants, Jews, who together account for roughly 12% of the population), your main experience of religion is probably attending a Catholic mass for a baptism, a wedding, or a funeral.
I used to joke that, for most French people, the Catholic Church is little more than an event-organizing agency. Most people simply don't interact with it outside those special occasions.
Why do so few people go to mass otherwise?
Again, there are several reasons. The most obvious is that many people reject religion, and the Catholic Church in particular, altogether.
My parents' generation grew up rebelling against their own conservative parents. They took that rebellion so far that their children (myself included) weren't even baptized. This came as a shock to my grandparents, but they eventually resigned themselves to it, and loved us just as much.
Then there are two other reasons.
One is that there simply aren't enough priests anymore. Who would choose such a career, including renouncing sex, marriage, and family life? Very few people, as it turns out. And, in some cases, perhaps not always the most recommendable people.
The other reason is much simpler: going to mass in France is BORING.
You end up in some beautiful but dilapidated old church, almost entirely empty. There's no money for furniture, no money for heating, and barely anyone in attendance beyond the elderly. Whatever the priest says or sings is often dull, underwhelming, sometimes downright cringe, and completely disconnected from the audience. It feels less like a living religious experience than a ritual you're expected to endure.
This used to make more sense when everyone went to mass. For my grandparents' generation, going to the village church every Sunday, wearing their best clothes, was also a social occasion: you met everyone, caught up, showed your face, and reaffirmed your place in the community.
But once people started staying away, for whatever reason, reverse network effects kicked in. The fewer people attended, the less attractive the experience became. And churn became brutal.
There's a wonderful scene in the French-Canadian film "The Decline of the American Empire" in which the characters visit a Catholic church in Quebec that has effectively shut down. The priest laments:
"In 1968, people just stopped coming. It happened overnight. Nobody really knew why, but they never came back."
Now, in 2015, I moved to London with my wife and our two young children. We ended up spending five years there.
One of our goals in moving was for our two kids to become native English speakers. So, rather than settling in South Kensington or Knightsbridge, alongside all the other French families, and enrolling in the local French schools, we decided to live in Islington, a gentrified, formerly working-class neighborhood in northeast London, and send the kids to local preschools and schools.
We weren't looking to find the best establishments in town. We didn't even have the time or energy for that. We simply looked up the nearest ones on a map, knocked on their doors, and got the kids enrolled.
As it turned out, both were Church of England institutions: my daughter went to a primary school, my son to a preschool.
This came with quite a lot of religious content, which was completely foreign to us. Not just because it was a different church and a different religious tradition, but because religion had long since ceased to be part of our lives.
I've always been grateful for the Christian connection my grandparents provided. They were avid readers of conservative Catholic magazines, which I used to browse whenever I visited them. But that was about the extent of my exposure to Christianity.
So suddenly seeing my children become part of a genuinely religious community was quite a change. And I found the whole experience intriguing.
Then one day, we were invited to an end-of-year celebration at the parish church, about 50 meters from our home. Coming from France, I expected something dull and boring.
But as it turns out, the church was absolutely packed. There were children everywhere, including mine, along with their parents and extended families. And a big part of the celebration consisted of singing together.
One of the songs was "Lord, I Lift Your Name on High." The kids were delighted, and the whole room seemed to come alive with it. There was an energy and joy to the singing that I had never associated with a religious celebration.
I came home genuinely enthused by the experience and immediately looked the song up on the Internet. What was this? How had I never heard it before? And, more importantly, why was this experience so radically different from the dull Catholic celebrations I had grown accustomed to in France?
I then went down a Christian music rabbit hole.
I discovered that "Lord, I Lift Your Name on High" was written in 1989 by an American worship leader called Rick Founds, from California. It's part of what is known as contemporary Christian music, or contemporary praise and worship: a relatively modern tradition of writing accessible, catchy songs that congregations can sing together. It became enormously popular in American churches and eventually crossed denominational boundaries.
And I realized something quite important. Because people in England speak English, they have access to an enormous reservoir of Christian music produced in America. And America, as it turns out, is an absolute hotbed of religious music.
Think African American gospel, with its extraordinary tradition of soulful, exuberant congregational singing. Think of the rich traditions of Southern gospel, country, and bluegrass-influenced Christian music, rooted in predominantly white American evangelical communities. And then think of the more contemporary worship music that draws on all these influences.
The British can simply borrow from this extraordinary musical ecosystem and bring it into their churches, schools, and communities. They get to sing all these wonderful songs, with all the energy, emotion, and joy that come with them.
And it suddenly struck me that this was an enormous cultural advantage that I had never even thought about.
At some point, YouTube's algorithm started recommending videos of American megachurches. One of the churches I stumbled upon was @ElevationChurch, based in Charlotte, North Carolina, and led by Pastor @stevenfurtick. It has its own worship band, called Elevation Worship (@elevation_wrshp), made up of seriously accomplished musicians.
I started watching videos of these guys performing. And what I saw was extraordinary: a full band, with electric guitars, keyboards, bass, drums, backing vocalists, and a choir, delivering incredibly sophisticated, powerful music to audiences of thousands. The crowds weren't just sitting there listening. They were singing along, hands in the air, completely immersed in the music. Some of the videos were filmed in enormous arenas, with crowds that looked more like audiences at major rock concerts than anything I had ever associated with going to church.
This, I discovered, was the world of American megachurches: enormous evangelical congregations, often with their own professional-grade musical and production operations, where contemporary worship is a central part of the religious experience.
And because I'm very interested in America, I had to incorporate this discovery into my broader framework for understanding that very large, extraordinarily complex country.
This whole experience, which started in St. Mary's Church in Islington, London, helped me understand something about what holds American society together.
It's not a central government like we have in France. It's not a common ethnicity or even a common religion. It's the extraordinary density of large and small local communities that Americans build around shared experiences and interests.
Think about baseball games, motorcycle clubs, high school football, local volunteer fire departments, veterans' associations, parent-teacher associations, Rotary Clubs, country music festivals, hunting clubs, and, of course, megachurches.
These are places where people come together regularly, develop relationships, share experiences, make friends, raise their children, help one another, and acquire a sense of belonging. They give people an identity that is neither purely individual nor imposed from above.
This world comes with its fair share of controversies, of course. I'm a regular listener to the @ShawnRyanShow, which has introduced me to some of the more complicated and sometimes disturbing corners of American religious and community life.
But there's another side to it, which I had discovered first-hand in that church in Islington: joy, music, fellowship, generosity, mutual support, and the simple pleasure of being part of something bigger than yourself.
And I think understanding this is essential to understanding America.
There are two things I take away from this experience.
First, I'm genuinely grateful that we lived through this in Islington. I'm glad my children experienced it, even if they ended up just as irreligious as their parents (but at least they're English native speakers now.) And I've remained fascinated by this whole world. I still follow it, watch the videos, listen to the music, and approach it with a mixture of curiosity and amazement.
Second, when I learned that @RevAdamHamilton, the newly elected Democratic senator from Kansas, is himself a megachurch pastor, I wasn't particularly surprised.
Hamilton is the first Democrat elected to the US Senate from Kansas since 1932. He built the Church of the Resurrection (@umcresurrection), the country's largest United Methodist congregation, into a community of around 25,000 members. And I could immediately understand why he might have something compelling to say to Kansas voters.
He's spent decades building precisely the kind of community I've been describing: one that brings together people who might otherwise have very little in common, gives them a shared experience, and provides them with a sense of belonging and purpose.
In a country increasingly fractured by political polarization, especially under Trump, I suspect this is precisely the kind of leadership and community experience that many Americans are longing for.
Perhaps that's one of the things I learned, entirely by accident, in a little church in Islington: to understand America, you have to look beyond Washington, beyond the political parties, and beyond the usual categories we in Europe use to describe the country.
You have to look at the places where Americans actually come together, week after week, and sing.
Adam Hamilton, a church pastor now elected to Kansas's Senate seat, explains how the story of ancient Israel demonstrates how we have to love immigrants. Uploaded in September 2026.
Lion energy.